PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality pielord599,FratMank94 == Game 1 (734010472) == [Time] 1598645810 [06:16:51] PDBot has started watching. [League] Mono Black Ramp/Control by pielord599 (90801) vs Pdmill by fratmank94 (91043) [06:16:54] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [06:16:57] [CHAT] pielord599: gl hf [06:16:59] pielord599 chooses to play first. [06:17:00] [CHAT] FratMank94: glhf :) [06:17:16] pielord599 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [06:17:18] FratMank94 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [06:17:18] Turn 1: pielord599 [06:17:18] pielord599 skips their draw step. [06:17:25] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:17:32] pielord599 casts [Duress] targeting FratMank94. [06:17:55] FratMank94 discards [Sanity Grinding]. [06:17:55] FratMank94 reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Startled Awake], [Island], [Mind Funeral], [Grimoire Thief], [Dimir Guildgate], [Venture Deeper], and [Merfolk Secretkeeper]. [06:18:15] Turn 1: FratMank94 [06:18:18] FratMank94 plays [Dimir Guildgate]. [06:18:21] Turn 2: pielord599 [06:18:23] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:18:25] pielord599 casts [Ransack the Lab]. [06:18:30] pielord599 puts [Dark Ritual] and [Duress] into their graveyard. [06:18:38] Turn 2: FratMank94 [06:18:41] FratMank94 plays [Island]. [06:18:44] FratMank94 casts [Grimoire Thief]. [06:18:48] Turn 3: pielord599 [06:18:53] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:18:54] pielord599 casts [Culling Scales]. [06:19:00] Turn 3: FratMank94 [06:19:23] pielord599 is being attacked by [Grimoire Thief]. [06:19:23] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Grimoire Thief] onto the stack targeting pielord599 (Whenever Grimoire Thief becomes tapped, exile the top three cards of target opponent's library fac...). [06:19:24] [CHAT] pielord599: i was not aware most of these cards existed [06:19:39] FratMank94 casts [Grimoire Thief]. [06:19:42] Turn 4: pielord599 [06:19:46] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Culling Scales] onto the stack targeting [Grimoire Thief] (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target nonland permanent with the lowest converted mana c...). [06:19:51] pielord599 casts [Phylactery Lich]. [06:19:53] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:19:57] Turn 4: FratMank94 [06:20:19] Turn 5: pielord599 [06:20:19] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Culling Scales] onto the stack targeting [Grimoire Thief] (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target nonland permanent with the lowest converted mana c...). [06:20:33] FratMank94 is being attacked by [Phylactery Lich]. [06:20:39] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:20:42] pielord599 casts [Clackbridge Troll]. [06:20:54] FratMank94 casts [Logic Knot] targeting [Clackbridge Troll]. (X is 1). [06:21:09] Turn 5: FratMank94 [06:21:13] FratMank94 plays [Island]. [06:21:31] FratMank94 casts [Sanity Grinding] targeting pielord599. [06:21:31] FratMank94 reveals [Island] [06:21:31] FratMank94 reveals [Merfolk Secretkeeper] [06:21:31] FratMank94 reveals [Island] [06:21:31] FratMank94 reveals [Dismal Backwater] [06:21:31] FratMank94 reveals [Swamp] [06:21:31] FratMank94 reveals [Dismal Backwater] [06:21:31] FratMank94 reveals [Grimoire Thief] [06:21:31] FratMank94 reveals [Merfolk Secretkeeper] [06:21:32] FratMank94 reveals [Drown in the Loch] [06:21:32] FratMank94 reveals [Startled Awake] [06:21:32] pielord599 mills [Heartless Act], [Lake of the Dead], [Darksteel Axe], [Darksteel Axe], [Culling Scales], [Duress] and [Heartless Act]. [06:21:49] Turn 6: pielord599 [06:21:57] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Culling Scales] onto the stack targeting [Phylactery Lich] (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target nonland permanent with the lowest converted mana c...). [06:22:02] FratMank94 is being attacked by [Phylactery Lich]. [06:22:11] pielord599 casts [Culling Scales]. [06:22:13] Turn 6: FratMank94 [06:22:25] FratMank94 casts [Mind Funeral] targeting pielord599. [06:22:26] pielord599 reveals 7 cards with [Mind Funeral]: [Swamp], [Sign in Blood], [Dark Ritual], [Culling Scales], [Swamp], [Swamp], and [Swamp]. [06:22:35] FratMank94 has conceded from the game. Winner: pielord599 Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (734011122) == [Time] 1598646231 [06:23:51] PDBot has started watching. [06:23:52] FratMank94 chooses to play first. [06:24:01] [CHAT] FratMank94: lol thanks [06:24:06] FratMank94 mulligans to six cards. [06:24:26] [CHAT] FratMank94: my brother in law built a mill deck that wasn't too unlike this one a long time ago [06:24:30] pielord599 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [06:24:43] FratMank94 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [06:24:43] Turn 1: FratMank94 [06:24:48] FratMank94 skips their draw step. [06:24:50] FratMank94 plays [Dimir Guildgate]. [06:24:53] Turn 1: pielord599 [06:24:58] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:25:00] pielord599 casts [Darksteel Axe]. [06:25:08] [CHAT] pielord599: i was really worried that game since i had kept a very slow hand [06:25:12] Turn 2: FratMank94 [06:25:21] FratMank94 plays [Island]. [06:25:25] FratMank94 casts [Grimoire Thief]. [06:25:28] [CHAT] pielord599: especially once i saw all the scary mill cards in your hand [06:25:30] Turn 2: pielord599 [06:25:37] [CHAT] FratMank94: lol [06:25:38] pielord599 plays [Lake of the Dead]. [06:25:39] pielord599 sacrifices [Swamp]. [06:25:44] pielord599 casts [Dark Ritual]. [06:25:51] pielord599 casts [Phylactery Lich]. [06:25:58] pielord599 casts [Soul-Guide Lantern]. [06:26:02] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Soul-Guide Lantern] onto the stack targeting [Swamp] (When Soul-Guide Lantern enters the battlefield, exile target card from a graveyard.). [06:26:10] Turn 3: FratMank94 [06:26:13] FratMank94 plays [Dismal Backwater]. [06:26:14] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [06:26:20] [CHAT] pielord599: that 3 blue pips one can be super scary [06:26:27] FratMank94 casts [Winds of Rebuke] targeting [Phylactery Lich]. [06:26:28] FratMank94 returns [Phylactery Lich] to its owner's hand with [Winds of Rebuke]. [06:26:28] pielord599 mills [Duress] and [Swamp]. [06:26:28] FratMank94 mills [Drown in the Loch] and [Sanity Grinding]. [06:26:42] [CHAT] pielord599: oh yay now i get more phylactery counters on artifacts [06:26:47] pielord599 is being attacked by [Grimoire Thief]. [06:26:47] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Grimoire Thief] onto the stack targeting pielord599 (Whenever Grimoire Thief becomes tapped, exile the top three cards of target opponent's library fac...). [06:27:05] [CHAT] FratMank94: yeah, I clicked the wrong target and realized that I just punted [06:27:11] Turn 3: pielord599 [06:27:27] [CHAT] FratMank94: its what the deck is based around [06:27:33] [CHAT] FratMank94: puts up some fun games [06:27:40] [CHAT] pielord599: oh i didnt even realize that could bounce non-creature permanents [06:27:45] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:27:50] pielord599 casts [Ransack the Lab]. [06:27:54] [CHAT] FratMank94: yup, any nonland [06:28:03] pielord599 puts [Soul-Guide Lantern] and [Swamp] into their graveyard. [06:28:08] pielord599 casts [Phylactery Lich]. [06:28:20] Turn 4: FratMank94 [06:28:24] FratMank94 plays [Island]. [06:28:27] [CHAT] pielord599: man thats an unfortunate misclick [06:28:39] FratMank94 casts [Sanity Grinding] targeting pielord599. [06:28:39] FratMank94 reveals [Island] [06:28:39] FratMank94 reveals [Drown in the Loch] [06:28:39] FratMank94 reveals [Fraying Sanity] [06:28:39] FratMank94 reveals [Island] [06:28:39] FratMank94 reveals [Grimoire Thief] [06:28:39] FratMank94 reveals [Startled Awake] [06:28:40] FratMank94 reveals [Merfolk Secretkeeper] [06:28:40] FratMank94 reveals [Island] [06:28:40] FratMank94 reveals [Island] [06:28:40] FratMank94 reveals [Dimir Guildgate] [06:28:40] pielord599 mills [Culling Scales], [Phylactery Lich], [Darksteel Axe], [Dark Ritual], [Duress], [Swamp] and [Culling Scales]. [06:28:53] Turn 4: pielord599 [06:28:59] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:29:02] pielord599 activates an ability of [Soul-Guide Lantern] ( Draw a card.). [06:29:04] pielord599 draws a card with [Soul-Guide Lantern]'s ability. [06:29:14] pielord599 casts [Ransack the Lab]. [06:29:18] pielord599 puts [Lake of the Dead] and [Swamp] into their graveyard. [06:29:21] pielord599 casts [Sign in Blood] targeting pielord599. [06:29:22] pielord599 draws two cards with [Sign in Blood]. [06:29:29] FratMank94 is being attacked by [Phylactery Lich]. [06:29:40] Turn 5: FratMank94 [06:29:42] FratMank94 plays [Island]. [06:29:49] pielord599 is being attacked by [Grimoire Thief]. [06:29:49] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Grimoire Thief] onto the stack targeting pielord599 (Whenever Grimoire Thief becomes tapped, exile the top three cards of target opponent's library fac...). [06:30:10] FratMank94 casts [Breaking] targeting pielord599. [06:30:11] pielord599 mills [Clackbridge Troll], [Culling Scales], [Swamp], [Phylactery Lich], [Swamp], [Swamp], [Swamp] and [Duress]. [06:30:17] FratMank94 casts [Mind Funeral] targeting pielord599. [06:30:18] pielord599 reveals 15 cards with [Mind Funeral]: [Culling Scales], [Sign in Blood], [Swamp], [Phylactery Lich], [Choking Sands], [Darksteel Axe], [Swamp], [Swamp], [Ransack the Lab], [Duress], [06:30:18] [Ransack the Lab], [Dark Ritual], [Sign in Blood], [Soul-Guide Lantern], and [Swamp]. [06:30:26] [CHAT] pielord599: well [06:30:31] Turn 5: pielord599 [06:30:38] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:30:42] [CHAT] FratMank94: always worth it to play it out though [06:30:43] pielord599 casts [Sign in Blood] targeting pielord599. [06:30:46] pielord599 draws two cards with [Sign in Blood]. [06:30:47] pielord599 loses because of drawing a card with an empty library. Winner: FratMank94 Game 2 Completed. [06:30:52] FratMank94 has left the game. == Game 3 (734011734) == [Time] 1598646671 [06:31:12] PDBot has started watching. [06:31:15] pielord599 chooses to play first. [06:31:25] pielord599 begins the game with seven cards in hand. [06:31:44] [CHAT] FratMank94: 2 clackbridge and a dark ritual namely. couple other spells I don't remember and lands [06:31:50] FratMank94 mulligans to six cards. [06:32:07] [CHAT] pielord599: ah yeah those were some good spells to be able to counter [06:32:07] FratMank94 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [06:32:07] Turn 1: pielord599 [06:32:07] pielord599 skips their draw step. [06:32:09] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:32:14] Turn 1: FratMank94 [06:32:18] FratMank94 plays [Dismal Backwater]. [06:32:18] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [06:32:24] Turn 2: pielord599 [06:32:30] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:32:42] [CHAT] FratMank94: he gets, the job done AND has 2 pips [06:32:46] Turn 2: FratMank94 [06:32:50] FratMank94 plays [Dismal Backwater]. [06:32:50] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [06:32:55] Turn 3: pielord599 [06:32:59] pielord599 plays [Lake of the Dead]. [06:33:01] pielord599 sacrifices [Swamp]. [06:33:06] pielord599 casts [Clackbridge Troll]. [06:33:08] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Clackbridge Troll] onto the stack targeting FratMank94 (When Clackbridge Troll enters the battlefield, target opponent creates three 0/1 white Goat creatu...). [06:33:11] pielord599's [Clackbridge Troll] creates three Goat tokens under FratMank94's control. [06:33:13] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Clackbridge Troll] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, any opponent may sacrifice a creature. If a player does, ...). [06:33:19] pielord599 draws a card with [Clackbridge Troll]'s ability. [06:33:27] Turn 3: FratMank94 [06:33:30] FratMank94 plays [Island]. [06:33:46] FratMank94 casts [Sanity Grinding] targeting pielord599. [06:33:46] FratMank94 reveals [Winds of Rebuke] [06:33:46] FratMank94 reveals [Island] [06:33:46] FratMank94 reveals [Merfolk Secretkeeper] [06:33:46] FratMank94 reveals [Island] [06:33:46] FratMank94 reveals [Logic Knot] [06:33:46] FratMank94 reveals [Breaking/Entering] [06:33:46] FratMank94 reveals [Logic Knot] [06:33:47] FratMank94 reveals [Breaking/Entering] [06:33:47] FratMank94 reveals [Startled Awake] [06:33:47] FratMank94 reveals [Drown in the Loch] [06:33:47] pielord599 mills 11 cards. [06:33:48] [CHAT] pielord599: my deck is much better vs creature based decks than control decks [06:33:53] [CHAT] pielord599: damn [06:33:59] Turn 4: pielord599 [06:34:18] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Clackbridge Troll] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, any opponent may sacrifice a creature. If a player does, ...). [06:34:23] pielord599 draws a card with [Clackbridge Troll]'s ability. [06:34:28] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:34:34] pielord599 casts [Dark Ritual]. [06:34:41] pielord599 casts [Clackbridge Troll]. [06:34:43] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Clackbridge Troll] onto the stack targeting FratMank94 (When Clackbridge Troll enters the battlefield, target opponent creates three 0/1 white Goat creatu...). [06:34:46] pielord599's [Clackbridge Troll] creates three Goat tokens under FratMank94's control. [06:34:49] pielord599 casts [Ransack the Lab]. [06:34:55] [CHAT] pielord599: probably shoulda done that pre combat [06:34:56] pielord599 puts [Lake of the Dead] and [Lake of the Dead] into their graveyard. [06:35:00] Turn 4: FratMank94 [06:35:19] FratMank94 casts [Mind Funeral] targeting pielord599. [06:35:20] pielord599 reveals 7 cards with [Mind Funeral]: [Soul-Guide Lantern], [Phylactery Lich], [Swamp], [Lake of the Dead], [Darksteel Axe], [Swamp], and [Swamp]. [06:35:30] Turn 5: pielord599 [06:35:34] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Clackbridge Troll] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, any opponent may sacrifice a creature. If a player does, ...). [06:35:35] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Clackbridge Troll] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, any opponent may sacrifice a creature. If a player does, ...). [06:35:41] pielord599 draws a card with [Clackbridge Troll]'s ability. [06:35:47] pielord599 draws a card with [Clackbridge Troll]'s ability. [06:35:53] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:36:00] pielord599 casts [Duress] targeting FratMank94. [06:36:24] FratMank94 discards [Winds of Rebuke]. [06:36:24] FratMank94 reveals their hand to [Duress], containing [Grimoire Thief], [Drown in the Loch], [Entrancing Melody], and [Mind Funeral]. [06:36:31] pielord599 casts [Culling Scales]. [06:36:36] pielord599 casts [Soul-Guide Lantern]. [06:36:41] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Soul-Guide Lantern] onto the stack targeting [Winds of Rebuke] (When Soul-Guide Lantern enters the battlefield, exile target card from a graveyard.). [06:36:49] Turn 5: FratMank94 [06:36:52] FratMank94 plays [Island]. [06:37:07] FratMank94 casts [Grimoire Thief]. [06:37:15] [CHAT] pielord599: man i am making misplay after misplay [06:37:16] Turn 6: pielord599 [06:37:20] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Culling Scales] onto the stack targeting [Goat] token (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target nonland permanent with the lowest converted mana c...). [06:37:33] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Clackbridge Troll] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, any opponent may sacrifice a creature. If a player does, ...). [06:37:33] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Clackbridge Troll] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, any opponent may sacrifice a creature. If a player does, ...). [06:37:44] FratMank94 casts [Drown in the Loch] targeting [Clackbridge Troll] (Destroy target creature with converted mana cost less than or equal to the number of cards in its ...). [06:38:00] pielord599 draws a card with [Clackbridge Troll]'s ability. [06:38:12] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:38:23] pielord599 casts [Phylactery Lich]. [06:38:35] pielord599 activates an ability of [Soul-Guide Lantern] ( Draw a card.). [06:38:37] pielord599 draws a card with [Soul-Guide Lantern]'s ability. [06:38:52] Turn 6: FratMank94 [06:39:28] [CHAT] FratMank94: really? [06:39:29] FratMank94 plays [Dismal Backwater]. [06:39:30] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [06:39:40] [CHAT] pielord599: yeah, probably small things but they're making an impact [06:39:50] FratMank94 casts [Mind Funeral] targeting pielord599. [06:39:50] pielord599 reveals 10 cards with [Mind Funeral]: [Swamp], [Choking Sands], [Ransack the Lab], [Swamp], [Swamp], [Dark Ritual], [Clackbridge Troll], [Clackbridge Troll], [Ransack the Lab], and [Swamp]. [06:40:04] pielord599 is being attacked by [Grimoire Thief]. [06:40:04] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Grimoire Thief] onto the stack targeting pielord599 (Whenever Grimoire Thief becomes tapped, exile the top three cards of target opponent's library fac...). [06:40:11] [Phylactery Lich] blocks [Grimoire Thief]. [06:40:17] Turn 7: pielord599 [06:40:20] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Culling Scales] onto the stack targeting [Phylactery Lich] (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target nonland permanent with the lowest converted mana c...). [06:40:32] pielord599 plays [Swamp]. [06:40:38] pielord599 casts [Darksteel Axe]. [06:40:43] pielord599 casts [Darksteel Axe]. [06:40:53] PropaneAddict has started watching. [06:40:56] pielord599 casts [Phylactery Lich]. [06:40:59] [CHAT] FratMank94: heard that [06:41:05] pielord599 puts triggered ability from [Clackbridge Troll] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, any opponent may sacrifice a creature. If a player does, ...). [06:41:10] FratMank94 is being attacked by [Phylactery Lich] and [Clackbridge Troll]. [06:41:19] Turn 7: FratMank94 [06:41:33] FratMank94 casts [Entrancing Melody] targeting [Phylactery Lich]. (X is 3). [06:41:34] FratMank94 puts triggered ability from [Phylactery Lich] onto the stack (When you control no permanents with phylactery counters on them, sacrifice Phylactery Lich.). [06:41:46] [CHAT] FratMank94: gg [06:41:49] [CHAT] pielord599: gg [06:41:51] [CHAT] pielord599: very close games [06:42:06] FratMank94 has conceded from the game. Winner: pielord599 Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: pielord599: 2–1 [06:42:12] FratMank94 has left the game.