PennyDreadful
PD APAC r2 vs.  cotton2431
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
spe3,cotton2431

== Game 1 (679582516) ==
[Time] 1561881643
[18:00:43] PDBot has started watching.
[18:00:52] cotton2431 chooses to play first.
[18:00:52] [CHAT] spe3: gl hf!
[18:00:57] cotton2431 keeps this hand.
[18:00:59] spe3 keeps this hand.
[18:00:59] Turn 1: cotton2431
[18:00:59] cotton2431 skips their draw step.
[18:01:02] cotton2431 plays [Dismal Backwater].
[18:01:03] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:01:06] Turn 1: spe3
[18:01:08] spe3 plays [Vivid Marsh].
[18:01:11] Turn 2: cotton2431
[18:01:13] cotton2431 plays [Grand Coliseum].
[18:01:19] Turn 2: spe3
[18:01:21] spe3 plays [Dismal Backwater].
[18:01:21] spe3 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:01:28] Turn 3: cotton2431
[18:01:30] cotton2431 plays [Swamp].
[18:01:34] Turn 3: spe3
[18:01:36] spe3 plays [Calciform Pools].
[18:01:43] cotton2431 casts [Think Twice].
[18:01:44] cotton2431 draws a card with [Think Twice].
[18:01:47] Turn 4: cotton2431
[18:01:50] cotton2431 plays [Dismal Backwater].
[18:01:50] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:01:57] spe3 activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[18:01:59] Turn 4: spe3
[18:02:00] spe3 plays [Temple of Silence].
[18:02:00] spe3 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
[18:02:04] spe3 puts 1 card on top of their library.
[18:02:11] cotton2431 casts [Think Twice] from the graveyard.
[18:02:13] cotton2431 draws a card with [Think Twice].
[18:02:14] Turn 5: cotton2431
[18:02:18] cotton2431 plays [Evolving Wilds].
[18:02:26] spe3 activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[18:02:44] Turn 5: spe3
[18:03:07] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[18:03:16] spe3 discards [Descend upon the Sinful].
[18:03:16] Turn 6: cotton2431
[18:03:20] cotton2431 plays [Island].
[18:03:26] spe3 activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[18:03:28] Turn 6: spe3
[18:03:35] spe3 discards [Magister of Worth].
[18:03:35] Turn 7: cotton2431
[18:03:40] cotton2431 plays [Urza's Factory].
[18:03:46] spe3 activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[18:03:49] Turn 7: spe3
[18:04:10] spe3 casts [Vindicate] targeting [Urza's Factory].
[18:04:25] cotton2431 casts [Dismiss] targeting [Vindicate].
[18:04:29] cotton2431 draws a card with [Dismiss].
[18:04:36] spe3 casts [Vindicate] targeting [Grand Coliseum].
[18:04:46] spe3 has conceded from the game.
Winner: cotton2431
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (679582858) ==
[Time] 1561882039
[18:07:19] PDBot has started watching.
[18:07:26] spe3 chooses to play first.
[18:07:29] spe3 keeps this hand.
[18:07:31] cotton2431 keeps this hand.
[18:07:31] Turn 1: spe3
[18:07:31] spe3 skips their draw step.
[18:07:32] spe3 plays [Dismal Backwater].
[18:07:32] spe3 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:07:39] Turn 1: cotton2431
[18:07:46] cotton2431 plays [Dismal Backwater].
[18:07:46] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:07:51] Turn 2: spe3
[18:07:53] spe3 plays [Plains].
[18:07:59] Turn 2: cotton2431
[18:08:09] cotton2431 plays [Dreadship Reef].
[18:08:17] Turn 3: spe3
[18:08:18] spe3 plays [Dismal Backwater].
[18:08:18] spe3 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:08:26] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[18:08:28] Turn 3: cotton2431
[18:08:33] cotton2431 plays [Grand Coliseum].
[18:08:40] Turn 4: spe3
[18:08:42] spe3 plays [Vivid Marsh].
[18:08:47] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[18:08:49] Turn 4: cotton2431
[18:08:57] cotton2431 plays [Evolving Wilds].
[18:09:04] Turn 5: spe3
[18:09:06] spe3 plays [Island].
[18:09:10] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[18:09:23] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[18:09:26] Turn 5: cotton2431
[18:09:28] cotton2431 plays [Evolving Wilds].
[18:09:39] spe3 discards [Decree of Justice].
[18:09:39] spe3 cycles [Decree of Justice].
[18:09:39] spe3 puts triggered ability from [Decree of Justice] onto the stack (When you cycle Decree of Justice, you may pay {X}. If you do, create X 1/1 white Soldier creature ...).
[18:09:50] spe3's [Decree of Justice] creates two Soldier tokens.
[18:09:54] Turn 6: spe3
[18:09:58] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Soldier] token and [Soldier] token.
[18:10:05] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[18:10:08] j_meka has started watching.
[18:10:23] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[18:10:27] Turn 6: cotton2431
[18:10:40] cotton2431 plays [Island].
[18:11:02] cotton2431 casts [Thaumatic Compass].
[18:11:17] Turn 7: spe3
[18:11:19] spe3 plays [Urza's Factory].
[18:11:23] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Soldier] token and [Soldier] token.
[18:11:32] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Thaumatic Compass] ( Search your library for a basic land card, reveal it, put it into your hand, then shuffle your li...).
[18:11:38] cotton2431 reveals [Swamp].
[18:11:41] Turn 7: cotton2431
[18:11:46] cotton2431 plays [Swamp].
[18:12:00] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Thaumatic Compass] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you control seven or more lands, transform Thaumatic Compass...).
[18:12:06] spe3 discards [Decree of Justice].
[18:12:06] spe3 cycles [Decree of Justice].
[18:12:06] spe3 puts triggered ability from [Decree of Justice] onto the stack (When you cycle Decree of Justice, you may pay {X}. If you do, create X 1/1 white Soldier creature ...).
[18:12:15] spe3's [Decree of Justice] creates three Soldier tokens.
[18:12:27] Turn 8: spe3
[18:12:29] spe3 plays [Temple of Silence].
[18:12:29] spe3 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
[18:12:34] spe3 puts 1 card on top of their library.
[18:12:43] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, and [Soldier] token.
[18:13:07] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Spires of Orazca] targeting [Soldier] token ( Untap target attacking creature an opponent controls and remove it from combat.).
[18:13:18] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[18:13:21] Turn 8: cotton2431
[18:14:16] cotton2431 casts [Lost Legacy] targeting spe3.
[18:14:21] spe3 casts [Lazotep Plating].
[18:14:30] spe3's [Lazotep Plating] creates a Zombie Army token.
[18:14:35] cotton2431's [Lost Legacy] is removed from the stack because it has no legal targets.
[18:15:41] cotton2431 casts [Magister of Worth].
[18:16:01] spe3 casts [Overwhelming Denial] for its surge cost targeting [Magister of Worth].
[18:16:11] cotton2431 casts [Think Twice].
[18:16:14] cotton2431 draws a card with [Think Twice].
[18:16:16] cotton2431 plays [Urza's Factory].
[18:16:20] Turn 9: spe3
[18:16:25] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Zombie Army] token, [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, and [Soldier] token.
[18:16:30] Turn 9: cotton2431
[18:16:33] cotton2431 plays [Temple of Silence].
[18:16:33] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Temple of Silence] onto the stack (When Temple of Silence enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
[18:16:42] cotton2431 puts 1 card on top of their library.
[18:16:52] spe3 casts [Forbidden Alchemy].
[18:16:59] spe3 puts [Descend upon the Sinful], [Faerie Trickery], and [Tranquil Cove] into their graveyard.
[18:17:12] wizzardofoz has started watching.
[18:17:14] spe3 casts [Forbidden Alchemy].
[18:17:20] spe3 puts [Vindicate], [Vivid Creek], and [Power Sink] into their graveyard.
[18:17:22] Turn 10: spe3
[18:17:24] spe3 plays [Tectonic Edge].
[18:17:31] spe3 activates an ability of [Tectonic Edge] targeting [Urza's Factory] ( Destroy target nonbasic land.).
[18:17:45] cotton2431 discards [Decree of Justice].
[18:17:45] cotton2431 cycles [Decree of Justice].
[18:17:45] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Decree of Justice] onto the stack (When you cycle Decree of Justice, you may pay {X}. If you do, create X 1/1 white Soldier creature ...).
[18:18:02] cotton2431's [Decree of Justice] creates six Soldier tokens.
[18:18:17] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Zombie Army] token, [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, and [Soldier] token.
[18:18:22] [Soldier] token blocks [Soldier] token.
[18:18:27] [Soldier] token blocks [Soldier] token.
[18:18:29] [Soldier] token blocks [Soldier] token.
[18:18:31] [Soldier] token blocks [Soldier] token.
[18:18:33] [Soldier] token blocks [Soldier] token.
[18:18:35] [Soldier] token blocks [Zombie Army] token.
[18:18:51] Turn 10: cotton2431
[18:19:13] cotton2431 casts [Vindicate] targeting [Urza's Factory].
[18:19:19] spe3 casts [Faerie Trickery] targeting [Vindicate].
[18:20:34] cotton2431 casts [Perplex] targeting [Faerie Trickery].
[18:20:48] spe3 casts [Faerie Trickery] targeting [Vindicate].
[18:20:54] cotton2431 plays [Urza's Factory].
[18:21:09] Turn 11: spe3
[18:21:36] spe3 casts [Dig Through Time].
[18:21:55] cotton2431 casts [Dismiss] targeting [Dig Through Time].
[18:22:11] spe3 casts [Power Sink] targeting [Dismiss]. (X is 1).
[18:22:25] spe3 put a card on the bottom of the library.
[18:22:25] spe3 put a card on the bottom of the library.
[18:22:32] spe3 casts [Vindicate] targeting [Urza's Factory].
[18:22:34] spe3 plays [Tranquil Cove].
[18:22:34] spe3 puts triggered ability from [Tranquil Cove] onto the stack (When Tranquil Cove enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:22:40] Turn 11: cotton2431
[18:22:52] cotton2431 casts [Dig Through Time].
[18:24:05] cotton2431 casts [Vindicate] targeting [Urza's Factory].
[18:24:28] cotton2431 casts [Mind Shatter] targeting spe3. (X is 2).
[18:24:31] spe3 discards [Island].
[18:24:31] spe3 discards [Consecrate/Consume].
[18:24:38] Turn 12: spe3
[18:24:40] spe3 plays [Tectonic Edge].
[18:24:44] Turn 12: cotton2431
[18:24:55] cotton2431 casts [Forbidden Alchemy].
[18:25:01] cotton2431 puts [Swamp], [Lost Legacy], and [Thaumatic Compass] into their graveyard.
[18:25:16] spe3 casts [Forbidden Alchemy] from the graveyard.
[18:25:34] spe3 puts [Go for the Throat], [Temple of Silence], and [Swamp] into their graveyard.
[18:25:36] Turn 13: spe3
[18:25:37] spe3 plays [Calciform Pools].
[18:26:14] cotton2431 casts [Think Twice] from the graveyard.
[18:26:18] cotton2431 draws a card with [Think Twice].
[18:26:22] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[18:26:26] Turn 13: cotton2431
[18:26:29] cotton2431 plays [Island].
[18:26:35] Crandar has started watching.
[18:26:42] spe3 casts [Forbidden Alchemy] from the graveyard.
[18:26:45] [CHAT] Crandar: !record
[18:26:46] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  cotton2431 1-0 spe3
[18:26:47] spe3 puts [Vindicate], [Lazotep Plating], and [Summary Dismissal] into their graveyard.
[18:26:52] spe3 activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[18:26:55] Turn 14: spe3
[18:26:58] spe3 plays [Dismal Backwater].
[18:26:58] spe3 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:27:13] cotton2431 casts [Dig Through Time].
[18:27:38] spe3 casts [Dig Through Time].
[18:28:08] cotton2431 casts [Dissolve] targeting [Dig Through Time].
[18:28:12] cotton2431 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[18:28:35] Turn 14: cotton2431
[18:29:07] cotton2431 casts [Mind Shatter] targeting spe3. (X is 2).
[18:29:10] spe3 discards [Vivid Meadow].
[18:29:10] spe3 discards [Elixir of Immortality].
[18:29:32] spe3 activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[18:29:34] Turn 15: spe3
[18:29:46] spe3 casts [Magister of Worth].
[18:29:54] spe3 puts triggered ability from [Magister of Worth] onto the stack (When Magister of Worth enters the battlefield, starting with you, each player votes for grace or c...).
[18:29:59] spe3 votes for Condemnation
[18:30:01] cotton2431 votes for Condemnation
[18:30:07] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[18:30:10] Turn 15: cotton2431
[18:30:24] cotton2431 casts [Aetherling].
[18:30:33] spe3 activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[18:30:35] Turn 16: spe3
[18:30:37] spe3 plays [Calciform Pools].
[18:30:42] spe3 activates an ability of [Tectonic Edge] targeting [Spires of Orazca] ( Destroy target nonbasic land.).
[18:30:48] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[18:30:55] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Magister of Worth].
[18:31:06] Turn 16: cotton2431
[18:31:23] spe3 is being attacked by [Aetherling].
[18:31:31] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Aetherling] ( Exile Aetherling. Return it to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the ...).
[18:31:41] cotton2431 casts [Magister of Worth].
[18:31:44] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Magister of Worth] onto the stack (When Magister of Worth enters the battlefield, starting with you, each player votes for grace or c...).
[18:31:48] cotton2431 votes for Condemnation
[18:31:49] spe3 votes for Grace
[18:31:51] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Aetherling] onto the stack (Return Aetherling to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end st...).
[18:31:55] spe3 activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[18:32:00] spe3 activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[18:32:02] Turn 17: spe3
[18:32:10] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[18:32:13] Turn 17: cotton2431
[18:32:23] spe3 is being attacked by [Aetherling] and [Magister of Worth].
[18:32:39] cotton2431 casts [Vindicate] targeting [Calciform Pools].
[18:32:45] cotton2431 plays [Dismal Backwater].
[18:32:45] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Dismal Backwater] onto the stack (When Dismal Backwater enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:32:52] spe3 casts [Lazotep Plating].
[18:33:04] spe3's [Lazotep Plating] creates a Zombie Army token.
[18:33:06] Turn 18: spe3
[18:33:10] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Zombie Army] token.
[18:33:16] spe3 plays [Urza's Factory].
[18:33:20] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[18:33:23] Turn 18: cotton2431
[18:33:28] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Aetherling] ( Aetherling can't be blocked this turn.).
[18:33:35] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Aetherling] ( Aetherling gets +1/-1 until end of turn.).
[18:33:39] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Aetherling] ( Aetherling gets +1/-1 until end of turn.).
[18:33:45] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Aetherling] ( Aetherling gets +1/-1 until end of turn.).
[18:33:54] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Aetherling] ( Aetherling gets +1/-1 until end of turn.).
[18:34:02] [CHAT] spe3: gg
[18:34:04] spe3 has conceded from the game.
Winner: cotton2431
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: cotton2431: 2–0