PennyDreadful
PDS T8 vs PeppaBigT
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
PeppaBigT,Starswhirl

== Game 1 (735566284) ==
[Time] 1600029047
[06:30:48] PDBot has started watching.
[06:30:48] PeppaBigT joined the game.
[06:30:48] Starswhirl joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 17.10
[Gatherling] Round=5
[06:31:02] PeppaBigT chooses to play first.
[06:31:06] PeppaBigT begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[06:31:13] [CHAT] Starswhirl: gl anf hf^^
[06:31:14] Starswhirl mulligans to six cards.
[06:31:21] Starswhirl puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[06:31:21] Turn 1: PeppaBigT
[06:31:21] PeppaBigT skips their draw step.
[06:31:22] PeppaBigT plays [Bad River].
[06:31:27] Turn 1: Starswhirl
[06:31:32] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:31:35] Starswhirl casts [Duress] targeting PeppaBigT.
[06:31:47] Honorbound84 has started watching.
[06:31:49] PeppaBigT discards [Consume the Meek].
[06:31:49] PeppaBigT reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Erebos's Intervention], [Island], [Thought Erasure], [Skinrender], and [Tombstalker].
[06:31:50] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Consume the Meek[sU] has an advantageous bug.
This card does not respect 711.4b and treats the converted mana cost of the back side of double-faced permanents as 0.
[06:31:51] Honorbound84 has stopped watching.
[06:31:57] Turn 2: PeppaBigT
[06:32:00] PeppaBigT activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...).
[06:32:05] PeppaBigT plays [Island].
[06:32:08] PeppaBigT casts [Thought Erasure] targeting Starswhirl.
[06:32:18] Starswhirl discards [Lord of the Undead].
[06:32:18] Starswhirl reveals their hand to [Thought Erasure], containing [Swamp], [Swamp], [Death Baron], and [Swamp].
[06:32:22] PeppaBigT puts 1 card on top of their library.
[06:32:29] Turn 2: Starswhirl
[06:32:33] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:32:36] Turn 3: PeppaBigT
[06:32:39] PeppaBigT plays [Dismal Backwater].
[06:32:39] PeppaBigT puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[06:32:47] Turn 3: Starswhirl
[06:32:50] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:32:56] Starswhirl casts [Death Baron].
[06:33:02] Turn 4: PeppaBigT
[06:33:05] PeppaBigT plays [Island].
[06:33:09] PeppaBigT casts [Skinrender].
[06:33:14] PeppaBigT puts triggered ability from [Skinrender] onto the stack targeting [Death Baron] (When Skinrender enters the battlefield, put three -1/-1 counters on target creature.).
[06:33:21] Turn 4: Starswhirl
[06:33:24] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:33:27] Starswhirl casts [Diregraf Ghoul].
[06:33:32] Starswhirl casts [Lord of the Undead].
[06:33:46] Turn 5: PeppaBigT
[06:33:52] Starswhirl is being attacked by [Skinrender].
[06:34:05] PeppaBigT casts [Erebos's Intervention] targeting [Lord of the Undead]. (X is 2) (Target creature gets -X/-X until end of turn. You gain X life.).
[06:34:08] Turn 5: Starswhirl
[06:34:14] Starswhirl casts [Lord of the Undead].
[06:34:20] PeppaBigT is being attacked by [Diregraf Ghoul].
[06:34:32] PeppaBigT casts [Opt].
[06:34:36] PeppaBigT puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[06:34:36] PeppaBigT draws a card with [Opt].
[06:34:38] Turn 6: PeppaBigT
[06:34:46] Starswhirl is being attacked by [Skinrender].
[06:34:57] PeppaBigT discards [Lonely Sandbar].
[06:34:57] PeppaBigT cycles [Lonely Sandbar].
[06:35:03] PeppaBigT plays [Bad River].
[06:35:10] PeppaBigT casts [Tombstalker].
[06:35:16] Turn 6: Starswhirl
[06:35:19] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:35:24] Starswhirl activates an ability of [Lord of the Undead] targeting [Death Baron] ( Return target Zombie card from your graveyard to your hand.).
[06:35:32] Starswhirl returns [Death Baron] to its owner's hand with [Lord of the Undead]'s ability.
[06:35:36] Starswhirl casts [Death Baron].
[06:35:48] Turn 7: PeppaBigT
[06:35:52] PeppaBigT plays [Swamp].
[06:35:55] PeppaBigT casts [Phyrexian Rager].
[06:35:57] PeppaBigT puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Rager] onto the stack (When Phyrexian Rager enters the battlefield, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[06:35:59] PeppaBigT draws a card with [Phyrexian Rager]'s ability.
[06:36:04] PeppaBigT activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...).
[06:36:17] Starswhirl is being attacked by [Tombstalker].
[06:36:32] Turn 7: Starswhirl
[06:36:39] Starswhirl activates an ability of [Lord of the Undead] targeting [Lord of the Undead] ( Return target Zombie card from your graveyard to your hand.).
[06:36:43] Starswhirl returns [Lord of the Undead] to its owner's hand with [Lord of the Undead]'s ability.
[06:36:47] Starswhirl casts [Lord of the Undead].
[06:36:51] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:37:03] Turn 8: PeppaBigT
[06:37:08] PeppaBigT plays [Dismal Backwater].
[06:37:08] PeppaBigT puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[06:37:15] PeppaBigT casts [Forbidden Alchemy].
[06:37:27] PeppaBigT puts [Atris, Oracle of Half-Truths], [Barren Moor], and [Island] into their graveyard.
[06:37:51] PeppaBigT casts [Tombstalker].
[06:37:59] Starswhirl is being attacked by [Tombstalker].
[06:38:10] Turn 8: Starswhirl
[06:38:15] Starswhirl casts [Cemetery Reaper].
[06:38:50] Starswhirl has conceded from the game.
Winner: PeppaBigT
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (735567134) ==
[Time] 1600029581
[06:39:41] PDBot has started watching.
[06:39:45] Starswhirl chooses to play first.
[06:39:48] Starswhirl begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[06:39:51] PeppaBigT begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[06:39:51] Turn 1: Starswhirl
[06:39:54] Starswhirl skips their draw step.
[06:39:55] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:39:58] Starswhirl casts [Duress] targeting PeppaBigT.
[06:40:33] PeppaBigT discards [Drown in the Loch].
[06:40:33] PeppaBigT reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Moment of Craving], [Island], [Dismal Backwater], [Island], [Dismal Backwater], and [Island].
[06:40:40] Turn 1: PeppaBigT
[06:40:42] PeppaBigT plays [Dismal Backwater].
[06:40:43] PeppaBigT puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[06:40:51] Turn 2: Starswhirl
[06:40:55] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:40:57] Starswhirl casts [Carnophage].
[06:41:00] Starswhirl casts [Soul-Guide Lantern].
[06:41:03] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Soul-Guide Lantern] onto the stack targeting [Drown in the Loch] (When Soul-Guide Lantern enters the battlefield, exile target card from a graveyard.).
[06:41:09] Turn 2: PeppaBigT
[06:41:15] PeppaBigT plays [Island].
[06:41:21] Turn 3: Starswhirl
[06:41:21] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.).
[06:41:41] Starswhirl casts [Undead Augur].
[06:41:53] PeppaBigT casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Undead Augur].
[06:41:57] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Undead Augur] onto the stack (Whenever Undead Augur or another Zombie you control dies, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[06:42:01] Starswhirl draws a card with [Undead Augur]'s ability.
[06:42:04] PeppaBigT is being attacked by [Carnophage].
[06:42:11] Turn 3: PeppaBigT
[06:42:18] PeppaBigT plays [Bad River].
[06:42:25] Turn 4: Starswhirl
[06:42:25] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.).
[06:42:38] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:42:40] Starswhirl casts [Lord of the Undead].
[06:42:45] PeppaBigT is being attacked by [Carnophage].
[06:42:55] Turn 4: PeppaBigT
[06:42:59] PeppaBigT plays [Bad River].
[06:43:01] PeppaBigT activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...).
[06:43:09] PeppaBigT casts [Thought Erasure] targeting Starswhirl.
[06:43:17] Starswhirl discards [Dark Salvation].
[06:43:17] Starswhirl reveals their hand to [Thought Erasure], containing [Lake of the Dead] and [Soul-Guide Lantern].
[06:43:20] PeppaBigT puts 1 card on top of their library.
[06:43:31] Turn 5: Starswhirl
[06:43:31] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.).
[06:43:43] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:43:46] Starswhirl activates an ability of [Soul-Guide Lantern] ( Draw a card.).
[06:43:46] Starswhirl draws a card with [Soul-Guide Lantern]'s ability.
[06:44:03] Starswhirl casts [Soul-Guide Lantern].
[06:44:11] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Soul-Guide Lantern] onto the stack targeting [Thought Erasure] (When Soul-Guide Lantern enters the battlefield, exile target card from a graveyard.).
[06:44:23] PeppaBigT is being attacked by [Lord of the Undead] and [Carnophage].
[06:44:30] Turn 5: PeppaBigT
[06:44:35] PeppaBigT activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...).
[06:44:42] PeppaBigT plays [Island].
[06:44:48] PeppaBigT casts [Tombstalker].
[06:44:59] Turn 6: Starswhirl
[06:44:59] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.).
[06:45:17] Starswhirl casts [Cemetery Reaper].
[06:45:25] Starswhirl plays [Lake of the Dead].
[06:45:27] Starswhirl sacrifices [Swamp].
[06:46:07] PeppaBigT is being attacked by [Lord of the Undead] and [Carnophage].
[06:46:11] [Tombstalker] blocks [Lord of the Undead].
[06:46:17] Starswhirl casts [Nameless Inversion] targeting [Tombstalker].
[06:46:24] Turn 6: PeppaBigT
[06:46:27] PeppaBigT plays [Dismal Backwater].
[06:46:27] PeppaBigT puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[06:46:36] Turn 7: Starswhirl
[06:46:36] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.).
[06:46:46] Honorbound84 has started watching.
[06:46:56] PeppaBigT is being attacked by [Cemetery Reaper] and [Carnophage].
[06:47:03] Turn 7: PeppaBigT
[06:47:07] PeppaBigT plays [Dismal Backwater].
[06:47:08] PeppaBigT puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[06:47:20] Starswhirl activates an ability of [Soul-Guide Lantern] ( Draw a card.).
[06:47:20] Starswhirl draws a card with [Soul-Guide Lantern]'s ability.
[06:47:22] Turn 8: Starswhirl
[06:47:23] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.).
[06:47:37] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:47:41] PeppaBigT is being attacked by [Cemetery Reaper] and [Carnophage].
[06:47:48] Turn 8: PeppaBigT
[06:47:52] PeppaBigT has conceded from the game.
Winner: Starswhirl
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (735568010) ==
[Time] 1600030101
[06:48:22] PDBot has started watching.
[06:48:23] PeppaBigT begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[06:48:25] Starswhirl begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[06:48:25] Turn 1: PeppaBigT
[06:48:25] PeppaBigT skips their draw step.
[06:48:27] PeppaBigT plays [Lonely Sandbar].
[06:48:31] Turn 1: Starswhirl
[06:48:35] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:48:37] Starswhirl casts [Carnophage].
[06:48:43] Turn 2: PeppaBigT
[06:48:46] PeppaBigT plays [Swamp].
[06:48:48] PeppaBigT casts [Thought Erasure] targeting Starswhirl.
[06:49:10] Starswhirl discards [Liliana's Mastery].
[06:49:11] Starswhirl reveals their hand to [Thought Erasure], containing [Swamp], [Swamp], [Swamp], [Lord of the Undead], and [Soul-Guide Lantern].
[06:49:14] PeppaBigT puts 1 card on top of their library.
[06:49:20] Turn 2: Starswhirl
[06:49:20] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.).
[06:49:28] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:49:32] Starswhirl casts [Soul-Guide Lantern].
[06:49:35] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Soul-Guide Lantern] onto the stack targeting [Thought Erasure] (When Soul-Guide Lantern enters the battlefield, exile target card from a graveyard.).
[06:49:40] PeppaBigT is being attacked by [Carnophage].
[06:49:46] Turn 3: PeppaBigT
[06:49:49] PeppaBigT plays [Swamp].
[06:49:51] PeppaBigT casts [Jorubai Murk Lurker].
[06:50:02] Turn 3: Starswhirl
[06:50:02] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.).
[06:50:11] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:50:23] Starswhirl casts [Undead Augur].
[06:50:29] Turn 4: PeppaBigT
[06:50:32] PeppaBigT plays [Dismal Backwater].
[06:50:32] PeppaBigT puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[06:50:38] PeppaBigT casts [Thought Erasure] targeting Starswhirl.
[06:50:41] Starswhirl discards [Lord of the Undead].
[06:50:41] Starswhirl reveals their hand to [Thought Erasure], containing [Swamp] and [Swamp].
[06:50:43] PeppaBigT puts 1 card on top of their library.
[06:50:55] Starswhirl activates an ability of [Soul-Guide Lantern] ( Draw a card.).
[06:50:55] Starswhirl draws a card with [Soul-Guide Lantern]'s ability.
[06:50:57] Turn 4: Starswhirl
[06:50:57] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.).
[06:51:04] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:51:07] Starswhirl casts [Soul-Guide Lantern].
[06:51:10] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Soul-Guide Lantern] onto the stack targeting [Thought Erasure] (When Soul-Guide Lantern enters the battlefield, exile target card from a graveyard.).
[06:51:16] Starswhirl casts [Lord of the Undead].
[06:51:20] PeppaBigT is being attacked by [Undead Augur] and [Carnophage].
[06:51:24] [Jorubai Murk Lurker] blocks [Undead Augur].
[06:51:30] Turn 5: PeppaBigT
[06:51:37] PeppaBigT casts [Deep Analysis] targeting PeppaBigT.
[06:51:41] PeppaBigT draws two cards with [Deep Analysis].
[06:51:43] PeppaBigT plays [Swamp].
[06:51:53] Turn 5: Starswhirl
[06:51:54] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.).
[06:52:05] Starswhirl plays [Swamp].
[06:52:14] Starswhirl casts [Dark Salvation] targeting Starswhirl, and [Jorubai Murk Lurker]. (X is 2).
[06:52:14] Starswhirl's [Dark Salvation] creates two Zombie tokens.
[06:52:21] PeppaBigT is being attacked by [Lord of the Undead], [Undead Augur], and [Carnophage].
[06:52:26] [CHAT] PeppaBigT: nice
[06:52:37] Turn 6: PeppaBigT
[06:52:47] PeppaBigT plays [Island].
[06:52:50] bakert99 has started watching.
[06:52:54] PeppaBigT casts [Deep Analysis] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting PeppaBigT.
[06:52:58] PeppaBigT draws two cards with [Deep Analysis].
[06:53:03] [CHAT] bakert99: !record
[06:53:03] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  PeppaBigT 1-1 Starswhirl
[06:53:09] PeppaBigT casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Lord of the Undead].
[06:53:12] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Undead Augur] onto the stack (Whenever Undead Augur or another Zombie you control dies, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[06:53:16] Starswhirl draws a card with [Undead Augur]'s ability.
[06:53:20] PeppaBigT casts [Mire Triton].
[06:53:22] PeppaBigT puts triggered ability from [Mire Triton] onto the stack (When Mire Triton enters the battlefield, mill two cards and you gain 2 life.).
[06:53:26] PeppaBigT mills [Island] and [Dismal Backwater].
[06:53:32] Turn 6: Starswhirl
[06:53:33] Starswhirl puts triggered ability from [Carnophage] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, tap Carnophage unless you pay 1 life.).
[06:53:47] Starswhirl activates an ability of [Soul-Guide Lantern] ( Draw a card.).
[06:53:49] Starswhirl draws a card with [Soul-Guide Lantern]'s ability.
[06:53:53] Starswhirl casts [Death Baron].
[06:54:03] PeppaBigT is being attacked by [Zombie] token, [Zombie] token, [Undead Augur], and [Carnophage].
[06:54:06] [CHAT] PeppaBigT: nice
[06:54:09] PeppaBigT has conceded from the game.
Winner: Starswhirl
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Starswhirl: 2–1
[06:54:13] PeppaBigT has left the game.