PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Madman_quail,v1ndhl3r == Game 1 (725088940) == [Time] 1592065435 [02:23:56] PDBot has started watching. [02:23:56] Madman_quail joined the game. [League] Cruel Control V1 by v1ndhl3r (79380) vs Sinful Desire Storm 10 by madman_quail (79373) [02:23:57] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [02:24:06] Madman_quail chooses to play first. [02:24:10] Madman_quail begins the game with seven cards in hand. [02:24:11] [CHAT] v1ndhl3r: glhf! [02:24:17] v1ndhl3r begins the game with seven cards in hand. [02:24:17] Turn 1: Madman_quail [02:24:20] Madman_quail skips their draw step. [02:24:21] Madman_quail plays [Bad River]. [02:24:25] Turn 1: v1ndhl3r [02:24:31] v1ndhl3r plays [Swamp]. [02:24:33] Turn 2: Madman_quail [02:24:37] Madman_quail activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...). [02:24:43] Madman_quail plays [Island]. [02:24:46] Madman_quail casts [Opt]. [02:24:52] Madman_quail puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [02:24:53] Madman_quail draws a card with [Opt]. [02:24:55] [CHAT] Madman_quail: u2 [02:24:58] Turn 2: v1ndhl3r [02:25:03] v1ndhl3r plays [Island]. [02:25:06] v1ndhl3r casts [Thought Erasure] targeting Madman_quail. [02:25:13] Madman_quail discards [Dark Ritual]. [02:25:13] Madman_quail reveals their hand to [Thought Erasure], containing [Peer Through Depths], [Mind's Desire], [Peer Through Depths], [Mind's Desire], and [Island]. [02:25:20] v1ndhl3r puts [Swiftwater Cliffs] into their graveyard. [02:25:24] Turn 3: Madman_quail [02:25:28] Madman_quail casts [Peer Through Depths]. [02:25:36] Madman_quail puts [Frantic Search] into their hand with with [Peer Through Depths]. [02:25:39] Madman_quail plays [Island]. [02:25:43] Turn 3: v1ndhl3r [02:25:46] v1ndhl3r plays [Dismal Backwater]. [02:25:47] v1ndhl3r puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [02:25:51] v1ndhl3r casts [Thought Erasure] targeting Madman_quail. [02:25:55] Madman_quail discards [Primal Amulet]. [02:25:55] Madman_quail reveals their hand to [Thought Erasure], containing [Frantic Search], [Mind's Desire], [Peer Through Depths], and [Mind's Desire]. [02:25:55] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Primal Amulet[sU] has a graphical bug. Primal Wellspring's triggered ability has the text of Pyromancer's Goggles [02:25:58] v1ndhl3r puts 1 card on top of their library. [02:26:01] Turn 4: Madman_quail [02:26:08] Madman_quail casts [Shimmer of Possibility]. [02:26:17] Madman_quail plays [Waterveil Cavern]. [02:26:21] Madman_quail casts [Peer Through Depths]. [02:26:26] Madman_quail puts [Shimmer of Possibility] into their hand with with [Peer Through Depths]. [02:26:35] Turn 4: v1ndhl3r [02:26:39] v1ndhl3r plays [Mountain]. [02:26:41] Turn 5: Madman_quail [02:26:47] Madman_quail casts [Shimmer of Possibility]. [02:26:55] Madman_quail plays [Island]. [02:27:04] v1ndhl3r casts [Fact or Fiction]. [02:27:20] v1ndhl3r puts [Angrath's Rampage], [Swiftwater Cliffs], [Bloodfell Caves] into their hand with [Fact or Fiction]. [02:27:20] v1ndhl3r puts [Atris, Oracle of Half-Truths], [Swamp] into their graveyard. [02:27:23] Turn 5: v1ndhl3r [02:27:29] v1ndhl3r plays [Swiftwater Cliffs]. [02:27:29] v1ndhl3r puts triggered ability from [Swiftwater Cliffs] onto the stack (When Swiftwater Cliffs enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [02:27:35] Turn 6: Madman_quail [02:27:48] Madman_quail casts [Deep Analysis] targeting Madman_quail. [02:27:53] Madman_quail draws two cards with [Deep Analysis]. [02:28:00] Turn 6: v1ndhl3r [02:28:05] v1ndhl3r plays [Bloodfell Caves]. [02:28:05] v1ndhl3r puts triggered ability from [Bloodfell Caves] onto the stack (When Bloodfell Caves enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [02:28:09] Turn 7: Madman_quail [02:28:15] Madman_quail casts [Frantic Search]. [02:28:23] Madman_quail draws two cards with [Frantic Search]. [02:28:29] Madman_quail discards [Bad River]. [02:28:30] Madman_quail discards [Discovery/Dispersal]. [02:28:34] Madman_quail plays [Waterveil Cavern]. [02:28:46] Madman_quail casts [Dark Ritual]. [02:28:51] Madman_quail casts [Primal Amulet]. [02:28:57] v1ndhl3r casts [Neutralize] targeting [Primal Amulet]. [02:29:02] Madman_quail casts [Deep Analysis] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting Madman_quail. [02:29:04] Madman_quail draws two cards with [Deep Analysis]. [02:29:09] Turn 7: v1ndhl3r [02:29:27] Turn 8: Madman_quail [02:29:40] Madman_quail casts [Discovery]. [02:29:50] Madman_quail puts [Waterveil Cavern] into their graveyard and 1 card on top of their library. [02:29:50] Madman_quail draws a card with [Discovery]. [02:29:54] Madman_quail plays [Bad River]. [02:30:00] Madman_quail casts [Deep Analysis] targeting Madman_quail. [02:30:01] Madman_quail draws two cards with [Deep Analysis]. [02:30:07] Turn 8: v1ndhl3r [02:30:13] v1ndhl3r plays [Bloodfell Caves]. [02:30:13] v1ndhl3r puts triggered ability from [Bloodfell Caves] onto the stack (When Bloodfell Caves enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [02:30:17] Turn 9: Madman_quail [02:30:20] Madman_quail activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...). [02:30:29] Madman_quail plays [Island]. [02:30:39] Turn 9: v1ndhl3r [02:30:43] Madman_quail casts [Turnabout] targeting v1ndhl3r. [02:31:05] v1ndhl3r casts [Silumgar's Command] targeting [Turnabout], and [Swamp] (Return to hand) (Counter target noncreature spell. Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [02:31:13] v1ndhl3r returns [Swamp] to its owner's hand with [Silumgar's Command]. [02:31:28] Madman_quail casts [Peer Through Depths]. [02:31:35] Madman_quail puts [Sins of the Past] into their hand with with [Peer Through Depths]. [02:31:44] Turn 10: Madman_quail [02:31:47] Madman_quail plays [Swamp]. [02:31:59] Madman_quail casts [Turnabout] targeting Madman_quail. [02:32:03] Madman_quail chooses land for [Turnabout]. [02:32:13] Madman_quail casts [Frantic Search]. [02:32:18] Madman_quail draws two cards with [Frantic Search]. [02:32:25] Madman_quail discards [Mind's Desire]. [02:32:25] Madman_quail discards [Mind's Desire]. [02:32:40] Madman_quail casts [Frantic Search]. [02:32:44] Madman_quail draws two cards with [Frantic Search]. [02:32:54] Madman_quail discards [Swamp]. [02:32:54] Madman_quail discards [Bad River]. [02:33:09] Madman_quail casts [Sins of the Past] targeting [Mind's Desire]. [02:34:00] v1ndhl3r casts [Erebos's Intervention] targeting [Mind's Desire], and [Mind's Desire]. (X is 1) (Exile up to twice X target cards from graveyards.). [02:34:18] Madman_quail's [Sins of the Past] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets. [02:34:25] Madman_quail casts [Discovery]. [02:34:32] Madman_quail puts 2 cards on top of their library. [02:34:32] Madman_quail draws a card with [Discovery]. [02:34:49] Madman_quail casts [Deep Analysis] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting Madman_quail. [02:34:51] Madman_quail draws two cards with [Deep Analysis]. [02:34:58] Turn 10: v1ndhl3r [02:35:06] v1ndhl3r plays [Mountain]. [02:35:31] v1ndhl3r casts [Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker]. [02:35:35] v1ndhl3r activates an ability of [Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker] targeting [Swamp] ( Destroy target noncreature permanent.). [02:35:39] Turn 11: Madman_quail [02:35:50] Turn 11: v1ndhl3r [02:35:56] v1ndhl3r activates an ability of [Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker] targeting [Waterveil Cavern] ( Destroy target noncreature permanent.). [02:36:07] Madman_quail casts [Opt]. [02:36:12] Madman_quail puts 1 card on top of their library. [02:36:12] Madman_quail draws a card with [Opt]. [02:36:16] Madman_quail casts [Turnabout] targeting v1ndhl3r. [02:36:25] v1ndhl3r casts [Fact or Fiction]. [02:36:52] v1ndhl3r puts [Cruel Ultimatum], [Angrath's Rampage], [Swamp], [Island] into their hand with [Fact or Fiction]. [02:36:52] v1ndhl3r puts [Neutralize] into their graveyard. [02:37:00] Madman_quail chooses land for [Turnabout]. [02:37:08] v1ndhl3r discards [Doom Blade]. [02:37:08] v1ndhl3r discards [Cut/Ribbons]. [02:37:08] Turn 12: Madman_quail [02:37:18] Madman_quail casts [Opt]. [02:37:22] Madman_quail puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [02:37:22] Madman_quail draws a card with [Opt]. [02:37:25] Madman_quail casts [Opt]. [02:37:29] Madman_quail puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [02:37:29] Madman_quail draws a card with [Opt]. [02:37:31] Madman_quail casts [Shimmer of Possibility]. [02:37:47] Turn 12: v1ndhl3r [02:37:57] v1ndhl3r plays [Dismal Backwater]. [02:37:57] v1ndhl3r puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [02:38:02] v1ndhl3r activates an ability of [Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker] targeting Madman_quail ( Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker deals 7 damage to target player or planeswalker. That player or that pl...). [02:38:04] Madman_quail has conceded from the game. Winner: v1ndhl3r Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (725090226) == [Time] 1592066352 [02:39:13] PDBot has started watching. [02:39:15] Madman_quail joined the game. [02:39:24] Madman_quail chooses to play first. [02:39:31] Madman_quail begins the game with seven cards in hand. [02:39:38] v1ndhl3r begins the game with seven cards in hand. [02:39:38] Turn 1: Madman_quail [02:39:40] Madman_quail skips their draw step. [02:39:41] Madman_quail plays [Swamp]. [02:39:46] Turn 1: v1ndhl3r [02:39:49] v1ndhl3r plays [Swiftwater Cliffs]. [02:39:50] v1ndhl3r puts triggered ability from [Swiftwater Cliffs] onto the stack (When Swiftwater Cliffs enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [02:39:54] Turn 2: Madman_quail [02:39:58] Madman_quail plays [Island]. [02:40:01] Madman_quail casts [Discovery]. [02:40:08] Madman_quail puts 2 cards on top of their library. [02:40:08] Madman_quail draws a card with [Discovery]. [02:40:13] Turn 2: v1ndhl3r [02:40:16] v1ndhl3r plays [Bloodfell Caves]. [02:40:16] v1ndhl3r puts triggered ability from [Bloodfell Caves] onto the stack (When Bloodfell Caves enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [02:40:19] Turn 3: Madman_quail [02:40:25] Madman_quail casts [Shimmer of Possibility]. [02:40:32] Madman_quail plays [Bad River]. [02:40:34] Turn 3: v1ndhl3r [02:40:38] v1ndhl3r plays [Island]. [02:40:42] Turn 4: Madman_quail [02:40:47] Madman_quail activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...). [02:40:59] Madman_quail casts [Frantic Search]. [02:41:04] Madman_quail draws two cards with [Frantic Search]. [02:41:18] Madman_quail discards [Deep Analysis]. [02:41:18] Madman_quail discards [Frantic Search]. [02:41:23] Madman_quail plays [Waterveil Cavern]. [02:41:29] Madman_quail casts [Deep Analysis] from the graveyard using an alternate cost targeting Madman_quail. [02:41:31] Madman_quail draws two cards with [Deep Analysis]. [02:41:41] Madman_quail casts [Discovery]. [02:41:48] Madman_quail puts [Waterveil Cavern] into their graveyard and 1 card on top of their library. [02:41:48] Madman_quail draws a card with [Discovery]. [02:41:52] Turn 4: v1ndhl3r [02:41:56] v1ndhl3r plays [Swamp]. [02:42:02] v1ndhl3r casts [Slaughter Games] targeting Madman_quail. [02:42:13] v1ndhl3r names Tendrils of Agony for [Slaughter Games]. [02:42:47] Turn 5: Madman_quail [02:42:52] Madman_quail plays [Bad River]. [02:42:58] Madman_quail casts [Dark Ritual]. [02:43:02] Madman_quail casts [Dark Ritual]. [02:43:13] Madman_quail casts [Frantic Search]. [02:43:15] Madman_quail draws two cards with [Frantic Search]. [02:43:22] Madman_quail discards [Mind's Desire]. [02:43:22] Madman_quail discards [Island]. [02:43:28] Madman_quail activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...). [02:43:42] Madman_quail casts [Shimmer of Possibility]. [02:44:07] Madman_quail casts [Sins of the Past] targeting [Mind's Desire]. [02:44:12] Madman_quail casts [Mind's Desire] from the graveyard. [02:44:12] Madman_quail puts triggered ability from [Mind's Desire] onto the stack (5 spells cast before Mind's Desire this turn. Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each ...). [02:44:40] Madman_quail casts [Opt]. [02:44:48] Madman_quail puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [02:44:48] Madman_quail draws a card with [Opt]. [02:44:51] Madman_quail casts [Primal Amulet]. [02:45:00] Madman_quail casts [Pteramander]. [02:45:07] Madman_quail casts [Dark Ritual]. [02:45:07] Madman_quail puts triggered ability from [Primal Amulet] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, put a charge counter on Primal Amulet. Then if ther...). [02:45:18] Turn 5: v1ndhl3r [02:45:26] v1ndhl3r plays [Dismal Backwater]. [02:45:27] v1ndhl3r puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [02:45:39] v1ndhl3r casts [Slaughter Games] targeting Madman_quail. [02:45:46] v1ndhl3r names Murmuring Mystic for [Slaughter Games]. [02:46:11] Turn 6: Madman_quail [02:46:18] Madman_quail casts [Peer Through Depths]. [02:46:18] Madman_quail puts triggered ability from [Primal Amulet] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, put a charge counter on Primal Amulet. Then if ther...). [02:46:25] Madman_quail puts [Deep Analysis] into their hand with with [Peer Through Depths]. [02:46:31] Madman_quail activates an ability of [Pteramander] ( Adapt 4.). [02:46:36] v1ndhl3r is being attacked by [Pteramander]. [02:46:45] Madman_quail casts [Pteramander]. [02:46:48] Turn 6: v1ndhl3r [02:46:54] v1ndhl3r plays [Swamp]. [02:46:59] v1ndhl3r casts [Angrath's Rampage] targeting Madman_quail (Target player sacrifices an artifact.). [02:47:02] Madman_quail sacrifices [Primal Amulet]. [02:47:05] Turn 7: Madman_quail [02:47:15] Madman_quail activates an ability of [Pteramander] ( Adapt 4.). [02:47:22] v1ndhl3r is being attacked by [Pteramander] and [Pteramander]. [02:47:37] v1ndhl3r casts [Fact or Fiction]. [02:47:47] v1ndhl3r puts [Cruel Ultimatum], [Dismal Backwater] into their hand with [Fact or Fiction]. [02:47:47] v1ndhl3r puts [Fact or Fiction], [Thought Erasure], [Thought Erasure] into their graveyard. [02:47:54] Turn 7: v1ndhl3r [02:47:59] Madman_quail casts [Turnabout] targeting v1ndhl3r. [02:48:08] v1ndhl3r has conceded from the game. Winner: Madman_quail Game 2 Completed. [02:48:11] v1ndhl3r has left the game. == Game 3 (725091316) == [Time] 1592067073 [02:51:14] PDBot has started watching. [02:51:14] v1ndhl3r joined the game. [02:51:16] Madman_quail joined the game. [02:51:22] v1ndhl3r chooses to play first. [02:51:27] v1ndhl3r mulligans to six cards. [02:53:19] Madman_quail begins the game with seven cards in hand. [02:53:27] v1ndhl3r mulligans to five cards. [02:53:38] v1ndhl3r puts two cards on the bottom of their library and begins the game with five cards in hand. [02:53:38] Turn 1: v1ndhl3r [02:53:46] v1ndhl3r skips their draw step. [02:53:47] v1ndhl3r plays [Swiftwater Cliffs]. [02:53:47] v1ndhl3r puts triggered ability from [Swiftwater Cliffs] onto the stack (When Swiftwater Cliffs enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [02:53:53] Turn 1: Madman_quail [02:53:56] Madman_quail plays [Waterveil Cavern]. [02:54:00] Turn 2: v1ndhl3r [02:54:03] v1ndhl3r plays [Swamp]. [02:54:08] Turn 2: Madman_quail [02:54:11] Madman_quail plays [Island]. [02:54:16] Madman_quail casts [Discovery]. [02:54:23] Madman_quail puts 2 cards on top of their library. [02:54:23] Madman_quail draws a card with [Discovery]. [02:54:26] Turn 3: v1ndhl3r [02:54:30] v1ndhl3r plays [Island]. [02:54:32] Turn 3: Madman_quail [02:54:36] Madman_quail plays [Waterveil Cavern]. [02:54:41] Madman_quail casts [Dark Ritual]. [02:54:47] Madman_quail casts [Primal Amulet]. [02:54:54] Turn 4: v1ndhl3r [02:55:02] v1ndhl3r casts [Angrath's Rampage] targeting Madman_quail (Target player sacrifices an artifact.). [02:55:05] Madman_quail sacrifices [Primal Amulet]. [02:55:12] Turn 4: Madman_quail [02:55:15] Madman_quail plays [Bad River]. [02:55:21] Madman_quail casts [Pteramander]. [02:55:35] Turn 5: v1ndhl3r [02:55:51] v1ndhl3r casts [Angrath's Rampage] targeting Madman_quail (Target player sacrifices a creature.). [02:55:53] Madman_quail sacrifices [Pteramander]. [02:55:56] Turn 5: Madman_quail [02:55:57] Madman_quail activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...). [02:56:07] Madman_quail casts [Murmuring Mystic]. [02:56:14] Turn 6: v1ndhl3r [02:56:18] v1ndhl3r plays [Island]. [02:56:21] Turn 6: Madman_quail [02:56:26] Madman_quail casts [Peer Through Depths]. [02:56:26] Madman_quail puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...). [02:56:28] Madman_quail's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token. [02:56:36] Madman_quail puts [Shimmer of Possibility] into their hand with with [Peer Through Depths]. [02:56:41] Madman_quail casts [Shimmer of Possibility]. [02:56:41] Madman_quail puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...). [02:56:44] Madman_quail's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token. [02:56:59] v1ndhl3r is being attacked by [Murmuring Mystic]. [02:57:10] v1ndhl3r casts [Fact or Fiction]. [02:57:24] v1ndhl3r puts [Angrath's Rampage], [Dismal Backwater] into their hand with [Fact or Fiction]. [02:57:24] v1ndhl3r puts [Atris, Oracle of Half-Truths], [Neutralize], [Neutralize] into their graveyard. [02:57:26] Turn 7: v1ndhl3r [02:57:31] v1ndhl3r plays [Dismal Backwater]. [02:57:31] v1ndhl3r puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [02:57:44] Turn 7: Madman_quail [02:57:52] v1ndhl3r is being attacked by [Bird Illusion] token, [Bird Illusion] token, and [Murmuring Mystic]. [02:58:03] Madman_quail casts [Shimmer of Possibility]. [02:58:03] Madman_quail puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...). [02:58:06] Madman_quail's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token. [02:58:16] Madman_quail casts [Opt]. [02:58:17] Madman_quail puts triggered ability from [Murmuring Mystic] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Bird Illusion creature token with...). [02:58:22] Madman_quail's [Murmuring Mystic] creates a Bird Illusion token. [02:58:28] Madman_quail puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [02:58:28] Madman_quail draws a card with [Opt]. [02:58:29] Madman_quail plays [Bad River]. [02:58:36] v1ndhl3r casts [Fact or Fiction]. [02:58:48] v1ndhl3r puts [Thought Erasure], [Fact or Fiction], [Slaughter Games], [Cruel Ultimatum] into their hand with [Fact or Fiction]. [02:58:48] v1ndhl3r puts [Erebos's Intervention] into their graveyard. [02:58:51] Turn 8: v1ndhl3r [02:58:58] v1ndhl3r plays [Island]. [02:59:09] v1ndhl3r casts [Erebos's Intervention] targeting [Murmuring Mystic]. (X is 5) (Target creature gets -X/-X until end of turn. You gain X life.). [02:59:14] Turn 8: Madman_quail [02:59:19] Madman_quail activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card, put it onto the battlefield, then shuffle your l...). [02:59:31] v1ndhl3r is being attacked by [Bird Illusion] token, [Bird Illusion] token, [Bird Illusion] token, and [Bird Illusion] token. [02:59:44] Madman_quail casts [Primal Amulet]. [02:59:48] Turn 9: v1ndhl3r [03:00:00] v1ndhl3r casts [Angrath's Rampage] targeting Madman_quail (Target player sacrifices an artifact.). [03:00:16] Madman_quail sacrifices [Primal Amulet]. [03:00:21] v1ndhl3r casts [Thought Erasure] targeting Madman_quail. [03:00:28] [CHAT] Madman_quail: gtg [03:00:31] Madman_quail has conceded from the game. [03:00:31] Madman_quail has lost connection to the game. Winner: v1ndhl3r Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: v1ndhl3r: 2–1