PennyDreadful Penny Dreadful League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality SheafCohomology,blight_of_frog == Game 1 (672763946) == [Time] 1557238260 [00:11:01] PDBot has started watching. [00:11:01] blight_of_frog joined the game. [00:11:04] SheafCohomology chooses to play first. [League] Miracle Grow by sheafcohomology (48444) vs Bird Proliferate by blight_of_frog (48409) [00:11:05] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [00:11:11] SheafCohomology mulligans to 6 cards. [00:11:11] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: hello! [00:11:17] blight_of_frog keeps this hand. [00:11:19] [CHAT] SheafCohomology: Hello! [00:11:24] SheafCohomology mulligans to 5 cards. [00:11:26] SheafCohomology keeps this hand. [00:11:29] SheafCohomology puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [00:11:29] Turn 1: SheafCohomology [00:11:29] SheafCohomology skips their draw step. [00:11:31] SheafCohomology plays [Woodland Stream]. [00:11:35] Turn 1: blight_of_frog [00:11:38] blight_of_frog plays [Vivid Marsh]. [00:11:41] Turn 2: SheafCohomology [00:11:42] SheafCohomology plays [Island]. [00:11:47] Turn 2: blight_of_frog [00:11:54] blight_of_frog plays [Island]. [00:12:00] blight_of_frog casts [Glint-Nest Crane]. [00:12:06] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Glint-Nest Crane] onto the stack (When Glint-Nest Crane enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library. You may ...). [00:12:20] blight_of_frog puts [Power Conduit] into their hand with with [Glint-Nest Crane]'s ability. [00:12:34] SheafCohomology casts [Anticipate]. [00:12:59] Turn 3: SheafCohomology [00:13:08] SheafCohomology plays [Forest]. [00:13:11] SheafCohomology casts [Telling Time]. [00:13:40] SheafCohomology put a card in his or her hand. [00:13:41] SheafCohomology put a card on top of their library. [00:13:50] Turn 3: blight_of_frog [00:13:57] blight_of_frog plays [Forest]. [00:14:05] blight_of_frog casts [Druids' Repository]. [00:14:17] SheafCohomology is being attacked by [Glint-Nest Crane]. [00:14:17] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Druids' Repository] onto the stack (Whenever a creature you control attacks, put a charge counter on Druids' Repository.). [00:14:30] SheafCohomology casts [Obsessive Search]. [00:14:32] SheafCohomology draws a card with [Obsessive Search]. [00:14:33] Turn 4: SheafCohomology [00:14:40] SheafCohomology casts [Anticipate]. [00:14:57] SheafCohomology plays [Woodland Stream]. [00:15:08] Turn 4: blight_of_frog [00:15:35] SheafCohomology is being attacked by [Glint-Nest Crane]. [00:15:35] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Druids' Repository] onto the stack (Whenever a creature you control attacks, put a charge counter on Druids' Repository.). [00:16:01] blight_of_frog casts [Viral Drake]. [00:16:13] blight_of_frog plays [Vivid Marsh]. [00:16:21] Turn 5: SheafCohomology [00:16:25] SheafCohomology casts [Lorescale Coatl]. [00:16:29] SheafCohomology plays [Thornwood Falls]. [00:16:30] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Thornwood Falls] onto the stack (When Thornwood Falls enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [00:16:40] Turn 5: blight_of_frog [00:16:45] blight_of_frog plays [Forest]. [00:16:57] blight_of_frog casts [Power Conduit]. [00:17:09] blight_of_frog activates an ability of [Power Conduit] targeting [Viral Drake] ( Put a +1/+1 counter on target creature.). [00:17:23] SheafCohomology is being attacked by [Viral Drake]. [00:17:23] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Druids' Repository] onto the stack (Whenever a creature you control attacks, put a charge counter on Druids' Repository.). [00:17:35] SheafCohomology has 2 poison counters. [00:17:50] blight_of_frog casts [Throne of Geth]. [00:17:58] blight_of_frog casts [Terrarion]. [00:18:04] blight_of_frog activates an ability of [Throne of Geth] ( Proliferate.). [00:18:04] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Terrarion] onto the stack (When Terrarion is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.). [00:18:07] blight_of_frog draws a card with [Terrarion]'s ability. [00:18:16] blight_of_frog chooses [Vivid Marsh], [Viral Drake], [Druids' Repository], [Vivid Marsh], and SheafCohomology with [Throne of Geth]'s ability. [00:18:16] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Vivid Marsh]. [00:18:16] blight_of_frog adds +1/+1 counter to [Viral Drake]. [00:18:16] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Druids' Repository]. [00:18:16] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Vivid Marsh]. [00:18:16] blight_of_frog adds poison counter to SheafCohomology. [00:18:25] blight_of_frog casts [Glint-Nest Crane]. [00:18:26] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Glint-Nest Crane] onto the stack (When Glint-Nest Crane enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library. You may ...). [00:18:32] blight_of_frog puts [Terrarion] into their hand with with [Glint-Nest Crane]'s ability. [00:18:41] SheafCohomology casts [Cerulean Wisps] targeting [Lorescale Coatl]. [00:18:44] SheafCohomology draws a card with [Cerulean Wisps]. [00:18:45] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Lorescale Coatl] onto the stack (Whenever you draw a card, you may put a +1/+1 counter on Lorescale Coatl.). [00:18:52] Turn 6: SheafCohomology [00:18:52] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Lorescale Coatl] onto the stack (Whenever you draw a card, you may put a +1/+1 counter on Lorescale Coatl.). [00:18:58] SheafCohomology casts [Aqueous Form] targeting [Lorescale Coatl]. [00:19:05] blight_of_frog is being attacked by [Lorescale Coatl]. [00:19:05] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Aqueous Form] onto the stack (Whenever enchanted creature attacks, scry 1.). [00:19:12] SheafCohomology puts 1 card on top of their library. [00:19:27] Turn 6: blight_of_frog [00:19:36] blight_of_frog casts [Terrarion]. [00:19:43] blight_of_frog activates an ability of [Throne of Geth] ( Proliferate.). [00:19:43] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Terrarion] onto the stack (When Terrarion is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.). [00:19:47] blight_of_frog draws a card with [Terrarion]'s ability. [00:19:57] blight_of_frog chooses [Vivid Marsh], [Viral Drake], [Druids' Repository], [Vivid Marsh], and SheafCohomology with [Throne of Geth]'s ability. [00:19:57] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Vivid Marsh]. [00:19:57] blight_of_frog adds +1/+1 counter to [Viral Drake]. [00:19:57] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Druids' Repository]. [00:19:57] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Vivid Marsh]. [00:19:57] blight_of_frog adds poison counter to SheafCohomology. [00:19:57] SheafCohomology has conceded from the game. Winner: blight_of_frog Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (672764710) == [Time] 1557238858 [00:20:59] PDBot has started watching. [00:21:01] SheafCohomology chooses to play first. [00:21:05] SheafCohomology keeps this hand. [00:21:06] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: not sure why ive never seen another person using a poison deck, they be not too bad [00:21:12] blight_of_frog keeps this hand. [00:21:12] Turn 1: SheafCohomology [00:21:12] SheafCohomology skips their draw step. [00:21:13] SheafCohomology plays [Thornwood Falls]. [00:21:13] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Thornwood Falls] onto the stack (When Thornwood Falls enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [00:21:26] Turn 1: blight_of_frog [00:21:31] blight_of_frog plays [Vivid Grove]. [00:21:43] [CHAT] SheafCohomology: Well, I ran into a more traditional play-a-small-creature-and-pump-them-a-bunch deck the other day. [00:21:49] Turn 2: SheafCohomology [00:21:53] SheafCohomology plays [Island]. [00:21:56] SheafCohomology casts [Obsessive Search]. [00:22:05] [CHAT] SheafCohomology: Also, my deck is bad, so I wouldn't use it for comparison. [00:22:09] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: that might be more effective than mine [00:22:11] SheafCohomology draws a card with [Obsessive Search]. [00:22:39] [CHAT] SheafCohomology: It used Wild Defiance. [00:22:49] Turn 2: blight_of_frog [00:22:59] blight_of_frog plays [Island]. [00:23:05] blight_of_frog casts [Glint-Nest Crane]. [00:23:06] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Glint-Nest Crane] onto the stack (When Glint-Nest Crane enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library. You may ...). [00:23:13] blight_of_frog puts [Terrarion] into their hand with with [Glint-Nest Crane]'s ability. [00:23:29] Turn 3: SheafCohomology [00:23:45] SheafCohomology plays [Forest]. [00:23:52] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: ill have to check that card out [00:24:14] SheafCohomology casts [Quirion Dryad]. [00:24:28] Turn 3: blight_of_frog [00:24:31] blight_of_frog plays [Forest]. [00:24:40] blight_of_frog casts [Power Conduit]. [00:24:54] blight_of_frog casts [Terrarion]. [00:25:07] blight_of_frog activates an ability of [Power Conduit] targeting [Glint-Nest Crane] ( Put a +1/+1 counter on target creature.). [00:25:14] SheafCohomology is being attacked by [Glint-Nest Crane]. [00:25:30] SheafCohomology casts [Mizzium Skin] targeting [Quirion Dryad]. [00:25:30] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:25:45] Turn 4: SheafCohomology [00:25:48] SheafCohomology plays [Island]. [00:25:53] SheafCohomology casts [Lorescale Coatl]. [00:25:53] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:26:03] blight_of_frog is being attacked by [Quirion Dryad]. [00:26:13] Turn 4: blight_of_frog [00:26:17] blight_of_frog plays [Island]. [00:26:31] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Terrarion] onto the stack (When Terrarion is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.). [00:26:36] blight_of_frog draws a card with [Terrarion]'s ability. [00:26:46] blight_of_frog casts [Viral Drake]. [00:26:58] blight_of_frog activates an ability of [Power Conduit] targeting [Viral Drake] ( Put a +1/+1 counter on target creature.). [00:27:08] Turn 5: SheafCohomology [00:27:08] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Lorescale Coatl] onto the stack (Whenever you draw a card, you may put a +1/+1 counter on Lorescale Coatl.). [00:27:24] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: I was so happy when a bunch of vivid lands went legal [00:27:53] SheafCohomology casts [Blink of an Eye] (with kicker) targeting [Viral Drake]. [00:27:53] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:28:00] SheafCohomology returns [Viral Drake] to its owner's hand with [Blink of an Eye]. [00:28:00] SheafCohomology draws a card with [Blink of an Eye]. [00:28:01] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Lorescale Coatl] onto the stack (Whenever you draw a card, you may put a +1/+1 counter on Lorescale Coatl.). [00:28:08] SheafCohomology plays [Forest]. [00:28:13] blight_of_frog is being attacked by [Lorescale Coatl] and [Quirion Dryad]. [00:28:25] Turn 5: blight_of_frog [00:28:37] blight_of_frog casts [Viral Drake]. [00:28:45] blight_of_frog plays [Vivid Marsh]. [00:28:56] Turn 6: SheafCohomology [00:28:57] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Lorescale Coatl] onto the stack (Whenever you draw a card, you may put a +1/+1 counter on Lorescale Coatl.). [00:29:17] SheafCohomology casts [Telling Time]. [00:29:17] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:29:35] SheafCohomology put a card in his or her hand. [00:29:39] SheafCohomology put a card on top of their library. [00:29:55] SheafCohomology casts [Aqueous Form] targeting [Quirion Dryad]. [00:29:56] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:30:22] SheafCohomology casts [Blink of an Eye] targeting [Glint-Nest Crane]. [00:30:22] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:30:26] SheafCohomology returns [Glint-Nest Crane] to its owner's hand with [Blink of an Eye]. [00:30:30] blight_of_frog is being attacked by [Lorescale Coatl] and [Quirion Dryad]. [00:30:30] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Aqueous Form] onto the stack (Whenever enchanted creature attacks, scry 1.). [00:30:33] SheafCohomology puts 1 card on top of their library. [00:30:43] blight_of_frog has conceded from the game. Winner: SheafCohomology Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (672765412) == [Time] 1557239479 [00:31:20] PDBot has started watching. [00:31:32] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: mysideboard kill spells are no good, as they rely on giving -1-1 counters and proliferating them [00:31:34] blight_of_frog chooses to play first. [00:31:41] blight_of_frog keeps this hand. [00:31:50] SheafCohomology keeps this hand. [00:31:50] Turn 1: blight_of_frog [00:31:50] blight_of_frog skips their draw step. [00:31:52] blight_of_frog plays [Vivid Marsh]. [00:32:02] Turn 1: SheafCohomology [00:32:04] SheafCohomology plays [Thornwood Falls]. [00:32:04] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Thornwood Falls] onto the stack (When Thornwood Falls enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [00:32:25] [CHAT] SheafCohomology: Yes, that's the first time I've seen the cancellation of +1/+1 and -1/-1 counters be seriously relevant. [00:32:33] Turn 2: blight_of_frog [00:32:37] blight_of_frog plays [Island]. [00:32:42] blight_of_frog casts [Terrarion]. [00:32:49] blight_of_frog casts [Vedalken Certarch]. [00:32:57] Turn 2: SheafCohomology [00:33:00] SheafCohomology plays [Island]. [00:33:03] SheafCohomology casts [Quirion Dryad]. [00:33:13] Turn 3: blight_of_frog [00:33:16] blight_of_frog plays [Island]. [00:33:25] blight_of_frog casts [Throne of Geth]. [00:33:42] SheafCohomology is being attacked by [Vedalken Certarch]. [00:33:49] Turn 3: SheafCohomology [00:34:23] SheafCohomology casts [Obsessive Search]. [00:34:23] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:34:30] SheafCohomology draws a card with [Obsessive Search]. [00:34:36] SheafCohomology plays [Woodland Stream]. [00:34:39] SheafCohomology casts [Peek] targeting blight_of_frog. [00:34:39] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:34:48] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: tada [00:35:04] SheafCohomology draws a card with [Peek]. [00:35:09] blight_of_frog is being attacked by [Quirion Dryad]. [00:35:16] Turn 4: blight_of_frog [00:35:19] blight_of_frog plays [Island]. [00:35:26] blight_of_frog casts [Viral Drake]. [00:35:42] SheafCohomology is being attacked by [Vedalken Certarch]. [00:35:49] Turn 4: SheafCohomology [00:35:52] SheafCohomology plays [Island]. [00:36:14] SheafCohomology casts [Deeproot Champion]. [00:36:45] blight_of_frog is being attacked by [Quirion Dryad]. [00:37:00] Turn 5: blight_of_frog [00:37:04] blight_of_frog plays [Vivid Creek]. [00:37:13] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Terrarion] onto the stack (When Terrarion is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, draw a card.). [00:37:24] blight_of_frog draws a card with [Terrarion]'s ability. [00:37:29] blight_of_frog casts [Druids' Repository]. [00:37:54] SheafCohomology is being attacked by [Viral Drake] and [Vedalken Certarch]. [00:37:54] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Druids' Repository] onto the stack (Whenever a creature you control attacks, put a charge counter on Druids' Repository.). [00:37:54] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Druids' Repository] onto the stack (Whenever a creature you control attacks, put a charge counter on Druids' Repository.). [00:38:11] SheafCohomology has 1 poison counter. [00:38:24] blight_of_frog activates an ability of [Throne of Geth] ( Proliferate.). [00:38:35] blight_of_frog chooses [Druids' Repository], [Vivid Creek], [Vivid Marsh], and SheafCohomology with [Throne of Geth]'s ability. [00:38:35] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Druids' Repository]. [00:38:35] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Vivid Creek]. [00:38:35] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Vivid Marsh]. [00:38:35] blight_of_frog adds poison counter to SheafCohomology. [00:38:47] SheafCohomology casts [Telling Time]. [00:38:48] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:38:48] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Champion] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Deeproot Champion.). [00:39:05] SheafCohomology put a card in his or her hand. [00:39:06] SheafCohomology put a card on top of their library. [00:39:10] Turn 5: SheafCohomology [00:39:24] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: you can use those like combat trick, i think. you should have been able to block my certarch [00:39:36] [CHAT] SheafCohomology: Yes, I realized that right after I passed through the step... [00:39:40] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: ah [00:40:20] SheafCohomology casts [Anticipate]. [00:40:21] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:40:22] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Champion] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Deeproot Champion.). [00:40:38] SheafCohomology plays [Forest]. [00:40:52] SheafCohomology casts [Obsessive Search]. [00:40:54] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:40:54] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Champion] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Deeproot Champion.). [00:41:02] SheafCohomology draws a card with [Obsessive Search]. [00:41:14] blight_of_frog is being attacked by [Deeproot Champion] and [Quirion Dryad]. [00:41:22] Turn 6: blight_of_frog [00:41:25] blight_of_frog plays [Forest]. [00:41:35] blight_of_frog activates an ability of [Viral Drake] ( Proliferate.). [00:41:44] blight_of_frog chooses [Druids' Repository], [Vivid Creek], [Vivid Marsh], and SheafCohomology with [Viral Drake]'s ability. [00:41:44] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Druids' Repository]. [00:41:44] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Vivid Creek]. [00:41:44] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Vivid Marsh]. [00:41:44] blight_of_frog adds poison counter to SheafCohomology. [00:41:59] blight_of_frog casts [Throne of Geth]. [00:42:09] blight_of_frog activates an ability of [Throne of Geth] ( Proliferate.). [00:42:20] blight_of_frog chooses [Druids' Repository] and SheafCohomology with [Throne of Geth]'s ability. [00:42:20] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Druids' Repository]. [00:42:20] blight_of_frog adds poison counter to SheafCohomology. [00:42:34] blight_of_frog activates an ability of [Viral Drake] ( Proliferate.). [00:42:40] [CHAT] SheafCohomology: I feel like the Certarch and the Throne of Geth don't play nicely with each other. [00:42:57] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: no, geth is too jank, sadly [00:43:05] blight_of_frog chooses [Druids' Repository] and SheafCohomology with [Viral Drake]'s ability. [00:43:05] blight_of_frog adds charge counter to [Druids' Repository]. [00:43:05] blight_of_frog adds poison counter to SheafCohomology. [00:43:18] SheafCohomology is being attacked by [Viral Drake] and [Vedalken Certarch]. [00:43:18] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Druids' Repository] onto the stack (Whenever a creature you control attacks, put a charge counter on Druids' Repository.). [00:43:18] blight_of_frog puts triggered ability from [Druids' Repository] onto the stack (Whenever a creature you control attacks, put a charge counter on Druids' Repository.). [00:43:29] [CHAT] SheafCohomology: Geth + Terrarion is nice, but I think you'd need to be building around it more dedicatedly. [00:43:55] SheafCohomology casts [Blink of an Eye] targeting [Druids' Repository]. [00:43:56] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Quirion Dryad] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a white, blue, black, or red spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Quirion Dryad.). [00:43:56] SheafCohomology puts triggered ability from [Deeproot Champion] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a noncreature spell, put a +1/+1 counter on Deeproot Champion.). [00:43:59] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: terrarion i think is worse than th implements, as well [00:44:08] [CHAT] blight_of_frog: usually [00:44:15] SheafCohomology returns [Druids' Repository] to its owner's hand with [Blink of an Eye]. [00:44:25] SheafCohomology has 6 poison counters. [00:44:31] blight_of_frog has conceded from the game. Winner: SheafCohomology Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: SheafCohomology: 2–1 [00:44:36] blight_of_frog has left the game.