PennyDreadful
PD league
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
bhelyer,JackSlagel

== Game 1 (638106992) ==
[15:45:22] PDBot has started watching.
[15:45:22] JackSlagel joined the game.
[15:45:22] bhelyer joined the game.
[League] Battle of Wits by jackslagel (24158) vs Evershrike by bhelyer (24154)
[15:45:25] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
[15:45:31] bhelyer chooses to play first.
[15:45:34] bhelyer keeps this hand.
[15:45:45] [CHAT] JackSlagel: you're gonna mill out if you're not careful
[15:45:53] [CHAT] JackSlagel: hardly any cards at all
[15:45:59] [CHAT] bhelyer: oh jesus
[15:46:02] JackSlagel keeps this hand.
[15:46:02] Turn 1: bhelyer
[15:46:04] bhelyer skips their draw step.
[15:46:06] [CHAT] bhelyer: is battle of wits legal?
[15:46:14] [CHAT] JackSlagel: yeah
[15:46:19] [CHAT] JackSlagel: lol, or i'm just insane
[15:46:26] [CHAT] bhelyer: of course it is, what was I thinking
[15:46:36] [CHAT] bhelyer: in what format is BoW viable 
[15:46:39] [CHAT] bhelyer: (PD?)
[15:46:43] bhelyer plays [Pine Barrens].
[15:46:44] Turn 1: JackSlagel
[15:46:57] [CHAT] JackSlagel: um, yeah, just PD
[15:47:09] [CHAT] JackSlagel: there's that modern version floating around, but it's "viable"
[15:47:18] [CHAT] bhelyer: "doesn't lose, sometimes"
[15:47:29] [CHAT] JackSlagel: it's still like 40% which is good
[15:47:31] [CHAT] JackSlagel: for battle of wits
[15:47:41] [CHAT] JackSlagel: just kind of burnt out with this season, wanted to try something fun
[15:47:51] JackSlagel plays [Nomad Outpost].
[15:47:54] Turn 2: bhelyer
[15:48:03] [CHAT] bhelyer: playing magic? 
[15:48:05] [CHAT] bhelyer: for fun?
[15:48:10] [CHAT] bhelyer: strange idea
[15:48:11] bhelyer plays [Forest].
[15:48:15] bhelyer casts [Wailing Ghoul].
[15:48:15] bhelyer puts triggered ability from [Wailing Ghoul] onto the stack (When Wailing Ghoul enters the battlefield, put the top two cards of your library into your graveya...).
[15:48:16] Turn 2: JackSlagel
[15:48:18] [CHAT] JackSlagel: oh god, pinebarons?
[15:48:31] [CHAT] JackSlagel: dude, i dont think you're that desperate for duals
[15:48:48] [CHAT] JackSlagel: savage lands and sandsteppe citadel are both legal
[15:48:58] [CHAT] JackSlagel: i guess maybe the colorless is the ticket
[15:49:12] JackSlagel plays [Thornwood Falls].
[15:49:12] JackSlagel puts triggered ability from [Thornwood Falls] onto the stack (When Thornwood Falls enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[15:49:15] Turn 3: bhelyer
[15:49:24] [CHAT] bhelyer: no no, I just threw this together quickly, savage lands is a good call
[15:49:39] [CHAT] bhelyer: although someone's got to use these old cards
[15:49:53] [CHAT] bhelyer: otherwise the modo team could just not implement them and no one would notice
[15:49:55] [CHAT] bhelyer: :P
[15:49:57] bhelyer plays [Forest].
[15:50:00] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Wailing Ghoul].
[15:50:07] bhelyer casts [Crow of Dark Tidings].
[15:50:08] bhelyer puts triggered ability from [Crow of Dark Tidings] onto the stack (When Crow of Dark Tidings enters the battlefield, put the top two cards of your library into your ...).
[15:50:08] Turn 3: JackSlagel
[15:50:17] [CHAT] JackSlagel: yeah, and they put them in a masters set, ffs
[15:50:26] [CHAT] JackSlagel: like, here, have worse duals than every core set
[15:50:36] [CHAT] bhelyer: could be kamigawa duals
[15:50:49] JackSlagel plays [Mountain].
[15:50:56] JackSlagel casts [Stinging Shot] targeting [Crow of Dark Tidings].
[15:50:56] bhelyer puts triggered ability from [Crow of Dark Tidings] onto the stack (When Crow of Dark Tidings dies, put the top two cards of your library into your graveyard.).
[15:51:07] JackSlagel casts [Ultimate Price] targeting [Wailing Ghoul].
[15:51:11] Turn 4: bhelyer
[15:51:14] [CHAT] bhelyer: I was gonna ask about maindeck stinging shot
[15:51:18] [CHAT] bhelyer: but then I remembered, bow
[15:51:27] bhelyer casts [Wailing Ghoul].
[15:51:29] bhelyer puts triggered ability from [Wailing Ghoul] onto the stack (When Wailing Ghoul enters the battlefield, put the top two cards of your library into your graveya...).
[15:51:33] bhelyer casts [Wreath of Geists] targeting [Wailing Ghoul].
[15:51:34] Turn 4: JackSlagel
[15:51:46] [CHAT] JackSlagel: yeah, lots of cycling cards to smooth out the mana
[15:52:07] JackSlagel casts [Naturalize] targeting [Wreath of Geists].
[15:52:10] Turn 5: bhelyer
[15:52:14] bhelyer plays [Swamp].
[15:52:23] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Wailing Ghoul].
[15:52:28] bhelyer casts [Wailing Ghoul].
[15:52:28] bhelyer puts triggered ability from [Wailing Ghoul] onto the stack (When Wailing Ghoul enters the battlefield, put the top two cards of your library into your graveya...).
[15:52:32] Turn 5: JackSlagel
[15:52:37] JackSlagel plays [Seaside Citadel].
[15:52:53] JackSlagel casts [Pilfered Plans] targeting bhelyer.
[15:52:53] JackSlagel draws two cards with [Pilfered Plans].
[15:52:59] Turn 6: bhelyer
[15:53:09] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Wailing Ghoul] and [Wailing Ghoul].
[15:53:14] bhelyer puts [Putrefy], [Rot Farm Skeleton], [Swamp], and [Forest] into their graveyard with with [Rot Farm Skeleton]'s ability.
[15:53:14] bhelyer activates an ability of [Rot Farm Skeleton] ( Return Rot Farm Skeleton from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[15:53:15] Turn 6: JackSlagel
[15:53:56] JackSlagel plays [Evolving Wilds].
[15:54:07] JackSlagel casts [Carrier Thrall].
[15:54:10] JackSlagel activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[15:54:25] Turn 7: bhelyer
[15:54:34] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Rot Farm Skeleton], [Wailing Ghoul], and [Wailing Ghoul].
[15:54:37] [Carrier Thrall] blocks [Rot Farm Skeleton].
[15:54:40] JackSlagel puts triggered ability from [Carrier Thrall] onto the stack (When Carrier Thrall dies, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. It has 'Sacrifice t...).
[15:54:42] JackSlagel's [Carrier Thrall] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[15:54:47] bhelyer puts [Rot Farm Skeleton], [Foul Orchard], [Foul Orchard], and [Golgari Guildgate] into their graveyard with with [Rot Farm Skeleton]'s ability.
[15:54:47] bhelyer activates an ability of [Rot Farm Skeleton] ( Return Rot Farm Skeleton from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[15:54:47] Turn 7: JackSlagel
[15:55:14] JackSlagel casts [Rogue Refiner].
[15:55:15] JackSlagel puts triggered ability from [Rogue Refiner] onto the stack (When Rogue Refiner enters the battlefield, draw a card and you get {EE}.).
[15:55:18] JackSlagel draws a card with [Rogue Refiner]'s ability.
[15:55:19] JackSlagel gains 2 energy from [Rogue Refiner]'s ability.
[15:55:27] Turn 8: bhelyer
[15:55:56] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Rot Farm Skeleton].
[15:55:56] JackSlagel casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Rot Farm Skeleton].
[15:55:58] bhelyer puts [Evershrike], [Wreath of Geists], [Putrefy], and [Swamp] into their graveyard with with [Rot Farm Skeleton]'s ability.
[15:55:58] bhelyer activates an ability of [Rot Farm Skeleton] ( Return Rot Farm Skeleton from your graveyard to the battlefield.).
[15:55:59] Turn 8: JackSlagel
[15:55:59] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Evershrike[sU] has a Advantageous bug.
If you activate Evershrike's ability multiple times before having it get reanimated, each trigger will let you attach an aura.
[15:56:06] JackSlagel plays [Jungle Shrine].
[15:56:10] bhelyer is being attacked by [Rogue Refiner].
[15:56:17] [Wailing Ghoul] blocks [Rogue Refiner].
[15:56:17] [Wailing Ghoul] blocks [Rogue Refiner].
[15:56:21] Blockers for [Rogue Refiner] are ordered as follows: [Wailing Ghoul], [Wailing Ghoul]
[15:56:25] JackSlagel casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Wailing Ghoul].
[15:56:35] Turn 9: bhelyer
[15:56:47] Turn 9: JackSlagel
[15:57:12] JackSlagel casts [Razaketh's Rite].
[15:57:34] JackSlagel casts [Jaddi Offshoot].
[15:57:59] bhelyer activates an ability of [Evershrike]. (X is 2) ( Return Evershrike from your graveyard to the battlefield. You may put an Aura card with converted...).
[15:58:12] Turn 10: bhelyer
[15:58:17] bhelyer casts [Exoskeletal Armor] targeting [Evershrike].
[15:58:25] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Evershrike].
Winner: bhelyer
Game 1 Completed.
[15:58:38] bhelyer has left the game.

== Game 2 (638109162) ==
[16:01:15] PDBot has started watching.
[16:01:19] JackSlagel joined the game.
[16:01:35] JackSlagel chooses to play first.
[16:01:43] JackSlagel keeps this hand.
[16:01:45] bhelyer keeps this hand.
[16:01:45] Turn 1: JackSlagel
[16:01:47] JackSlagel skips their draw step.
[16:01:48] JackSlagel plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[16:01:53] Turn 1: bhelyer
[16:01:59] bhelyer plays [Pine Barrens].
[16:02:00] Turn 2: JackSlagel
[16:02:07] JackSlagel plays [Swamp].
[16:02:09] Turn 2: bhelyer
[16:02:12] bhelyer plays [Swamp].
[16:02:15] bhelyer casts [Wailing Ghoul].
[16:02:20] JackSlagel casts [Anticipate].
[16:02:33] bhelyer puts triggered ability from [Wailing Ghoul] onto the stack (When Wailing Ghoul enters the battlefield, put the top two cards of your library into your graveya...).
[16:02:36] Turn 3: JackSlagel
[16:02:43] JackSlagel discards [Unburden].
[16:02:43] JackSlagel cycles [Unburden].
[16:02:45] JackSlagel plays [Scoured Barrens].
[16:02:45] JackSlagel puts triggered ability from [Scoured Barrens] onto the stack (When Scoured Barrens enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[16:02:48] Turn 3: bhelyer
[16:02:51] bhelyer plays [Swamp].
[16:02:55] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Wailing Ghoul].
[16:02:59] Turn 4: JackSlagel
[16:03:02] JackSlagel plays [Island].
[16:03:33] JackSlagel casts [Cranial Extraction] targeting bhelyer.
[16:03:41] bhelyer activates an ability of [Evershrike]. (X is 1) ( Return Evershrike from your graveyard to the battlefield. You may put an Aura card with converted...).
[16:04:15] JackSlagel names Exoskeletal Armor for [Cranial Extraction].
[16:04:38] Turn 4: bhelyer
[16:04:46] bhelyer plays [Golgari Guildgate].
[16:04:50] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Evershrike] and [Wailing Ghoul].
[16:04:56] bhelyer casts [Benefaction of Rhonas].
[16:04:56] bhelyer reveals 5 cards with [Benefaction of Rhonas]: [Lay Bare the Heart], [Putrefy], [Naturalize], [Crow of Dark Tidings], and [Crow of Dark Tidings].
[16:05:01] Turn 5: JackSlagel
[16:05:29] JackSlagel casts [Torment of Scarabs] targeting bhelyer.
[16:05:31] Turn 5: bhelyer
[16:05:31] JackSlagel puts triggered ability from [Torment of Scarabs] onto the stack (At the beginning of enchanted player's upkeep, that player loses 3 life unless they sacrifice a no...).
[16:05:39] bhelyer discards [Forest].
[16:05:41] bhelyer plays [Svogthos, the Restless Tomb].
[16:05:45] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Evershrike] and [Wailing Ghoul].
[16:05:51] bhelyer casts [Crow of Dark Tidings].
[16:05:52] bhelyer puts triggered ability from [Crow of Dark Tidings] onto the stack (When Crow of Dark Tidings enters the battlefield, put the top two cards of your library into your ...).
[16:05:57] Turn 6: JackSlagel
[16:06:12] JackSlagel plays [Desert of the Mindful].
[16:06:19] Turn 6: bhelyer
[16:06:19] JackSlagel puts triggered ability from [Torment of Scarabs] onto the stack (At the beginning of enchanted player's upkeep, that player loses 3 life unless they sacrifice a no...).
[16:06:31] bhelyer plays [Swamp].
[16:06:37] bhelyer activates an ability of [Svogthos, the Restless Tomb] ( Until end of turn, Svogthos, the Restless Tomb becomes a black and green Plant Zombie creature wi...).
[16:06:50] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Crow of Dark Tidings], [Svogthos, the Restless Tomb], [Evershrike], and [Wailing Ghoul].
[16:06:57] JackSlagel casts [Farm] targeting [Evershrike].
[16:07:00] Turn 7: JackSlagel
[16:07:13] JackSlagel casts [Market] from the graveyard.
[16:07:13] JackSlagel draws two cards with [Market].
[16:07:23] [CHAT] bhelyer: Farm, the second silliest name for a magic card, just before 'Mouth'
[16:07:51] cotton2431 has started watching.
[16:07:52] JackSlagel discards [Island].
[16:07:52] JackSlagel discards [Shadowmage Infiltrator].
[16:07:55] JackSlagel plays [Forest].
[16:07:58] JackSlagel casts [Jaddi Offshoot].
[16:08:00] Turn 7: bhelyer
[16:08:01] JackSlagel puts triggered ability from [Torment of Scarabs] onto the stack (At the beginning of enchanted player's upkeep, that player loses 3 life unless they sacrifice a no...).
[16:08:09] bhelyer discards [Putrefy].
[16:08:21] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Crow of Dark Tidings].
[16:08:27] JackSlagel casts [Ultimate Price] targeting [Crow of Dark Tidings].
[16:08:32] bhelyer puts triggered ability from [Crow of Dark Tidings] onto the stack (When Crow of Dark Tidings dies, put the top two cards of your library into your graveyard.).
[16:08:47] bhelyer casts [Splinterfright].
[16:08:51] Turn 8: JackSlagel
[16:08:57] [CHAT] JackSlagel: hahaha
[16:09:08] [CHAT] JackSlagel: i think market is actually a decent name for a spell
[16:09:10] cotton2431 has stopped watching.
[16:09:23] JackSlagel discards [Desert of the Mindful].
[16:09:23] JackSlagel cycles [Desert of the Mindful].
[16:09:25] [CHAT] bhelyer: Farm is like someone google translate swords to ploughshares
[16:09:38] JackSlagel plays [Seaside Citadel].
[16:09:38] JackSlagel puts triggered ability from [Jaddi Offshoot] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
[16:09:49] JackSlagel casts [Eternal Scourge].
[16:10:09] bhelyer casts [Putrefy] targeting [Jaddi Offshoot].
[16:10:09] Turn 8: bhelyer
[16:10:10] bhelyer puts triggered ability from [Splinterfright] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, put the top two cards of your library into your graveyard.).
[16:10:10] JackSlagel puts triggered ability from [Torment of Scarabs] onto the stack (At the beginning of enchanted player's upkeep, that player loses 3 life unless they sacrifice a no...).
[16:10:50] bhelyer casts [Putrefy] targeting [Eternal Scourge].
[16:10:51] JackSlagel puts triggered ability from [Eternal Scourge] onto the stack (When Eternal Scourge becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls, exile Eternal ...).
[16:10:53] JackSlagel exiles [Eternal Scourge] with its own ability.
[16:10:55] bhelyer's [Putrefy] is countered because it has no legal targets.
[16:11:00] JackSlagel is being attacked by [Splinterfright] and [Wailing Ghoul].
Winner: bhelyer
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: bhelyer: 2–0
[16:11:20] bhelyer has left the game.