PennyDreadful
pd
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
JayceArveduin,Butterwhale

== Game 1 (624757114) ==
[15:14:59] PDBot has started watching.
[League] Host doesn't have active run
[15:15:06] JayceArveduin chooses to play first.
[15:15:19] JayceArveduin keeps this hand.
[15:15:30] Butterwhale keeps this hand.
[15:15:30] Turn 1: JayceArveduin
[15:15:30] JayceArveduin skips their draw step.
[15:15:36] JayceArveduin plays [Woodland Stream].
[15:15:41] Turn 1: Butterwhale
[15:15:42] Butterwhale plays [Plains].
[15:15:44] Butterwhale casts [Loam Lion].
[15:15:56] Turn 2: JayceArveduin
[15:15:59] JayceArveduin plays [Forest].
[15:16:05] JayceArveduin casts [Palace Familiar].
[15:16:13] Turn 2: Butterwhale
[15:16:24] Turn 3: JayceArveduin
[15:16:27] JayceArveduin casts [Viridian Emissary].
[15:16:34] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Needlessly greedy hand is punished. 
[15:16:45] Turn 3: Butterwhale
[15:17:00] Butterwhale discards [Bygone Bishop].
[15:17:00] Turn 4: JayceArveduin
[15:17:08] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Viridian Emissary].
[15:17:26] Turn 4: Butterwhale
[15:17:28] Butterwhale plays [Plains].
[15:17:37] Turn 5: JayceArveduin
[15:17:54] [CHAT] JayceArveduin: sadly I'm not fairing much better
[15:17:57] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Viridian Emissary].
[15:18:05] Turn 5: Butterwhale
[15:18:17] Butterwhale discards [Spear of Heliod].
[15:18:17] Turn 6: JayceArveduin
[15:18:27] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Viridian Emissary].
[15:18:33] JayceArveduin discards [Nekrataal].
[15:18:33] Turn 6: Butterwhale
[15:18:42] Butterwhale discards [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[15:18:42] Turn 7: JayceArveduin
[15:18:50] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Sad game is sad
[15:18:54] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Viridian Emissary].
[15:18:58] [CHAT] Butterwhale: At least you get in some beats
[15:19:04] JayceArveduin casts [Sidisi's Faithful].
[15:19:06] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Sidisi's Faithful] onto the stack (Exploit (When this creature enters the battlefield, you may sacrifice a creature.)).
[15:19:06] [CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Sidisi's Faithful[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
[15:19:09] JayceArveduin sacrifices [Viridian Emissary].
[15:19:10] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Viridian Emissary] onto the stack (When Viridian Emissary dies, you may search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the ba...).
[15:19:13] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Sidisi's Faithful] onto the stack targeting [Loam Lion] (When Sidisi's Faithful exploits a creature, return target creature to its owner's hand.).
[15:19:16] JayceArveduin returns [Loam Lion] to its owner's hand with [Sidisi's Faithful]'s ability.
[15:19:23] Turn 7: Butterwhale
[15:19:27] Butterwhale plays [Selesnya Guildgate].
[15:19:29] Butterwhale casts [Loam Lion].
[15:19:31] [CHAT] JayceArveduin: wait, that rotated? oops
[15:19:37] Turn 8: JayceArveduin
[15:19:51] JayceArveduin casts [Filigree Familiar].
[15:19:52] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Using a previous list?
[15:19:53] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar enters the battlefield, you gain 2 life.).
[15:20:00] [CHAT] JayceArveduin: yeah, thought I got all the old bits out
[15:20:09] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Palace Familiar].
[15:20:18] Turn 8: Butterwhale
[15:20:20] Butterwhale plays [Selesnya Guildgate].
[15:20:35] Butterwhale casts [Steward of Valeron].
[15:20:41] Turn 9: JayceArveduin
[15:20:43] JayceArveduin plays [Island].
[15:20:51] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Filigree Familiar] and [Palace Familiar].
[15:21:08] JayceArveduin casts [Wretched Gryff], emerging from [Filigree Familiar].
[15:21:09] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Wretched Gryff] onto the stack (When you cast this spell, draw a card.).
[15:21:10] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar dies, draw a card.).
[15:21:12] JayceArveduin draws a card with [Filigree Familiar]'s ability.
[15:21:15] JayceArveduin draws a card with [Wretched Gryff]'s ability.
[15:21:25] JayceArveduin discards [Sidisi's Faithful].
[15:21:25] Turn 9: Butterwhale
[15:21:51] Butterwhale casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[15:22:07] Butterwhale casts [Sunblade Elf].
[15:22:11] Butterwhale casts [Spear of Heliod].
[15:22:30] Turn 10: JayceArveduin
[15:22:32] JayceArveduin plays [Foul Orchard].
[15:22:38] JayceArveduin casts [Sultai Charm] targeting [Spear of Heliod] (Destroy target artifact or enchantment.).
[15:22:41] Butterwhale has conceded from the game.
Winner: JayceArveduin
Game 1 Completed.
[15:22:46] Butterwhale has left the game.

== Game 2 (624758684) ==
[15:23:21] PDBot has started watching.
[15:23:23] Butterwhale keeps this hand.
[15:23:32] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Okay lets try to have lands this time
[15:23:35] JayceArveduin keeps this hand.
[15:23:35] Turn 1: Butterwhale
[15:23:35] Butterwhale skips their draw step.
[15:23:36] Butterwhale plays [Plains].
[15:23:38] Butterwhale casts [Loam Lion].
[15:23:53] Turn 1: JayceArveduin
[15:24:08] JayceArveduin plays [Foul Orchard].
[15:24:15] Turn 2: Butterwhale
[15:24:18] Butterwhale plays [Forest].
[15:24:22] Butterwhale casts [Loam Lion].
[15:24:36] Butterwhale casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[15:24:40] JayceArveduin is being attacked by [Loam Lion].
[15:24:43] Turn 2: JayceArveduin
[15:24:45] JayceArveduin plays [Woodland Stream].
[15:24:51] Turn 3: Butterwhale
[15:24:53] Butterwhale plays [Selesnya Guildgate].
[15:24:59] JayceArveduin is being attacked by [Avacyn's Pilgrim], [Loam Lion], and [Loam Lion].
[15:25:03] Butterwhale casts [Fleecemane Lion].
[15:25:04] Turn 3: JayceArveduin
[15:25:07] JayceArveduin plays [Island].
[15:25:11] JayceArveduin casts [Filigree Familiar].
[15:25:14] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar enters the battlefield, you gain 2 life.).
[15:25:24] Turn 4: Butterwhale
[15:25:25] Butterwhale plays [Plains].
[15:25:29] Butterwhale casts [Banisher Priest].
[15:25:34] Butterwhale puts triggered ability from [Banisher Priest] onto the stack targeting [Filigree Familiar] (When Banisher Priest enters the battlefield, exile target creature an opponent controls until Bani...).
[15:25:39] JayceArveduin is being attacked by [Fleecemane Lion], [Avacyn's Pilgrim], [Loam Lion], and [Loam Lion].
[15:25:46] Turn 4: JayceArveduin
[15:25:48] JayceArveduin plays [Forest].
[15:25:55] JayceArveduin casts [Filigree Familiar].
[15:25:55] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar enters the battlefield, you gain 2 life.).
[15:26:00] Turn 5: Butterwhale
[15:26:02] Butterwhale plays [Forest].
[15:26:10] Butterwhale activates an ability of [Fleecemane Lion] ( Monstrosity 1.).
[15:26:20] JayceArveduin is being attacked by [Fleecemane Lion], [Loam Lion], and [Loam Lion].
[15:26:33] Turn 5: JayceArveduin
[15:26:43] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Filigree Familiar].
[15:26:51] Turn 6: Butterwhale
[15:27:02] JayceArveduin casts [Elder Deep-Fiend], emerging from [Filigree Familiar].
[15:27:06] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Elder Deep-Fiend] onto the stack targeting [Banisher Priest], [Avacyn's Pilgrim], [Loam Lion], and [Loam Lion] (When you cast this spell, tap up to 4 target permanents.).
[15:27:07] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar dies, draw a card.).
[15:27:10] [CHAT] Butterwhale: I love elder deep fiend
[15:27:13] JayceArveduin draws a card with [Filigree Familiar]'s ability.
[15:27:22] [CHAT] JayceArveduin: it's nice to get to actually use it now, lol
[15:27:29] Butterwhale plays [Plains].
[15:27:33] Butterwhale casts [Watchwolf].
[15:27:39] Turn 6: JayceArveduin
[15:27:42] JayceArveduin plays [Woodland Stream].
[15:27:47] [CHAT] Butterwhale: There was a point in standard where he was being used right?
[15:27:57] [CHAT] JayceArveduin: eyup
[15:28:01] [CHAT] JayceArveduin: that's why I couldn't run it, lol
[15:28:14] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Oh, yeah.
[15:28:20] Turn 7: Butterwhale
[15:28:29] Butterwhale casts [Banisher Priest].
[15:28:35] JayceArveduin has conceded from the game.
Winner: Butterwhale
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (624759670) ==
[15:28:51] PDBot has started watching.
[15:29:01] JayceArveduin chooses to play first.
[15:29:16] JayceArveduin mulligans to 6 cards.
[15:29:17] Butterwhale keeps this hand.
[15:29:20] JayceArveduin keeps this hand.
[15:29:22] JayceArveduin puts 1 card on top of their library.
[15:29:22] Turn 1: JayceArveduin
[15:29:22] JayceArveduin skips their draw step.
[15:29:24] JayceArveduin plays [Foul Orchard].
[15:29:29] Turn 1: Butterwhale
[15:29:37] Butterwhale plays [Plains].
[15:29:39] Butterwhale casts [Loam Lion].
[15:29:41] Turn 2: JayceArveduin
[15:29:56] JayceArveduin plays [Island].
[15:29:59] JayceArveduin casts [Palace Familiar].
[15:30:04] Turn 2: Butterwhale
[15:30:23] Butterwhale plays [Forest].
[15:30:30] JayceArveduin is being attacked by [Loam Lion].
[15:30:42] Butterwhale casts [Fleecemane Lion].
[15:30:43] Turn 3: JayceArveduin
[15:30:45] JayceArveduin plays [Swamp].
[15:30:49] JayceArveduin casts [Foul Emissary].
[15:30:51] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When Foul Emissary enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library. You may rev...).
[15:30:55] JayceArveduin puts [Distended Mindbender] into their hand with with [Foul Emissary]'s ability.
[15:30:56] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Distended Mindbender[sU] has a Graphical bug.
When only some cards from an opponent's hand are revealed, they do not appear in the revealed zone

[15:31:09] Turn 3: Butterwhale
[15:31:20] Butterwhale plays [Forest].
[15:31:29] JayceArveduin is being attacked by [Fleecemane Lion] and [Loam Lion].
[15:31:39] [Palace Familiar] blocks [Fleecemane Lion].
[15:31:55] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Palace Familiar] onto the stack (When Palace Familiar dies, draw a card.).
[15:31:58] JayceArveduin draws a card with [Palace Familiar]'s ability.
[15:32:12] Butterwhale casts [Steward of Valeron].
[15:32:15] Turn 4: JayceArveduin
[15:32:20] JayceArveduin plays [Swamp].
[15:32:28] JayceArveduin casts [Distended Mindbender], emerging from [Foul Emissary].
[15:32:30] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When you sacrifice Foul Emissary while casting a spell with emerge, create a 3/2 colorless Eldrazi...).
[15:32:30] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Distended Mindbender] onto the stack targeting Butterwhale (When you cast this spell, target opponent reveals their hand. You choose from it a nonland card wi...).
[15:32:42] Butterwhale discards [Selesnya Charm].
[15:32:42] Butterwhale discards [Selesnya Charm] to [Distended Mindbender]'s ability.
[15:32:46] JayceArveduin's [Foul Emissary] creates an Eldrazi Horror token.
[15:32:55] Turn 4: Butterwhale
[15:33:05] Butterwhale plays [Plains].
[15:33:09] Butterwhale activates an ability of [Fleecemane Lion] ( Monstrosity 1.).
[15:33:13] Turn 5: JayceArveduin
[15:33:17] JayceArveduin plays [Foul Orchard].
[15:33:34] Turn 5: Butterwhale
[15:33:43] Butterwhale plays [Forest].
[15:33:50] Butterwhale activates an ability of [Fleecemane Lion] ( Monstrosity 1.).
[15:34:03] [CHAT] Butterwhale: That won't add more counters?
[15:34:05] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Well... damn
[15:34:20] [CHAT] Butterwhale: If creature isn't monsterous
[15:34:24] [CHAT] Butterwhale: I need to learn to read
[15:34:27] Butterwhale casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim].
[15:34:48] JayceArveduin casts [Sultai Charm] (Draw two cards, then discard a card.).
[15:34:53] JayceArveduin draws two cards with [Sultai Charm].
[15:34:55] JayceArveduin discards [Swamp].
[15:34:57] Turn 6: JayceArveduin
[15:35:06] JayceArveduin casts [Youthful Scholar].
[15:35:15] Turn 6: Butterwhale
[15:35:18] Butterwhale plays [Selesnya Guildgate].
[15:35:45] Turn 7: JayceArveduin
[15:35:52] JayceArveduin casts [Filigree Familiar].
[15:35:53] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar enters the battlefield, you gain 2 life.).
[15:35:58] JayceArveduin casts [Viridian Emissary].
[15:36:05] Turn 7: Butterwhale
[15:36:24] Butterwhale casts [Advent of the Wurm].
[15:36:27] Butterwhale's [Advent of the Wurm] creates a Wurm token.
[15:36:28] Butterwhale plays [Selesnya Guildgate].
[15:36:55] Turn 8: JayceArveduin
[15:37:02] JayceArveduin casts [Nekrataal].
[15:37:08] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Nekrataal] onto the stack targeting [Wurm] token (When Nekrataal enters the battlefield, destroy target nonartifact, nonblack creature. That creatur...).
[15:37:20] Turn 8: Butterwhale
[15:37:29] Butterwhale plays [Forest].
[15:37:38] Turn 9: JayceArveduin
[15:37:44] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Hm. Well, I like your deck. Glad this isn't part of my league
[15:37:48] JayceArveduin casts [Wretched Gryff], emerging from [Youthful Scholar].
[15:37:50] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Youthful Scholar] onto the stack (When Youthful Scholar dies, draw two cards.).
[15:37:50] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Wretched Gryff] onto the stack (When you cast this spell, draw a card.).
[15:37:53] JayceArveduin draws a card with [Wretched Gryff]'s ability.
[15:37:56] [CHAT] JayceArveduin: lol
[15:38:08] JayceArveduin draws two cards with [Youthful Scholar]'s ability.
[15:38:12] [CHAT] JayceArveduin: don't worry, it's much worse, power wise, than recurring nightmares
[15:38:18] JayceArveduin plays [Swamp].
[15:38:25] JayceArveduin casts [Filigree Familiar].
[15:38:25] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Thankfully i haven't run into one of those.
[15:38:37] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Unfortunately its so popular i couldn't get my copies from card hoarder
[15:38:39] [CHAT] JayceArveduin: I did earlier, hundreds of redcaps per turns /qq
[15:38:39] [CHAT] Butterwhale: I am searching elsewhere
[15:38:45] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar enters the battlefield, you gain 2 life.).
[15:39:56] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Reanimator stuff has always been my true loves
[15:39:57] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Reanimator and dredge
[15:40:01] [CHAT] Butterwhale: My bae
[15:40:01] Turn 9: Butterwhale
[15:40:02] Butterwhale plays [Selesnya Guildgate].
[15:40:02] Turn 10: JayceArveduin
[15:40:03] [CHAT] JayceArveduin: phew, I take it animate dead rotated?
[15:40:04] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Wretched Gryff].
[15:40:06] [CHAT] Butterwhale: I dunno, haven't seen one in any of the recent lists as I browsed
[15:40:15] [CHAT] JayceArveduin: then it prolly has, deck was too good not to play
[15:40:23] JayceArveduin casts [Youthful Scholar].
[15:40:34] Turn 10: Butterwhale
[15:41:26] JayceArveduin is being attacked by [Fleecemane Lion].
[15:41:31] [Filigree Familiar] blocks [Fleecemane Lion].
[15:41:39] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar dies, draw a card.).
[15:41:39] JayceArveduin draws a card with [Filigree Familiar]'s ability.
[15:41:42] Butterwhale plays [Plains].
[15:41:43] Turn 11: JayceArveduin
[15:41:45] JayceArveduin plays [Woodland Stream].
[15:41:53] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Wretched Gryff].
[15:42:06] JayceArveduin casts [Wretched Gryff], emerging from [Youthful Scholar].
[15:42:08] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Youthful Scholar] onto the stack (When Youthful Scholar dies, draw two cards.).
[15:42:08] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Wretched Gryff] onto the stack (When you cast this spell, draw a card.).
[15:42:09] JayceArveduin draws a card with [Wretched Gryff]'s ability.
[15:42:10] JayceArveduin draws two cards with [Youthful Scholar]'s ability.
[15:42:19] JayceArveduin casts [Foul Emissary].
[15:42:21] JayceArveduin puts triggered ability from [Foul Emissary] onto the stack (When Foul Emissary enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library. You may rev...).
[15:42:27] JayceArveduin puts [Distended Mindbender] into their hand with with [Foul Emissary]'s ability.
[15:42:39] [CHAT] Butterwhale: Yeahhh. I can't beat this kind of value engine without a great start
[15:42:41] Turn 11: Butterwhale
[15:43:22] Butterwhale casts [Steward of Valeron].
[15:43:36] Turn 12: JayceArveduin
[15:43:47] Butterwhale is being attacked by [Wretched Gryff] and [Wretched Gryff].
[15:43:50] Butterwhale has conceded from the game.
Winner: JayceArveduin
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: JayceArveduin: 2–1
[15:43:57] Butterwhale has left the game.