PennyDreadful
PDM vs Nydethess
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
Nydethess,Byvci

== Game 1 (674314828) ==
[Time] 1558403415
[11:50:15] PDBot has started watching.
[11:50:15] Nydethess joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Mondays 12.03
[Gatherling] Round=5
[11:51:14] Nydethess chooses to play first.
[11:51:20] Nydethess mulligans to 6 cards.
[11:51:22] Byvci keeps this hand.
[11:51:24] Nydethess keeps this hand.
[11:51:27] Nydethess puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[11:51:27] Turn 1: Nydethess
[11:51:27] Nydethess skips their draw step.
[11:51:28] Nydethess plays [Island].
[11:51:29] Nydethess casts [Mist-Cloaked Herald].
[11:51:33] Turn 1: Byvci
[11:51:36] Byvci plays [Mountain].
[11:51:41] Byvci casts [Stromkirk Noble].
[11:51:43] Turn 2: Nydethess
[11:51:47] Nydethess plays [Island].
[11:51:51] Nydethess reveals [Triton Shorestalker] with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability.
[11:51:51] Nydethess casts [Silvergill Adept] (revealing [Triton Shorestalker]).
[11:51:52] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Silvergill Adept] onto the stack (When Silvergill Adept enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
[11:51:55] Nydethess draws a card with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability.
[11:52:08] Turn 2: Byvci
[11:52:18] Nydethess is being attacked by [Stromkirk Noble].
[11:52:22] [Silvergill Adept] blocks [Stromkirk Noble].
[11:52:29] Byvci plays [Mountain].
[11:52:32] Byvci casts [Falkenrath Gorger].
[11:52:34] Byvci casts [Falkenrath Gorger].
[11:52:38] Turn 3: Nydethess
[11:52:40] Nydethess plays [Island].
[11:52:43] Nydethess casts [Curiosity] targeting [Mist-Cloaked Herald].
[11:52:45] Byvci is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald].
[11:52:49] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Curiosity] onto the stack (Whenever enchanted creature deals damage to an opponent, you may draw a card.).
[11:52:52] Nydethess draws a card with [Curiosity]'s ability.
[11:53:12] Turn 3: Byvci
[11:53:21] Nydethess is being attacked by [Falkenrath Gorger] and [Falkenrath Gorger].
[11:53:36] Byvci casts [Bonded Construct].
[11:53:36] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Bonded Construct[sU] has an unclassified bug.
Under rare circumstances, a player who controls two creatures that can't attack alone (such as Bonded Construct) but must attack with one of them will be able to attack with only that creature rather than being required to attack with both.
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Bonded Construct` or `!notbugged Bonded Construct`
[11:53:42] Byvci casts [Jackal Familiar].
[11:54:01] Nydethess casts [Disperse] targeting [Jackal Familiar].
[11:54:03] Nydethess returns [Jackal Familiar] to its owner's hand with [Disperse].
[11:54:05] Turn 4: Nydethess
[11:54:07] Nydethess plays [Island].
[11:54:12] Nydethess casts [Seafloor Oracle].
[11:54:17] Byvci is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald].
[11:54:24] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Curiosity] onto the stack (Whenever enchanted creature deals damage to an opponent, you may draw a card.).
[11:54:24] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Seafloor Oracle] onto the stack (Whenever a Merfolk you control deals combat damage to a player, draw a card.).
[11:54:26] Nydethess draws a card with [Seafloor Oracle]'s ability.
[11:54:26] Nydethess draws a card with [Curiosity]'s ability.
[11:54:30] Turn 4: Byvci
[11:54:42] Byvci plays [Mountain].
[11:54:47] Byvci casts [Village Messenger].
[11:55:00] Nydethess is being attacked by [Village Messenger], [Bonded Construct], [Falkenrath Gorger], and [Falkenrath Gorger].
[11:55:13] [Seafloor Oracle] blocks [Falkenrath Gorger].
[11:55:19] Byvci casts [Jackal Familiar].
[11:55:22] Byvci casts [Stromkirk Noble].
[11:55:25] Turn 5: Nydethess
[11:55:27] Nydethess plays [Island].
[11:55:40] Byvci is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald].
[11:55:46] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Curiosity] onto the stack (Whenever enchanted creature deals damage to an opponent, you may draw a card.).
[11:55:46] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Seafloor Oracle] onto the stack (Whenever a Merfolk you control deals combat damage to a player, draw a card.).
[11:55:46] Nydethess draws a card with [Seafloor Oracle]'s ability.
[11:55:46] Nydethess draws a card with [Curiosity]'s ability.
[11:55:50] Nydethess casts [Deeproot Waters].
[11:55:55] Nydethess casts [Coralhelm Commander].
[11:55:55] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Waters] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, create a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token with hexproof.).
[11:55:58] Nydethess's [Deeproot Waters] creates a Merfolk token.
[11:56:01] Turn 5: Byvci
[11:56:05] Byvci casts [Song of Blood].
[11:56:18] Nydethess is being attacked by [Stromkirk Noble], [Jackal Familiar], [Village Messenger], [Bonded Construct], and [Falkenrath Gorger].
[11:56:18] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Song of Blood] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks this turn, it gets +1/+0 for each creature card put into your graveyar...).
[11:56:18] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Song of Blood] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks this turn, it gets +1/+0 for each creature card put into your graveyar...).
[11:56:18] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Song of Blood] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks this turn, it gets +1/+0 for each creature card put into your graveyar...).
[11:56:18] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Song of Blood] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks this turn, it gets +1/+0 for each creature card put into your graveyar...).
[11:56:18] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Song of Blood] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks this turn, it gets +1/+0 for each creature card put into your graveyar...).
[11:56:36] [Merfolk] token blocks [Falkenrath Gorger].
[11:56:39] [Seafloor Oracle] blocks [Bonded Construct].
[11:56:41] [Coralhelm Commander] blocks [Jackal Familiar].
[11:56:45] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Stromkirk Noble] onto the stack (Whenever Stromkirk Noble deals combat damage to a player, put a +1/+1 counter on it.).
[11:56:52] Byvci casts [Rakdos Cackler].
[11:56:57] Turn 6: Nydethess
[11:57:00] Nydethess plays [Island].
[11:57:09] Byvci is being attacked by [Mist-Cloaked Herald].
[11:57:12] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Curiosity] onto the stack (Whenever enchanted creature deals damage to an opponent, you may draw a card.).
[11:57:15] Nydethess draws a card with [Curiosity]'s ability.
[11:57:18] Nydethess casts [Coralhelm Commander].
[11:57:18] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Waters] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, create a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token with hexproof.).
[11:57:20] Nydethess's [Deeproot Waters] creates a Merfolk token.
[11:57:38] Nydethess casts [Coralhelm Commander].
[11:57:38] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Waters] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, create a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token with hexproof.).
[11:57:39] Nydethess's [Deeproot Waters] creates a Merfolk token.
[11:57:47] Turn 6: Byvci
[11:57:56] Byvci casts [Village Messenger].
[11:58:04] Turn 7: Nydethess
[11:58:06] Nydethess plays [Island].
[11:58:12] Nydethess casts [Triton Shorestalker].
[11:58:12] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Waters] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, create a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token with hexproof.).
[11:58:14] Nydethess's [Deeproot Waters] creates a Merfolk token.
[11:58:31] Nydethess activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up).
[11:58:35] Nydethess activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up).
[11:58:47] Byvci is being attacked by [Coralhelm Commander] and [Mist-Cloaked Herald].
[11:58:52] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Curiosity] onto the stack (Whenever enchanted creature deals damage to an opponent, you may draw a card.).
[11:58:53] Nydethess draws a card with [Curiosity]'s ability.
[11:58:59] Nydethess activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up).
[11:59:02] Nydethess activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up).
[11:59:06] Turn 7: Byvci
[11:59:49] Byvci casts [Jackal Familiar].
[12:00:03] Turn 8: Nydethess
[12:00:05] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:00:08] Nydethess activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up).
[12:00:11] Nydethess activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up).
[12:00:16] Nydethess activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up).
[12:00:18] Nydethess activates an ability of [Coralhelm Commander] (Level up).
[12:00:27] Byvci is being attacked by [Coralhelm Commander], [Coralhelm Commander], and [Mist-Cloaked Herald].
[12:00:32] Byvci has conceded from the game.
Winner: Nydethess
Game 1 Completed.
[12:00:35] Byvci has left the game.

== Game 2 (674316230) ==
[Time] 1558404083
[12:01:23] PDBot has started watching.
[12:01:27] Byvci chooses to play first.
[12:01:43] Byvci keeps this hand.
[12:01:45] Nydethess mulligans to 6 cards.
[12:01:47] Nydethess keeps this hand.
[12:01:49] Nydethess puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[12:01:49] Turn 1: Byvci
[12:01:52] Byvci skips their draw step.
[12:01:53] Byvci plays [Mountain].
[12:01:54] Byvci casts [Village Messenger].
[12:01:57] Nydethess is being attacked by [Village Messenger].
[12:01:58] Turn 1: Nydethess
[12:01:59] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:02:01] Nydethess casts [Mist-Cloaked Herald].
[12:02:05] Turn 2: Byvci
[12:02:09] Byvci casts [Forge Devil].
[12:02:11] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Forge Devil] onto the stack targeting [Mist-Cloaked Herald] (When Forge Devil enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target creature and 1 damage to you.).
[12:02:18] Nydethess is being attacked by [Village Messenger].
[12:02:25] Turn 2: Nydethess
[12:02:26] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:02:31] Nydethess casts [River Sneak].
[12:02:36] Turn 3: Byvci
[12:02:42] Nydethess is being attacked by [Forge Devil] and [Village Messenger].
[12:02:49] Byvci casts [Rigging Runner].
[12:02:52] Turn 3: Nydethess
[12:02:54] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:02:55] Nydethess casts [River Sneak].
[12:02:56] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [River Sneak] onto the stack (Whenever another Merfolk enters the battlefield under your control, River Sneak gets +1/+1 until e...).
[12:03:02] Nydethess casts [Triton Shorestalker].
[12:03:02] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [River Sneak] onto the stack (Whenever another Merfolk enters the battlefield under your control, River Sneak gets +1/+1 until e...).
[12:03:02] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [River Sneak] onto the stack (Whenever another Merfolk enters the battlefield under your control, River Sneak gets +1/+1 until e...).
[12:03:07] Byvci is being attacked by [River Sneak].
[12:03:11] Turn 4: Byvci
[12:03:19] Nydethess is being attacked by [Rigging Runner], [Forge Devil], and [Village Messenger].
[12:03:25] [Triton Shorestalker] blocks [Village Messenger].
[12:03:35] Byvci casts [Jackal Familiar].
[12:03:38] Turn 4: Nydethess
[12:03:40] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:03:44] Byvci is being attacked by [River Sneak] and [River Sneak].
[12:03:50] Turn 5: Byvci
[12:04:04] Nydethess is being attacked by [Jackal Familiar] and [Forge Devil].
[12:04:11] Byvci casts [Jackal Familiar].
[12:04:15] Nydethess returns [River Sneak] to its owner's hand with with [Familiar's Ruse]'s ability.
[12:04:15] Nydethess casts [Familiar's Ruse] targeting [Jackal Familiar].
[12:04:18] Turn 5: Nydethess
[12:04:21] Nydethess casts [River Sneak].
[12:04:36] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [River Sneak] onto the stack (Whenever another Merfolk enters the battlefield under your control, River Sneak gets +1/+1 until e...).
[12:04:39] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:04:41] Byvci is being attacked by [River Sneak].
[12:04:49] Turn 6: Byvci
[12:04:56] Nydethess is being attacked by [Jackal Familiar], [Rigging Runner], and [Forge Devil].
[12:04:59] [River Sneak] blocks [Forge Devil].
[12:05:02] [River Sneak] stops blocking.
[12:05:12] Byvci casts [Falkenrath Gorger].
[12:05:16] Turn 6: Nydethess
[12:05:19] Nydethess casts [Mist-Cloaked Herald].
[12:05:20] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [River Sneak] onto the stack (Whenever another Merfolk enters the battlefield under your control, River Sneak gets +1/+1 until e...).
[12:05:20] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [River Sneak] onto the stack (Whenever another Merfolk enters the battlefield under your control, River Sneak gets +1/+1 until e...).
[12:05:31] Byvci is being attacked by [River Sneak].
[12:05:38] Turn 7: Byvci
[12:05:57] Nydethess is being attacked by [Jackal Familiar], [Rigging Runner], and [Forge Devil].
[12:06:00] [Mist-Cloaked Herald] blocks [Forge Devil].
[12:06:10] Byvci casts [Rigging Runner].
[12:06:14] Turn 7: Nydethess
[12:06:25] Nydethess casts [Triton Shorestalker].
[12:06:27] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [River Sneak] onto the stack (Whenever another Merfolk enters the battlefield under your control, River Sneak gets +1/+1 until e...).
[12:06:27] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [River Sneak] onto the stack (Whenever another Merfolk enters the battlefield under your control, River Sneak gets +1/+1 until e...).
[12:06:32] Turn 8: Byvci
[12:07:07] Nydethess is being attacked by [Rigging Runner] and [Jackal Familiar].
[12:07:11] [Triton Shorestalker] blocks [Rigging Runner].
[12:07:12] [River Sneak] blocks [Jackal Familiar].
[12:07:26] Byvci casts [Akki Avalanchers].
[12:07:30] Nydethess has conceded from the game.
Winner: Byvci
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (674317092) ==
[Time] 1558404484
[12:08:04] PDBot has started watching.
[12:08:07] Nydethess chooses to play first.
[12:08:13] Nydethess keeps this hand.
[12:08:14] Byvci keeps this hand.
[12:08:14] Turn 1: Nydethess
[12:08:15] Nydethess skips their draw step.
[12:08:16] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:08:17] Nydethess casts [Triton Shorestalker].
[12:08:21] Turn 1: Byvci
[12:08:23] Byvci plays [Mountain].
[12:08:24] Byvci casts [Rakdos Cackler].
[12:08:32] Turn 2: Nydethess
[12:08:33] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:08:36] Nydethess casts [Coralhelm Commander].
[12:08:40] Byvci is being attacked by [Triton Shorestalker].
[12:08:47] Turn 2: Byvci
[12:08:49] Byvci plays [Mountain].
[12:08:52] Byvci casts [Arc Trail] targeting [Coralhelm Commander] (Choose target creature, planeswalker, or player to deal 2 to), and [Triton Shorestalker] (Choose target creature, planeswalker, or player to deal 1 to).
[12:08:56] Nydethess is being attacked by [Rakdos Cackler].
[12:09:00] Turn 3: Nydethess
[12:09:01] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:09:03] Nydethess casts [Deeproot Waters].
[12:09:07] Turn 3: Byvci
[12:09:11] Nydethess is being attacked by [Rakdos Cackler].
[12:09:16] Byvci plays [Mountain].
[12:09:17] Byvci casts [Rigging Runner].
[12:09:20] Byvci casts [Firedrinker Satyr].
[12:09:21] Byvci casts [Jackal Familiar].
[12:09:24] Turn 4: Nydethess
[12:09:26] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:09:28] Nydethess casts [Merfolk Sovereign].
[12:09:28] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Waters] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, create a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token with hexproof.).
[12:09:31] Nydethess's [Deeproot Waters] creates a Merfolk token.
[12:09:35] Nydethess casts [Mist-Cloaked Herald].
[12:09:36] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Waters] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, create a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token with hexproof.).
[12:09:37] Nydethess's [Deeproot Waters] creates a Merfolk token.
[12:09:42] Turn 4: Byvci
[12:09:46] Byvci plays [Mountain].
[12:09:51] Byvci casts [Song of Blood].
[12:09:59] Byvci casts [Arc Trail] targeting [Merfolk Sovereign] (Choose target creature, planeswalker, or player to deal 2 to), and [Mist-Cloaked Herald] (Choose target creature, planeswalker, or player to deal 1 to).
[12:10:08] Nydethess is being attacked by [Jackal Familiar], [Firedrinker Satyr], [Rigging Runner], and [Rakdos Cackler].
[12:10:08] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Song of Blood] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks this turn, it gets +1/+0 for each creature card put into your graveyar...).
[12:10:08] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Song of Blood] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks this turn, it gets +1/+0 for each creature card put into your graveyar...).
[12:10:08] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Song of Blood] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks this turn, it gets +1/+0 for each creature card put into your graveyar...).
[12:10:08] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Song of Blood] onto the stack (Whenever a creature attacks this turn, it gets +1/+0 for each creature card put into your graveyar...).
[12:10:22] [Merfolk] token blocks [Firedrinker Satyr].
[12:10:29] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Firedrinker Satyr] onto the stack (Whenever Firedrinker Satyr is dealt damage, it deals that much damage to you.).
[12:10:35] Turn 5: Nydethess
[12:10:40] Nydethess casts [Merfolk Sovereign].
[12:10:40] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Waters] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, create a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token with hexproof.).
[12:10:42] Nydethess's [Deeproot Waters] creates a Merfolk token.
[12:10:45] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:10:48] Turn 5: Byvci
[12:10:55] Nydethess is being attacked by [Jackal Familiar], [Rigging Runner], and [Rakdos Cackler].
[12:10:59] [Merfolk] token blocks [Rakdos Cackler].
[12:11:01] [Merfolk] token blocks [Jackal Familiar].
[12:11:08] Byvci casts [Village Messenger].
[12:11:13] Turn 6: Nydethess
[12:11:18] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:11:23] Turn 6: Byvci
[12:11:23] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Village Messenger] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Village Messenger.).
[12:11:30] Nydethess is being attacked by [Moonrise Intruder] and [Rigging Runner].
[12:11:54] Byvci casts [Firedrinker Satyr].
[12:11:58] Turn 7: Nydethess
[12:12:05] Nydethess casts [Silvergill Adept].
[12:12:05] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Waters] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, create a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token with hexproof.).
[12:12:07] Nydethess's [Deeproot Waters] creates a Merfolk token.
[12:12:10] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Silvergill Adept] onto the stack (When Silvergill Adept enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
[12:12:13] Nydethess draws a card with [Silvergill Adept]'s ability.
[12:12:15] Nydethess casts [Triton Shorestalker].
[12:12:15] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Waters] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, create a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token with hexproof.).
[12:12:17] Nydethess's [Deeproot Waters] creates a Merfolk token.
[12:12:23] Turn 7: Byvci
[12:12:23] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Moonrise Intruder] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if a player cast two or more spells last turn, transform Moonrise...).
[12:13:00] flac0 has started watching.
[12:13:18] Byvci casts [Firedrinker Satyr].
[12:13:27] Turn 8: Nydethess
[12:13:30] Nydethess casts [River Sneak].
[12:13:30] Nydethess puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Waters] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, create a 1/1 blue Merfolk creature token with hexproof.).
[12:13:31] Nydethess's [Deeproot Waters] creates a Merfolk token.
[12:14:01] Byvci is being attacked by [Triton Shorestalker].
[12:14:08] Turn 8: Byvci
[12:14:53] Turn 9: Nydethess
[12:14:53] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Village Messenger] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Village Messenger.).
[12:15:20] Byvci is being attacked by [River Sneak].
[12:15:27] Turn 9: Byvci
[12:15:44] Byvci casts [Akki Avalanchers].
[12:15:57] Turn 10: Nydethess
[12:16:00] Nydethess plays [Island].
[12:16:05] Turn 10: Byvci
[12:16:19] Byvci casts [Arc Trail] targeting [Merfolk Sovereign] (Choose target creature, planeswalker, or player to deal 2 to), and [Silvergill Adept] (Choose target creature, planeswalker, or player to deal 1 to).
[12:16:28] Byvci casts [Forge Devil].
[12:16:32] Byvci puts triggered ability from [Forge Devil] onto the stack targeting [River Sneak] (When Forge Devil enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target creature and 1 damage to you.).
[12:16:40] Nydethess is being attacked by [Akki Avalanchers], [Firedrinker Satyr], [Firedrinker Satyr], [Moonrise Intruder], and [Rigging Runner].
[12:16:43] Nydethess has conceded from the game.
Winner: Byvci
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Byvci: 2–1
[12:16:46] Nydethess draws their next card.
[12:16:47] Nydethess draws their next card.
[12:16:49] Nydethess draws their next card.
[12:16:51] Nydethess draws their next card.
[12:16:51] Byvci has left the game.
[12:16:52] Nydethess draws their next card.