PennyDreadful
PDM R2 
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
nerdyjoe,matiberto

== Game 1 (655207460) ==
[Time] 1545095560
[12:12:41] PDBot has started watching.
[12:12:41] matiberto joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Mondays 10.11
[Gatherling] Round=3
[12:12:48] nerdyjoe chooses to play first.
[12:12:52] nerdyjoe keeps this hand.
[12:13:37] matiberto keeps this hand.
[12:13:37] Turn 1: nerdyjoe
[12:13:42] nerdyjoe skips their draw step.
[12:13:43] nerdyjoe plays [Opulent Palace].
[12:14:20] Turn 1: matiberto
[12:14:22] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:14:27] matiberto casts [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:15:01] Turn 2: nerdyjoe
[12:15:01] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[12:15:02] Turn 2: matiberto
[12:15:02] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:15:02] matiberto casts [Champion of the Flame].
[12:15:03] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:15:08] nerdyjoe casts [Bile Blight] targeting [Champion of the Flame].
[12:15:25] Turn 3: nerdyjoe
[12:15:27] nerdyjoe plays [Island].
[12:15:32] Turn 3: matiberto
[12:15:34] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:15:42] matiberto casts [Inventor's Apprentice].
[12:15:46] matiberto casts [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:15:57] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:16:12] Turn 4: nerdyjoe
[12:16:23] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[12:16:25] nerdyjoe casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:16:30] Turn 4: matiberto
[12:16:33] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:16:37] matiberto casts [Sai of the Shinobi].
[12:16:57] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Inventor's Apprentice] and [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:17:02] Turn 5: nerdyjoe
[12:17:05] nerdyjoe plays [Opulent Palace].
[12:17:11] Turn 5: matiberto
[12:17:13] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:17:19] matiberto casts [Enraged Giant].
[12:17:26] nerdyjoe casts [Dissipate] targeting [Enraged Giant].
[12:17:32] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Inventor's Apprentice] and [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:17:34] Turn 6: nerdyjoe
[12:17:42] nerdyjoe plays [Island].
[12:17:45] Turn 6: matiberto
[12:17:48] matiberto casts [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:17:54] nerdyjoe casts [Dissipate] targeting [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:18:08] matiberto activates an ability of [Sai of the Shinobi] targeting [Goblin Gaveleer] (Equip {2}).
[12:18:14] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Inventor's Apprentice] and [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:18:20] nerdyjoe casts [Sultai Charm] targeting [Goblin Gaveleer] (Destroy target monocolored creature.).
[12:18:29] Turn 7: nerdyjoe
[12:18:33] nerdyjoe plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:18:35] Turn 7: matiberto
[12:18:39] matiberto casts [Shuko].
[12:18:42] matiberto activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Inventor's Apprentice] (Equip {0}).
[12:18:45] matiberto activates an ability of [Sai of the Shinobi] targeting [Inventor's Apprentice] (Equip {2}).
[12:18:48] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Inventor's Apprentice].
[12:18:48] Turn 8: nerdyjoe
[12:18:51] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
[12:19:01] nerdyjoe puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
[12:19:04] Turn 8: matiberto
[12:19:07] matiberto casts [Champion of the Flame].
[12:19:09] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Sai of the Shinobi] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may attach Sai of the Shinobi t...).
[12:19:14] matiberto chooses not to use [Sai of the Shinobi]'s ability.
[12:19:18] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Inventor's Apprentice].
[12:19:24] nerdyjoe casts [Consume the Meek].
[12:19:31] Turn 9: nerdyjoe
[12:19:34] nerdyjoe plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:19:36] Turn 9: matiberto
[12:19:39] matiberto casts [Shuko].
[12:19:43] Turn 10: nerdyjoe
[12:19:45] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
[12:19:51] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[12:19:53] nerdyjoe puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
[12:19:54] Turn 10: matiberto
[12:19:56] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:19:59] Turn 11: nerdyjoe
[12:20:03] nerdyjoe plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:20:04] nerdyjoe casts [Precognition Field].
[12:20:09] Turn 11: matiberto
[12:20:24] matiberto casts [Sweatworks Brawler].
[12:20:28] matiberto puts triggered ability from [Sai of the Shinobi] onto the stack (Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under your control, you may attach Sai of the Shinobi t...).
[12:20:36] matiberto activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Sweatworks Brawler] (Equip {0}).
[12:20:40] nerdyjoe casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Sweatworks Brawler].
[12:20:49] matiberto activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Sweatworks Brawler] (Equip {0}).
[12:20:53] Turn 12: nerdyjoe
[12:20:59] nerdyjoe casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Sweatworks Brawler].
[12:21:03] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[12:21:07] Turn 12: matiberto
[12:21:12] matiberto casts [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[12:21:17] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
[12:21:28] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Precognition Field] ( Exile the top card of your library.).
[12:21:36] nerdyjoe casts [Void Shatter] targeting [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[12:21:49] nerdyjoe puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
[12:21:53] Turn 13: nerdyjoe
[12:21:57] nerdyjoe plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:21:59] Turn 13: matiberto
[12:22:02] matiberto casts [Sai of the Shinobi].
[12:22:12] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Precognition Field] ( Exile the top card of your library.).
[12:22:15] Turn 14: nerdyjoe
[12:22:21] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
[12:22:28] nerdyjoe casts [Compulsive Research] targeting nerdyjoe.
[12:22:28] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Compulsive Research[sU] has an advantageous bug.
Dredging rather than drawing can let you avoid discarding
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Compulsive Research` or `!notbugged Compulsive Research`
[12:22:30] nerdyjoe draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[12:22:33] nerdyjoe discards [Dreadship Reef].
[12:22:37] nerdyjoe puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
[12:22:38] Turn 14: matiberto
[12:22:41] matiberto casts [Bone Saw].
[12:22:47] Turn 15: nerdyjoe
[12:22:50] nerdyjoe plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:22:53] Turn 15: matiberto
[12:23:00] Turn 16: nerdyjoe
[12:23:03] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
[12:23:09] nerdyjoe plays [Forest].
[12:23:12] nerdyjoe puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
[12:23:13] Turn 16: matiberto
[12:23:17] matiberto casts [Inventor's Apprentice].
[12:23:22] nerdyjoe casts [Void Shatter] targeting [Inventor's Apprentice].
[12:23:25] Turn 17: nerdyjoe
[12:23:28] nerdyjoe plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:23:31] Turn 17: matiberto
[12:23:36] matiberto casts [Sai of the Shinobi].
[12:23:39] nerdyjoe casts [Void Shatter] targeting [Sai of the Shinobi].
[12:23:45] Turn 18: nerdyjoe
[12:23:47] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
[12:23:53] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[12:23:58] nerdyjoe puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
[12:24:04] nerdyjoe discards [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:24:05] Turn 18: matiberto
[12:24:14] nerdyjoe casts [Sultai Charm] targeting [Sai of the Shinobi] (Destroy target artifact or enchantment.).
[12:24:23] nerdyjoe casts [Sultai Charm] targeting [Sai of the Shinobi] (Destroy target artifact or enchantment.).
[12:24:25] Turn 19: nerdyjoe
[12:24:31] Turn 19: matiberto
[12:24:37] nerdyjoe casts [Anticipate].
[12:24:45] Turn 20: nerdyjoe
[12:24:49] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[12:25:08] nerdyjoe discards [Barter in Blood].
[12:25:08] Turn 20: matiberto
[12:25:11] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:25:16] matiberto casts [Bone Saw].
[12:25:24] Turn 21: nerdyjoe
[12:25:27] nerdyjoe plays [Urza's Factory].
[12:25:30] Turn 21: matiberto
[12:25:38] matiberto casts [Inventor's Apprentice].
[12:25:47] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Urza's Factory] ( Create a 2/2 colorless Assembly-Worker artifact creature token.).
[12:25:47] nerdyjoe's [Urza's Factory] creates an Assembly-Worker token.
[12:25:49] Turn 22: nerdyjoe
[12:25:52] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[12:25:58] Turn 22: matiberto
[12:26:01] matiberto casts [Inventor's Apprentice].
[12:26:06] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:26:08] matiberto activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Inventor's Apprentice] (Equip {0}).
[12:26:11] nerdyjoe casts [Bile Blight] targeting [Inventor's Apprentice].
[12:26:21] matiberto's Shuko is countered because it has no legal targets.
[12:26:27] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Urza's Factory] ( Create a 2/2 colorless Assembly-Worker artifact creature token.).
[12:26:28] nerdyjoe's [Urza's Factory] creates an Assembly-Worker token.
[12:26:29] Turn 23: nerdyjoe
[12:26:35] matiberto is being attacked by [Assembly-Worker] token and [Assembly-Worker] token.
[12:26:38] Turn 23: matiberto
[12:26:42] matiberto casts [Sai of the Shinobi].
[12:26:51] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Urza's Factory] ( Create a 2/2 colorless Assembly-Worker artifact creature token.).
[12:26:52] nerdyjoe's [Urza's Factory] creates an Assembly-Worker token.
[12:26:53] Turn 24: nerdyjoe
[12:26:56] nerdyjoe plays [Island].
[12:26:59] matiberto is being attacked by [Assembly-Worker] token, [Assembly-Worker] token, and [Assembly-Worker] token.
[12:27:03] Turn 24: matiberto
[12:27:07] matiberto casts [Shuko].
[12:27:13] nerdyjoe casts [Anticipate].
[12:27:20] Turn 25: nerdyjoe
[12:27:24] nerdyjoe plays [Opulent Palace].
[12:27:28] matiberto is being attacked by [Assembly-Worker] token, [Assembly-Worker] token, and [Assembly-Worker] token.
[12:27:33] nerdyjoe discards [Barter in Blood].
[12:27:33] Turn 25: matiberto
[12:27:38] matiberto has conceded from the game.
Winner: nerdyjoe
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (655209122) ==
[Time] 1545096504
[12:28:24] PDBot has started watching.
[12:28:25] matiberto chooses to play first.
[12:28:27] matiberto keeps this hand.
[12:28:30] nerdyjoe keeps this hand.
[12:28:31] Turn 1: matiberto
[12:28:31] matiberto skips their draw step.
[12:28:33] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:28:36] matiberto casts [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:28:39] Turn 1: nerdyjoe
[12:28:44] nerdyjoe plays [Opulent Palace].
[12:28:46] Turn 2: matiberto
[12:28:48] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:28:50] matiberto casts [Shuko].
[12:28:54] matiberto activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Goblin Gaveleer] (Equip {0}).
[12:28:57] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:29:00] Turn 2: nerdyjoe
[12:29:04] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[12:29:08] nerdyjoe casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:29:15] Turn 3: matiberto
[12:29:16] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:29:23] matiberto casts [Sweatworks Brawler].
[12:29:27] Turn 3: nerdyjoe
[12:29:36] nerdyjoe plays [Encroaching Wastes].
[12:29:38] nerdyjoe casts [Elixir of Immortality].
[12:29:40] Turn 4: matiberto
[12:29:43] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:29:45] matiberto activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Sweatworks Brawler] (Equip {0}).
[12:29:49] matiberto casts [Inventor's Apprentice].
[12:29:54] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Sweatworks Brawler].
[12:30:01] nerdyjoe casts [Anticipate].
[12:30:23] Turn 4: nerdyjoe
[12:30:37] nerdyjoe casts [Compulsive Research] targeting nerdyjoe.
[12:30:40] nerdyjoe draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[12:31:05] nerdyjoe discards [Forbid].
[12:31:06] nerdyjoe discards [Moment of Craving].
[12:31:07] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[12:31:10] nerdyjoe casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Inventor's Apprentice].
[12:31:18] Turn 5: matiberto
[12:31:21] matiberto casts [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:31:26] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Sweatworks Brawler].
[12:31:29] Turn 5: nerdyjoe
[12:31:33] nerdyjoe plays [Urza's Factory].
[12:31:40] Turn 6: matiberto
[12:31:45] matiberto casts [Accorder's Shield].
[12:31:53] matiberto activates an ability of [Accorder's Shield] targeting [Goblin Gaveleer] (Equip {3}).
[12:31:59] matiberto activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Goblin Gaveleer] (Equip {0}).
[12:32:05] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Goblin Gaveleer] and [Sweatworks Brawler].
[12:32:12] nerdyjoe casts [Sultai Charm] targeting [Goblin Gaveleer] (Destroy target monocolored creature.).
[12:32:20] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Elixir of Immortality] ( You gain 5 life. Shuffle Elixir of Immortality and your graveyard into their owner's library.).
[12:32:22] Turn 6: nerdyjoe
[12:32:27] nerdyjoe casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Sweatworks Brawler].
[12:32:31] Turn 7: matiberto
[12:32:55] Turn 7: nerdyjoe
[12:32:57] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[12:33:01] Turn 8: matiberto
[12:33:03] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:33:05] matiberto casts [Bone Saw].
[12:33:10] Turn 8: nerdyjoe
[12:33:13] nerdyjoe plays [Island].
[12:33:16] Turn 9: matiberto
[12:33:19] matiberto casts [Heap Doll].
[12:33:26] matiberto activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Heap Doll] (Equip {0}).
[12:33:34] matiberto activates an ability of [Bone Saw] targeting [Heap Doll] (Equip {1}).
[12:33:39] matiberto activates an ability of [Accorder's Shield] targeting [Heap Doll] (Equip {3}).
[12:33:42] nerdyjoe casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Heap Doll].
[12:33:47] matiberto's Accorder's Shield is countered because it has no legal targets.
[12:33:49] Turn 9: nerdyjoe
[12:33:56] nerdyjoe casts [Curse of Death's Hold] targeting matiberto.
[12:33:57] [CHAT] matiberto: why not doing ht from the begginnign
[12:34:00] Turn 10: matiberto
[12:34:13] matiberto casts [Goblin Gaveleer].
[12:34:18] Turn 10: nerdyjoe
[12:34:23] Turn 11: matiberto
[12:34:31] matiberto casts [Pillar of Flame] targeting nerdyjoe.
[12:34:37] Turn 11: nerdyjoe
[12:34:42] nerdyjoe casts [Compulsive Research] targeting nerdyjoe.
[12:34:43] nerdyjoe draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[12:34:48] nerdyjoe discards [Urza's Factory].
[12:34:49] nerdyjoe plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:34:51] Turn 12: matiberto
[12:34:54] matiberto plays [Mountain].
[12:34:59] matiberto casts [Champion of the Flame].
[12:35:05] Turn 12: nerdyjoe
[12:35:07] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
[12:35:12] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[12:35:16] nerdyjoe puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
[12:35:18] Turn 13: matiberto
[12:35:22] matiberto casts [Shuko].
[12:35:28] Turn 13: nerdyjoe
[12:35:31] nerdyjoe plays [Thawing Glaciers].
[12:35:34] Turn 14: matiberto
[12:35:38] matiberto casts [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[12:35:45] matiberto activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame] (Equip {0}).
[12:35:48] nerdyjoe casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[12:35:57] matiberto's Shuko is countered because it has no legal targets.
[12:36:00] [CHAT] matiberto: got bored
[12:36:01] Turn 14: nerdyjoe
[12:36:01] [CHAT] matiberto: bye 
[12:36:03] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[12:36:04] matiberto has conceded from the game.
Winner: nerdyjoe
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: nerdyjoe: 2–0
[12:36:08] matiberto has left the game.