PennyDreadful
pdt r4 vs Ashamael
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
Ashamael,Rhispin

== Game 1 (662553136) ==
[Time] 1549591756
[13:09:16] PDBot has started watching.
[13:09:16] Rhispin joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Thursdays 11.02
[Gatherling] Round=4
[13:09:24] Ashamael chooses to play first.
[13:09:28] Ashamael keeps this hand.
[13:09:42] Rhispin keeps this hand.
[13:09:42] Turn 1: Ashamael
[13:09:47] Ashamael skips their draw step.
[13:09:56] Ashamael plays [Plains].
[13:10:00] Turn 1: Rhispin
[13:10:04] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:10:18] Rhispin casts [Treefolk Harbinger].
[13:10:20] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Treefolk Harbinger] onto the stack (When Treefolk Harbinger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a Treefolk or Fore...).
[13:10:32] Rhispin reveals [Bosk Banneret].
[13:10:43] Turn 2: Ashamael
[13:10:55] Ashamael plays [Island].
[13:11:02] Turn 2: Rhispin
[13:11:08] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:11:13] Rhispin casts [Gyre Sage].
[13:11:29] Turn 3: Ashamael
[13:11:36] Ashamael plays [Sunken Hollow].
[13:11:47] Ashamael casts [Painful Truths] (with 3 colors).
[13:11:54] Ashamael draws three cards with [Painful Truths].
[13:12:04] Ashamael discards [Tainted Remedy].
[13:12:04] Turn 3: Rhispin
[13:12:12] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:12:19] Rhispin casts [Bosk Banneret].
[13:12:23] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Gyre Sage] onto the stack (Evolve (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, if that creature has grea...).
[13:12:43] Ashamael is being attacked by [Gyre Sage].
[13:12:48] Turn 4: Ashamael
[13:13:06] Ashamael plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[13:13:15] Turn 4: Rhispin
[13:13:20] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:13:34] Rhispin casts [Dauntless Dourbark].
[13:13:40] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Gyre Sage] onto the stack (Evolve (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, if that creature has grea...).
[13:14:05] Rhispin casts [Dauntless Dourbark].
[13:14:08] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Gyre Sage] onto the stack (Evolve (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, if that creature has grea...).
[13:14:23] Ashamael casts [Anticipate].
[13:14:34] flac0 has started watching.
[13:14:52] Ashamael put a card on the bottom of the library.
[13:14:52] Ashamael put a card on the bottom of the library.
[13:15:00] Ashamael is being attacked by [Bosk Banneret].
[13:15:08] Turn 5: Ashamael
[13:15:22] Ashamael plays [Tranquil Cove].
[13:15:22] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Tranquil Cove] onto the stack (When Tranquil Cove enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[13:15:32] Ashamael casts [Tainted Remedy].
[13:15:40] Turn 5: Rhispin
[13:15:43] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:15:50] Rhispin casts [Timber Protector].
[13:15:54] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Gyre Sage] onto the stack (Evolve (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, if that creature has grea...).
[13:16:09] Ashamael is being attacked by [Dauntless Dourbark], [Dauntless Dourbark], [Bosk Banneret], [Gyre Sage], and [Treefolk Harbinger].
[13:16:11] Ashamael has conceded from the game.
Winner: Rhispin
Game 1 Completed.
[13:16:13] flac0 has stopped watching.
[13:16:14] Ashamael has left the game.

== Game 2 (662554116) ==
[Time] 1549592316
[13:18:37] PDBot has started watching.
[13:18:39] Ashamael chooses to play first.
[13:18:43] Ashamael keeps this hand.
[13:18:47] Rhispin keeps this hand.
[13:18:47] Turn 1: Ashamael
[13:18:49] Ashamael skips their draw step.
[13:18:51] Ashamael plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[13:18:55] Turn 1: Rhispin
[13:18:58] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:19:05] Turn 2: Ashamael
[13:19:10] Ashamael plays [Island].
[13:19:15] Turn 2: Rhispin
[13:19:18] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:19:21] Rhispin casts [Beastcaller Savant].
[13:19:28] Ashamael casts [Anticipate].
[13:19:39] Ashamael put a card on the bottom of the library.
[13:19:39] Ashamael put a card on the bottom of the library.
[13:19:50] Ashamael is being attacked by [Beastcaller Savant].
[13:19:54] Turn 3: Ashamael
[13:20:07] Ashamael plays [Choked Estuary].
[13:20:15] Turn 3: Rhispin
[13:20:18] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:20:24] Rhispin casts [Carven Caryatid].
[13:20:26] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Carven Caryatid] onto the stack (When Carven Caryatid enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
[13:20:29] Rhispin draws a card with [Carven Caryatid]'s ability.
[13:20:38] Ashamael is being attacked by [Beastcaller Savant].
[13:20:45] Ashamael casts [Anticipate].
[13:20:58] Ashamael put a card on the bottom of the library.
[13:20:58] Ashamael put a card on the bottom of the library.
[13:21:02] Turn 4: Ashamael
[13:21:50] Ashamael plays [Plains].
[13:22:02] Turn 4: Rhispin
[13:22:06] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:22:21] Rhispin casts [Heartwood Storyteller].
[13:22:38] Rhispin casts [Treefolk Harbinger].
[13:22:42] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Treefolk Harbinger] onto the stack (When Treefolk Harbinger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a Treefolk or Fore...).
[13:22:49] Rhispin reveals [Dauntless Dourbark].
[13:22:58] Ashamael is being attacked by [Beastcaller Savant].
[13:23:17] Turn 5: Ashamael
[13:23:44] Ashamael plays [Sunken Hollow].
[13:23:44] Ashamael casts [End Hostilities].
[13:23:45] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Heartwood Storyteller] onto the stack (Whenever a player casts a noncreature spell, each of that player's opponents may draw a card.).
[13:23:47] Rhispin draws a card with [Heartwood Storyteller]'s ability.
[13:23:55] Turn 5: Rhispin
[13:23:58] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:24:34] Rhispin casts [Battlewand Oak].
[13:24:48] Turn 6: Ashamael
[13:24:58] Ashamael plays [Island].
[13:25:04] Turn 6: Rhispin
[13:25:07] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:25:07] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Battlewand Oak] onto the stack (Whenever a Forest enters the battlefield under your control, Battlewand Oak gets +2/+2 until end o...).
[13:25:14] Rhispin casts [Rootgrapple] targeting [Arcane Sanctum].
[13:25:14] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Battlewand Oak] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Treefolk spell, Battlewand Oak gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[13:25:31] Rhispin draws a card with [Rootgrapple].
[13:25:39] Ashamael is being attacked by [Battlewand Oak].
[13:25:43] Turn 7: Ashamael
[13:25:47] Ashamael plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[13:25:55] Turn 7: Rhispin
[13:25:59] Rhispin casts [Bosk Banneret].
[13:25:59] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Battlewand Oak] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Treefolk spell, Battlewand Oak gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[13:26:12] Rhispin casts [Dauntless Dourbark].
[13:26:12] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Battlewand Oak] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a Treefolk spell, Battlewand Oak gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[13:26:38] Ashamael is being attacked by [Battlewand Oak].
[13:26:49] Turn 8: Ashamael
[13:26:56] Ashamael casts [Nature's Ruin].
[13:27:00] Ashamael plays [Swamp].
[13:27:06] Turn 8: Rhispin
[13:27:19] Seven47 has started watching.
[13:27:28] Rhispin casts [Bosk Banneret].
[13:27:33] Rhispin casts [Abzan Beastmaster].
[13:27:52] Ashamael casts [Azorius Charm] (Draw a card.).
[13:27:54] Ashamael draws a card with [Azorius Charm].
[13:27:56] Turn 9: Ashamael
[13:28:12] Ashamael casts [Nature's Ruin].
[13:28:18] Turn 9: Rhispin
[13:28:22] Rhispin casts [Treefolk Harbinger].
[13:28:24] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Treefolk Harbinger] onto the stack (When Treefolk Harbinger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a Treefolk or Fore...).
[13:28:34] Rhispin reveals [Timber Protector].
[13:28:50] Turn 10: Ashamael
[13:29:02] Turn 10: Rhispin
[13:29:07] Rhispin casts [Timber Protector].
[13:29:13] Ashamael casts [Rune Snag] targeting [Timber Protector].
[13:29:26] Ashamael casts [Azorius Charm] (Draw a card.).
[13:29:28] Ashamael draws a card with [Azorius Charm].
[13:29:30] Turn 11: Ashamael
[13:29:41] Ashamael casts [Treasure Cruise].
[13:29:43] Ashamael draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[13:29:46] Ashamael plays [Island].
[13:29:54] Turn 11: Rhispin
[13:29:58] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:30:04] Rhispin casts [Dauntless Dourbark].
[13:30:10] Ashamael casts [Think Twice].
[13:30:13] Ashamael draws a card with [Think Twice].
[13:30:26] Ashamael casts [Think Twice].
[13:30:28] Ashamael draws a card with [Think Twice].
[13:30:44] Ashamael casts [Think Twice] from the graveyard.
[13:30:45] Ashamael draws a card with [Think Twice].
[13:30:53] Turn 12: Ashamael
[13:30:59] Ashamael casts [Ulcerate] targeting [Treefolk Harbinger].
[13:31:10] Ashamael casts [Consuming Vapors] targeting Rhispin.
[13:31:15] Rhispin sacrifices [Dauntless Dourbark].
[13:31:28] Ashamael plays [Plains].
[13:31:40] Ashamael casts [Painful Truths] (with 3 colors).
[13:31:43] Ashamael draws three cards with [Painful Truths].
[13:31:49] Turn 12: Rhispin
[13:31:55] Turn 13: Ashamael
[13:31:56] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Consuming Vapors] onto the stack (Rebound (If you cast this spell from your hand, exile it as it resolves. At the beginning of you...).
[13:32:03] Ashamael casts [Consuming Vapors] targeting Ashamael.
[13:32:15] Ashamael plays [Choked Estuary].
[13:32:52] Ashamael casts [Treasure Cruise].
[13:32:55] Ashamael draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[13:33:14] Ashamael casts [Careful Consideration] (Enhanced) targeting Ashamael.
[13:33:14] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Careful Consideration[sU] has an unclassified bug.
Copy spells that care about being cast during a main phase such as Careful Consideration sometimes do not confer the main phase bonus.
[13:33:18] Ashamael draws four cards with [Careful Consideration].
[13:33:26] Ashamael discards [Choked Estuary].
[13:33:26] Ashamael discards [Arcane Sanctum].
[13:33:40] Ashamael discards [Swamp].
[13:33:44] Ashamael discards [Island].
[13:33:49] Ashamael discards [Plains].
[13:33:50] Turn 13: Rhispin
[13:33:59] Rhispin casts [Bosk Banneret].
[13:34:06] Turn 14: Ashamael
[13:34:09] Ashamael plays [Plains].
[13:34:13] Ashamael casts [Tainted Remedy].
[13:34:27] Ashamael casts [Beacon of Immortality] targeting Rhispin.
[13:34:51] Rhispin casts [Crushing Canopy] targeting [Tainted Remedy] (Destroy target enchantment.).
[13:34:56] Ashamael casts [Rune Snag] targeting [Crushing Canopy].
Winner: Ashamael
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (662556022) ==
[Time] 1549593434
[13:37:15] PDBot has started watching.
[13:37:20] Rhispin keeps this hand.
[13:37:24] Ashamael keeps this hand.
[13:37:24] Turn 1: Rhispin
[13:37:26] Rhispin skips their draw step.
[13:37:28] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:37:31] Turn 1: Ashamael
[13:37:36] Ashamael plays [Tranquil Cove].
[13:37:36] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Tranquil Cove] onto the stack (When Tranquil Cove enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[13:37:38] Turn 2: Rhispin
[13:37:41] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:37:46] Turn 2: Ashamael
[13:37:53] Ashamael plays [Plains].
[13:37:57] Turn 3: Rhispin
[13:38:00] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:38:04] Rhispin casts [Carven Caryatid].
[13:38:08] Rhispin puts triggered ability from [Carven Caryatid] onto the stack (When Carven Caryatid enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
[13:38:12] Ashamael casts [Anticipate].
[13:38:20] Murpady has started watching.
[13:38:26] Ashamael put a card on the bottom of the library.
[13:38:27] Ashamael put a card on the bottom of the library.
[13:38:29] Rhispin draws a card with [Carven Caryatid]'s ability.
[13:38:33] Turn 3: Ashamael
[13:38:38] Ashamael plays [Choked Estuary].
[13:38:49] Turn 4: Rhispin
[13:38:52] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:39:08] Rhispin casts [Battlewand Oak].
[13:39:13] Ashamael casts [Rune Snag] targeting [Battlewand Oak].
[13:39:15] bakert99 has started watching.
[13:39:23] Turn 4: Ashamael
[13:39:32] Ashamael plays [Island].
[13:39:40] Ashamael casts [Painful Truths] (with 3 colors).
[13:39:42] Ashamael draws three cards with [Painful Truths].
[13:40:07] Ashamael discards [Anticipate].
[13:40:07] Turn 5: Rhispin
[13:40:14] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:40:24] Rhispin casts [Timber Protector].
[13:40:33] Turn 5: Ashamael
[13:40:38] Ashamael plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[13:40:41] Ashamael casts [Nature's Ruin].
[13:40:44] dacowftw has started watching.
[13:40:48] Turn 6: Rhispin
[13:40:50] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:40:52] Rhispin casts [Gaea's Herald].
[13:40:58] Rhispin casts [Dauntless Dourbark].
[13:41:05] Turn 6: Ashamael
[13:41:45] Ashamael casts [Treasure Cruise].
[13:41:49] Ashamael draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[13:41:53] Ashamael plays [Choked Estuary].
[13:42:10] Ashamael discards [Painful Truths].
[13:42:10] Turn 7: Rhispin
[13:42:16] [CHAT] dacowftw: !record
[13:42:17] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  Rhispin 1-1 Ashamael
[13:42:41] Ashamael is being attacked by [Dauntless Dourbark] and [Gaea's Herald].
[13:42:45] Ashamael casts [Condemn] targeting [Dauntless Dourbark].
[13:43:09] Rhispin casts [Dauntless Dourbark].
[13:43:14] Turn 7: Ashamael
[13:43:23] Ashamael plays [Sunken Hollow].
[13:43:39] Ashamael casts [Tainted Remedy].
[13:43:47] Turn 8: Rhispin
[13:43:57] Rhispin plays [Forest].
[13:44:00] Rhispin casts [Insist].
[13:44:04] Rhispin draws a card with [Insist].
[13:44:11] Rhispin casts [Abzan Beastmaster].
[13:44:22] Ashamael is being attacked by [Dauntless Dourbark] and [Gaea's Herald].
[13:44:31] Ashamael casts [Azorius Charm] targeting [Dauntless Dourbark] (Put target attacking or blocking creature on top of its owner's library.).
[13:44:37] Rhispin casts [Back to Nature].
[13:44:43] Ashamael casts [Rune Snag] targeting [Back to Nature].
[13:44:59] Turn 8: Ashamael
[13:45:07] Ashamael casts [Beacon of Immortality] targeting Rhispin.
[13:45:15] bakert99 has stopped watching.
Winner: Ashamael
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Ashamael: 2–1
[13:45:22] Ashamael has left the game.
[13:45:27] Rhispin draws their next card.
[13:45:28] Rhispin draws their next card.
[13:45:29] Rhispin draws their next card.
[13:45:36] Rhispin draws their next card.
[13:45:38] Rhispin draws their next card.
[13:45:39] Rhispin draws their next card.
[13:45:40] Rhispin draws their next card.