PennyDreadful
PDM R1 vs brian1234
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
brian1234,nerdyjoe

== Game 1 (644551694) ==
[10:04:05] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Mondays 10.02
[Gatherling] Round=1
[10:04:07] brian1234 joined the game.
[10:04:17] brian1234 chooses to play first.
[10:04:23] brian1234 mulligans to 6 cards.
[10:04:25] nerdyjoe keeps this hand.
[10:04:27] brian1234 mulligans to 5 cards.
[10:04:32] brian1234 keeps this hand.
[10:04:36] brian1234 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[10:04:36] Turn 1: brian1234
[10:04:36] brian1234 skips their draw step.
[10:04:38] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:04:41] Turn 1: nerdyjoe
[10:04:43] nerdyjoe plays [Opulent Palace].
[10:04:49] Turn 2: brian1234
[10:04:54] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:04:57] brian1234 casts [Consul's Lieutenant].
[10:05:00] Turn 2: nerdyjoe
[10:05:01] nerdyjoe plays [Island].
[10:05:05] nerdyjoe casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Consul's Lieutenant].
[10:05:10] nerdyjoe casts [Elixir of Immortality].
[10:05:15] Turn 3: brian1234
[10:05:17] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:05:19] brian1234 casts [Always Watching].
[10:05:26] Turn 3: nerdyjoe
[10:05:27] nerdyjoe plays [Island].
[10:05:31] Turn 4: brian1234
[10:05:34] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:05:36] brian1234 casts [Thraben Doomsayer].
[10:05:43] nerdyjoe casts [Dissipate] targeting [Thraben Doomsayer].
[10:05:51] Turn 4: nerdyjoe
[10:05:56] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[10:05:59] nerdyjoe casts [Precognition Field].
[10:06:05] Turn 5: brian1234
[10:06:08] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:06:11] Turn 5: nerdyjoe
[10:06:28] Turn 6: brian1234
[10:06:32] brian1234 casts [Precinct Captain].
[10:06:38] nerdyjoe casts [Void Shatter] targeting [Precinct Captain].
[10:06:46] Turn 6: nerdyjoe
[10:06:52] Turn 7: brian1234
[10:07:02] nerdyjoe casts [Sultai Charm] targeting [Always Watching] (Destroy target artifact or enchantment.).
[10:07:03] Turn 7: nerdyjoe
[10:07:10] Turn 8: brian1234
[10:07:13] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:07:15] Turn 8: nerdyjoe
[10:07:18] nerdyjoe plays [Encroaching Wastes].
[10:07:27] Turn 9: brian1234
[10:07:29] brian1234 casts [Hearthfire Hobgoblin].
[10:07:40] nerdyjoe casts [Sultai Charm] (Draw two cards, then discard a card.).
[10:07:41] nerdyjoe draws two cards with [Sultai Charm].
[10:07:43] nerdyjoe discards [Precognition Field].
[10:07:44] Turn 9: nerdyjoe
[10:07:46] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[10:07:49] nerdyjoe casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Hearthfire Hobgoblin].
[10:07:54] Turn 10: brian1234
[10:07:56] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:08:09] [CHAT] brian1234: i think your deck is bs
[10:08:15] Turn 10: nerdyjoe
[10:08:16] nerdyjoe plays [Encroaching Wastes].
[10:08:20] Turn 11: brian1234
[10:08:23] brian1234 casts [Hearthfire Hobgoblin].
[10:08:27] nerdyjoe casts [Dissipate] targeting [Hearthfire Hobgoblin].
[10:08:33] Turn 11: nerdyjoe
[10:08:34] nerdyjoe plays [Dreadship Reef].
[10:08:39] Turn 12: brian1234
[10:08:42] brian1234 casts [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:08:49] nerdyjoe casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:08:51] Turn 12: nerdyjoe
[10:08:53] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[10:09:00] Turn 13: brian1234
[10:09:04] brian1234 casts [Light from Within].
[10:09:15] nerdyjoe casts [Dissipate] targeting [Light from Within].
[10:09:22] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[10:09:25] Turn 13: nerdyjoe
[10:09:27] nerdyjoe plays [Urza's Factory].
[10:09:33] Turn 14: brian1234
[10:09:38] brian1234 casts [Thistledown Liege].
[10:09:50] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Urza's Factory] ( Create a 2/2 colorless Assembly-Worker artifact creature token.).
[10:09:50] nerdyjoe's [Urza's Factory] creates an Assembly-Worker token.
[10:09:52] Turn 14: nerdyjoe
[10:09:54] nerdyjoe plays [Opulent Palace].
[10:10:04] nerdyjoe casts [Compulsive Research] targeting nerdyjoe.
[10:10:04] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Compulsive Research[sU] has a Advantageous bug.
Dredging rather than drawing can let you avoid discarding
[10:10:07] nerdyjoe draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[10:10:12] nerdyjoe discards [Swamp].
[10:10:17] nerdyjoe casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Thistledown Liege].
[10:10:23] Turn 15: brian1234
[10:10:30] brian1234 has conceded from the game.
Winner: nerdyjoe
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (644552810) ==
[10:11:02] PDBot has started watching.
[10:11:09] brian1234 chooses to play first.
[10:11:15] brian1234 keeps this hand.
[10:11:22] nerdyjoe mulligans to 6 cards.
[10:11:26] nerdyjoe mulligans to 5 cards.
[10:11:28] nerdyjoe keeps this hand.
[10:11:30] nerdyjoe puts 1 card on top of their library.
[10:11:30] Turn 1: brian1234
[10:11:30] brian1234 skips their draw step.
[10:11:33] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:11:35] brian1234 casts [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:11:41] Turn 1: nerdyjoe
[10:11:44] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[10:11:50] Turn 2: brian1234
[10:11:53] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:11:56] brian1234 casts [Precinct Captain].
[10:12:01] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:12:08] Turn 2: nerdyjoe
[10:12:09] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[10:12:19] Turn 3: brian1234
[10:12:21] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:12:24] brian1234 casts [Always Watching].
[10:12:32] nerdyjoe casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Precinct Captain].
[10:12:44] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:12:48] Turn 3: nerdyjoe
[10:12:51] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[10:14:21] Turn 4: brian1234
[10:14:21] brian1234 casts [Precinct Captain].
[10:14:22] nerdyjoe casts [Dissipate] targeting [Precinct Captain].
[10:14:22] brian1234 casts [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:14:22] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:14:22] Turn 4: nerdyjoe
[10:14:23] nerdyjoe casts [Bile Blight] targeting [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:14:23] Turn 5: brian1234
[10:14:23] brian1234 casts [Hearthfire Hobgoblin].
[10:14:28] Turn 5: nerdyjoe
[10:14:29] nerdyjoe casts [Compulsive Research] targeting nerdyjoe.
[10:14:29] nerdyjoe draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[10:14:29] nerdyjoe discards [Dreadship Reef].
[10:14:29] nerdyjoe plays [Island].
[10:14:29] Turn 6: brian1234
[10:14:30] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Hearthfire Hobgoblin].
[10:14:30] Turn 6: nerdyjoe
[10:14:30] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[10:14:30] nerdyjoe casts [Precognition Field].
[10:14:30] Turn 7: brian1234
[10:14:31] brian1234 casts [Precinct Captain].
[10:14:35] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Hearthfire Hobgoblin].
[10:14:43] Turn 7: nerdyjoe
[10:14:46] nerdyjoe plays [Opulent Palace].
[10:14:51] nerdyjoe casts [Barter in Blood].
[10:14:57] brian1234 sacrifices [Precinct Captain].
[10:14:58] brian1234 sacrifices [Hearthfire Hobgoblin].
[10:15:03] Turn 8: brian1234
[10:15:07] brian1234 casts [Hearthfire Hobgoblin].
[10:15:13] Turn 8: nerdyjoe
[10:15:19] Turn 9: brian1234
[10:15:22] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:15:26] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Hearthfire Hobgoblin].
[10:15:30] nerdyjoe casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Hearthfire Hobgoblin].
[10:15:39] brian1234 casts [Thistledown Liege].
[10:15:44] nerdyjoe casts [Void Shatter] targeting [Thistledown Liege].
[10:15:53] Turn 9: nerdyjoe
[10:16:00] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Precognition Field] ( Exile the top card of your library.).
[10:16:06] nerdyjoe has conceded from the game.
Winner: brian1234
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (644553670) ==
[10:16:30] PDBot has started watching.
[10:16:33] nerdyjoe keeps this hand.
[10:16:35] brian1234 keeps this hand.
[10:16:35] Turn 1: nerdyjoe
[10:16:35] nerdyjoe skips their draw step.
[10:16:37] nerdyjoe plays [Island].
[10:16:38] nerdyjoe casts [Elixir of Immortality].
[10:16:40] Turn 1: brian1234
[10:16:41] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:16:43] brian1234 casts [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:16:47] Turn 2: nerdyjoe
[10:16:50] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[10:16:53] Turn 2: brian1234
[10:16:55] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:16:57] brian1234 casts [Consul's Lieutenant].
[10:17:02] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:17:09] Turn 3: nerdyjoe
[10:17:10] nerdyjoe plays [Encroaching Wastes].
[10:17:14] nerdyjoe casts [Compulsive Research] targeting nerdyjoe.
[10:17:16] nerdyjoe draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[10:17:20] nerdyjoe discards [Thawing Glaciers].
[10:17:28] Turn 3: brian1234
[10:17:30] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:17:33] brian1234 casts [Always Watching].
[10:17:38] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Consul's Lieutenant] and [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:17:42] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Renown 1 (When this creature deals combat damage to a player, if it isn't renowned, put one +1/+...).
[10:17:49] Turn 4: nerdyjoe
[10:18:01] nerdyjoe plays [Forest].
[10:18:09] Turn 4: brian1234
[10:18:11] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:18:14] brian1234 casts [Consul's Lieutenant].
[10:18:20] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Consul's Lieutenant] and [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:18:20] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Whenever Consul's Lieutenant attacks, if it's renowned, other attacking creatures you control get ...).
[10:18:29] nerdyjoe casts [Naturalize] targeting [Always Watching].
[10:18:45] Turn 5: nerdyjoe
[10:18:59] nerdyjoe plays [Dreadship Reef].
[10:19:18] Turn 5: brian1234
[10:19:21] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:19:29] brian1234 casts [Mirrorweave] targeting [Consul's Lieutenant].
[10:20:10] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Consul's Lieutenant], [Consul's Lieutenant], and [Consul's Lieutenant].
[10:20:10] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Whenever Consul's Lieutenant attacks, if it's renowned, other attacking creatures you control get ...).
[10:20:24] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[10:20:26] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Elixir of Immortality] ( You gain 5 life. Shuffle Elixir of Immortality and your graveyard into their owner's library.).
[10:20:31] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Renown 1 (When this creature deals combat damage to a player, if it isn't renowned, put one +1/+...).
[10:20:31] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Renown 1 (When this creature deals combat damage to a player, if it isn't renowned, put one +1/+...).
[10:20:42] Turn 6: nerdyjoe
[10:20:46] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[10:20:56] Turn 6: brian1234
[10:20:59] brian1234 casts [Always Watching].
[10:21:08] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Consul's Lieutenant], [Consul's Lieutenant], and [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:21:08] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Whenever Consul's Lieutenant attacks, if it's renowned, other attacking creatures you control get ...).
[10:21:08] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Whenever Consul's Lieutenant attacks, if it's renowned, other attacking creatures you control get ...).
[10:21:37] nerdyjoe casts [Consume the Meek].
[10:21:39] brian1234's [Consul's Lieutenant]'s triggered ability does not resolve because the intervening "if" condition is not met.
[10:21:39] brian1234's [Consul's Lieutenant]'s triggered ability does not resolve because the intervening "if" condition is not met.
[10:21:43] Turn 7: nerdyjoe
[10:21:46] nerdyjoe plays [Encroaching Wastes].
[10:21:49] nerdyjoe casts [Precognition Field].
[10:21:59] nerdyjoe casts [Compulsive Research] targeting nerdyjoe.
[10:21:59] nerdyjoe draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[10:22:05] nerdyjoe discards [Thawing Glaciers].
[10:22:05] Turn 7: brian1234
[10:22:08] brian1234 casts [Thraben Doomsayer].
[10:22:18] Turn 8: nerdyjoe
[10:22:24] nerdyjoe plays [Opulent Palace].
[10:22:41] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Precognition Field] ( Exile the top card of your library.).
[10:22:47] Turn 8: brian1234
[10:22:50] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:22:54] brian1234 casts [Thraben Doomsayer].
[10:22:59] nerdyjoe casts [Void Shatter] targeting [Thraben Doomsayer].
[10:23:04] brian1234 casts [Thraben Doomsayer].
[10:23:10] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Thraben Doomsayer].
[10:23:37] Turn 9: nerdyjoe
[10:23:58] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Precognition Field] ( Exile the top card of your library.).
[10:24:09] nerdyjoe casts [Naturalize] targeting [Always Watching].
[10:24:20] Turn 9: brian1234
[10:24:25] nerdyjoe is being attacked by [Thraben Doomsayer] and [Thraben Doomsayer].
[10:24:30] nerdyjoe casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Thraben Doomsayer].
[10:24:41] Turn 10: nerdyjoe
[10:24:44] nerdyjoe casts [Sultai Charm] targeting [Thraben Doomsayer] (Destroy target monocolored creature.).
[10:24:49] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[10:24:54] Turn 10: brian1234
[10:25:00] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:25:02] brian1234 casts [Regal Caracal].
[10:25:08] nerdyjoe casts [Void Shatter] targeting [Regal Caracal].
[10:25:13] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[10:25:16] Turn 11: nerdyjoe
[10:25:22] nerdyjoe plays [Opulent Palace].
[10:25:28] Turn 11: brian1234
[10:25:36] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Precognition Field] ( Exile the top card of your library.).
[10:25:41] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[10:25:42] Turn 12: nerdyjoe
[10:25:45] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[10:25:50] Turn 12: brian1234
[10:25:54] Turn 13: nerdyjoe
[10:26:04] Turn 13: brian1234
[10:26:06] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:26:11] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Dreadship Reef] ( Put a storage counter on Dreadship Reef.).
[10:26:12] Turn 14: nerdyjoe
[10:26:16] nerdyjoe plays [Forest].
[10:26:22] Turn 14: brian1234
[10:26:24] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:26:27] Turn 15: nerdyjoe
[10:26:33] Turn 15: brian1234
[10:26:35] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:26:38] Turn 16: nerdyjoe
[10:26:41] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[10:26:46] Turn 16: brian1234
[10:26:48] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:26:54] nerdyjoe casts [Sultai Charm] (Draw two cards, then discard a card.).
[10:26:54] nerdyjoe draws two cards with [Sultai Charm].
[10:26:57] nerdyjoe discards [Wretched Banquet].
[10:26:58] Turn 17: nerdyjoe
[10:27:00] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[10:27:03] Turn 17: brian1234
[10:27:05] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:27:08] Turn 18: nerdyjoe
[10:27:09] nerdyjoe plays [Island].
[10:27:13] Turn 18: brian1234
[10:27:19] Turn 19: nerdyjoe
[10:27:21] nerdyjoe plays [Swamp].
[10:27:32] nerdyjoe casts [Elixir of Immortality].
[10:27:37] Turn 19: brian1234
[10:27:39] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:27:42] Turn 20: nerdyjoe
[10:27:45] nerdyjoe plays [Island].
[10:27:49] Turn 20: brian1234
[10:27:53] Turn 21: nerdyjoe
[10:27:55] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[10:27:57] Dragonas77 has started watching.
[10:28:01] Turn 21: brian1234
[10:28:06] brian1234 casts [Precinct Captain].
[10:28:20] Turn 22: nerdyjoe
[10:28:24] nerdyjoe casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Precinct Captain].
[10:28:32] Turn 22: brian1234
[10:28:40] brian1234 casts [Light from Within].
[10:28:44] nerdyjoe casts [Void Shatter] targeting [Light from Within].
[10:28:56] brian1234 casts [Precinct Captain].
[10:29:01] nerdyjoe casts [Forbid] targeting [Precinct Captain].
[10:29:03] MOCHET has started watching.
[10:29:09] brian1234 casts [Benevolent Bodyguard].
[10:29:11] Dragonas77 has stopped watching.
[10:29:14] brian1234 casts [Consul's Lieutenant].
[10:29:23] nerdyjoe casts [Consume the Meek].
[10:29:26] Turn 23: nerdyjoe
[10:29:32] Turn 23: brian1234
[10:29:34] danieldlf has started watching.
[10:29:36] Turn 24: nerdyjoe
[10:29:50] Turn 24: brian1234
[10:29:54] Zelytic has started watching.
[10:30:03] brian1234 casts [Precinct Captain].
[10:30:08] brian1234 casts [Regal Caracal].
[10:30:15] POLAKOWALSKI has started watching.
[10:30:18] nerdyjoe casts [Power Sink] targeting [Regal Caracal]. (X is 9).
[10:30:30] Turn 25: nerdyjoe
[10:30:31] POLAKOWALSKI has stopped watching.
[10:30:32] nerdyjoe plays [Opulent Palace].
[10:30:35] nerdyjoe casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Precinct Captain].
[10:30:37] Zelytic has stopped watching.
[10:30:41] Turn 25: brian1234
[10:30:45] brian1234 casts [Light from Within].
[10:30:50] nerdyjoe casts [Dissipate] targeting [Light from Within].
[10:30:59] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Precognition Field] ( Exile the top card of your library.).
[10:31:02] Turn 26: nerdyjoe
[10:31:03] nerdyjoe plays [Choked Estuary].
[10:31:12] Turn 26: brian1234
[10:31:14] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:31:17] Turn 27: nerdyjoe
[10:31:28] Turn 27: brian1234
[10:31:31] brian1234 casts [Thistledown Liege].
[10:31:37] [CHAT] MOCHET: !record
[10:31:37] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  nerdyjoe 1-1 brian1234
[10:31:39] nerdyjoe casts [Bile Blight] targeting [Thistledown Liege].
[10:31:44] nerdyjoe casts [Sultai Charm] (Draw two cards, then discard a card.).
[10:31:44] nerdyjoe draws two cards with [Sultai Charm].
[10:31:49] nerdyjoe discards [Power Sink].
[10:31:50] Turn 28: nerdyjoe
[10:31:59] nerdyjoe casts [Compulsive Research] targeting nerdyjoe.
[10:31:59] nerdyjoe draws three cards with [Compulsive Research].
[10:32:06] nerdyjoe discards [Wretched Banquet].
[10:32:06] nerdyjoe discards [Barter in Blood].
[10:32:08] nerdyjoe plays [Urza's Factory].
[10:32:11] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Elixir of Immortality] ( You gain 5 life. Shuffle Elixir of Immortality and your graveyard into their owner's library.).
[10:32:19] Turn 28: brian1234
[10:32:21] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[10:32:28] nerdyjoe activates an ability of [Urza's Factory] ( Create a 2/2 colorless Assembly-Worker artifact creature token.).
[10:32:28] nerdyjoe's [Urza's Factory] creates an Assembly-Worker token.
[10:32:29] Turn 29: nerdyjoe
[10:32:38] brian1234 is being attacked by [Assembly-Worker] token.
[10:32:47] nerdyjoe discards [Barter in Blood].
[10:32:47] Turn 29: brian1234
[10:32:51] brian1234 casts [Thistledown Liege].
[10:32:58] nerdyjoe casts [Void Shatter] targeting [Thistledown Liege].
[10:33:03] brian1234 has conceded from the game.
Winner: nerdyjoe
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: nerdyjoe: 2–1