PennyDreadful PD League or PD Test BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality ShiftingShadows,AVPfanJoe == Game 1 (673584052) == [Time] 1557892798 [13:59:58] PDBot has started watching. [13:59:58] ShiftingShadows joined the game. [13:59:59] AVPfanJoe joined the game. [League] ShiftingShadows doesn't have active run [14:00:03] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD][sR] This is not a valid League pairing! [14:00:03] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD][sR] ShiftingShadows, you do not have an active run. [14:00:14] ShiftingShadows chooses to play first. [14:00:20] ShiftingShadows mulligans to 6 cards. [14:00:23] AVPfanJoe mulligans to 6 cards. [14:00:25] ShiftingShadows keeps this hand. [14:00:45] AVPfanJoe keeps this hand. [14:00:50] ShiftingShadows puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [14:00:53] AVPfanJoe puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [14:00:53] Turn 1: ShiftingShadows [14:00:53] ShiftingShadows skips their draw step. [14:00:55] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:01:02] Turn 1: AVPfanJoe [14:01:04] AVPfanJoe plays [Forest]. [14:01:06] AVPfanJoe casts [Llanowar Elves]. [14:01:10] Turn 2: ShiftingShadows [14:01:12] ShiftingShadows plays [Cabal Stronghold]. [14:01:17] ShiftingShadows casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Llanowar Elves]. [14:01:20] Turn 2: AVPfanJoe [14:01:23] AVPfanJoe plays [Island]. [14:01:25] AVPfanJoe casts [Sylvan Caryatid]. [14:01:31] Turn 3: ShiftingShadows [14:01:33] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:01:38] ShiftingShadows casts [Vona's Hunger]. [14:01:46] AVPfanJoe sacrifices [Sylvan Caryatid]. [14:01:54] Turn 3: AVPfanJoe [14:01:56] AVPfanJoe plays [Forest]. [14:01:58] AVPfanJoe casts [Shardless Agent]. [14:01:59] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [14:02:04] AVPfanJoe casts [Coiling Oracle]. [14:02:04] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Coiling Oracle] onto the stack (When Coiling Oracle enters the battlefield, reveal the top card of your library. If it's a land ca...). [14:02:06] AVPfanJoe reveals [Simic Charm] with [Coiling Oracle]'s ability. [14:02:13] Turn 4: ShiftingShadows [14:02:32] ShiftingShadows casts [Go for the Throat] targeting [Coiling Oracle]. [14:02:40] Turn 4: AVPfanJoe [14:02:45] AVPfanJoe casts [Coiling Oracle]. [14:02:47] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Coiling Oracle] onto the stack (When Coiling Oracle enters the battlefield, reveal the top card of your library. If it's a land ca...). [14:02:48] AVPfanJoe reveals [Simic Guildgate] with [Coiling Oracle]'s ability. [14:02:53] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Shardless Agent]. [14:02:57] Turn 5: ShiftingShadows [14:03:04] ShiftingShadows casts [Addle] targeting AVPfanJoe. [14:03:11] ShiftingShadows chooses blue. [14:03:11] AVPfanJoe reveals their hand to [Addle], containing [Dissolve], [Simic Charm], [Simic Charm], and [Duplicant]. [14:03:19] AVPfanJoe discards [Dissolve]. [14:03:25] Turn 5: AVPfanJoe [14:03:28] AVPfanJoe plays [Simic Guildgate]. [14:03:37] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Coiling Oracle] and [Shardless Agent]. [14:03:40] Turn 6: ShiftingShadows [14:03:42] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:04:00] ShiftingShadows casts [Mutilate]. [14:04:08] Turn 6: AVPfanJoe [14:04:10] AVPfanJoe plays [Island]. [14:04:16] Turn 7: ShiftingShadows [14:04:21] ShiftingShadows casts [Endless Whispers]. [14:04:42] [CHAT] ShiftingShadows: i know i know wtf is he playing [14:04:46] [CHAT] ShiftingShadows: =P [14:04:58] Turn 7: AVPfanJoe [14:05:13] AVPfanJoe plays [Simic Guildgate]. [14:05:27] Turn 8: ShiftingShadows [14:05:29] ShiftingShadows plays [Cabal Stronghold]. [14:05:34] [CHAT] AVPfanJoe: your idea of fun is pretty convoluted haha [14:05:39] Turn 8: AVPfanJoe [14:05:41] AVPfanJoe plays [Forest]. [14:05:53] [CHAT] ShiftingShadows: lol this is true at times [14:05:58] Turn 9: ShiftingShadows [14:06:18] [CHAT] ShiftingShadows: the fun is in the talking between doing nothing [14:06:21] Turn 9: AVPfanJoe [14:06:29] AVPfanJoe casts [Shardless Agent]. [14:06:30] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [14:06:37] ShiftingShadows casts [Succumb to Temptation]. [14:06:40] ShiftingShadows draws two cards with [Succumb to Temptation]. [14:06:48] AVPfanJoe casts [Sylvan Caryatid]. [14:06:57] Turn 10: ShiftingShadows [14:06:59] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:07:21] Turn 10: AVPfanJoe [14:07:22] AVPfanJoe plays [Simic Guildgate]. [14:07:28] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Shardless Agent]. [14:07:39] Turn 11: ShiftingShadows [14:07:41] ShiftingShadows plays [Cabal Stronghold]. [14:07:47] ShiftingShadows casts [Succumb to Temptation]. [14:07:49] ShiftingShadows draws two cards with [Succumb to Temptation]. [14:07:57] [CHAT] ShiftingShadows: this hand ugh [14:08:06] Turn 11: AVPfanJoe [14:08:19] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Shardless Agent]. [14:08:26] ShiftingShadows casts [Vona's Hunger]. [14:08:46] AVPfanJoe sacrifices [Shardless Agent]. [14:08:46] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack targeting ShiftingShadows (When this creature is put into a graveyard, target opponent puts it onto the battlefield at the be...). [14:08:51] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from Triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack (Return this creature to the battlefield under target's control. ). [14:08:56] Turn 12: ShiftingShadows [14:09:07] ShiftingShadows casts [Phage the Untouchable]. [14:09:49] Turn 12: AVPfanJoe [14:10:00] AVPfanJoe casts [Duplicant]. [14:10:07] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Duplicant] onto the stack targeting [Phage the Untouchable] (When Duplicant enters the battlefield, you may exile target nontoken creature.). [14:10:23] Turn 13: ShiftingShadows [14:10:41] ShiftingShadows casts [Corrupt] targeting AVPfanJoe. [14:11:10] Turn 13: AVPfanJoe [14:11:13] AVPfanJoe plays [Woodland Stream]. [14:11:19] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Duplicant]. [14:11:25] [Shardless Agent] blocks [Duplicant]. [14:11:27] ShiftingShadows puts triggered ability from ShiftingShadows onto the stack targeting AVPfanJoe (When this creature is put into a graveyard, target opponent puts it onto the battlefield at the be...). [14:11:30] ShiftingShadows puts triggered ability from Triggered ability from ShiftingShadows onto the stack (Return this creature to the battlefield under target's control. ). [14:11:32] Turn 14: ShiftingShadows [14:11:34] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:11:56] ShiftingShadows casts [Endless Whispers]. [14:12:10] Turn 14: AVPfanJoe [14:12:14] AVPfanJoe casts [Coiling Oracle]. [14:12:16] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Coiling Oracle] onto the stack (When Coiling Oracle enters the battlefield, reveal the top card of your library. If it's a land ca...). [14:12:19] AVPfanJoe reveals [Island] with [Coiling Oracle]'s ability. [14:12:28] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Shardless Agent] and [Duplicant]. [14:12:38] ShiftingShadows casts [Go for the Throat] targeting [Coiling Oracle]. [14:12:58] AVPfanJoe casts [Simic Charm] targeting [Coiling Oracle] (Return target creature to its owner's hand.). [14:13:03] AVPfanJoe returns [Coiling Oracle] to its owner's hand with [Simic Charm]. [14:13:26] ShiftingShadows's [Go for the Throat] is countered because it has no legal targets. [14:13:36] AVPfanJoe casts [Coiling Oracle]. [14:13:38] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Coiling Oracle] onto the stack (When Coiling Oracle enters the battlefield, reveal the top card of your library. If it's a land ca...). [14:13:42] AVPfanJoe reveals [Coiling Oracle] with [Coiling Oracle]'s ability. [14:13:47] AVPfanJoe casts [Coiling Oracle]. [14:13:52] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Coiling Oracle] onto the stack (When Coiling Oracle enters the battlefield, reveal the top card of your library. If it's a land ca...). [14:13:57] AVPfanJoe reveals [Island] with [Coiling Oracle]'s ability. [14:14:01] Turn 15: ShiftingShadows [14:14:03] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:14:13] ShiftingShadows casts [Corrupt] targeting [Duplicant]. [14:14:26] AVPfanJoe casts [Simic Charm] (Permanents you control gain hexproof until end of turn.). [14:14:32] ShiftingShadows's [Corrupt] is countered because it has no legal targets. [14:14:40] Turn 15: AVPfanJoe [14:14:49] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Coiling Oracle], [Coiling Oracle], [Shardless Agent], and [Duplicant]. [14:14:55] Turn 16: ShiftingShadows [14:15:27] ShiftingShadows casts [Corrupt] targeting [Duplicant]. [14:15:34] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack targeting ShiftingShadows (When this creature is put into a graveyard, target opponent puts it onto the battlefield at the be...). [14:15:34] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack targeting ShiftingShadows (When this creature is put into a graveyard, target opponent puts it onto the battlefield at the be...). [14:15:41] ShiftingShadows casts [Vona's Hunger]. [14:15:52] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack targeting ShiftingShadows (When this creature is put into a graveyard, target opponent puts it onto the battlefield at the be...). [14:15:52] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack targeting ShiftingShadows (When this creature is put into a graveyard, target opponent puts it onto the battlefield at the be...). [14:15:53] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack targeting ShiftingShadows (When this creature is put into a graveyard, target opponent puts it onto the battlefield at the be...). [14:15:53] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack targeting ShiftingShadows (When this creature is put into a graveyard, target opponent puts it onto the battlefield at the be...). [14:16:02] [CHAT] AVPfanJoe: lovely [14:16:07] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from Triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack (Return this creature to the battlefield under target's control. ). [14:16:07] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from Triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack (Return this creature to the battlefield under target's control. ). [14:16:07] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from Triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack (Return this creature to the battlefield under target's control. ). [14:16:07] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from Triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack (Return this creature to the battlefield under target's control. ). [14:16:07] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from Triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack (Return this creature to the battlefield under target's control. ). [14:16:08] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from Triggered ability from AVPfanJoe onto the stack (Return this creature to the battlefield under target's control. ). [14:16:17] [CHAT] ShiftingShadows: i could have played red [14:16:25] ShiftingShadows puts triggered ability from [Duplicant] onto the stack targeting [Coiling Oracle] (When Duplicant enters the battlefield, you may exile target nontoken creature.). [14:16:39] Turn 16: AVPfanJoe [14:16:53] [CHAT] AVPfanJoe: red doesn't play with its food before it eats [14:17:10] [CHAT] AVPfanJoe: hand is all dorks [14:17:13] AVPfanJoe has conceded from the game. Winner: ShiftingShadows Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (673585538) == [Time] 1557893973 [14:19:33] PDBot has started watching. [14:19:37] AVPfanJoe keeps this hand. [14:19:39] ShiftingShadows keeps this hand. [14:19:39] Turn 1: AVPfanJoe [14:19:39] AVPfanJoe skips their draw step. [14:19:41] AVPfanJoe plays [Forest]. [14:19:43] AVPfanJoe casts [Llanowar Elves]. [14:19:51] Turn 1: ShiftingShadows [14:19:52] ShiftingShadows plays [Cabal Stronghold]. [14:19:58] Turn 2: AVPfanJoe [14:19:59] AVPfanJoe plays [Island]. [14:20:02] AVPfanJoe casts [Sylvan Caryatid]. [14:20:08] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Llanowar Elves]. [14:20:14] Turn 2: ShiftingShadows [14:20:16] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:20:19] ShiftingShadows casts [Go for the Throat] targeting [Llanowar Elves]. [14:20:25] Turn 3: AVPfanJoe [14:20:27] AVPfanJoe plays [Island]. [14:20:31] Turn 3: ShiftingShadows [14:20:33] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:20:39] Turn 4: AVPfanJoe [14:20:41] AVPfanJoe plays [Island]. [14:20:49] AVPfanJoe casts [Sylvan Caryatid]. [14:20:59] ShiftingShadows casts [Succumb to Temptation]. [14:21:03] ShiftingShadows draws two cards with [Succumb to Temptation]. [14:21:05] Turn 4: ShiftingShadows [14:21:08] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:21:11] ShiftingShadows casts [Prism Ring]. [14:21:27] ShiftingShadows chooses black for [Prism Ring]. [14:21:31] Turn 5: AVPfanJoe [14:21:48] Turn 5: ShiftingShadows [14:21:51] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:21:59] ShiftingShadows casts [Endless Whispers]. [14:21:59] ShiftingShadows puts triggered ability from [Prism Ring] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell of the chosen color, you gain 1 life.). [14:22:09] AVPfanJoe casts [Supreme Will] targeting [Endless Whispers] (Counter target spell unless its controller pays {3}.). [14:22:20] Turn 6: AVPfanJoe [14:22:23] AVPfanJoe casts [Coiling Oracle]. [14:22:25] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Coiling Oracle] onto the stack (When Coiling Oracle enters the battlefield, reveal the top card of your library. If it's a land ca...). [14:22:27] AVPfanJoe reveals [Urban Evolution] with [Coiling Oracle]'s ability. [14:22:31] Turn 6: ShiftingShadows [14:22:34] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:22:44] ShiftingShadows casts [Corrupt] targeting AVPfanJoe. [14:22:45] ShiftingShadows puts triggered ability from [Prism Ring] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell of the chosen color, you gain 1 life.). [14:23:06] [CHAT] AVPfanJoe: not playing burn huh? [14:23:10] Turn 7: AVPfanJoe [14:23:19] AVPfanJoe casts [Urban Evolution]. [14:23:20] [CHAT] ShiftingShadows: not red atleast [14:23:22] AVPfanJoe draws three cards with [Urban Evolution]. [14:23:24] AVPfanJoe plays [Island]. [14:23:31] AVPfanJoe casts [Llanowar Elves]. [14:23:37] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Coiling Oracle]. [14:23:41] Turn 7: ShiftingShadows [14:23:44] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:23:49] ShiftingShadows casts [Mutilate]. [14:23:49] ShiftingShadows puts triggered ability from [Prism Ring] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell of the chosen color, you gain 1 life.). [14:24:01] Turn 8: AVPfanJoe [14:24:09] AVPfanJoe casts [Prophet of Kruphix]. [14:24:17] ShiftingShadows casts [Vona's Hunger]. [14:24:17] ShiftingShadows puts triggered ability from [Prism Ring] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell of the chosen color, you gain 1 life.). [14:24:28] AVPfanJoe sacrifices [Prophet of Kruphix]. [14:24:31] Turn 8: ShiftingShadows [14:24:33] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:24:36] Turn 9: AVPfanJoe [14:24:38] AVPfanJoe plays [Forest]. [14:24:43] AVPfanJoe casts [Shardless Agent]. [14:24:44] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [14:24:48] AVPfanJoe casts [Sylvan Caryatid]. [14:24:54] Turn 9: ShiftingShadows [14:24:55] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:25:00] Turn 10: AVPfanJoe [14:25:07] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Shardless Agent]. [14:25:14] AVPfanJoe casts [Shardless Agent]. [14:25:14] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [14:25:27] AVPfanJoe casts [Simic Charm] targeting [Shardless Agent] (Return target creature to its owner's hand.). [14:25:27] AVPfanJoe returns [Shardless Agent] to its owner's hand with [Simic Charm]. [14:25:32] Turn 10: ShiftingShadows [14:25:34] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:25:38] ShiftingShadows casts [Addle] targeting AVPfanJoe. [14:25:38] ShiftingShadows puts triggered ability from [Prism Ring] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell of the chosen color, you gain 1 life.). [14:25:50] AVPfanJoe casts [Dissolve] targeting [Addle]. [14:25:57] AVPfanJoe puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [14:26:05] Turn 11: AVPfanJoe [14:26:13] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Shardless Agent]. [14:26:20] AVPfanJoe casts [Shardless Agent]. [14:26:20] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Shardless Agent] onto the stack (Cascade). [14:26:25] AVPfanJoe casts [Llanowar Elves]. [14:26:30] Turn 11: ShiftingShadows [14:26:32] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:26:37] Turn 12: AVPfanJoe [14:26:48] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Shardless Agent] and [Shardless Agent]. [14:26:58] AVPfanJoe casts [Urban Evolution]. [14:26:58] AVPfanJoe draws three cards with [Urban Evolution]. [14:27:01] AVPfanJoe plays [Island]. [14:27:05] Turn 12: ShiftingShadows [14:27:07] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:27:12] Turn 13: AVPfanJoe [14:27:15] AVPfanJoe plays [Woodland Stream]. [14:27:41] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Llanowar Elves], [Shardless Agent], and [Shardless Agent]. [14:27:42] Turn 13: ShiftingShadows [14:27:42] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:27:52] ShiftingShadows casts [Phage the Untouchable]. [14:27:52] ShiftingShadows puts triggered ability from [Prism Ring] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell of the chosen color, you gain 1 life.). [14:28:14] AVPfanJoe casts [Supreme Will] (Look at the top four cards of your library. Put one of them into your hand and the rest on the bot...). [14:28:40] AVPfanJoe casts [Simic Charm] targeting [Phage the Untouchable] (Return target creature to its owner's hand.). [14:28:40] AVPfanJoe returns [Phage the Untouchable] to its owner's hand with [Simic Charm]. [14:28:44] Turn 14: AVPfanJoe [14:28:55] ShiftingShadows is being attacked by [Llanowar Elves], [Shardless Agent], and [Shardless Agent]. [14:29:00] Turn 14: ShiftingShadows [14:29:11] ShiftingShadows casts [Phage the Untouchable]. [14:29:11] ShiftingShadows puts triggered ability from [Prism Ring] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell of the chosen color, you gain 1 life.). [14:29:20] AVPfanJoe casts [Draining Whelk]. [14:29:24] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Draining Whelk] onto the stack targeting [Phage the Untouchable] (When Draining Whelk enters the battlefield, counter target spell. Put X +1/+1 counters on Draining...). [14:29:31] ShiftingShadows casts [Vona's Hunger]. [14:29:31] ShiftingShadows puts triggered ability from [Prism Ring] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a spell of the chosen color, you gain 1 life.). [14:30:17] ShiftingShadows has conceded from the game. Winner: AVPfanJoe Game 2 Completed. [14:30:21] ShiftingShadows has left the game. == Game 3 (673586406) == [Time] 1557894682 [14:31:22] PDBot has started watching. [14:31:27] ShiftingShadows chooses to play first. [14:31:30] ShiftingShadows keeps this hand. [14:31:32] AVPfanJoe mulligans to 6 cards. [14:31:39] AVPfanJoe keeps this hand. [14:31:42] AVPfanJoe puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [14:31:42] Turn 1: ShiftingShadows [14:31:42] ShiftingShadows skips their draw step. [14:31:44] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:31:48] Turn 1: AVPfanJoe [14:31:50] AVPfanJoe plays [Woodland Stream]. [14:31:54] Turn 2: ShiftingShadows [14:31:55] ShiftingShadows plays [Cabal Stronghold]. [14:31:59] ShiftingShadows casts [Addle] targeting AVPfanJoe. [14:32:03] ShiftingShadows chooses blue. [14:32:03] AVPfanJoe reveals their hand to [Addle], containing [Plaxmanta], [Dissolve], [Sylvan Primordial], [Sylvan Caryatid], [Shardless Agent], and [Sylvan Caryatid]. [14:32:14] AVPfanJoe discards [Dissolve]. [14:32:21] Turn 2: AVPfanJoe [14:32:24] AVPfanJoe plays [Simic Guildgate]. [14:32:30] Turn 3: ShiftingShadows [14:32:32] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:32:36] Turn 3: AVPfanJoe [14:32:40] AVPfanJoe casts [Sylvan Caryatid]. [14:32:52] ShiftingShadows casts [Vona's Hunger]. [14:32:55] AVPfanJoe sacrifices [Sylvan Caryatid]. [14:32:56] Turn 4: ShiftingShadows [14:32:58] ShiftingShadows plays [Swamp]. [14:33:01] ShiftingShadows casts [Endless Whispers]. [14:33:18] Turn 4: AVPfanJoe [14:33:18] AVPfanJoe casts [Coiling Oracle]. [14:33:18] AVPfanJoe puts triggered ability from [Coiling Oracle] onto the stack (When Coiling Oracle enters the battlefield, reveal the top card of your library. If it's a land ca...). [14:33:22] AVPfanJoe reveals [Coiling Oracle] with [Coiling Oracle]'s ability. [14:33:25] [CHAT] AVPfanJoe: these draws [14:33:34] [CHAT] AVPfanJoe: you can have it [14:33:36] [CHAT] AVPfanJoe: gg [14:33:42] AVPfanJoe has conceded from the game. Winner: ShiftingShadows Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: ShiftingShadows: 2–1 [14:33:43] [CHAT] ShiftingShadows: gg [14:33:47] ShiftingShadows has left the game.