Modern
Tribal Apocalypse Round 4
BuggedCardObserver,Tourney
Generalissimo,Boso

== Game 1 (722992032) ==
[Time] 1590260737
[05:05:38] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Tribal Apocalypse 10.20
[Gatherling] Round=4
[05:06:16] vole has started watching.
[05:06:31] [CHAT] Boso: Companion game 1? can't start with a sideboard
[05:06:36] kittyburglar has started watching.
[05:07:05] [CHAT] Boso: you'd need to put it in the side on game 2
[05:07:45] [CHAT] Generalissimo: That's...not correct.
[05:08:03] [CHAT] Boso: thats waht the ruling was earlier today
[05:08:26] [CHAT] Boso: it's in the sideboard 
[05:08:42] [CHAT] Generalissimo: Let me just message Kumagoro.
[05:09:53] vole has stopped watching.
[05:10:21] Boso begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[05:11:02] Generalissimo mulligans to six cards.
[05:11:06] [CHAT] Boso: did you submit it with yorion in the sideboard I'm guessing not because you can't
[05:11:09] Generalissimo puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[05:11:09] Turn 1: Boso
[05:11:10] Boso skips their draw step.
[05:11:34] [CHAT] Generalissimo: No, we handle it by putting the companion in the comments.
[05:11:37] [CHAT] Boso: you would obviously have to use the deck how you submitted it
[05:14:32] _Kumagoro_ has started watching.
[05:14:47] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: Companions are allowed in Tribal Wars game, from game 1 onward.
[05:14:55] [CHAT] Boso: this is game 1
[05:15:06] vole has started watching.
[05:15:11] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: It doesn't matter which game is it, companions are not sideboarded in
[05:15:17] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: They're outside the game
[05:15:20] [CHAT] kittyburglar: no
[05:15:29] [CHAT] Boso: wizards says they are in sideboard
[05:15:38] [CHAT] Boso: don't you know the rules?
[05:15:41] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: Yes, and you cast them from there
[05:15:52] [CHAT] kittyburglar: don't you have 61 cards in deck kumagoro so you can side out a companion?
[05:15:52] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: You don't seem to know the rules, it's even said on the card
[05:16:06] [CHAT] Boso: so how can he have it game 1 in a tournament with no sideboard allowed
[05:16:16] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: No, the companions is not moved into the deck, it would have no purpose in the deck, it's cast from outside the deck
[05:16:22] [CHAT] Boso: if it's in sideboard
[05:16:34] [CHAT] Generalissimo: How would it make sense to be allowed it in game 2 and 3 but not 1?
[05:16:35] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: We allowed it, just like Commander did
[05:16:37] [CHAT] Boso: it takes up a sideboard slot
[05:16:43] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: Commander doesn't have a sideboard either, but uses companions
[05:16:50] [CHAT] Boso: it's a sieboard card
[05:17:38] [CHAT] Boso: so he starts the game with a card in his sideboard which is not allowed by this tournaments rules
[05:18:07] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: It's not sideboarded in, it's played from outside the game, read the rules about companoons, watch videos of how companions work in MTGO and Arena
[05:18:19] vole has stopped watching.
[05:18:21] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: It's allowed by this tournament rules, we ruled on it
[05:18:26] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: And we allowed it
[05:18:34] vole has started watching.
[05:18:40] [CHAT] Boso: It osen't matter if it's sideboarded in the rules are no sideboard whtsoever and the companion is in the sideboard
[05:18:44] vole has stopped watching.
[05:19:14] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: We changed the rules!
[05:19:27] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: Just like the Commander council did
[05:19:35] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: Just like in Brawl
[05:19:54] [CHAT] Boso: that wasn't made clear anywhere in registration or the rules
[05:19:59] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: All formats use companions now, regardless of the existence of a sideboard. If you don't have a sideboard, you just have a single card in it, the companion
[05:20:22] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: I'm sorry about that, I'll put it in the documents somewhere
[05:20:32] Boso has conceded from the game.
Winner: Generalissimo
Game 1 Completed.
[05:20:36] [CHAT] _Kumagoro_: Bottom line, this is perfectly legal
[05:20:43] Boso has left the game.

== Game 2 (722993832) ==
[Time] 1590261659
[05:20:59] PDBot has started watching.
[05:21:00] Boso has conceded from the game.
Winner: Generalissimo
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: Generalissimo: 2–0
[05:21:02] Boso has left the game.