PennyDreadful
Penny Dreadful 
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
kaniba,Matrim_Cauthon

== Game 1 (738730648) ==
[Time] 1602697570
[04:46:10] PDBot has started watching.
[League] Host doesn't have active run
[04:46:12] Matrim_Cauthon chooses to play first.
[04:46:16] Matrim_Cauthon begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:46:19] kaniba begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:46:19] Turn 1: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:46:23] Matrim_Cauthon skips their draw step.
[04:46:24] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Vivid Marsh].
[04:46:32] Turn 1: kaniba
[04:46:34] kaniba plays [Swamp].
[04:46:39] Turn 2: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:46:45] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Izzet Boilerworks].
[04:46:45] Matrim_Cauthon puts triggered ability from [Izzet Boilerworks] onto the stack (When Izzet Boilerworks enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[04:46:48] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Vivid Marsh] to its owner's hand with [Izzet Boilerworks]'s ability.
[04:46:51] Turn 2: kaniba
[04:46:53] kaniba plays [Swamp].
[04:46:57] kaniba casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting Matrim_Cauthon.
[04:47:00] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Explore].
[04:47:00] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Rakdos Carnarium].
[04:47:04] Turn 3: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:47:06] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Vivid Marsh].
[04:47:11] Turn 3: kaniba
[04:47:13] kaniba plays [Swamp].
[04:47:18] Turn 4: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:47:27] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[04:47:30] Matrim_Cauthon reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Collected Conjuring], [Smallpox], [Explore], [Sunken Ruins], and [Bala Ged Recovery].
[04:47:31] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Smallpox[sU] has an advantageous bug.
The client incorrectly display that you may choose to discard either the Adventure or the creature side of an Adventure card
[04:47:40] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Bala Ged Recovery] and [Explore] into their hand with with [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[04:47:40] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Smallpox], [Collected Conjuring], and [Sunken Ruins] into their graveyard.
[04:47:42] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Bala Ged Sanctuary].
[04:47:47] Turn 4: kaniba
[04:47:54] kaniba plays [Witch's Cottage].
[04:47:54] No legal targets to choose for [Witch's Cottage]'s triggered ability.
[04:48:00] kaniba casts [Bloodline Keeper].
[04:48:05] Turn 5: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:48:10] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Fetid Heath].
[04:48:18] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Smallpox].
[04:48:32] Matrim_Cauthon chooses a card from their hand.
[04:48:37] kaniba chooses a card from their hand.
[04:48:37] kaniba chooses a card from their hand.
[04:48:37] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Bala Ged Recovery].
[04:48:37] kaniba discards [Heartless Act].
[04:48:39] kaniba sacrifices [Bloodline Keeper].
[04:48:45] Matrim_Cauthon sacrifices [Bala Ged Sanctuary].
[04:48:55] kaniba sacrifices [Swamp].
[04:49:03] Turn 5: kaniba
[04:49:07] kaniba casts [Hypnotic Specter].
[04:49:14] Turn 6: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:49:21] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Collected Conjuring].
[04:49:50] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Bala Ged Recovery] targeting [Collected Conjuring].
[04:49:53] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Vindicate] targeting [Hypnotic Specter].
[04:50:08] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Collected Conjuring] to its owner's hand with [Bala Ged Recovery].
[04:50:09] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Golgari Rot Farm].
[04:50:09] Matrim_Cauthon puts triggered ability from [Golgari Rot Farm] onto the stack (When Golgari Rot Farm enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[04:50:15] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Fetid Heath] to its owner's hand with [Golgari Rot Farm]'s ability.
[04:50:19] Turn 6: kaniba
[04:50:26] Turn 7: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:50:28] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Fetid Heath].
[04:50:41] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Bala Ged Recovery] targeting [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[04:50:42] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Pieces of the Puzzle] to its owner's hand with [Bala Ged Recovery].
[04:50:52] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[04:50:55] Matrim_Cauthon reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Night of Souls' Betrayal], [Collected Conjuring], [Vivid Marsh], [Pieces of the Puzzle], and [Pelakka Predation].
[04:50:59] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Pieces of the Puzzle] and [Collected Conjuring] into their hand with with [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[04:50:59] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Pelakka Predation], [Night of Souls' Betrayal], and [Vivid Marsh] into their graveyard.
[04:51:06] Turn 7: kaniba
[04:51:08] kaniba plays [Swamp].
[04:51:12] kaniba casts [Bloodline Keeper].
[04:51:18] Turn 8: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:51:20] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[04:51:21] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Snow-Covered Swamp[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[04:51:32] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Vindicate] targeting [Bloodline Keeper].
[04:51:36] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Collected Conjuring].
[04:51:48] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting kaniba.
[04:51:52] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Explore].
[04:51:57] Matrim_Cauthon draws a card with [Explore].
[04:51:59] kaniba discards [Grasp of Darkness].
[04:51:59] kaniba discards [Bile Blight].
[04:52:04] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Orzhov Basilica].
[04:52:04] Matrim_Cauthon puts triggered ability from [Orzhov Basilica] onto the stack (When Orzhov Basilica enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[04:52:08] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Snow-Covered Swamp] to its owner's hand with [Orzhov Basilica]'s ability.
[04:52:13] Turn 8: kaniba
[04:52:15] kaniba plays [Swamp].
[04:52:20] Turn 9: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:52:23] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Explore].
[04:52:24] Matrim_Cauthon draws a card with [Explore].
[04:52:26] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Sunken Ruins].
[04:52:27] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[04:52:30] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[04:52:32] Matrim_Cauthon reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Timely Reinforcements], [Vindicate], [Sunken Ruins], [Explore], and [Collected Conjuring].
[04:52:38] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Timely Reinforcements] and [Vindicate] into their hand with with [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[04:52:38] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Explore], [Collected Conjuring], and [Sunken Ruins] into their graveyard.
[04:52:57] Turn 9: kaniba
[04:53:00] kaniba plays [Witch's Cottage].
[04:53:17] kaniba puts triggered ability from [Witch's Cottage] onto the stack targeting [Bloodline Keeper] (When Witch's Cottage enters the battlefield untapped, you may put target creature card from your g...).
[04:53:22] kaniba chooses not to use [Witch's Cottage]'s ability.
[04:53:27] Turn 10: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:53:35] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting kaniba.
[04:53:38] kaniba discards [Grasp of Darkness].
[04:53:38] kaniba discards [Heartless Act].
[04:53:45] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Collected Conjuring].
[04:53:53] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Pelakka Predation] targeting kaniba.
[04:53:55] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[04:53:57] Matrim_Cauthon reveals 5 cards with [Pieces of the Puzzle]: [Clear the Mind], [Fetid Heath], [Hymn to Tourach], [Spikefield Hazard], and [Smallpox].
[04:54:04] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Clear the Mind] and [Smallpox] into their hand with with [Pieces of the Puzzle].
[04:54:04] Matrim_Cauthon puts [Hymn to Tourach], [Spikefield Hazard], and [Fetid Heath] into their graveyard.
[04:54:12] kaniba reveals their hand to [Pelakka Predation], containing no cards.
[04:54:14] Matrim_Cauthon plays [River of Tears].
[04:54:22] Turn 10: kaniba
[04:54:26] kaniba has conceded from the game.
Winner: Matrim_Cauthon
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (738731534) ==
[Time] 1602698191
[04:56:32] PDBot has started watching.
[04:56:35] kaniba begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:56:37] Matrim_Cauthon begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[04:56:37] Turn 1: kaniba
[04:56:38] kaniba skips their draw step.
[04:56:39] kaniba plays [Swamp].
[04:56:45] kaniba casts [Tormod's Crypt].
[04:56:52] kaniba casts [Duress] targeting Matrim_Cauthon.
[04:57:20] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Vindicate].
[04:57:20] Matrim_Cauthon reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Vivid Marsh], [Sunken Ruins], [Orzhov Basilica], [Slagstorm], [Praetor's Grasp], [Spikefield Cave], and [Spikefield Hazard].
[04:57:24] Turn 1: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:57:28] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Vivid Marsh].
[04:57:33] Turn 2: kaniba
[04:57:37] kaniba plays [Witch's Cottage].
[04:57:42] Turn 2: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:57:47] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Golgari Rot Farm].
[04:57:47] Matrim_Cauthon puts triggered ability from [Golgari Rot Farm] onto the stack (When Golgari Rot Farm enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[04:57:59] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Vivid Marsh] to its owner's hand with [Golgari Rot Farm]'s ability.
[04:58:04] Turn 3: kaniba
[04:58:10] kaniba plays [Swamp].
[04:58:20] kaniba casts [Hypnotic Specter].
[04:58:26] Turn 3: Matrim_Cauthon
[04:58:33] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Vivid Marsh].
[04:58:39] Turn 4: kaniba
[04:58:54] kaniba plays [Witch's Cottage].
[04:58:55] No legal targets to choose for [Witch's Cottage]'s triggered ability.
[05:00:06] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Hypnotic Specter].
[05:00:09] kaniba puts triggered ability from [Hypnotic Specter] onto the stack (Whenever Hypnotic Specter deals damage to an opponent, that player discards a card at random.).
[05:00:12] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Bala Ged Recovery].
[05:00:25] kaniba casts [Memoricide] targeting Matrim_Cauthon.
[05:00:58] kaniba names Praetor's Grasp for [Memoricide].
[05:01:42] Turn 4: Matrim_Cauthon
[05:02:08] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Spikefield Cave].
[05:02:15] Turn 5: kaniba
[05:02:24] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Hypnotic Specter].
[05:02:32] kaniba puts triggered ability from [Hypnotic Specter] onto the stack (Whenever Hypnotic Specter deals damage to an opponent, that player discards a card at random.).
[05:02:34] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Sunken Ruins].
[05:02:42] kaniba casts [Desecration Demon].
[05:02:45] Turn 5: Matrim_Cauthon
[05:03:02] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Collected Conjuring].
[05:03:11] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Flaying Tendrils].
[05:03:13] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Vindicate] targeting [Desecration Demon].
[05:03:23] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Orzhov Basilica].
[05:03:24] Matrim_Cauthon puts triggered ability from [Orzhov Basilica] onto the stack (When Orzhov Basilica enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[05:03:27] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Vivid Marsh] to its owner's hand with [Orzhov Basilica]'s ability.
[05:03:32] Turn 6: kaniba
[05:03:38] kaniba casts [Duress] targeting Matrim_Cauthon.
[05:04:18] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Ondu Inversion].
[05:04:18] Matrim_Cauthon reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Vivid Marsh], [Izzet Boilerworks], and [Slagstorm].
[05:04:23] kaniba casts [Vampire Nighthawk].
[05:04:27] Turn 6: Matrim_Cauthon
[05:04:40] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Vivid Marsh].
[05:04:47] Turn 7: kaniba
[05:04:58] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Vampire Nighthawk].
[05:05:03] Turn 7: Matrim_Cauthon
[05:05:27] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Slagstorm] (Slagstorm deals 3 damage to each creature.).
[05:05:32] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Izzet Boilerworks].
[05:05:32] Matrim_Cauthon puts triggered ability from [Izzet Boilerworks] onto the stack (When Izzet Boilerworks enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[05:05:36] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Spikefield Cave] to its owner's hand with [Izzet Boilerworks]'s ability.
[05:05:38] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Timely Reinforcements].
[05:05:45] Turn 8: kaniba
[05:05:50] kaniba plays [Swamp].
[05:06:04] kaniba casts [Bloodline Keeper].
[05:06:10] Turn 8: Matrim_Cauthon
[05:06:20] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Collected Conjuring].
[05:06:33] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Bala Ged Recovery] targeting [Vindicate].
[05:06:36] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Hymn to Tourach] targeting kaniba.
[05:06:39] kaniba activates an ability of [Tormod's Crypt] targeting Matrim_Cauthon ({T}, Sacrifice Tormod's Crypt: Exile all cards from target player's graveyard.).
[05:06:45] kaniba discards [Nightveil Specter].
[05:06:49] Matrim_Cauthon's [Bala Ged Recovery] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[05:06:51] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Rakdos Carnarium].
[05:06:51] Matrim_Cauthon puts triggered ability from [Rakdos Carnarium] onto the stack (When Rakdos Carnarium enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[05:06:58] Matrim_Cauthon returns [Vivid Marsh] to its owner's hand with [Rakdos Carnarium]'s ability.
[05:07:02] Turn 9: kaniba
[05:07:08] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Bloodline Keeper].
[05:07:16] kaniba casts [Vampire Nighthawk].
[05:07:18] Turn 9: Matrim_Cauthon
[05:08:21] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Vivid Marsh].
[05:08:27] Matrim_Cauthon casts [Smallpox].
[05:08:35] Matrim_Cauthon chooses a card from their hand.
[05:08:35] Matrim_Cauthon discards [Spikefield Hazard].
[05:08:36] kaniba sacrifices [Vampire Nighthawk].
[05:08:38] Matrim_Cauthon sacrifices [Vivid Marsh].
[05:08:39] kaniba sacrifices [Swamp].
[05:08:49] Turn 10: kaniba
[05:08:57] Matrim_Cauthon is being attacked by [Bloodline Keeper].
[05:09:08] kaniba casts [Nightveil Specter].
[05:09:11] Turn 10: Matrim_Cauthon
[05:09:16] Matrim_Cauthon has conceded from the game.
Winner: kaniba
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (738732704) ==
[Time] 1602698982
[05:09:43] PDBot has started watching.
[05:09:44] Matrim_Cauthon mulligans to six cards.
[05:09:46] kaniba begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[05:09:50] Matrim_Cauthon puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[05:09:50] Turn 1: Matrim_Cauthon
[05:09:50] Matrim_Cauthon skips their draw step.
[05:09:53] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Bala Ged Sanctuary].
[05:09:57] Turn 1: kaniba
[05:09:59] kaniba plays [Swamp].
[05:10:02] kaniba casts [Tormod's Crypt].
[05:10:07] Turn 2: Matrim_Cauthon
[05:10:09] Matrim_Cauthon plays [Snow-Covered Swamp].
[05:10:14] Turn 2: kaniba
[05:10:16] kaniba plays [Swamp].
[05:10:21] Turn 3: Matrim_Cauthon
[05:10:24] Matrim_Cauthon has conceded from the game.
[05:10:24] Matrim_Cauthon has lost connection to the game.
Winner: kaniba
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: kaniba: 2–1