PennyDreadful
PD League
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
Ishibiki341,NGE

== Game 1 (637321768) ==
[17:04:53] PDBot has started watching.
[League] Pd-Nightmare by ishibiki341 (23835) vs Appeal to Authority by nge (23861)
[17:04:56] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match!
[17:04:59] [CHAT] NGE: GLHF!
[17:05:01] NGE chooses to play first.
[17:05:06] NGE keeps this hand.
[17:05:08] [CHAT] Ishibiki341: glhf
[17:05:14] Ishibiki341 keeps this hand.
[17:05:14] Turn 1: NGE
[17:05:14] NGE skips their draw step.
[17:05:17] NGE plays [Selesnya Guildgate].
[17:05:19] Turn 1: Ishibiki341
[17:05:25] Ishibiki341 plays [Evolving Wilds].
[17:05:31] Turn 2: NGE
[17:05:34] NGE plays [Plains].
[17:05:37] NGE casts [Fleecemane Lion].
[17:05:45] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[17:06:02] Turn 2: Ishibiki341
[17:06:10] Ishibiki341 plays [Forest].
[17:06:12] Ishibiki341 casts [Noose Constrictor].
[17:06:19] Turn 3: NGE
[17:06:23] NGE plays [Plains].
[17:06:33] NGE casts [Bygone Bishop].
[17:06:42] Turn 3: Ishibiki341
[17:06:49] Ishibiki341 plays [Forest].
[17:06:51] Ishibiki341 casts [Civic Wayfinder].
[17:06:55] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Civic Wayfinder] onto the stack (When Civic Wayfinder enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, re...).
[17:07:03] Ishibiki341 reveals [Forest].
[17:07:10] Turn 4: NGE
[17:07:16] NGE plays [Vitu-Ghazi, the City-Tree].
[17:07:28] Turn 4: Ishibiki341
[17:07:37] Ishibiki341 casts [Lone Rider].
[17:07:41] Ishibiki341 plays [Selesnya Sanctuary].
[17:07:41] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Selesnya Sanctuary] onto the stack (When Selesnya Sanctuary enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[17:07:46] Ishibiki341 returns [Forest] to its owner's hand with [Selesnya Sanctuary]'s ability.
[17:08:02] Turn 5: NGE
[17:08:07] NGE casts [Fleecemane Lion].
[17:08:07] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:08:09] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:08:14] NGE plays [Forest].
[17:08:21] NGE casts [Adanto Vanguard].
[17:08:21] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:08:23] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:08:29] Turn 5: Ishibiki341
[17:08:45] Ishibiki341 plays [Forest].
[17:08:50] Ishibiki341 casts [Sylvan Ranger].
[17:08:53] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...).
[17:09:04] Ishibiki341 reveals [Swamp].
[17:09:13] Turn 6: NGE
[17:09:19] NGE plays [Plains].
[17:09:28] NGE casts [Bygone Bishop].
[17:09:29] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:09:31] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:09:31] Turn 6: Ishibiki341
[17:09:39] Ishibiki341 plays [Swamp].
[17:09:48] Ishibiki341 casts [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[17:10:04] NGE activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[17:10:04] NGE draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[17:10:07] Turn 7: NGE
[17:10:18] NGE casts [Adanto Vanguard].
[17:10:19] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:10:19] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:10:26] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:10:28] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:10:43] Turn 7: Ishibiki341
[17:10:51] Ishibiki341 plays [Swamp].
[17:11:11] NGE is being attacked by [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[17:11:30] Ishibiki341 discards [Ghost-Lit Stalker].
[17:11:30] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Ghost-Lit Stalker] targeting NGE ( Target player discards four cards.).
[17:11:48] NGE discards [Advent of the Wurm].
[17:11:48] NGE discards [Appeal/Authority].
[17:11:52] NGE activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[17:11:52] NGE draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[17:11:57] NGE activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[17:11:57] NGE draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[17:12:00] Turn 8: NGE
[17:12:05] NGE casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[17:12:05] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:12:05] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:12:07] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:12:08] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:12:18] NGE casts [Selesnya Charm] targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star] (Exile target creature with power 5 or greater.).
[17:12:34] Ishibiki341 is being attacked by [Adanto Vanguard] and [Adanto Vanguard].
[17:12:40] Turn 8: Ishibiki341
[17:12:45] Ishibiki341 plays [Scoured Barrens].
[17:12:45] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Scoured Barrens] onto the stack (When Scoured Barrens enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[17:13:18] NGE activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[17:13:18] NGE draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[17:13:20] Turn 9: NGE
[17:13:23] NGE plays [Forest].
[17:13:26] NGE casts [Sunblade Elf].
[17:13:26] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:13:26] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:13:28] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:13:29] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:13:35] Ishibiki341 is being attacked by [Adanto Vanguard] and [Adanto Vanguard].
[17:13:44] [Lone Rider] blocks [Adanto Vanguard].
[17:13:45] [Sylvan Ranger] blocks [Adanto Vanguard].
[17:13:51] NGE activates an ability of [Adanto Vanguard] ( Adanto Vanguard gains indestructible until end of turn.).
[17:13:52] NGE activates an ability of [Adanto Vanguard] ( Adanto Vanguard gains indestructible until end of turn.).
[17:14:01] Turn 9: Ishibiki341
[17:14:07] Ishibiki341 plays [Forest].
[17:14:22] NGE activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[17:14:22] NGE draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[17:14:25] NGE activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[17:14:26] NGE draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[17:14:30] NGE activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[17:14:30] NGE draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[17:14:33] Turn 10: NGE
[17:14:36] NGE plays [Forest].
[17:14:45] NGE casts [Appeal] targeting [Adanto Vanguard].
[17:14:51] NGE casts [Authority] from the graveyard targeting [Noose Constrictor], and [Civic Wayfinder].
[17:14:56] Ishibiki341 is being attacked by [Sunblade Elf], [Avacyn's Pilgrim], [Adanto Vanguard], [Bygone Bishop], [Adanto Vanguard], [Fleecemane Lion], [Bygone Bishop], and [Fleecemane Lion].
Winner: NGE
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (637322762) ==
[17:15:54] PDBot has started watching.
[17:15:57] Ishibiki341 keeps this hand.
[17:16:00] NGE keeps this hand.
[17:16:00] Turn 1: Ishibiki341
[17:16:02] Ishibiki341 skips their draw step.
[17:16:03] Ishibiki341 plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[17:16:07] Turn 1: NGE
[17:16:11] NGE plays [Forest].
[17:16:12] NGE casts [Sunblade Elf].
[17:16:14] Turn 2: Ishibiki341
[17:16:19] Ishibiki341 plays [Forest].
[17:16:25] Ishibiki341 casts [Sylvan Ranger].
[17:16:27] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...).
[17:16:36] Ishibiki341 reveals [Plains].
[17:16:39] Turn 2: NGE
[17:16:44] NGE plays [Plains].
[17:16:49] Ishibiki341 is being attacked by [Sunblade Elf].
[17:16:54] NGE casts [Adanto Vanguard].
[17:16:56] Turn 3: Ishibiki341
[17:17:01] Ishibiki341 plays [Plains].
[17:17:06] Ishibiki341 casts [Civic Wayfinder].
[17:17:08] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Civic Wayfinder] onto the stack (When Civic Wayfinder enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, re...).
[17:17:16] Ishibiki341 reveals [Swamp].
[17:17:35] Turn 3: NGE
[17:17:40] NGE plays [Vitu-Ghazi, the City-Tree].
[17:17:43] Ishibiki341 is being attacked by [Adanto Vanguard] and [Sunblade Elf].
[17:17:59] NGE casts [Fleecemane Lion].
[17:18:00] Turn 4: Ishibiki341
[17:18:07] Ishibiki341 plays [Swamp].
[17:18:11] Ishibiki341 casts [Glare of Subdual].
[17:18:34] Turn 4: NGE
[17:18:48] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Glare of Subdual] targeting [Fleecemane Lion] ( Tap target artifact or creature.).
[17:19:00] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Glare of Subdual] targeting [Adanto Vanguard] ( Tap target artifact or creature.).
[17:19:10] NGE casts [Sunblade Elf].
[17:19:17] Turn 5: Ishibiki341
[17:19:29] Ishibiki341 plays [Forest].
[17:19:41] Ishibiki341 casts [Unflinching Courage] targeting [Civic Wayfinder].
[17:19:56] NGE is being attacked by [Civic Wayfinder].
[17:20:07] Ishibiki341 casts [Glory-Bound Initiate].
[17:20:15] Turn 5: NGE
[17:20:29] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Glare of Subdual] targeting [Fleecemane Lion] ( Tap target artifact or creature.).
[17:20:35] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Glare of Subdual] targeting [Adanto Vanguard] ( Tap target artifact or creature.).
[17:20:48] Turn 6: Ishibiki341
[17:20:54] Ishibiki341 plays [Scoured Barrens].
[17:20:54] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Scoured Barrens] onto the stack (When Scoured Barrens enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[17:21:06] NGE is being attacked by [Civic Wayfinder].
[17:21:15] [Sunblade Elf] blocks [Civic Wayfinder].
[17:21:16] [Sunblade Elf] blocks [Civic Wayfinder].
[17:21:21] Blockers for [Civic Wayfinder] are ordered as follows: [Sunblade Elf], [Sunblade Elf]
[17:21:43] Ishibiki341 casts [Sylvan Ranger].
[17:21:44] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...).
[17:21:52] Ishibiki341 reveals [Forest].
[17:21:59] Turn 6: NGE
[17:22:01] NGE plays [Selesnya Guildgate].
[17:22:13] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Glare of Subdual] targeting [Fleecemane Lion] ( Tap target artifact or creature.).
[17:22:18] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Glare of Subdual] targeting [Adanto Vanguard] ( Tap target artifact or creature.).
[17:22:25] Turn 7: Ishibiki341
[17:22:31] Ishibiki341 plays [Forest].
[17:22:44] NGE is being attacked by [Glory-Bound Initiate] and [Sylvan Ranger].
[17:22:56] Ishibiki341 casts [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[17:23:03] Turn 7: NGE
[17:23:05] NGE plays [Selesnya Guildgate].
[17:23:09] NGE casts [Banisher Priest].
[17:23:22] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Glare of Subdual] targeting [Fleecemane Lion] ( Tap target artifact or creature.).
[17:23:29] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Glare of Subdual] targeting [Adanto Vanguard] ( Tap target artifact or creature.).
[17:23:37] NGE puts triggered ability from [Banisher Priest] onto the stack targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star] (When Banisher Priest enters the battlefield, exile target creature an opponent controls until Bani...).
[17:23:51] Turn 8: Ishibiki341
[17:24:13] NGE is being attacked by [Glory-Bound Initiate].
[17:24:13] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Glory-Bound Initiate] onto the stack (Whenever Glory-Bound Initiate attacks and exerts, it gets +1/+3 and gains lifelink until end of tu...).
[17:24:27] Ishibiki341 casts [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[17:24:34] Turn 8: NGE
[17:24:41] NGE casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[17:24:52] NGE casts [Fabled Hero].
[17:25:07] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Glare of Subdual] targeting [Fleecemane Lion] ( Tap target artifact or creature.).
[17:25:16] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Glare of Subdual] targeting [Adanto Vanguard] ( Tap target artifact or creature.).
[17:25:21] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Glare of Subdual] targeting [Banisher Priest] ( Tap target artifact or creature.).
[17:25:28] Turn 9: Ishibiki341
[17:25:42] NGE is being attacked by [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[17:25:53] Ishibiki341 casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[17:26:00] Ishibiki341 activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Civic Wayfinder] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[17:26:04] NGE has conceded from the game.
Winner: Ishibiki341
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (637323688) ==
[17:26:45] PDBot has started watching.
[17:26:47] NGE keeps this hand.
[17:26:53] Ishibiki341 keeps this hand.
[17:26:53] Turn 1: NGE
[17:26:53] NGE skips their draw step.
[17:26:59] NGE plays [Forest].
[17:27:00] Turn 1: Ishibiki341
[17:27:04] Ishibiki341 plays [Scoured Barrens].
[17:27:04] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Scoured Barrens] onto the stack (When Scoured Barrens enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[17:27:12] Turn 2: NGE
[17:27:14] NGE plays [Plains].
[17:27:16] NGE casts [Adanto Vanguard].
[17:27:21] Turn 2: Ishibiki341
[17:27:26] Ishibiki341 plays [Forest].
[17:27:33] Ishibiki341 casts [Lone Rider].
[17:27:43] Turn 3: NGE
[17:27:49] Ishibiki341 is being attacked by [Adanto Vanguard].
[17:27:59] NGE plays [Plains].
[17:28:02] NGE casts [Bygone Bishop].
[17:28:05] Turn 3: Ishibiki341
[17:28:18] Ishibiki341 casts [Lone Rider].
[17:28:23] Ishibiki341 plays [Selesnya Sanctuary].
[17:28:23] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Selesnya Sanctuary] onto the stack (When Selesnya Sanctuary enters the battlefield, return a land you control to its owner's hand.).
[17:28:29] Ishibiki341 returns [Forest] to its owner's hand with [Selesnya Sanctuary]'s ability.
[17:28:36] Turn 4: NGE
[17:28:46] NGE plays [Forest].
[17:28:53] Ishibiki341 is being attacked by [Adanto Vanguard].
[17:29:01] Turn 4: Ishibiki341
[17:29:04] Ishibiki341 plays [Forest].
[17:29:11] Ishibiki341 casts [Loxodon Hierarch].
[17:29:14] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Loxodon Hierarch] onto the stack (When Loxodon Hierarch enters the battlefield, you gain 4 life.).
[17:29:26] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Lone Rider] onto the stack (At the beginning of the end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, transform Lone Rider.).
[17:29:27] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Lone Rider] onto the stack (At the beginning of the end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, transform Lone Rider.).
[17:29:34] Turn 5: NGE
[17:29:48] NGE plays [Selesnya Guildgate].
[17:29:52] NGE casts [Banisher Priest].
[17:29:52] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:29:55] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:30:00] NGE puts triggered ability from [Banisher Priest] onto the stack targeting [It That Rides as One] (When Banisher Priest enters the battlefield, exile target creature an opponent controls until Bani...).
[17:30:26] Turn 5: Ishibiki341
[17:30:32] Ishibiki341 plays [Forest].
[17:30:51] NGE is being attacked by [It That Rides as One].
[17:31:02] Ishibiki341 casts [Sylvan Ranger].
[17:31:03] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...).
[17:31:09] Ishibiki341 reveals [Swamp].
[17:31:16] Turn 6: NGE
[17:31:22] NGE plays [Plains].
[17:31:24] NGE activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[17:31:26] NGE draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[17:31:31] NGE casts [Fabled Hero].
[17:31:31] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:31:35] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:31:50] Ishibiki341 is being attacked by [Bygone Bishop].
[17:32:10] Ishibiki341 casts [Congregation at Dawn].
[17:32:20] Ishibiki341 reveals [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[17:32:20] Ishibiki341 reveals [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[17:32:20] Ishibiki341 reveals [Magister of Worth].
[17:32:21] Ishibiki341 put a card on top of Ishibiki341's library.
[17:32:22] Ishibiki341 put a card on top of Ishibiki341's library.
[17:32:23] Ishibiki341 put a card on top of Ishibiki341's library.
[17:32:25] Turn 6: Ishibiki341
[17:32:40] NGE is being attacked by [Sylvan Ranger], [Loxodon Hierarch], and [It That Rides as One].
[17:32:59] [Banisher Priest] blocks [It That Rides as One].
[17:33:07] [Fabled Hero] blocks [It That Rides as One].
[17:33:09] [Adanto Vanguard] blocks [Loxodon Hierarch].
[17:33:13] Blockers for [It That Rides as One] are ordered as follows: [Banisher Priest], [Fabled Hero]
[17:33:27] NGE activates an ability of [Adanto Vanguard] ( Adanto Vanguard gains indestructible until end of turn.).
[17:33:39] Ishibiki341 plays [Swamp].
[17:33:50] Ishibiki341 casts [Civic Wayfinder].
[17:33:51] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Civic Wayfinder] onto the stack (When Civic Wayfinder enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, re...).
[17:34:04] Ishibiki341 reveals [Plains].
[17:34:07] Ishibiki341 puts triggered ability from [Lone Rider] onto the stack (At the beginning of the end step, if you gained 3 or more life this turn, transform Lone Rider.).
[17:34:11] Turn 7: NGE
[17:34:16] NGE activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[17:34:18] NGE draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[17:34:19] NGE plays [Plains].
[17:35:01] NGE casts [Sunblade Elf].
[17:35:02] NGE puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[17:35:02] NGE's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[17:35:04] NGE activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[17:35:04] NGE draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[17:35:04] Turn 7: Ishibiki341
[17:35:04] Ishibiki341 plays [Plains].
[17:35:05] NGE is being attacked by [Civic Wayfinder], [It That Rides as One], [Sylvan Ranger], [Loxodon Hierarch], and [It That Rides as One].
[17:35:20] [Adanto Vanguard] blocks [Loxodon Hierarch].
[17:35:21] [Sunblade Elf] blocks [Sylvan Ranger].
[17:35:22] [Bygone Bishop] blocks [Civic Wayfinder].
[17:35:54] Ishibiki341 casts [Loxodon Hierarch].
[17:35:57] NGE has conceded from the game.
Winner: Ishibiki341
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: Ishibiki341: 2–1
[17:36:01] NGE has left the game.