PennyDreadful PD LEAGUE BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Gibble,Carmandor == Game 1 (653845000) == [Time] 1544220727 [09:12:07] PDBot has started watching. [League] Aristocrats Watchers by carmandor (30309) vs Grixis Breakfast by gibble (30342) [09:12:11] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [09:12:15] Gibble chooses to play first. [09:12:15] Carmandor joined the game. [09:12:18] Gibble keeps this hand. [09:12:26] [CHAT] Gibble: hey gl hf [09:12:38] Carmandor mulligans to 6 cards. [09:12:42] Carmandor mulligans to 5 cards. [09:12:44] Carmandor mulligans to 4 cards. [09:12:48] Carmandor keeps this hand. [09:12:51] Carmandor puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [09:12:51] Turn 1: Gibble [09:12:51] Gibble skips their draw step. [09:12:52] Gibble plays [Crumbling Necropolis]. [09:12:56] Turn 1: Carmandor [09:13:00] Carmandor plays [Swamp]. [09:13:03] Turn 2: Gibble [09:13:07] Gibble plays [Crumbling Necropolis]. [09:13:11] Turn 2: Carmandor [09:13:16] Carmandor plays [Swamp]. [09:13:19] Carmandor casts [Mesmeric Fiend]. [09:13:22] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack targeting Gibble (When Mesmeric Fiend enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a no...). [09:13:32] Gibble reveals their hand to [Mesmeric Fiend]'s ability, containing [Mountain], [Haunted Dead], [Shuko], [Shuko], and [Early Frost]. [09:13:38] Turn 3: Gibble [09:13:40] Gibble plays [Mountain]. [09:13:46] Gibble casts [Shuko]. [09:13:52] Gibble casts [Cephalid Illusionist]. [09:13:55] Gibble activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Cephalid Illusionist] (Equip {0}). [09:13:55] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Cephalid Illusionist] onto the stack (Whenever Cephalid Illusionist becomes the target of a spell or ability, put the top three cards of...). [09:14:03] Gibble activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Cephalid Illusionist] (Equip {0}). [09:14:03] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Cephalid Illusionist] onto the stack (Whenever Cephalid Illusionist becomes the target of a spell or ability, put the top three cards of...). [09:14:05] Gibble activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Cephalid Illusionist] (Equip {0}). [09:14:05] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Cephalid Illusionist] onto the stack (Whenever Cephalid Illusionist becomes the target of a spell or ability, put the top three cards of...). [09:14:07] Gibble activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Cephalid Illusionist] (Equip {0}). [09:14:07] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Cephalid Illusionist] onto the stack (Whenever Cephalid Illusionist becomes the target of a spell or ability, put the top three cards of...). [09:14:10] Gibble activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Cephalid Illusionist] (Equip {0}). [09:14:10] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Cephalid Illusionist] onto the stack (Whenever Cephalid Illusionist becomes the target of a spell or ability, put the top three cards of...). [09:14:10] Carmandor has conceded from the game. Winner: Gibble Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (653845354) == [Time] 1544220924 [09:15:25] PDBot has started watching. [09:15:29] Carmandor chooses to play first. [09:15:32] Carmandor keeps this hand. [09:15:42] Gibble mulligans to 6 cards. [09:15:45] Gibble keeps this hand. [09:15:48] Gibble puts 1 card on top of their library. [09:15:48] Turn 1: Carmandor [09:15:51] Carmandor skips their draw step. [09:15:54] Carmandor plays [Desert of the Glorified]. [09:15:58] Turn 1: Gibble [09:15:59] Gibble plays [Crumbling Necropolis]. [09:16:02] Turn 2: Carmandor [09:16:05] Carmandor plays [Swamp]. [09:16:08] Carmandor casts [Watchers of the Dead]. [09:16:13] Turn 2: Gibble [09:16:15] Gibble plays [Choked Estuary]. [09:16:18] Gibble casts [Shuko]. [09:16:23] Turn 3: Carmandor [09:16:26] Carmandor plays [Swamp]. [09:16:32] Gibble is being attacked by [Watchers of the Dead]. [09:16:38] Carmandor casts [Brain Maggot]. [09:16:41] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Brain Maggot] onto the stack targeting Gibble (When Brain Maggot enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a nonl...). [09:16:46] Gibble reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [See Beyond], [Psychatog], [Psychatog], [Treasure Cruise], and [Repeal]. [09:17:12] Turn 3: Gibble [09:17:16] Gibble casts [See Beyond]. [09:17:17] Gibble draws two cards with [See Beyond]. [09:17:32] Gibble plays [Choked Estuary]. [09:17:37] Turn 4: Carmandor [09:17:43] Carmandor plays [Spawning Pool]. [09:17:48] Gibble is being attacked by [Brain Maggot] and [Watchers of the Dead]. [09:18:03] Turn 4: Gibble [09:18:08] Gibble plays [Mountain]. [09:18:12] Gibble casts [Haunted Dead]. [09:18:14] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Haunted Dead] onto the stack (When Haunted Dead enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Spirit creature token with flying.). [09:18:16] Gibble's [Haunted Dead] creates a Spirit token. [09:18:18] Gibble activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Spirit] token (Equip {0}). [09:18:24] Carmandor casts [Bile Blight] targeting [Haunted Dead]. [09:18:33] Turn 5: Carmandor [09:18:39] Carmandor casts [Zulaport Cutthroat]. [09:18:52] Carmandor casts [Zulaport Cutthroat]. [09:18:57] Turn 5: Gibble [09:19:13] Carmandor is being attacked by [Spirit] token. [09:19:23] Gibble casts [Psychatog]. [09:19:26] Gibble plays [Choked Estuary]. [09:19:29] Gibble activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Psychatog] (Equip {0}). [09:19:32] Turn 6: Carmandor [09:19:39] Carmandor casts [Grasp of Darkness] targeting [Psychatog]. [09:19:47] Gibble is being attacked by [Zulaport Cutthroat], [Zulaport Cutthroat], [Brain Maggot], and [Watchers of the Dead]. [09:19:53] Carmandor casts [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:20:00] Turn 6: Gibble [09:20:35] Gibble discards [Narcomoeba]. [09:20:35] Gibble discards [Swamp]. [09:20:35] Gibble activates an ability of [Haunted Dead] ( Return Haunted Dead from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.). [09:20:39] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Haunted Dead] onto the stack (When Haunted Dead enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Spirit creature token with flying.). [09:20:41] Gibble's [Haunted Dead] creates a Spirit token. [09:20:43] Gibble activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Spirit] token (Equip {0}). [09:20:51] Turn 7: Carmandor [09:21:00] Carmandor casts [Grim Haruspex]. [09:21:08] Gibble is being attacked by [Bloodthrone Vampire], [Zulaport Cutthroat], and [Zulaport Cutthroat]. [09:21:14] [Spirit] token blocks [Zulaport Cutthroat]. [09:21:15] [Spirit] token blocks [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:21:20] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). [09:21:47] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...). [09:21:47] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...). [09:21:47] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Grim Haruspex] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature you control dies, draw a card.). [09:21:48] Carmandor draws a card with [Grim Haruspex]'s ability. [09:21:48] Turn 7: Gibble [09:21:55] Gibble casts [Treasure Cruise]. [09:21:59] Gibble draws three cards with [Treasure Cruise]. [09:22:02] Gibble plays [Crumbling Necropolis]. [09:22:04] Gibble activates an ability of [Shuko] targeting [Spirit] token (Equip {0}). [09:22:11] Turn 8: Carmandor [09:22:18] Carmandor casts [Brain Maggot]. [09:22:19] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Brain Maggot] onto the stack targeting Gibble (When Brain Maggot enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a nonl...). [09:22:21] Gibble reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [Island], [Island], and [Psychatog]. [09:22:30] Carmandor casts [Sultai Emissary]. [09:22:36] Gibble has conceded from the game. Winner: Carmandor Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (653846138) == [Time] 1544221388 [09:23:08] PDBot has started watching. [09:23:12] Gibble chooses to play first. [09:23:15] Gibble keeps this hand. [09:23:21] Carmandor mulligans to 6 cards. [09:23:24] Carmandor keeps this hand. [09:23:26] Carmandor puts 1 card on top of their library. [09:23:26] Turn 1: Gibble [09:23:26] Gibble skips their draw step. [09:23:28] Gibble plays [Crumbling Necropolis]. [09:23:31] Turn 1: Carmandor [09:23:34] Carmandor plays [Spawning Pool]. [09:23:38] Turn 2: Gibble [09:23:41] Gibble plays [Foreboding Ruins]. [09:23:46] Turn 2: Carmandor [09:23:49] Carmandor plays [Swamp]. [09:23:52] Carmandor casts [Watchers of the Dead]. [09:23:59] Turn 3: Gibble [09:24:03] Gibble plays [Island]. [09:24:07] Gibble casts [Compulsive Research] targeting Gibble. [09:24:08] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Compulsive Research[sU] has an advantageous bug. Dredging rather than drawing can let you avoid discarding [09:24:10] Gibble draws three cards with [Compulsive Research]. [09:24:22] Gibble discards [Choked Estuary]. [09:24:27] Turn 3: Carmandor [09:24:31] Carmandor plays [Swamp]. [09:24:36] Gibble is being attacked by [Watchers of the Dead]. [09:24:43] Turn 4: Gibble [09:24:47] Gibble plays [Foreboding Ruins]. [09:24:55] Turn 4: Carmandor [09:25:01] Gibble casts [Early Frost] targeting [Swamp], [Swamp], and [Spawning Pool]. [09:25:12] Carmandor plays [Desert of the Glorified]. [09:25:16] Gibble is being attacked by [Watchers of the Dead]. [09:25:24] Turn 5: Gibble [09:25:32] Gibble plays [Foreboding Ruins]. [09:25:40] Turn 5: Carmandor [09:25:44] Carmandor plays [Swamp]. [09:25:49] Carmandor casts [Grim Haruspex]. [09:25:56] Gibble is being attacked by [Watchers of the Dead]. [09:26:04] Turn 6: Gibble [09:26:12] Gibble casts [Radiant Flames] (with 3 colors). [09:26:19] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Grim Haruspex] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature you control dies, draw a card.). [09:26:21] Carmandor draws a card with [Grim Haruspex]'s ability. [09:26:23] Gibble plays [Island]. [09:26:25] Gibble casts [Narcomoeba]. [09:26:32] Turn 6: Carmandor [09:26:39] Carmandor plays [Swamp]. [09:27:31] Carmandor casts [Memoricide] targeting Gibble. [09:27:43] Carmandor names Psychatog for [Memoricide]. [09:28:02] Turn 7: Gibble [09:28:05] Gibble plays [Mountain]. [09:28:09] Carmandor is being attacked by [Narcomoeba]. [09:28:15] Gibble casts [Cephalid Illusionist]. [09:28:23] Carmandor casts [Bile Blight] targeting [Cephalid Illusionist]. [09:28:23] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Cephalid Illusionist] onto the stack (Whenever Cephalid Illusionist becomes the target of a spell or ability, put the top three cards of...). [09:28:27] Turn 7: Carmandor [09:28:31] Carmandor plays [Swamp]. [09:28:45] Carmandor casts [Immortal Servitude]. (X is 2). [09:28:56] Carmandor casts [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:29:02] Turn 8: Gibble [09:29:07] Carmandor is being attacked by [Narcomoeba]. [09:29:14] Gibble casts [Narcomoeba]. [09:29:17] Turn 8: Carmandor [09:29:23] Carmandor casts [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:29:29] Carmandor casts [Grim Haruspex]. [09:29:37] Gibble is being attacked by [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:29:40] [Narcomoeba] blocks [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:29:44] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). [09:29:44] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Grim Haruspex] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature you control dies, draw a card.). [09:29:46] Carmandor draws a card with [Grim Haruspex]'s ability. [09:29:54] Carmandor casts [Zulaport Cutthroat]. [09:29:59] Turn 9: Gibble [09:30:03] Gibble plays [Island]. [09:30:22] Gibble casts [Cephalid Illusionist]. [09:30:31] Turn 9: Carmandor [09:30:36] Carmandor casts [Carrier Thrall]. [09:30:42] Carmandor activates an ability of [Spawning Pool] ( Spawning Pool becomes a 1/1 black Skeleton creature with '{B}: Regenerate this creature' until en...). [09:30:50] Gibble is being attacked by [Bloodthrone Vampire] and [Spawning Pool]. [09:30:58] [Narcomoeba] blocks [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:30:59] [Narcomoeba] stops blocking. [09:31:10] [Narcomoeba] blocks [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:31:15] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). [09:31:17] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...). [09:31:19] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Grim Haruspex] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature you control dies, draw a card.). [09:31:19] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Carrier Thrall] onto the stack (When Carrier Thrall dies, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. It has 'Sacrifice t...). [09:31:22] Carmandor's [Carrier Thrall] creates an Eldrazi Scion token. [09:31:26] Carmandor draws a card with [Grim Haruspex]'s ability. [09:31:40] Carmandor casts [Carrier Thrall]. [09:31:45] Turn 10: Gibble [09:31:54] Gibble casts [Dread Return] targeting [Cephalid Illusionist]. [09:32:08] Turn 10: Carmandor [09:32:13] Carmandor casts [Brain Maggot]. [09:32:16] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Brain Maggot] onto the stack targeting Gibble (When Brain Maggot enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a nonl...). [09:32:19] Gibble reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [Dread Return] and [Early Frost]. [09:32:40] Gibble is being attacked by [Carrier Thrall], [Eldrazi Scion] token, and [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:32:44] [Cephalid Illusionist] blocks [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:32:51] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). [09:32:53] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...). [09:32:55] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Grim Haruspex] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature you control dies, draw a card.). [09:32:55] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Carrier Thrall] onto the stack (When Carrier Thrall dies, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. It has 'Sacrifice t...). [09:33:01] Gibble activates an ability of [Cephalid Illusionist] targeting [Cephalid Illusionist] ( Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt to and dealt by target creature you control this tu...). [09:33:02] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Cephalid Illusionist] onto the stack (Whenever Cephalid Illusionist becomes the target of a spell or ability, put the top three cards of...). [09:33:20] Carmandor's [Carrier Thrall] creates an Eldrazi Scion token. [09:33:21] Carmandor draws a card with [Grim Haruspex]'s ability. [09:33:24] chesspi64 has started watching. [09:33:28] 1 damage caused by [Cephalid Illusionist] to [Bloodthrone Vampire] is prevented. [09:33:28] 3 damage caused by [Bloodthrone Vampire] to [Cephalid Illusionist] is prevented. [09:33:31] Carmandor plays [Swamp]. [09:33:40] chesspi64 has stopped watching. [09:33:44] Turn 11: Gibble [09:33:55] Gibble casts [Dread Return] targeting [Flayer of the Hatebound]. [09:34:10] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Flayer of the Hatebound] onto the stack targeting [Zulaport Cutthroat] (Whenever Flayer of the Hatebound or another creature enters the battlefield from your graveyard, t...). [09:34:16] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...). [09:34:16] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Grim Haruspex] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature you control dies, draw a card.). [09:34:18] Carmandor draws a card with [Grim Haruspex]'s ability. [09:34:33] Carmandor discards [Desert of the Glorified]. [09:34:34] Carmandor cycles [Desert of the Glorified]. [09:34:38] Turn 11: Carmandor [09:35:11] Carmandor casts [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:35:20] Carmandor casts [Gatekeeper of Malakir] (with kicker). [09:35:27] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Gatekeeper of Malakir] onto the stack targeting Gibble (When Gatekeeper of Malakir enters the battlefield, if it was kicked, target player sacrifices a cr...). [09:35:31] chesspi64 has started watching. [09:35:32] Gibble sacrifices [Flayer of the Hatebound]. [09:35:32] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Flayer of the Hatebound] onto the stack (Undying (When this creature dies, if it had no +1/+1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...). [09:35:38] chesspi64 has stopped watching. [09:35:38] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Flayer of the Hatebound] onto the stack targeting [Grim Haruspex] (Whenever Flayer of the Hatebound or another creature enters the battlefield from your graveyard, t...). [09:36:02] Gibble activates an ability of [Cephalid Illusionist] targeting [Cephalid Illusionist] ( Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt to and dealt by target creature you control this tu...). [09:36:02] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Cephalid Illusionist] onto the stack (Whenever Cephalid Illusionist becomes the target of a spell or ability, put the top three cards of...). [09:36:09] Turn 12: Gibble [09:36:13] Gibble casts [Compulsive Research] targeting Gibble. [09:36:15] Gibble draws three cards with [Compulsive Research]. [09:36:18] Gibble discards [Swamp]. [09:36:31] Gibble plays [Swamp]. [09:36:35] chesspi64 has started watching. [09:36:38] Turn 12: Carmandor [09:36:47] Carmandor activates an ability of [Spawning Pool] ( Spawning Pool becomes a 1/1 black Skeleton creature with '{B}: Regenerate this creature' until en...). [09:36:57] Gibble is being attacked by [Gatekeeper of Malakir], [Bloodthrone Vampire], [Eldrazi Scion] token, [Eldrazi Scion] token, [Bloodthrone Vampire], and [Spawning Pool]. [09:37:02] chesspi64 has stopped watching. [09:37:21] [Flayer of the Hatebound] blocks [Gatekeeper of Malakir]. [09:37:23] [Cephalid Illusionist] blocks [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:37:24] [Cephalid Illusionist] blocks [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [09:37:32] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). [09:37:48] Gibble activates an ability of [Cephalid Illusionist] targeting [Cephalid Illusionist] ( Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt to and dealt by target creature you control this tu...). [09:37:48] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Cephalid Illusionist] onto the stack (Whenever Cephalid Illusionist becomes the target of a spell or ability, put the top three cards of...). [09:37:54] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Narcomoeba] onto the stack (When Narcomoeba is put into your graveyard from your library, you may put it onto the battlefield.). [09:38:09] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Flayer of the Hatebound] onto the stack targeting [Eldrazi Scion] token (Whenever Flayer of the Hatebound or another creature enters the battlefield from your graveyard, t...). [09:38:24] Gibble activates an ability of [Cephalid Illusionist] targeting [Cephalid Illusionist] ( Prevent all combat damage that would be dealt to and dealt by target creature you control this tu...). [09:38:24] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Cephalid Illusionist] onto the stack (Whenever Cephalid Illusionist becomes the target of a spell or ability, put the top three cards of...). [09:38:39] 1 damage caused by [Cephalid Illusionist] to [Bloodthrone Vampire] is prevented. [09:38:39] 3 damage caused by [Bloodthrone Vampire] to [Cephalid Illusionist] is prevented. [09:38:39] 1 damage caused by [Cephalid Illusionist] to [Bloodthrone Vampire] is prevented. [09:38:39] 1 damage caused by [Bloodthrone Vampire] to [Cephalid Illusionist] is prevented. [09:38:44] Turn 13: Gibble [09:39:35] Gibble discards [Shuko]. [09:39:35] Gibble discards [Scatter Arc]. [09:39:35] Gibble activates an ability of [Haunted Dead] ( Return Haunted Dead from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.). [09:39:43] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Flayer of the Hatebound] onto the stack targeting [Watchers of the Dead] (Whenever Flayer of the Hatebound or another creature enters the battlefield from your graveyard, t...). [09:39:43] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Haunted Dead] onto the stack (When Haunted Dead enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Spirit creature token with flying.). [09:39:47] Gibble's [Haunted Dead] creates a Spirit token. [09:40:09] Gibble casts [Dread Return] from the graveyard targeting [Flayer of the Hatebound]. [09:40:54] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Flayer of the Hatebound] onto the stack targeting Carmandor (Whenever Flayer of the Hatebound or another creature enters the battlefield from your graveyard, t...). [09:40:56] Gibble puts triggered ability from [Flayer of the Hatebound] onto the stack targeting Carmandor (Whenever Flayer of the Hatebound or another creature enters the battlefield from your graveyard, t...). [09:41:08] Carmandor is being attacked by [Flayer of the Hatebound]. [09:41:17] Turn 13: Carmandor [09:41:32] Carmandor casts [Immortal Servitude]. (X is 2). [09:42:12] [CHAT] Gibble: ggs [09:42:15] Gibble has conceded from the game. Winner: Carmandor Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: Carmandor: 2–1