PennyDreadful Penny Dreadful BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality jace_fair,Matrim_Cauthon == Game 1 (738778180) == [Time] 1602729113 [13:31:54] PDBot has started watching. [League] Host doesn't have active run [13:32:09] jace_fair chooses to play first. [13:32:18] jace_fair mulligans to six cards. [13:32:20] Matrim_Cauthon begins the game with seven cards in hand. [13:32:33] jace_fair puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [13:32:33] Turn 1: jace_fair [13:32:33] jace_fair skips their draw step. [13:32:36] jace_fair plays [Tranquil Cove]. [13:32:36] jace_fair puts triggered ability from [Tranquil Cove] onto the stack (When Tranquil Cove enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [13:32:39] Turn 1: Matrim_Cauthon [13:32:42] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Snow-Covered Swamp]. [13:32:43] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Snow-Covered Swamp[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful. [13:32:47] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Duress] targeting jace_fair. [13:32:50] [CHAT] jace_fair: ? [13:32:57] [CHAT] jace_fair: snow lands aren't legal [13:33:18] [CHAT] Matrim_Cauthon: whoops didnt realize i clicked on a snow land haha [13:33:45] jace_fair discards [Kabira Takedown]. [13:33:45] jace_fair reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Mystic Gate], [Plains], [Watcher of the Spheres], and [Serra Avenger]. [13:33:54] Turn 2: jace_fair [13:33:57] jace_fair plays [Plains]. [13:34:01] jace_fair casts [Watcher of the Spheres]. [13:34:06] Turn 2: Matrim_Cauthon [13:34:09] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Vivid Marsh]. [13:34:12] Turn 3: jace_fair [13:34:15] jace_fair plays [Mystic Gate]. [13:34:24] jace_fair casts [Honor of the Pure]. [13:34:31] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Watcher of the Spheres]. [13:34:37] Turn 3: Matrim_Cauthon [13:34:51] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Smallpox]. [13:34:51] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Smallpox[sU] has an advantageous bug. The client incorrectly display that you may choose to discard either the Adventure or the creature side of an Adventure card [13:35:10] Matrim_Cauthon chooses a card from their hand. [13:35:14] jace_fair chooses a card from their hand. [13:35:14] jace_fair chooses a card from their hand. [13:35:14] jace_fair discards [Favorable Winds]. [13:35:14] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Spikefield Hazard]. [13:35:16] jace_fair sacrifices [Watcher of the Spheres]. [13:35:20] Matrim_Cauthon sacrifices [Snow-Covered Swamp]. [13:35:21] jace_fair sacrifices [Plains]. [13:35:23] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Golgari Rot Farm]. [13:35:23] Matrim_Cauthon puts triggered ability from [Golgari Rot Farm] onto the stack (When Golgari Rot Farm enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.). [13:35:27] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Vivid Marsh] to its owner's hand with [Golgari Rot Farm]'s ability. [13:35:32] Turn 4: jace_fair [13:35:41] jace_fair casts [Serra Avenger]. [13:35:47] jace_fair plays [Tranquil Cove]. [13:35:47] jace_fair puts triggered ability from [Tranquil Cove] onto the stack (When Tranquil Cove enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [13:35:50] Turn 4: Matrim_Cauthon [13:36:02] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Vivid Marsh]. [13:36:06] Turn 5: jace_fair [13:36:11] jace_fair plays [Plains]. [13:36:14] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Serra Avenger]. [13:36:20] Turn 5: Matrim_Cauthon [13:36:29] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Bala Ged Recovery] targeting [Smallpox]. [13:36:32] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Smallpox] to its owner's hand with [Bala Ged Recovery]. [13:36:34] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Spikefield Cave]. [13:36:38] Turn 6: jace_fair [13:36:45] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Serra Avenger]. [13:36:59] jace_fair casts [Linvala, Shield of Sea Gate]. [13:37:11] Turn 6: Matrim_Cauthon [13:37:22] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Smallpox]. [13:37:35] Matrim_Cauthon chooses a card from their hand. [13:37:36] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Pieces of the Puzzle]. [13:37:40] jace_fair sacrifices [Serra Avenger]. [13:37:42] Matrim_Cauthon sacrifices [Spikefield Cave]. [13:37:45] jace_fair sacrifices [Plains]. [13:37:49] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Explore]. [13:37:51] Matrim_Cauthon draws a card with [Explore]. [13:37:54] Matrim_Cauthon plays [River of Tears]. [13:38:00] Turn 7: jace_fair [13:38:03] jace_fair plays [Island]. [13:38:07] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Linvala, Shield of Sea Gate]. [13:38:15] Turn 7: Matrim_Cauthon [13:38:26] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Smallpox]. [13:38:32] [CHAT] jace_fair: ugggggh [13:38:38] Matrim_Cauthon chooses a card from their hand. [13:38:38] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Flaying Tendrils]. [13:38:40] jace_fair sacrifices [Linvala, Shield of Sea Gate]. [13:38:42] Matrim_Cauthon sacrifices [Vivid Marsh]. [13:38:44] jace_fair sacrifices [Island]. [13:38:46] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Spikefield Cave]. [13:38:52] Turn 8: jace_fair [13:38:57] jace_fair casts [Healer's Hawk]. [13:39:02] Turn 8: Matrim_Cauthon [13:39:07] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Pieces of the Puzzle]. [13:39:08] Matrim_Cauthon reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Fetid Heath], [Golgari Rot Farm], [Sunken Ruins], [Pieces of the Puzzle], and [Hymn to Tourach]. [13:39:12] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Hymn to Tourach] and [Pieces of the Puzzle] into their hand with with [Pieces of the Puzzle]. [13:39:12] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Golgari Rot Farm], [Sunken Ruins], and [Fetid Heath] into their graveyard. [13:39:13] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Vivid Marsh]. [13:39:27] [CHAT] Matrim_Cauthon: lolol gg [13:39:31] Matrim_Cauthon has conceded from the game. Winner: jace_fair Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (738778954) == [Time] 1602729639 [13:40:39] PDBot has started watching. [13:40:44] Matrim_Cauthon chooses to play first. [13:40:44] [CHAT] jace_fair: love his vids [13:40:48] Matrim_Cauthon begins the game with seven cards in hand. [13:40:58] jace_fair begins the game with seven cards in hand. [13:40:58] Turn 1: Matrim_Cauthon [13:40:58] Matrim_Cauthon skips their draw step. [13:41:06] [CHAT] Matrim_Cauthon: yeah hes pretty great. i know its prob not fun to play against though [13:41:08] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Sunken Ruins]. [13:41:25] [CHAT] Matrim_Cauthon: just like walls in pauper lol [13:41:34] [CHAT] jace_fair: lol it's no biggie, I play a Johulkaups deck in this format sometimes [13:41:41] Turn 1: jace_fair [13:41:43] jace_fair plays [Plains]. [13:41:47] jace_fair casts [Judge's Familiar]. [13:41:53] Turn 2: Matrim_Cauthon [13:41:58] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Izzet Boilerworks]. [13:41:58] Matrim_Cauthon puts triggered ability from [Izzet Boilerworks] onto the stack (When Izzet Boilerworks enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.). [13:42:01] [CHAT] jace_fair: when I feel like stomping on the cloudpsot decks [13:42:05] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Sunken Ruins] to its owner's hand with [Izzet Boilerworks]'s ability. [13:42:08] Turn 2: jace_fair [13:42:12] jace_fair plays [Plains]. [13:42:17] jace_fair casts [Segovian Angel]. [13:42:24] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Judge's Familiar]. [13:42:28] Turn 3: Matrim_Cauthon [13:42:32] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Sunken Ruins]. [13:42:42] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting jace_fair. [13:42:46] jace_fair discards [Spell Pierce]. [13:42:46] jace_fair discards [Watcher of the Spheres]. [13:42:55] Turn 3: jace_fair [13:43:12] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Segovian Angel] and [Judge's Familiar]. [13:43:28] Turn 4: Matrim_Cauthon [13:43:31] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Sunken Ruins]. [13:43:45] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Smallpox]. [13:44:01] Matrim_Cauthon chooses a card from their hand. [13:44:12] jace_fair chooses a card from their hand. [13:44:12] jace_fair chooses a card from their hand. [13:44:12] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Bala Ged Recovery]. [13:44:12] jace_fair discards [Watcher of the Spheres]. [13:44:14] jace_fair sacrifices [Segovian Angel]. [13:44:18] Matrim_Cauthon sacrifices [Sunken Ruins]. [13:44:19] jace_fair sacrifices [Plains]. [13:44:30] Turn 4: jace_fair [13:44:32] jace_fair plays [Plains]. [13:44:35] jace_fair casts [Serra Avenger]. [13:44:40] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Judge's Familiar]. [13:44:47] Turn 5: Matrim_Cauthon [13:44:51] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Fetid Heath]. [13:45:09] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Vindicate] targeting [Serra Avenger]. [13:45:22] Turn 5: jace_fair [13:45:27] [CHAT] jace_fair: Judge's Familiar has been Thalia so far lol [13:45:34] [CHAT] Matrim_Cauthon: yeah no kidding! [13:45:37] jace_fair casts [Healer's Hawk]. [13:45:50] [CHAT] jace_fair: I love that card, it's good if they play around it or if they don't [13:45:54] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Judge's Familiar]. [13:46:04] jace_fair plays [Evolving Wilds]. [13:46:10] Turn 6: Matrim_Cauthon [13:46:27] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Collected Conjuring]. [13:46:33] jace_fair activates an ability of [Judge's Familiar] targeting [Collected Conjuring] (Sacrifice Judge's Familiar: Counter target instant or sorcery spell unless its controller pays {1}...). [13:46:38] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Bala Ged Sanctuary]. [13:46:46] jace_fair activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [13:46:52] Turn 6: jace_fair [13:46:55] [CHAT] Matrim_Cauthon: exactly and sometimes you just have to jam into it [13:46:55] jace_fair plays [Island]. [13:46:58] jace_fair casts [Linvala, Shield of Sea Gate]. [13:47:05] [CHAT] Matrim_Cauthon: familiar that is. thalia is an awesome card in her own right [13:47:18] [CHAT] jace_fair: if thalia were in this format I would be playing it, believe you me [13:47:37] [CHAT] jace_fair: I play a few Wingmare in this deck too [13:47:40] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Healer's Hawk]. [13:47:47] Turn 7: Matrim_Cauthon [13:47:51] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Pelakka Caverns]. [13:48:21] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Explore]. [13:48:24] Matrim_Cauthon draws a card with [Explore]. [13:48:26] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Sunken Ruins]. [13:48:35] Turn 7: jace_fair [13:48:39] jace_fair casts [Serra Avenger]. [13:48:51] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Linvala, Shield of Sea Gate] and [Healer's Hawk]. [13:48:55] Turn 8: Matrim_Cauthon [13:49:28] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Approach of the Second Sun]. [13:49:33] [CHAT] jace_fair: ruh roh [13:49:35] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Approach of the Second Sun] beneath the top 6 cards of their library. [13:49:36] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Orzhov Basilica]. [13:49:36] Matrim_Cauthon puts triggered ability from [Orzhov Basilica] onto the stack (When Orzhov Basilica enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.). [13:49:39] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Bala Ged Sanctuary] to its owner's hand with [Orzhov Basilica]'s ability. [13:49:40] Turn 8: jace_fair [13:49:57] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Serra Avenger], [Linvala, Shield of Sea Gate], and [Healer's Hawk]. [13:50:02] jace_fair casts [Rally of Wings]. [13:50:07] Turn 9: Matrim_Cauthon [13:50:12] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Pieces of the Puzzle]. [13:50:15] Matrim_Cauthon reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Orzhov Basilica], [Spikefield Hazard], [Pieces of the Puzzle], [Vindicate], and [Vivid Marsh]. [13:50:26] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Pieces of the Puzzle] and [Vindicate] into their hand with with [Pieces of the Puzzle]. [13:50:26] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Spikefield Hazard], [Orzhov Basilica], and [Vivid Marsh] into their graveyard. [13:50:39] [CHAT] Matrim_Cauthon: this deck needs a way to gain life i think [13:51:07] [CHAT] jace_fair: I only had you by one turn, ~10 draws in my deck were lethal by my math [13:51:17] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Pieces of the Puzzle]. [13:51:21] [CHAT] jace_fair: (rally and my 8 anthems) [13:51:23] Matrim_Cauthon reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Explore], [Smallpox], [Vivid Marsh], [Vivid Marsh], and [Approach of the Second Sun]. [13:51:28] Matrim_Cauthon puts no cards into their hand with with [Pieces of the Puzzle]. [13:51:28] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Smallpox], [Explore], [Vivid Marsh], [Vivid Marsh], and [Approach of the Second Sun] into their graveyard. [13:51:31] [CHAT] Matrim_Cauthon: ggs! [13:51:34] [CHAT] jace_fair: ggs [13:51:35] Matrim_Cauthon has conceded from the game. Winner: jace_fair Game 2 Completed. Match Winner: jace_fair: 2–0 [13:51:39] jace_fair has left the game.