PennyDreadfulCommander PD EDH BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Adrei,Error23UK,HopeBurnsBright == Game 1 (733508126) == [Time] 1598196539 [01:29:05] PDBot has started watching. [01:29:05] Adrei joined the game. [01:29:09] Adrei chooses to play first. [01:29:09] Adrei chooses [Marwyn, the Nurturer] as their commander. [01:29:09] HopeBurnsBright chooses [Siona, Captain of the Pyleas] as their commander. [01:29:09] Error23UK chooses [Nath of the Gilt-Leaf] as their commander. [01:29:42] Adrei begins the game with seven cards in hand. [01:29:46] HopeBurnsBright begins the game with seven cards in hand. [01:29:49] Error23UK mulligans to seven cards. [01:29:53] Error23UK begins the game with seven cards in hand. [01:29:53] Turn 1: Adrei [01:29:58] Adrei plays [Forest]. [01:30:13] Turn 1: HopeBurnsBright [01:30:18] HopeBurnsBright plays [Selesnya Guildgate]. [01:30:30] Turn 1: Error23UK [01:30:38] Error23UK plays [Forest]. [01:30:44] Turn 2: Adrei [01:30:49] Adrei plays [Forest]. [01:30:55] Adrei casts [Gempalm Strider]. [01:30:59] Turn 2: HopeBurnsBright [01:31:15] HopeBurnsBright plays [Plains]. [01:31:19] HopeBurnsBright casts [Season of Growth]. [01:31:21] Turn 2: Error23UK [01:31:22] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Season of Growth[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful. [01:31:33] Error23UK plays [Swamp]. [01:31:38] Error23UK casts [Wolf-Skull Shaman]. [01:31:39] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Wolf-Skull Shaman[sU] has an unclassified bug. Wolf-Skull Shaman automatically reveals the top card of your library without a prompt. Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Wolf-Skull Shaman` or `!notbugged Wolf-Skull Shaman` [01:31:39] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Wolf-Skull Shaman[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful. [01:31:51] Turn 3: Adrei [01:32:15] Adrei plays [Forest]. [01:32:45] Adrei casts [Presence of Gond] targeting [Gempalm Strider]. [01:32:52] Adrei activates an ability of [Gempalm Strider] ( Create a 1/1 green Elf Warrior creature token.). [01:32:53] Adrei's [Gempalm Strider] creates an Elf Warrior token. [01:32:56] Turn 3: HopeBurnsBright [01:33:04] HopeBurnsBright plays [Forest]. [01:33:10] HopeBurnsBright casts [Mesa Enchantress]. [01:33:11] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Season of Growth] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, scry 1.). [01:33:21] HopeBurnsBright puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [01:33:24] Turn 3: Error23UK [01:33:24] Error23UK puts triggered ability from [Wolf-Skull Shaman] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may look at the top card of your library. If it shares a crea...). [01:33:39] Error23UK plays [Forest]. [01:34:05] Error23UK casts [Imperious Perfect]. [01:34:18] Turn 4: Adrei [01:34:35] Adrei casts [Marwyn, the Nurturer]. [01:34:38] Adrei activates an ability of [Gempalm Strider] ( Create a 1/1 green Elf Warrior creature token.). [01:34:39] Adrei's [Gempalm Strider] creates an Elf Warrior token. [01:34:39] Adrei puts triggered ability from [Marwyn, the Nurturer] onto the stack (Whenever another Elf enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Marwyn, the...). [01:34:47] Turn 4: HopeBurnsBright [01:34:55] HopeBurnsBright plays [Plains]. [01:35:03] HopeBurnsBright casts [Siona, Captain of the Pyleas]. [01:35:11] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Siona, Captain of the Pyleas] onto the stack (When Siona, Captain of the Pyleas enters the battlefield, look at the top seven cards of your libr...). [01:35:12] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Season of Growth] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, scry 1.). [01:35:19] HopeBurnsBright puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [01:35:31] HopeBurnsBright puts Rancor in their hand. [01:35:39] HopeBurnsBright casts [Hyena Umbra] targeting [Mesa Enchantress]. [01:35:40] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Hyena Umbra[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful. [sG] In order to prevent further spamming, I'll stop warning you now. [sG] For more information about Penny Dreadful, see pdmtgo.com or reddit.com/r/PennyDreadfulMTG [01:35:42] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card.). [01:35:43] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Season of Growth] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell that targets a creature you control, draw a card.). [01:35:43] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Season of Growth]'s ability. [01:35:46] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:35:48] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Siona, Captain of the Pyleas] onto the stack (Whenever an Aura you control becomes attached to a creature you control, create a 1/1 white Human ...). [01:35:49] HopeBurnsBright's [Siona, Captain of the Pyleas] creates a Human Soldier token. [01:35:49] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Season of Growth] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, scry 1.). [01:35:54] HopeBurnsBright puts 1 card on top of their library. [01:36:00] Turn 4: Error23UK [01:36:01] Error23UK puts triggered ability from [Wolf-Skull Shaman] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may look at the top card of your library. If it shares a crea...). [01:36:28] Error23UK plays [Swamp]. [01:36:36] Error23UK casts [Rend Flesh] targeting [Marwyn, the Nurturer]. [01:37:00] Turn 5: Adrei [01:37:23] Adrei casts [Krosan Restorer]. [01:37:28] Adrei activates an ability of [Gempalm Strider] ( Create a 1/1 green Elf Warrior creature token.). [01:37:29] Adrei's [Gempalm Strider] creates an Elf Warrior token. [01:37:40] Turn 5: HopeBurnsBright [01:37:44] HopeBurnsBright plays [Plains]. [01:37:50] HopeBurnsBright casts [Wild Growth] targeting [Selesnya Guildgate]. [01:37:51] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card.). [01:37:56] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:38:26] HopeBurnsBright casts [Market Festival] targeting [Plains]. [01:38:27] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card.). [01:38:30] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:38:59] HopeBurnsBright casts [Setessan Champion]. [01:39:00] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Season of Growth] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, scry 1.). [01:39:08] HopeBurnsBright puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [01:39:19] Turn 5: Error23UK [01:39:19] Error23UK puts triggered ability from [Wolf-Skull Shaman] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may look at the top card of your library. If it shares a crea...). [01:39:32] Error23UK plays [Swamp]. [01:39:50] Error23UK casts [Plague Boiler]. [01:40:14] Turn 6: Adrei [01:40:38] Adrei activates an ability of [Gempalm Strider] ( Create a 1/1 green Elf Warrior creature token.). [01:40:39] Adrei's [Gempalm Strider] creates an Elf Warrior token. [01:40:48] Error23UK is being attacked by [Elf Warrior] token, [Elf Warrior] token, and [Elf Warrior] token. [01:40:55] [Wolf-Skull Shaman] blocks [Elf Warrior] token. [01:40:57] [Imperious Perfect] blocks [Elf Warrior] token. [01:41:06] Turn 6: HopeBurnsBright [01:41:12] HopeBurnsBright plays [Graypelt Refuge]. [01:41:12] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Graypelt Refuge] onto the stack (When Graypelt Refuge enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [01:41:42] HopeBurnsBright casts [Sixth Sense] targeting [Mesa Enchantress]. [01:41:44] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card.). [01:41:45] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Season of Growth] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell that targets a creature you control, draw a card.). [01:41:50] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Season of Growth]'s ability. [01:41:56] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:42:04] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Setessan Champion] onto the stack (Whenever an enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Setessan...). [01:42:04] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Siona, Captain of the Pyleas] onto the stack (Whenever an Aura you control becomes attached to a creature you control, create a 1/1 white Human ...). [01:42:08] HopeBurnsBright's [Siona, Captain of the Pyleas] creates a Human Soldier token. [01:42:08] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Season of Growth] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, scry 1.). [01:42:22] HopeBurnsBright puts 1 card on top of their library. [01:42:26] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Setessan Champion]'s ability. [01:42:43] HopeBurnsBright casts [Rancor] targeting [Mesa Enchantress]. [01:42:46] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card.). [01:42:47] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Season of Growth] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell that targets a creature you control, draw a card.). [01:42:48] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Season of Growth]'s ability. [01:42:51] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:43:05] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Setessan Champion] onto the stack (Whenever an enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Setessan...). [01:43:05] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Siona, Captain of the Pyleas] onto the stack (Whenever an Aura you control becomes attached to a creature you control, create a 1/1 white Human ...). [01:43:06] HopeBurnsBright's [Siona, Captain of the Pyleas] creates a Human Soldier token. [01:43:07] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Season of Growth] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, scry 1.). [01:43:19] HopeBurnsBright puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [01:43:19] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Setessan Champion]'s ability. [01:43:50] HopeBurnsBright casts [Fanatical Devotion]. [01:43:50] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card.). [01:43:53] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:44:00] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Setessan Champion] onto the stack (Whenever an enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Setessan...). [01:44:01] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Setessan Champion]'s ability. [01:45:11] HopeBurnsBright casts [Conviction] targeting [Setessan Champion]. [01:45:15] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card.). [01:45:15] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Season of Growth] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell that targets a creature you control, draw a card.). [01:45:16] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Season of Growth]'s ability. [01:45:19] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:45:26] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Setessan Champion] onto the stack (Whenever an enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, put a +1/+1 counter on Setessan...). [01:45:27] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Siona, Captain of the Pyleas] onto the stack (Whenever an Aura you control becomes attached to a creature you control, create a 1/1 white Human ...). [01:45:28] HopeBurnsBright's [Siona, Captain of the Pyleas] creates a Human Soldier token. [01:45:28] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Season of Growth] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, scry 1.). [01:45:37] HopeBurnsBright puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [01:45:38] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Setessan Champion]'s ability. [01:46:30] Adrei is being attacked by [Mesa Enchantress]. [01:46:30] Error23UK is being attacked by [Setessan Champion]. [01:46:38] [Wolf-Skull Shaman] blocks [Setessan Champion]. [01:46:47] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card.). [01:46:58] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:48:42] HopeBurnsBright discards [Wolfwillow Haven]. [01:48:42] HopeBurnsBright discards [Utopia Sprawl]. [01:48:42] HopeBurnsBright discards [Plains]. [01:48:42] HopeBurnsBright discards [Sigil of the Empty Throne]. [01:48:42] HopeBurnsBright discards [Ajani's Chosen]. [01:48:42] HopeBurnsBright discards [Plains]. [01:48:42] HopeBurnsBright discards [Heliod's Punishment]. [01:48:43] Turn 6: Error23UK [01:48:43] Error23UK puts triggered ability from [Plague Boiler] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, put a plague counter on Plague Boiler.). [01:49:12] Error23UK casts [Putrefy] targeting [Setessan Champion]. [01:49:54] Turn 7: Adrei [01:50:11] Adrei activates an ability of [Gempalm Strider] ( Create a 1/1 green Elf Warrior creature token.). [01:50:17] Adrei's [Gempalm Strider] creates an Elf Warrior token. [01:50:29] Error23UK is being attacked by [Elf Warrior] token and [Elf Warrior] token. [01:50:39] [Imperious Perfect] blocks [Elf Warrior] token. [01:51:04] Adrei discards [Genesis]. [01:51:04] Turn 7: HopeBurnsBright [01:51:09] HopeBurnsBright plays [Forest]. [01:51:29] HopeBurnsBright casts [Three Dreams]. [01:52:00] HopeBurnsBright reveals [Bear Umbra]. [01:52:00] HopeBurnsBright reveals [Sage's Reverie]. [01:52:01] HopeBurnsBright reveals [Snake Umbra]. [01:52:48] Error23UK is being attacked by [Mesa Enchantress]. [01:52:58] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card.). [01:53:03] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:53:28] HopeBurnsBright discards [Snake Umbra]. [01:53:29] HopeBurnsBright discards [Sage's Reverie]. [01:53:29] HopeBurnsBright discards [Bear Umbra]. [01:53:29] Turn 7: Error23UK [01:53:30] Error23UK puts triggered ability from [Plague Boiler] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, put a plague counter on Plague Boiler.). [01:53:41] Error23UK activates an ability of [Plague Boiler] ( Put a plague counter on Plague Boiler or remove a plague counter from it.). [01:54:03] HopeBurnsBright activates an ability of [Fanatical Devotion] targeting [Mesa Enchantress] ( Regenerate target creature.). [01:54:37] Error23UK puts triggered ability from [Plague Boiler] onto the stack (When Plague Boiler has three or more plague counters on it, sacrifice it. If you do, destroy all n...). [01:54:53] Adrei activates an ability of [Krosan Restorer] targeting [Forest] ( Untap target land.). [01:55:47] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Rancor] onto the stack (When Rancor is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, return Rancor to its owner's hand.). [01:55:56] Adrei casts [Yeva, Nature's Herald]. [01:56:43] Turn 8: Adrei [01:57:02] Adrei puts triggered ability from [Genesis] onto the stack targeting [Gempalm Strider] (At the beginning of your upkeep, if Genesis is in your graveyard, you may pay {2G}. If you do, ret...). [01:57:08] Adrei plays [Forest]. [01:57:12] Adrei casts [Path of Discovery]. [01:57:23] HopeBurnsBright is being attacked by [Yeva, Nature's Herald]. [01:57:35] Turn 8: HopeBurnsBright [01:57:39] HopeBurnsBright plays [Forest]. [01:57:55] HopeBurnsBright casts [Retether]. [01:58:04] [Wild Growth] can't be attached to a legal object. @I(It will not enter the battlefield, and remain in its current zone.) [01:58:04] [Market Festival] can't be attached to a legal object. @I(It will not enter the battlefield, and remain in its current zone.) [01:58:04] [Utopia Sprawl] can't be attached to a legal object. @I(It will not enter the battlefield, and remain in its current zone.) [01:58:04] [Wolfwillow Haven] can't be attached to a legal object. @I(It will not enter the battlefield, and remain in its current zone.) [01:58:27] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Sage's Reverie] onto the stack (When Sage's Reverie enters the battlefield, draw a card for each Aura you control that's attached ...). [01:58:31] HopeBurnsBright draws seven cards with [Sage's Reverie]'s ability. [01:58:50] HopeBurnsBright casts [Rancor] targeting [Mesa Enchantress]. [01:58:51] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card.). [01:58:54] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:59:04] HopeBurnsBright casts [Whip Silk] targeting [Mesa Enchantress]. [01:59:04] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card.). [01:59:07] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:59:34] HopeBurnsBright casts [Transcendent Envoy]. [01:59:35] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an enchantment spell, you may draw a card.). [01:59:38] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [01:59:48] Error23UK is being attacked by [Mesa Enchantress]. [01:59:48] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever this creature attacks, untap all lands you control.). [02:00:06] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals damage to an opponent, you may draw a card.). [02:00:07] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Mesa Enchantress] onto the stack (Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, you may draw a card.). [02:00:15] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [02:00:19] HopeBurnsBright draws a card with [Mesa Enchantress]'s ability. [02:00:56] HopeBurnsBright casts [Auratouched Mage]. [02:00:57] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Auratouched Mage] onto the stack (When Auratouched Mage enters the battlefield, search your library for an Aura card that could ench...). [02:02:06] HopeBurnsBright discards [Plains]. [02:02:06] HopeBurnsBright discards [Forest]. [02:02:06] HopeBurnsBright discards [Forest]. [02:02:06] HopeBurnsBright discards [Crystal Chimes]. [02:02:06] HopeBurnsBright discards [Blighted Woodland]. [02:02:06] HopeBurnsBright discards [Blossoming Sands]. [02:02:06] HopeBurnsBright discards [Idyllic Tutor]. [02:02:06] HopeBurnsBright discards [Overgrowth]. [02:02:07] Turn 8: Error23UK [02:02:15] Error23UK plays [Swamp]. [02:02:22] Error23UK casts [Extinguish All Hope]. [02:02:40] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Pattern of Rebirth] onto the stack (When enchanted creature dies, that creature's controller may search their library for a creature c...). [02:02:50] Error23UK has conceded from the game. [02:02:50] Error23UK is now a watcher. [02:03:04] HopeBurnsBright puts triggered ability from [Boonweaver Giant] onto the stack (When Boonweaver Giant enters the battlefield, you may search your graveyard, hand, and/or library ...). [02:03:13] Adrei has conceded from the game. Winner: HopeBurnsBright Game 1 Completed. [02:03:17] HopeBurnsBright has left the game.