PennyDreadful
pds r4 vs mdog
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
crazybaloth,mdog

== Game 1 (739078544) ==
[Time] 1602963296
[06:34:57] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Saturdays 18.03
[Gatherling] Round=4
[06:34:59] mdog joined the game.
[06:35:04] crazybaloth chooses to play first.
[06:35:08] crazybaloth begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[06:35:15] mdog mulligans to six cards.
[06:35:37] mdog puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[06:35:37] Turn 1: crazybaloth
[06:35:39] crazybaloth skips their draw step.
[06:35:40] crazybaloth plays [Swamp].
[06:35:52] Turn 1: mdog
[06:35:58] mdog plays [Vault of Whispers].
[06:36:02] mdog casts [Witch's Oven].
[06:36:07] Turn 2: crazybaloth
[06:36:13] crazybaloth plays [Sunken Ruins].
[06:36:29] crazybaloth casts [Brainstorm].
[06:36:36] crazybaloth draws three cards with [Brainstorm].
[06:36:54] crazybaloth casts [Ponder].
[06:37:18] crazybaloth chooses to shuffle his or her library.
[06:37:18] crazybaloth draws a card with [Ponder].
[06:37:23] crazybaloth casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting mdog.
[06:37:28] crazybaloth draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[06:37:32] Turn 2: mdog
[06:37:40] mdog casts [Cauldron Familiar].
[06:37:41] mdog puts triggered ability from [Cauldron Familiar] onto the stack (When Cauldron Familiar enters the battlefield, each opponent loses 1 life and you gain 1 life.).
[06:37:53] mdog plays [Orzhov Basilica].
[06:37:53] mdog puts triggered ability from [Orzhov Basilica] onto the stack (When Orzhov Basilica enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[06:38:01] mdog returns [Vault of Whispers] to its owner's hand with [Orzhov Basilica]'s ability.
[06:38:14] Turn 3: crazybaloth
[06:38:20] crazybaloth casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting mdog.
[06:38:25] crazybaloth draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[06:38:28] crazybaloth plays [Sunken Ruins].
[06:38:45] crazybaloth casts [Brainstorm].
[06:38:49] mdog activates an ability of [Witch's Oven] ( Create a Food token. If the sacrificed creature's toughness was four or greater, create two Food ...).
[06:38:50] mdog's [Witch's Oven] creates a Food token.
[06:38:53] crazybaloth draws three cards with [Brainstorm].
[06:39:11] crazybaloth casts [Strategic Planning].
[06:39:15] crazybaloth puts [Cruel Bargain] and [Ransack the Lab] into their graveyard.
[06:39:32] mdog activates an ability of [Cauldron Familiar] ( Return Cauldron Familiar from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[06:39:33] mdog puts triggered ability from [Cauldron Familiar] onto the stack (When Cauldron Familiar enters the battlefield, each opponent loses 1 life and you gain 1 life.).
[06:39:42] Turn 3: mdog
[06:39:49] mdog plays [Vault of Whispers].
[06:40:22] mdog casts [Vindicate] targeting [Swamp].
[06:40:32] crazybaloth is being attacked by [Cauldron Familiar].
[06:40:34] Turn 4: crazybaloth
[06:40:39] crazybaloth casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting mdog.
[06:40:43] crazybaloth draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[06:40:47] crazybaloth casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting mdog.
[06:40:50] crazybaloth draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe].
[06:41:00] mdog activates an ability of [Witch's Oven] ( Create a Food token. If the sacrificed creature's toughness was four or greater, create two Food ...).
[06:41:01] mdog's [Witch's Oven] creates a Food token.
[06:41:06] mdog activates an ability of [Cauldron Familiar] ( Return Cauldron Familiar from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[06:41:08] mdog puts triggered ability from [Cauldron Familiar] onto the stack (When Cauldron Familiar enters the battlefield, each opponent loses 1 life and you gain 1 life.).
[06:41:11] Turn 4: mdog
[06:41:15] mdog plays [Vault of Whispers].
[06:41:22] mdog casts [Cranial Plating].
[06:41:30] mdog activates an ability of [Cranial Plating] targeting [Cauldron Familiar] (Equip {1}).
[06:41:37] crazybaloth is being attacked by [Cauldron Familiar].
[06:41:53] Turn 5: crazybaloth
[06:41:56] crazybaloth plays [River of Tears].
[06:42:05] crazybaloth casts [Dark Ritual].
[06:42:16] crazybaloth casts [Cabal Ritual].
[06:42:38] crazybaloth casts [Frantic Search].
[06:42:43] crazybaloth draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[06:43:02] crazybaloth discards [River of Tears].
[06:43:02] crazybaloth discards [Cruel Bargain].
[06:43:14] crazybaloth casts [Brainstorm].
[06:43:17] crazybaloth draws three cards with [Brainstorm].
[06:43:38] crazybaloth casts [Ransack the Lab].
[06:43:44] crazybaloth puts [Bad River] and [Swamp] into their graveyard.
[06:43:46] crazybaloth casts [Dark Ritual].
[06:43:54] crazybaloth casts [Cabal Ritual].
[06:44:04] crazybaloth casts [Repeal] targeting [Cranial Plating]. (X is 2).
[06:44:20] crazybaloth returns [Cranial Plating] to its owner's hand with [Repeal].
[06:44:20] crazybaloth draws a card with [Repeal].
[06:44:33] crazybaloth casts [Treasure Cruise].
[06:44:47] crazybaloth draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[06:44:52] crazybaloth casts [Ransack the Lab].
[06:45:09] crazybaloth puts [Brainstorm] and [Chromatic Star] into their graveyard.
[06:46:26] crazybaloth casts [Tendrils of Agony] targeting mdog.
[06:46:26] crazybaloth puts triggered ability from [Tendrils of Agony] onto the stack (10 spells cast before Tendrils of Agony this turn.
Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for ...).
[06:46:48] mdog activates an ability of [Witch's Oven] ( Create a Food token. If the sacrificed creature's toughness was four or greater, create two Food ...).
[06:46:49] mdog's [Witch's Oven] creates a Food token.
[06:46:54] mdog activates an ability of [Cauldron Familiar] ( Return Cauldron Familiar from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[06:46:54] mdog puts triggered ability from [Cauldron Familiar] onto the stack (When Cauldron Familiar enters the battlefield, each opponent loses 1 life and you gain 1 life.).
[06:47:01] Turn 5: mdog
[06:47:08] mdog plays [Fetid Heath].
[06:47:20] mdog casts [Witch's Oven].
[06:47:30] mdog casts [Cranial Plating].
[06:47:41] mdog activates an ability of [Cranial Plating] targeting [Cauldron Familiar] (Equip {1}).
[06:47:50] crazybaloth is being attacked by [Cauldron Familiar].
[06:48:00] Turn 6: crazybaloth
[06:48:09] crazybaloth casts [Treasure Cruise].
[06:48:12] crazybaloth draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[06:48:25] crazybaloth plays [Island].
[06:49:39] crazybaloth casts [Ponder].
[06:49:49] crazybaloth chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[06:49:49] crazybaloth draws a card with [Ponder].
[06:49:50] crazybaloth casts [Ponder].
[06:49:59] crazybaloth chooses to shuffle his or her library.
[06:50:00] crazybaloth draws a card with [Ponder].
[06:50:02] crazybaloth casts [Chromatic Star].
[06:50:18] mdog activates an ability of [Witch's Oven] ( Create a Food token. If the sacrificed creature's toughness was four or greater, create two Food ...).
[06:50:18] mdog's [Witch's Oven] creates a Food token.
[06:50:28] mdog activates an ability of [Cauldron Familiar] ( Return Cauldron Familiar from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[06:50:29] mdog puts triggered ability from [Cauldron Familiar] onto the stack (When Cauldron Familiar enters the battlefield, each opponent loses 1 life and you gain 1 life.).
[06:50:35] mdog activates an ability of [Witch's Oven] ( Create a Food token. If the sacrificed creature's toughness was four or greater, create two Food ...).
[06:50:35] mdog's [Witch's Oven] creates a Food token.
[06:50:49] mdog activates an ability of [Cauldron Familiar] ( Return Cauldron Familiar from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[06:50:49] mdog puts triggered ability from [Cauldron Familiar] onto the stack (When Cauldron Familiar enters the battlefield, each opponent loses 1 life and you gain 1 life.).
[06:50:55] Turn 6: mdog
[06:52:24] mdog casts [Herald of Anguish].
[06:52:32] mdog activates an ability of [Cranial Plating] targeting [Cauldron Familiar] (Equip {1}).
[06:52:43] crazybaloth is being attacked by [Cauldron Familiar].
[06:52:52] mdog puts triggered ability from [Herald of Anguish] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, each opponent discards a card.).
[06:52:59] crazybaloth chooses a card from their hand.
[06:52:59] crazybaloth discards [Sunken Ruins].
[06:53:01] Turn 7: crazybaloth
[06:53:11] crazybaloth puts triggered ability from [Chromatic Star] onto the stack (When Chromatic Star is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.).
[06:53:16] crazybaloth draws a card with [Chromatic Star]'s ability.
[06:53:25] crazybaloth casts [Frantic Search].
[06:53:25] crazybaloth draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[06:53:31] crazybaloth discards [Island].
[06:53:31] crazybaloth discards [River of Tears].
[06:53:45] crazybaloth casts [Dark Ritual].
[06:53:49] crazybaloth casts [Cabal Ritual].
[06:53:57] crazybaloth casts [Strategic Planning].
[06:54:02] crazybaloth puts [Cabal Ritual] and [Frantic Search] into their graveyard.
[06:54:12] crazybaloth casts [Treasure Cruise].
[06:54:12] crazybaloth draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[06:54:18] crazybaloth casts [Ponder].
[06:54:23] crazybaloth chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[06:54:23] crazybaloth draws a card with [Ponder].
[06:54:25] crazybaloth casts [Tendrils of Agony] targeting mdog.
[06:54:25] crazybaloth puts triggered ability from [Tendrils of Agony] onto the stack (6 spells cast before Tendrils of Agony this turn.
Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for e...).
Winner: crazybaloth
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (739080712) ==
[Time] 1602964597
[06:56:38] PDBot has started watching.
[06:56:40] mdog chooses to play first.
[06:56:46] mdog begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[06:56:48] crazybaloth mulligans to six cards.
[06:57:01] crazybaloth puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[06:57:01] Turn 1: mdog
[06:57:02] mdog skips their draw step.
[06:57:04] mdog plays [Plains].
[06:57:08] mdog casts [Witch's Oven].
[06:57:13] Turn 1: crazybaloth
[06:57:16] crazybaloth plays [River of Tears].
[06:57:19] Turn 2: mdog
[06:57:23] mdog plays [Fetid Heath].
[06:57:28] mdog casts [Ancestral Blade].
[06:57:30] mdog puts triggered ability from [Ancestral Blade] onto the stack (When Ancestral Blade enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token, then attac...).
[06:57:37] mdog's [Ancestral Blade] creates a Soldier token.
[06:57:40] Turn 2: crazybaloth
[06:57:43] crazybaloth plays [River of Tears].
[06:57:46] crazybaloth casts [Ransack the Lab].
[06:57:52] crazybaloth puts [Cruel Bargain] and [Treasure Cruise] into their graveyard.
[06:57:57] Turn 3: mdog
[06:58:01] mdog plays [Swamp].
[06:58:15] crazybaloth is being attacked by [Soldier] token.
[06:58:24] mdog casts [Vindicate] targeting [River of Tears].
[06:58:31] Turn 3: crazybaloth
[06:58:35] crazybaloth casts [Ponder].
[06:58:40] crazybaloth chooses to not shuffle his or her library.
[06:58:40] crazybaloth draws a card with [Ponder].
[06:58:41] crazybaloth plays [Sunken Ruins].
[06:58:46] Turn 4: mdog
[06:58:51] mdog plays [Vault of Whispers].
[06:58:55] nfcunha has started watching.
[06:59:05] mdog casts [Vindicate] targeting [Sunken Ruins].
[06:59:15] crazybaloth is being attacked by [Soldier] token.
[06:59:16] Turn 4: crazybaloth
[06:59:21] crazybaloth casts [Brainstorm].
[06:59:23] crazybaloth draws three cards with [Brainstorm].
[07:00:42] crazybaloth plays [River of Tears].
[07:00:44] crazybaloth casts [Dark Ritual].
[07:00:48] crazybaloth casts [Cabal Ritual].
[07:00:52] crazybaloth casts [Ransack the Lab].
[07:00:59] crazybaloth puts [Silundi Vision] and [Pieces of the Puzzle] into their graveyard.
[07:01:01] crazybaloth casts [Ransack the Lab].
[07:01:21] crazybaloth puts [Frantic Search] and [Dark Ritual] into their graveyard.
[07:01:24] crazybaloth casts [Chromatic Star].
[07:01:32] crazybaloth casts [Dark Ritual].
[07:01:38] crazybaloth puts triggered ability from [Chromatic Star] onto the stack (When Chromatic Star is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.).
[07:01:42] crazybaloth draws a card with [Chromatic Star]'s ability.
[07:01:48] crazybaloth casts [Repeal] targeting [Soldier] token. (X is 0).
[07:01:57] mdog activates an ability of [Witch's Oven] ( Create a Food token. If the sacrificed creature's toughness was four or greater, create two Food ...).
[07:01:58] mdog's [Witch's Oven] creates a Food token.
[07:02:08] crazybaloth's [Repeal] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[07:02:15] Turn 5: mdog
[07:02:19] mdog plays [Plains].
[07:02:24] mdog casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[07:02:25] mdog puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting crazybaloth (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[07:02:50] yellowvanblake has started watching.
[07:02:56] [CHAT] yellowvanblake: !record
[07:02:56] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  crazybaloth 1-0 mdog
[07:03:14] crazybaloth reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Cabal Ritual].
[07:03:17] mdog casts [Ancestral Blade].
[07:03:19] mdog puts triggered ability from [Ancestral Blade] onto the stack (When Ancestral Blade enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token, then attac...).
[07:03:26] mdog's [Ancestral Blade] creates a Soldier token.
[07:03:35] mdog activates an ability of [Ancestral Blade] targeting [Tidehollow Sculler] (Equip {1}).
[07:03:41] Turn 5: crazybaloth
[07:03:49] Turn 6: mdog
[07:04:00] crazybaloth is being attacked by [Soldier] token and [Tidehollow Sculler].
[07:04:09] Turn 6: crazybaloth
[07:04:12] crazybaloth plays [Island].
[07:04:33] crazybaloth casts [Cabal Ritual].
[07:04:39] crazybaloth casts [Feed the Swarm] targeting [Tidehollow Sculler].
[07:04:59] mdog puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack (When Tidehollow Sculler leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
[07:05:06] crazybaloth casts [Murmuring Mystic].
[07:05:13] Turn 7: mdog
[07:05:16] mdog plays [Vault of Whispers].
[07:05:43] mdog activates an ability of [Ancestral Blade] targeting [Soldier] token (Equip {1}).
[07:05:53] crazybaloth is being attacked by [Soldier] token.
[07:05:57] [Murmuring Mystic] blocks [Soldier] token.
[07:06:11] mdog casts [Herald of Anguish].
[07:06:24] mdog activates an ability of [Herald of Anguish] targeting [Murmuring Mystic] ( Target creature gets -2/-2 until end of turn.).
[07:06:28] mdog puts triggered ability from [Herald of Anguish] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, each opponent discards a card.).
[07:06:29] Turn 7: crazybaloth
[07:06:36] crazybaloth plays [Bad River].
[07:06:54] Turn 8: mdog
[07:07:05] crazybaloth is being attacked by [Herald of Anguish] and [Soldier] token.
[07:07:21] mdog casts [Vindicate] targeting [Island].
[07:07:26] mdog puts triggered ability from [Herald of Anguish] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, each opponent discards a card.).
[07:07:28] Turn 8: crazybaloth
[07:07:32] crazybaloth activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...).
[07:07:53] crazybaloth casts [Ponder].
[07:08:00] crazybaloth chooses to shuffle his or her library.
[07:08:00] crazybaloth draws a card with [Ponder].
[07:08:04] crazybaloth has conceded from the game.
Winner: mdog
Game 2 Completed.
[07:08:09] mdog has left the game.

== Game 3 (739081902) ==
[Time] 1602965358
[07:09:18] PDBot has started watching.
[07:09:20] crazybaloth chooses to play first.
[07:09:28] crazybaloth mulligans to six cards.
[07:09:30] mdog mulligans to six cards.
[07:09:32] crazybaloth mulligans to five cards.
[07:09:38] mdog mulligans to five cards.
[07:09:43] crazybaloth puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[07:09:58] mdog puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand.
[07:09:58] Turn 1: crazybaloth
[07:10:00] crazybaloth skips their draw step.
[07:10:01] crazybaloth plays [Bad River].
[07:10:04] Turn 1: mdog
[07:10:07] mdog plays [Plains].
[07:10:11] mdog casts [Deafening Silence].
[07:10:14] Torres6 has started watching.
[07:10:18] Turn 2: crazybaloth
[07:10:21] crazybaloth plays [Island].
[07:10:23] crazybaloth activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...).
[07:10:31] crazybaloth casts [Ransack the Lab].
[07:10:34] crazybaloth puts [Island] and [Island] into their graveyard.
[07:10:35] Turn 2: mdog
[07:10:39] mdog plays [Vault of Whispers].
[07:10:44] mdog casts [Tidehollow Sculler].
[07:10:45] mdog puts triggered ability from [Tidehollow Sculler] onto the stack targeting crazybaloth (When Tidehollow Sculler enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose ...).
[07:10:58] crazybaloth reveals their hand to [Tidehollow Sculler]'s ability, containing [Tendrils of Agony], [Bad River], and [River of Tears].
[07:11:04] Turn 3: crazybaloth
[07:11:07] crazybaloth plays [Bad River].
[07:11:10] Turn 3: mdog
[07:11:13] mdog plays [Plains].
[07:11:28] crazybaloth is being attacked by [Tidehollow Sculler].
[07:11:36] mdog casts [Ethersworn Canonist].
[07:11:44] mdog casts [Toolcraft Exemplar].
[07:11:50] Turn 4: crazybaloth
[07:11:52] crazybaloth activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...).
[07:12:08] crazybaloth casts [Silundi Vision].
[07:12:12] crazybaloth puts Feed the Swarm in their hand.
[07:12:13] crazybaloth plays [Bad River].
[07:12:15] Turn 4: mdog
[07:12:21] mdog casts [Cranial Plating].
[07:12:32] mdog activates an ability of [Cranial Plating] targeting [Toolcraft Exemplar] (Equip {1}).
[07:12:36] mdog puts triggered ability from [Toolcraft Exemplar] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, if you control an artifact, Toolcraft Exemplar gets +2/+1...).
[07:12:44] crazybaloth is being attacked by [Toolcraft Exemplar], [Ethersworn Canonist], and [Tidehollow Sculler].
[07:12:52] Turn 5: crazybaloth
[07:12:57] crazybaloth has conceded from the game.
Winner: mdog
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: mdog: 2–1
[07:13:04] mdog has left the game.