PennyDreadful
Penny Dreadful vs JoshHolladay
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
trevor3693,JoshHolladay

== Game 1 (626377870) ==
[04:33:06] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 9.02
[Gatherling] Round=2
[04:33:08] JoshHolladay joined the game.
[04:33:12] trevor3693 chooses to play first.
[04:33:16] trevor3693 mulligans to 6 cards.
[04:33:21] JoshHolladay keeps this hand.
[04:33:23] trevor3693 keeps this hand.
[04:33:27] trevor3693 puts 1 card on top of their library.
[04:33:27] Turn 1: trevor3693
[04:33:27] trevor3693 skips their draw step.
[04:33:28] trevor3693 plays [Simic Guildgate].
[04:33:31] flac0 has started watching.
[04:33:33] Turn 1: JoshHolladay
[04:33:36] JoshHolladay plays [Golgari Guildgate].
[04:33:43] Turn 2: trevor3693
[04:33:45] trevor3693 plays [Island].
[04:33:48] trevor3693 exiles [Riftwing Cloudskate] with 3 time counters.
[04:33:54] Turn 2: JoshHolladay
[04:34:04] JoshHolladay plays [Forest].
[04:34:08] Turn 3: trevor3693
[04:34:08] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Riftwing Cloudskate] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[04:34:15] trevor3693 plays [Forest].
[04:34:18] trevor3693 casts [Mimic Vat].
[04:34:18] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Mimic Vat[sU] has a Disadvantageous bug.
Clones such as Phyrexian Metamorph are not granted haste by Mimic Vat.

[04:34:26] Turn 3: JoshHolladay
[04:34:31] JoshHolladay plays [Swamp].
[04:34:37] JoshHolladay casts [Gatecreeper Vine].
[04:34:37] JoshHolladay puts triggered ability from [Gatecreeper Vine] onto the stack (When Gatecreeper Vine enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card or...).
[04:34:43] JoshHolladay reveals [Mountain].
[04:34:48] Turn 4: trevor3693
[04:34:48] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Riftwing Cloudskate] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[04:35:03] Turn 4: JoshHolladay
[04:35:11] JoshHolladay plays [Mountain].
[04:35:20] JoshHolladay casts [Catacomb Sifter].
[04:35:21] JoshHolladay puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (When Catacomb Sifter enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. ...).
[04:35:23] JoshHolladay's [Catacomb Sifter] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[04:35:27] Turn 5: trevor3693
[04:35:27] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Riftwing Cloudskate] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)).
[04:35:31] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Riftwing Cloudskate] onto the stack (Suspend (When the last time counter is removed from the suspended card, cast it without paying i...).
[04:35:38] trevor3693 casts [Riftwing Cloudskate].
[04:35:46] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Riftwing Cloudskate] onto the stack targeting [Mountain] (When Riftwing Cloudskate enters the battlefield, return target permanent to its owner's hand.).
[04:35:49] trevor3693 returns [Mountain] to its owner's hand with [Riftwing Cloudskate]'s ability.
[04:35:58] JoshHolladay is being attacked by [Riftwing Cloudskate].
[04:36:08] Turn 5: JoshHolladay
[04:36:12] trevor3693 casts [Elder Deep-Fiend], emerging from [Riftwing Cloudskate].
[04:36:14] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Whenever a nontoken creature dies, you may exile that card. If you do, return each other card exil...).
[04:36:18] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Elder Deep-Fiend] onto the stack targeting [Catacomb Sifter], [Golgari Guildgate], [Forest], and [Swamp] (When you cast this spell, tap up to 4 target permanents.).
[04:37:08] JoshHolladay plays [Swamp].
[04:37:18] Turn 6: trevor3693
[04:37:20] trevor3693 plays [Forest].
[04:37:23] trevor3693 activates an ability of [Mimic Vat] ( Create a token that's a copy of a card exiled with Mimic Vat. It gains haste. Exile it at the beg...).
[04:37:27] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Riftwing Cloudskate] onto the stack targeting [Golgari Guildgate] (When Riftwing Cloudskate enters the battlefield, return target permanent to its owner's hand.).
[04:37:30] trevor3693 returns [Golgari Guildgate] to its owner's hand with [Riftwing Cloudskate]'s ability.
[04:37:36] JoshHolladay is being attacked by [Riftwing Cloudskate] and [Elder Deep-Fiend].
[04:37:44] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Mimic Vat] onto the stack (Exile Riftwing Cloudskate at the beginning of the end step.).
[04:37:50] Turn 6: JoshHolladay
[04:37:55] JoshHolladay plays [Mountain].
[04:38:24] JoshHolladay casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:38:31] Turn 7: trevor3693
[04:38:53] trevor3693 casts [Whirler Rogue].
[04:38:58] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Whirler Rogue] onto the stack (When Whirler Rogue enters the battlefield, create two 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature toke...).
[04:39:01] trevor3693's [Whirler Rogue] creates two Thopter tokens.
[04:39:06] trevor3693 activates an ability of [Whirler Rogue] targeting [Elder Deep-Fiend] ( Target creature can't be blocked this turn.).
[04:39:15] JoshHolladay is being attacked by [Elder Deep-Fiend].
[04:39:24] trevor3693 plays [Thornwood Falls].
[04:39:24] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Thornwood Falls] onto the stack (When Thornwood Falls enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[04:39:29] Turn 7: JoshHolladay
[04:39:35] JoshHolladay plays [Swamp].
[04:39:42] JoshHolladay has conceded from the game.
Winner: trevor3693
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (626379656) ==
[04:41:23] PDBot has started watching.
[04:41:27] JoshHolladay chooses to play first.
[04:41:38] JoshHolladay keeps this hand.
[04:41:38] trevor3693 keeps this hand.
[04:41:39] Turn 1: JoshHolladay
[04:41:39] JoshHolladay skips their draw step.
[04:41:39] JoshHolladay plays [Rakdos Guildgate].
[04:41:48] Turn 1: trevor3693
[04:41:49] trevor3693 plays [Forest].
[04:41:53] Turn 2: JoshHolladay
[04:41:56] JoshHolladay plays [Gruul Guildgate].
[04:42:00] Turn 2: trevor3693
[04:42:02] trevor3693 plays [Island].
[04:42:09] Turn 3: JoshHolladay
[04:42:16] JoshHolladay plays [Swamp].
[04:42:32] JoshHolladay casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:42:32] Turn 3: trevor3693
[04:42:32] trevor3693 plays [Island].
[04:42:34] trevor3693 casts [Filigree Familiar].
[04:42:37] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar enters the battlefield, you gain 2 life.).
[04:42:45] Turn 4: JoshHolladay
[04:42:50] JoshHolladay plays [Swamp].
[04:43:01] JoshHolladay casts [Saruli Gatekeepers].
[04:43:01] JoshHolladay puts triggered ability from [Saruli Gatekeepers] onto the stack (When Saruli Gatekeepers enters the battlefield, if you control two or more Gates, you gain 7 life.).
[04:43:07] Turn 4: trevor3693
[04:43:15] trevor3693 plays [Island].
[04:43:28] trevor3693 casts [Whirler Rogue].
[04:43:35] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Whirler Rogue] onto the stack (When Whirler Rogue enters the battlefield, create two 1/1 colorless Thopter artifact creature toke...).
[04:43:38] trevor3693's [Whirler Rogue] creates two Thopter tokens.
[04:43:42] trevor3693 activates an ability of [Whirler Rogue] targeting [Filigree Familiar] ( Target creature can't be blocked this turn.).
[04:43:49] JoshHolladay is being attacked by [Filigree Familiar].
[04:43:57] Turn 5: JoshHolladay
[04:44:09] JoshHolladay casts [Cranial Extraction] targeting trevor3693.
[04:45:13] JoshHolladay names Elder Deep-Fiend for [Cranial Extraction].
[04:45:15] JoshHolladay plays [Rakdos Guildgate].
[04:45:15] Turn 5: trevor3693
[04:45:17] JoshHolladay is being attacked by [Thopter] token and [Whirler Rogue].
[04:45:17] trevor3693 activates an ability of [Whirler Rogue] targeting [Whirler Rogue] ( Target creature can't be blocked this turn.).
[04:45:53] Odintu2nd has started watching.
[04:46:23] Turn 6: JoshHolladay
[04:47:16] JoshHolladay casts [Jund Charm] (Jund Charm deals 2 damage to each creature.).
[04:47:26] trevor3693 casts [Flashfreeze] targeting [Jund Charm].
[04:47:37] Turn 6: trevor3693
[04:47:40] trevor3693 plays [Forest].
[04:47:59] trevor3693 casts [Riftwing Cloudskate].
[04:48:07] trevor3693 puts triggered ability from [Riftwing Cloudskate] onto the stack targeting [Gruul Guildgate] (When Riftwing Cloudskate enters the battlefield, return target permanent to its owner's hand.).
[04:48:10] trevor3693 returns [Gruul Guildgate] to its owner's hand with [Riftwing Cloudskate]'s ability.
[04:48:17] trevor3693 activates an ability of [Whirler Rogue] targeting [Whirler Rogue] ( Target creature can't be blocked this turn.).
[04:48:26] JoshHolladay is being attacked by [Thopter] token and [Whirler Rogue].
[04:48:33] Turn 7: JoshHolladay
[04:48:47] JoshHolladay plays [Forest].
[04:49:42] Turn 7: trevor3693
[04:49:46] trevor3693 plays [Island].
[04:49:54] trevor3693 activates an ability of [Whirler Rogue] targeting [Whirler Rogue] ( Target creature can't be blocked this turn.).
[04:50:06] JoshHolladay is being attacked by [Riftwing Cloudskate], [Thopter] token, and [Whirler Rogue].
[04:50:43] Turn 8: JoshHolladay
[04:50:54] JoshHolladay plays [Gruul Guildgate].
[04:51:27] Turn 8: trevor3693
[04:51:41] trevor3693 activates an ability of [Whirler Rogue] targeting [Whirler Rogue] ( Target creature can't be blocked this turn.).
[04:51:51] JoshHolladay is being attacked by [Riftwing Cloudskate], [Thopter] token, and [Whirler Rogue].
[04:52:03] Turn 9: JoshHolladay
[04:52:09] JoshHolladay plays [Mountain].
[04:52:14] JoshHolladay casts [Greenseeker].
[04:52:30] Turn 9: trevor3693
[04:52:40] JoshHolladay is being attacked by [Riftwing Cloudskate], [Thopter] token, and [Whirler Rogue].
[04:52:42] trevor3693 activates an ability of [Whirler Rogue] targeting [Whirler Rogue] ( Target creature can't be blocked this turn.).
[04:53:17] JoshHolladay casts [Naturalize] targeting [Thopter] token.
[04:53:45] Turn 10: JoshHolladay
[04:53:55] JoshHolladay discards [Smelt-Ward Gatekeepers].
[04:53:55] JoshHolladay activates an ability of [Greenseeker] ( Search your library for a basic land card, reveal it, and put it into your hand. Then shuffle you...).
[04:54:11] JoshHolladay reveals [Swamp].
[04:54:13] JoshHolladay plays [Swamp].
[04:54:23] JoshHolladay activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Smelt-Ward Gatekeepers] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[04:54:40] trevor3693 casts [Memory's Journey] targeting JoshHolladay, [Saruli Gatekeepers], and [Smelt-Ward Gatekeepers].
[04:54:57] JoshHolladay's Recurring Nightmare is countered because it has no legal targets.
[04:55:11] JoshHolladay has conceded from the game.
Winner: trevor3693
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: trevor3693: 2–0