PennyDreadfulCommander Penny Dreadful EDH BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality u1f79a,MattMobius,FratMank94,Nanmanking18 == Game 1 (742977752) == [Time] 1606008788 [12:33:13] PDBot has started watching. [12:33:13] MattMobius joined the game. [12:33:22] [CHAT] MattMobius: hi GL HF [12:33:23] Nanmanking18 chooses to play first. [12:33:23] Nanmanking18 chooses [Angus Mackenzie] as their commander. [12:33:23] u1f79a chooses [Kemba, Kha Regent] as their commander. [12:33:23] FratMank94 chooses [Karador, Ghost Chieftain] as their commander. [12:33:23] MattMobius chooses [Shalai, Voice of Plenty] as their commander. [12:33:24] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Angus Mackenzie[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful. [12:33:24] [CHAT] FratMank94: Hello, glhf all :) [12:33:33] Nanmanking18 mulligans to seven cards. [12:33:35] [CHAT] u1f79a: u2! [12:33:46] u1f79a begins the game with seven cards in hand. [12:33:54] FratMank94 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [12:33:58] MattMobius mulligans to seven cards. [12:34:01] Nanmanking18 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [12:34:03] MattMobius begins the game with seven cards in hand. [12:34:03] Turn 1: Nanmanking18 [12:34:07] Nanmanking18 plays [Plains]. [12:34:30] Turn 1: u1f79a [12:34:34] u1f79a plays [New Benalia]. [12:34:35] u1f79a puts triggered ability from [New Benalia] onto the stack (When New Benalia enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [12:34:43] u1f79a puts 1 card on top of their library. [12:34:43] u1f79a scrys 1. [12:34:49] Turn 1: FratMank94 [12:34:56] FratMank94 plays [Elfhame Palace]. [12:35:01] Turn 1: MattMobius [12:35:06] MattMobius plays [Forest]. [12:35:08] MattMobius casts [Elvish Mystic]. [12:35:49] Nanmanking18 casts [Enlightened Tutor]. [12:35:50] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Enlightened Tutor[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful. [12:36:04] Nanmanking18 reveals [Sol Ring]. [12:36:05] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Sol Ring[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful. [sG] In order to prevent further spamming, I'll stop warning you now. [sG] For more information about Penny Dreadful, see pdmtgo.com or reddit.com/r/PennyDreadfulMTG [12:36:11] Turn 2: Nanmanking18 [12:36:15] Nanmanking18 casts [Sol Ring]. [12:36:42] Nanmanking18 plays [Plains]. [12:36:49] Nanmanking18 casts [Solemnity]. [12:36:49] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Solemnity[sU] has an advantageous bug. Solemnity does not prevent a player from paying tribute cost, but the creature won't get the +1/+1 counter Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Solemnity` or `!notbugged Solemnity` [12:37:01] Turn 2: u1f79a [12:37:05] u1f79a plays [Plains]. [12:37:08] u1f79a casts [Relic Seeker]. [12:37:32] Turn 2: FratMank94 [12:37:39] FratMank94 plays [Wooded Bastion]. [12:37:44] FratMank94 casts [Talisman of Unity]. [12:37:51] FratMank94 casts [Llanowar Elves]. [12:37:58] Turn 2: MattMobius [12:38:02] MattMobius plays [Forest]. [12:38:07] MattMobius casts [Kodama's Reach]. [12:38:07] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Kodama's Reach[sU] has a graphical bug. This spell fails to display the destination zones of the chosen lands in the game log. [12:38:17] MattMobius reveals [Plains]. [12:38:17] MattMobius reveals [Plains]. [12:38:26] Turn 3: Nanmanking18 [12:38:38] Nanmanking18 casts [Karmic Justice]. [12:38:57] Turn 3: u1f79a [12:39:02] u1f79a plays [Plains]. [12:39:17] Nanmanking18 is being attacked by [Relic Seeker]. [12:39:41] u1f79a puts triggered ability from [Relic Seeker] onto the stack (Renown 1 (When this creature deals combat damage to a player, if it isn't renowned, put a +1/+1 ...). [12:39:45] u1f79a puts triggered ability from [Relic Seeker] onto the stack (When Relic Seeker becomes renowned, you may search your library for an Equipment card, reveal it, ...). [12:40:34] u1f79a reveals [Lightning Greaves]. [12:40:45] u1f79a casts [Kemba, Kha Regent]. [12:40:50] Turn 3: FratMank94 [12:40:58] FratMank94 plays [Terramorphic Expanse]. [12:41:01] FratMank94 activates an ability of [Terramorphic Expanse] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [12:41:33] FratMank94 casts [Elvish Mystic]. [12:41:41] FratMank94 casts [Orzhov Signet]. [12:41:54] Nanmanking18 is being attacked by [Llanowar Elves]. [12:42:08] Turn 3: MattMobius [12:42:13] MattMobius plays [Plains]. [12:42:18] MattMobius casts [Shalai, Voice of Plenty]. [12:42:38] Nanmanking18 is being attacked by [Elvish Mystic]. [12:42:49] Turn 4: Nanmanking18 [12:42:54] Nanmanking18 plays [Wooded Bastion]. [12:43:10] Turn 4: u1f79a [12:43:10] u1f79a puts triggered ability from [Kemba, Kha Regent] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, create a 2/2 white Cat creature token for each Equipment attached...). [12:43:22] u1f79a casts [Lightning Greaves]. [12:43:28] u1f79a activates an ability of [Lightning Greaves] targeting [Kemba, Kha Regent] (Equip {0}). [12:43:36] Nanmanking18 is being attacked by [Kemba, Kha Regent] and [Relic Seeker]. [12:43:42] Nanmanking18 has been dealt 2 total damage by u1f79a's commander, [Kemba, Kha Regent]. [12:43:46] Turn 4: FratMank94 [12:44:03] FratMank94 casts [Corpse Connoisseur]. [12:44:27] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Corpse Connoisseur] onto the stack (When Corpse Connoisseur enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a creature card an...). [12:44:58] FratMank94 plays [Foul Orchard]. [12:45:06] [CHAT] Nanmanking18: whats up [12:45:07] Nanmanking18 is being attacked by [Elvish Mystic] and [Llanowar Elves]. [12:45:18] Turn 4: MattMobius [12:45:25] MattMobius plays [Blossoming Sands]. [12:45:25] MattMobius puts triggered ability from [Blossoming Sands] onto the stack (When Blossoming Sands enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [12:45:42] MattMobius casts [Wayfaring Temple]. [12:46:10] Nanmanking18 is being attacked by [Shalai, Voice of Plenty] and [Elvish Mystic]. [12:46:24] Nanmanking18 has been dealt 3 total damage by MattMobius's commander, [Shalai, Voice of Plenty]. [12:46:33] Turn 5: Nanmanking18 [12:46:49] Nanmanking18 casts [Norn's Annex]. [12:47:09] Turn 5: u1f79a [12:47:09] u1f79a puts triggered ability from [Kemba, Kha Regent] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, create a 2/2 white Cat creature token for each Equipment attached...). [12:47:22] u1f79a's [Kemba, Kha Regent] creates a Cat token. [12:47:34] [CHAT] Nanmanking18: i dont know why everyone attacking me but ok [12:47:35] u1f79a casts [Bonesplitter]. [12:47:41] u1f79a activates an ability of [Lightning Greaves] targeting [Cat] token (Equip {0}). [12:47:46] u1f79a activates an ability of [Bonesplitter] targeting [Kemba, Kha Regent] (Equip {1}). [12:47:50] [CHAT] FratMank94: bc, we are playing Penny Dreadful legality, and you are not [12:48:04] Nanmanking18 is being attacked by [Cat] token, [Kemba, Kha Regent], and [Relic Seeker]. [12:48:11] Nanmanking18 has been dealt 6 total damage by u1f79a's commander, [Kemba, Kha Regent]. [12:48:15] u1f79a activates an ability of [Lightning Greaves] targeting [Kemba, Kha Regent] (Equip {0}). [12:48:21] Turn 5: FratMank94 [12:48:31] [CHAT] Nanmanking18: what is that [12:49:04] [CHAT] MattMobius: cards that are 2 cents or less [12:49:05] [CHAT] FratMank94: basically its a format that rotates quarterly and when the format rotates any card that is .02TIX or less is legat [12:49:23] Nanmanking18 is being attacked by [Corpse Connoisseur]. [12:49:25] [CHAT] Nanmanking18: then why didnt you post that [12:49:36] [CHAT] Nanmanking18: i didnt see any reqiurmenta [12:49:43] [CHAT] u1f79a: it was in the game title [12:49:49] [CHAT] Nanmanking18: i didnt see it [12:49:51] [CHAT] FratMank94: I did, thats why the Penny Dreadful bot stated your cards weren't penny dreadful legal [12:50:10] FratMank94 casts [Dread Return] targeting [Artisan of Kozilek]. [12:50:19] Turn 5: MattMobius [12:50:24] MattMobius plays [Plains]. [12:50:30] MattMobius casts [Renata, Called to the Hunt]. [12:50:36] [CHAT] Nanmanking18: then why i dont just leave? [12:51:02] MattMobius casts [Abzan Falconer]. [12:51:21] Nanmanking18 is being attacked by [Wayfaring Temple] and [Shalai, Voice of Plenty]. [12:51:31] Nanmanking18 has been dealt 6 total damage by MattMobius's commander, [Shalai, Voice of Plenty]. [12:51:32] MattMobius puts triggered ability from [Wayfaring Temple] onto the stack (Whenever Wayfaring Temple deals combat damage to a player, populate.). [12:51:35] MattMobius has no creature tokens to copy. [12:51:40] Turn 6: Nanmanking18 [12:51:51] Nanmanking18 has conceded from the game. [12:51:53] Nanmanking18 is now a watcher. [12:52:03] Nanmanking18 has stopped watching. [12:52:11] Turn 6: u1f79a [12:52:12] u1f79a puts triggered ability from [Kemba, Kha Regent] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, create a 2/2 white Cat creature token for each Equipment attached...). [12:52:15] u1f79a's [Kemba, Kha Regent] creates two Cat tokens. [12:52:27] u1f79a casts [Heraldic Banner]. [12:52:30] u1f79a chooses white for [Heraldic Banner]. [12:53:03] MattMobius is being attacked by [Cat] token and [Relic Seeker]. [12:53:14] Turn 6: FratMank94 [12:53:45] u1f79a is being attacked by [Artisan of Kozilek]. [12:53:45] MattMobius is being attacked by [Corpse Connoisseur]. [12:53:45] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Artisan of Kozilek] onto the stack (Annihilator 2 (Whenever this creature attacks, defending player sacrifices two permanents.)). [12:53:52] u1f79a sacrifices [Cat] token. [12:53:53] u1f79a sacrifices [Cat] token. [12:54:06] [Cat] token blocks [Artisan of Kozilek]. [12:54:36] FratMank94 casts [Karador, Ghost Chieftain]. [12:54:41] FratMank94 plays [Blossoming Sands]. [12:54:42] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Blossoming Sands] onto the stack (When Blossoming Sands enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [12:54:50] Turn 6: MattMobius [12:54:56] MattMobius plays [Plains]. [12:55:17] MattMobius activates an ability of [Shalai, Voice of Plenty] ( Put a +1/+1 counter on each creature you control.). [12:55:57] FratMank94 is being attacked by [Abzan Falconer], [Renata, Called to the Hunt], [Wayfaring Temple], [Shalai, Voice of Plenty], and [Elvish Mystic]. [12:56:05] FratMank94 has been dealt 4 total damage by MattMobius's commander, [Shalai, Voice of Plenty]. [12:56:06] MattMobius puts triggered ability from [Wayfaring Temple] onto the stack (Whenever Wayfaring Temple deals combat damage to a player, populate.). [12:56:10] MattMobius has no creature tokens to copy. [12:56:20] Turn 7: u1f79a [12:56:20] u1f79a puts triggered ability from [Kemba, Kha Regent] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, create a 2/2 white Cat creature token for each Equipment attached...). [12:56:24] u1f79a's [Kemba, Kha Regent] creates two Cat tokens. [12:56:54] u1f79a casts [Pristine Talisman]. [12:56:59] u1f79a casts [Wayfarer's Bauble]. [12:57:19] FratMank94 is being attacked by [Kemba, Kha Regent]. [12:57:27] FratMank94 has been dealt 5 total damage by u1f79a's commander, [Kemba, Kha Regent]. [12:57:31] Turn 7: FratMank94 [12:58:08] MattMobius is being attacked by [Artisan of Kozilek]. [12:58:08] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Artisan of Kozilek] onto the stack (Annihilator 2 (Whenever this creature attacks, defending player sacrifices two permanents.)). [12:58:13] MattMobius sacrifices [Plains]. [12:58:14] MattMobius sacrifices [Plains]. [12:58:35] FratMank94 plays [Fetid Heath]. [12:58:53] FratMank94 casts [Deathcap Cultivator]. [12:59:04] Turn 7: MattMobius [12:59:23] [CHAT] FratMank94: so flying boiz seem pretty good [12:59:25] MattMobius casts [Increasing Devotion]. [12:59:28] MattMobius's [Increasing Devotion] creates five Human tokens. [13:00:13] u1f79a is being attacked by [Abzan Falconer], [Shalai, Voice of Plenty], and [Elvish Mystic]. [13:00:14] FratMank94 is being attacked by [Renata, Called to the Hunt] and [Wayfaring Temple]. [13:00:20] [CHAT] FratMank94: gg [13:00:30] u1f79a has been dealt 4 total damage by MattMobius's commander, [Shalai, Voice of Plenty]. [13:00:32] MattMobius puts triggered ability from [Wayfaring Temple] onto the stack (Whenever Wayfaring Temple deals combat damage to a player, populate.). [13:00:33] FratMank94 is now a watcher. [13:00:39] MattMobius's [Wayfaring Temple] creates a Human token. [13:00:42] Turn 8: u1f79a [13:00:43] u1f79a puts triggered ability from [Kemba, Kha Regent] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, create a 2/2 white Cat creature token for each Equipment attached...). [13:00:43] u1f79a's [Kemba, Kha Regent] creates two Cat tokens. [13:01:15] [CHAT] MattMobius: i thought i was pretty dead last round [13:01:25] u1f79a casts [Dusk]. [13:01:33] [CHAT] u1f79a: gah [13:01:37] [CHAT] u1f79a: punted [13:01:48] [CHAT] u1f79a: meant to hold priority there [13:01:57] Turn 8: MattMobius [13:02:01] MattMobius plays [Forest]. [13:02:09] MattMobius casts [Shalai, Voice of Plenty]. [13:02:12] [CHAT] u1f79a: how do i exactly hold priority in modo? [13:02:26] u1f79a is being attacked by [Human] token, [Human] token, [Human] token, [Human] token, [Human] token, [Human] token, and [Elvish Mystic]. [13:02:32] Turn 9: u1f79a [13:02:42] u1f79a casts [Kemba, Kha Regent]. [13:02:45] u1f79a activates an ability of [Lightning Greaves] targeting [Kemba, Kha Regent] (Equip {0}). [13:02:53] Turn 9: MattMobius [13:03:03] MattMobius activates an ability of [Shalai, Voice of Plenty] ( Put a +1/+1 counter on each creature you control.). [13:03:20] u1f79a is being attacked by [Shalai, Voice of Plenty], [Human] token, [Human] token, [Human] token, [Human] token, [Human] token, [Human] token, and [Elvish Mystic]. [13:03:23] [Kemba, Kha Regent] blocks [Elvish Mystic]. [13:03:26] u1f79a has been dealt 8 total damage by MattMobius's commander, [Shalai, Voice of Plenty]. Winner: MattMobius Game 1 Completed. [13:03:26] [CHAT] MattMobius: GG [13:03:35] [CHAT] u1f79a: ggs [13:03:40] [CHAT] FratMank94: you have to hold ctrl [13:03:46] [CHAT] u1f79a: i was lol [13:03:47] [CHAT] FratMank94: gg [13:03:48] [CHAT] u1f79a: so that was odd [13:03:53] [CHAT] FratMank94: hmm, maybe they changed it [13:03:57] MattMobius draws their next card. [13:03:59] MattMobius draws their next card. [13:04:01] [CHAT] u1f79a: i might've f6'd by accident [13:04:11] [CHAT] MattMobius: always check the key binding [13:04:17] [CHAT] MattMobius: it changes with each update [13:04:22] [CHAT] u1f79a: ah gotcha