PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality wmackinnonwhs,NotGood == Game 1 (738055628) == [Time] 1602103178 [07:39:39] PDBot has started watching. [League] Reanimator by wmackinnonwhs (103172) vs Storm by notgood (103200) [07:39:41] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [07:39:47] NotGood chooses to play first. [07:39:50] NotGood begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:39:52] wmackinnonwhs mulligans to six cards. [07:39:58] wmackinnonwhs puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [07:39:58] Turn 1: NotGood [07:40:00] NotGood skips their draw step. [07:40:03] NotGood plays [Swamp]. [07:40:04] NotGood casts [Chromatic Star]. [07:40:05] Turn 1: wmackinnonwhs [07:40:07] wmackinnonwhs plays [Mountain]. [07:40:08] Turn 2: NotGood [07:40:12] NotGood plays [Island]. [07:40:14] NotGood casts [Strategic Planning]. [07:40:16] NotGood puts [Cabal Ritual] and [Sunken Ruins] into their graveyard. [07:40:17] Turn 2: wmackinnonwhs [07:40:21] wmackinnonwhs plays [Mountain]. [07:40:26] wmackinnonwhs discards [Heartless Act]. [07:40:26] wmackinnonwhs discards [Ritual of Soot]. [07:40:26] wmackinnonwhs casts [Cathartic Reunion]. [07:40:27] wmackinnonwhs draws three cards with [Cathartic Reunion]. [07:40:28] Turn 3: NotGood [07:40:36] NotGood plays [Sunken Ruins]. [07:40:41] NotGood casts [Brainstorm]. [07:40:41] NotGood draws three cards with [Brainstorm]. [07:40:47] NotGood casts [Ponder]. [07:40:50] NotGood chooses to shuffle his or her library. [07:40:50] NotGood draws a card with [Ponder]. [07:40:52] NotGood casts [Chromatic Star]. [07:40:53] Turn 3: wmackinnonwhs [07:40:58] wmackinnonwhs plays [Swamp]. [07:41:07] wmackinnonwhs discards [Reanimate]. [07:41:07] wmackinnonwhs discards [Terastodon]. [07:41:07] wmackinnonwhs casts [Cathartic Reunion]. [07:41:07] wmackinnonwhs draws three cards with [Cathartic Reunion]. [07:41:12] wmackinnonwhs casts [Reanimate] targeting [Terastodon]. [07:41:15] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Terastodon] onto the stack targeting [Island], [Swamp], and [Sunken Ruins] (When Terastodon enters the battlefield, you may destroy up to three target noncreature permanents....). [07:41:18] wmackinnonwhs's [Terastodon] creates an Elephant token under NotGood's control. [07:41:18] wmackinnonwhs's [Terastodon] creates an Elephant token under NotGood's control. [07:41:18] wmackinnonwhs's [Terastodon] creates an Elephant token under NotGood's control. [07:41:18] Turn 4: NotGood [07:41:23] Turn 4: wmackinnonwhs [07:41:27] wmackinnonwhs plays [Swamp]. [07:41:31] NotGood is being attacked by [Terastodon]. [07:41:51] wmackinnonwhs casts [Heartless Act] targeting [Terastodon] (Destroy target creature with no counters on it.). [07:41:57] wmackinnonwhs casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Terastodon]. [07:41:57] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...). [07:42:00] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Terastodon] onto the stack targeting [Swamp], [Mountain], and [Chromatic Star] (When Terastodon enters the battlefield, you may destroy up to three target noncreature permanents....). [07:42:02] wmackinnonwhs's [Terastodon] creates an Elephant token. [07:42:02] wmackinnonwhs's [Terastodon] creates an Elephant token. [07:42:02] wmackinnonwhs's [Terastodon] creates an Elephant token under NotGood's control. [07:42:02] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Chromatic Star] onto the stack (When Chromatic Star is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.). [07:42:03] NotGood draws a card with [Chromatic Star]'s ability. [07:42:03] Turn 5: NotGood [07:42:12] NotGood plays [Sunken Ruins]. [07:42:15] Turn 5: wmackinnonwhs [07:42:39] wmackinnonwhs plays [Lavaclaw Reaches]. [07:42:46] NotGood is being attacked by [Elephant] token and [Elephant] token. [07:42:49] [Elephant] token blocks [Elephant] token. [07:42:50] [Elephant] token blocks [Elephant] token. [07:42:58] wmackinnonwhs casts [Haggle]. [07:43:00] wmackinnonwhs discards [Mountain]. [07:43:00] wmackinnonwhs draws a card with [Haggle]. [07:43:05] Turn 6: NotGood [07:43:08] NotGood plays [Island]. [07:43:28] NotGood casts [Strategic Planning]. [07:43:31] NotGood puts [Gitaxian Probe] and [Swamp] into their graveyard. [07:43:33] Turn 6: wmackinnonwhs [07:43:40] wmackinnonwhs casts [Merchant of the Vale]. [07:43:42] wmackinnonwhs plays [Lavaclaw Reaches]. [07:43:47] NotGood is being attacked by [Terastodon]. [07:43:48] [Elephant] token blocks [Terastodon]. [07:43:49] Turn 7: NotGood [07:43:54] NotGood plays [Island]. [07:44:01] NotGood casts [Dark Ritual]. [07:44:03] NotGood casts [Cabal Ritual]. [07:44:04] NotGood casts [Cabal Ritual]. [07:44:06] NotGood casts [Cabal Ritual]. [07:44:08] NotGood casts [Ponder]. [07:44:16] NotGood chooses to shuffle his or her library. [07:44:16] NotGood draws a card with [Ponder]. [07:44:19] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Chromatic Star] onto the stack (When Chromatic Star is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.). [07:44:21] NotGood draws a card with [Chromatic Star]'s ability. [07:44:23] NotGood casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting wmackinnonwhs. [07:44:25] NotGood draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe]. [07:44:30] NotGood casts [Strategic Planning]. [07:44:33] NotGood puts [Diminishing Returns] and [Evolving Wilds] into their graveyard. [07:44:41] NotGood casts [Treasure Cruise]. [07:44:41] NotGood draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise]. [07:44:43] NotGood casts [Dark Ritual]. [07:44:46] NotGood casts [Cruel Bargain]. [07:44:46] NotGood draws four cards with [Cruel Bargain]. [07:44:48] NotGood casts [Dark Ritual]. [07:44:51] NotGood casts [Tendrils of Agony] targeting wmackinnonwhs. [07:44:51] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Tendrils of Agony] onto the stack (11 spells cast before Tendrils of Agony this turn. Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for ...). [07:44:54] wmackinnonwhs has conceded from the game. Winner: NotGood Game 1 Completed. [07:44:59] wmackinnonwhs has left the game. == Game 2 (738056146) == [Time] 1602103527 [07:45:27] PDBot has started watching. [07:45:30] wmackinnonwhs chooses to play first. [07:45:35] wmackinnonwhs begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:45:48] NotGood begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:45:48] Turn 1: wmackinnonwhs [07:45:48] wmackinnonwhs skips their draw step. [07:45:50] wmackinnonwhs plays [Mountain]. [07:45:53] wmackinnonwhs casts [Haggle]. [07:45:59] wmackinnonwhs discards [Terastodon]. [07:45:59] wmackinnonwhs draws a card with [Haggle]. [07:45:59] Turn 1: NotGood [07:46:05] NotGood plays [Swamp]. [07:46:07] NotGood casts [Chromatic Star]. [07:46:08] Turn 2: wmackinnonwhs [07:46:12] wmackinnonwhs plays [Swamp]. [07:46:15] wmackinnonwhs casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting NotGood. [07:46:21] NotGood reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Island], [Evolving Wilds], [Frantic Search], [Sunken Ruins], and [Dark Ritual]. [07:46:22] Turn 2: NotGood [07:46:29] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Chromatic Star] onto the stack (When Chromatic Star is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.). [07:46:30] NotGood draws a card with [Chromatic Star]'s ability. [07:46:31] NotGood casts [Brainstorm]. [07:46:31] NotGood draws three cards with [Brainstorm]. [07:46:36] NotGood plays [Evolving Wilds]. [07:46:37] NotGood activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [07:46:41] Turn 3: wmackinnonwhs [07:46:49] wmackinnonwhs plays [Swamp]. [07:46:53] wmackinnonwhs casts [Animate Dead] targeting [Terastodon]. [07:46:53] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Animate Dead] onto the stack (When Animate Dead enters the battlefield, if it's on the battlefield, it loses 'enchant creature c...). [07:47:00] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Terastodon] onto the stack targeting [Swamp], and [Island] (When Terastodon enters the battlefield, you may destroy up to three target noncreature permanents....). [07:47:04] wmackinnonwhs's [Terastodon] creates an Elephant token under NotGood's control. [07:47:04] wmackinnonwhs's [Terastodon] creates an Elephant token under NotGood's control. [07:47:10] Turn 3: NotGood [07:47:44] NotGood plays [Evolving Wilds]. [07:47:46] Turn 4: wmackinnonwhs [07:47:52] wmackinnonwhs plays [Swamp]. [07:48:00] wmackinnonwhs casts [Memoricide] targeting NotGood. [07:48:10] wmackinnonwhs names Tendrils of Agony for [Memoricide]. [07:48:33] NotGood has conceded from the game. Winner: wmackinnonwhs Game 2 Completed. [07:48:38] wmackinnonwhs has left the game. == Game 3 (738056408) == [Time] 1602103737 [07:48:58] PDBot has started watching. [07:49:12] NotGood chooses to play first. [07:49:15] NotGood begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:49:21] wmackinnonwhs begins the game with seven cards in hand. [07:49:21] Turn 1: NotGood [07:49:24] NotGood skips their draw step. [07:49:28] NotGood casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting wmackinnonwhs. [07:49:33] NotGood draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe]. [07:49:34] NotGood plays [Sunken Ruins]. [07:49:35] Turn 1: wmackinnonwhs [07:49:39] wmackinnonwhs plays [Lavaclaw Reaches]. [07:49:39] Turn 2: NotGood [07:49:42] NotGood plays [Island]. [07:49:44] Turn 2: wmackinnonwhs [07:49:48] wmackinnonwhs plays [Swamp]. [07:49:52] wmackinnonwhs casts [Burning Inquiry]. [07:49:56] wmackinnonwhs draws three cards with [Burning Inquiry]. [07:49:56] NotGood draws three cards with [Burning Inquiry]. [07:49:56] wmackinnonwhs discards [Graven Cairns]. [07:49:56] wmackinnonwhs discards [Animate Dead]. [07:49:56] wmackinnonwhs discards [Mountain]. [07:49:56] NotGood discards [Swamp]. [07:49:56] NotGood discards [Cabal Ritual]. [07:49:56] NotGood discards [Tendrils of Agony]. [07:50:04] NotGood casts [Brainstorm]. [07:50:04] NotGood draws three cards with [Brainstorm]. [07:50:20] Turn 3: NotGood [07:50:24] NotGood plays [Evolving Wilds]. [07:50:26] NotGood activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [07:50:40] NotGood casts [Treasure Cruise]. [07:50:43] NotGood draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise]. [07:50:49] NotGood discards [Evolving Wilds]. [07:50:49] Turn 3: wmackinnonwhs [07:50:52] wmackinnonwhs plays [Mountain]. [07:50:55] wmackinnonwhs casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting NotGood. [07:51:10] NotGood reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Gitaxian Probe], [Island], [Dark Ritual], [Chromatic Star], [Frantic Search], and [Diminishing Returns]. [07:51:13] Turn 4: NotGood [07:51:20] NotGood casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting wmackinnonwhs. [07:51:24] NotGood draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe]. [07:51:40] NotGood casts [Chromatic Star]. [07:51:44] NotGood plays [Swamp]. [07:51:46] NotGood casts [Duress] targeting wmackinnonwhs. [07:51:49] wmackinnonwhs discards [Cathartic Reunion]. [07:51:49] wmackinnonwhs reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Animate Dead], [Reanimate], [Reanimate], and [Agonizing Remorse]. [07:51:51] Turn 4: wmackinnonwhs [07:52:03] wmackinnonwhs casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting NotGood. [07:52:07] NotGood reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing [Island], [Dark Ritual], and [Diminishing Returns]. [07:52:08] wmackinnonwhs plays [Swamp]. [07:52:10] Turn 5: NotGood [07:52:21] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Chromatic Star] onto the stack (When Chromatic Star is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.). [07:52:22] NotGood draws a card with [Chromatic Star]'s ability. [07:52:33] NotGood casts [Dark Ritual]. [07:52:34] NotGood casts [Dark Ritual]. [07:52:40] NotGood plays [Island]. [07:52:42] NotGood casts [Diminishing Returns]. [07:52:46] NotGood chooses the number 7. [07:52:46] NotGood draws seven cards with [Diminishing Returns]. [07:52:48] wmackinnonwhs chooses the number 7. [07:52:48] wmackinnonwhs draws seven cards with [Diminishing Returns]. [07:52:52] NotGood casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting wmackinnonwhs. [07:52:55] NotGood draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe]. [07:52:58] NotGood casts [Dark Ritual]. [07:53:08] NotGood casts [Frantic Search]. [07:53:08] NotGood draws two cards with [Frantic Search]. [07:53:11] NotGood discards [Evolving Wilds]. [07:53:11] NotGood discards [Evolving Wilds]. [07:53:18] NotGood casts [Murmuring Mystic]. [07:53:23] NotGood casts [Dark Ritual]. [07:53:23] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...). [07:53:25] NotGood's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token. [07:53:31] NotGood casts [Ponder]. [07:53:31] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...). [07:53:31] NotGood's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token. [07:53:49] NotGood chooses to not shuffle his or her library. [07:53:49] NotGood draws a card with [Ponder]. [07:53:51] NotGood casts [Chromatic Star]. [07:53:55] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Chromatic Star] onto the stack (When Chromatic Star is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.). [07:53:55] NotGood draws a card with [Chromatic Star]'s ability. [07:53:58] NotGood casts [Duress] targeting wmackinnonwhs. [07:53:58] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...). [07:53:58] NotGood's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token. [07:54:07] wmackinnonwhs discards [Reanimate]. [07:54:07] wmackinnonwhs reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Duress], [Swamp], [Burning Inquiry], [Swamp], [Cathartic Reunion], and [Sphinx of the Steel Wind]. [07:54:09] NotGood casts [Brainstorm]. [07:54:09] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...). [07:54:09] NotGood's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token. [07:54:10] NotGood draws three cards with [Brainstorm]. [07:54:21] NotGood casts [Ponder]. [07:54:21] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...). [07:54:22] NotGood's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token. [07:54:30] NotGood chooses to not shuffle his or her library. [07:54:30] NotGood draws a card with [Ponder]. [07:54:32] NotGood casts [Gitaxian Probe] targeting wmackinnonwhs. [07:54:32] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...). [07:54:32] NotGood's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token. [07:54:35] NotGood draws a card with [Gitaxian Probe]. [07:54:35] Turn 5: wmackinnonwhs [07:54:49] wmackinnonwhs discards [Swamp]. [07:54:49] wmackinnonwhs discards [Sphinx of the Steel Wind]. [07:54:49] wmackinnonwhs casts [Cathartic Reunion]. [07:54:49] wmackinnonwhs draws three cards with [Cathartic Reunion]. [07:54:53] wmackinnonwhs plays [Mountain]. [07:54:56] wmackinnonwhs casts [Burning Inquiry]. [07:54:56] wmackinnonwhs draws three cards with [Burning Inquiry]. [07:54:56] NotGood draws three cards with [Burning Inquiry]. [07:54:56] wmackinnonwhs discards [Burning Inquiry]. [07:54:56] wmackinnonwhs discards [Swamp]. [07:54:56] wmackinnonwhs discards [Merchant of the Vale]. [07:54:56] NotGood discards [Treasure Cruise]. [07:54:56] NotGood discards [Frantic Search]. [07:54:56] NotGood discards [Brainstorm]. [07:55:03] wmackinnonwhs casts [Reanimate] targeting [Sphinx of the Steel Wind]. [07:55:07] wmackinnonwhs casts [Duress] targeting NotGood. [07:55:10] NotGood discards [Ponder]. [07:55:10] NotGood reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Cabal Ritual]. [07:55:11] Turn 6: NotGood [07:55:18] NotGood casts [Duress] targeting wmackinnonwhs. [07:55:19] NotGood puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...). [07:55:19] NotGood's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token. [07:55:22] wmackinnonwhs discards [Cathartic Reunion]. [07:55:22] wmackinnonwhs reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Swamp] and [Swamp]. [07:55:24] Turn 6: wmackinnonwhs [07:55:30] wmackinnonwhs casts [Agonizing Remorse] targeting NotGood. [07:55:31] NotGood reveals their hand to [Agonizing Remorse], containing no cards. [07:55:33] wmackinnonwhs plays [Swamp]. [07:55:38] NotGood is being attacked by [Sphinx of the Steel Wind]. [07:55:50] Turn 7: NotGood [07:55:58] Turn 7: wmackinnonwhs [07:56:06] NotGood is being attacked by [Sphinx of the Steel Wind]. [07:56:10] [Bird Illusion] token blocks [Sphinx of the Steel Wind]. [07:56:18] Turn 8: NotGood [07:56:27] NotGood has conceded from the game. Winner: wmackinnonwhs Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: wmackinnonwhs: 2–1