PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality cookthebook,emctwo == Game 1 (742389174) == [Time] 1605495176 [13:52:57] PDBot has started watching. [13:52:57] emctwo joined the game. [League] Dredge by cookthebook (109961) vs Merfolk by emctwo (109716) [13:53:00] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [13:53:06] [CHAT] cookthebook: glhf [13:53:08] cookthebook chooses to play first. [13:53:17] cookthebook begins the game with seven cards in hand. [13:53:20] emctwo mulligans to six cards. [13:53:34] emctwo puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [13:53:34] Turn 1: cookthebook [13:53:39] cookthebook skips their draw step. [13:53:40] cookthebook plays [Nomad Outpost]. [13:53:41] Turn 1: emctwo [13:53:45] emctwo plays [Island]. [13:53:46] emctwo casts [Cursecatcher]. [13:53:49] Turn 2: cookthebook [13:53:54] cookthebook plays [Nomad Outpost]. [13:53:56] cookthebook casts [Insolent Neonate]. [13:54:01] cookthebook discards [Golgari Grave-Troll]. [13:54:01] cookthebook activates an ability of [Insolent Neonate] ( Draw a card.). [13:54:01] cookthebook draws a card with [Insolent Neonate]'s ability. [13:54:04] cookthebook mills [Silversmote Ghoul], [Cathartic Reunion], [Mountain], [Vivid Meadow], [Stinkweed Imp] and [Darkblast]. [13:54:07] Turn 2: emctwo [13:54:16] emctwo plays [Island]. [13:54:19] emctwo casts [Master of the Pearl Trident]. [13:54:22] cookthebook is being attacked by [Cursecatcher]. [13:54:27] Turn 3: cookthebook [13:54:32] cookthebook mills [Secluded Steppe], [Smiting Helix], [Cathartic Reunion], [Shriekhorn] and [Savage Lands]. [13:54:37] cookthebook casts [Shriekhorn]. [13:54:42] cookthebook activates an ability of [Shriekhorn] targeting cookthebook ( Target player mills two cards.). [13:54:44] cookthebook mills [Darkblast] and [Conflagrate]. [13:54:55] Turn 3: emctwo [13:54:58] emctwo plays [Island]. [13:55:17] emctwo casts [Merfolk Sovereign]. [13:55:24] cookthebook is being attacked by [Master of the Pearl Trident] and [Cursecatcher]. [13:55:29] Turn 4: cookthebook [13:55:31] cookthebook activates an ability of [Shriekhorn] targeting cookthebook ( Target player mills two cards.). [13:55:32] cookthebook mills [Ashen Ghoul] and [Nomad Outpost]. [13:55:37] cookthebook mills [Ashen Ghoul], [Mountain] and [Stinkweed Imp]. [13:55:42] cookthebook casts [Smiting Helix] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Merfolk Sovereign]. [13:55:51] cookthebook puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...). [13:55:55] Turn 4: emctwo [13:55:58] emctwo plays [Island]. [13:56:02] cookthebook is being attacked by [Master of the Pearl Trident] and [Cursecatcher]. [13:56:07] emctwo casts [Coralhelm Commander]. [13:56:11] emctwo activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up). [13:56:14] Turn 5: cookthebook [13:56:17] cookthebook activates an ability of [Shriekhorn] targeting cookthebook ( Target player mills two cards.). [13:56:18] cookthebook mills [Forgotten Cave] and [Mountain]. [13:56:26] cookthebook mills [Creeping Chill], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Savage Lands], [Cathartic Reunion] and [Stinkweed Imp]. [13:56:26] cookthebook puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...). [13:56:30] cookthebook exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability. [13:57:24] Turn 5: emctwo [13:57:31] emctwo activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up). [13:57:37] emctwo activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up). [13:57:41] emctwo activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up). [13:57:52] cookthebook is being attacked by [Coralhelm Commander], [Master of the Pearl Trident], and [Cursecatcher]. [13:57:55] [Silversmote Ghoul] blocks [Master of the Pearl Trident]. [13:57:58] emctwo casts [Dive Down] targeting [Master of the Pearl Trident]. [13:58:07] cookthebook activates an ability of [Silversmote Ghoul] ( Draw a card.). [13:58:09] cookthebook draws a card with [Silversmote Ghoul]'s ability. [13:58:11] cookthebook mills [Creeping Chill], [Haunted Dead], [Vivid Meadow], [Cathartic Reunion], [Shriekhorn] and [Smiting Helix]. [13:58:11] cookthebook puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...). [13:58:14] cookthebook exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability. [13:58:27] Turn 6: cookthebook [13:58:37] cookthebook discards [Golgari Grave-Troll]. [13:58:37] cookthebook discards [Golgari Grave-Troll]. [13:58:37] cookthebook activates an ability of [Haunted Dead] ( Return Haunted Dead from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.). [13:58:43] cookthebook puts triggered ability from [Haunted Dead] onto the stack (When Haunted Dead enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Spirit creature token with flying.). [13:58:46] cookthebook's [Haunted Dead] creates a Spirit token. [13:58:51] cookthebook mills [Insolent Neonate], [Rugged Prairie], [Nomad Outpost], [Haunted Dead], [Silversmote Ghoul] and [Smiting Helix]. [13:58:59] Turn 6: emctwo [13:59:11] cookthebook is being attacked by [Coralhelm Commander], [Master of the Pearl Trident], and [Cursecatcher]. [13:59:13] [Spirit] token blocks [Coralhelm Commander]. [13:59:34] emctwo reveals [Coralhelm Commander] with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [13:59:34] emctwo casts [Silvergill Adept] (revealing [Coralhelm Commander]). [13:59:35] emctwo puts triggered ability from [Silvergill Adept] onto the stack (When Silvergill Adept enters the battlefield, draw a card.). [13:59:36] emctwo draws a card with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [13:59:47] emctwo casts [Coralhelm Commander]. [13:59:50] Turn 7: cookthebook [14:00:10] cookthebook mills [Creeping Chill], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Forgotten Cave], [Shriekhorn] and [Ashen Ghoul]. [14:00:10] cookthebook puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...). [14:00:14] cookthebook exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability. [14:00:22] cookthebook casts [Smiting Helix] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Master of the Pearl Trident]. [14:00:27] emctwo activates an ability of [Cursecatcher] targeting [Smiting Helix] ( Counter target instant or sorcery spell unless its controller pays {1}.). [14:00:31] cookthebook has conceded from the game. Winner: emctwo Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (742390074) == [Time] 1605495687 [14:01:27] PDBot has started watching. [14:01:28] cookthebook chooses to play first. [14:01:32] cookthebook mulligans to six cards. [14:01:34] emctwo mulligans to six cards. [14:01:40] cookthebook puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [14:01:59] emctwo puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [14:01:59] Turn 1: cookthebook [14:02:05] cookthebook skips their draw step. [14:02:07] cookthebook plays [Mountain]. [14:02:08] Turn 1: emctwo [14:02:13] emctwo plays [Island]. [14:02:15] emctwo casts [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. [14:02:17] Turn 2: cookthebook [14:02:22] cookthebook plays [Rugged Prairie]. [14:02:26] cookthebook discards [Golgari Grave-Troll]. [14:02:26] cookthebook discards [Mountain]. [14:02:26] cookthebook casts [Cathartic Reunion]. [14:02:26] cookthebook draws three cards with [Cathartic Reunion]. [14:02:28] cookthebook mills [Insolent Neonate], [Lightning Axe], [Stinkweed Imp], [Nomad Outpost], [Stinkweed Imp] and [Forgotten Cave]. [14:02:30] cookthebook mills [Silversmote Ghoul], [Conflagrate], [Shriekhorn], [Insolent Neonate] and [Nomad Outpost]. [14:02:31] cookthebook mills [Silversmote Ghoul], [Smiting Helix], [Vivid Meadow], [Darkblast] and [Ashen Ghoul]. [14:02:35] Turn 2: emctwo [14:02:39] emctwo plays [Island]. [14:02:41] emctwo casts [Curious Obsession] targeting [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. [14:02:43] emctwo casts [Cursecatcher]. [14:02:46] cookthebook is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. [14:02:49] emctwo puts triggered ability from [Mist-Cloaked Herald] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card.). [14:02:52] emctwo draws a card with [Mist-Cloaked Herald]'s ability. [14:02:54] Turn 3: cookthebook [14:02:59] cookthebook mills [Shriekhorn], [Shriekhorn] and [Rugged Prairie]. [14:03:09] cookthebook casts [Smiting Helix] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Cursecatcher]. [14:03:13] emctwo activates an ability of [Cursecatcher] targeting [Smiting Helix] ( Counter target instant or sorcery spell unless its controller pays {1}.). [14:03:16] cookthebook plays [Savage Lands]. [14:03:20] Turn 3: emctwo [14:03:26] cookthebook is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. [14:03:27] emctwo puts triggered ability from [Mist-Cloaked Herald] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card.). [14:03:30] emctwo draws a card with [Mist-Cloaked Herald]'s ability. [14:03:31] emctwo plays [Island]. [14:03:37] emctwo reveals [Merrow Reejerey] with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [14:03:37] emctwo casts [Silvergill Adept] (revealing [Merrow Reejerey]). [14:03:37] emctwo puts triggered ability from [Silvergill Adept] onto the stack (When Silvergill Adept enters the battlefield, draw a card.). [14:03:39] emctwo draws a card with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability. [14:03:41] Turn 4: cookthebook [14:03:55] cookthebook discards [Golgari Grave-Troll]. [14:03:55] cookthebook discards [Stinkweed Imp]. [14:03:55] cookthebook casts [Cathartic Reunion]. [14:03:58] cookthebook draws three cards with [Cathartic Reunion]. [14:03:59] cookthebook mills [Forgotten Cave], [Rugged Prairie], [Creeping Chill], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Savage Lands] and [Creeping Chill]. [14:04:03] cookthebook mills [Nomad Outpost], [Golgari Grave-Troll], [Silversmote Ghoul], [Stinkweed Imp], [Vivid Meadow] and [Vivid Meadow]. [14:04:04] cookthebook mills [Lightning Axe], [Vivid Meadow], [Creeping Chill], [Stinkweed Imp], [Smiting Helix] and [Golgari Grave-Troll]. [14:04:04] cookthebook puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...). [14:04:04] cookthebook puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...). [14:04:04] cookthebook puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...). [14:04:09] cookthebook exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability. [14:04:13] cookthebook exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability. [14:04:14] cookthebook exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability. [14:04:20] cookthebook puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...). [14:04:20] cookthebook puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...). [14:04:20] cookthebook puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...). [14:04:24] Turn 4: emctwo [14:04:29] emctwo plays [Island]. [14:04:31] emctwo casts [Merrow Reejerey]. [14:04:36] cookthebook casts [Darkblast] targeting [Silvergill Adept]. [14:04:38] emctwo has conceded from the game. Winner: cookthebook Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (742390478) == [Time] 1605495917 [14:05:18] PDBot has started watching. [14:05:21] emctwo begins the game with seven cards in hand. [14:05:22] cookthebook mulligans to six cards. [14:05:27] cookthebook mulligans to five cards. [14:05:33] cookthebook mulligans to four cards. [14:05:40] cookthebook puts three cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with four cards in hand. [14:05:40] Turn 1: emctwo [14:05:42] emctwo skips their draw step. [14:05:44] emctwo plays [Island]. [14:05:47] Turn 1: cookthebook [14:05:50] cookthebook plays [Mountain]. [14:05:51] cookthebook casts [Shriekhorn]. [14:05:55] cookthebook activates an ability of [Shriekhorn] targeting cookthebook ( Target player mills two cards.). [14:05:56] cookthebook mills [Rugged Prairie] and [Rugged Prairie]. [14:06:00] Turn 2: emctwo [14:06:04] emctwo casts [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. [14:06:09] Turn 2: cookthebook [14:06:11] cookthebook activates an ability of [Shriekhorn] targeting cookthebook ( Target player mills two cards.). [14:06:12] cookthebook mills [Nomad Outpost] and [Savage Lands]. [14:06:17] cookthebook plays [Nomad Outpost]. [14:06:21] Turn 3: emctwo [14:06:24] emctwo plays [Island]. [14:06:28] emctwo casts [Curious Obsession] targeting [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. [14:06:30] emctwo casts [Curious Obsession] targeting [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. [14:06:33] cookthebook is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. [14:06:35] emctwo puts triggered ability from [Mist-Cloaked Herald] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card.). [14:06:35] emctwo puts triggered ability from [Mist-Cloaked Herald] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card.). [14:06:42] emctwo draws a card with [Mist-Cloaked Herald]'s ability. [14:06:43] emctwo draws a card with [Mist-Cloaked Herald]'s ability. [14:06:49] emctwo casts [Tormod's Crypt]. [14:06:51] Turn 3: cookthebook [14:06:55] cookthebook activates an ability of [Shriekhorn] targeting cookthebook ( Target player mills two cards.). [14:06:58] cookthebook mills [Cathartic Reunion] and [Mountain]. [14:07:02] cookthebook plays [Vivid Meadow]. [14:07:07] Turn 4: emctwo [14:07:11] emctwo plays [Island]. [14:07:20] emctwo casts [Master of the Pearl Trident]. [14:07:25] emctwo casts [Aquitect's Will] targeting [Nomad Outpost]. [14:07:25] emctwo draws a card with [Aquitect's Will]. [14:07:29] cookthebook is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald]. [14:07:33] emctwo puts triggered ability from [Mist-Cloaked Herald] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card.). [14:07:33] emctwo puts triggered ability from [Mist-Cloaked Herald] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card.). [14:07:34] emctwo draws a card with [Mist-Cloaked Herald]'s ability. [14:07:35] emctwo draws a card with [Mist-Cloaked Herald]'s ability. [14:07:37] Turn 4: cookthebook [14:07:46] cookthebook has conceded from the game. Winner: emctwo Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: emctwo: 2–1