PennyDreadful
pds r3 vs chomp
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
lovetapsmtg,chompmtg

== Game 1 (656975074) ==
[Time] 1546113545
[06:59:05] PDBot has started watching.
[06:59:06] lovetapsmtg joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Saturdays 10.13
[Gatherling] Round=3
[06:59:09] chompmtg joined the game.
[06:59:16] chompmtg chooses to play first.
[06:59:21] chompmtg keeps this hand.
[06:59:54] lovetapsmtg keeps this hand.
[06:59:54] Turn 1: chompmtg
[06:59:54] chompmtg skips their draw step.
[06:59:57] chompmtg plays [Mountain].
[07:00:10] chompmtg casts [Sai of the Shinobi].
[07:00:16] Turn 1: lovetapsmtg
[07:00:24] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:00:36] Turn 2: chompmtg
[07:00:40] chompmtg plays [Mountain].
[07:00:44] chompmtg casts [Goblin Gaveleer].
[07:00:50] chompmtg puts triggered ability from [Sai of the Shinobi] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may attach Sai of the Shinobi t...).
[07:00:59] lovetapsmtg casts [Fungal Infection] targeting [Goblin Gaveleer].
[07:01:04] lovetapsmtg's [Fungal Infection] creates a Saproling token.
[07:01:19] chompmtg casts [Inventor's Apprentice].
[07:01:20] chompmtg puts triggered ability from [Sai of the Shinobi] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may attach Sai of the Shinobi t...).
[07:01:37] Turn 2: lovetapsmtg
[07:01:55] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:02:11] lovetapsmtg casts [Pilfering Imp].
[07:02:21] lovetapsmtg casts [Cry of Contrition] targeting chompmtg.
[07:02:27] chompmtg discards [Mountain].
[07:02:36] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Cry of Contrition] onto the stack targeting [Pilfering Imp] (When Cry of Contrition is put into a graveyard after resolving, exile it haunting target creature.).
[07:02:49] Turn 3: chompmtg
[07:02:53] chompmtg plays [Mountain].
[07:02:59] chompmtg casts [Geistflame] targeting [Pilfering Imp].
[07:03:09] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Cry of Contrition] onto the stack targeting chompmtg (When the creature Cry of Contrition haunts dies, target player discards a card.).
[07:03:16] chompmtg discards [Mountain].
[07:03:28] lovetapsmtg is being attacked by [Inventor's Apprentice].
[07:03:37] Turn 3: lovetapsmtg
[07:03:42] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:03:56] lovetapsmtg casts [Gatekeeper of Malakir] (with kicker).
[07:04:12] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Gatekeeper of Malakir] onto the stack targeting chompmtg (When Gatekeeper of Malakir enters the battlefield, if it was kicked, target player sacrifices a cr...).
[07:04:25] chompmtg sacrifices [Inventor's Apprentice].
[07:04:37] chompmtg is being attacked by [Saproling] token.
[07:04:46] Turn 4: chompmtg
[07:04:51] chompmtg casts [Champion of the Flame].
[07:04:51] chompmtg puts triggered ability from [Sai of the Shinobi] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may attach Sai of the Shinobi t...).
[07:05:01] Turn 4: lovetapsmtg
[07:05:07] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:05:11] lovetapsmtg casts [Duty-Bound Dead].
[07:05:37] chompmtg is being attacked by [Saproling] token.
[07:05:37] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Duty-Bound Dead] onto the stack (Exalted).
[07:06:03] Turn 5: chompmtg
[07:06:09] chompmtg casts [Goblin Cratermaker].
[07:06:14] chompmtg puts triggered ability from [Sai of the Shinobi] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may attach Sai of the Shinobi t...).
[07:06:22] chompmtg chooses not to use [Sai of the Shinobi]'s ability.
[07:06:28] chompmtg activates an ability of [Goblin Cratermaker] targeting [Duty-Bound Dead] ( Goblin Cratermaker deals 2 damage to target creature.).
[07:06:52] lovetapsmtg is being attacked by [Champion of the Flame].
[07:07:07] [Gatekeeper of Malakir] blocks [Champion of the Flame].
[07:07:15] lovetapsmtg casts [Supernatural Stamina] targeting [Gatekeeper of Malakir].
[07:07:24] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Gatekeeper of Malakir] onto the stack (When this creature dies, return it to the battlefield tapped under its owner's control.).
[07:07:31] Turn 5: lovetapsmtg
[07:07:47] chompmtg is being attacked by [Gatekeeper of Malakir] and [Saproling] token.
[07:08:02] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:08:06] Turn 6: chompmtg
[07:08:10] chompmtg casts [Goblin Gaveleer].
[07:08:13] chompmtg puts triggered ability from [Sai of the Shinobi] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may attach Sai of the Shinobi t...).
[07:08:20] Turn 6: lovetapsmtg
[07:08:28] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:08:48] Turn 7: chompmtg
[07:08:57] chompmtg casts [Goblin Cratermaker].
[07:08:59] chompmtg puts triggered ability from [Sai of the Shinobi] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may attach Sai of the Shinobi t...).
[07:09:07] chompmtg chooses not to use [Sai of the Shinobi]'s ability.
[07:09:14] chompmtg activates an ability of [Goblin Cratermaker] targeting [Gatekeeper of Malakir] ( Goblin Cratermaker deals 2 damage to target creature.).
[07:09:23] lovetapsmtg is being attacked by [Goblin Gaveleer].
[07:09:36] Turn 7: lovetapsmtg
[07:09:48] lovetapsmtg has conceded from the game.
Winner: chompmtg
Game 1 Completed.
[07:09:54] lovetapsmtg has left the game.

== Game 2 (656977204) ==
[Time] 1546114277
[07:11:18] PDBot has started watching.
[07:11:22] lovetapsmtg chooses to not play first.
[07:11:30] chompmtg mulligans to 6 cards.
[07:11:42] lovetapsmtg keeps this hand.
[07:11:51] chompmtg keeps this hand.
[07:11:58] chompmtg puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[07:11:58] Turn 1: chompmtg
[07:11:58] chompmtg skips their draw step.
[07:12:01] chompmtg plays [Mountain].
[07:12:06] chompmtg casts [Inventor's Apprentice].
[07:12:13] Turn 1: lovetapsmtg
[07:12:21] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:12:24] lovetapsmtg casts [Vampire Cutthroat].
[07:12:37] Turn 2: chompmtg
[07:12:41] chompmtg plays [Mountain].
[07:12:45] chompmtg casts [Goblin Cratermaker].
[07:12:53] lovetapsmtg is being attacked by [Inventor's Apprentice].
[07:13:01] Turn 2: lovetapsmtg
[07:13:07] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:13:18] chompmtg is being attacked by [Vampire Cutthroat].
[07:13:32] lovetapsmtg casts [Thornbow Archer].
[07:13:40] lovetapsmtg casts [Sanitarium Skeleton].
[07:13:52] Turn 3: chompmtg
[07:13:56] chompmtg plays [Mountain].
[07:14:04] chompmtg casts [Geistflame] targeting [Vampire Cutthroat].
[07:14:15] chompmtg casts [Goblin Cratermaker].
[07:14:31] Turn 3: lovetapsmtg
[07:14:41] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:15:37] lovetapsmtg casts [Eyeblight's Ending] targeting [Goblin Cratermaker].
[07:15:53] Turn 4: chompmtg
[07:15:58] chompmtg casts [Bone Saw].
[07:16:06] chompmtg casts [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[07:16:10] chompmtg puts triggered ability from [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, for each Aura and Equipment attached to Valduk, Keeper of...).
[07:16:20] Turn 4: lovetapsmtg
[07:16:44] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:16:47] lovetapsmtg casts [Vicious Conquistador].
[07:16:59] Turn 5: chompmtg
[07:17:02] chompmtg plays [Mountain].
[07:17:08] chompmtg activates an ability of [Bone Saw] targeting [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame] (Equip {1}).
[07:17:13] chompmtg puts triggered ability from [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, for each Aura and Equipment attached to Valduk, Keeper of...).
[07:17:16] chompmtg's [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame] creates an Elemental token.
[07:17:37] lovetapsmtg is being attacked by [Elemental] token.
[07:17:57] chompmtg puts triggered ability from [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame] onto the stack (Exile tokens.).
[07:18:02] Turn 5: lovetapsmtg
[07:18:14] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:18:24] lovetapsmtg casts [Eyeblight's Ending] targeting [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[07:18:46] Turn 6: chompmtg
[07:18:50] chompmtg plays [Mountain].
[07:18:55] chompmtg activates an ability of [Bone Saw] targeting [Goblin Cratermaker] (Equip {1}).
[07:19:12] Turn 6: lovetapsmtg
[07:19:59] Turn 7: chompmtg
[07:20:14] chompmtg casts [Sweatworks Brawler].
[07:20:38] Turn 7: lovetapsmtg
[07:20:46] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:20:53] lovetapsmtg casts [Duty-Bound Dead].
[07:21:16] chompmtg is being attacked by [Thornbow Archer].
[07:21:19] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Thornbow Archer] onto the stack (Whenever Thornbow Archer attacks, each opponent who doesn't control an Elf loses 1 life.).
[07:21:19] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Duty-Bound Dead] onto the stack (Exalted).
[07:21:56] [Inventor's Apprentice] blocks [Thornbow Archer].
[07:22:21] Turn 8: chompmtg
[07:22:29] chompmtg casts [Goblin Cratermaker].
[07:22:48] Turn 8: lovetapsmtg
[07:23:12] chompmtg is being attacked by [Thornbow Archer].
[07:23:14] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Thornbow Archer] onto the stack (Whenever Thornbow Archer attacks, each opponent who doesn't control an Elf loses 1 life.).
[07:23:14] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Duty-Bound Dead] onto the stack (Exalted).
[07:23:39] [Inventor's Apprentice] blocks [Thornbow Archer].
[07:23:57] lovetapsmtg casts [Fungal Infection] targeting [Inventor's Apprentice].
[07:24:06] lovetapsmtg's [Fungal Infection] creates a Saproling token.
[07:24:18] Turn 9: chompmtg
[07:24:25] chompmtg casts [Champion of the Flame].
[07:24:32] chompmtg activates an ability of [Bone Saw] targeting [Champion of the Flame] (Equip {1}).
[07:24:37] lovetapsmtg casts [Fungal Infection] targeting [Champion of the Flame].
[07:24:42] lovetapsmtg's [Fungal Infection] creates a Saproling token.
[07:24:46] chompmtg's Bone Saw is countered because it has no legal targets.
[07:25:04] Turn 9: lovetapsmtg
[07:25:39] Turn 10: chompmtg
[07:25:56] chompmtg plays [Mountain].
[07:26:03] Turn 10: lovetapsmtg
[07:26:34] chompmtg is being attacked by [Thornbow Archer].
[07:26:37] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Thornbow Archer] onto the stack (Whenever Thornbow Archer attacks, each opponent who doesn't control an Elf loses 1 life.).
[07:26:37] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Duty-Bound Dead] onto the stack (Exalted).
[07:26:52] Turn 11: chompmtg
[07:26:56] chompmtg casts [Sai of the Shinobi].
[07:27:07] chompmtg activates an ability of [Sai of the Shinobi] targeting [Goblin Cratermaker] (Equip {2}).
[07:28:08] lovetapsmtg casts [Vendetta] targeting [Sweatworks Brawler].
[07:28:08] Turn 11: lovetapsmtg
[07:28:13] lovetapsmtg plays [Swamp].
[07:28:29] lovetapsmtg casts [Gatekeeper of Malakir] (with kicker).
[07:28:40] chompmtg activates an ability of [Goblin Cratermaker] targeting [Thornbow Archer] ( Goblin Cratermaker deals 2 damage to target creature.).
[07:29:01] chompmtg activates an ability of [Goblin Cratermaker] targeting [Vicious Conquistador] ( Goblin Cratermaker deals 2 damage to target creature.).
[07:29:14] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Gatekeeper of Malakir] onto the stack targeting chompmtg (When Gatekeeper of Malakir enters the battlefield, if it was kicked, target player sacrifices a cr...).
[07:29:31] chompmtg is being attacked by [Saproling] token, [Saproling] token, and [Sanitarium Skeleton].
[07:29:42] Turn 12: chompmtg
[07:29:46] chompmtg casts [Goblin Gaveleer].
[07:29:48] chompmtg puts triggered ability from [Sai of the Shinobi] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may attach Sai of the Shinobi t...).
[07:30:01] chompmtg activates an ability of [Bone Saw] targeting [Goblin Gaveleer] (Equip {1}).
[07:30:14] Turn 12: lovetapsmtg
[07:30:41] chompmtg is being attacked by [Gatekeeper of Malakir].
[07:30:41] lovetapsmtg puts triggered ability from [Duty-Bound Dead] onto the stack (Exalted).
[07:31:05] Turn 13: chompmtg
[07:31:09] chompmtg plays [Mountain].
[07:31:30] chompmtg casts [Geistflame] from the graveyard targeting [Saproling] token.
[07:31:50] lovetapsmtg is being attacked by [Goblin Gaveleer].
[07:32:09] [Sanitarium Skeleton] blocks [Goblin Gaveleer].
[07:32:12] [Saproling] token blocks [Goblin Gaveleer].
[07:32:14] [Duty-Bound Dead] blocks [Goblin Gaveleer].
[07:32:31] Blockers for [Goblin Gaveleer] are ordered as follows: [Sanitarium Skeleton], [Duty-Bound Dead], [Saproling] token
[07:32:44] lovetapsmtg activates an ability of [Duty-Bound Dead] ( Regenerate Duty-Bound Dead.).
[07:33:14] lovetapsmtg activates an ability of [Sanitarium Skeleton] ( Return Sanitarium Skeleton from your graveyard to your hand.).
[07:33:27] chompmtg has conceded from the game.
Winner: lovetapsmtg
Game 2 Completed.
[07:33:35] lovetapsmtg has left the game.