PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality WilloWisp11,Charonimus == Game 1 (729989090) == [Time] 1595600825 [00:27:06] PDBot has started watching. [00:27:06] WilloWisp11 joined the game. [00:27:06] Charonimus joined the game. [League] Hermit Dredge by willowisp11 (84129) vs Druid by charonimus (84126) [00:27:07] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [00:27:15] WilloWisp11 chooses to play first. [00:27:19] WilloWisp11 mulligans to six cards. [00:27:30] Charonimus begins the game with seven cards in hand. [00:27:49] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: do you where you look on the website to check your league progress? I clicked off and lost it [00:27:56] WilloWisp11 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [00:27:56] Turn 1: WilloWisp11 [00:27:56] WilloWisp11 skips their draw step. [00:27:58] WilloWisp11 plays [Vivid Marsh]. [00:28:29] [CHAT] Charonimus: uhm im pretty new too, actually since yesterday^^ sry [00:28:40] Turn 1: Charonimus [00:28:49] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: okay okay i started yesterday or the day before, GL [00:28:59] [CHAT] Charonimus: same :) [00:29:04] Charonimus plays [Crumbling Vestige]. [00:29:05] Charonimus puts triggered ability from [Crumbling Vestige] onto the stack (When Crumbling Vestige enters the battlefield, add one mana of any color.). [00:29:09] Charonimus chooses green. [00:29:11] Charonimus casts [Elvish Mystic]. [00:29:14] Turn 2: WilloWisp11 [00:29:17] WilloWisp11 plays [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:29:20] WilloWisp11 casts [Hermit Druid]. [00:29:23] Turn 2: Charonimus [00:29:37] Charonimus plays [Simic Guildgate]. [00:29:39] Charonimus casts [Elvish Mystic]. [00:29:43] Turn 3: WilloWisp11 [00:29:49] WilloWisp11 activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...). [00:29:51] WilloWisp11 reveals [Tomb of Urami]. [00:29:51] WilloWisp11 reveals [Shambling Shell]. [00:29:51] WilloWisp11 reveals [Temple of Malady]. [00:29:51] WilloWisp11 reveals [Jungle Hollow]. [00:29:51] WilloWisp11 reveals [Benefaction of Rhonas]. [00:29:51] WilloWisp11 reveals [Shambling Shell]. [00:29:51] WilloWisp11 reveals [Hermit Druid]. [00:29:51] WilloWisp11 reveals [Tomb of Urami]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Silversmote Ghoul]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Ghoulsteed]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Creeping Chill]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Silversmote Ghoul]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Dakmor Salvage]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Zombie Infestation]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Ghoulsteed]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Dakmor Salvage]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Silversmote Ghoul]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Putrid Imp]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Sylvan Library]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Golgari Brownscale]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Silversmote Ghoul]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Sylvan Library]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Temple of Malady]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Creeping Chill]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Zombie Infestation]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Temple of Malady]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Sylvan Library]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Tomb of Urami]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Dakmor Salvage]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Putrid Imp]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Raven's Crime]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Zombie Infestation]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Temple of Malady]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Dread Return]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Jungle Hollow]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Sylvan Library]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Putrid Imp]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Hermit Druid]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Darksteel Colossus]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Zombie Infestation]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Memory's Journey]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Lotleth Giant]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Tomb of Urami]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Benefaction of Rhonas]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Dakmor Salvage]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Golgari Brownscale]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Vivid Marsh]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Darksteel Colossus]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Dread Return]. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Darksteel Colossus] and shuffles it into their library. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 reveals [Darksteel Colossus] and shuffles it into their library. [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...). [00:29:52] WilloWisp11 puts triggered ability from [Creeping Chill] onto the stack (When Creeping Chill is put into your graveyard from your library, you may exile it. If you do, Cre...). [00:30:06] WilloWisp11 exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability. [00:30:10] WilloWisp11 exiles [Creeping Chill] with its own ability. [00:30:13] WilloWisp11 puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...). [00:30:13] WilloWisp11 puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...). [00:30:13] WilloWisp11 puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...). [00:30:13] WilloWisp11 puts triggered ability from [Silversmote Ghoul] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, return Silversmote Ghou...). [00:30:30] Turn 3: Charonimus [00:31:18] Turn 4: WilloWisp11 [00:31:23] WilloWisp11 reveals [Darksteel Colossus] and shuffles it into their library. [00:31:23] WilloWisp11 reveals [Darksteel Colossus] and shuffles it into their library. [00:31:23] WilloWisp11 mills [Darksteel Colossus] and [Darksteel Colossus]. [00:31:26] WilloWisp11 plays [Dakmor Salvage]. [00:31:35] WilloWisp11 casts [Hermit Druid]. [00:32:03] WilloWisp11 casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Lotleth Giant]. [00:32:19] Charonimus casts [Miscast] targeting [Dread Return]. [00:32:43] Turn 4: Charonimus [00:33:05] Turn 5: WilloWisp11 [00:33:08] WilloWisp11 reveals [Darksteel Colossus] and shuffles it into their library. [00:33:08] WilloWisp11 reveals [Darksteel Colossus] and shuffles it into their library. [00:33:08] WilloWisp11 mills [Darksteel Colossus] and [Darksteel Colossus]. [00:33:09] WilloWisp11 puts triggered ability from [Golgari Brownscale] onto the stack (When Golgari Brownscale is put into your hand from your graveyard, you gain 2 life.). [00:33:26] WilloWisp11 casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting [Lotleth Giant]. [00:34:24] Charonimus casts [Memory's Journey] targeting WilloWisp11. [00:34:41] WilloWisp11 puts triggered ability from [Lotleth Giant] onto the stack targeting Charonimus (When Lotleth Giant enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent for each creature ...). [00:34:53] [CHAT] Charonimus: why did that not work? [00:35:05] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: i have to chose the cards [00:35:21] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: i get to choose the cards ithink? [00:35:21] [CHAT] Charonimus: oh i see [00:35:36] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: andjust chose not to [00:35:45] [CHAT] Charonimus: nah i think i get to choose [00:35:56] [CHAT] Charonimus: well [00:36:00] [CHAT] Charonimus: gg [00:36:03] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: it says target player, if you target me im the player [00:36:05] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: gg [00:36:08] Charonimus has conceded from the game. Winner: WilloWisp11 Game 1 Completed. [00:36:12] WilloWisp11 has left the game. == Game 2 (729990172) == [Time] 1595601474 [00:37:55] PDBot has started watching. [00:38:04] Charonimus chooses to play first. [00:38:15] [CHAT] Charonimus: i just checked [00:38:24] [CHAT] Charonimus: i should get to choose [00:38:51] [CHAT] Charonimus: probably i screwed up magic online somehow and did not choose a target [00:39:00] Charonimus begins the game with seven cards in hand. [00:39:34] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: it says"target player shuffles up to three cards from his or her graveyard into his or her library" if you target me, im the player and get to choose [00:39:40] WilloWisp11 mulligans to six cards. [00:39:48] WilloWisp11 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [00:39:48] Turn 1: Charonimus [00:39:49] [CHAT] Charonimus: three target cards [00:39:50] Charonimus skips their draw step. [00:40:01] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: no its target player [00:40:07] [CHAT] Charonimus: targets are chosen as the spell is cast [00:40:14] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: yeah i am the target [00:40:24] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: you target the player not the cards [00:40:26] [CHAT] Charonimus: you have to target a player, but not need to target cards [00:40:46] [CHAT] Charonimus: both are targets just check notes on scryfall [00:40:52] Charonimus plays [Temple of Mystery]. [00:40:53] Charonimus puts triggered ability from [Temple of Mystery] onto the stack (When Temple of Mystery enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [00:41:05] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: but the target player gets to choose the target cards [00:41:19] Charonimus puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [00:41:26] Turn 1: WilloWisp11 [00:41:29] WilloWisp11 plays [Dakmor Salvage]. [00:41:30] [CHAT] Charonimus: nope [00:41:32] Turn 2: Charonimus [00:41:39] Charonimus plays [Simic Guildgate]. [00:41:42] Charonimus casts [Elvish Mystic]. [00:41:49] Turn 2: WilloWisp11 [00:41:52] WilloWisp11 plays [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:41:54] WilloWisp11 casts [Hermit Druid]. [00:41:57] Turn 3: Charonimus [00:42:10] Charonimus plays [Thornwood Falls]. [00:42:11] Charonimus puts triggered ability from [Thornwood Falls] onto the stack (When Thornwood Falls enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [00:42:17] Charonimus casts [Soul-Guide Lantern]. [00:42:18] No legal targets to choose for [Soul-Guide Lantern]'s triggered ability. [00:42:28] Charonimus casts [Hermit Druid]. [00:42:32] Turn 3: WilloWisp11 [00:42:39] WilloWisp11 plays [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:42:46] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: oops [00:43:00] Turn 4: Charonimus [00:43:17] Charonimus casts [Birds of Paradise]. [00:43:47] Turn 4: WilloWisp11 [00:43:55] WilloWisp11 plays [Tomb of Urami]. [00:43:59] WilloWisp11 casts [Shambling Shell]. [00:44:24] Charonimus activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...). [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Crumbling Vestige]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Mana Leak]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Temple of Mystery]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Memory's Journey]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Woodland Stream]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Crumbling Vestige]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Memory Lapse]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Elvish Mystic]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Fact or Fiction]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Memory Lapse]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Miscast]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Crumbling Vestige]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Fblthp, the Lost]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Elvish Mystic]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Soul-Guide Lantern]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Miscast]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Crumbling Vestige]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Soul-Guide Lantern]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Memory Lapse]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Soul-Guide Lantern]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Temple of Mystery]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Hermit Druid]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Temple of Mystery]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Garruk Wildspeaker]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Coiling Oracle]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Hermit Druid]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Hall of the Bandit Lord]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Thornwood Falls]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Dread Return]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Laboratory Maniac]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Hermit Druid]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Fblthp, the Lost]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Fact or Fiction]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Woodland Stream]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Think Twice]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Thornwood Falls]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Fact or Fiction]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Thornwood Falls]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Miscast]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Coiling Oracle]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Coiling Oracle]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Simic Guildgate]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Compulsive Research]. [00:44:25] Charonimus reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [00:44:26] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Compulsive Research[sU] has an advantageous bug. Dredging rather than drawing can let you avoid discarding in a specific case [00:44:37] Turn 5: Charonimus [00:45:00] Charonimus casts [Memory's Journey] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting Charonimus, and [Laboratory Maniac]. [00:45:25] WilloWisp11 has conceded from the game. Winner: Charonimus Game 2 Completed. [00:45:29] WilloWisp11 has left the game. == Game 3 (729991036) == [Time] 1595602025 [00:47:06] PDBot has started watching. [00:47:07] WilloWisp11 mulligans to six cards. [00:47:15] Charonimus begins the game with seven cards in hand. [00:47:18] WilloWisp11 puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [00:47:18] Turn 1: WilloWisp11 [00:47:19] WilloWisp11 skips their draw step. [00:47:21] WilloWisp11 plays [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:47:24] WilloWisp11 casts [Soul-Guide Lantern]. [00:47:29] No legal targets to choose for [Soul-Guide Lantern]'s triggered ability. [00:47:35] Turn 1: Charonimus [00:47:39] Charonimus plays [Temple of Mystery]. [00:47:40] Charonimus puts triggered ability from [Temple of Mystery] onto the stack (When Temple of Mystery enters the battlefield, scry 1.). [00:47:51] Charonimus puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [00:47:54] Turn 2: WilloWisp11 [00:48:02] WilloWisp11 plays [Dakmor Salvage]. [00:48:05] Turn 2: Charonimus [00:48:18] Charonimus plays [Crumbling Vestige]. [00:48:18] Charonimus puts triggered ability from [Crumbling Vestige] onto the stack (When Crumbling Vestige enters the battlefield, add one mana of any color.). [00:48:23] Charonimus chooses green. [00:48:27] Charonimus casts [Hermit Druid]. [00:48:31] Turn 3: WilloWisp11 [00:48:35] WilloWisp11 plays [Dakmor Salvage]. [00:48:37] WilloWisp11 casts [Sylvan Library]. [00:48:41] Turn 3: Charonimus [00:49:01] Charonimus plays [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:49:08] Charonimus casts [Laboratory Maniac]. [00:49:28] Turn 4: WilloWisp11 [00:49:29] WilloWisp11 puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Library] onto the stack (At the beginning of your draw step, you may draw two additional cards. If you do, choose two cards...). [00:49:35] WilloWisp11 draws two cards with [Sylvan Library]'s ability. [00:49:39] WilloWisp11 put a card on top of WilloWisp11's library. [00:49:44] WilloWisp11 put a card on top of WilloWisp11's library. [00:49:50] WilloWisp11 casts [Hermit Druid]. [00:49:58] Turn 4: Charonimus [00:50:02] Charonimus activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...). [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Thornwood Falls]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Crumbling Vestige]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Coiling Oracle]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Thornwood Falls]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Return to Nature]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Soul-Guide Lantern]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Miscast]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Dread Return]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Fact or Fiction]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Temple of Mystery]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Crumbling Vestige]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Think Twice]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Soul-Guide Lantern]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Coiling Oracle]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Hall of the Bandit Lord]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Memory Lapse]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Fact or Fiction]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Elvish Mystic]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Hermit Druid]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Simic Guildgate]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Memory's Journey]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Soul-Guide Lantern]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Woodland Stream]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Elvish Mystic]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Memory Lapse]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Temple of Mystery]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Hermit Druid]. [00:50:03] Charonimus reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Memory Lapse]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Coiling Oracle]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Crumbling Vestige]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Temple of Mystery]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Fblthp, the Lost]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Thornwood Falls]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Soul-Guide Lantern]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Miscast]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Compulsive Research]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Thornwood Falls]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Compulsive Research]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Okina, Temple to the Grandfathers]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Birds of Paradise]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Coiling Oracle]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Simic Guildgate]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Fact or Fiction]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Memory Lapse]. [00:50:04] Charonimus reveals [Elvish Mystic]. [00:50:21] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: gg [00:50:24] [CHAT] Charonimus: gg [00:50:29] [CHAT] WilloWisp11: didn't find the removal [00:50:32] WilloWisp11 has conceded from the game. Winner: Charonimus Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: Charonimus: 2–1 [00:50:36] WilloWisp11 has left the game.