PennyDreadful
PD League
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
soldiermage,Carmandor

== Game 1 (646339658) ==
[00:36:13] PDBot has started watching.
[00:36:13] Carmandor joined the game.
[League] Looping Wave by soldiermage (27420) vs Aristocrats by carmandor (27419)
[00:36:18] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
[00:36:22] soldiermage chooses to play first.
[00:36:25] soldiermage mulligans to 6 cards.
[00:36:27] Carmandor keeps this hand.
[00:36:28] soldiermage keeps this hand.
[00:36:30] soldiermage puts 1 card on top of their library.
[00:36:30] Turn 1: soldiermage
[00:36:30] soldiermage skips their draw step.
[00:36:34] soldiermage plays [Desert of the Mindful].
[00:36:37] Turn 1: Carmandor
[00:36:42] Carmandor plays [Desert of the Glorified].
[00:36:44] Turn 2: soldiermage
[00:36:46] soldiermage plays [Evolving Wilds].
[00:36:47] soldiermage activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[00:36:57] Turn 2: Carmandor
[00:37:00] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:37:02] Carmandor casts [Skirsdag High Priest].
[00:37:04] Turn 3: soldiermage
[00:37:10] soldiermage plays [Mountain].
[00:37:13] soldiermage casts [Compulsive Research] targeting soldiermage.
[00:37:13] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Compulsive Research[sU] has a Advantageous bug.
Dredging rather than drawing can let you avoid discarding
[00:37:15] soldiermage draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[00:37:35] soldiermage discards [Rupture Spire].
[00:37:41] Turn 3: Carmandor
[00:37:48] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:37:51] soldiermage is being attacked by [Skirsdag High Priest].
[00:37:59] Carmandor casts [Carrier Thrall].
[00:38:01] Turn 4: soldiermage
[00:38:03] soldiermage plays [Evolving Wilds].
[00:38:05] soldiermage activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[00:38:13] soldiermage casts [Compulsive Research] targeting soldiermage.
[00:38:14] soldiermage draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[00:38:35] soldiermage discards [Rupture Spire].
[00:38:41] Turn 4: Carmandor
[00:38:48] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:38:53] soldiermage is being attacked by [Carrier Thrall].
[00:39:07] Carmandor casts [Gatekeeper of Malakir] (with kicker).
[00:39:09] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Gatekeeper of Malakir] onto the stack targeting Carmandor (When Gatekeeper of Malakir enters the battlefield, if it was kicked, target player sacrifices a cr...).
[00:39:16] Carmandor sacrifices [Carrier Thrall].
[00:39:16] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Carrier Thrall] onto the stack (When Carrier Thrall dies, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. It has 'Sacrifice t...).
[00:39:18] Carmandor's [Carrier Thrall] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[00:39:25] Carmandor activates an ability of [Skirsdag High Priest] ( Create a 5/5 black Demon creature token with flying.).
[00:39:25] Carmandor's [Skirsdag High Priest] creates a Demon token.
[00:39:30] Carmandor casts [Zulaport Cutthroat].
[00:39:32] Turn 5: soldiermage
[00:39:43] soldiermage plays [Desert of the True].
[00:39:59] Turn 5: Carmandor
[00:40:09] Carmandor casts [Brain Maggot].
[00:40:15] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Brain Maggot] onto the stack targeting soldiermage (When Brain Maggot enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals their hand and you choose a nonl...).
[00:40:18] soldiermage reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [Desert of the True], [Lull], [Resounding Thunder], [Edge of Autumn], [Vizier of Tumbling Sands], [New Perspectives], and [Resounding Thunder].
[00:40:42] Carmandor casts [Zulaport Cutthroat].
[00:40:54] soldiermage is being attacked by [Zulaport Cutthroat], [Demon] token, and [Gatekeeper of Malakir].
[00:41:08] soldiermage casts [Resounding Thunder] targeting [Brain Maggot].
[00:41:09] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...).
[00:41:10] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...).
[00:41:16] Turn 6: soldiermage
[00:41:24] soldiermage plays [Desert of the Glorified].
[00:41:33] Turn 6: Carmandor
[00:41:37] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:41:52] soldiermage is being attacked by [Zulaport Cutthroat], [Zulaport Cutthroat], [Demon] token, and [Gatekeeper of Malakir].
[00:41:56] soldiermage casts [Lull].
[00:42:04] 2 damage caused by [Gatekeeper of Malakir] to soldiermage is prevented.
[00:42:04] 5 damage caused by [Demon] token to soldiermage is prevented.
[00:42:04] 1 damage caused by [Zulaport Cutthroat] to soldiermage is prevented.
[00:42:04] 1 damage caused by [Zulaport Cutthroat] to soldiermage is prevented.
[00:42:10] Carmandor casts [Grim Haruspex].
[00:42:14] Turn 7: soldiermage
[00:42:18] soldiermage casts [New Perspectives].
[00:42:20] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [New Perspectives] onto the stack (When New Perspectives enters the battlefield, draw three cards.).
[00:42:24] soldiermage draws three cards with [New Perspectives]'s ability.
[00:42:27] soldiermage discards [Resounding Wave].
[00:42:27] soldiermage cycles [Resounding Wave].
[00:42:40] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Resounding Wave] onto the stack targeting [Demon] token, and [Zulaport Cutthroat] ( When you cycle Resounding Wave, return 2 target permanents to their owners' hands.).
[00:42:46] soldiermage returns [Demon] token and [Zulaport Cutthroat] to their owner's hand with [Resounding Wave]'s ability.
[00:42:50] soldiermage discards [Desert of the Indomitable].
[00:42:50] soldiermage cycles [Desert of the Indomitable].
[00:42:55] soldiermage discards [Jund Sojourners].
[00:42:55] soldiermage cycles [Jund Sojourners].
[00:42:56] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Jund Sojourners] onto the stack targeting Carmandor (When you cycle Jund Sojourners or it dies, you may have it deal 1 damage to any target. ;).
[00:43:03] soldiermage discards [Edge of Autumn].
[00:43:03] soldiermage cycles [Edge of Autumn].
[00:43:06] soldiermage discards [Vizier of Tumbling Sands].
[00:43:06] soldiermage cycles [Vizier of Tumbling Sands].
[00:43:09] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Vizier of Tumbling Sands] onto the stack targeting [Desert of the Mindful] (When you cycle Vizier of Tumbling Sands, untap target permanent.).
[00:43:17] soldiermage discards [Desert of the True].
[00:43:17] soldiermage cycles [Desert of the True].
[00:43:21] soldiermage discards [Edge of Autumn].
[00:43:21] soldiermage cycles [Edge of Autumn].
[00:43:23] soldiermage discards [Edge of Autumn].
[00:43:23] soldiermage cycles [Edge of Autumn].
[00:43:26] soldiermage discards [Desert of the Fervent].
[00:43:26] soldiermage cycles [Desert of the Fervent].
[00:43:28] soldiermage discards [Desert of the Fervent].
[00:43:28] soldiermage cycles [Desert of the Fervent].
[00:43:33] soldiermage discards [Resounding Wave].
[00:43:33] soldiermage cycles [Resounding Wave].
[00:43:40] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Resounding Wave] onto the stack targeting [Gatekeeper of Malakir], and [Zulaport Cutthroat] ( When you cycle Resounding Wave, return 2 target permanents to their owners' hands.).
[00:43:42] soldiermage returns [Gatekeeper of Malakir] and [Zulaport Cutthroat] to their owner's hand with [Resounding Wave]'s ability.
[00:43:47] soldiermage discards [Desert of the Indomitable].
[00:43:47] soldiermage cycles [Desert of the Indomitable].
[00:44:00] soldiermage discards [Shefet Monitor].
[00:44:00] soldiermage cycles [Shefet Monitor].
[00:44:00] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Shefet Monitor] onto the stack (When you cycle Shefet Monitor, you may search your library for a basic land card or a Desert card,...).
[00:44:14] soldiermage discards [Desert of the Mindful].
[00:44:15] soldiermage cycles [Desert of the Mindful].
[00:44:19] soldiermage discards [Resounding Thunder].
[00:44:19] soldiermage cycles [Resounding Thunder].
[00:44:22] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Resounding Thunder] onto the stack targeting Carmandor ( When you cycle Resounding Thunder, it deals 6 damage to any target.).
[00:44:27] soldiermage discards [Resounding Thunder].
[00:44:27] soldiermage cycles [Resounding Thunder].
[00:44:31] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Resounding Thunder] onto the stack targeting Carmandor ( When you cycle Resounding Thunder, it deals 6 damage to any target.).
[00:44:36] soldiermage discards [Desert of the Glorified].
[00:44:36] soldiermage cycles [Desert of the Glorified].
[00:44:38] soldiermage discards [Desert of the Indomitable].
[00:44:38] soldiermage cycles [Desert of the Indomitable].
[00:44:41] soldiermage discards [Resounding Wave].
[00:44:41] soldiermage cycles [Resounding Wave].
[00:44:45] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Resounding Wave] onto the stack targeting [Skirsdag High Priest], and [Grim Haruspex] ( When you cycle Resounding Wave, return 2 target permanents to their owners' hands.).
[00:44:46] soldiermage returns [Skirsdag High Priest] and [Grim Haruspex] to their owner's hand with [Resounding Wave]'s ability.
[00:44:50] soldiermage discards [Countervailing Winds].
[00:44:50] soldiermage cycles [Countervailing Winds].
[00:44:55] soldiermage plays [Island].
[00:45:04] soldiermage casts [Compulsive Research] targeting soldiermage.
[00:45:04] soldiermage draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[00:45:11] soldiermage discards [Evolving Wilds].
[00:45:13] soldiermage discards [Resounding Wave].
[00:45:14] soldiermage cycles [Resounding Wave].
[00:45:16] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Resounding Wave] onto the stack targeting [Desert of the Glorified], and [Swamp] ( When you cycle Resounding Wave, return 2 target permanents to their owners' hands.).
[00:45:17] soldiermage returns [Desert of the Glorified] and [Swamp] to their owner's hand with [Resounding Wave]'s ability.
[00:45:22] soldiermage discards [Shefet Monitor].
[00:45:23] soldiermage cycles [Shefet Monitor].
[00:45:23] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Shefet Monitor] onto the stack (When you cycle Shefet Monitor, you may search your library for a basic land card or a Desert card,...).
[00:45:28] soldiermage fails to find a basic land card or a Desert card.
[00:45:35] soldiermage discards [Jund Sojourners].
[00:45:35] soldiermage cycles [Jund Sojourners].
[00:45:37] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Jund Sojourners] onto the stack targeting Carmandor (When you cycle Jund Sojourners or it dies, you may have it deal 1 damage to any target. ;).
[00:45:52] soldiermage discards [Edge of Autumn].
[00:45:52] soldiermage cycles [Edge of Autumn].
[00:45:55] soldiermage discards [Shefet Monitor].
[00:45:55] soldiermage cycles [Shefet Monitor].
[00:45:55] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Shefet Monitor] onto the stack (When you cycle Shefet Monitor, you may search your library for a basic land card or a Desert card,...).
[00:46:00] soldiermage chooses not to use [Shefet Monitor]'s ability.
[00:46:05] soldiermage discards [Resounding Thunder].
[00:46:05] soldiermage cycles [Resounding Thunder].
[00:46:08] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Resounding Thunder] onto the stack targeting Carmandor ( When you cycle Resounding Thunder, it deals 6 damage to any target.).
[00:46:13] soldiermage discards [Shefet Monitor].
[00:46:13] soldiermage cycles [Shefet Monitor].
[00:46:13] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Shefet Monitor] onto the stack (When you cycle Shefet Monitor, you may search your library for a basic land card or a Desert card,...).
[00:46:17] soldiermage chooses not to use [Shefet Monitor]'s ability.
[00:46:20] soldiermage discards [Vizier of Tumbling Sands].
[00:46:21] soldiermage cycles [Vizier of Tumbling Sands].
[00:46:22] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Vizier of Tumbling Sands] onto the stack targeting [Swamp] (When you cycle Vizier of Tumbling Sands, untap target permanent.).
[00:46:27] soldiermage discards [Vizier of Tumbling Sands].
[00:46:27] soldiermage cycles [Vizier of Tumbling Sands].
[00:46:29] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Vizier of Tumbling Sands] onto the stack targeting [Mountain] (When you cycle Vizier of Tumbling Sands, untap target permanent.).
[00:46:34] soldiermage casts [Shadow of the Grave].
[00:46:35] soldiermage returns [Vizier of Tumbling Sands], [Vizier of Tumbling Sands], [Shefet Monitor], [Resounding Thunder], [Shefet Monitor], [Edge of Autumn], [Jund Sojourners], [Shefet Monitor], [Resounding Wave], [Evolving Wilds], 
[00:46:35] [Countervailing Winds], [Resounding Wave], [Desert of the Indomitable], [Desert of the Glorified], [Resounding Thunder], [Resounding Thunder], [Desert of the Mindful], [Shefet Monitor], [Desert of the Indomitable], [Resounding Wave], 
[00:46:35] [Desert of the Fervent], [Desert of the Fervent], [Edge of Autumn], [Edge of Autumn], [Desert of the True], [Vizier of Tumbling Sands], [Edge of Autumn], [Jund Sojourners], [Desert of the Indomitable], and [Resounding Wave] to their owner's hand with [Shadow of the Grave].
[00:46:45] soldiermage discards [Resounding Thunder].
[00:46:45] soldiermage cycles [Resounding Thunder].
[00:46:47] soldiermage puts triggered ability from [Resounding Thunder] onto the stack targeting Carmandor ( When you cycle Resounding Thunder, it deals 6 damage to any target.).
Winner: soldiermage
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (646341252) ==
[00:48:01] PDBot has started watching.
[00:48:04] Carmandor mulligans to 6 cards.
[00:48:09] soldiermage keeps this hand.
[00:48:10] Carmandor keeps this hand.
[00:48:13] Carmandor puts 1 card on top of their library.
[00:48:14] Turn 1: Carmandor
[00:48:15] Carmandor skips their draw step.
[00:48:16] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:48:18] Turn 1: soldiermage
[00:48:22] soldiermage plays [Desert of the Mindful].
[00:48:26] Turn 2: Carmandor
[00:48:28] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:48:31] Carmandor casts [Carrier Thrall].
[00:48:32] Turn 2: soldiermage
[00:48:35] soldiermage plays [Desert of the Fervent].
[00:48:38] Turn 3: Carmandor
[00:48:42] soldiermage is being attacked by [Carrier Thrall].
[00:48:46] Carmandor casts [Bloodthrone Vampire].
[00:48:48] Turn 3: soldiermage
[00:48:50] soldiermage plays [Mountain].
[00:48:55] soldiermage casts [Compulsive Research] targeting soldiermage.
[00:48:56] soldiermage draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[00:49:21] soldiermage discards [Jund Sojourners].
[00:49:21] soldiermage discards [Countervailing Winds].
[00:49:29] Turn 4: Carmandor
[00:49:32] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:49:37] Carmandor casts [Zulaport Cutthroat].
[00:49:43] soldiermage is being attacked by [Bloodthrone Vampire] and [Carrier Thrall].
[00:49:52] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[00:49:56] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...).
[00:49:56] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Carrier Thrall] onto the stack (When Carrier Thrall dies, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. It has 'Sacrifice t...).
[00:49:59] Carmandor's [Carrier Thrall] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[00:50:05] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...).
[00:50:07] Carmandor casts [Sultai Emissary].
[00:50:08] Turn 4: soldiermage
[00:50:12] soldiermage plays [Evolving Wilds].
[00:50:14] soldiermage activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[00:51:04] soldiermage casts [Resounding Thunder] targeting [Zulaport Cutthroat].
[00:51:04] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[00:51:04] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...).
[00:51:04] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Sultai Emissary] onto the stack (When Sultai Emissary dies, manifest the top card of your library.).
[00:51:04] Carmandor manifests the top card of his or her library with Sultai Emissary.
[00:51:08] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[00:51:08] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...).
[00:51:13] soldiermage's [Resounding Thunder] is countered because it has no legal targets.
[00:51:16] Turn 5: Carmandor
[00:51:19] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:51:21] Carmandor casts [Grim Haruspex].
[00:51:25] soldiermage is being attacked by manifested creature #1 and [Bloodthrone Vampire].
[00:51:36] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[00:51:40] Turn 5: soldiermage
[00:51:54] soldiermage plays [Desert of the Glorified].
[00:52:03] soldiermage casts [Edge of Autumn].
[00:52:07] Turn 6: Carmandor
[00:52:16] Carmandor casts [Memoricide] targeting soldiermage.
[00:52:19] soldiermage has conceded from the game.
[00:52:19] Carmandor reveals manifested creature #1 as Swamp.
Winner: Carmandor
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (646341860) ==
[00:52:42] PDBot has started watching.
[00:52:44] soldiermage chooses to play first.
[00:52:58] soldiermage keeps this hand.
[00:53:00] Carmandor keeps this hand.
[00:53:00] Turn 1: soldiermage
[00:53:01] soldiermage skips their draw step.
[00:53:01] soldiermage plays [Desert of the Mindful].
[00:53:04] Turn 1: Carmandor
[00:53:07] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:53:09] Turn 2: soldiermage
[00:53:12] soldiermage plays [Desert of the True].
[00:53:15] Turn 2: Carmandor
[00:53:18] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:53:22] Carmandor casts [Bloodthrone Vampire].
[00:53:25] Turn 3: soldiermage
[00:53:31] soldiermage plays [Desert of the Fervent].
[00:53:39] Turn 3: Carmandor
[00:53:42] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:53:46] soldiermage is being attacked by [Bloodthrone Vampire].
[00:53:52] Carmandor casts [Grim Haruspex].
[00:53:54] Turn 4: soldiermage
[00:54:01] soldiermage casts [Resounding Wave] targeting [Swamp].
[00:54:03] soldiermage returns [Swamp] to its owner's hand with [Resounding Wave].
[00:54:07] Turn 4: Carmandor
[00:54:10] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:54:13] Carmandor casts [Bloodthrone Vampire].
[00:54:17] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[00:54:17] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Grim Haruspex] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature you control dies, draw a card.).
[00:54:19] Carmandor draws a card with [Grim Haruspex]'s ability.
[00:54:26] soldiermage is being attacked by [Grim Haruspex] and [Bloodthrone Vampire].
[00:54:29] Turn 5: soldiermage
[00:54:36] soldiermage casts [Resounding Thunder] targeting [Grim Haruspex].
[00:54:41] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[00:54:44] soldiermage's [Resounding Thunder] is countered because it has no legal targets.
[00:54:47] Turn 5: Carmandor
[00:54:50] Carmandor plays [Swamp].
[00:54:53] Carmandor casts [Carrier Thrall].
[00:54:55] Carmandor casts [Zulaport Cutthroat].
[00:54:57] soldiermage is being attacked by [Bloodthrone Vampire].
[00:55:00] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[00:55:01] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...).
[00:55:01] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Carrier Thrall] onto the stack (When Carrier Thrall dies, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. It has 'Sacrifice t...).
[00:55:03] Carmandor's [Carrier Thrall] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[00:55:11] Carmandor activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[00:55:11] Carmandor puts triggered ability from [Zulaport Cutthroat] onto the stack (Whenever Zulaport Cutthroat or another creature you control dies, each opponent loses 1 life and y...).
[00:55:19] Turn 6: soldiermage
[00:55:31] soldiermage has conceded from the game.
Winner: Carmandor
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Carmandor: 2–1