PennyDreadfulCommander
PD League
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Sooly,Waltzmark,k3pper

== Game 1 (720471250) ==
[Time] 1588519124
[01:18:50] PDBot has started watching.
[01:18:50] Waltzmark joined the game.
[01:18:50] k3pper joined the game.
[01:18:50] Sooly joined the game.
[01:19:09] k3pper chooses to play first.
[01:19:09] k3pper chooses [General Tazri] as their commander.
[01:19:09] Waltzmark chooses [Gisa and Geralf] as their commander.
[01:19:09] Sooly chooses [Athreos, Shroud-Veiled] as their commander.
[01:19:10] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Gisa and Geralf[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[01:19:11] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Athreos, Shroud-Veiled[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[01:19:19] k3pper begins the game with seven cards in hand.
[01:19:23] Waltzmark mulligans to seven cards.
[01:19:27] Sooly mulligans to seven cards.
[01:19:30] Waltzmark mulligans to six cards.
[01:19:34] Sooly mulligans to six cards.
[01:19:51] Waltzmark puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[01:20:01] Sooly puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand.
[01:20:01] Turn 1: k3pper
[01:20:10] k3pper plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[01:20:11] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Sandsteppe Citadel[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[sG] In order to prevent further spamming, I'll stop warning you now.
[sG] For more information about Penny Dreadful, see pdmtgo.com or reddit.com/r/PennyDreadfulMTG
[01:20:21] Turn 1: Waltzmark
[01:20:24] Waltzmark plays [Swamp].
[01:20:27] Waltzmark casts [Vampiric Tutor].
[01:20:44] Turn 1: Sooly
[01:20:51] Sooly plays [Swamp].
[01:20:54] Turn 2: k3pper
[01:20:59] k3pper plays [Mountain].
[01:21:03] k3pper casts [Rampant Growth].
[01:21:26] Turn 2: Waltzmark
[01:21:32] Waltzmark plays [Dismal Backwater].
[01:21:32] Waltzmark puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[01:21:35] Turn 2: Sooly
[01:21:41] Sooly plays [Plains].
[01:21:46] Sooly casts [Mind Stone].
[01:21:51] Turn 3: k3pper
[01:22:07] k3pper plays [Mystic Monastery].
[01:22:19] Turn 3: Waltzmark
[01:22:28] Waltzmark plays [Island].
[01:22:41] Turn 3: Sooly
[01:22:47] Sooly casts [Worn Powerstone].
[01:22:55] Sooly plays [Orzhov Basilica].
[01:22:56] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Orzhov Basilica] onto the stack (When Orzhov Basilica enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[01:23:00] Sooly returns [Plains] to its owner's hand with [Orzhov Basilica]'s ability.
[01:23:09] Turn 4: k3pper
[01:23:19] k3pper plays [Opulent Palace].
[01:23:27] k3pper casts [Soulherder].
[01:23:35] No legal targets to choose for [Soulherder]'s triggered ability.
[01:23:36] Turn 4: Waltzmark
[01:23:40] Waltzmark plays [Swamp].
[01:23:56] Waltzmark casts [Forgotten Creation].
[01:24:15] Turn 4: Sooly
[01:24:20] Sooly plays [Plains].
[01:24:31] Sooly casts [Athreos, Shroud-Veiled].
[01:24:57] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Athreos, Shroud-Veiled] onto the stack targeting [Soulherder] (At the beginning of your end step, put a coin counter on another target creature.).
[01:25:08] Turn 5: k3pper
[01:25:18] k3pper plays [Terramorphic Expanse].
[01:25:26] k3pper casts [Kazuul Warlord].
[01:25:28] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:25:39] k3pper activates an ability of [Terramorphic Expanse] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[01:26:06] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Soulherder] onto the stack targeting [Kazuul Warlord] (At the beginning of your end step, you may exile another target creature you control, then return ...).
[01:26:15] k3pper chooses not to use [Soulherder]'s ability.
[01:26:16] Turn 5: Waltzmark
[01:26:17] Waltzmark puts triggered ability from [Forgotten Creation] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may discard all the cards in your hand. If you do, draw that ...).
[01:26:41] Waltzmark discards [Withered Wretch].
[01:26:41] Waltzmark discards [Corpse Harvester].
[01:26:42] Waltzmark discards [Vanquisher's Banner].
[01:26:42] Waltzmark discards [Mystical Teachings].
[01:26:44] Waltzmark draws four cards with [Forgotten Creation]'s ability.
[01:26:51] Waltzmark plays [Island].
[01:27:09] Waltzmark casts [Death Baron].
[01:27:17] Waltzmark casts [Rotting Rats].
[01:27:18] Waltzmark puts triggered ability from [Rotting Rats] onto the stack (When Rotting Rats enters the battlefield, each player discards a card.).
[01:27:19] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Rotting Rats[sU] has an advantageous bug.
The client incorrectly display that you may choose to discard either the Adventure or the creature side of an Adventure card
[01:27:29] Waltzmark chooses a card from their hand.
[01:27:32] Sooly chooses a card from their hand.
[01:27:32] Sooly chooses a card from their hand.
[01:27:48] k3pper chooses a card from their hand.
[01:27:48] k3pper chooses a card from their hand.
[01:27:48] k3pper chooses a card from their hand.
[01:27:48] Waltzmark discards [Zombie Master].
[01:27:49] k3pper discards [Deadeye Navigator].
[01:27:49] Sooly discards [Swamp].
[01:27:58] Turn 5: Sooly
[01:28:25] Sooly plays [Terramorphic Expanse].
[01:28:29] Sooly activates an ability of [Terramorphic Expanse] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[01:28:53] Sooly casts [Gray Merchant of Asphodel].
[01:28:55] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Gray Merchant of Asphodel] onto the stack (When Gray Merchant of Asphodel enters the battlefield, each opponent loses X life, where X is your...).
[01:29:07] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Athreos, Shroud-Veiled] onto the stack targeting [Gray Merchant of Asphodel] (At the beginning of your end step, put a coin counter on another target creature.).
[01:29:09] Turn 6: k3pper
[01:29:27] k3pper plays [Nomad Outpost].
[01:29:46] k3pper casts [Sea Gate Loremaster].
[01:29:48] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:30:30] Sooly is being attacked by [Kazuul Warlord].
[01:30:51] [Gray Merchant of Asphodel] blocks [Kazuul Warlord].
[01:31:04] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Athreos, Shroud-Veiled] onto the stack (Whenever a creature with a coin counter on it dies or is put into exile, return that card to the b...).
[01:31:11] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Gray Merchant of Asphodel] onto the stack (When Gray Merchant of Asphodel enters the battlefield, each opponent loses X life, where X is your...).
[01:31:34] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Soulherder] onto the stack targeting [Sea Gate Loremaster] (At the beginning of your end step, you may exile another target creature you control, then return ...).
[01:31:46] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:31:46] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Soulherder] onto the stack (Whenever a creature is exiled from the battlefield, put a +1/+1 counter on Soulherder.).
[01:32:00] Turn 6: Waltzmark
[01:32:01] Waltzmark puts triggered ability from [Forgotten Creation] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may discard all the cards in your hand. If you do, draw that ...).
[01:32:11] Waltzmark discards [Diregraf Captain].
[01:32:11] Waltzmark draws a card with [Forgotten Creation]'s ability.
[01:32:17] Waltzmark plays [Swamp].
[01:32:28] Waltzmark casts [Gisa and Geralf].
[01:32:32] Waltzmark puts triggered ability from [Gisa and Geralf] onto the stack (When Gisa and Geralf enters the battlefield, put the top four cards of your library into your grav...).
[01:33:37] Sooly is being attacked by [Forgotten Creation].
[01:34:00] Turn 6: Sooly
[01:34:24] Sooly activates an ability of [Mind Stone] ( Draw a card.).
[01:34:28] Sooly draws a card with [Mind Stone]'s ability.
[01:34:55] Sooly casts [Fumigate].
[01:35:06] Waltzmark casts [Negate] targeting [Fumigate].
[01:35:13] Sooly plays [Orzhov Guildgate].
[01:35:26] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Athreos, Shroud-Veiled] onto the stack targeting [Gray Merchant of Asphodel] (At the beginning of your end step, put a coin counter on another target creature.).
[01:35:33] Turn 7: k3pper
[01:36:33] k3pper casts [General Tazri].
[01:36:41] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:36:42] k3pper puts triggered ability from [General Tazri] onto the stack (When General Tazri enters the battlefield, you may search your library for an Ally creature card, ...).
[01:37:41] k3pper reveals [Ondu Cleric].
[01:37:59] k3pper casts [Ondu Cleric].
[01:38:03] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Ondu Cleric] onto the stack (Whenever Ondu Cleric or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may gain life ...).
[01:38:03] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:39:48] Sooly is being attacked by [Kazuul Warlord].
[01:39:56] [Gray Merchant of Asphodel] blocks [Kazuul Warlord].
[01:40:04] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Athreos, Shroud-Veiled] onto the stack (Whenever a creature with a coin counter on it dies or is put into exile, return that card to the b...).
[01:40:09] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Gray Merchant of Asphodel] onto the stack (When Gray Merchant of Asphodel enters the battlefield, each opponent loses X life, where X is your...).
[01:40:19] k3pper activates an ability of [Sea Gate Loremaster] ( Draw a card for each Ally you control.).
[01:40:20] k3pper draws four cards with [Sea Gate Loremaster]'s ability.
[01:40:42] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Soulherder] onto the stack targeting [General Tazri] (At the beginning of your end step, you may exile another target creature you control, then return ...).
[01:40:47] Turn 7: Waltzmark
[01:40:48] Waltzmark puts triggered ability from [Forgotten Creation] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may discard all the cards in your hand. If you do, draw that ...).
[01:40:53] Waltzmark draws zero cards with [Forgotten Creation]'s ability.
[01:41:17] Waltzmark casts [Corpse Harvester] from the graveyard.
[01:42:17] Turn 7: Sooly
[01:42:27] Sooly plays [Swamp].
[01:43:20] Sooly casts [Oblation] targeting [Gray Merchant of Asphodel].
[01:43:27] Sooly draws two cards with [Oblation].
[01:44:22] Sooly casts [Command the Dreadhorde] targeting [Deadeye Navigator], [Liliana, Untouched by Death], [Diregraf Captain], and [Zombie Master].
[01:44:56] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Deadeye Navigator] onto the stack (Soulbond (When this creature enters the battlefield, you may pair it with another unpaired creat...).
[01:44:57] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Deadeye Navigator] onto the stack (Soulbond (When another creature enters the battlefield, you may pair this creature with it.)).
[01:44:57] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Deadeye Navigator] onto the stack (Soulbond (When another creature enters the battlefield, you may pair this creature with it.)).
[01:45:15] Sooly's [Deadeye Navigator]'s triggered ability does not resolve because the intervening "if" condition is not met.
[01:45:15] Sooly's [Deadeye Navigator]'s triggered ability does not resolve because the intervening "if" condition is not met.
[01:45:47] Sooly activates an ability of [Liliana, Untouched by Death] targeting [Death Baron] ( Target creature gets -X/-X until end of turn, where X is the number of Zombies you control.).
[01:46:43] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Athreos, Shroud-Veiled] onto the stack targeting [Forgotten Creation] (At the beginning of your end step, put a coin counter on another target creature.).
[01:46:50] Turn 8: k3pper
[01:47:45] k3pper casts [Mirror Image].
[01:47:56] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Ondu Cleric] onto the stack (Whenever Ondu Cleric or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may gain life ...).
[01:47:57] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:47:57] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:48:32] k3pper casts [Akoum Battlesinger].
[01:48:39] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Ondu Cleric] onto the stack (Whenever Ondu Cleric or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may gain life ...).
[01:48:43] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:48:46] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:48:46] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Akoum Battlesinger] onto the stack (Whenever Akoum Battlesinger or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may hav...).
[01:49:20] k3pper casts [Harabaz Druid].
[01:49:27] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Ondu Cleric] onto the stack (Whenever Ondu Cleric or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may gain life ...).
[01:49:30] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Akoum Battlesinger] onto the stack (Whenever Akoum Battlesinger or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may hav...).
[01:49:31] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:49:31] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:50:04] k3pper plays [Jungle Shrine].
[01:51:53] Sooly is being attacked by [Akoum Battlesinger], [Ondu Cleric], [Sea Gate Loremaster], and [Kazuul Warlord].
[01:52:09] [Athreos, Shroud-Veiled] blocks [Kazuul Warlord].
[01:52:14] [Deadeye Navigator] blocks [Sea Gate Loremaster].
[01:52:14] [Diregraf Captain] blocks [Ondu Cleric].
[01:52:16] [Zombie Master] blocks [Akoum Battlesinger].
[01:52:28] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Diregraf Captain] onto the stack targeting Waltzmark (Whenever another Zombie you control dies, target opponent loses 1 life.).
[01:52:46] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Soulherder] onto the stack targeting [Harabaz Druid] (At the beginning of your end step, you may exile another target creature you control, then return ...).
[01:53:14] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Soulherder] onto the stack (Whenever a creature is exiled from the battlefield, put a +1/+1 counter on Soulherder.).
[01:53:16] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Akoum Battlesinger] onto the stack (Whenever Akoum Battlesinger or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may hav...).
[01:53:16] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:53:17] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[01:53:41] Turn 8: Waltzmark
[01:53:41] Waltzmark puts triggered ability from [Forgotten Creation] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you may discard all the cards in your hand. If you do, draw that ...).
[01:53:45] Waltzmark discards [Island].
[01:53:45] Waltzmark draws a card with [Forgotten Creation]'s ability.
[01:53:55] acer62887 has started watching.
[01:54:11] Waltzmark activates an ability of [Corpse Harvester] ( Search your library for a Zombie card and a Swamp card, reveal them, and put them into your hand....).
[01:54:41] Waltzmark reveals [Diregraf Colossus].
[01:54:45] Waltzmark reveals [Swamp].
[01:54:55] Waltzmark casts [Frantic Search].
[01:54:56] Waltzmark draws two cards with [Frantic Search].
[01:55:06] Waltzmark discards [Swamp].
[01:55:06] Waltzmark discards [Swamp].
[01:55:36] Waltzmark plays [Swamp].
[01:55:49] Waltzmark casts [Diregraf Colossus].
[01:56:40] Waltzmark casts [Withered Wretch] from the graveyard.
[01:56:40] Waltzmark puts triggered ability from [Diregraf Colossus] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Zombie spell, create a tapped 2/2 black Zombie creature token.).
[01:56:40] Waltzmark's [Diregraf Colossus] creates a Zombie token.
[01:56:49] Turn 8: Sooly
[01:58:41] Sooly plays [Evolving Wilds].
[01:58:43] Sooly activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[01:59:02] Sooly activates an ability of [Liliana, Untouched by Death] ( Put the top three cards of your library into your graveyard. If at least one of them is a Zombie ...).
[01:59:47] Sooly casts [Flickerwisp].
[02:00:00] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Flickerwisp] onto the stack targeting [Liliana, Untouched by Death] (When Flickerwisp enters the battlefield, exile another target permanent. Return that card to the b...).
[02:00:18] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Athreos, Shroud-Veiled] onto the stack targeting [Diregraf Colossus] (At the beginning of your end step, put a coin counter on another target creature.).
[02:00:18] Sooly puts triggered ability from [Flickerwisp] onto the stack (Return Liliana, Untouched by Death to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning o...).
[02:00:22] Turn 9: k3pper
[02:01:29] k3pper activates an ability of [Sea Gate Loremaster] ( Draw a card for each Ally you control.).
[02:01:30] k3pper draws five cards with [Sea Gate Loremaster]'s ability.
[02:01:38] k3pper plays [Forest].
[02:02:30] k3pper casts [General Tazri].
[02:02:41] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[02:02:41] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[02:02:42] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Akoum Battlesinger] onto the stack (Whenever Akoum Battlesinger or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may hav...).
[02:02:43] k3pper puts triggered ability from [General Tazri] onto the stack (When General Tazri enters the battlefield, you may search your library for an Ally creature card, ...).
[02:03:25] k3pper reveals [Kabira Evangel].
[02:04:21] k3pper casts [Kabira Evangel].
[02:04:27] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Akoum Battlesinger] onto the stack (Whenever Akoum Battlesinger or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may hav...).
[02:04:32] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kabira Evangel] onto the stack (Whenever Kabira Evangel or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may choose ...).
[02:04:32] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[02:04:32] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[02:04:54] k3pper chooses black.
[02:05:16] k3pper casts [Lantern Scout].
[02:05:21] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Lantern Scout] onto the stack (Whenever Lantern Scout or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, creatures you co...).
[02:05:26] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[02:05:27] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[02:05:30] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kabira Evangel] onto the stack (Whenever Kabira Evangel or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may choose ...).
[02:05:30] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Akoum Battlesinger] onto the stack (Whenever Akoum Battlesinger or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may hav...).
[02:05:49] k3pper chooses blue.
[02:06:47] k3pper casts [Jwari Shapeshifter].
[02:06:58] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Lantern Scout] onto the stack (Whenever Lantern Scout or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, creatures you co...).
[02:07:04] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kabira Evangel] onto the stack (Whenever Kabira Evangel or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may choose ...).
[02:07:07] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Akoum Battlesinger] onto the stack (Whenever Akoum Battlesinger or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may hav...).
[02:07:07] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[02:07:07] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[02:07:07] k3pper puts triggered ability from [Kazuul Warlord] onto the stack (Whenever Kazuul Warlord or another Ally enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a +...).
[02:07:52] k3pper chooses white.
[02:08:22] Sooly is being attacked by [Akoum Battlesinger] and [Kazuul Warlord].
[02:08:22] Waltzmark is being attacked by [Kazuul Warlord].
Winner: k3pper
Game 1 Completed.
[02:08:47] Sooly has left the game.
[02:08:58] k3pper has left the game.