PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality cotton2431,wmackinnonwhs == Game 1 (644564738) == [11:21:22] PDBot has started watching. [11:21:22] cotton2431 joined the game. [League] New Perspectives by wmackinnonwhs (26648) vs Esper Control(6) by cotton2431 (26644) [11:21:25] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [11:21:38] wmackinnonwhs chooses to play first. [11:21:44] wmackinnonwhs keeps this hand. [11:21:45] cotton2431 keeps this hand. [11:21:45] Turn 1: wmackinnonwhs [11:21:48] wmackinnonwhs skips their draw step. [11:21:51] wmackinnonwhs plays [Desert of the Mindful]. [11:22:10] Turn 1: cotton2431 [11:22:35] cotton2431 plays [Vivid Meadow]. [11:22:39] Turn 2: wmackinnonwhs [11:22:43] wmackinnonwhs plays [Forest]. [11:22:48] wmackinnonwhs casts [Edge of Autumn]. [11:23:19] Turn 2: cotton2431 [11:23:24] cotton2431 plays [Mystic Monastery]. [11:23:29] Turn 3: wmackinnonwhs [11:23:32] wmackinnonwhs plays [Swamp]. [11:23:38] wmackinnonwhs casts [Weirding Wood] targeting [Swamp]. [11:23:41] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Weirding Wood] onto the stack (When Weirding Wood enters the battlefield, investigate.). [11:23:48] wmackinnonwhs's [Weirding Wood] creates a Clue token. [11:23:53] wmackinnonwhs activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.). [11:23:54] wmackinnonwhs draws a card with [Clue] token's ability. [11:23:56] Turn 3: cotton2431 [11:24:05] martyvburen has started watching. [11:24:12] cotton2431 plays [Evolving Wilds]. [11:24:15] Turn 4: wmackinnonwhs [11:24:36] wmackinnonwhs casts [Weirding Wood] targeting [Forest]. [11:24:39] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Weirding Wood] onto the stack (When Weirding Wood enters the battlefield, investigate.). [11:24:43] wmackinnonwhs's [Weirding Wood] creates a Clue token. [11:24:49] wmackinnonwhs casts [Edge of Autumn]. [11:25:02] wmackinnonwhs discards [Glassdust Hulk]. [11:25:02] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Glassdust Hulk]. [11:25:15] cotton2431 casts [Whispers of the Muse]. [11:25:15] cotton2431 draws a card with [Whispers of the Muse]. [11:25:18] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [11:25:23] Turn 4: cotton2431 [11:25:33] cotton2431 plays [Scoured Barrens]. [11:25:33] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Scoured Barrens] onto the stack (When Scoured Barrens enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [11:25:36] Turn 5: wmackinnonwhs [11:25:48] wmackinnonwhs casts [New Perspectives]. [11:25:51] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [New Perspectives] onto the stack (When New Perspectives enters the battlefield, draw three cards.). [11:25:54] wmackinnonwhs draws three cards with [New Perspectives]'s ability. [11:25:58] wmackinnonwhs discards [Resounding Wave]. [11:25:58] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Resounding Wave]. [11:26:02] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Resounding Wave] onto the stack targeting [Mystic Monastery], and [Island] ( When you cycle Resounding Wave, return 2 target permanents to their owners' hands.). [11:26:03] martyvburen has stopped watching. [11:26:04] wmackinnonwhs returns [Mystic Monastery] and [Island] to their owner's hand with [Resounding Wave]'s ability. [11:26:11] wmackinnonwhs discards [Vizier of Tumbling Sands]. [11:26:11] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Vizier of Tumbling Sands]. [11:26:13] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Vizier of Tumbling Sands] onto the stack targeting [Swamp] (When you cycle Vizier of Tumbling Sands, untap target permanent.). [11:26:22] wmackinnonwhs discards [Resounding Thunder]. [11:26:22] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Resounding Thunder]. [11:26:25] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Resounding Thunder] onto the stack targeting cotton2431 ( When you cycle Resounding Thunder, it deals 6 damage to any target.). [11:26:35] wmackinnonwhs discards [Shefet Monitor]. [11:26:35] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Shefet Monitor]. [11:26:35] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Shefet Monitor] onto the stack (When you cycle Shefet Monitor, you may search your library for a basic land card or a Desert card,...). [11:26:48] wmackinnonwhs discards [Lonely Sandbar]. [11:26:48] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Lonely Sandbar]. [11:26:53] wmackinnonwhs discards [Lonely Sandbar]. [11:26:53] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Lonely Sandbar]. [11:26:55] wmackinnonwhs discards [Resounding Wave]. [11:26:55] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Resounding Wave]. [11:26:59] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Resounding Wave] onto the stack targeting [Vivid Meadow], and [Scoured Barrens] ( When you cycle Resounding Wave, return 2 target permanents to their owners' hands.). [11:27:01] wmackinnonwhs returns [Vivid Meadow] and [Scoured Barrens] to their owner's hand with [Resounding Wave]'s ability. [11:27:06] wmackinnonwhs discards [Desert of the Indomitable]. [11:27:06] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Desert of the Indomitable]. [11:27:09] wmackinnonwhs discards [Lonely Sandbar]. [11:27:09] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Lonely Sandbar]. [11:27:12] wmackinnonwhs discards [Resounding Thunder]. [11:27:12] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Resounding Thunder]. [11:27:15] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Resounding Thunder] onto the stack targeting cotton2431 ( When you cycle Resounding Thunder, it deals 6 damage to any target.). [11:27:22] wmackinnonwhs discards [Edge of Autumn]. [11:27:22] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Edge of Autumn]. [11:27:25] wmackinnonwhs discards [Desert of the Indomitable]. [11:27:25] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Desert of the Indomitable]. [11:27:29] wmackinnonwhs discards [Resounding Thunder]. [11:27:29] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Resounding Thunder]. [11:27:31] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Resounding Thunder] onto the stack targeting cotton2431 ( When you cycle Resounding Thunder, it deals 6 damage to any target.). [11:27:40] wmackinnonwhs casts [Shadow of the Grave]. [11:27:40] wmackinnonwhs returns [Resounding Thunder], [Desert of the Indomitable], [Edge of Autumn], [Resounding Thunder], [Lonely Sandbar], [Desert of the Indomitable], [Resounding Wave], [Lonely Sandbar], [Lonely Sandbar], [Shefet Monitor], [11:27:40] [Resounding Thunder], [Vizier of Tumbling Sands], and [Resounding Wave] to their owner's hand with [Shadow of the Grave]. [11:27:44] wmackinnonwhs discards [Resounding Thunder]. [11:27:44] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Resounding Thunder]. [11:27:46] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Resounding Thunder] onto the stack targeting cotton2431 ( When you cycle Resounding Thunder, it deals 6 damage to any target.). Winner: wmackinnonwhs Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (644566186) == [11:30:00] PDBot has started watching. [11:30:02] cotton2431 keeps this hand. [11:30:06] wmackinnonwhs keeps this hand. [11:30:06] Turn 1: cotton2431 [11:30:09] cotton2431 skips their draw step. [11:30:09] cotton2431 plays [Vivid Meadow]. [11:30:13] Turn 1: wmackinnonwhs [11:30:18] wmackinnonwhs plays [Lonely Sandbar]. [11:30:22] Turn 2: cotton2431 [11:30:24] cotton2431 plays [Island]. [11:30:29] Turn 2: wmackinnonwhs [11:30:34] wmackinnonwhs plays [Lonely Sandbar]. [11:30:37] Turn 3: cotton2431 [11:30:46] cotton2431 plays [Island]. [11:30:50] Turn 3: wmackinnonwhs [11:30:53] wmackinnonwhs plays [Forest]. [11:30:57] wmackinnonwhs casts [Weirding Wood] targeting [Forest]. [11:31:15] cotton2431 discards [Terror]. [11:31:15] cotton2431 discards [Curse of Thirst]. [11:31:16] cotton2431 casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Weirding Wood]. [11:31:19] Turn 4: cotton2431 [11:31:22] cotton2431 plays [Island]. [11:31:25] Turn 4: wmackinnonwhs [11:31:28] wmackinnonwhs plays [Opulent Palace]. [11:31:33] wmackinnonwhs casts [Beneath the Sands]. [11:31:46] Turn 5: cotton2431 [11:31:49] cotton2431 plays [Island]. [11:31:53] Turn 5: wmackinnonwhs [11:32:01] wmackinnonwhs discards [Glassdust Hulk]. [11:32:01] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Glassdust Hulk]. [11:32:11] Turn 6: cotton2431 [11:32:15] cotton2431 plays [Urza's Factory]. [11:32:26] Turn 6: wmackinnonwhs [11:32:35] wmackinnonwhs discards [Vizier of Tumbling Sands]. [11:32:35] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Vizier of Tumbling Sands]. [11:32:38] wmackinnonwhs puts triggered ability from [Vizier of Tumbling Sands] onto the stack targeting [Lonely Sandbar] (When you cycle Vizier of Tumbling Sands, untap target permanent.). [11:32:45] wmackinnonwhs plays [Forest]. [11:33:01] cotton2431 casts [Whispers of the Muse] with buyback. [11:33:09] cotton2431 draws a card with [Whispers of the Muse]. [11:33:11] Turn 7: cotton2431 [11:33:15] cotton2431 plays [Vivid Meadow]. [11:33:19] Turn 7: wmackinnonwhs [11:33:23] wmackinnonwhs plays [Forest]. [11:33:42] wmackinnonwhs casts [New Perspectives]. [11:34:18] martyvburen has started watching. [11:34:28] cotton2431 discards [Utter End]. [11:34:28] cotton2431 discards [Utter End]. [11:34:28] cotton2431 casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [New Perspectives]. [11:34:31] martyvburen has stopped watching. [11:34:37] Turn 8: cotton2431 [11:34:47] Turn 8: wmackinnonwhs [11:34:57] cotton2431 casts [Whispers of the Muse] with buyback. [11:35:00] cotton2431 draws a card with [Whispers of the Muse]. [11:35:03] Turn 9: cotton2431 [11:35:23] cotton2431 casts [Memoricide] targeting wmackinnonwhs. [11:35:34] wmackinnonwhs casts [Resounding Wave] targeting [Vivid Meadow]. [11:35:50] wmackinnonwhs returns [Vivid Meadow] to its owner's hand with [Resounding Wave]. [11:35:59] wmackinnonwhs casts [Resounding Wave] targeting [Vivid Meadow]. [11:36:01] wmackinnonwhs returns [Vivid Meadow] to its owner's hand with [Resounding Wave]. [11:36:22] cotton2431 names New Perspectives for [Memoricide]. [11:37:34] cotton2431 plays [Vivid Meadow]. [11:37:36] Turn 9: wmackinnonwhs [11:37:50] wmackinnonwhs casts [Resounding Wave] targeting [Vivid Meadow]. [11:37:52] wmackinnonwhs returns [Vivid Meadow] to its owner's hand with [Resounding Wave]. [11:37:56] Turn 10: cotton2431 [11:37:59] cotton2431 plays [Vivid Meadow]. [11:38:02] Turn 10: wmackinnonwhs [11:38:11] wmackinnonwhs plays [Island]. [11:38:17] Turn 11: cotton2431 [11:38:20] cotton2431 plays [Vivid Meadow]. [11:38:24] Turn 11: wmackinnonwhs [11:38:48] wmackinnonwhs discards [Edge of Autumn]. [11:38:48] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Edge of Autumn]. [11:38:57] wmackinnonwhs discards [Edge of Autumn]. [11:38:57] wmackinnonwhs cycles [Edge of Autumn]. [11:39:05] wmackinnonwhs has conceded from the game. Winner: cotton2431 Game 2 Completed. == Game 3 (644567890) == [11:39:32] PDBot has started watching. [11:39:33] martyvburen has started watching. [11:40:01] wmackinnonwhs chooses to play first. [11:40:09] wmackinnonwhs mulligans to 6 cards. [11:40:11] cotton2431 keeps this hand. [11:40:12] martyvburen has stopped watching. [11:40:12] wmackinnonwhs keeps this hand. [11:40:18] wmackinnonwhs puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [11:40:18] Turn 1: wmackinnonwhs [11:40:20] wmackinnonwhs skips their draw step. [11:40:21] wmackinnonwhs plays [Opulent Palace]. [11:40:25] Turn 1: cotton2431 [11:40:32] cotton2431 plays [Thawing Glaciers]. [11:40:36] Turn 2: wmackinnonwhs [11:40:39] wmackinnonwhs plays [Forest]. [11:40:45] Turn 2: cotton2431 [11:40:52] cotton2431 plays [Choked Estuary]. [11:40:57] Turn 3: wmackinnonwhs [11:41:08] wmackinnonwhs plays [Lonely Sandbar]. [11:41:14] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...). [11:41:23] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.). [11:41:26] Turn 3: cotton2431 [11:41:38] cotton2431 plays [Island]. [11:42:18] cotton2431 discards [Cruel Reality]. [11:42:18] Turn 4: wmackinnonwhs [11:42:30] wmackinnonwhs plays [Desert of the Mindful]. [11:42:34] wmackinnonwhs casts [Weirding Wood] targeting [Forest]. [11:43:09] cotton2431 discards [Evolving Wilds]. [11:43:09] cotton2431 discards [Detritivore]. [11:43:09] cotton2431 casts [Forbid] with buyback targeting [Weirding Wood]. [11:43:10] Turn 4: cotton2431 [11:43:24] cotton2431 plays [Thawing Glaciers]. [11:43:28] Turn 5: wmackinnonwhs [11:43:42] Turn 5: cotton2431 [11:43:48] cotton2431 plays [Choked Estuary]. [11:44:03] wmackinnonwhs casts [Resounding Wave] targeting [Choked Estuary]. [11:44:07] wmackinnonwhs returns [Choked Estuary] to its owner's hand with [Resounding Wave]. [11:44:11] Turn 6: wmackinnonwhs [11:44:18] wmackinnonwhs casts [Drake Haven]. [11:44:36] wmackinnonwhs has conceded from the game. Winner: cotton2431 Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: cotton2431: 2–1 [11:44:41] cotton2431 has left the game.