PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Gibble,thejacob == Game 1 (661967968) == [Time] 1549161045 [13:30:47] PDBot has started watching. [League] Sultai Emerge by gibble (35171) vs Greed Pile by thejacob (35500) [13:30:49] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [13:30:52] thejacob chooses to play first. [13:30:53] [CHAT] Gibble: hi gl hf [13:30:54] thejacob keeps this hand. [13:30:55] Gibble mulligans to 6 cards. [13:30:57] Gibble keeps this hand. [13:30:59] Gibble puts 1 card on top of their library. [13:30:59] Turn 1: thejacob [13:31:01] thejacob skips their draw step. [13:31:02] thejacob plays [Nomad Outpost]. [13:31:04] Turn 1: Gibble [13:31:06] Gibble plays [Lumbering Falls]. [13:31:08] Turn 2: thejacob [13:31:10] thejacob plays [Nomad Outpost]. [13:31:12] Turn 2: Gibble [13:31:14] Gibble plays [Swamp]. [13:31:16] Gibble casts [Dusk Legion Zealot]. [13:31:16] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Dusk Legion Zealot] onto the stack (When Dusk Legion Zealot enters the battlefield, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.). [13:31:17] Gibble draws a card with [Dusk Legion Zealot]'s ability. [13:31:17] Turn 3: thejacob [13:31:21] thejacob casts [Boros Signet]. [13:31:24] thejacob plays [Arcane Sanctum]. [13:31:24] Turn 3: Gibble [13:31:29] thejacob is being attacked by [Dusk Legion Zealot]. [13:31:33] Gibble plays [Swamp]. [13:31:35] Gibble casts [Viridian Emissary]. [13:31:36] Turn 4: thejacob [13:32:11] thejacob casts [Radiant Flames] (with 3 colors). [13:32:14] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Viridian Emissary] onto the stack (When Viridian Emissary dies, you may search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the ba...). [13:32:21] thejacob plays [Lavaclaw Reaches]. [13:32:24] Turn 4: Gibble [13:32:37] Gibble casts [Whip of Erebos]. [13:32:43] Turn 5: thejacob [13:32:56] thejacob casts [Painful Truths] (with 3 colors). [13:32:57] thejacob draws three cards with [Painful Truths]. [13:32:59] thejacob plays [Evolving Wilds]. [13:33:02] Turn 5: Gibble [13:33:09] Gibble casts [Sylvan Ranger]. [13:33:11] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...). [13:33:15] Gibble reveals [Forest]. [13:33:16] Gibble plays [Forest]. [13:33:20] Gibble casts [Viridian Emissary]. [13:33:25] thejacob activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [13:33:29] Turn 6: thejacob [13:33:42] thejacob casts [Painful Truths] (with 3 colors). [13:33:43] thejacob draws three cards with [Painful Truths]. [13:33:57] thejacob casts [Mardu Charm] targeting Gibble (Target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a noncreature, nonland card from it. That player di...). [13:34:12] Gibble reveals their hand to [Mardu Charm], containing [Nekrataal], [Edric, Spymaster of Trest], [Foul Emissary], and [Elder Deep-Fiend]. [13:34:19] thejacob discards [Decree of Justice]. [13:34:19] Turn 6: Gibble [13:34:26] Gibble casts [Edric, Spymaster of Trest]. [13:34:28] thejacob is being attacked by [Viridian Emissary] and [Sylvan Ranger]. [13:34:31] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Edric, Spymaster of Trest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature deals combat damage to one of your opponents, its controller may draw a card.). [13:34:31] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Edric, Spymaster of Trest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature deals combat damage to one of your opponents, its controller may draw a card.). [13:34:37] Gibble plays [Choked Estuary]. [13:34:41] Gibble casts [Viridian Emissary]. [13:34:42] Turn 7: thejacob [13:34:51] thejacob casts [Radiant Flames] (with 2 colors). [13:34:52] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Viridian Emissary] onto the stack (When Viridian Emissary dies, you may search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the ba...). [13:34:52] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Viridian Emissary] onto the stack (When Viridian Emissary dies, you may search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the ba...). [13:35:09] thejacob casts [Treasure Cruise]. [13:35:10] thejacob draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise]. [13:35:12] thejacob plays [Nomad Outpost]. [13:35:16] thejacob discards [Evolving Wilds]. [13:35:16] Turn 7: Gibble [13:35:19] Gibble plays [Choked Estuary]. [13:35:23] Gibble casts [Foul Emissary]. [13:35:27] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When Foul Emissary enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library. You may rev...). [13:35:31] Gibble puts [Fleshbag Marauder] into their hand with with [Foul Emissary]'s ability. [13:35:39] Turn 8: thejacob [13:35:44] Gibble casts [Elder Deep-Fiend], emerging from [Foul Emissary]. [13:35:45] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When you sacrifice Foul Emissary while casting a spell with emerge, create a 3/2 colorless Eldrazi...). [13:35:49] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Elder Deep-Fiend] onto the stack targeting [Nomad Outpost], [Nomad Outpost], [Nomad Outpost], and [Arcane Sanctum] (When you cast this spell, tap up to four target permanents.). [13:36:07] Gibble's [Foul Emissary] creates an Eldrazi Horror token. [13:36:42] thejacob casts [Crackling Doom]. [13:36:54] thejacob casts [Pulse of the Fields]. [13:36:59] thejacob plays [Lavaclaw Reaches]. [13:37:02] Turn 8: Gibble [13:37:08] Gibble casts [Foul Emissary]. [13:37:12] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When Foul Emissary enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library. You may rev...). [13:37:16] Gibble puts [Elder Deep-Fiend] into their hand with with [Foul Emissary]'s ability. [13:37:22] thejacob is being attacked by [Eldrazi Horror] token. [13:37:26] thejacob casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Eldrazi Horror] token. [13:37:42] Turn 9: thejacob [13:37:49] Gibble casts [Elder Deep-Fiend], emerging from [Foul Emissary]. [13:37:52] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When you sacrifice Foul Emissary while casting a spell with emerge, create a 3/2 colorless Eldrazi...). [13:37:56] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Elder Deep-Fiend] onto the stack targeting [Nomad Outpost], [Nomad Outpost], [Nomad Outpost], and [Lavaclaw Reaches] (When you cast this spell, tap up to four target permanents.). [13:38:23] thejacob casts [Pulse of the Fields]. [13:38:27] Gibble's [Foul Emissary] creates an Eldrazi Horror token. [13:38:30] thejacob casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Eldrazi Horror] token. [13:38:41] thejacob casts [Consuming Vapors] targeting Gibble. [13:38:45] Gibble sacrifices [Elder Deep-Fiend]. [13:38:46] Turn 9: Gibble [13:38:55] Turn 10: thejacob [13:38:55] thejacob puts triggered ability from [Consuming Vapors] onto the stack (Rebound (If you cast this spell from your hand, exile it as it resolves. At the beginning of you...). [13:38:59] thejacob casts [Consuming Vapors] targeting Gibble. [13:39:05] thejacob casts [Rakdos Signet]. [13:39:15] Gibble casts [Elder Deep-Fiend]. [13:39:23] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Elder Deep-Fiend] onto the stack targeting [Lavaclaw Reaches], [Nomad Outpost], [Lavaclaw Reaches], and [Nomad Outpost] (When you cast this spell, tap up to four target permanents.). [13:39:27] Turn 10: Gibble [13:39:54] Gibble activates an ability of [Whip of Erebos] targeting [Foul Emissary] ( Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. It gains haste. Exile it at t...). [13:39:56] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When Foul Emissary enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library. You may rev...). [13:40:00] Gibble puts [Elder Deep-Fiend] into their hand with with [Foul Emissary]'s ability. [13:40:03] Gibble plays [Golgari Guildgate]. [13:40:07] thejacob is being attacked by [Foul Emissary] and [Elder Deep-Fiend]. [13:40:24] Gibble casts [Lashweed Lurker], emerging from [Foul Emissary]. [13:40:25] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When you sacrifice Foul Emissary while casting a spell with emerge, create a 3/2 colorless Eldrazi...). [13:40:27] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Lashweed Lurker] onto the stack targeting [Rakdos Signet] (When you cast this spell, you may put target nonland permanent on top of its owner's library.). [13:40:34] Gibble's [Foul Emissary] creates an Eldrazi Horror token. [13:40:35] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Whip of Erebos] onto the stack (Exile Foul Emissary at the beginning of the next end step.). [13:40:38] Turn 11: thejacob [13:40:46] thejacob casts [Rakdos Signet]. [13:40:50] Turn 11: Gibble [13:41:04] Gibble activates an ability of [Whip of Erebos] targeting [Edric, Spymaster of Trest] ( Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. It gains haste. Exile it at t...). [13:41:14] thejacob is being attacked by [Edric, Spymaster of Trest], [Eldrazi Horror] token, [Lashweed Lurker], and [Elder Deep-Fiend]. [13:41:28] thejacob discards [Decree of Justice]. [13:41:28] thejacob cycles [Decree of Justice]. [13:41:28] thejacob puts triggered ability from [Decree of Justice] onto the stack (When you cycle Decree of Justice, you may pay {X}. If you do, create X 1/1 white Soldier creature ...). [13:41:38] thejacob's [Decree of Justice] creates four Soldier tokens. [13:42:00] Gibble casts [Elder Deep-Fiend], emerging from [Lashweed Lurker]. [13:42:03] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Elder Deep-Fiend] onto the stack targeting [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, and [Soldier] token (When you cast this spell, tap up to four target permanents.). [13:42:11] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Edric, Spymaster of Trest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature deals combat damage to one of your opponents, its controller may draw a card.). [13:42:11] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Edric, Spymaster of Trest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature deals combat damage to one of your opponents, its controller may draw a card.). [13:42:11] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Edric, Spymaster of Trest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature deals combat damage to one of your opponents, its controller may draw a card.). [13:42:24] Gibble plays [Lumbering Falls]. [13:42:47] Gibble casts [Nekrataal]. [13:42:51] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Nekrataal] onto the stack targeting [Soldier] token (When Nekrataal enters the battlefield, destroy target nonartifact, nonblack creature. That creatur...). [13:42:55] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Whip of Erebos] onto the stack (Exile Edric, Spymaster of Trest at the beginning of the next end step.). [13:42:58] Turn 12: thejacob [13:43:29] thejacob casts [Radiant Flames] (with 3 colors). [13:43:37] thejacob casts [Consuming Vapors] targeting Gibble. [13:43:39] Gibble sacrifices [Elder Deep-Fiend]. [13:43:41] thejacob plays [Evolving Wilds]. [13:43:42] thejacob activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [13:43:49] Turn 12: Gibble [13:43:54] Gibble casts [Foul Emissary]. [13:43:54] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When Foul Emissary enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library. You may rev...). [13:43:57] Gibble puts [Arborback Stomper] into their hand with with [Foul Emissary]'s ability. [13:44:05] Gibble casts [Distended Mindbender], emerging from [Foul Emissary]. [13:44:05] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Distended Mindbender[sU] has a disadvantageous bug. When only some cards from an opponent's hand are revealed, they do not appear in the revealed zone [13:44:06] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When you sacrifice Foul Emissary while casting a spell with emerge, create a 3/2 colorless Eldrazi...). [13:44:06] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Distended Mindbender] onto the stack targeting thejacob (When you cast this spell, target opponent reveals their hand. You choose from it a nonland card wi...). [13:44:09] thejacob has conceded from the game. Winner: Gibble Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (661969496) == [Time] 1549161919 [13:45:20] PDBot has started watching. [13:45:22] thejacob mulligans to 6 cards. [13:45:24] Gibble keeps this hand. [13:45:26] thejacob keeps this hand. [13:45:27] thejacob puts 1 card on top of their library. [13:45:27] Turn 1: thejacob [13:45:30] thejacob skips their draw step. [13:45:31] thejacob plays [Arcane Sanctum]. [13:45:32] Turn 1: Gibble [13:45:34] Gibble plays [Choked Estuary]. [13:45:36] Turn 2: thejacob [13:45:40] thejacob plays [Vivid Crag]. [13:45:42] Turn 2: Gibble [13:45:44] Gibble plays [Forest]. [13:45:46] Gibble casts [Viridian Emissary]. [13:45:47] Turn 3: thejacob [13:45:53] thejacob casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Gibble. [13:46:20] Gibble discards [Death Denied]. [13:46:20] Gibble reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Arborback Stomper], [Murderous Redcap], [Distended Mindbender], [Forest], and [Commune with Nature]. [13:46:23] thejacob plays [Nomad Outpost]. [13:46:26] Turn 3: Gibble [13:46:30] thejacob is being attacked by [Viridian Emissary]. [13:46:34] Gibble casts [Commune with Nature]. [13:46:39] Gibble puts [Foul Emissary] into their hand with with [Commune with Nature]. [13:46:42] Gibble plays [Forest]. [13:46:43] Gibble casts [Commune with Nature]. [13:46:48] Gibble puts [Edric, Spymaster of Trest] into their hand with with [Commune with Nature]. [13:46:50] Turn 4: thejacob [13:47:04] thejacob plays [Nomad Outpost]. [13:47:18] thejacob casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Gibble. [13:47:19] bocco123 has started watching. [13:47:27] Gibble discards [Foul Emissary]. [13:47:27] Gibble reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Edric, Spymaster of Trest], [Arborback Stomper], [Murderous Redcap], and [Distended Mindbender]. [13:47:31] Turn 4: Gibble [13:47:35] Gibble casts [Edric, Spymaster of Trest]. [13:47:37] thejacob is being attacked by [Viridian Emissary]. [13:47:40] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Edric, Spymaster of Trest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature deals combat damage to one of your opponents, its controller may draw a card.). [13:47:43] Turn 5: thejacob [13:47:48] thejacob plays [Evolving Wilds]. [13:47:51] thejacob activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [13:48:07] thejacob casts [Mardu Charm] targeting [Edric, Spymaster of Trest] (Mardu Charm deals 4 damage to target creature.). [13:48:11] Turn 5: Gibble [13:48:14] thejacob is being attacked by [Viridian Emissary]. [13:48:15] Turn 6: thejacob [13:48:30] thejacob discards [Eternal Dragon]. [13:48:30] thejacob cycles [Eternal Dragon]. [13:48:33] thejacob reveals [Plains]. [13:48:34] thejacob plays [Plains]. [13:48:39] thejacob casts [Utter End] targeting [Viridian Emissary]. [13:48:41] Turn 6: Gibble [13:48:44] Turn 7: thejacob [13:48:52] Turn 7: Gibble [13:48:55] Gibble plays [Lumbering Falls]. [13:49:04] thejacob casts [Mardu Charm] (Create two 1/1 white Warrior creature tokens. They gain first strike until end of turn.). [13:49:04] thejacob's [Mardu Charm] creates two Warrior tokens. [13:49:08] Turn 8: thejacob [13:49:12] thejacob activates an ability of [Eternal Dragon] ( Return Eternal Dragon from your graveyard to your hand.). [13:49:13] [Eternal Dragon] is returned to thejacob's hand from the graveyard. [13:49:16] thejacob plays [Arcane Sanctum]. [13:49:19] Gibble is being attacked by [Warrior] token and [Warrior] token. [13:49:22] Turn 8: Gibble [13:49:28] Gibble casts [Falkenrath Noble]. [13:49:29] Turn 9: thejacob [13:49:38] thejacob casts [Eternal Dragon]. [13:49:43] Turn 9: Gibble [13:49:51] Gibble casts [Viridian Emissary]. [13:49:55] Turn 10: thejacob [13:50:00] Gibble is being attacked by [Eternal Dragon]. [13:50:19] thejacob casts [Decree of Justice]. (X is 1). [13:50:21] thejacob's [Decree of Justice] creates an Angel token. [13:50:22] Turn 10: Gibble [13:50:28] Gibble casts [Foul Emissary]. [13:50:28] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When Foul Emissary enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library. You may rev...). [13:50:36] Gibble puts [Elder Deep-Fiend] into their hand with with [Foul Emissary]'s ability. [13:51:10] Gibble discards [Distended Mindbender]. [13:51:10] Turn 11: thejacob [13:51:20] thejacob casts [Painful Truths] (with 3 colors). [13:51:21] thejacob draws three cards with [Painful Truths]. [13:51:32] thejacob casts [Boros Signet]. [13:51:38] thejacob casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Gibble. [13:51:52] Gibble discards [Elder Deep-Fiend]. [13:51:52] Gibble reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Arborback Stomper], [Whip of Erebos], [Entomber Exarch], [Arborback Stomper], [Murderous Redcap], and [Distended Mindbender]. [13:52:02] Gibble is being attacked by [Angel] token and [Eternal Dragon]. [13:52:07] [Falkenrath Noble] blocks [Eternal Dragon]. [13:52:12] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Falkenrath Noble] onto the stack targeting thejacob (Whenever Falkenrath Noble or another creature dies, target player loses 1 life and you gain 1 life...). [13:52:16] Turn 11: Gibble [13:52:29] Turn 12: thejacob [13:52:35] Gibble is being attacked by [Angel] token and [Eternal Dragon]. [13:52:39] Turn 12: Gibble [13:52:43] Gibble has conceded from the game. Winner: thejacob Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (661970320) == [Time] 1549162399 [13:53:20] PDBot has started watching. [13:53:20] thejacob joined the game. [13:53:26] Gibble chooses to play first. [13:53:29] Gibble keeps this hand. [13:53:31] thejacob keeps this hand. [13:53:31] Turn 1: Gibble [13:53:33] Gibble skips their draw step. [13:53:34] Gibble plays [Forest]. [13:53:35] Gibble casts [Commune with Nature]. [13:53:39] Gibble puts [Sylvan Ranger] into their hand with with [Commune with Nature]. [13:54:32] Turn 1: thejacob [13:54:32] thejacob plays [Lavaclaw Reaches]. [13:54:32] Turn 2: Gibble [13:54:33] Gibble plays [Island]. [13:54:33] Gibble casts [Sylvan Ranger]. [13:54:33] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...). [13:54:33] Gibble reveals [Swamp]. [13:54:33] Turn 2: thejacob [13:54:33] thejacob plays [Arcane Sanctum]. [13:54:33] Turn 3: Gibble [13:54:33] Gibble casts [Commune with Nature]. [13:54:33] Gibble puts [Nekrataal] into their hand with with [Commune with Nature]. [13:54:33] Gibble plays [Swamp]. [13:54:33] thejacob is being attacked by [Sylvan Ranger]. [13:54:33] Turn 3: thejacob [13:54:33] thejacob plays [Urza's Factory]. [13:54:36] thejacob casts [Boros Signet]. [13:54:43] thejacob discards [Eternal Dragon]. [13:54:43] thejacob cycles [Eternal Dragon]. [13:54:46] thejacob reveals [Plains]. [13:54:48] Turn 4: Gibble [13:54:53] Gibble plays [Island]. [13:54:54] Gibble casts [Viridian Emissary]. [13:54:57] thejacob is being attacked by [Sylvan Ranger]. [13:54:58] Turn 4: thejacob [13:55:15] thejacob casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Gibble. [13:55:44] Gibble discards [Entomber Exarch]. [13:55:44] Gibble reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Nekrataal], [Elder Deep-Fiend], [Forest], and [Death Denied]. [13:55:49] thejacob plays [Plains]. [13:55:54] thejacob casts [Painful Truths] (with 3 colors). [13:55:56] thejacob draws three cards with [Painful Truths]. [13:55:58] Turn 5: Gibble [13:56:01] Gibble plays [Forest]. [13:56:04] thejacob is being attacked by [Viridian Emissary] and [Sylvan Ranger]. [13:56:05] Turn 5: thejacob [13:56:10] Gibble casts [Elder Deep-Fiend], emerging from [Viridian Emissary]. [13:56:13] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Elder Deep-Fiend] onto the stack targeting [Boros Signet], [Plains], [Arcane Sanctum], and [Lavaclaw Reaches] (When you cast this spell, tap up to four target permanents.). [13:56:13] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Viridian Emissary] onto the stack (When Viridian Emissary dies, you may search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the ba...). [13:56:24] emobrian has started watching. [13:56:32] thejacob plays [Evolving Wilds]. [13:56:37] Turn 6: Gibble [13:56:49] Gibble casts [Sylvan Ranger]. [13:56:50] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...). [13:56:55] Gibble reveals [Swamp]. [13:56:56] Gibble plays [Swamp]. [13:57:00] thejacob is being attacked by [Elder Deep-Fiend] and [Sylvan Ranger]. [13:57:02] thejacob activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [13:57:14] Turn 6: thejacob [13:57:19] Gibble casts [Elder Deep-Fiend], emerging from [Sylvan Ranger]. [13:57:20] emobrian has stopped watching. [13:57:22] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Elder Deep-Fiend] onto the stack targeting [Swamp], [Boros Signet], [Arcane Sanctum], and [Lavaclaw Reaches] (When you cast this spell, tap up to four target permanents.). [13:57:30] thejacob casts [Pulse of the Fields]. [13:57:40] thejacob has conceded from the game. Winner: Gibble Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: Gibble: 2–1