PennyDreadful
PD vs. TheUsualSuspect
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
TheUsualSuspect,1KBestK

== Game 1 (673017914) ==
[Time] 1557443164
[09:06:04] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Thursdays 12.01
[Gatherling] Round=1
[09:06:09] 1KBestK chooses to play first.
[09:06:24] 1KBestK mulligans to 6 cards.
[09:06:27] TheUsualSuspect keeps this hand.
[09:06:29] 1KBestK mulligans to 5 cards.
[09:06:30] 1KBestK keeps this hand.
[09:06:32] 1KBestK puts 1 card on top of their library.
[09:06:32] Turn 1: 1KBestK
[09:06:40] 1KBestK skips their draw step.
[09:06:42] 1KBestK plays [Desert of the True].
[09:06:51] Turn 1: TheUsualSuspect
[09:06:54] TheUsualSuspect plays [Swiftwater Cliffs].
[09:06:54] TheUsualSuspect puts triggered ability from [Swiftwater Cliffs] onto the stack (When Swiftwater Cliffs enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[09:06:57] Turn 2: 1KBestK
[09:07:19] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:07:24] Turn 2: TheUsualSuspect
[09:07:27] TheUsualSuspect plays [Mountain].
[09:07:30] TheUsualSuspect casts [Strategic Planning].
[09:07:46] TheUsualSuspect puts [Burst Lightning] and [Compulsive Research] into their graveyard.
[09:07:46] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Compulsive Research[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Dredging rather than drawing can let you avoid discarding
[09:07:54] Turn 3: 1KBestK
[09:07:58] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:08:09] Turn 3: TheUsualSuspect
[09:08:13] TheUsualSuspect plays [Mountain].
[09:08:16] TheUsualSuspect casts [Boros Reckoner].
[09:08:25] Turn 4: 1KBestK
[09:08:27] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:08:35] Turn 4: TheUsualSuspect
[09:08:38] TheUsualSuspect plays [Aether Hub].
[09:08:38] TheUsualSuspect puts triggered ability from [Aether Hub] onto the stack (When Aether Hub enters the battlefield, you get {E}.).
[09:08:41] TheUsualSuspect gains 1 energy from [Aether Hub]'s ability.
[09:08:48] TheUsualSuspect discards [Mogg Maniac].
[09:08:48] TheUsualSuspect casts [Tormenting Voice].
[09:08:50] TheUsualSuspect draws two cards with [Tormenting Voice].
[09:08:58] Turn 5: 1KBestK
[09:09:03] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:09:09] 1KBestK casts [Planar Outburst].
[09:09:16] Turn 5: TheUsualSuspect
[09:09:19] TheUsualSuspect plays [Aether Hub].
[09:09:19] TheUsualSuspect puts triggered ability from [Aether Hub] onto the stack (When Aether Hub enters the battlefield, you get {E}.).
[09:09:21] TheUsualSuspect gains 1 energy from [Aether Hub]'s ability.
[09:09:26] Turn 6: 1KBestK
[09:09:30] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:09:36] Turn 6: TheUsualSuspect
[09:10:07] TheUsualSuspect casts [Treasure Cruise].
[09:10:09] TheUsualSuspect draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[09:10:11] TheUsualSuspect plays [Izzet Boilerworks].
[09:10:12] TheUsualSuspect puts triggered ability from [Izzet Boilerworks] onto the stack (When Izzet Boilerworks enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[09:10:17] TheUsualSuspect returns [Aether Hub] to its owner's hand with [Izzet Boilerworks]'s ability.
[09:10:21] TheUsualSuspect casts [Strategic Planning].
[09:10:28] TheUsualSuspect puts [Strategic Planning] and [Nahiri's Wrath] into their graveyard.
[09:10:29] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Nahiri's Wrath[sU] has an unclassified bug.
The prompt box of Nahiri's Wrath displays incorrect text.
[09:10:36] TheUsualSuspect discards [Swiftwater Cliffs].
[09:10:59] TheUsualSuspect discards [Aether Hub].
[09:10:59] Turn 7: 1KBestK
[09:11:06] 1KBestK casts [Astral Slide].
[09:11:13] Turn 7: TheUsualSuspect
[09:11:22] TheUsualSuspect casts [Mogg Maniac].
[09:11:33] TheUsualSuspect casts [Boros Reckoner].
[09:11:42] Turn 8: 1KBestK
[09:11:54] 1KBestK casts [Planar Outburst].
[09:12:03] Turn 8: TheUsualSuspect
[09:12:17] TheUsualSuspect casts [Treasure Cruise].
[09:12:19] TheUsualSuspect draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[09:12:25] TheUsualSuspect casts [Compulsive Research] targeting TheUsualSuspect.
[09:12:26] TheUsualSuspect draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[09:12:33] TheUsualSuspect discards [Izzet Boilerworks].
[09:12:35] TheUsualSuspect plays [Island].
[09:12:53] TheUsualSuspect discards [Strategic Planning].
[09:12:55] TheUsualSuspect discards [Tormenting Voice].
[09:12:55] Turn 9: 1KBestK
[09:13:10] Turn 9: TheUsualSuspect
[09:13:26] TheUsualSuspect casts [Dig Through Time].
[09:13:46] TheUsualSuspect casts [Mogg Maniac].
[09:13:59] TheUsualSuspect discards [Kindle the Carnage].
[09:13:59] Turn 10: 1KBestK
[09:14:22] Turn 10: TheUsualSuspect
[09:14:38] 1KBestK is being attacked by [Mogg Maniac].
[09:14:42] 1KBestK casts [Pitfall Trap] using an alternate cost targeting [Mogg Maniac].
[09:15:02] TheUsualSuspect casts [Mogg Maniac].
[09:15:08] TheUsualSuspect casts [Kindle the Carnage].
[09:15:16] 1KBestK discards [Desert of the True].
[09:15:16] 1KBestK cycles [Desert of the True].
[09:15:16] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Mogg Maniac] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...).
[09:15:25] TheUsualSuspect discards [Supreme Will].
[09:15:31] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Mogg Maniac to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end s...).
[09:15:37] Turn 11: 1KBestK
[09:15:43] 1KBestK casts [Thunderstaff].
[09:15:48] Turn 11: TheUsualSuspect
[09:16:01] TheUsualSuspect casts [Compulsive Research] targeting TheUsualSuspect.
[09:16:03] TheUsualSuspect draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[09:16:12] TheUsualSuspect discards [Island].
[09:16:51] Turn 12: 1KBestK
[09:17:16] TheUsualSuspect casts [Dig Through Time].
[09:17:30] Turn 12: TheUsualSuspect
[09:17:32] TheUsualSuspect plays [Island].
[09:17:36] TheUsualSuspect casts [Stuffy Doll].
[09:17:41] The chosen player is 1KBestK.
[09:17:58] Turn 13: 1KBestK
[09:18:07] 1KBestK discards [Eternal Dragon].
[09:18:07] 1KBestK cycles [Eternal Dragon].
[09:18:11] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Stuffy Doll] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...).
[09:18:23] 1KBestK reveals [Plains].
[09:18:24] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:18:34] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Stuffy Doll to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end s...).
[09:18:41] The chosen player is 1KBestK.
[09:18:52] Turn 13: TheUsualSuspect
[09:19:03] TheUsualSuspect casts [Stuffy Doll].
[09:19:11] The chosen player is 1KBestK.
[09:19:12] TheUsualSuspect plays [Evolving Wilds].
[09:19:21] Turn 14: 1KBestK
[09:19:28] 1KBestK casts [Guardian Seraph].
[09:19:41] TheUsualSuspect casts [Supreme Will] targeting [Guardian Seraph] (Counter target spell unless its controller pays {3}.).
[09:19:53] TheUsualSuspect activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[09:19:59] 1KBestK discards [Oketra's Attendant].
[09:19:59] 1KBestK cycles [Oketra's Attendant].
[09:20:00] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Stuffy Doll] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...).
[09:20:17] Turn 14: TheUsualSuspect
[09:20:21] TheUsualSuspect plays [Aether Hub].
[09:20:21] TheUsualSuspect puts triggered ability from [Aether Hub] onto the stack (When Aether Hub enters the battlefield, you get {E}.).
[09:20:26] TheUsualSuspect gains 1 energy from [Aether Hub]'s ability.
[09:20:44] TheUsualSuspect discards [Dig Through Time].
[09:20:44] TheUsualSuspect discards [Nahiri's Wrath].
[09:20:44] TheUsualSuspect discards [Nahiri's Wrath].
[09:20:44] TheUsualSuspect casts [Nahiri's Wrath] targeting [Mogg Maniac], and [Stuffy Doll]. (X is 3).
[09:20:52] TheUsualSuspect puts triggered ability from [Stuffy Doll] onto the stack (Whenever Stuffy Doll is dealt damage, it deals that much damage to the chosen player.).
[09:20:52] TheUsualSuspect puts triggered ability from [Mogg Maniac] onto the stack targeting 1KBestK (Whenever Mogg Maniac is dealt damage, it deals that much damage to target opponent or planeswalker...).
Winner: TheUsualSuspect
Game 1 Completed.
[09:21:02] 1KBestK has left the game.

== Game 2 (673019340) ==
[Time] 1557444131
[09:22:11] PDBot has started watching.
[09:22:35] 1KBestK chooses to play first.
[09:22:39] 1KBestK keeps this hand.
[09:22:41] TheUsualSuspect keeps this hand.
[09:22:41] Turn 1: 1KBestK
[09:22:42] 1KBestK skips their draw step.
[09:22:43] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:22:51] Turn 1: TheUsualSuspect
[09:22:53] TheUsualSuspect plays [Swiftwater Cliffs].
[09:22:53] TheUsualSuspect puts triggered ability from [Swiftwater Cliffs] onto the stack (When Swiftwater Cliffs enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[09:22:57] Turn 2: 1KBestK
[09:23:01] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:23:07] Turn 2: TheUsualSuspect
[09:23:09] TheUsualSuspect plays [Island].
[09:23:14] TheUsualSuspect discards [Nahiri's Wrath].
[09:23:14] TheUsualSuspect casts [Tormenting Voice].
[09:23:14] TheUsualSuspect draws two cards with [Tormenting Voice].
[09:23:19] Turn 3: 1KBestK
[09:23:23] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:23:28] 1KBestK casts [Aven Riftwatcher].
[09:23:30] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Aven Riftwatcher] onto the stack (When Aven Riftwatcher enters the battlefield, you gain 2 life.).
[09:23:37] Turn 3: TheUsualSuspect
[09:23:41] TheUsualSuspect plays [Aether Hub].
[09:23:41] TheUsualSuspect puts triggered ability from [Aether Hub] onto the stack (When Aether Hub enters the battlefield, you get {E}.).
[09:23:43] TheUsualSuspect gains 1 energy from [Aether Hub]'s ability.
[09:23:45] TheUsualSuspect casts [Strategic Planning].
[09:23:49] Kaitoukid111 has started watching.
[09:23:51] TheUsualSuspect puts [Evolving Wilds] and [Supreme Will] into their graveyard.
[09:23:57] Turn 4: 1KBestK
[09:23:57] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Aven Riftwatcher] onto the stack (Vanishing 3 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter from this card.)).
[09:24:07] 1KBestK casts [Astral Slide].
[09:24:14] TheUsualSuspect is being attacked by [Aven Riftwatcher].
[09:24:22] Turn 4: TheUsualSuspect
[09:24:38] TheUsualSuspect plays [Swiftwater Cliffs].
[09:24:38] TheUsualSuspect puts triggered ability from [Swiftwater Cliffs] onto the stack (When Swiftwater Cliffs enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[09:24:59] TheUsualSuspect discards [Stuffy Doll].
[09:24:59] TheUsualSuspect casts [Nahiri's Wrath] targeting [Aven Riftwatcher]. (X is 1).
[09:25:02] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Aven Riftwatcher] onto the stack (When Aven Riftwatcher leaves the battlefield, you gain 2 life.).
[09:25:08] Turn 5: 1KBestK
[09:25:13] 1KBestK casts [Astral Slide].
[09:25:22] Turn 5: TheUsualSuspect
[09:25:25] TheUsualSuspect plays [Island].
[09:25:28] TheUsualSuspect casts [Chandra Nalaar].
[09:25:34] TheUsualSuspect activates an ability of [Chandra Nalaar] targeting 1KBestK ( Chandra Nalaar deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker.).
[09:25:56] Turn 6: 1KBestK
[09:26:01] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:26:09] 1KBestK discards [Eternal Dragon].
[09:26:09] 1KBestK cycles [Eternal Dragon].
[09:26:09] No legal targets to choose for [Astral Slide]'s triggered ability.
[09:26:09] No legal targets to choose for [Astral Slide]'s triggered ability.
[09:26:11] 1KBestK reveals [Plains].
[09:26:18] Turn 6: TheUsualSuspect
[09:26:22] TheUsualSuspect activates an ability of [Chandra Nalaar] targeting 1KBestK ( Chandra Nalaar deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker.).
[09:26:30] TheUsualSuspect casts [Dig Through Time].
[09:26:44] [CHAT] 1KBestK: this is like
[09:26:49] [CHAT] 1KBestK: my worst matchup
[09:26:56] Turn 7: 1KBestK
[09:27:03] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:27:06] 1KBestK casts [Astral Slide].
[09:27:14] [CHAT] 1KBestK: because it's jsut so slow
[09:27:18] TheUsualSuspect casts [Supreme Will] targeting [Astral Slide] (Counter target spell unless its controller pays {3}.).
[09:27:28] Turn 7: TheUsualSuspect
[09:27:36] TheUsualSuspect plays [Evolving Wilds].
[09:27:38] TheUsualSuspect activates an ability of [Chandra Nalaar] targeting 1KBestK ( Chandra Nalaar deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker.).
[09:27:42] TheUsualSuspect activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[09:27:52] TheUsualSuspect casts [Compulsive Research] targeting TheUsualSuspect.
[09:27:53] TheUsualSuspect draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[09:27:57] TheUsualSuspect discards [Treasure Cruise].
[09:27:57] TheUsualSuspect discards [Compulsive Research].
[09:28:01] TheUsualSuspect casts [Mogg Maniac].
[09:28:08] Turn 8: 1KBestK
[09:28:16] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:28:18] littlefield has started watching.
[09:28:21] 1KBestK casts [Rule of Law].
[09:28:34] Turn 8: TheUsualSuspect
[09:28:35] Honorbound84 has started watching.
[09:28:39] TheUsualSuspect activates an ability of [Chandra Nalaar] targeting 1KBestK ( Chandra Nalaar deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker.).
[09:28:48] TheUsualSuspect casts [Boros Reckoner].
[09:29:04] Turn 9: 1KBestK
[09:29:08] 1KBestK activates an ability of [Eternal Dragon] ( Return Eternal Dragon from your graveyard to your hand.).
[09:29:09] [Eternal Dragon] is returned to 1KBestK's hand from the graveyard.
[09:29:13] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:29:26] 1KBestK discards [Eternal Dragon].
[09:29:26] 1KBestK cycles [Eternal Dragon].
[09:29:28] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Boros Reckoner] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...).
[09:29:29] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack targeting [Mogg Maniac] (Whenever a player cycles a card, you may exile target creature. If you do, return that card to the...).
[09:29:39] 1KBestK reveals [Plains].
[09:29:44] TheUsualSuspect casts [Dig Through Time].
[09:29:53] Turn 9: TheUsualSuspect
[09:30:00] TheUsualSuspect casts [Mogg Maniac].
[09:30:05] TheUsualSuspect activates an ability of [Chandra Nalaar] targeting 1KBestK ( Chandra Nalaar deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker.).
[09:30:11] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Mogg Maniac to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end s...).
[09:30:11] 1KBestK puts triggered ability from [Astral Slide] onto the stack (Return Boros Reckoner to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next en...).
[09:30:15] Turn 10: 1KBestK
[09:30:18] 1KBestK plays [Plains].
[09:30:20] 1KBestK has conceded from the game.
Winner: TheUsualSuspect
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: TheUsualSuspect: 2–0
[09:30:23] TheUsualSuspect draws their next card.