PennyDreadful
PD Test
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Muth,OldSchoolGrinder

== Game 1 (729570164) ==
[Time] 1595335145
[22:39:06] PDBot has started watching.
[22:39:06] OldSchoolGrinder joined the game.
[League] Host doesn't have active run
[22:39:12] [CHAT] Muth: glhf
[22:39:13] OldSchoolGrinder chooses to play first.
[22:39:28] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: thanks
[22:39:52] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: I have a short deck on purpose just for testing right now
[22:39:58] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: Just to let you know
[22:40:01] OldSchoolGrinder mulligans to six cards.
[22:40:31] [CHAT] Muth: I mean, that's gonna make it more consistent than it will be at 60 cards, not a great indicator of success
[22:40:34] Muth begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[22:41:16] [CHAT] Muth: I'll still play it, just something to keep in mind
[22:41:24] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: It's more like I took out 6 cards that weren't working and now I want to see how it runs
[22:41:45] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: More like, I want to see what needs to be put in
[22:41:49] OldSchoolGrinder puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[22:41:49] Turn 1: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:41:49] OldSchoolGrinder skips their draw step.
[22:41:56] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[22:41:59] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Slumbering Dragon].
[22:42:14] Turn 1: Muth
[22:42:16] Muth plays [Island].
[22:42:26] Turn 2: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:42:31] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[22:42:40] Muth casts [Opt].
[22:42:50] Muth puts 1 card on top of their library.
[22:42:50] Muth draws a card with [Opt].
[22:42:52] Turn 2: Muth
[22:42:54] Muth plays [Island].
[22:43:10] Turn 3: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:43:14] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[22:43:38] Muth casts [Opt].
[22:43:43] Muth puts 1 card on top of their library.
[22:43:43] Muth draws a card with [Opt].
[22:43:44] Turn 3: Muth
[22:43:46] Muth plays [Island].
[22:43:48] Muth casts [Tempest Djinn].
[22:43:55] Turn 4: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:43:59] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[22:44:03] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Tectonic Giant].
[22:44:11] Turn 4: Muth
[22:44:14] Muth plays [Island].
[22:44:24] Muth casts [Tempest Djinn].
[22:44:36] OldSchoolGrinder is being attacked by [Tempest Djinn].
[22:44:36] OldSchoolGrinder puts triggered ability from [Slumbering Dragon] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks you or a planeswalker you control, put a +1/+1 counter on Slumbering D...).
[22:44:51] Turn 5: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:44:53] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[22:44:57] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Zuran Orb].
[22:45:03] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Demanding Dragon].
[22:45:07] OldSchoolGrinder puts triggered ability from [Demanding Dragon] onto the stack targeting Muth (When Demanding Dragon enters the battlefield, it deals 5 damage to target opponent unless that pla...).
[22:45:31] Turn 5: Muth
[22:45:35] Muth plays [Island].
[22:45:46] Muth discards [Dizzy Spell].
[22:45:46] Muth transmutes [Dizzy Spell].
[22:45:59] Muth reveals [Phyrexian Dreadnought].
[22:46:22] OldSchoolGrinder is being attacked by [Tempest Djinn] and [Tempest Djinn].
[22:46:22] OldSchoolGrinder puts triggered ability from [Slumbering Dragon] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks you or a planeswalker you control, put a +1/+1 counter on Slumbering D...).
[22:46:22] OldSchoolGrinder puts triggered ability from [Slumbering Dragon] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks you or a planeswalker you control, put a +1/+1 counter on Slumbering D...).
[22:47:14] Turn 6: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:47:47] Muth is being attacked by [Demanding Dragon] and [Tectonic Giant].
[22:47:52] OldSchoolGrinder puts triggered ability from [Tectonic Giant] onto the stack (Tectonic Giant deals 3 damage to each opponent.).
[22:48:04] Muth casts [Trickbind] targeting Triggered ability from Tectonic Giant.
[22:48:50] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Browbeat] targeting OldSchoolGrinder.
[22:48:59] OldSchoolGrinder draws three cards with [Browbeat].
[22:49:10] Turn 6: Muth
[22:49:13] Muth plays [Island].
[22:49:27] OldSchoolGrinder is being attacked by [Tempest Djinn] and [Tempest Djinn].
[22:49:27] OldSchoolGrinder puts triggered ability from [Slumbering Dragon] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks you or a planeswalker you control, put a +1/+1 counter on Slumbering D...).
[22:49:28] OldSchoolGrinder puts triggered ability from [Slumbering Dragon] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks you or a planeswalker you control, put a +1/+1 counter on Slumbering D...).
[22:49:47] OldSchoolGrinder activates an ability of [Zuran Orb] ( You gain 2 life.).
[22:49:50] Muth casts [Trickbind] targeting Zuran Orb.
[22:50:08] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Fling] targeting Muth (The chosen target will be damaged when this spell resolves).
[22:50:13] Muth casts [Frantic Inventory].
[22:50:17] Muth draws a card with [Frantic Inventory].
[22:50:24] Muth casts [Repeal] targeting [Zuran Orb]. (X is 0).
[22:50:32] Muth returns [Zuran Orb] to its owner's hand with [Repeal].
[22:50:32] Muth draws a card with [Repeal].
[22:50:40] Muth has conceded from the game.
Winner: OldSchoolGrinder
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (729571086) ==
[Time] 1595335898
[22:51:39] PDBot has started watching.
[22:51:42] Muth chooses to play first.
[22:51:45] Muth begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[22:51:49] OldSchoolGrinder begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[22:51:49] Turn 1: Muth
[22:51:49] Muth skips their draw step.
[22:51:50] Muth plays [Island].
[22:51:56] Turn 1: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:51:59] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[22:52:02] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Slumbering Dragon].
[22:52:07] Turn 2: Muth
[22:52:09] Muth plays [Island].
[22:52:11] Muth casts [Eldrazi Mimic].
[22:52:28] Turn 2: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:52:33] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[22:52:37] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Slumbering Dragon].
[22:52:42] Turn 3: Muth
[22:52:45] Muth plays [Island].
[22:52:47] Muth casts [Phyrexian Dreadnought].
[22:52:55] Muth puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Dreadnought] onto the stack (When Phyrexian Dreadnought enters the battlefield, sacrifice it unless you sacrifice any number of...).
[22:52:55] Muth puts triggered ability from [Eldrazi Mimic] onto the stack (Whenever another colorless creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may change Eldr...).
[22:53:14] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: I really think that's a cheap combo
[22:53:22] Turn 3: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:53:25] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[22:53:32] [CHAT] Muth: it costs about 0.05 tix
[22:53:33] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Shredded Sails] targeting [Phyrexian Dreadnought] (Destroy target artifact.).
[22:53:39] Muth casts [Negate] targeting [Shredded Sails].
[22:53:42] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: I mean cheap in another way
[22:53:53] Turn 4: Muth
[22:54:02] OldSchoolGrinder is being attacked by [Phyrexian Dreadnought].
[22:54:02] OldSchoolGrinder puts triggered ability from [Slumbering Dragon] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks you or a planeswalker you control, put a +1/+1 counter on Slumbering D...).
[22:54:02] OldSchoolGrinder puts triggered ability from [Slumbering Dragon] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks you or a planeswalker you control, put a +1/+1 counter on Slumbering D...).
[22:54:12] [CHAT] Muth: It's a budget format, doesn't mean it isn't powerful
[22:54:21] Turn 4: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:54:34] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Shredded Sails] targeting [Phyrexian Dreadnought] (Destroy target artifact.).
[22:54:38] Muth casts [Mana Leak] targeting [Shredded Sails].
[22:54:57] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: That's also not what I mean
[22:55:02] OldSchoolGrinder has conceded from the game.
Winner: Muth
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (729571364) ==
[Time] 1595336159
[22:55:59] PDBot has started watching.
[22:56:03] OldSchoolGrinder chooses to play first.
[22:56:09] OldSchoolGrinder begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[22:56:09] [CHAT] Muth: Then I did understand. Eureka and Dark Ritual are legal in the format, this isn't standard
[22:56:15] Muth begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[22:56:15] Turn 1: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:56:15] OldSchoolGrinder skips their draw step.
[22:56:19] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[22:56:34] Turn 1: Muth
[22:56:36] Muth plays [Island].
[22:56:56] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: Well anyway, it seems more like solitaire than Magic
[22:57:00] Turn 2: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:57:03] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[22:57:07] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Goblin Cratermaker].
[22:57:08] [CHAT] Muth: Welcome to Magic
[22:57:15] Muth casts [Opt].
[22:57:21] Muth puts 1 card on top of their library.
[22:57:21] Muth draws a card with [Opt].
[22:57:30] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: You mean the new Magic
[22:57:39] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: I played back in the mid 90s
[22:57:45] Turn 2: Muth
[22:57:52] [CHAT] Muth: These are old cards, dreadnought + stifle has been a thing for ages
[22:57:53] Muth plays [Island].
[22:57:56] Muth casts [Eldrazi Mimic].
[22:58:16] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: I remember dreadnaught
[22:58:23] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: I actually have the paper card
[22:58:49] Turn 3: OldSchoolGrinder
[22:58:52] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[22:59:10] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Goblin Cratermaker].
[22:59:22] Turn 3: Muth
[22:59:24] Muth plays [Island].
[23:00:10] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: But nowadays, people just find ways to cheat the purpose of the cards, rather than trying to build good decks
[23:00:35] [CHAT] Muth: Uhhhh..... Channel Fireball was literally one of the original combos, ending games on turn 1?
[23:00:38] OldSchoolGrinder is being attacked by [Eldrazi Mimic].
[23:01:27] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: I don't remember a turn one kill with that combo
[23:01:41] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: You need 3 mana, plus life gain
[23:02:03] [CHAT] Muth: Black lotus, land, channel, fireball
[23:02:13] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: But you die too
[23:02:58] [CHAT] Muth: Lotus for GGG, cast channel, G floating. Play mountain, you have fireball for twenty leaving you at 1
[23:03:03] Muth casts [Eldrazi Mimic].
[23:03:21] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: Yeah I see. Anyway I remember that combo.
[23:03:24] Muth puts triggered ability from [Eldrazi Mimic] onto the stack (Whenever another colorless creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may change Eldr...).
[23:03:37] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: But at least it's in the spirit of the cards
[23:03:50] [CHAT] Muth: lmao
[23:03:53] [CHAT] Muth: lol
[23:04:05] Turn 4: OldSchoolGrinder
[23:04:10] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[23:04:22] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Browbeat] targeting OldSchoolGrinder.
[23:04:33] Muth has [Browbeat] deal 5 damage to them.
[23:05:14] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: People today just invent ways to break the intention of the cards so that they do things they were never intended for and it ruins the game
[23:05:18] Muth casts [Opt].
[23:05:23] Muth puts 1 card on top of their library.
[23:05:23] Muth draws a card with [Opt].
[23:05:24] Turn 4: Muth
[23:05:26] Muth plays [Island].
[23:05:34] OldSchoolGrinder is being attacked by [Eldrazi Mimic].
[23:05:46] Muth casts [Tempest Djinn].
[23:05:58] Turn 5: OldSchoolGrinder
[23:06:01] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[23:06:10] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Shredded Sails] targeting [Tempest Djinn] (Shredded Sails deals 4 damage to target creature with flying. ).
[23:06:12] [CHAT] Muth: Did you look at this format before building a deck?
[23:06:15] Muth casts [Miscast] targeting [Shredded Sails].
[23:06:26] [CHAT] Muth: There's plenty that isn't "fair"
[23:06:35] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: That's my point
[23:06:41] [CHAT] Muth: And it's fun
[23:07:02] [CHAT] Muth: Magic isn't meant to be *your* way of playing, it's different things for everybody
[23:07:09] [CHAT] Muth: That's the beauty of it
[23:07:25] Turn 5: Muth
[23:07:27] Muth plays [Island].
[23:07:30] Muth casts [Frantic Inventory].
[23:07:33] Muth draws a card with [Frantic Inventory].
[23:07:41] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: If you say so....
[23:07:57] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: I remember when it actually was that way. What you just described
[23:08:03] OldSchoolGrinder is being attacked by [Tempest Djinn] and [Eldrazi Mimic].
[23:08:05] [CHAT] Muth: Still is
[23:08:16] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Shredded Sails] targeting [Tempest Djinn] (Shredded Sails deals 4 damage to target creature with flying. ).
[23:08:38] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: When did you start playing?
[23:10:04] [CHAT] Muth: 7th edition. I played with vizzerdix and unsummons. I've played kitchen table magic at the school yard
[23:10:24] [CHAT] Muth: There has always been big combos that end the game
[23:10:31] Turn 6: OldSchoolGrinder
[23:10:39] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Browbeat] targeting OldSchoolGrinder.
[23:10:47] [CHAT] Muth: Phyrexian processor and voltaic key?
[23:11:01] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: I got out before that stuff
[23:11:07] [CHAT] Muth: lol
[23:11:22] Muth has [Browbeat] deal 5 damage to them.
[23:11:47] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: The last pact I bought was mirage/visions something like that
[23:11:57] Turn 6: Muth
[23:12:00] Muth plays [Island].
[23:12:00] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: *pack
[23:12:27] OldSchoolGrinder is being attacked by [Eldrazi Mimic].
[23:12:44] [CHAT] Muth: Natural order was in visions
[23:13:15] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: So what?
[23:13:21] [CHAT] Muth: Cadaverous bloom was in mirage
[23:13:32] Turn 7: OldSchoolGrinder
[23:13:34] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[23:13:38] OldSchoolGrinder casts [The Flame of Keld].
[23:13:42] OldSchoolGrinder puts triggered ability from [The Flame of Keld] onto the stack (Discard your hand.).
[23:13:56] Turn 7: Muth
[23:13:59] Muth plays [Island].
[23:14:20] OldSchoolGrinder is being attacked by [Eldrazi Mimic].
[23:14:37] Turn 8: OldSchoolGrinder
[23:14:38] OldSchoolGrinder puts triggered ability from [The Flame of Keld] onto the stack (Draw two cards.).
[23:14:42] OldSchoolGrinder draws two cards with [The Flame of Keld]'s ability.
[23:14:47] OldSchoolGrinder casts [Zuran Orb].
[23:14:54] OldSchoolGrinder plays [Mountain].
[23:15:04] Turn 8: Muth
[23:15:08] Muth plays [Island].
[23:15:11] Muth casts [Phyrexian Dreadnought].
[23:15:32] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: I don't understand your point
[23:15:41] Muth puts triggered ability from [Phyrexian Dreadnought] onto the stack (When Phyrexian Dreadnought enters the battlefield, sacrifice it unless you sacrifice any number of...).
[23:15:41] Muth puts triggered ability from [Eldrazi Mimic] onto the stack (Whenever another colorless creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may change Eldr...).
[23:15:42] Muth puts triggered ability from [Eldrazi Mimic] onto the stack (Whenever another colorless creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may change Eldr...).
[23:16:09] OldSchoolGrinder activates an ability of [Goblin Cratermaker] targeting [Eldrazi Mimic] ( Destroy target colorless nonland permanent.).
[23:16:15] Muth casts [Trickbind] targeting Goblin Cratermaker.
[23:16:39] [CHAT] Muth: These cards are absurdly powerful and enabled game-winning combos, and they were in your time too
[23:16:43] Muth casts [Trickbind] targeting Triggered ability from Phyrexian Dreadnought.
[23:17:27] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: These two cards together? Because I don't remember a combo with them.
[23:17:38] [CHAT] Muth: Seperate combos
[23:17:59] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: Wit hother cards that came later I'm sure.
[23:18:12] OldSchoolGrinder is being attacked by [Eldrazi Mimic] and [Eldrazi Mimic].
[23:18:33] OldSchoolGrinder activates an ability of [Goblin Cratermaker] targeting [Eldrazi Mimic] ( Destroy target colorless nonland permanent.).
[23:18:40] OldSchoolGrinder activates an ability of [Zuran Orb] ( You gain 2 life.).
[23:18:50] OldSchoolGrinder activates an ability of [Zuran Orb] ( You gain 2 life.).
[23:19:16] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: There's no way around it, man. People just find the cheapest ways to cheat the spirit of the cards
[23:19:23] [CHAT] Muth: prosperity and cadaverous bloom
[23:19:35] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: If you think that's fun then keep playing I guess
[23:19:48] [CHAT] OldSchoolGrinder: I mean 3 dreadnaughts in one turn
[23:19:57] OldSchoolGrinder has run out of time and has lost the match.
Winner: Muth
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Muth: 2–1