PennyDreadfulCommander Penny Dreadful EDH BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Back_Alley_G,EternalParadox38,midwestlunatic == Game 1 (646243614) == [10:52:07] PDBot has started watching. [10:52:07] midwestlunatic joined the game. [10:52:07] Back_Alley_G joined the game. [10:52:16] Back_Alley_G chooses to play first. [10:52:16] Back_Alley_G chooses [Brago, King Eternal] as their commander. [10:52:17] midwestlunatic chooses [Tatyova, Benthic Druid] as their commander. [10:52:17] EternalParadox38 chooses [Tibor and Lumia] as their commander. [10:52:22] Back_Alley_G keeps this hand. [10:52:33] midwestlunatic keeps this hand. [10:52:45] EternalParadox38 mulligans to 7 cards. [10:52:47] EternalParadox38 keeps this hand. [10:52:47] Turn 1: Back_Alley_G [10:52:50] Back_Alley_G plays [Meandering River]. [10:52:52] Turn 1: midwestlunatic [10:53:03] midwestlunatic plays [Thawing Glaciers]. [10:53:06] Turn 1: EternalParadox38 [10:53:09] EternalParadox38 plays [Memorial to Genius]. [10:53:12] Turn 2: Back_Alley_G [10:53:16] Back_Alley_G plays [Plains]. [10:53:19] Back_Alley_G casts [Augury Owl]. [10:53:22] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Augury Owl] onto the stack (When Augury Owl enters the battlefield, scry 3.). [10:54:10] Back_Alley_G puts 1 card on the bottom of their library and 2 cards on top of their library. [10:54:10] Turn 2: midwestlunatic [10:54:49] midwestlunatic plays [Forest]. [10:54:49] midwestlunatic activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...). [10:54:50] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.). [10:54:50] midwestlunatic discards [Bad River]. [10:54:50] Turn 2: EternalParadox38 [10:54:50] EternalParadox38 plays [Mountain]. [10:54:58] Turn 3: Back_Alley_G [10:55:00] Back_Alley_G plays [Plains]. [10:55:02] Back_Alley_G casts [Transmogrifying Wand]. [10:55:09] midwestlunatic is being attacked by [Augury Owl]. [10:55:13] Turn 3: midwestlunatic [10:55:20] midwestlunatic plays [Thawing Glaciers]. [10:55:24] midwestlunatic casts [Blackblade Reforged]. [10:55:28] Turn 3: EternalParadox38 [10:55:35] EternalParadox38 plays [Island]. [10:55:43] EternalParadox38 casts [Cultivator's Caravan]. [10:55:51] Turn 4: Back_Alley_G [10:55:53] Back_Alley_G plays [Plains]. [10:55:57] Back_Alley_G casts [Brago, King Eternal]. [10:56:04] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Augury Owl]. [10:56:07] Turn 4: midwestlunatic [10:56:18] midwestlunatic plays [Island]. [10:56:31] midwestlunatic casts [Borderland Ranger]. [10:56:31] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Borderland Ranger] onto the stack (When Borderland Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, ...). [10:56:41] midwestlunatic reveals [Forest]. [10:56:44] Turn 4: EternalParadox38 [10:56:57] EternalParadox38 plays [Island]. [10:57:07] EternalParadox38 casts [Levitation]. [10:57:17] Turn 5: Back_Alley_G [10:57:45] Back_Alley_G discards [Secluded Steppe]. [10:57:45] Back_Alley_G cycles [Secluded Steppe]. [10:57:51] Back_Alley_G plays [Plains]. [10:58:15] Back_Alley_G casts [Reality Acid] targeting [Thawing Glaciers]. [10:58:36] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Brago, King Eternal]. [10:58:36] midwestlunatic is being attacked by [Augury Owl]. [10:58:40] EternalParadox38 has been dealt 2 total damage by Back_Alley_G's commander, [Brago, King Eternal]. [10:58:48] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Brago, King Eternal] onto the stack targeting [Reality Acid], [Augury Owl], and [Brago, King Eternal] (Whenever Brago, King Eternal deals combat damage to a player, exile any number of target nonland p...). [10:59:09] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Augury Owl] onto the stack (When Augury Owl enters the battlefield, scry 3.). [10:59:09] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Reality Acid] onto the stack (When Reality Acid leaves the battlefield, enchanted permanent's controller sacrifices it.). [10:59:50] Back_Alley_G puts 3 cards on top of their library. [10:59:51] Turn 5: midwestlunatic [10:59:56] midwestlunatic plays [Forest]. [11:00:28] midwestlunatic casts [Hunting Wilds]. [11:00:39] Turn 5: EternalParadox38 [11:01:03] EternalParadox38 casts [Tibor and Lumia]. [11:01:09] EternalParadox38 plays [Island]. [11:01:15] Turn 6: Back_Alley_G [11:01:16] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Reality Acid] onto the stack (Vanishing 3 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter from this card.)). [11:01:31] Back_Alley_G casts [Cultivator's Caravan]. [11:01:48] Back_Alley_G casts [Stasis Snare]. [11:01:55] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Stasis Snare] onto the stack targeting [Tibor and Lumia] (When Stasis Snare enters the battlefield, exile target creature an opponent controls until Stasis ...). [11:02:22] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Augury Owl]. [11:02:22] midwestlunatic is being attacked by [Brago, King Eternal]. [11:02:41] midwestlunatic has been dealt 2 total damage by Back_Alley_G's commander, [Brago, King Eternal]. [11:02:51] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Brago, King Eternal] onto the stack targeting [Brago, King Eternal], [Augury Owl], and [Cultivator's Caravan] (Whenever Brago, King Eternal deals combat damage to a player, exile any number of target nonland p...). [11:02:54] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Augury Owl] onto the stack (When Augury Owl enters the battlefield, scry 3.). [11:03:19] Back_Alley_G puts 1 card on the bottom of their library and 2 cards on top of their library. [11:03:31] Turn 6: midwestlunatic [11:03:36] [CHAT] Back_Alley_G: oops, forgot about the acid [11:04:11] midwestlunatic casts [Brutalizer Exarch]. [11:04:26] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Brutalizer Exarch] onto the stack targeting [Reality Acid] (Put target noncreature permanent on the bottom of its owner's library.). [11:04:45] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Reality Acid] onto the stack (When Reality Acid leaves the battlefield, enchanted permanent's controller sacrifices it.). [11:04:53] midwestlunatic plays [Woodland Stream]. [11:05:01] Turn 6: EternalParadox38 [11:05:40] EternalParadox38 casts [Chain Reaction]. [11:05:55] EternalParadox38 plays [Spinerock Knoll]. [11:05:55] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Spinerock Knoll] onto the stack (Hideaway). [11:05:55] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Spinerock Knoll[sU] has a Disadvantageous bug. Shelldock Isle and other hideaway lands from Lorwyn do not allow you to play lands. Our data about this bug is out of date. Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed). You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Spinerock Knoll` or `!notbugged Spinerock Knoll` [11:06:18] Turn 7: Back_Alley_G [11:06:21] Back_Alley_G plays [Island]. [11:06:33] Back_Alley_G casts [Brago, King Eternal]. [11:06:38] Turn 7: midwestlunatic [11:06:56] midwestlunatic casts [Viridian Zealot]. [11:07:13] midwestlunatic activates an ability of [Viridian Zealot] targeting [Transmogrifying Wand] ( Destroy target artifact or enchantment.). [11:07:20] midwestlunatic casts [Mul Daya Channelers]. [11:07:26] Turn 7: EternalParadox38 [11:07:38] EternalParadox38 plays [Island]. [11:07:52] EternalParadox38 casts [Tibor and Lumia]. [11:08:06] Turn 8: Back_Alley_G [11:08:19] Back_Alley_G casts [Knight-Captain of Eos]. [11:08:24] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Knight-Captain of Eos] onto the stack (When Knight-Captain of Eos enters the battlefield, create two 1/1 white Soldier creature tokens.). [11:08:30] Back_Alley_G's [Knight-Captain of Eos] creates two Soldier tokens. [11:08:44] midwestlunatic is being attacked by [Brago, King Eternal]. [11:08:55] midwestlunatic has been dealt 4 total damage by Back_Alley_G's commander, [Brago, King Eternal]. [11:09:02] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Brago, King Eternal] onto the stack targeting [Brago, King Eternal], [Knight-Captain of Eos], [Stasis Snare], and [Cultivator's Caravan] (Whenever Brago, King Eternal deals combat damage to a player, exile any number of target nonland p...). [11:09:18] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Stasis Snare] onto the stack targeting [Tibor and Lumia] (When Stasis Snare enters the battlefield, exile target creature an opponent controls until Stasis ...). [11:09:18] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Knight-Captain of Eos] onto the stack (When Knight-Captain of Eos enters the battlefield, create two 1/1 white Soldier creature tokens.). [11:09:21] Back_Alley_G's [Knight-Captain of Eos] creates two Soldier tokens. [11:09:42] Turn 8: midwestlunatic [11:10:08] midwestlunatic casts [Trophy Mage]. [11:10:12] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Trophy Mage] onto the stack (When Trophy Mage enters the battlefield, you may search your library for an artifact card with con...). [11:10:25] midwestlunatic reveals [Transmogrifying Wand]. [11:10:36] midwestlunatic casts [Transmogrifying Wand]. [11:10:58] Turn 8: EternalParadox38 [11:11:16] EternalParadox38 casts [Spellbound Dragon]. [11:11:34] Turn 9: Back_Alley_G [11:12:10] Back_Alley_G casts [Banishing Light]. [11:12:21] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Banishing Light] onto the stack targeting [Transmogrifying Wand] (When Banishing Light enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent an opponent controls u...). [11:12:54] [CHAT] Back_Alley_G: sorcery speed only [11:13:06] [CHAT] midwestlunatic: ah I need to read [11:13:09] [CHAT] midwestlunatic: bummer [11:13:38] midwestlunatic is being attacked by [Brago, King Eternal]. [11:13:53] midwestlunatic has been dealt 6 total damage by Back_Alley_G's commander, [Brago, King Eternal]. [11:14:01] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Brago, King Eternal] onto the stack targeting [Knight-Captain of Eos], [Brago, King Eternal], [Cultivator's Caravan], and [Stasis Snare] (Whenever Brago, King Eternal deals combat damage to a player, exile any number of target nonland p...). [11:14:11] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Stasis Snare] onto the stack targeting [Spellbound Dragon] (When Stasis Snare enters the battlefield, exile target creature an opponent controls until Stasis ...). [11:14:11] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Knight-Captain of Eos] onto the stack (When Knight-Captain of Eos enters the battlefield, create two 1/1 white Soldier creature tokens.). [11:14:14] Back_Alley_G's [Knight-Captain of Eos] creates two Soldier tokens. [11:14:23] Back_Alley_G casts [Silver Myr]. [11:14:30] Turn 9: midwestlunatic [11:16:02] midwestlunatic casts [Altered Ego]. (X is 3). [11:16:34] Turn 9: EternalParadox38 [11:17:10] EternalParadox38 casts [Willbreaker]. [11:17:33] EternalParadox38 casts [Slip Through Space] targeting [Brago, King Eternal]. [11:17:34] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Willbreaker] onto the stack (Whenever a creature an opponent controls becomes the target of a spell or ability you control, gai...). [11:17:49] EternalParadox38 draws a card with [Slip Through Space]. [11:18:01] EternalParadox38 plays [Lonely Sandbar]. [11:18:12] Turn 10: Back_Alley_G [11:18:43] Back_Alley_G casts [Luminate Primordial]. [11:18:49] [CHAT] midwestlunatic: I hate mtgo interface, the wand is covering my lands [11:19:13] [CHAT] Back_Alley_G: yeah, that aspect of multiplayer could use some work [11:19:45] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Luminate Primordial] onto the stack targeting [Brago, King Eternal], and [Brago, King Eternal] (When Luminate Primordial enters the battlefield, for each opponent, exile up to one target creatur...). [11:20:09] Turn 10: midwestlunatic [11:20:38] midwestlunatic casts [Tatyova, Benthic Druid]. [11:20:52] midwestlunatic plays [Skyshroud Forest]. [11:20:52] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Tatyova, Benthic Druid] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life and draw a card.). [11:20:59] midwestlunatic draws a card with [Tatyova, Benthic Druid]'s ability. [11:21:21] midwestlunatic activates an ability of [Blackblade Reforged] targeting [Tatyova, Benthic Druid] (Equip legendary creature {3} ). [11:22:21] Turn 10: EternalParadox38 [11:23:00] EternalParadox38 plays [Highland Lake]. [11:23:13] EternalParadox38 casts [Tibor and Lumia]. [11:23:40] Turn 11: Back_Alley_G [11:23:57] Back_Alley_G plays [Plains]. [11:24:04] Back_Alley_G casts [Brago, King Eternal]. [11:24:21] Back_Alley_G activates an ability of [Cultivator's Caravan] (Crew 3). [11:24:38] EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Luminate Primordial] and [Cultivator's Caravan]. [11:24:57] Turn 11: midwestlunatic [11:25:39] midwestlunatic plays [Island]. [11:25:39] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Tatyova, Benthic Druid] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life and draw a card.). [11:25:39] midwestlunatic draws a card with [Tatyova, Benthic Druid]'s ability. [11:26:08] midwestlunatic discards [Shefet Monitor]. [11:26:08] midwestlunatic cycles [Shefet Monitor]. [11:26:08] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Shefet Monitor] onto the stack (When you cycle Shefet Monitor, you may search your library for a basic land card or a Desert card,...). [11:26:23] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Tatyova, Benthic Druid] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life and draw a card.). [11:26:23] midwestlunatic draws a card with [Tatyova, Benthic Druid]'s ability. [11:27:06] midwestlunatic casts [Journey of Discovery] (Entwine). [11:27:19] midwestlunatic reveals [Forest]. [11:27:20] midwestlunatic reveals [Island]. [11:27:36] midwestlunatic plays [Forest]. [11:27:36] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Tatyova, Benthic Druid] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life and draw a card.). [11:27:36] midwestlunatic draws a card with [Tatyova, Benthic Druid]'s ability. [11:27:43] midwestlunatic plays [Island]. [11:27:43] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Tatyova, Benthic Druid] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life and draw a card.). [11:27:44] midwestlunatic draws a card with [Tatyova, Benthic Druid]'s ability. [11:28:28] midwestlunatic casts [Centaur Chieftain]. [11:28:33] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Centaur Chieftain] onto the stack (When Centaur Chieftain enters the battlefield, creatures you control get +1/+1 and gain trample un...). [11:28:51] Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Tatyova, Benthic Druid]. [11:29:03] Back_Alley_G has been dealt 16 total damage by midwestlunatic's commander, [Tatyova, Benthic Druid]. [11:29:24] Turn 11: EternalParadox38 [11:30:17] EternalParadox38 casts [Archetype of Imagination]. [11:30:30] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Tibor and Lumia] onto the stack targeting [Brago, King Eternal] (Whenever you cast a blue spell, target creature gains flying until end of turn.). [11:30:30] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Willbreaker] onto the stack (Whenever a creature an opponent controls becomes the target of a spell or ability you control, gai...). [11:31:00] Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Tibor and Lumia]. [11:31:21] Back_Alley_G has been dealt 3 total damage by EternalParadox38's commander, [Tibor and Lumia]. [11:31:32] EternalParadox38 casts [Protean Raider]. [11:31:34] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Tibor and Lumia] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a red spell, Tibor and Lumia deals 1 damage to each creature without flying.). [11:31:44] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Tibor and Lumia] onto the stack targeting [Tatyova, Benthic Druid] (Whenever you cast a blue spell, target creature gains flying until end of turn.). [11:31:44] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Willbreaker] onto the stack (Whenever a creature an opponent controls becomes the target of a spell or ability you control, gai...). [11:32:22] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Luminate Primordial] onto the stack targeting [Luminate Primordial], and [Mul Daya Channelers] (When Luminate Primordial enters the battlefield, for each opponent, exile up to one target creatur...). [11:32:22] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Willbreaker] onto the stack (Whenever a creature an opponent controls becomes the target of a spell or ability you control, gai...). [11:32:22] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Willbreaker] onto the stack (Whenever a creature an opponent controls becomes the target of a spell or ability you control, gai...). [11:32:27] EternalParadox38's Triggered ability from Luminate Primordial is countered because it has illegal targets. [11:32:30] Turn 12: Back_Alley_G [11:32:46] Back_Alley_G casts [Resolute Archangel]. [11:32:58] Back_Alley_G puts triggered ability from [Resolute Archangel] onto the stack (When Resolute Archangel enters the battlefield, if your life total is less than your starting life...). [11:33:03] Back_Alley_G plays [Vivid Meadow]. [11:33:14] Turn 12: midwestlunatic [11:33:37] midwestlunatic discards [Desert of the Indomitable]. [11:33:37] midwestlunatic cycles [Desert of the Indomitable]. [11:34:12] midwestlunatic plays [Urza's Factory]. [11:34:51] midwestlunatic casts [Verdeloth the Ancient] (with kicker). (X is 5). [11:34:54] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Verdeloth the Ancient] onto the stack (When Verdeloth the Ancient enters the battlefield, if it was kicked, create X 1/1 green Saproling ...). [11:35:00] midwestlunatic's [Verdeloth the Ancient] creates five Saproling tokens. [11:35:20] Turn 12: EternalParadox38 [11:35:59] EternalParadox38 casts [Docent of Perfection]. [11:36:02] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Tibor and Lumia] onto the stack targeting [Verdeloth the Ancient] (Whenever you cast a blue spell, target creature gains flying until end of turn.). [11:36:02] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Willbreaker] onto the stack (Whenever a creature an opponent controls becomes the target of a spell or ability you control, gai...). [11:38:01] midwestlunatic is being attacked by [Luminate Primordial], [Archetype of Imagination], [Brago, King Eternal], [Tibor and Lumia], [Luminate Primordial], [Willbreaker], and [Mul Daya Channelers]. [11:38:01] Back_Alley_G is being attacked by [Tatyova, Benthic Druid]. [11:38:33] EternalParadox38 casts [Uncaged Fury] targeting [Archetype of Imagination]. [11:38:35] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Docent of Perfection] onto the stack (Whenever you cast an instant or sorcery spell, create a 1/1 blue Human Wizard creature token. Then...). [11:38:35] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Tibor and Lumia] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a red spell, Tibor and Lumia deals 1 damage to each creature without flying.). [11:38:39] EternalParadox38's [Docent of Perfection] creates a Human Wizard token. [11:38:48] Back_Alley_G has been dealt 32 total damage by midwestlunatic's commander, [Tatyova, Benthic Druid]. [11:38:48] midwestlunatic has been dealt 5 total damage by EternalParadox38's commander, [Tibor and Lumia]. [11:38:48] midwestlunatic has been dealt 8 total damage by Back_Alley_G's commander, [Brago, King Eternal]. [11:38:48] Back_Alley_G loses the game due to being dealt 21 or more damage by [Tatyova, Benthic Druid]. [11:38:49] Back_Alley_G is now a watcher. [11:38:55] [CHAT] Back_Alley_G: gg [11:39:21] EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Brago, King Eternal] onto the stack targeting [Tibor and Lumia], and [Archetype of Imagination] (Whenever Brago, King Eternal deals combat damage to a player, exile any number of target nonland p...). [11:39:32] Turn 13: midwestlunatic [11:40:08] midwestlunatic discards [Desert of the Mindful]. [11:40:08] midwestlunatic cycles [Desert of the Mindful]. [11:40:19] midwestlunatic discards [Beneath the Sands]. [11:40:19] midwestlunatic cycles [Beneath the Sands]. [11:41:13] midwestlunatic discards [Krosan Tusker]. [11:41:13] midwestlunatic cycles [Krosan Tusker]. [11:41:13] midwestlunatic puts triggered ability from [Krosan Tusker] onto the stack (When you cycle Krosan Tusker, you may search your library for a basic land card, reveal that card,...). [11:41:31] midwestlunatic reveals [Forest]. [11:41:38] midwestlunatic plays [Forest]. [11:41:51] midwestlunatic activates an ability of [Transmogrifying Wand] targeting [Archetype of Imagination] ( Destroy target creature. Its controller creates a 2/4 white Ox creature token.). [11:41:56] midwestlunatic's [Transmogrifying Wand] creates an Ox token under EternalParadox38's control. [11:42:06] midwestlunatic casts [Trygon Predator]. [11:42:44] [CHAT] midwestlunatic: ah the shift on top [11:42:49] [CHAT] midwestlunatic: can't beat that, gg [11:42:54] [CHAT] EternalParadox38: gg [11:42:55] midwestlunatic has conceded from the game. Winner: EternalParadox38 Game 1 Completed. [11:43:03] midwestlunatic has left the game.