PennyDreadful
PD APAC R3 VS cotton2431
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
brian1234,cotton2431

== Game 1 (640942180) ==
[18:20:19] PDBot has started watching.
[18:20:19] cotton2431 joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=APAC Penny Dreadful Sundays 9.12
[Gatherling] Round=3
[18:20:25] cotton2431 chooses to play first.
[18:20:32] cotton2431 keeps this hand.
[18:20:34] brian1234 mulligans to 6 cards.
[18:20:37] brian1234 keeps this hand.
[18:20:43] brian1234 puts 1 card on top of their library.
[18:20:43] Turn 1: cotton2431
[18:20:43] cotton2431 skips their draw step.
[18:20:56] cotton2431 plays [Foul Orchard].
[18:20:58] Turn 1: brian1234
[18:21:00] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:21:02] brian1234 casts [Toolcraft Exemplar].
[18:21:06] Turn 2: cotton2431
[18:21:14] cotton2431 plays [Evolving Wilds].
[18:21:20] Turn 2: brian1234
[18:21:23] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:21:37] brian1234 casts [Glint Hawk Idol].
[18:21:41] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Toolcraft Exemplar] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, if you control an artifact, Toolcraft Exemplar gets +2/+1...).
[18:21:47] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Toolcraft Exemplar].
[18:21:53] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[18:22:03] Turn 3: cotton2431
[18:22:23] cotton2431 casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Toolcraft Exemplar].
[18:22:30] cotton2431 plays [Frost Marsh].
[18:22:37] Turn 3: brian1234
[18:22:39] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:22:43] brian1234 casts [Always Watching].
[18:22:49] Turn 4: cotton2431
[18:22:52] cotton2431 plays [Swamp].
[18:23:00] Turn 4: brian1234
[18:23:05] brian1234 casts [Court Homunculus].
[18:23:08] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Glint Hawk Idol] onto the stack (Whenever another artifact enters the battlefield under your control, you may have Glint Hawk Idol ...).
[18:23:23] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Glint Hawk Idol].
[18:23:36] cotton2431 casts [Fact or Fiction].
[18:24:04] cotton2431 puts [Viridian Emissary], [Island], [Dead Weight] into their hand with [Fact or Fiction].
[18:24:04] cotton2431 puts [Krosan Tusker], [Void Shatter] into their graveyard.
[18:24:10] Turn 5: cotton2431
[18:24:18] cotton2431 plays [Island].
[18:24:43] cotton2431 casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Court Homunculus].
[18:24:56] Turn 5: brian1234
[18:24:59] brian1234 casts [Court Homunculus].
[18:25:24] cotton2431 casts [Putrefy] targeting [Glint Hawk Idol].
[18:25:39] Turn 6: cotton2431
[18:26:25] cotton2431 casts [Viridian Emissary].
[18:26:26] Turn 6: brian1234
[18:26:27] brian1234 casts [Glint Hawk Idol].
[18:26:27] cotton2431 casts [Dissolve] targeting [Glint Hawk Idol].
[18:26:32] cotton2431 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[18:26:41] Turn 7: cotton2431
[18:26:48] cotton2431 casts [Venser's Journal].
[18:26:58] Turn 7: brian1234
[18:27:01] brian1234 casts [Court Homunculus].
[18:27:07] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Court Homunculus].
[18:27:23] Turn 8: cotton2431
[18:27:23] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:27:37] Turn 8: brian1234
[18:27:42] brian1234 casts [Spined Thopter].
[18:27:53] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Court Homunculus] and [Court Homunculus].
[18:28:14] cotton2431 casts [Fact or Fiction].
[18:28:50] cotton2431 puts [Aetherling], [Evolving Wilds] into their hand with [Fact or Fiction].
[18:28:51] cotton2431 puts [Golden Demise], [Golden Demise], [Fact or Fiction] into their graveyard.
[18:29:07] [Viridian Emissary] blocks [Court Homunculus].
[18:29:12] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Viridian Emissary] onto the stack (When Viridian Emissary dies, you may search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the ba...).
[18:29:25] Turn 9: cotton2431
[18:29:25] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:29:42] cotton2431 casts [Life's Finale] targeting brian1234.
[18:30:26] Turn 9: brian1234
[18:30:27] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:30:32] Turn 10: cotton2431
[18:30:32] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:30:37] cotton2431 plays [Evolving Wilds].
[18:30:45] Turn 10: brian1234
[18:30:48] brian1234 plays [Grasping Dunes].
[18:30:55] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[18:31:01] cotton2431 casts [Telling Time].
[18:31:03] cotton2431 put a card in his or her hand.
[18:31:04] cotton2431 put a card on top of their library.
[18:31:06] Turn 11: cotton2431
[18:31:06] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:31:17] cotton2431 casts [Aetherling].
[18:31:31] cotton2431 plays [Thornwood Falls].
[18:31:31] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Thornwood Falls] onto the stack (When Thornwood Falls enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:31:37] Turn 11: brian1234
[18:31:39] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:31:41] brian1234 casts [Parallax Wave].
[18:31:47] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Aetherling] ( Exile Aetherling. Return it to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the ...).
[18:31:55] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Aetherling] onto the stack (Return Aetherling to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end st...).
[18:31:59] Turn 12: cotton2431
[18:31:59] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:32:10] brian1234 is being attacked by [Aetherling].
[18:32:14] brian1234 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Aetherling] ( Exile target creature.).
[18:32:17] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Aetherling] ( Exile Aetherling. Return it to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the ...).
[18:32:23] brian1234's Parallax Wave is countered because it has no legal targets.
[18:32:25] cotton2431 plays [Island].
[18:32:27] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Aetherling] onto the stack (Return Aetherling to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end st...).
[18:32:32] Turn 12: brian1234
[18:32:33] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...).
[18:32:38] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:32:44] Turn 13: cotton2431
[18:32:44] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:32:52] cotton2431 casts [Viridian Emissary].
[18:33:01] brian1234 is being attacked by [Aetherling].
[18:33:05] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Aetherling] ( Aetherling gets +1/-1 until end of turn.).
[18:33:08] brian1234 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Aetherling] ( Exile target creature.).
[18:33:13] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Aetherling] ( Exile Aetherling. Return it to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the ...).
[18:33:20] brian1234's Parallax Wave is countered because it has no legal targets.
[18:33:23] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Aetherling] onto the stack (Return Aetherling to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end st...).
[18:33:27] Turn 13: brian1234
[18:33:27] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...).
[18:33:33] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:33:39] brian1234 activates an ability of [Grasping Dunes] targeting [Viridian Emissary] ( Put a -1/-1 counter on target creature.).
[18:33:41] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Viridian Emissary] onto the stack (When Viridian Emissary dies, you may search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the ba...).
[18:33:54] brian1234 casts [Parallax Wave].
[18:34:03] cotton2431 casts [Dissolve] targeting [Parallax Wave].
[18:34:07] brian1234 has conceded from the game.
Winner: cotton2431
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (640944504) ==
[18:36:46] PDBot has started watching.
[18:36:48] brian1234 chooses to play first.
[18:36:53] brian1234 keeps this hand.
[18:36:55] cotton2431 keeps this hand.
[18:36:55] Turn 1: brian1234
[18:36:55] brian1234 skips their draw step.
[18:36:56] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:36:58] brian1234 casts [Court Homunculus].
[18:37:05] Turn 1: cotton2431
[18:37:07] cotton2431 plays [Evolving Wilds].
[18:37:13] Turn 2: brian1234
[18:37:16] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:37:20] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Court Homunculus].
[18:37:25] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[18:37:30] Turn 2: cotton2431
[18:37:34] cotton2431 plays [Thornwood Falls].
[18:37:34] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Thornwood Falls] onto the stack (When Thornwood Falls enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:37:40] Turn 3: brian1234
[18:37:44] brian1234 casts [Glint Hawk Idol].
[18:37:51] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Court Homunculus].
[18:38:00] Turn 3: cotton2431
[18:38:08] cotton2431 plays [Evolving Wilds].
[18:38:19] Turn 4: brian1234
[18:38:22] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:38:24] brian1234 casts [Always Watching].
[18:38:32] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Court Homunculus].
[18:38:40] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[18:39:03] cotton2431 casts [Telling Time].
[18:39:14] cotton2431 put a card in his or her hand.
[18:39:15] cotton2431 put a card on top of their library.
[18:39:17] Turn 4: cotton2431
[18:40:01] cotton2431 plays [Evolving Wilds].
[18:40:07] cotton2431 casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Court Homunculus].
[18:40:10] Turn 5: brian1234
[18:40:16] brian1234 casts [Chief of the Foundry].
[18:40:21] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Glint Hawk Idol] onto the stack (Whenever another artifact enters the battlefield under your control, you may have Glint Hawk Idol ...).
[18:40:33] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Glint Hawk Idol] and [Court Homunculus].
[18:40:42] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[18:40:54] Turn 5: cotton2431
[18:41:08] [CHAT] brian1234: i read that like a book
[18:41:54] [CHAT] brian1234: i knew you would pick blue mana
[18:42:03] cotton2431 casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Chief of the Foundry].
[18:42:14] Turn 6: brian1234
[18:42:21] brian1234 casts [Always Watching].
[18:42:35] cotton2431 casts [Dissolve] targeting [Always Watching].
[18:42:50] cotton2431 puts 1 card on top of their library.
[18:42:57] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Chief of the Foundry] and [Court Homunculus].
[18:43:02] Turn 6: cotton2431
[18:43:05] cotton2431 plays [Island].
[18:43:22] CalicoDan has started watching.
[18:43:37] [CHAT] CalicoDan: !record
[18:43:38] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  cotton2431 1-0 brian1234
[18:43:47] cotton2431 discards [Krosan Tusker].
[18:43:48] cotton2431 cycles [Krosan Tusker].
[18:43:48] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Krosan Tusker] onto the stack (When you cycle Krosan Tusker, you may search your library for a basic land card, reveal that card,...).
[18:43:59] cotton2431 reveals [Forest].
[18:44:15] Turn 7: brian1234
[18:44:20] brian1234 activates an ability of [Glint Hawk Idol] ( Glint Hawk Idol becomes a 2/2 Bird artifact creature with flying until end of turn.).
[18:44:26] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Chief of the Foundry], [Glint Hawk Idol], and [Court Homunculus].
Winner: brian1234
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (640945596) ==
[18:45:07] PDBot has started watching.
[18:45:08] cotton2431 chooses to play first.
[18:45:15] cotton2431 keeps this hand.
[18:45:19] brian1234 keeps this hand.
[18:45:19] Turn 1: cotton2431
[18:45:19] cotton2431 skips their draw step.
[18:45:41] cotton2431 plays [Thornwood Falls].
[18:45:41] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Thornwood Falls] onto the stack (When Thornwood Falls enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:45:44] Turn 1: brian1234
[18:45:47] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:45:51] brian1234 casts [Toolcraft Exemplar].
[18:45:56] Turn 2: cotton2431
[18:46:12] cotton2431 plays [Evolving Wilds].
[18:46:18] Turn 2: brian1234
[18:46:20] brian1234 plays [Foundry of the Consuls].
[18:46:21] jgabrielygalan has started watching.
[18:46:24] brian1234 casts [Glint Hawk Idol].
[18:46:27] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Toolcraft Exemplar] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, if you control an artifact, Toolcraft Exemplar gets +2/+1...).
[18:46:35] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Toolcraft Exemplar].
[18:46:41] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[18:46:48] Turn 3: cotton2431
[18:46:49] [CHAT] jgabrielygalan: !record
[18:46:50] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record:  cotton2431 1-1 brian1234
[18:46:57] cotton2431 casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Toolcraft Exemplar].
[18:47:02] cotton2431 plays [Island].
[18:47:08] Turn 3: brian1234
[18:47:10] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:47:20] brian1234 casts [Spined Thopter].
[18:47:22] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Glint Hawk Idol] onto the stack (Whenever another artifact enters the battlefield under your control, you may have Glint Hawk Idol ...).
[18:47:31] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Glint Hawk Idol].
[18:47:40] cotton2431 casts [Telling Time].
[18:47:47] cotton2431 put a card in his or her hand.
[18:47:48] cotton2431 put a card on top of their library.
[18:47:52] Turn 4: cotton2431
[18:48:00] cotton2431 plays [Thornwood Falls].
[18:48:00] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Thornwood Falls] onto the stack (When Thornwood Falls enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:48:13] Turn 4: brian1234
[18:48:17] brian1234 casts [Always Watching].
[18:48:18] fish_can_topdeck has started watching.
[18:48:33] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Spined Thopter].
[18:48:49] emerald000 has started watching.
[18:48:51] cotton2431 casts [Putrefy] targeting [Glint Hawk Idol].
[18:48:55] Meerschwein2 has started watching.
[18:48:58] Turn 5: cotton2431
[18:49:03] Pseudodude has started watching.
[18:49:22] cotton2431 plays [Island].
[18:49:23] fish_can_topdeck has stopped watching.
[18:49:27] cotton2431 casts [Venser's Journal].
[18:49:36] Turn 5: brian1234
[18:49:42] brian1234 casts [Always Watching].
[18:49:49] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Spined Thopter].
[18:49:56] Turn 6: cotton2431
[18:49:56] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:50:08] cotton2431 plays [Evolving Wilds].
[18:50:13] Turn 6: brian1234
[18:50:15] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:50:20] brian1234 casts [Spined Thopter].
[18:50:39] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Spined Thopter].
[18:50:51] cotton2431 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[18:51:11] cotton2431 casts [Sultai Charm] targeting [Always Watching] (Destroy target artifact or enchantment.).
[18:51:16] Turn 7: cotton2431
[18:51:16] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:51:39] cotton2431 casts [Aetherling].
[18:51:48] Turn 7: brian1234
[18:51:53] brian1234 casts [Parallax Wave].
[18:51:57] brian1234 activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Aetherling] ( Exile target creature.).
[18:52:02] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Spined Thopter] and [Spined Thopter].
[18:52:08] Turn 8: cotton2431
[18:52:08] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:52:25] cotton2431 casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Spined Thopter].
[18:52:35] Turn 8: brian1234
[18:52:35] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...).
[18:52:39] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:52:42] brian1234 casts [Always Watching].
[18:52:53] cotton2431 casts [Dissolve] targeting [Always Watching].
[18:52:58] cotton2431 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[18:53:04] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Spined Thopter].
[18:53:08] Turn 9: cotton2431
[18:53:08] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:53:25] Turn 9: brian1234
[18:53:25] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...).
[18:53:31] brian1234 casts [Glint Hawk Idol].
[18:53:52] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Spined Thopter].
[18:53:59] Turn 10: cotton2431
[18:53:59] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:54:14] Turn 10: brian1234
[18:54:14] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...).
[18:54:24] brian1234 casts [Fleetwheel Cruiser].
[18:54:38] cotton2431 casts [Void Shatter] targeting [Fleetwheel Cruiser].
[18:54:47] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Spined Thopter].
[18:55:18] Turn 11: cotton2431
[18:55:18] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:56:50] cotton2431 plays [Thornwood Falls].
[18:56:50] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Thornwood Falls] onto the stack (When Thornwood Falls enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[18:57:15] Turn 11: brian1234
[18:57:15] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...).
[18:58:10] brian1234 casts [Toolcraft Exemplar].
[18:58:11] brian1234 activates an ability of [Glint Hawk Idol] ( Glint Hawk Idol becomes a 2/2 Bird artifact creature with flying until end of turn.).
[18:58:11] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Toolcraft Exemplar] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, if you control an artifact, Toolcraft Exemplar gets +2/+1...).
[18:58:11] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Glint Hawk Idol] and [Spined Thopter].
[18:58:12] cotton2431 casts [Sultai Charm] targeting [Glint Hawk Idol] (Destroy target artifact or enchantment.).
[18:58:25] brian1234 casts [Glint Hawk Idol].
[18:58:31] Turn 12: cotton2431
[18:58:31] cotton2431 puts triggered ability from [Venser's Journal] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you gain 1 life for each card in your hand.).
[18:58:43] cotton2431 casts [Golden Demise].
[18:58:51] Turn 12: brian1234
[18:58:51] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...).
[18:58:55] brian1234 puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (When Parallax Wave leaves the battlefield, each player returns to the battlefield all cards they o...).
[18:59:00] brian1234 plays [Plains].
[18:59:03] brian1234 activates an ability of [Glint Hawk Idol] ( Glint Hawk Idol becomes a 2/2 Bird artifact creature with flying until end of turn.).
[18:59:08] cotton2431 is being attacked by [Glint Hawk Idol].
Winner: brian1234
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: brian1234: 2–1
[18:59:20] brian1234 has left the game.