PennyDreadful PD R4 vs Ashamael BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney Ashamael,Butterwhale == Game 1 (624985506) == [12:01:01] PDBot has started watching. [12:01:01] Butterwhale joined the game. [Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Mondays 9.01 [Gatherling] Round=4 [12:01:11] Ashamael chooses to play first. [12:01:15] Ashamael keeps this hand. [12:01:19] Butterwhale mulligans to 6 cards. [12:01:21] Butterwhale mulligans to 5 cards. [12:01:24] Butterwhale keeps this hand. [12:01:27] Butterwhale puts 1 card on top of their library. [12:01:27] Turn 1: Ashamael [12:01:27] Ashamael skips their draw step. [12:01:29] Ashamael plays [Scoured Barrens]. [12:01:30] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Scoured Barrens] onto the stack (When Scoured Barrens enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [12:01:32] Turn 1: Butterwhale [12:01:33] Butterwhale plays [Mountain]. [12:01:36] Butterwhale casts [Stromkirk Noble]. [12:01:38] Turn 2: Ashamael [12:01:55] [CHAT] Butterwhale: GLHF [12:02:26] kyosukenoir has started watching. [12:02:59] Ashamael plays [Swamp]. [12:03:03] Ashamael casts [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [12:03:05] Turn 2: Butterwhale [12:03:09] Butterwhale plays [Mountain]. [12:03:15] Butterwhale casts [Burst Lightning] targeting [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [12:03:23] Ashamael is being attacked by [Stromkirk Noble]. [12:03:27] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Stromkirk Noble] onto the stack (Whenever Stromkirk Noble deals combat damage to a player, put a +1/+1 counter on it.). [12:03:30] Turn 3: Ashamael [12:03:47] Ashamael plays [Nomad Outpost]. [12:03:52] Turn 3: Butterwhale [12:03:54] Butterwhale plays [Mountain]. [12:03:57] Butterwhale casts [Scab-Clan Berserker]. [12:03:58] [CHAT] Ashamael: you too [12:04:09] Ashamael casts [Ultimate Price] targeting [Scab-Clan Berserker]. [12:04:13] Ashamael is being attacked by [Stromkirk Noble]. [12:04:16] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Stromkirk Noble] onto the stack (Whenever Stromkirk Noble deals combat damage to a player, put a +1/+1 counter on it.). [12:04:23] Turn 4: Ashamael [12:04:39] Ashamael plays [Swamp]. [12:04:54] Ashamael casts [Parallax Wave]. [12:04:56] Turn 4: Butterwhale [12:05:17] Ashamael activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Stromkirk Noble] ( Exile target creature.). [12:05:24] Butterwhale casts [Rivalry]. [12:05:32] Turn 5: Ashamael [12:05:32] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...). [12:05:32] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Rivalry] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, if that player controls more lands than each other playe...). [12:05:58] Ashamael casts [Vizier of Remedies]. [12:06:01] Ashamael casts [Vizier of Remedies]. [12:06:02] Turn 5: Butterwhale [12:06:05] Butterwhale plays [Mountain]. [12:06:10] Butterwhale casts [Searing Spear] targeting [Vizier of Remedies]. [12:06:15] Ashamael activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Vizier of Remedies] ( Exile target creature.). [12:06:21] Butterwhale's [Searing Spear] is countered because it has no legal targets. [12:06:24] Butterwhale casts [Ankh of Mishra]. [12:06:31] flac0 has started watching. [12:06:33] Turn 6: Ashamael [12:06:33] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...). [12:06:57] Ashamael plays [Swamp]. [12:06:58] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Ankh of Mishra] onto the stack (Whenever a land enters the battlefield, Ankh of Mishra deals 2 damage to that land's controller.). [12:07:12] Ashamael casts [Grim Haruspex]. [12:07:15] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Vizier of Remedies]. [12:07:19] Turn 6: Butterwhale [12:07:24] Butterwhale casts [Village Messenger]. [12:07:33] Turn 7: Ashamael [12:07:33] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...). [12:07:33] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Rivalry] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, if that player controls more lands than each other playe...). [12:07:40] Ashamael casts [Demonic Consultation]. [12:07:50] Ashamael names Murderous Redcap for [Demonic Consultation]. [12:07:50] Ashamael reveals [Recurring Nightmare]. [12:07:50] Ashamael reveals [Cartel Aristocrat]. [12:07:50] Ashamael reveals [Ultimate Price]. [12:07:50] Ashamael reveals [Swamp]. [12:07:50] Ashamael reveals [Vizier of Remedies]. [12:07:50] Ashamael reveals [Swamp]. [12:07:50] Ashamael reveals [Murderous Redcap]. [12:07:57] Ashamael casts [Murderous Redcap]. [12:08:04] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack targeting [Village Messenger] (When Murderous Redcap enters the battlefield, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.). [12:08:14] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Grim Haruspex] and [Vizier of Remedies]. [12:08:21] Turn 7: Butterwhale [12:08:28] Turn 8: Ashamael [12:08:28] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...). [12:08:28] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Rivalry] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, if that player controls more lands than each other playe...). [12:08:32] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (When Parallax Wave leaves the battlefield, each player returns to the battlefield all cards they o...). [12:08:44] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Murderous Redcap], [Grim Haruspex], and [Vizier of Remedies]. [12:08:54] [Stromkirk Noble] blocks [Vizier of Remedies]. [12:08:57] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Grim Haruspex] onto the stack (Whenever another nontoken creature you control dies, draw a card.). [12:08:59] Ashamael draws a card with [Grim Haruspex]'s ability. [12:09:05] Ashamael casts [Recurring Nightmare]. [12:09:14] Ashamael activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Bloodthrone Vampire] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...). [12:09:25] Ashamael activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). [12:09:26] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...). [12:09:31] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack targeting Butterwhale (When Murderous Redcap enters the battlefield, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.). [12:09:38] Ashamael activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). [12:09:38] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...). [12:09:41] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack targeting Butterwhale (When Murderous Redcap enters the battlefield, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.). [12:09:43] Ashamael activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.). [12:09:43] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...). [12:09:45] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack targeting Butterwhale (When Murderous Redcap enters the battlefield, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.). [12:09:47] Butterwhale has conceded from the game. Winner: Ashamael Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (624987862) == [12:10:28] PDBot has started watching. [12:10:33] Butterwhale chooses to play first. [12:10:41] Butterwhale keeps this hand. [12:10:53] Ashamael keeps this hand. [12:10:53] Turn 1: Butterwhale [12:10:53] Butterwhale skips their draw step. [12:10:55] Butterwhale plays [Mountain]. [12:10:57] Butterwhale casts [Village Messenger]. [12:11:06] Ashamael is being attacked by [Village Messenger]. [12:11:09] Turn 1: Ashamael [12:11:13] Ashamael plays [Swamp]. [12:11:16] Ashamael casts [Demonic Consultation]. [12:11:21] Ashamael names Parallax Wave for [Demonic Consultation]. [12:11:21] Ashamael reveals [Vizier of Remedies]. [12:11:21] Ashamael reveals [Carrier Thrall]. [12:11:21] Ashamael reveals [Bygone Bishop]. [12:11:21] Ashamael reveals [Ultimate Price]. [12:11:21] Ashamael reveals [Cartel Aristocrat]. [12:11:21] Ashamael reveals [Plains]. [12:11:21] Ashamael reveals [Swamp]. [12:11:21] Ashamael reveals [Bloodthrone Vampire]. [12:11:21] Ashamael reveals [Parallax Wave]. [12:11:23] Turn 2: Butterwhale [12:11:27] Butterwhale plays [Ramunap Ruins]. [12:11:32] Butterwhale casts [Stromkirk Noble]. [12:11:36] Butterwhale casts [Village Messenger]. [12:11:41] Ashamael is being attacked by [Village Messenger] and [Village Messenger]. [12:11:46] Turn 2: Ashamael [12:11:52] Ashamael plays [Plains]. [12:11:55] Ashamael casts [Lone Missionary]. [12:11:55] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Lone Missionary] onto the stack (When Lone Missionary enters the battlefield, you gain 4 life.). [12:11:57] Turn 3: Butterwhale [12:12:08] Butterwhale casts [Searing Spear] targeting [Lone Missionary]. [12:12:21] Ashamael is being attacked by [Village Messenger], [Stromkirk Noble], and [Village Messenger]. [12:12:23] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Stromkirk Noble] onto the stack (Whenever Stromkirk Noble deals combat damage to a player, put a +1/+1 counter on it.). [12:12:28] Turn 3: Ashamael [12:14:18] Ashamael plays [Nomad Outpost]. [12:14:21] Ashamael casts [Vizier of Remedies]. [12:14:27] Turn 4: Butterwhale [12:14:38] Butterwhale casts [Arc Trail] targeting Ashamael (Choose target creature, planeswalker, or player to deal 2 to), and [Vizier of Remedies] (Choose target creature, planeswalker, or player to deal 1 to). [12:14:48] Ashamael is being attacked by [Village Messenger], [Stromkirk Noble], and [Village Messenger]. [12:14:51] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Stromkirk Noble] onto the stack (Whenever Stromkirk Noble deals combat damage to a player, put a +1/+1 counter on it.). [12:14:59] Turn 4: Ashamael [12:15:02] Ashamael plays [Plains]. [12:15:06] Ashamael casts [Parallax Wave]. [12:15:14] Turn 5: Butterwhale [12:15:26] Ashamael is being attacked by [Village Messenger], [Stromkirk Noble], and [Village Messenger]. [12:15:29] Ashamael activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Stromkirk Noble] ( Exile target creature.). [12:15:34] Ashamael activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Village Messenger] ( Exile target creature.). [12:16:29] Turn 5: Ashamael [12:16:29] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...). [12:16:29] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Village Messenger] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Village Messenger.). [12:16:41] [CHAT] kyosukenoir: !record [12:16:41] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Record: Ashamael 1-0 Butterwhale [12:16:44] Ashamael plays [Scoured Barrens]. [12:16:44] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Scoured Barrens] onto the stack (When Scoured Barrens enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [12:17:13] Turn 6: Butterwhale [12:17:23] Ashamael is being attacked by [Moonrise Intruder]. [12:17:27] Ashamael activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Moonrise Intruder] ( Exile target creature.). [12:17:36] Turn 6: Ashamael [12:17:36] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...). [12:17:43] Ashamael plays [Nomad Outpost]. [12:17:47] Ashamael casts [Demonic Consultation]. [12:18:20] Ashamael names Murderous Redcap for [Demonic Consultation]. [12:18:20] Ashamael reveals [Swamp]. [12:18:20] Ashamael reveals [Swamp]. [12:18:20] Ashamael reveals [Lone Missionary]. [12:18:20] Ashamael reveals [Scoured Barrens]. [12:18:20] Ashamael reveals [Demonic Consultation]. [12:18:20] Ashamael reveals [Swamp]. [12:18:20] Ashamael reveals [Plains]. [12:18:20] Ashamael reveals [Vizier of Remedies]. [12:18:20] Ashamael reveals [Murderous Redcap]. [12:18:25] [CHAT] Ashamael: ah [12:18:28] [CHAT] Ashamael: punted a bit there [12:18:29] Turn 7: Butterwhale [12:18:39] Butterwhale casts [Rakdos Cackler]. [12:18:48] Turn 7: Ashamael [12:18:48] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...). [12:18:49] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (When Parallax Wave leaves the battlefield, each player returns to the battlefield all cards they o...). [12:19:15] Ashamael casts [Murderous Redcap]. [12:19:22] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack targeting [Rakdos Cackler] (When Murderous Redcap enters the battlefield, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.). [12:19:28] Turn 8: Butterwhale [12:19:43] Ashamael is being attacked by [Stromkirk Noble], [Village Messenger], and [Village Messenger]. [12:19:51] [Murderous Redcap] blocks [Village Messenger]. [12:19:57] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Stromkirk Noble] onto the stack (Whenever Stromkirk Noble deals combat damage to a player, put a +1/+1 counter on it.). [12:20:10] Butterwhale casts [Demonfire] targeting [Murderous Redcap]. (X is 1). [12:20:20] Turn 8: Ashamael [12:20:31] Ashamael casts [Murderous Redcap]. [12:20:36] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Murderous Redcap] onto the stack targeting [Stromkirk Noble] (When Murderous Redcap enters the battlefield, it deals damage equal to its power to any target.). [12:20:42] Ashamael plays [Plains]. [12:20:50] Turn 9: Butterwhale [12:20:53] Butterwhale plays [Sunscorched Desert]. [12:20:56] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Sunscorched Desert] onto the stack targeting Ashamael (When Sunscorched Desert enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker...). [12:21:37] Butterwhale casts [Stormblood Berserker]. [12:21:48] Turn 9: Ashamael [12:21:50] Monkeryz has started watching. [12:21:53] Ashamael casts [Parallax Wave]. [12:21:57] Ashamael activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Stormblood Berserker] ( Exile target creature.). [12:21:59] Ashamael activates an ability of [Parallax Wave] targeting [Village Messenger] ( Exile target creature.). [12:22:03] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Murderous Redcap]. [12:22:09] Turn 10: Butterwhale [12:22:15] Butterwhale casts [Rivalry]. [12:22:23] Turn 10: Ashamael [12:22:23] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...). [12:22:23] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Rivalry] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, if that player controls more lands than each other playe...). [12:22:35] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Murderous Redcap]. [12:22:40] Turn 11: Butterwhale [12:22:48] Butterwhale casts [Firebrand Archer]. [12:22:59] Ashamael casts [Ultimate Price] targeting [Firebrand Archer]. [12:23:03] Turn 11: Ashamael [12:23:03] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...). [12:23:04] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Rivalry] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, if that player controls more lands than each other playe...). [12:23:13] Ashamael plays [Scoured Barrens]. [12:23:13] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Scoured Barrens] onto the stack (When Scoured Barrens enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [12:23:28] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Murderous Redcap]. [12:23:32] Turn 12: Butterwhale [12:23:34] Butterwhale plays [Sunscorched Desert]. [12:23:37] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Sunscorched Desert] onto the stack targeting Ashamael (When Sunscorched Desert enters the battlefield, it deals 1 damage to target player or planeswalker...). [12:23:46] Butterwhale casts [Disorder]. [12:23:59] [CHAT] Butterwhale: lol [12:24:03] [CHAT] Ashamael: uh [12:24:04] [CHAT] Butterwhale: That didn't... I can't read [12:24:09] [CHAT] Ashamael: hahaha [12:24:20] Turn 12: Ashamael [12:24:20] Ashamael puts triggered ability from [Parallax Wave] onto the stack (Fading 5 (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a fade counter from this card. If you can't, s...). [12:24:20] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Rivalry] onto the stack (At the beginning of each player's upkeep, if that player controls more lands than each other playe...). [12:24:55] [CHAT] Ashamael: hm [12:25:01] [CHAT] Ashamael: I think I have to go for the 50/50 here now [12:25:04] [CHAT] Ashamael: wish me luck [12:25:06] Ashamael casts [Demonic Consultation]. [12:25:11] Ashamael names Recurring Nightmare for [Demonic Consultation]. [12:25:11] Ashamael reveals [Swamp]. [12:25:11] Ashamael reveals [Swamp]. [12:25:11] Ashamael reveals [Swamp]. [12:25:11] Ashamael reveals [Ultimate Price]. [12:25:11] Ashamael reveals [Cartel Aristocrat]. [12:25:11] [CHAT] Butterwhale: No luck