PennyDreadful
PD
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
horndog1982,trulin

== Game 1 (640400212) ==
[16:55:12] PDBot has started watching.
[League] Delay of Game by trulin (25012) vs Esper Cloudpost Control by horndog1982 (25028)
[16:55:15] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] If this is a league game, don't forget to report!
[16:55:20] [CHAT] horndog1982: hf gl
[16:55:23] horndog1982 chooses to play first.
[16:55:28] horndog1982 keeps this hand.
[16:55:29] trulin keeps this hand.
[16:55:29] Turn 1: horndog1982
[16:55:35] horndog1982 skips their draw step.
[16:55:38] horndog1982 plays [Cloudpost].
[16:55:44] Turn 1: trulin
[16:55:47] trulin plays [Island].
[16:55:55] Turn 2: horndog1982
[16:56:01] horndog1982 plays [Island].
[16:56:09] Turn 2: trulin
[16:56:13] trulin plays [Island].
[16:56:19] trulin casts [Everflowing Chalice] (with kicker).
[League] Invalid Match
[16:56:19] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD][sR] Everflowing Chalice was not on a submitted league decklist. This is not a league match.
[16:56:28] Turn 3: horndog1982
[16:56:39] horndog1982 plays [Plains].
[16:56:45] horndog1982 casts [Dimir Keyrune].
[16:56:49] Turn 3: trulin
[16:56:54] trulin plays [Mage-Ring Network].
[16:57:38] trulin casts [Tezzeret's Gambit].
[16:57:41] trulin draws two cards with [Tezzeret's Gambit].
[16:57:45] trulin chooses [Everflowing Chalice] with [Tezzeret's Gambit].
[16:57:45] trulin adds charge counter to [Everflowing Chalice].
[16:57:49] Turn 4: horndog1982
[16:57:56] horndog1982 plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[16:58:32] horndog1982 casts [Culling Scales].
[16:58:45] Turn 4: trulin
[16:59:05] trulin plays [Island].
[16:59:15] trulin casts [Steady Progress].
[16:59:22] trulin chooses [Everflowing Chalice] with [Steady Progress].
[16:59:22] trulin adds charge counter to [Everflowing Chalice].
[16:59:22] trulin draws a card with [Steady Progress].
[16:59:31] trulin casts [Viral Drake].
[16:59:44] Turn 5: horndog1982
[16:59:44] horndog1982 puts triggered ability from [Culling Scales] onto the stack targeting [Everflowing Chalice] (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target nonland permanent with the lowest converted mana c...).
[16:59:57] horndog1982 plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[17:00:13] horndog1982 casts [Druidic Satchel].
[17:00:27] Turn 5: trulin
[17:00:39] trulin plays [Island].
[17:01:08] trulin casts [Epiphany at the Drownyard]. (X is 4).
[17:02:03] trulin puts [Steady Progress], [Avarice Totem] into their hand with [Epiphany at the Drownyard].
[17:02:03] trulin puts [Steady Progress], [Trophy Mage], [Stoic Rebuttal] into their graveyard.
[17:02:21] horndog1982 is being attacked by [Viral Drake].
[17:02:24] horndog1982 has 1 poison counter.
[17:02:30] horndog1982 casts [Reciprocate] targeting [Viral Drake].
[17:02:38] Turn 6: horndog1982
[17:02:42] horndog1982 puts triggered ability from [Culling Scales] onto the stack targeting [Culling Scales] (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target nonland permanent with the lowest converted mana c...).
[17:03:03] horndog1982 casts [Lone Revenant].
[17:03:22] Turn 6: trulin
[17:03:35] trulin plays [Glimmerpost].
[17:03:36] trulin puts triggered ability from [Glimmerpost] onto the stack (When Glimmerpost enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life for each Locus on the battlefield.).
[17:04:12] trulin casts [Steady Progress].
[17:04:18] trulin chooses horndog1982 with [Steady Progress].
[17:04:18] trulin adds poison counter to horndog1982.
[17:04:18] trulin draws a card with [Steady Progress].
[17:04:24] trulin casts [Everflowing Chalice] (with kicker).
[17:04:37] Turn 7: horndog1982
[17:04:47] trulin is being attacked by [Lone Revenant].
[17:04:50] horndog1982 puts triggered ability from [Lone Revenant] onto the stack (Whenever Lone Revenant deals combat damage to a player, if you control no other creatures, look at...).
[17:05:25] horndog1982 casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting trulin.
[17:05:37] [CHAT] trulin: blue white black value?
[17:05:50] [CHAT] horndog1982: yeah esper
[17:05:50] [CHAT] trulin: this deck was in the process of being made when we started lol
[17:06:04] [CHAT] trulin: so its got a lot of useless cards
[17:06:14] [CHAT] horndog1982: well actually this is my33rd game on this deck
[17:06:24] [CHAT] horndog1982: are you new in pd?
[17:06:27] [CHAT] trulin: no
[17:06:30] [CHAT] trulin: pick plz
[17:06:39] [CHAT] trulin: new as of a month yes
[17:06:40] trulin discards [Avarice Totem].
[17:06:40] trulin reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Disperse], [Briber's Purse], [Glimmerpost], [Mind Spring], and [Disperse].
[17:07:12] [CHAT] horndog1982: can i add you as buddy. wanna test some of my new deck also.
[17:07:17] [CHAT] trulin: sure
[17:07:25] [CHAT] trulin: please continue
[17:07:26] [CHAT] horndog1982: okie
[17:07:34] horndog1982 casts [Azorius Keyrune].
[17:07:42] trulin activates an ability of [Mage-Ring Network] ( Put a storage counter on Mage-Ring Network.).
[17:07:49] Turn 7: trulin
[17:08:05] trulin plays [Glimmerpost].
[17:08:05] trulin puts triggered ability from [Glimmerpost] onto the stack (When Glimmerpost enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life for each Locus on the battlefield.).
[17:08:37] trulin casts [Mind Spring]. (X is 6).
[17:08:51] horndog1982 casts [Syncopate] targeting [Mind Spring]. (X is 2).
[17:08:55] trulin has conceded from the game.
Winner: horndog1982
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (640402318) ==
[17:11:00] PDBot has started watching.
[17:11:05] trulin chooses to play first.
[17:11:14] trulin keeps this hand.
[17:11:21] horndog1982 keeps this hand.
[17:11:21] Turn 1: trulin
[17:11:23] trulin skips their draw step.
[17:11:25] trulin plays [Cloudpost].
[17:11:27] Turn 1: horndog1982
[17:11:31] horndog1982 plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[17:11:36] Turn 2: trulin
[17:11:38] trulin plays [Island].
[17:11:41] Turn 2: horndog1982
[17:11:50] horndog1982 plays [Swamp].
[17:11:54] horndog1982 casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting trulin.
[17:12:16] trulin discards [Trophy Mage].
[17:12:16] trulin reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Island], [Sky Swallower], [Sphinx of Magosi], [Tezzeret's Gambit], and [Tezzeret's Gambit].
[17:12:22] Turn 3: trulin
[17:12:25] trulin plays [Island].
[17:12:32] trulin casts [Tezzeret's Gambit].
[17:12:34] trulin draws two cards with [Tezzeret's Gambit].
[17:12:37] trulin chooses no cards with [Tezzeret's Gambit].
[17:12:44] Turn 3: horndog1982
[17:12:53] Turn 4: trulin
[17:12:55] trulin plays [Island].
[17:13:07] trulin casts [Everflowing Chalice] (kicked 2 times).
[17:13:15] Turn 4: horndog1982
[17:13:24] horndog1982 casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting trulin.
[17:13:49] trulin discards [Sphinx of Magosi].
[17:13:49] trulin reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Avarice Totem], [Island], [Sky Swallower], and [Tezzeret's Gambit].
[17:13:56] Turn 5: trulin
[17:13:58] trulin plays [Island].
[17:14:20] trulin casts [Tezzeret's Gambit].
[17:14:22] trulin draws two cards with [Tezzeret's Gambit].
[17:14:29] trulin chooses [Everflowing Chalice] with [Tezzeret's Gambit].
[17:14:29] trulin adds charge counter to [Everflowing Chalice].
[17:14:42] trulin casts [Clone Shell].
[17:14:45] trulin puts triggered ability from [Clone Shell] onto the stack (When Clone Shell enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library, exile one fac...).
[17:15:09] Turn 5: horndog1982
[17:15:24] horndog1982 discards [Culling Scales].
[17:15:24] Turn 6: trulin
[17:15:32] trulin plays [Mage-Ring Network].
[17:15:52] trulin casts [Viral Drake].
[17:16:18] horndog1982 is being attacked by [Clone Shell].
[17:16:25] Turn 6: horndog1982
[17:16:30] horndog1982 plays [Glimmerpost].
[17:16:30] horndog1982 puts triggered ability from [Glimmerpost] onto the stack (When Glimmerpost enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life for each Locus on the battlefield.).
[17:16:37] horndog1982 casts [Dimir Keyrune].
[17:16:56] trulin activates an ability of [Mage-Ring Network] ( Put a storage counter on Mage-Ring Network.).
[17:16:58] trulin activates an ability of [Viral Drake] ( Proliferate.).
[17:17:01] trulin chooses [Mage-Ring Network] and [Everflowing Chalice] with [Viral Drake]'s ability.
[17:17:01] trulin adds storage counter to [Mage-Ring Network].
[17:17:01] trulin adds charge counter to [Everflowing Chalice].
[17:17:03] Turn 7: trulin
[17:17:22] horndog1982 is being attacked by [Viral Drake] and [Clone Shell].
[17:17:25] horndog1982 has 1 poison counter.
[17:17:39] Turn 7: horndog1982
[17:17:54] horndog1982 casts [Culling Scales].
[17:18:16] trulin activates an ability of [Viral Drake] ( Proliferate.).
[17:18:25] trulin chooses [Mage-Ring Network], [Everflowing Chalice], and horndog1982 with [Viral Drake]'s ability.
[17:18:25] trulin adds storage counter to [Mage-Ring Network].
[17:18:25] trulin adds charge counter to [Everflowing Chalice].
[17:18:25] trulin adds poison counter to horndog1982.
[17:18:34] trulin activates an ability of [Viral Drake] ( Proliferate.).
[17:18:43] trulin chooses [Mage-Ring Network], [Everflowing Chalice], and horndog1982 with [Viral Drake]'s ability.
[17:18:43] trulin adds storage counter to [Mage-Ring Network].
[17:18:43] trulin adds charge counter to [Everflowing Chalice].
[17:18:43] trulin adds poison counter to horndog1982.
[17:18:54] trulin activates an ability of [Mage-Ring Network] ( Put a storage counter on Mage-Ring Network.).
[17:19:05] Turn 8: trulin
[17:19:09] trulin plays [Island].
[17:19:40] horndog1982 is being attacked by [Viral Drake] and [Clone Shell].
[17:19:44] horndog1982 has 4 poison counters.
[17:20:21] horndog1982 casts [Reciprocate] targeting [Viral Drake].
[17:21:18] trulin activates an ability of [Viral Drake] ( Proliferate.).
[17:21:18] trulin chooses [Mage-Ring Network] and horndog1982 with [Viral Drake]'s ability.
[17:21:18] trulin adds storage counter to [Mage-Ring Network].
[17:21:18] trulin adds poison counter to horndog1982.
[17:21:19] trulin activates an ability of [Viral Drake] ( Proliferate.).
[17:21:25] trulin chooses [Mage-Ring Network] and horndog1982 with [Viral Drake]'s ability.
[17:21:25] trulin adds storage counter to [Mage-Ring Network].
[17:21:25] trulin adds poison counter to horndog1982.
[17:21:31] trulin activates an ability of [Viral Drake] ( Proliferate.).
[17:21:35] trulin chooses [Mage-Ring Network] and horndog1982 with [Viral Drake]'s ability.
[17:21:35] trulin adds storage counter to [Mage-Ring Network].
[17:21:35] trulin adds poison counter to horndog1982.
[17:21:38] trulin activates an ability of [Viral Drake] ( Proliferate.).
[17:21:44] trulin chooses [Mage-Ring Network] and horndog1982 with [Viral Drake]'s ability.
[17:21:44] trulin adds storage counter to [Mage-Ring Network].
[17:21:45] trulin adds poison counter to horndog1982.
[17:22:00] Turn 8: horndog1982
[17:22:00] horndog1982 puts triggered ability from [Culling Scales] onto the stack targeting [Everflowing Chalice] (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target nonland permanent with the lowest converted mana c...).
[17:22:09] horndog1982 plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[17:22:18] horndog1982 casts [Dimir Keyrune].
[17:22:30] Turn 9: trulin
[17:22:36] trulin plays [Island].
[17:22:52] trulin casts [Contingency Plan].
[17:22:53] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Contingency Plan[sU] has a Graphical bug.
Some spells that let you look at the top cards of your library and choose multiple cards one-by-one to send to the graveyard will incorrectly display the visual order of the chosen cards in the graveyard.
Our data about this bug is out of date.  Please let us know if this card is still bugged (or if it's been fixed).
You can do so by PM'ing this bot, or by typing `!stillbugged Contingency Plan` or `!notbugged Contingency Plan`
[17:23:21] trulin put a card on top of trulin's library.
[17:23:32] trulin put a card on top of trulin's library.
[17:23:36] trulin put a card on top of trulin's library.
[17:23:45] horndog1982 is being attacked by [Clone Shell].
[17:24:15] trulin casts [Mirage Mirror].
[17:24:32] Turn 9: horndog1982
[17:24:38] horndog1982 puts triggered ability from [Culling Scales] onto the stack targeting [Mirage Mirror] (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target nonland permanent with the lowest converted mana c...).
[17:24:53] trulin activates an ability of [Mirage Mirror] targeting [Cloudpost] ( Mirage Mirror becomes a copy of target artifact, creature, enchantment, or land until end of turn...).
[17:25:08] trulin activates an ability of [Mage-Ring Network] ( Put a storage counter on Mage-Ring Network.).
[17:25:14] horndog1982's Triggered ability from Culling Scales is countered because it has no legal targets.
[17:25:24] horndog1982 plays [Plains].
[17:25:27] [CHAT] trulin: hmm
[17:25:46] [CHAT] horndog1982: well kinda surprise too haha
[17:25:52] [CHAT] trulin: i guess that makes sense?
[17:26:00] [CHAT] trulin: not really
[17:26:24] horndog1982 casts [Psychic Intrusion] targeting trulin.
[17:26:29] [CHAT] horndog1982: yeah
[17:26:55] [CHAT] trulin: pick the skyswallower
[17:26:58] trulin reveals their hand to [Psychic Intrusion], containing [Sky Swallower].
[17:27:11] [CHAT] horndog1982: will lose a lot
[17:27:20] [CHAT] horndog1982: even my mana
[17:27:24] Turn 10: trulin
[17:27:48] trulin activates an ability of [Mirage Mirror] targeting [Clone Shell] ( Mirage Mirror becomes a copy of target artifact, creature, enchantment, or land until end of turn...).
[17:27:59] horndog1982 is being attacked by [Clone Shell] and [Clone Shell].
[17:28:11] Turn 10: horndog1982
[17:28:14] [CHAT] trulin: haha yeah
[17:28:16] horndog1982 puts triggered ability from [Culling Scales] onto the stack targeting [Mirage Mirror] (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target nonland permanent with the lowest converted mana c...).
[17:28:38] trulin activates an ability of [Mirage Mirror] targeting [Culling Scales] ( Mirage Mirror becomes a copy of target artifact, creature, enchantment, or land until end of turn...).
[17:28:44] trulin activates an ability of [Mage-Ring Network] ( Put a storage counter on Mage-Ring Network.).
[17:29:15] [CHAT] horndog1982: oh that wa wrong
[17:29:24] [CHAT] trulin: thats a bug
[17:29:26] [CHAT] trulin: wtf
[17:29:31] [CHAT] trulin: lol
[17:29:42] horndog1982 casts [Avarice Totem].
[17:30:30] horndog1982 activates an ability of [Avarice Totem] targeting [Clone Shell] ( Exchange control of Avarice Totem and target nonland permanent.).
[17:31:00] Turn 11: trulin
[17:31:04] trulin plays [Glimmerpost].
[17:31:04] trulin puts triggered ability from [Glimmerpost] onto the stack (When Glimmerpost enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life for each Locus on the battlefield.).
[17:31:47] Turn 11: horndog1982
[17:31:47] horndog1982 puts triggered ability from [Culling Scales] onto the stack targeting [Avarice Totem] (At the beginning of your upkeep, destroy target nonland permanent with the lowest converted mana c...).
[17:32:08] trulin activates an ability of [Avarice Totem] targeting [Culling Scales] ( Exchange control of Avarice Totem and target nonland permanent.).
[17:32:14] [CHAT] trulin: misclick
[17:32:22] [CHAT] trulin: but i want to see what happens
[17:32:32] [CHAT] horndog1982: yeah curious too
[17:32:39] [CHAT] trulin: i think i get it and yours is destoryed
[17:32:44] [CHAT] trulin: mwahah
[17:33:05] [CHAT] trulin: very strange mtg 
[17:33:08] [CHAT] horndog1982: aha, very complicated mechanics, but maes sense
[17:33:13] [CHAT] horndog1982: yeah
[17:33:27] [CHAT] trulin: made more sense than than the mirror to be honest
[17:34:01] [CHAT] horndog1982: yeah. but mirrors is more complicated
[17:34:19] [CHAT] trulin: i guess the mirror becomes a different card, so you didn't target the copy but the old card
[17:34:57] [CHAT] horndog1982: yeah. you shoud have choose cloudpost, casue it doent have a casting cost
[17:35:15] trulin is being attacked by [Clone Shell].
[17:35:44] horndog1982 casts [Dimir Keyrune].
[17:35:50] trulin casts [Stoic Rebuttal] targeting [Dimir Keyrune].
[17:36:02] horndog1982 casts [Utter End] targeting [Culling Scales].
[17:36:09] trulin activates an ability of [Mage-Ring Network] ( Put a storage counter on Mage-Ring Network.).
[17:36:16] Turn 12: trulin
[17:36:28] trulin casts [Steady Progress].
[17:36:33] trulin chooses [Mage-Ring Network] and horndog1982 with [Steady Progress].
[17:36:33] trulin adds storage counter to [Mage-Ring Network].
[17:36:33] trulin adds poison counter to horndog1982.
[17:36:33] trulin draws a card with [Steady Progress].
[17:36:46] trulin plays [Island].
[17:36:52] trulin activates an ability of [Mage-Ring Network] ( Put a storage counter on Mage-Ring Network.).
[17:36:59] Turn 12: horndog1982
[17:37:06] horndog1982 casts [Druidic Satchel].
[17:37:16] trulin is being attacked by [Clone Shell].
[17:37:22] Turn 13: trulin
[17:37:38] trulin casts [Sphinx of Magosi].
[17:37:50] [CHAT] trulin: COUNTERSPELL
[17:37:51] horndog1982 casts [Summary Dismissal].
[17:37:56] [CHAT] horndog1982: yeah
[17:38:10] trulin casts [Sky Swallower].
[17:38:20] trulin puts triggered ability from [Sky Swallower] onto the stack targeting horndog1982 (When Sky Swallower enters the battlefield, target opponent gains control of all other permanents y...).
[17:38:20] [CHAT] trulin: i'd rather lose in glory
[17:38:24] [CHAT] trulin: than be counter spelled to death
[17:38:25] [CHAT] trulin: tbh
[17:38:37] Turn 13: horndog1982
[17:38:52] [CHAT] trulin: lost too many games with no strategy but, oh sorry your next 4 cards are countered go home
[17:38:54] [CHAT] horndog1982: don have removal so..
[17:39:00] horndog1982 plays [Glimmerpost].
[17:39:00] horndog1982 puts triggered ability from [Glimmerpost] onto the stack (When Glimmerpost enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life for each Locus on the battlefield.).
[17:39:03] [CHAT] trulin: you had exile, idk how many more
[17:39:26] horndog1982 casts [Druidic Satchel].
[17:39:35] horndog1982 activates an ability of [Druidic Satchel] ( Reveal the top card of your library. If it's a creature card, create a 1/1 green Saproling creatu...).
[17:39:36] horndog1982 reveals [Plains] with [Druidic Satchel]'s ability.
[17:39:53] RegMonger has started watching.
[17:39:54] Turn 14: trulin
[17:39:57] trulin plays [Island].
[17:40:05] horndog1982 is being attacked by [Sky Swallower].
[17:40:22] horndog1982 activates an ability of [Druidic Satchel] ( Reveal the top card of your library. If it's a creature card, create a 1/1 green Saproling creatu...).
[17:40:23] horndog1982 reveals [Cloudpost] with [Druidic Satchel]'s ability.
[17:40:26] Turn 14: horndog1982
[17:40:40] horndog1982 casts [Lone Revenant].
[17:40:54] horndog1982 activates an ability of [Dimir Keyrune] ( Dimir Keyrune becomes a 2/2 blue and black Horror artifact creature until end of turn and can't b...).
[17:41:01] horndog1982 activates an ability of [Dimir Keyrune] ( Dimir Keyrune becomes a 2/2 blue and black Horror artifact creature until end of turn and can't b...).
[17:41:08] horndog1982 activates an ability of [Druidic Satchel] ( Reveal the top card of your library. If it's a creature card, create a 1/1 green Saproling creatu...).
[17:41:10] horndog1982 reveals [Arcane Sanctum] with [Druidic Satchel]'s ability.
[17:41:19] trulin is being attacked by [Dimir Keyrune] and [Dimir Keyrune].
[17:41:30] Turn 15: trulin
[17:41:33] trulin plays [Glimmerpost].
[17:41:33] trulin puts triggered ability from [Glimmerpost] onto the stack (When Glimmerpost enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life for each Locus on the battlefield.).
[17:41:43] horndog1982 is being attacked by [Sky Swallower].
[17:41:53] [CHAT] trulin: OMG
[17:41:55] [CHAT] trulin: lololol
[17:41:58] [CHAT] horndog1982: lols
[17:42:04] [CHAT] trulin: thats the funniest thing
[17:42:07] [CHAT] horndog1982: it was flying for  it
[17:42:07] [CHAT] trulin: ive every seen
[17:42:08] [CHAT] horndog1982: hahaha
[17:42:25] [CHAT] trulin: wait draw the top card
[17:42:26] [CHAT] horndog1982: can we play again for a few minutes late
[17:42:30] [CHAT] trulin: if its glimmerpost
[17:42:31] [CHAT] trulin: you live
[17:42:33] [CHAT] horndog1982: have to eat lucnh
[17:42:40] [CHAT] trulin: i have to sleep
[17:42:43] [CHAT] trulin: lets play another time
[17:42:44] [CHAT] horndog1982: well see if im lucky nough
[17:42:49] [CHAT] horndog1982: sere
Winner: trulin
Game 2 Completed.
[17:43:05] horndog1982 has left the game.