PennyDreadful
PD top4 vs karakusk
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
karakusk,matiberto

== Game 1 (660144160) ==
[Time] 1548019202
[08:20:02] PDBot has started watching.
[08:20:02] karakusk joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 10.16
[Gatherling] Round=5
[08:20:14] karakusk chooses to play first.
[08:20:18] karakusk mulligans to 6 cards.
[08:20:20] matiberto keeps this hand.
[08:20:31] karakusk mulligans to 5 cards.
[08:20:33] [CHAT] matiberto: gland hf
[08:20:34] karakusk mulligans to 4 cards.
[08:20:36] karakusk keeps this hand.
[08:20:38] karakusk puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[08:20:38] Turn 1: karakusk
[08:20:38] karakusk skips their draw step.
[08:20:40] karakusk plays [Island].
[08:20:42] karakusk casts [Shuko].
[08:20:44] Turn 1: matiberto
[08:21:16] matiberto plays [Rootwater Depths].
[08:21:19] matiberto casts [Shuko].
[08:21:21] Turn 2: karakusk
[08:21:27] Turn 2: matiberto
[08:21:39] matiberto plays [Tranquil Garden].
[08:21:46] matiberto casts [Hermit Druid].
[08:22:00] Turn 3: karakusk
[08:22:02] karakusk plays [Island].
[08:22:06] Turn 3: matiberto
[08:22:14] matiberto plays [Opulent Palace].
[08:22:16] matiberto activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Hermit Druid] (Equip {0}).
[08:22:21] karakusk is being attacked by [Hermit Druid].
[08:22:37] karakusk casts [Anticipate].
[08:22:56] Turn 4: karakusk
[08:23:00] karakusk casts [Consign] targeting [Hermit Druid].
[08:23:03] karakusk returns [Hermit Druid] to its owner's hand with [Consign].
[08:23:10] Turn 4: matiberto
[08:23:39] matiberto plays [Waterveil Cavern].
[08:23:59] matiberto casts [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:23:59] matiberto reveals 4 cards with [Tracker's Instincts]: [Waterveil Cavern], [Splinterfright], [Tracker's Instincts], and [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:24:03] matiberto puts [Splinterfright] into their hand with with [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:24:03] matiberto puts [Tracker's Instincts], [Tracker's Instincts], and [Waterveil Cavern] into their graveyard.
[08:24:11] matiberto casts [Hermit Druid].
[08:24:13] Turn 5: karakusk
[08:25:42] karakusk plays [Island].
[08:25:44] karakusk casts [Narcomoeba].
[08:25:57] karakusk activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Narcomoeba] (Equip {0}).
[08:26:04] Turn 5: matiberto
[08:26:07] matiberto plays [Vivid Grove].
[08:26:14] matiberto activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
[08:26:14] matiberto reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:26:14] matiberto reveals [Cephalid Illusionist].
[08:26:14] matiberto reveals [Cephalid Illusionist].
[08:26:14] matiberto reveals [Graveblade Marauder].
[08:26:14] matiberto reveals [Graveblade Marauder].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Narcomoeba].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Shuko].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Kessig Cagebreakers].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Rootwater Depths].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Vivid Grove].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Narcomoeba].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Shaman en-Kor].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Opulent Palace].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Splinterfright].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Narcomoeba].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Opulent Palace].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Rootwater Depths].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Narcomoeba].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Urborg].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Hermit Druid].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Hermit Druid].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Opulent Palace].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Dread Return].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Kessig Cagebreakers].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Vivid Grove].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Shuko].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Haunted Dead].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Rootwater Depths].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Cephalid Illusionist].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Splinterfright].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Graveblade Marauder].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Tranquil Garden].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Cephalid Illusionist].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Lotleth Giant].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Splinterfright].
[08:26:15] matiberto reveals [Shaman en-Kor].
[08:26:15] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[08:26:15] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[08:26:15] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[08:26:15] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[08:26:45] matiberto casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard targeting [Lotleth Giant].
[08:26:46] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Lotleth Giant] onto the stack targeting karakusk (When Lotleth Giant enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent for each creature ...).
Winner: matiberto
Game 1 Completed.
[08:26:53] matiberto has left the game.

== Game 2 (660145626) ==
[Time] 1548019760
[08:29:20] PDBot has started watching.
[08:29:21] karakusk chooses to play first.
[08:29:24] karakusk mulligans to 6 cards.
[08:29:27] matiberto keeps this hand.
[08:29:29] karakusk mulligans to 5 cards.
[08:29:34] karakusk mulligans to 4 cards.
[08:29:36] karakusk keeps this hand.
[08:29:38] karakusk puts 1 card on top of their library.
[08:29:38] Turn 1: karakusk
[08:29:38] karakusk skips their draw step.
[08:29:40] karakusk plays [Island].
[08:29:46] Turn 1: matiberto
[08:29:53] matiberto plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:29:56] Turn 2: karakusk
[08:30:47] karakusk plays [Swamp].
[08:30:51] Turn 2: matiberto
[08:31:13] matiberto plays [Rootwater Depths].
[08:31:17] matiberto casts [Hermit Druid].
[08:31:20] Turn 3: karakusk
[08:31:24] karakusk plays [Island].
[08:31:26] Turn 3: matiberto
[08:31:36] matiberto plays [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:31:37] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Crumbling Vestige] onto the stack (When Crumbling Vestige enters the battlefield, add one mana of any color.).
[08:31:42] matiberto chooses blue.
[08:31:48] matiberto casts [Cephalid Illusionist].
[08:32:21] matiberto activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Splinterfright].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Early Frost].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Dread Return].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Trygon Predator].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Hermit Druid].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Narcomoeba].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Splinterfright].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Urborg].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Shuko].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Offalsnout].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Offalsnout].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Cephalid Illusionist].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Narcomoeba].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Shuko].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Waterveil Cavern].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Trygon Predator].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Waterveil Cavern].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Cephalid Illusionist].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Tranquil Garden].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Opulent Palace].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Narcomoeba].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Splinterfright].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Rootwater Depths].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Rootwater Depths].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Lotleth Giant].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Vivid Grove].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Graveblade Marauder].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Opulent Palace].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Rootwater Depths].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Haunted Dead].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Shuko].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Graveblade Marauder].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Trygon Predator].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Hermit Druid].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Graveblade Marauder].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Opulent Palace].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Early Frost].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Tranquil Garden].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Cephalid Illusionist].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Narcomoeba].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Vendetta].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Opulent Palace].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Vendetta].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Lotleth Giant].
[08:32:23] matiberto reveals [Lotleth Giant].
[08:32:24] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[08:32:24] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[08:32:24] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[08:32:24] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[08:32:51] matiberto casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard targeting [Lotleth Giant].
[08:34:07] karakusk casts [Cremate] targeting [Lotleth Giant].
[08:34:12] karakusk draws a card with [Cremate].
[08:34:17] matiberto's [Dread Return] is countered because it has no legal targets.
[08:36:06] matiberto has conceded from the game.
Winner: karakusk
Game 2 Completed.
[08:36:10] matiberto has left the game.

== Game 3 (660146794) ==
[Time] 1548020239
[08:37:20] PDBot has started watching.
[08:37:21] matiberto keeps this hand.
[08:37:23] karakusk keeps this hand.
[08:37:23] Turn 1: matiberto
[08:37:25] matiberto skips their draw step.
[08:37:28] matiberto plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:37:30] Turn 1: karakusk
[08:37:32] karakusk plays [Swamp].
[08:37:34] Turn 2: matiberto
[08:37:41] matiberto plays [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:37:41] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Crumbling Vestige] onto the stack (When Crumbling Vestige enters the battlefield, add one mana of any color.).
[08:37:46] matiberto chooses green.
[08:37:48] matiberto casts [Hermit Druid].
[08:37:50] Turn 2: karakusk
[08:37:55] karakusk plays [Island].
[08:38:05] Turn 3: matiberto
[08:38:12] karakusk casts [Early Frost] targeting [Sandsteppe Citadel], and [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:38:21] matiberto plays [Opulent Palace].
[08:38:24] karakusk is being attacked by [Hermit Druid].
[08:38:24] Turn 3: karakusk
[08:38:29] karakusk plays [Island].
[08:38:31] karakusk casts [Anticipate].
[08:38:42] Turn 4: matiberto
[08:38:51] matiberto plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:39:02] matiberto activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Rootwater Depths].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Vendetta].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Dread Return].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Rootwater Depths].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Opulent Palace].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Narcomoeba].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Vivid Grove].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Shuko].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Splinterfright].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Opulent Palace].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Shuko].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Urborg].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Trygon Predator].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Cephalid Illusionist].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Waterveil Cavern].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Early Frost].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Cephalid Illusionist].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Rootwater Depths].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Narcomoeba].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Opulent Palace].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Shuko].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Vendetta].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Waterveil Cavern].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Narcomoeba].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Lotleth Giant].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Graveblade Marauder].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Hermit Druid].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Offalsnout].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Early Frost].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Splinterfright].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Haunted Dead].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Shuko].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Early Frost].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Lotleth Giant].
[08:39:10] matiberto reveals [Offalsnout].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Lotleth Giant].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Rootwater Depths].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Cephalid Illusionist].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Vivid Grove].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Graveblade Marauder].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Hermit Druid].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Vivid Grove].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Tranquil Garden].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Crumbling Vestige].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Tranquil Garden].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Dread Return].
[08:39:11] matiberto reveals [Tracker's Instincts].
[08:39:11] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[08:39:11] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[08:39:11] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.).
[08:39:41] matiberto casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard targeting [Lotleth Giant].
[08:39:41] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Lotleth Giant] onto the stack targeting karakusk (When Lotleth Giant enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent for each creature ...).
[08:40:15] matiberto discards [Trygon Predator].
[08:40:15] matiberto discards [Trygon Predator].
[08:40:15] matiberto activates an ability of [Haunted Dead] ( Return Haunted Dead from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.).
[08:40:15] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Haunted Dead] onto the stack (When Haunted Dead enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Spirit creature token with flying.).
[08:40:18] matiberto's [Haunted Dead] creates a Spirit token.
[08:40:37] matiberto casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard targeting [Lotleth Giant].
[08:40:38] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Lotleth Giant] onto the stack targeting karakusk (When Lotleth Giant enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target opponent for each creature ...).
Winner: matiberto
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: matiberto: 2–1