PennyDreadful
PDT R2 vs.  Gibble
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
nanaiper,Gibble

== Game 1 (657809484) ==
[Time] 1546563452
[11:57:32] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Thursdays 10.13
[Gatherling] Round=2
[11:57:38] Gibble chooses to play first.
[11:57:41] [CHAT] nanaiper: gl
[11:57:43] Gibble keeps this hand.
[11:57:44] nanaiper keeps this hand.
[11:57:44] Turn 1: Gibble
[11:57:44] Gibble skips their draw step.
[11:57:45] Gibble plays [Mystic Monastery].
[11:57:48] Turn 1: nanaiper
[11:57:49] [CHAT] Gibble: hey  gl hf
[11:57:49] nanaiper plays [Opulent Palace].
[11:57:52] Turn 2: Gibble
[11:57:54] Gibble plays [Plains].
[11:57:57] Turn 2: nanaiper
[11:57:58] nanaiper plays [Choked Estuary].
[11:58:03] Turn 3: Gibble
[11:58:11] Gibble plays [Vivid Meadow].
[11:58:14] Turn 3: nanaiper
[11:58:16] nanaiper plays [Forest].
[11:58:19] nanaiper casts [Trail of Evidence].
[11:58:26] Gibble casts [Kindle] targeting nanaiper.
[11:58:28] Turn 4: Gibble
[11:58:40] Gibble plays [Kjeldoran Outpost].
[11:58:41] Gibble sacrifices [Plains].
[11:58:50] Gibble casts [Repeal] targeting [Trail of Evidence]. (X is 3).
[11:58:53] Gibble returns [Trail of Evidence] to its owner's hand with [Repeal].
[11:58:53] Gibble draws a card with [Repeal].
[11:58:59] Turn 4: nanaiper
[11:59:05] nanaiper casts [Trail of Evidence].
[11:59:07] nanaiper plays [Jwar Isle Refuge].
[11:59:07] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Jwar Isle Refuge] onto the stack (When Jwar Isle Refuge enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[11:59:08] Turn 5: Gibble
[11:59:14] Gibble casts [Banishing Light].
[11:59:16] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Banishing Light] onto the stack targeting [Trail of Evidence] (When Banishing Light enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent an opponent controls u...).
[11:59:18] Turn 5: nanaiper
[11:59:21] nanaiper plays [Choked Estuary].
[11:59:25] nanaiper casts [Precognition Field].
[11:59:29] Turn 6: Gibble
[11:59:31] Gibble plays [Urza's Factory].
[11:59:35] Gibble casts [Compulsive Research] targeting Gibble.
[11:59:36] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Compulsive Research[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Dredging rather than drawing can let you avoid discarding
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Compulsive Research` or `!notbugged Compulsive Research`
[11:59:36] Gibble draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[11:59:45] Gibble discards [Plains].
[11:59:47] Turn 6: nanaiper
[11:59:50] nanaiper plays [Opulent Palace].
[11:59:54] nanaiper casts [Compulsive Research] targeting nanaiper.
[11:59:56] nanaiper draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[12:00:04] nanaiper discards [Opulent Palace].
[12:00:05] Turn 7: Gibble
[12:00:08] Gibble plays [Evolving Wilds].
[12:00:10] Turn 7: nanaiper
[12:00:13] nanaiper casts [Elixir of Immortality].
[12:00:17] nanaiper plays [Choked Estuary].
[12:00:27] Gibble casts [Warleader's Helix] targeting nanaiper.
[12:00:30] Gibble activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[12:00:32] Turn 8: Gibble
[12:00:52] nanaiper activates an ability of [Elixir of Immortality] ( You gain 5 life. Shuffle Elixir of Immortality and your graveyard into their owner's library.).
[12:00:56] Turn 8: nanaiper
[12:01:06] Gibble activates an ability of [Kjeldoran Outpost] ( Create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token.).
[12:01:07] Gibble's [Kjeldoran Outpost] creates a Soldier token.
[12:01:12] Gibble casts [Kindle] targeting nanaiper.
[12:01:15] Turn 9: Gibble
[12:01:21] nanaiper casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Soldier] token.
[12:01:28] Turn 9: nanaiper
[12:01:29] nanaiper plays [Island].
[12:01:38] Gibble activates an ability of [Kjeldoran Outpost] ( Create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token.).
[12:01:39] Gibble's [Kjeldoran Outpost] creates a Soldier token.
[12:01:42] Turn 10: Gibble
[12:01:43] Gibble plays [Island].
[12:01:47] nanaiper is being attacked by [Soldier] token.
[12:01:57] nanaiper casts [Careful Consideration] targeting nanaiper.
[12:01:57] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Careful Consideration[sU] has an unclassified bug.
Copy spells that care about being cast during a main phase such as Careful Consideration sometimes do not confer the main phase bonus.
[12:02:06] Gibble discards [Radiant Flames].
[12:02:06] Gibble discards [Radiant Flames].
[12:02:06] Gibble casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Careful Consideration].
[12:02:26] nanaiper casts [Tribute to Hunger] targeting Gibble.
[12:02:30] Gibble sacrifices [Soldier] token.
[12:02:32] Turn 10: nanaiper
[12:02:39] nanaiper casts [Oona, Queen of the Fae].
[12:02:48] Gibble casts [Forbid] targeting [Oona, Queen of the Fae].
[12:02:53] nanaiper casts [Power Sink] targeting [Forbid]. (X is 1).
[12:02:59] Turn 11: Gibble
[12:03:02] Gibble plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:03:28] Turn 11: nanaiper
[12:03:32] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[12:03:36] Gibble is being attacked by [Oona, Queen of the Fae].
[12:03:48] Gibble casts [White Sun's Zenith]. (X is 3).
[12:03:54] nanaiper casts [Power Sink] targeting [White Sun's Zenith]. (X is 1).
[12:03:58] Turn 12: Gibble
[12:04:19] nanaiper activates an ability of [Oona, Queen of the Fae] targeting Gibble. (X is 3) ( Choose a color. Target opponent exiles the top X cards of their library. For each card of the cho...).
[12:04:24] nanaiper chooses blue.
[12:04:24] nanaiper's [Oona, Queen of the Fae] creates a Faerie Rogue token.
[12:04:26] Turn 12: nanaiper
[12:04:33] Gibble is being attacked by [Faerie Rogue] token and [Oona, Queen of the Fae].
[12:04:42] Gibble activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
[12:04:58] Gibble activates an ability of [Kjeldoran Outpost] ( Create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token.).
[12:04:59] Gibble's [Kjeldoran Outpost] creates a Soldier token.
[12:05:00] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
[12:05:04] Turn 13: Gibble
[12:05:10] nanaiper is being attacked by [Soldier] token.
[12:05:15] Gibble plays [Vivid Meadow].
[12:05:23] nanaiper activates an ability of [Oona, Queen of the Fae] targeting Gibble. (X is 5) ( Choose a color. Target opponent exiles the top X cards of their library. For each card of the cho...).
[12:05:32] nanaiper chooses blue.
[12:05:32] nanaiper's [Oona, Queen of the Fae] creates a Faerie Rogue token.
[12:05:34] Turn 13: nanaiper
[12:05:41] Gibble is being attacked by [Faerie Rogue] token, [Faerie Rogue] token, and [Oona, Queen of the Fae].
[12:05:50] Gibble activates an ability of [Kjeldoran Outpost] ( Create a 1/1 white Soldier creature token.).
[12:05:51] Gibble's [Kjeldoran Outpost] creates a Soldier token.
[12:05:56] Gibble casts [Warleader's Helix] targeting nanaiper.
[12:06:00] Turn 14: Gibble
[12:06:05] nanaiper is being attacked by [Soldier] token and [Soldier] token.
[12:06:10] Gibble plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:06:19] nanaiper activates an ability of [Oona, Queen of the Fae] targeting Gibble. (X is 5) ( Choose a color. Target opponent exiles the top X cards of their library. For each card of the cho...).
[12:06:23] nanaiper chooses white.
[12:06:26] Turn 14: nanaiper
[12:06:38] Gibble is being attacked by [Faerie Rogue] token, [Faerie Rogue] token, and [Oona, Queen of the Fae].
[12:06:45] Gibble casts [Repeal] targeting [Oona, Queen of the Fae]. (X is 6).
[12:06:55] nanaiper discards [Wretched Banquet].
[12:06:55] nanaiper discards [Bile Blight].
[12:06:55] nanaiper casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Repeal].
[12:07:01] Turn 15: Gibble
[12:07:10] Gibble has conceded from the game.
Winner: nanaiper
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (657810870) ==
[Time] 1546564111
[12:08:32] PDBot has started watching.
[12:08:37] Gibble chooses to play first.
[12:08:40] Gibble keeps this hand.
[12:08:42] nanaiper keeps this hand.
[12:08:42] Turn 1: Gibble
[12:08:42] Gibble skips their draw step.
[12:08:43] Gibble plays [Vivid Meadow].
[12:08:46] Turn 1: nanaiper
[12:08:48] nanaiper plays [Choked Estuary].
[12:08:51] nanaiper casts [Scrabbling Claws].
[12:08:52] Turn 2: Gibble
[12:08:54] Gibble plays [Plains].
[12:08:56] Turn 2: nanaiper
[12:08:59] nanaiper plays [Opulent Palace].
[12:09:01] Turn 3: Gibble
[12:09:02] Gibble plays [Plains].
[12:09:04] Turn 3: nanaiper
[12:09:07] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[12:09:14] nanaiper casts [Trail of Evidence].
[12:09:19] Turn 4: Gibble
[12:09:21] Gibble plays [Island].
[12:09:24] Turn 4: nanaiper
[12:09:27] nanaiper plays [Forest].
[12:09:32] Turn 5: Gibble
[12:09:38] Turn 5: nanaiper
[12:10:12] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[12:10:12] Turn 6: Gibble
[12:10:12] Gibble plays [Kjeldoran Outpost].
[12:10:12] Gibble sacrifices [Plains].
[12:10:14] nanaiper casts [Careful Consideration] targeting nanaiper.
[12:10:14] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Trail of Evidence] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, investigate.).
[12:10:23] Gibble casts [Invoke the Divine] targeting [Trail of Evidence].
[12:10:32] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:10:35] Gibble exiles [Plains].
[12:10:37] nanaiper's [Trail of Evidence] creates a Clue token.
[12:10:39] nanaiper draws four cards with [Careful Consideration].
[12:10:48] nanaiper discards [Forbid].
[12:10:48] nanaiper discards [Bile Blight].
[12:10:48] nanaiper discards [Jwar Isle Refuge].
[12:10:50] Turn 6: nanaiper
[12:10:52] nanaiper plays [Encroaching Wastes].
[12:10:56] nanaiper activates an ability of [Encroaching Wastes] targeting [Kjeldoran Outpost] ( Destroy target nonbasic land.).
[12:10:59] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:11:01] Gibble exiles [Kjeldoran Outpost].
[12:11:04] Turn 7: Gibble
[12:11:10] Gibble casts [Repeal] targeting [Clue] token. (X is 0).
[12:11:13] Gibble returns [Clue] token to its owner's hand with [Repeal].
[12:11:13] Gibble draws a card with [Repeal].
[12:11:18] Turn 7: nanaiper
[12:11:21] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:11:24] Gibble exiles [Repeal].
[12:11:27] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[12:11:35] nanaiper casts [Compulsive Research] targeting nanaiper.
[12:11:35] nanaiper draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[12:11:45] nanaiper discards [Island].
[12:11:48] Turn 8: Gibble
[12:11:59] Gibble discards [Kindle].
[12:11:59] Turn 8: nanaiper
[12:12:01] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:12:04] Gibble exiles [Kindle].
[12:12:05] nanaiper plays [Jwar Isle Refuge].
[12:12:05] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Jwar Isle Refuge] onto the stack (When Jwar Isle Refuge enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[12:12:10] Turn 9: Gibble
[12:12:17] Gibble discards [Prophetic Bolt].
[12:12:17] Turn 9: nanaiper
[12:12:19] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:12:23] Gibble exiles [Prophetic Bolt].
[12:12:33] nanaiper casts [Treasure Cruise].
[12:12:37] Gibble casts [Dissipate] targeting [Treasure Cruise].
[12:12:49] nanaiper discards [Bile Blight].
[12:12:49] nanaiper discards [Island].
[12:12:49] nanaiper casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Dissipate].
[12:12:50] nanaiper draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise].
[12:12:52] nanaiper plays [Opulent Palace].
[12:12:54] Turn 10: Gibble
[12:12:58] Turn 10: nanaiper
[12:13:00] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:13:02] Gibble exiles [Dissipate].
[12:13:03] nanaiper plays [Opulent Palace].
[12:13:05] Turn 11: Gibble
[12:13:12] Gibble discards [Kindle].
[12:13:12] Turn 11: nanaiper
[12:13:14] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:13:16] Gibble exiles [Kindle].
[12:13:17] nanaiper plays [Choked Estuary].
[12:13:20] Turn 12: Gibble
[12:13:21] Gibble plays [Evolving Wilds].
[12:13:30] nanaiper casts [Sultai Charm] (Draw two cards, then discard a card.).
[12:13:32] nanaiper draws two cards with [Sultai Charm].
[12:13:36] nanaiper discards [Choked Estuary].
[12:13:37] Turn 12: nanaiper
[12:13:38] nanaiper plays [Urza's Factory].
[12:13:40] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:13:42] Gibble activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[12:13:48] Gibble exiles [Evolving Wilds].
[12:13:53] Turn 13: Gibble
[12:13:57] Gibble casts [Faith's Fetters] targeting [Urza's Factory].
[12:14:07] nanaiper casts [Forbid] targeting [Faith's Fetters].
[12:14:15] Turn 13: nanaiper
[12:14:18] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[12:14:20] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:14:22] Gibble exiles [Faith's Fetters].
[12:14:25] Turn 14: Gibble
[12:14:27] Gibble plays [Mountain].
[12:14:41] nanaiper activates an ability of [Urza's Factory] ( Create a 2/2 colorless Assembly-Worker artifact creature token.).
[12:14:43] nanaiper's [Urza's Factory] creates an Assembly-Worker token.
[12:14:44] Turn 14: nanaiper
[12:14:48] nanaiper plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:14:52] Gibble is being attacked by [Assembly-Worker] token.
[12:14:56] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:14:59] Gibble exiles [Invoke the Divine].
[12:15:03] Gibble casts [Anticipate].
[12:15:16] Turn 15: Gibble
[12:15:28] Gibble plays [Evolving Wilds].
[12:15:29] Gibble activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[12:15:43] nanaiper activates an ability of [Urza's Factory] ( Create a 2/2 colorless Assembly-Worker artifact creature token.).
[12:15:44] nanaiper's [Urza's Factory] creates an Assembly-Worker token.
[12:15:45] Turn 15: nanaiper
[12:15:47] nanaiper plays [Opulent Palace].
[12:15:51] Gibble is being attacked by [Assembly-Worker] token and [Assembly-Worker] token.
[12:15:55] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:15:57] Gibble exiles [Evolving Wilds].
[12:16:04] Gibble casts [Prophetic Bolt] targeting [Assembly-Worker] token.
[12:16:11] nanaiper casts [Naturalize] targeting [Assembly-Worker] token.
[12:16:17] Gibble's [Prophetic Bolt] is countered because it has no legal targets.
[12:16:18] Turn 16: Gibble
[12:16:21] Gibble plays [Plains].
[12:16:25] Gibble casts [Faith's Fetters] targeting [Urza's Factory].
[12:16:31] nanaiper casts [Overwhelming Denial] targeting [Faith's Fetters].
[12:16:40] nanaiper activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
[12:16:49] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting [Faith's Fetters] ( Exile target card from a graveyard. Draw a card.).
[12:16:51] nanaiper draws a card with [Scrabbling Claws]'s ability.
[12:16:52] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
[12:16:56] Turn 16: nanaiper
[12:16:57] nanaiper plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:17:02] Gibble is being attacked by [Assembly-Worker] token.
[12:17:06] nanaiper casts [Scrabbling Claws].
[12:17:14] nanaiper casts [Scrabbling Claws].
[12:17:18] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:17:21] Gibble exiles [Prophetic Bolt].
[12:17:22] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:17:24] Gibble exiles [Anticipate].
[12:17:27] Turn 17: Gibble
[12:17:35] Gibble casts [Lone Revenant].
[12:17:49] nanaiper casts [Overwhelming Denial] targeting [Lone Revenant].
[12:17:56] Turn 17: nanaiper
[12:18:01] Gibble is being attacked by [Assembly-Worker] token.
[12:18:06] Turn 18: Gibble
[12:18:07] Gibble plays [Izzet Guildgate].
[12:18:18] nanaiper activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
[12:18:26] nanaiper activates an ability of [Urza's Factory] ( Create a 2/2 colorless Assembly-Worker artifact creature token.).
[12:18:33] Gibble casts [White Sun's Zenith]. (X is 4).
[12:18:37] nanaiper casts [Power Sink] targeting [White Sun's Zenith]. (X is 1).
[12:18:42] nanaiper's [Urza's Factory] creates an Assembly-Worker token.
[12:18:44] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting Gibble ( Target player exiles a card from their graveyard.).
[12:18:47] Gibble exiles [White Sun's Zenith].
[12:18:51] nanaiper activates an ability of [Scrabbling Claws] targeting [Lone Revenant] ( Exile target card from a graveyard. Draw a card.).
[12:18:52] nanaiper draws a card with [Scrabbling Claws]'s ability.
[12:18:53] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
[12:18:55] Turn 18: nanaiper
[12:19:01] Gibble is being attacked by [Assembly-Worker] token and [Assembly-Worker] token.
[12:19:06] nanaiper casts [Careful Consideration] (Enhanced) targeting nanaiper.
[12:19:06] nanaiper draws four cards with [Careful Consideration].
[12:19:10] nanaiper discards [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:19:10] nanaiper discards [Choked Estuary].
[12:19:12] nanaiper plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:19:14] Turn 19: Gibble
[12:19:18] Gibble plays [Mystic Monastery].
[12:19:25] nanaiper activates an ability of [Urza's Factory] ( Create a 2/2 colorless Assembly-Worker artifact creature token.).
[12:19:26] nanaiper's [Urza's Factory] creates an Assembly-Worker token.
[12:19:27] Turn 19: nanaiper
[12:19:34] Gibble is being attacked by [Assembly-Worker] token, [Assembly-Worker] token, and [Assembly-Worker] token.
[12:19:40] Turn 20: Gibble
[12:19:44] [CHAT] Gibble: ggs
[12:19:47] Gibble has conceded from the game.
Winner: nanaiper
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: nanaiper: 2–0
[12:19:51] Gibble has left the game.