PennyDreadful
PDT R4 vs ash
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
Ashamael,thundershot899

== Game 1 (625744268) ==
[11:37:16] PDBot has started watching.
[11:37:16] Ashamael joined the game.
[11:37:16] thundershot899 joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Thursdays 9.01
[Gatherling] Round=4
[11:37:18] thundershot899 chooses to play first.
[11:37:21] thundershot899 keeps this hand.
[11:37:32] Ashamael mulligans to 6 cards.
[11:37:37] Ashamael keeps this hand.
[11:38:02] Ashamael puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[11:38:02] Turn 1: thundershot899
[11:38:02] thundershot899 skips their draw step.
[11:38:03] thundershot899 plays [Swamp].
[11:38:06] Turn 1: Ashamael
[11:38:08] Ashamael plays [Swamp].
[11:38:15] thundershot899 discards [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:38:15] thundershot899 cycles [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:38:16] Turn 2: thundershot899
[11:38:18] thundershot899 plays [Island].
[11:38:20] Turn 2: Ashamael
[11:38:22] Ashamael plays [Plains].
[11:38:40] Ashamael casts [Oona's Prowler].
[11:38:42] thundershot899 discards [Striped Riverwinder].
[11:38:42] thundershot899 cycles [Striped Riverwinder].
[11:38:43] thundershot899 discards [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:38:43] thundershot899 cycles [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:38:43] Turn 3: thundershot899
[11:38:45] thundershot899 plays [Swamp].
[11:38:57] Turn 3: Ashamael
[11:39:28] [CHAT] Ashamael: sorry brb one minute
[11:39:32] [CHAT] thundershot899: np
[11:40:40] Ashamael plays [Plains].
[11:41:14] thundershot899 is being attacked by [Oona's Prowler].
[11:41:23] thundershot899 discards [Archfiend of Ifnir].
[11:41:23] thundershot899 cycles [Archfiend of Ifnir].
[11:41:26] Turn 4: thundershot899
[11:41:29] thundershot899 plays [Swamp].
[11:41:43] Ashamael casts [Demonic Consultation].
[11:41:50] Ashamael names Recurring Nightmare for [Demonic Consultation].
[11:41:50] Ashamael reveals [Plains].
[11:41:50] Ashamael reveals [Oona's Prowler].
[11:41:50] Ashamael reveals [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[11:41:50] Ashamael reveals [Ayli, Eternal Pilgrim].
[11:41:50] Ashamael reveals [Scoured Barrens].
[11:41:50] Ashamael reveals [Recurring Nightmare].
[11:42:01] Turn 4: Ashamael
[11:42:05] Ashamael casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[11:42:14] thundershot899 is being attacked by [Oona's Prowler].
[11:42:20] thundershot899 discards [Lurching Rotbeast].
[11:42:20] thundershot899 cycles [Lurching Rotbeast].
[11:42:22] Turn 5: thundershot899
[11:42:25] thundershot899 plays [Swamp].
[11:42:33] Turn 5: Ashamael
[11:43:16] Ashamael plays [Swamp].
[11:43:23] thundershot899 is being attacked by [Oona's Prowler].
[11:43:28] Turn 6: thundershot899
[11:43:31] thundershot899 plays [Island].
[11:43:35] thundershot899 casts [Living Death].
[11:43:41] Ashamael discards [Yosei, the Morning Star].
[11:43:41] Ashamael activates an ability of [Oona's Prowler] ( Oona's Prowler gets -2/-0 until end of turn.).
[11:43:57] thundershot899 casts [Scarab Feast] targeting [Yosei, the Morning Star], and [Demonic Consultation].
[11:46:02] [CHAT] Ashamael: sorry deciding if I want to DC for a one of
[11:46:12] [CHAT] thundershot899: whats the worst that will happen :P
[11:46:18] [CHAT] Ashamael: true
[11:46:23] [CHAT] Ashamael: I don't think I win if I don't
[11:46:26] Ashamael casts [Demonic Consultation].
[11:46:27] [CHAT] thundershot899: 6/37
[11:46:33] Ashamael names Pull from Eternity for [Demonic Consultation].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Plains].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Scoured Barrens].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Recurring Nightmare].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Plains].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Linvala, the Preserver].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Angel of Despair].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Plains].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Plains].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Scoured Barrens].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Heir of Falkenrath].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Plains].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Swamp].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Bygone Bishop].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Scoured Barrens].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Stormtide Leviathan].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Demonic Consultation].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Heir of Falkenrath].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Parallax Wave].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Bygone Bishop].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Heir of Falkenrath].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Swamp].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Swamp].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Eternal Scourge].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Swamp].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Plains].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Swamp].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Bygone Bishop].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Serra Avenger].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Parallax Wave].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Recurring Nightmare].
[11:46:33] Ashamael reveals [Swamp].
[11:46:33] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Heir of Falkenrath[sU] has a Advantageous bug.
If Heir of Falkenrath's ability is used to transform it into Heir to the Night, then it transforms back into Heir of Falkenrath in the same turn in some way, its activated ability can be used again.

[11:46:36] [CHAT] Ashamael: unlucky
[11:46:48] [CHAT] thundershot899: go for for the leviathan?
[11:46:58] [CHAT] Ashamael: pull from eternity
[11:46:59] [CHAT] thundershot899: oh pull
[11:47:02] [CHAT] Ashamael: to get yosei back
[11:47:04] [CHAT] thundershot899: yeah
[11:47:06] [CHAT] Ashamael: or leviathan
[11:47:08] Ashamael has conceded from the game.
Winner: thundershot899
Game 1 Completed.
[11:47:13] thundershot899 has left the game.

== Game 2 (625746556) ==
[11:47:51] PDBot has started watching.
[11:47:52] [CHAT] thundershot899: no risk no reward
[11:47:55] [CHAT] thundershot899: I agree with going for it
[11:47:55] Ashamael chooses to play first.
[11:48:01] Ashamael keeps this hand.
[11:48:10] thundershot899 keeps this hand.
[11:48:10] Turn 1: Ashamael
[11:48:10] Ashamael skips their draw step.
[11:48:12] Ashamael plays [Swamp].
[11:48:15] Turn 1: thundershot899
[11:48:18] thundershot899 plays [Swamp].
[11:48:21] Turn 2: Ashamael
[11:48:24] Ashamael plays [Swamp].
[11:48:26] Ashamael casts [Heir of Falkenrath].
[11:48:33] thundershot899 discards [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:48:33] thundershot899 cycles [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:48:34] Turn 2: thundershot899
[11:48:42] thundershot899 plays [Swamp].
[11:48:46] Turn 3: Ashamael
[11:49:02] thundershot899 is being attacked by [Heir of Falkenrath].
[11:49:12] Ashamael discards [Stormtide Leviathan].
[11:49:12] Ashamael activates an ability of [Heir of Falkenrath] ( Transform Heir of Falkenrath.).
[11:49:23] thundershot899 discards [Archfiend of Ifnir].
[11:49:23] thundershot899 cycles [Archfiend of Ifnir].
[11:49:24] Turn 3: thundershot899
[11:49:28] thundershot899 plays [Island].
[11:49:32] Turn 4: Ashamael
[11:49:35] Ashamael plays [Plains].
[11:49:41] thundershot899 is being attacked by [Heir to the Night].
[11:49:48] Ashamael casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[11:50:14] thundershot899 casts [Demonic Consultation].
[11:50:21] thundershot899 names Syncopate for [Demonic Consultation].
[11:50:21] thundershot899 reveals [Island].
[11:50:21] thundershot899 reveals [Arcane Sanctum].
[11:50:21] thundershot899 reveals [Demonic Consultation].
[11:50:21] thundershot899 reveals [Island].
[11:50:21] thundershot899 reveals [Syncopate].
[11:50:26] thundershot899 casts [Syncopate] targeting [Recurring Nightmare]. (X is 1).
[11:50:36] Turn 4: thundershot899
[11:50:39] thundershot899 plays [Swamp].
[11:50:44] Turn 5: Ashamael
[11:50:54] Ashamael plays [Nomad Outpost].
[11:50:59] thundershot899 is being attacked by [Heir to the Night].
[11:51:08] thundershot899 discards [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:51:08] thundershot899 cycles [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:51:12] thundershot899 discards [Striped Riverwinder].
[11:51:12] thundershot899 cycles [Striped Riverwinder].
[11:51:15] Turn 5: thundershot899
[11:51:18] thundershot899 plays [Swamp].
[11:52:04] Turn 6: Ashamael
[11:52:10] Ashamael plays [Plains].
[11:52:15] thundershot899 is being attacked by [Heir to the Night].
[11:52:38] Ashamael casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[11:53:42] Ashamael activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Stormtide Leviathan] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[11:53:45] thundershot899 casts [Demonic Consultation].
[11:53:53] thundershot899 names Scarab Feast for [Demonic Consultation].
[11:53:53] thundershot899 reveals [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:53:53] thundershot899 reveals [Striped Riverwinder].
[11:53:53] thundershot899 reveals [Syncopate].
[11:53:53] thundershot899 reveals [Arcane Sanctum].
[11:53:53] thundershot899 reveals [Lurching Rotbeast].
[11:53:53] thundershot899 reveals [Lurching Rotbeast].
[11:53:54] thundershot899 reveals [Curator of Mysteries].
[11:53:54] thundershot899 reveals [Curator of Mysteries].
[11:53:54] thundershot899 reveals [Demonic Consultation].
[11:53:54] thundershot899 reveals [Archfiend of Ifnir].
[11:53:54] thundershot899 reveals [Curator of Mysteries].
[11:53:54] thundershot899 reveals [Swamp].
[11:53:54] thundershot899 reveals [Lurching Rotbeast].
[11:53:54] thundershot899 reveals [Arcane Sanctum].
[11:53:54] thundershot899 reveals [Swamp].
[11:53:54] thundershot899 reveals [Syncopate].
[11:53:55] thundershot899 reveals [Scarab Feast].
[11:54:10] thundershot899 casts [Scarab Feast] targeting [Stormtide Leviathan], and [Heir of Falkenrath].
[11:54:50] Ashamael's Recurring Nightmare is countered because it has no legal targets.
[11:54:58] thundershot899 discards [Lurching Rotbeast].
[11:54:58] thundershot899 cycles [Lurching Rotbeast].
[11:55:02] thundershot899 discards [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:55:02] thundershot899 cycles [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:55:06] thundershot899 discards [Curator of Mysteries].
[11:55:06] thundershot899 cycles [Curator of Mysteries].
[11:55:08] Turn 6: thundershot899
[11:55:10] thundershot899 plays [Swamp].
[11:55:15] thundershot899 casts [Living Death].
[11:55:53] Ashamael casts [Scarab Feast] targeting [Striped Riverwinder], [Archfiend of Ifnir], and [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:56:01] Turn 7: Ashamael
[11:56:11] Ashamael casts [Bygone Bishop].
[11:56:19] Turn 7: thundershot899
[11:56:25] Ashamael is being attacked by [Curator of Mysteries], [Lurching Rotbeast], [Horror of the Broken Lands], and [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:56:29] [Bygone Bishop] blocks [Horror of the Broken Lands].
[11:56:44] thundershot899 plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[11:56:47] Turn 8: Ashamael
[11:56:55] [CHAT] Ashamael: man
[11:57:00] [CHAT] Ashamael: I topdeck a second scarab feast
[11:57:04] [CHAT] Ashamael: the turn after you living death
[11:57:06] [CHAT] Ashamael: feelsbad
[11:57:08] [CHAT] Ashamael: gg
[11:57:09] [CHAT] thundershot899: gg
[11:57:12] Ashamael has conceded from the game.
Winner: thundershot899
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: thundershot899: 2–0