PennyDreadful
Penny Dreadful Sunday R4 v Sad Man Cody
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
bakert99,MrSad

== Game 1 (663720080) ==
[Time] 1550433893
[07:04:54] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 11.04
[Gatherling] Round=4
[07:05:12] [CHAT] MrSad: glhf
[07:05:16] bakert99 chooses to play first.
[07:05:20] [CHAT] bakert99: bllf
[07:05:24] [CHAT] bakert99: (bad luck lose fast)
[07:05:25] [CHAT] MrSad: low fun?
[07:05:25] [CHAT] bakert99: :P
[07:05:26] [CHAT] MrSad: oh
[07:05:28] bakert99 keeps this hand.
[07:05:33] MrSad mulligans to 6 cards.
[07:05:35] MrSad keeps this hand.
[07:05:36] [CHAT] bakert99: :D
[07:05:44] [CHAT] bakert99: you can take a loss here i assume
[07:05:48] [CHAT] bakert99: but i will beat you fair and square
[07:05:52] [CHAT] MrSad: angling for a freebie :P
[07:05:59] [CHAT] bakert99: never!
[07:06:02] [CHAT] bakert99: well
[07:06:03] [CHAT] bakert99: sometimes
[07:06:04] [CHAT] bakert99: but not now
[07:06:05] [CHAT] bakert99: :D
[07:06:15] MrSad puts 1 card on top of their library.
[07:06:15] Turn 1: bakert99
[07:06:15] bakert99 skips their draw step.
[07:06:18] bakert99 plays [Mountain].
[07:06:20] Turn 1: MrSad
[07:06:20] [CHAT] MrSad: haha
[07:06:24] MrSad plays [Plains].
[07:06:27] MrSad casts [Doomed Traveler].
[07:06:30] Turn 2: bakert99
[07:06:32] bakert99 plays [Swamp].
[07:06:34] bakert99 casts [Carrier Thrall].
[07:06:36] Turn 2: MrSad
[07:07:04] bakert99 is being attacked by [Doomed Traveler].
[07:07:09] MrSad plays [Plains].
[07:07:30] MrSad casts [Precinct Captain].
[07:07:31] Turn 3: bakert99
[07:07:34] bakert99 plays [Mountain].
[07:07:49] bakert99 casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Precinct Captain].
[07:07:56] MrSad is being attacked by [Carrier Thrall].
[07:07:59] Turn 3: MrSad
[07:08:20] bakert99 is being attacked by [Doomed Traveler].
[07:08:26] MrSad casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[07:08:30] MrSad casts [Student of Warfare].
[07:08:37] bakert99 casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Student of Warfare].
[07:08:39] Turn 4: bakert99
[07:08:41] bakert99 plays [Nomad Outpost].
[07:08:45] bakert99 casts [Grim Haruspex].
[07:08:48] Turn 4: MrSad
[07:09:32] MrSad casts [Student of Warfare].
[07:09:54] Turn 5: bakert99
[07:10:01] bakert99 casts [Mimic Vat].
[07:10:01] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Mimic Vat[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Mimic Vat will return previously exiled card to the graveyard incorrectly if you say 'Yes' to the trigger when the target has been exiled
[07:10:15] Turn 5: MrSad
[07:11:01] MrSad plays [Plains].
[07:11:06] MrSad casts [Bygone Bishop].
[07:11:17] Turn 6: bakert99
[07:11:26] bakert99 casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting MrSad.
[07:12:10] MrSad discards [Brave the Elements].
[07:12:10] MrSad reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Honor of the Pure].
[07:12:17] [CHAT] bakert99: well that was tough
[07:12:27] Turn 6: MrSad
[07:12:36] [CHAT] MrSad: you definitely took the one i didn't want you to take
[07:12:39] [CHAT] MrSad: XD
[07:12:45] [CHAT] bakert99: i mean they're both great
[07:12:54] [CHAT] bakert99: but one of them wins you the game the other one just makes my job a lot harder
[07:13:51] MrSad casts [Honor of the Pure].
[07:14:08] bakert99 is being attacked by [Bygone Bishop].
[07:14:15] MrSad activates an ability of [Student of Warfare] (Level up).
[07:14:17] MrSad plays [Plains].
[07:14:18] MrSad activates an ability of [Student of Warfare] (Level up).
[07:14:25] bakert99 casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Student of Warfare].
[07:14:25] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature dies, you may exile that card. If you do, return each other card exil...).
[07:14:35] Turn 7: bakert99
[07:14:50] bakert99 casts [Whip of Erebos].
[07:14:55] Turn 7: MrSad
[07:15:08] bakert99 is being attacked by [Bygone Bishop].
[07:15:11] Turn 8: bakert99
[07:15:24] MrSad is being attacked by [Carrier Thrall].
[07:15:39] Turn 8: MrSad
[07:16:45] bakert99 is being attacked by [Bygone Bishop] and [Doomed Traveler].
[07:16:49] bakert99 activates an ability of [Mimic Vat] ( Create a token that's a copy of a card exiled with Mimic Vat. It gains haste. Exile it at the beg...).
[07:16:51] bakert99's [Mimic Vat] creates a Student of Warfare.
[07:16:58] [Student of Warfare] blocks [Doomed Traveler].
[07:17:06] MrSad casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[07:17:06] MrSad puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[07:17:09] MrSad's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[07:17:14] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Exile tokens.).
[07:17:21] Turn 9: bakert99
[07:17:23] bakert99 plays [Swamp].
[07:18:12] MrSad activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[07:18:15] swahili has started watching.
[07:18:22] bakert99 casts [Burst Lightning] (with kicker) targeting [Bygone Bishop].
[07:18:26] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature dies, you may exile that card. If you do, return each other card exil...).
[07:18:34] MrSad draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[07:18:38] Turn 9: MrSad
[07:18:48] MrSad casts [Hunted Witness].
[07:18:50] Turn 10: bakert99
[07:19:03] MrSad is being attacked by [Carrier Thrall].
[07:19:11] Turn 10: MrSad
[07:19:30] MrSad casts [Bygone Bishop].
[07:19:39] bakert99 activates an ability of [Mimic Vat] ( Create a token that's a copy of a card exiled with Mimic Vat. It gains haste. Exile it at the beg...).
[07:19:39] bakert99's [Mimic Vat] creates a Bygone Bishop.
[07:19:42] Turn 11: bakert99
[07:19:57] MrSad is being attacked by [Bygone Bishop].
[07:20:11] flac0 has started watching.
[07:20:13] [Bygone Bishop] blocks [Bygone Bishop].
[07:20:19] [CHAT] flac0: !record
[07:20:19] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:   0-0 
[07:20:24] bakert99 casts [Caldera Hellion].
[07:20:37] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Grim Haruspex] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature you control dies, draw a card.).
[07:20:38] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature dies, you may exile that card. If you do, return each other card exil...).
[07:20:39] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature dies, you may exile that card. If you do, return each other card exil...).
[07:20:40] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Carrier Thrall] onto the stack (When Carrier Thrall dies, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. It has 'Sacrifice t...).
[07:20:40] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Caldera Hellion] onto the stack (When Caldera Hellion enters the battlefield, it deals 3 damage to each creature.).
[07:20:43] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature dies, you may exile that card. If you do, return each other card exil...).
[07:20:43] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature dies, you may exile that card. If you do, return each other card exil...).
[07:20:43] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature dies, you may exile that card. If you do, return each other card exil...).
[07:20:43] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature dies, you may exile that card. If you do, return each other card exil...).
[07:20:43] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature dies, you may exile that card. If you do, return each other card exil...).
[07:20:45] MrSad puts triggered ability from [Hunted Witness] onto the stack (When Hunted Witness dies, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token with lifelink.).
[07:20:45] MrSad puts triggered ability from [Doomed Traveler] onto the stack (When Doomed Traveler dies, create a 1/1 white Spirit creature token with flying.).
[07:20:50] MrSad's [Doomed Traveler] creates a Spirit token.
[07:20:52] MrSad's [Hunted Witness] creates a Soldier token.
[07:21:02] bakert99 chooses not to use [Mimic Vat]'s ability.
[07:21:05] bakert99 chooses not to use [Mimic Vat]'s ability.
[07:21:09] bakert99 chooses not to use [Mimic Vat]'s ability.
[07:21:12] bakert99 chooses not to use [Mimic Vat]'s ability.
[07:21:14] Murpady has started watching.
[07:21:14] bakert99 chooses not to use [Mimic Vat]'s ability.
[07:21:15] bakert99's [Carrier Thrall] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[07:21:20] bakert99 chooses not to use [Mimic Vat]'s ability.
[07:21:22] bakert99 chooses not to use [Mimic Vat]'s ability.
[07:21:23] bakert99 draws a card with [Grim Haruspex]'s ability.
[07:21:25] bakert99 plays [Foreboding Ruins].
[07:21:28] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Exile tokens.).
[07:21:28] Turn 11: MrSad
[07:22:03] Turn 12: bakert99
[07:22:08] bakert99 activates an ability of [Mimic Vat] ( Create a token that's a copy of a card exiled with Mimic Vat. It gains haste. Exile it at the beg...).
[07:22:08] bakert99's [Mimic Vat] creates a Bygone Bishop.
[07:22:13] bakert99 casts [Liliana's Specter].
[07:22:13] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[07:22:14] bakert99's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[07:22:16] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Liliana's Specter] onto the stack (When Liliana's Specter enters the battlefield, each opponent discards a card.).
[07:22:21] MrSad discards [Plains].
[07:22:27] MrSad is being attacked by [Bygone Bishop] and [Caldera Hellion].
[07:22:29] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Exile tokens.).
[07:22:29] Turn 12: MrSad
[07:22:39] MrSad casts [Honor of the Pure].
[07:22:51] Turn 13: bakert99
[07:22:58] bakert99 activates an ability of [Mimic Vat] ( Create a token that's a copy of a card exiled with Mimic Vat. It gains haste. Exile it at the beg...).
[07:23:01] bakert99's [Mimic Vat] creates a Bygone Bishop.
[07:23:15] bakert99 casts [Bedeck] targeting [Spirit] token.
[07:23:23] bakert99 casts [Dusk Legion Zealot].
[07:23:23] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[07:23:25] bakert99's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[07:23:26] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Dusk Legion Zealot] onto the stack (When Dusk Legion Zealot enters the battlefield, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[07:23:28] bakert99 draws a card with [Dusk Legion Zealot]'s ability.
[07:23:29] bakert99 plays [Lavaclaw Reaches].
[07:23:33] MrSad is being attacked by [Bygone Bishop], [Liliana's Specter], and [Caldera Hellion].
[07:23:34] [Soldier] token blocks [Caldera Hellion].
[07:23:37] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Exile tokens.).
[07:23:37] Turn 13: MrSad
[07:23:39] MrSad plays [Plains].
[07:23:41] MrSad casts [Banisher Priest].
[07:23:45] MrSad puts triggered ability from [Banisher Priest] onto the stack targeting [Caldera Hellion] (When Banisher Priest enters the battlefield, exile target creature an opponent controls until Bani...).
[07:23:46] Turn 14: bakert99
[07:23:55] bakert99 activates an ability of [Lavaclaw Reaches] ( Until end of turn, Lavaclaw Reaches becomes a 2/2 black and red Elemental creature with '{X}: Thi...).
[07:24:05] MrSad is being attacked by [Lavaclaw Reaches], [Dusk Legion Zealot], and [Liliana's Specter].
[07:24:14] [Banisher Priest] blocks [Lavaclaw Reaches].
[07:24:18] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature dies, you may exile that card. If you do, return each other card exil...).
[07:24:23] bakert99 chooses not to use [Mimic Vat]'s ability.
[07:24:27] bakert99 casts [Liliana's Specter].
[07:24:27] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Liliana's Specter] onto the stack (When Liliana's Specter enters the battlefield, each opponent discards a card.).
[07:24:31] MrSad discards [Plains].
[07:24:31] Turn 14: MrSad
[07:24:42] Turn 15: bakert99
[07:24:47] MrSad is being attacked by [Liliana's Specter] and [Liliana's Specter].
Winner: bakert99
Game 1 Completed.
[07:24:53] Murpady has stopped watching.

== Game 2 (663722794) ==
[Time] 1550435185
[07:26:26] PDBot has started watching.
[07:26:55] MrSad mulligans to 6 cards.
[07:26:58] bakert99 keeps this hand.
[07:27:00] MrSad mulligans to 5 cards.
[07:27:03] MrSad keeps this hand.
[07:27:06] MrSad puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[07:27:06] Turn 1: MrSad
[07:27:08] MrSad skips their draw step.
[07:27:09] MrSad plays [Plains].
[07:27:10] MrSad casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[07:27:15] Turn 1: bakert99
[07:27:17] bakert99 plays [Foreboding Ruins].
[07:27:20] Turn 2: MrSad
[07:27:22] MrSad plays [Plains].
[07:27:27] bakert99 is being attacked by [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[07:27:34] MrSad casts [Precinct Captain].
[07:27:39] bakert99 casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Precinct Captain].
[07:27:41] Turn 2: bakert99
[07:27:43] bakert99 plays [Foreboding Ruins].
[07:27:48] bakert99 casts [Carrier Thrall].
[07:27:50] Turn 3: MrSad
[07:28:00] MrSad casts [Hunted Witness].
[07:28:05] Turn 3: bakert99
[07:28:14] bakert99 plays [Swamp].
[07:28:18] bakert99 casts [Liliana's Specter].
[07:28:18] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Liliana's Specter] onto the stack (When Liliana's Specter enters the battlefield, each opponent discards a card.).
[07:28:27] MrSad discards [Stasis Snare].
[07:28:30] Turn 4: MrSad
[07:28:31] swahili has stopped watching.
[07:28:43] MrSad casts [Honor of the Pure].
[07:28:50] bakert99 is being attacked by [Hunted Witness].
[07:28:56] [Carrier Thrall] blocks [Hunted Witness].
[07:28:57] MrSad puts triggered ability from [Hunted Witness] onto the stack (When Hunted Witness dies, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token with lifelink.).
[07:28:58] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Carrier Thrall] onto the stack (When Carrier Thrall dies, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. It has 'Sacrifice t...).
[07:28:58] bakert99's [Carrier Thrall] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[07:28:58] MrSad's [Hunted Witness] creates a Soldier token.
[07:28:58] Turn 4: bakert99
[07:29:05] bakert99 plays [Lavaclaw Reaches].
[07:29:12] Turn 5: MrSad
[07:29:19] MrSad casts [Honor of the Pure].
[07:29:30] bakert99 is being attacked by [Soldier] token and [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[07:29:38] bakert99 casts [Bedeck] targeting [Soldier] token.
[07:29:38] MrSad puts triggered ability from [Soldier of the Pantheon] onto the stack (Whenever an opponent casts a multicolored spell, you gain 1 life.).
[07:29:45] [Liliana's Specter] blocks [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[07:29:47] [Eldrazi Scion] token blocks [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[07:29:48] flac0 has started watching.
[07:29:51] Blockers for [Soldier of the Pantheon] are ordered as follows: [Liliana's Specter], [Eldrazi Scion] token
[07:29:55] Turn 5: bakert99
[07:29:58] bakert99 plays [Mountain].
[07:30:02] bakert99 casts [Carrier Thrall].
[07:30:07] Turn 6: MrSad
[07:30:11] MrSad casts [Doomed Traveler].
[07:30:18] Turn 6: bakert99
[07:30:23] bakert99 plays [Swamp].
[07:30:27] bakert99 casts [Whip of Erebos].
[07:30:38] Turn 7: MrSad
[07:30:50] Murpady has started watching.
[07:31:04] bakert99 is being attacked by [Doomed Traveler].
[07:31:14] MrSad casts [Sundering Growth] targeting [Whip of Erebos].
[07:31:17] Phyrexian_Machinist has started watching.
[07:31:19] MrSad has no creature tokens to copy.
[07:31:21] Turn 7: bakert99
[07:31:26] bakert99 casts [Whip of Erebos].
[07:31:33] MrSad is being attacked by [Carrier Thrall].
[07:31:34] Turn 8: MrSad
[07:31:41] bakert99 is being attacked by [Doomed Traveler].
[07:31:46] MrSad casts [Doomed Traveler].
[07:31:50] Turn 8: bakert99
[07:32:02] bakert99 activates an ability of [Whip of Erebos] targeting [Liliana's Specter] ( Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. It gains haste. Exile it at t...).
[07:32:04] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Liliana's Specter] onto the stack (When Liliana's Specter enters the battlefield, each opponent discards a card.).
[07:32:08] MrSad discards [Plains].
[07:32:17] MrSad is being attacked by [Liliana's Specter].
[07:32:22] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Whip of Erebos] onto the stack (Exile Liliana's Specter at the beginning of the next end step.).
[07:32:25] Turn 9: MrSad
[07:32:37] bakert99 is being attacked by [Doomed Traveler] and [Doomed Traveler].
[07:32:41] [Carrier Thrall] blocks [Doomed Traveler].
[07:32:43] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Carrier Thrall] onto the stack (When Carrier Thrall dies, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. It has 'Sacrifice t...).
[07:32:45] bakert99's [Carrier Thrall] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[07:32:50] MrSad casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[07:33:07] bakert99 casts [Terror] targeting [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[07:33:09] Turn 9: bakert99
[07:33:10] bakert99 plays [Mountain].
[07:33:14] bakert99 activates an ability of [Lavaclaw Reaches] ( Until end of turn, Lavaclaw Reaches becomes a 2/2 black and red Elemental creature with '{X}: Thi...).
[07:33:24] MrSad is being attacked by [Eldrazi Scion] token and [Lavaclaw Reaches].
[07:33:30] bakert99 activates an ability of [Lavaclaw Reaches]. (X is 3) ( This creature gets +X/+0 until end of turn.).
[07:33:32] Turn 10: MrSad
[07:34:24] bakert99 is being attacked by [Doomed Traveler].
[07:34:30] MrSad casts [Absolute Law].
[07:34:30] Turn 10: bakert99
[07:34:40] bakert99 plays [Swamp].
[07:34:47] bakert99 activates an ability of [Whip of Erebos] targeting [Carrier Thrall] ( Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. It gains haste. Exile it at t...).
[07:34:53] Sami8s has started watching.
[07:34:54] MrSad is being attacked by [Carrier Thrall].
[07:35:02] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Whip of Erebos] onto the stack (Exile Carrier Thrall at the beginning of the next end step.).
[07:35:03] Turn 11: MrSad
[07:35:26] bakert99 is being attacked by [Doomed Traveler].
[07:35:34] Turn 11: bakert99
[07:35:39] bakert99 activates an ability of [Whip of Erebos] targeting [Carrier Thrall] ( Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. It gains haste. Exile it at t...).
[07:35:47] MrSad is being attacked by [Carrier Thrall].
[07:35:52] bakert99 plays [Lavaclaw Reaches].
[07:35:54] bakert99 puts triggered ability from [Whip of Erebos] onto the stack (Exile Carrier Thrall at the beginning of the next end step.).
[07:35:57] Turn 12: MrSad
[07:36:02] MrSad plays [Plains].
[07:38:23] [CHAT] Murpady: !record
[07:38:23] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  bakert99 1-0 MrSad
[07:38:35] bakert99 is being attacked by [Doomed Traveler].
[07:38:46] Turn 12: bakert99
[07:38:48] bakert99 plays [Swamp].
[07:38:52] bakert99 activates an ability of [Lavaclaw Reaches] ( Until end of turn, Lavaclaw Reaches becomes a 2/2 black and red Elemental creature with '{X}: Thi...).
[07:38:58] bakert99 activates an ability of [Lavaclaw Reaches] ( Until end of turn, Lavaclaw Reaches becomes a 2/2 black and red Elemental creature with '{X}: Thi...).
[07:39:09] MrSad is being attacked by [Lavaclaw Reaches], [Eldrazi Scion] token, and [Lavaclaw Reaches].
[07:39:16] [Doomed Traveler] blocks [Lavaclaw Reaches].
[07:39:25] bakert99 activates an ability of [Lavaclaw Reaches]. (X is 2) ( This creature gets +X/+0 until end of turn.).
[07:39:28] Turn 13: MrSad
[07:39:55] MrSad casts [Banisher Priest].
[07:39:55] MrSad puts triggered ability from [Banisher Priest] onto the stack targeting [Eldrazi Scion] token (When Banisher Priest enters the battlefield, exile target creature an opponent controls until Bani...).
[07:40:03] bakert99 is being attacked by [Doomed Traveler] and [Doomed Traveler].
[07:40:05] Turn 13: bakert99
[07:40:10] bakert99 casts [Burst Lightning] targeting MrSad.
Winner: bakert99
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: bakert99: 2–0
[07:40:24] MrSad has left the game.