PennyDreadful penny dreadful BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Gabbalis,Smokage == Game 1 (692930824) == [Time] 1572079081 [19:38:02] PDBot has started watching. [19:38:02] Smokage joined the game. [League] Host doesn't have active run [19:38:11] [CHAT] Smokage: Is this league? [19:38:16] [CHAT] Gabbalis: no, [19:38:17] [CHAT] Gabbalis: alas [19:38:19] Smokage chooses to play first. [19:38:23] [CHAT] Smokage: nvm lets go! [19:38:26] Smokage mulligans to six cards. [19:38:26] [CHAT] Gabbalis: woot! [19:38:28] Gabbalis begins the game with seven cards in hand. [19:38:41] Smokage puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [19:38:41] Turn 1: Smokage [19:38:43] Smokage skips their draw step. [19:38:44] Smokage plays [Nomad Outpost]. [19:38:46] Turn 1: Gabbalis [19:38:50] Gabbalis plays [Plains]. [19:38:53] Turn 2: Smokage [19:38:55] Smokage plays [Plains]. [19:38:58] Smokage casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Gabbalis. [19:39:24] Gabbalis discards [Vindicate]. [19:39:24] Gabbalis reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Ultimate Price], [Seal of Cleansing], [Homicidal Seclusion], [Demonic Rising], [Swamp], and [Haunted Plate Mail]. [19:39:34] Turn 2: Gabbalis [19:39:37] Gabbalis plays [Swamp]. [19:39:39] Gabbalis casts [Seal of Cleansing]. [19:39:44] Turn 3: Smokage [19:39:52] Turn 3: Gabbalis [19:39:59] Gabbalis casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Smokage. [19:40:09] Smokage discards [Painful Truths]. [19:40:09] Smokage reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Basilica Bell-Haunt], [Basilica Bell-Haunt], [Diabolic Edict], and [Magister of Worth]. [19:40:12] Turn 4: Smokage [19:40:17] Turn 4: Gabbalis [19:40:25] [CHAT] Gabbalis: lol [19:40:32] [CHAT] Smokage: well this is a fun game [19:40:34] Turn 5: Smokage [19:40:45] Turn 5: Gabbalis [19:40:48] Gabbalis plays [Plains]. [19:40:52] [CHAT] Smokage: a cmon [19:41:01] Turn 6: Smokage [19:41:03] Smokage plays [Plains]. [19:41:11] Smokage casts [Painful Truths] (with 2 colors). [19:41:13] Smokage draws two cards with [Painful Truths]. [19:41:17] Turn 6: Gabbalis [19:41:28] Turn 7: Smokage [19:41:31] Smokage plays [Nomad Outpost]. [19:41:38] [CHAT] Gabbalis: miiiight need a couple more lands myself [19:41:45] [CHAT] Smokage: im on 24, u? [19:41:56] [CHAT] Smokage: was on 25 before but flooded 70% of games lol [19:42:07] [CHAT] Gabbalis: i forget. just transitioned this deck from like... season 2 or something [19:42:10] Turn 7: Gabbalis [19:42:17] [CHAT] Smokage: oh cool [19:42:22] [CHAT] Smokage: im new to pd myself [19:42:34] [CHAT] Gabbalis: nod [19:42:40] [CHAT] Smokage: saw that vindicate was legal and that was all it took for me to start [19:43:16] [CHAT] Gabbalis: its gotten almost cooler as time has passed. though I do miss storm and reanimator metas [19:43:21] Gabbalis discards [Homicidal Seclusion]. [19:43:21] Turn 8: Smokage [19:43:27] Smokage plays [Swamp]. [19:43:30] Smokage casts [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [19:43:32] Smokage puts triggered ability from [Basilica Bell-Haunt] onto the stack (When Basilica Bell-Haunt enters the battlefield, each opponent discards a card and you gain 3 life...). [19:43:41] Gabbalis discards [Homicidal Seclusion]. [19:43:45] [CHAT] Smokage: haha yeah i saw some older games [19:43:48] [CHAT] Smokage: many sick decks [19:43:54] [CHAT] Smokage: channel is pretty busted tho [19:44:01] [CHAT] Smokage: 4x orims chant is a must lol [19:44:14] [CHAT] Gabbalis: yeah. and these smokestack decks... woof [19:44:28] [CHAT] Smokage: the yosei decks? [19:44:30] [CHAT] Gabbalis: they aren't as busted but my midrange strats aren't fareing well [19:44:32] [CHAT] Smokage: or actual smokestack? [19:44:41] [CHAT] Gabbalis: actual smokestacks [19:44:46] [CHAT] Smokage: oh haven't faced it [19:44:54] Turn 8: Gabbalis [19:45:04] Gabbalis plays [Swamp]. [19:45:09] Gabbalis casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Plains]. [19:45:11] [CHAT] Smokage: yeah smokestack sounds annoying [19:45:17] Turn 9: Smokage [19:45:24] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [19:45:33] Smokage plays [Plains]. [19:45:38] Smokage casts [Vindicate] targeting [Underworld Connections]. [19:45:41] Gabbalis activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [19:45:41] [CHAT] Smokage: oops [19:45:45] [CHAT] Smokage: misclicked XD [19:45:47] Gabbalis draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [19:45:56] Turn 9: Gabbalis [19:46:07] [CHAT] Smokage: its more fun if you have the plains tho [19:46:12] Gabbalis plays [Nomad Outpost]. [19:46:15] Gabbalis casts [Haunted Plate Mail]. [19:46:24] Turn 10: Smokage [19:46:34] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [19:46:49] Smokage casts [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [19:46:50] Smokage puts triggered ability from [Basilica Bell-Haunt] onto the stack (When Basilica Bell-Haunt enters the battlefield, each opponent discards a card and you gain 3 life...). [19:46:56] Gabbalis discards [Ultimate Price]. [19:47:01] Turn 10: Gabbalis [19:47:08] Gabbalis casts [Demonic Rising]. [19:47:17] Gabbalis activates an ability of [Haunted Plate Mail] ( Until end of turn, Haunted Plate Mail becomes a 4/4 Spirit artifact creature that's no longer an ...). [19:47:20] Gabbalis puts triggered ability from [Demonic Rising] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you control exactly one creature, create a 5/5 black Demon c...). [19:47:25] Smokage casts [Diabolic Edict] targeting Gabbalis. [19:47:27] Gabbalis sacrifices [Haunted Plate Mail]. [19:47:29] Gabbalis's [Demonic Rising]'s triggered ability does not resolve because the intervening "if" condition is not met. [19:47:31] Turn 11: Smokage [19:47:37] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt] and [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [19:47:43] Smokage plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [19:47:45] Turn 11: Gabbalis [19:47:50] Gabbalis casts [Barter in Blood]. [19:47:54] Smokage sacrifices [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [19:47:54] Smokage sacrifices [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [19:48:00] Turn 12: Smokage [19:48:06] Smokage casts [Gerrard's Verdict] targeting Gabbalis. [19:48:11] Gabbalis discards [Homicidal Seclusion]. [19:48:11] Gabbalis discards [Demonic Rising]. [19:48:13] Smokage plays [Swamp]. [19:48:19] Smokage casts [Magister of Worth]. [19:48:20] Smokage puts triggered ability from [Magister of Worth] onto the stack (When Magister of Worth enters the battlefield, starting with you, each player votes for grace or c...). [19:48:24] Smokage votes for Grace [19:48:26] Gabbalis votes for Condemnation [19:48:32] Turn 12: Gabbalis [19:48:35] Gabbalis plays [Plains]. [19:48:44] Gabbalis casts [Vindicate] targeting [Magister of Worth]. [19:48:59] Gabbalis casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Plains]. [19:49:02] Turn 13: Smokage [19:49:11] Turn 13: Gabbalis [19:49:21] Gabbalis activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [19:49:22] Gabbalis draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [19:49:26] Gabbalis plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [19:49:31] Turn 14: Smokage [19:49:37] Turn 14: Gabbalis [19:49:44] Gabbalis casts [Spirit Mirror]. [19:49:49] Gabbalis plays [Nomad Outpost]. [19:50:00] Turn 15: Smokage [19:50:10] Gabbalis activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [19:50:12] Gabbalis draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [19:50:14] Turn 15: Gabbalis [19:50:14] Gabbalis puts triggered ability from [Spirit Mirror] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if there are no Reflection tokens on the battlefield, create a 2/...). [19:50:22] Smokage casts [Orim's Chant] targeting Gabbalis. [19:50:28] Gabbalis's [Spirit Mirror] creates a Reflection token. [19:50:32] Smokage casts [Malicious Affliction] targeting [Reflection] token. [19:50:38] Gabbalis plays [Spawning Pool]. [19:50:45] Gabbalis activates an ability of [Spawning Pool] ( Spawning Pool becomes a 1/1 black Skeleton creature with '{B}: Regenerate this creature' until en...). [19:50:46] Gabbalis puts triggered ability from [Demonic Rising] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you control exactly one creature, create a 5/5 black Demon c...). [19:50:47] Gabbalis's [Demonic Rising] creates a Demon token. [19:50:48] Turn 16: Smokage [19:50:54] Smokage casts [Gerrard's Verdict] targeting Gabbalis. [19:51:00] Gabbalis discards [Nomad Outpost]. [19:51:07] Turn 16: Gabbalis [19:51:07] Gabbalis puts triggered ability from [Spirit Mirror] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if there are no Reflection tokens on the battlefield, create a 2/...). [19:51:09] Gabbalis's [Spirit Mirror] creates a Reflection token. [19:51:13] Smokage is being attacked by [Demon] token. [19:51:23] Gabbalis activates an ability of [Spirit Mirror] targeting [Reflection] token ( Destroy target Reflection.). [19:51:25] Gabbalis puts triggered ability from [Demonic Rising] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you control exactly one creature, create a 5/5 black Demon c...). [19:51:32] Smokage casts [Go for the Throat] targeting [Demon] token. [19:51:40] Gabbalis activates an ability of [Spawning Pool] ( Spawning Pool becomes a 1/1 black Skeleton creature with '{B}: Regenerate this creature' until en...). [19:51:43] Gabbalis's [Demonic Rising] creates a Demon token. [19:51:44] Turn 17: Smokage [19:51:49] Smokage casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Demon] token. [19:51:54] Smokage casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Demon] token. [19:51:58] Turn 17: Gabbalis [19:51:58] Gabbalis puts triggered ability from [Spirit Mirror] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if there are no Reflection tokens on the battlefield, create a 2/...). [19:52:01] Gabbalis's [Spirit Mirror] creates a Reflection token. [19:52:08] Smokage is being attacked by [Demon] token. [19:52:17] Gabbalis activates an ability of [Spirit Mirror] targeting [Reflection] token ( Destroy target Reflection.). [19:52:19] Gabbalis puts triggered ability from [Demonic Rising] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you control exactly one creature, create a 5/5 black Demon c...). [19:52:22] Gabbalis's [Demonic Rising] creates a Demon token. [19:52:23] Turn 18: Smokage [19:52:51] Smokage casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Demon] token. [19:52:58] Turn 18: Gabbalis [19:52:58] Gabbalis puts triggered ability from [Spirit Mirror] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if there are no Reflection tokens on the battlefield, create a 2/...). [19:53:00] Gabbalis's [Spirit Mirror] creates a Reflection token. [19:53:08] Gabbalis casts [Homicidal Seclusion]. [19:53:11] Smokage has conceded from the game. Winner: Gabbalis Game 1 Completed. [19:53:16] Smokage has left the game. == Game 2 (692931920) == [Time] 1572080051 [19:54:12] PDBot has started watching. [19:54:12] Smokage chooses to play first. [19:54:15] Smokage begins the game with seven cards in hand. [19:54:16] Gabbalis mulligans to six cards. [19:54:28] Gabbalis puts a card on the bottom of their library and begins the game with six cards in hand. [19:54:28] Turn 1: Smokage [19:54:30] Smokage skips their draw step. [19:54:31] Smokage plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [19:54:36] Turn 1: Gabbalis [19:54:39] Gabbalis plays [Nomad Outpost]. [19:54:47] Turn 2: Smokage [19:54:49] Smokage plays [Swamp]. [19:54:52] Smokage casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Gabbalis. [19:55:03] Gabbalis discards [Vindicate]. [19:55:03] Gabbalis reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Haunted Plate Mail], [Swamp], [Vindicate], [Plains], and [Plains]. [19:55:08] Turn 2: Gabbalis [19:55:11] Gabbalis plays [Swamp]. [19:55:15] Turn 3: Smokage [19:55:19] Smokage plays [Nomad Outpost]. [19:55:22] Smokage casts [Gerrard's Verdict] targeting Gabbalis. [19:55:27] Gabbalis discards [Haunted Plate Mail]. [19:55:28] Gabbalis discards [Plains]. [19:55:34] Turn 3: Gabbalis [19:55:38] Gabbalis plays [Swamp]. [19:55:46] Gabbalis casts [Vindicate] targeting [Nomad Outpost]. [19:55:50] Turn 4: Smokage [19:55:55] Smokage plays [Urborg]. [19:55:59] Smokage casts [Gerrard's Verdict] targeting Gabbalis. [19:56:02] Gabbalis discards [Demonic Rising]. [19:56:02] Gabbalis discards [Plains]. [19:56:07] Turn 4: Gabbalis [19:56:10] Gabbalis plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [19:56:15] Turn 5: Smokage [19:56:30] Smokage casts [Painful Truths] (with 2 colors). [19:56:30] Smokage draws two cards with [Painful Truths]. [19:56:32] Smokage plays [Nomad Outpost]. [19:56:36] Turn 5: Gabbalis [19:56:38] Gabbalis plays [Swamp]. [19:56:44] Turn 6: Smokage [19:57:02] Smokage casts [Painful Truths] (with 3 colors). [19:57:02] Smokage draws three cards with [Painful Truths]. [19:57:04] Smokage plays [Plains]. [19:57:06] Turn 6: Gabbalis [19:57:14] Gabbalis casts [Demonic Rising]. [19:57:19] Turn 7: Smokage [19:57:29] Smokage casts [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [19:57:31] Smokage puts triggered ability from [Basilica Bell-Haunt] onto the stack (When Basilica Bell-Haunt enters the battlefield, each opponent discards a card and you gain 3 life...). [19:57:37] Turn 7: Gabbalis [19:57:40] Smokage casts [Orim's Chant] targeting Gabbalis. [19:57:44] Gabbalis plays [Plains]. [19:57:49] Turn 8: Smokage [19:57:52] Smokage plays [Plains]. [19:57:55] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [19:58:02] Smokage casts [Vindicate] targeting [Demonic Rising]. [19:58:06] Turn 8: Gabbalis [19:58:12] Gabbalis casts [Homicidal Seclusion]. [19:58:18] Turn 9: Smokage [19:58:25] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [19:58:31] Turn 9: Gabbalis [19:58:33] Smokage casts [Orim's Chant] targeting Gabbalis. [19:58:43] Turn 10: Smokage [19:58:57] Smokage casts [Painful Truths] (with 3 colors). [19:58:58] Smokage draws three cards with [Painful Truths]. [19:59:10] Smokage plays [Swamp]. [19:59:19] Smokage casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Plains]. [19:59:22] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [19:59:29] Turn 10: Gabbalis [19:59:33] Smokage casts [Orim's Chant] targeting Gabbalis. [19:59:46] Turn 11: Smokage [19:59:49] Smokage activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [19:59:51] Smokage draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [19:59:52] Smokage plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [19:59:56] Smokage casts [Gerrard's Verdict] targeting Gabbalis. [19:59:59] Gabbalis discards [Spirit Mirror]. [19:59:59] Gabbalis discards [Seal of Cleansing]. [20:00:07] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [20:00:13] Turn 11: Gabbalis [20:00:17] Gabbalis casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Smokage. [20:00:22] Smokage discards [Diabolic Edict]. [20:00:22] Smokage reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Swamp], [Plains], and [Lay Bare the Heart]. [20:00:29] Turn 12: Smokage [20:00:33] Smokage activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [20:00:34] Smokage draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [20:00:36] Smokage plays [Swamp]. [20:00:39] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [20:00:44] Turn 12: Gabbalis [20:00:49] Gabbalis casts [Homicidal Seclusion]. [20:00:55] Turn 13: Smokage [20:00:58] Smokage activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [20:00:59] Smokage draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [20:01:01] Smokage plays [Plains]. [20:01:06] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [20:01:13] Turn 13: Gabbalis [20:01:24] Gabbalis casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Swamp]. [20:01:28] Gabbalis activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). [20:01:29] Gabbalis draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. [20:01:30] Gabbalis plays [Nomad Outpost]. [20:01:33] Gabbalis has conceded from the game. Winner: Smokage Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (692932432) == [Time] 1572080542 [20:02:22] PDBot has started watching. [20:02:25] Gabbalis chooses to play first. [20:02:28] Gabbalis begins the game with seven cards in hand. [20:02:32] Smokage begins the game with seven cards in hand. [20:02:32] Turn 1: Gabbalis [20:02:34] Gabbalis skips their draw step. [20:02:34] Gabbalis plays [Nomad Outpost]. [20:02:40] Turn 1: Smokage [20:02:42] Smokage plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [20:02:47] Turn 2: Gabbalis [20:02:51] Gabbalis plays [Spawning Pool]. [20:02:55] Turn 2: Smokage [20:02:58] Smokage plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [20:03:01] Turn 3: Gabbalis [20:03:04] Gabbalis plays [Plains]. [20:03:13] Turn 3: Smokage [20:03:15] Smokage plays [Swamp]. [20:03:23] Smokage casts [Vindicate] targeting [Nomad Outpost]. [20:03:33] Turn 4: Gabbalis [20:03:37] Gabbalis plays [Plains]. [20:03:41] Turn 4: Smokage [20:03:43] Smokage plays [Swamp]. [20:03:48] Smokage casts [Vindicate] targeting [Spawning Pool]. [20:03:53] Turn 5: Gabbalis [20:03:58] Gabbalis plays [Swamp]. [20:04:02] Turn 5: Smokage [20:04:06] Smokage plays [Plains]. [20:04:12] Smokage casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Plains]. [20:04:15] Smokage activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [20:04:16] Smokage draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [20:04:22] Turn 6: Gabbalis [20:04:25] Smokage casts [Orim's Chant] targeting Gabbalis. [20:04:31] Gabbalis plays [Plains]. [20:04:36] Turn 6: Smokage [20:04:40] Smokage activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [20:04:41] Smokage draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [20:04:46] Smokage casts [Vindicate] targeting [Swamp]. [20:04:52] Turn 7: Gabbalis [20:05:00] Turn 7: Smokage [20:05:02] Smokage activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [20:05:03] Smokage draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [20:05:04] Smokage plays [Nomad Outpost]. [20:05:08] Smokage casts [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [20:05:09] Smokage puts triggered ability from [Basilica Bell-Haunt] onto the stack (When Basilica Bell-Haunt enters the battlefield, each opponent discards a card and you gain 3 life...). [20:05:13] Gabbalis discards [Homicidal Seclusion]. [20:05:17] Turn 8: Gabbalis [20:05:28] Gabbalis plays [Nomad Outpost]. [20:05:33] Turn 8: Smokage [20:05:36] Smokage activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [20:05:37] Smokage draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [20:05:42] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [20:05:49] Smokage plays [Nomad Outpost]. [20:05:53] Smokage casts [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [20:05:54] Smokage puts triggered ability from [Basilica Bell-Haunt] onto the stack (When Basilica Bell-Haunt enters the battlefield, each opponent discards a card and you gain 3 life...). [20:06:00] Gabbalis discards [Demonic Rising]. [20:06:01] Turn 9: Gabbalis [20:06:12] Gabbalis casts [Memoricide] targeting Smokage. [20:06:25] Gabbalis names Orim's Chant for [Memoricide]. [20:06:47] [CHAT] Gabbalis: worth.... it.... [20:07:03] Turn 9: Smokage [20:07:12] [CHAT] Smokage: It's a pretty toxic card lol [20:07:14] Smokage activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [20:07:16] Smokage draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [20:07:20] Smokage casts [Gerrard's Verdict] targeting Gabbalis. [20:07:27] Gabbalis discards [Demonic Rising]. [20:07:27] Gabbalis discards [Underworld Connections]. [20:07:31] Smokage casts [Gerrard's Verdict] targeting Gabbalis. [20:07:34] Gabbalis discards [Homicidal Seclusion]. [20:07:34] Gabbalis discards [Demonic Rising]. [20:07:38] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt] and [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [20:07:42] Turn 10: Gabbalis [20:07:46] Gabbalis plays [Nomad Outpost]. [20:07:50] Gabbalis casts [Haunted Plate Mail]. [20:07:56] Turn 10: Smokage [20:07:59] Smokage activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [20:08:00] Smokage draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [20:08:04] Gabbalis is being attacked by [Basilica Bell-Haunt] and [Basilica Bell-Haunt]. [20:08:06] Gabbalis activates an ability of [Haunted Plate Mail] ( Until end of turn, Haunted Plate Mail becomes a 4/4 Spirit artifact creature that's no longer an ...). [20:08:16] Smokage casts [Malicious Affliction] targeting [Haunted Plate Mail]. [20:08:33] Smokage casts [Vindicate] targeting [Nomad Outpost]. [20:08:37] Turn 11: Gabbalis [20:08:45] Gabbalis has conceded from the game. Winner: Smokage Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: Smokage: 2–1 [20:08:48] Smokage draws their next card. [20:08:49] Gabbalis has left the game.