PennyDreadful
PDS R2 vs shadow438
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
shadow438,J000111

== Game 1 (624593556) ==
[04:34:51] PDBot has started watching.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 9.01
[Gatherling] Round=2
[04:34:56] [CHAT] J000111: GLHF :)
[04:35:01] shadow438 chooses to play first.
[04:35:02] shadow438 mulligans to 6 cards.
[04:35:05] J000111 keeps this hand.
[04:35:10] [CHAT] shadow438: gl
[04:35:11] shadow438 mulligans to 5 cards.
[04:35:13] shadow438 keeps this hand.
[04:35:16] shadow438 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[04:35:16] Turn 1: shadow438
[04:35:16] shadow438 skips their draw step.
[04:35:21] Turn 1: J000111
[04:35:26] [CHAT] J000111: uhh
[04:35:26] [CHAT] shadow438: well then
[04:35:27] J000111 plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[04:35:29] Turn 2: shadow438
[04:35:31] [CHAT] shadow438: i clicked on swamp
[04:35:31] [CHAT] shadow438: nothing
[04:35:33] shadow438 plays [Swamp].
[04:35:34] [CHAT] J000111: oh dear
[04:35:37] Turn 2: J000111
[04:35:40] J000111 plays [Swamp].
[04:35:42] [CHAT] shadow438: love me some lag
[04:35:43] J000111 casts [Merfolk Looter].
[04:35:46] Turn 3: shadow438
[04:35:51] [CHAT] J000111: are you also australian or something
[04:35:53] Turn 3: J000111
[04:35:57] [CHAT] shadow438: nah
[04:36:03] [CHAT] J000111: alt excuse: !quality
[04:36:06] J000111 activates an ability of [Merfolk Looter] ( Draw a card, then discard a card.).
[04:36:06] J000111 draws a card with [Merfolk Looter]'s ability.
[04:36:12] J000111 discards [Heir of Falkenrath].
[04:36:13] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Heir of Falkenrath[sU] has a Advantageous bug.
If Heir of Falkenrath's ability is used to transform it into Heir to the Night, then it transforms back into Heir of Falkenrath in the same turn in some way, its activated ability can be used again.

[04:36:13] J000111 plays [Swamp].
[04:36:17] J000111 casts [Filigree Familiar].
[04:36:17] J000111 puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar enters the battlefield, you gain 2 life.).
[04:36:18] Turn 4: shadow438
[04:36:21] shadow438 plays [Foul Orchard].
[04:36:25] Turn 4: J000111
[04:36:32] shadow438 is being attacked by [Filigree Familiar].
[04:36:41] J000111 activates an ability of [Merfolk Looter] ( Draw a card, then discard a card.).
[04:36:42] J000111 draws a card with [Merfolk Looter]'s ability.
[04:36:46] J000111 discards [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:36:52] J000111 casts [Filigree Familiar].
[04:36:52] J000111 puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar enters the battlefield, you gain 2 life.).
[04:36:54] Turn 5: shadow438
[04:36:58] shadow438 plays [Foul Orchard].
[04:36:59] shadow438 casts [Sylvan Ranger].
[04:36:59] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...).
[04:37:08] shadow438 reveals [Plains].
[04:37:08] Turn 5: J000111
[04:37:13] shadow438 is being attacked by [Filigree Familiar] and [Filigree Familiar].
[04:37:36] [Sylvan Ranger] blocks [Filigree Familiar].
[04:37:41] J000111 plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[04:37:46] Turn 6: shadow438
[04:37:48] shadow438 plays [Plains].
[04:37:51] shadow438 casts [Centaur Healer].
[04:37:53] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Centaur Healer] onto the stack (When Centaur Healer enters the battlefield, you gain 3 life.).
[04:38:06] shadow438 casts [Vessel of Nascency].
[04:38:15] J000111 casts [Demonic Consultation].
[04:38:20] J000111 names Angel of Despair for [Demonic Consultation].
[04:38:20] J000111 reveals [Thought Courier].
[04:38:20] J000111 reveals [Swamp].
[04:38:21] J000111 reveals [Demonic Consultation].
[04:38:21] J000111 reveals [Merfolk Looter].
[04:38:21] J000111 reveals [Angel of Despair].
[04:38:26] J000111 activates an ability of [Merfolk Looter] ( Draw a card, then discard a card.).
[04:38:26] J000111 draws a card with [Merfolk Looter]'s ability.
[04:38:27] J000111 discards [Angel of Despair].
[04:38:28] Turn 6: J000111
[04:38:38] J000111 plays [Island].
[04:38:40] J000111 casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:38:44] J000111 activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Angel of Despair] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[04:38:44] J000111 puts triggered ability from [Filigree Familiar] onto the stack (When Filigree Familiar dies, draw a card.).
[04:38:48] J000111 draws a card with [Filigree Familiar]'s ability.
[04:38:55] J000111 puts triggered ability from [Angel of Despair] onto the stack targeting [Plains] (When Angel of Despair enters the battlefield, destroy target permanent.).
[04:39:06] J000111 casts [Heir of Falkenrath].
[04:39:13] Turn 7: shadow438
[04:39:19] shadow438 has conceded from the game.
Winner: J000111
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (624594974) ==
[04:39:49] PDBot has started watching.
[04:40:01] shadow438 chooses to play first.
[04:40:04] shadow438 keeps this hand.
[04:40:15] J000111 keeps this hand.
[04:40:15] Turn 1: shadow438
[04:40:15] shadow438 skips their draw step.
[04:40:18] shadow438 plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[04:40:21] Turn 1: J000111
[04:40:23] J000111 plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[04:40:24] Turn 2: shadow438
[04:40:29] shadow438 plays [Forest].
[04:40:31] shadow438 casts [Sylvan Ranger].
[04:40:31] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...).
[04:40:36] shadow438 reveals [Plains].
[04:40:36] Turn 2: J000111
[04:40:39] J000111 plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[04:40:41] Turn 3: shadow438
[04:40:44] shadow438 casts [Vessel of Nascency].
[04:40:47] shadow438 plays [Plains].
[04:40:50] shadow438 activates an ability of [Vessel of Nascency] ( Reveal the top four cards of your library. You may put an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, ...).
[04:40:51] shadow438 reveals 4 cards with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability: [Fleecemane Lion], [Lay Bare the Heart], [Fleecemane Lion], and [Wingmate Roc].
[04:40:57] shadow438 puts [Fleecemane Lion] into their hand with with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability.
[04:40:57] shadow438 puts [Wingmate Roc], [Fleecemane Lion], and [Lay Bare the Heart] into their graveyard.
[04:41:10] J000111 is being attacked by [Sylvan Ranger].
[04:41:18] J000111 discards [Striped Riverwinder].
[04:41:18] J000111 cycles [Striped Riverwinder].
[04:41:19] Turn 3: J000111
[04:41:25] J000111 plays [Swamp].
[04:41:26] Turn 4: shadow438
[04:41:32] shadow438 plays [Forest].
[04:41:42] J000111 is being attacked by [Sylvan Ranger].
[04:41:48] shadow438 casts [Abzan Charm] (You draw two cards and you lose 2 life.).
[04:41:48] shadow438 draws two cards with [Abzan Charm].
[04:41:50] shadow438 casts [Thran Foundry].
[04:41:51] Turn 4: J000111
[04:41:57] J000111 plays [Swamp].
[04:42:01] Turn 5: shadow438
[04:42:19] shadow438 casts [Vessel of Nascency].
[04:42:45] shadow438 casts [Abzan Charm] (You draw two cards and you lose 2 life.).
[04:42:47] shadow438 draws two cards with [Abzan Charm].
[04:42:49] shadow438 plays [Scoured Barrens].
[04:42:49] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Scoured Barrens] onto the stack (When Scoured Barrens enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[04:42:53] J000111 is being attacked by [Sylvan Ranger].
[04:43:01] J000111 casts [Fact or Fiction].
[04:43:35] J000111 puts [Alhammarret, High Arbiter], [Recurring Nightmare] into their hand with [Fact or Fiction].
[04:43:35] J000111 puts [Arcane Sanctum], [Demonic Consultation], [Fact or Fiction] into their graveyard.
[04:43:38] Turn 5: J000111
[04:43:40] J000111 plays [Island].
[04:43:50] J000111 casts [Corpse Connoisseur].
[04:43:50] J000111 puts triggered ability from [Corpse Connoisseur] onto the stack (When Corpse Connoisseur enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a creature card an...).
[04:44:15] Turn 6: shadow438
[04:44:41] shadow438 plays [Foul Orchard].
[04:44:45] shadow438 casts [Fleecemane Lion].
[04:44:47] shadow438 casts [Fleecemane Lion].
[04:44:52] Turn 6: J000111
[04:45:09] J000111 casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:45:17] J000111 activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Angel of Despair] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[04:45:21] J000111 exiles [Thran Foundry] with [Thran Foundry]'s ability.
[04:45:21] shadow438 activates an ability of [Thran Foundry] targeting J000111 ( Target player shuffles their graveyard into their library.).
[04:45:26] J000111's Recurring Nightmare is countered because it has no legal targets.
[04:45:29] J000111 casts [Merfolk Looter].
[04:45:30] Turn 7: shadow438
[04:45:34] shadow438 plays [Swamp].
[04:45:43] J000111 is being attacked by [Fleecemane Lion], [Fleecemane Lion], and [Sylvan Ranger].
[04:45:53] shadow438 casts [Teneb, the Harvester].
[04:46:01] Turn 7: J000111
[04:46:04] J000111 plays [Swamp].
[04:46:11] J000111 activates an ability of [Merfolk Looter] ( Draw a card, then discard a card.).
[04:46:11] J000111 draws a card with [Merfolk Looter]'s ability.
[04:46:15] J000111 discards [Angel of Despair].
[04:46:22] J000111 casts [Living Death].
[04:46:29] J000111 puts triggered ability from [Angel of Despair] onto the stack targeting [Wingmate Roc] (When Angel of Despair enters the battlefield, destroy target permanent.).
[04:46:35] Turn 8: shadow438
[04:46:36] shadow438 plays [Plains].
[04:46:45] shadow438 casts [Utter End] targeting [Angel of Despair].
[04:46:55] J000111 is being attacked by [Fleecemane Lion].
[04:47:06] shadow438 activates an ability of [Vessel of Nascency] ( Reveal the top four cards of your library. You may put an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, ...).
[04:47:11] shadow438 reveals 4 cards with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability: [Sandsteppe Citadel], [Abzan Charm], [Plains], and [Plains].
[04:47:13] shadow438 puts [Sandsteppe Citadel] into their hand with with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability.
[04:47:13] shadow438 puts [Plains], [Plains], and [Abzan Charm] into their graveyard.
[04:47:26] J000111 casts [Demonic Consultation].
[04:48:33] J000111 names Corpse Connoisseur for [Demonic Consultation].
[04:48:33] J000111 reveals [Corpse Connoisseur].
[04:48:34] Turn 8: J000111
[04:48:34] J000111 plays [Swamp].
[04:48:34] J000111 casts [Corpse Connoisseur].
[04:48:35] J000111 puts triggered ability from [Corpse Connoisseur] onto the stack (When Corpse Connoisseur enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a creature card an...).
[04:48:38] Turn 9: shadow438
[04:48:38] shadow438 plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[04:48:38] shadow438 casts [Thran Foundry].
[04:48:38] J000111 is being attacked by [Fleecemane Lion].
[04:48:47] shadow438 casts [Wingmate Roc].
[04:48:52] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Wingmate Roc] onto the stack (When Wingmate Roc enters the battlefield, if you attacked with a creature this turn, create a 3/4 ...).
[04:48:55] shadow438's [Wingmate Roc] creates a Bird token.
[04:48:56] Turn 9: J000111
[04:49:06] J000111 casts [Alhammarret, High Arbiter].
[04:49:09] shadow438 reveals their hand to [Alhammarret, High Arbiter]'s ability, containing [Utter End].
[04:49:11] J000111 names Utter End.
[04:49:19] Turn 10: shadow438
[04:49:28] shadow438 casts [Whip of Erebos].
[04:49:42] shadow438 activates an ability of [Whip of Erebos] targeting [Teneb, the Harvester] ( Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. It gains haste. Exile it at t...).
[04:49:49] J000111 is being attacked by [Teneb, the Harvester], [Bird] token, [Wingmate Roc], and [Fleecemane Lion].
[04:49:49] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Wingmate Roc] onto the stack (Whenever Wingmate Roc attacks, you gain 1 life for each attacking creature.).
[04:49:56] [Corpse Connoisseur] blocks [Fleecemane Lion].
[04:49:59] [Alhammarret, High Arbiter] blocks [Teneb, the Harvester].
Winner: shadow438
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (624597974) ==
[04:50:39] PDBot has started watching.
[04:50:42] J000111 chooses to play first.
[04:50:46] J000111 keeps this hand.
[04:50:48] shadow438 mulligans to 6 cards.
[04:50:53] shadow438 mulligans to 5 cards.
[04:50:57] shadow438 mulligans to 4 cards.
[04:50:58] shadow438 keeps this hand.
[04:51:01] shadow438 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[04:51:01] Turn 1: J000111
[04:51:03] J000111 skips their draw step.
[04:51:06] J000111 plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[04:51:08] Turn 1: shadow438
[04:51:13] shadow438 plays [Foul Orchard].
[04:51:16] Turn 2: J000111
[04:51:16] Ninjatoga has started watching.
[04:51:18] J000111 plays [Swamp].
[04:51:20] J000111 casts [Thought Courier].
[04:51:21] Turn 2: shadow438
[04:51:38] shadow438 plays [Swamp].
[04:51:40] shadow438 casts [Sylvan Ranger].
[04:51:40] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...).
[04:51:44] shadow438 reveals [Plains].
[04:51:45] Turn 3: J000111
[04:51:51] J000111 activates an ability of [Thought Courier] ( Draw a card, then discard a card.).
[04:51:51] J000111 draws a card with [Thought Courier]'s ability.
[04:51:54] J000111 discards [Angel of Despair].
[04:51:55] J000111 plays [Arcane Sanctum].
[04:51:59] J000111 casts [Sinister Concoction].
[04:52:01] Turn 3: shadow438
[04:52:04] shadow438 plays [Plains].
[04:52:12] shadow438 casts [Abzan Charm] (You draw two cards and you lose 2 life.).
[04:52:14] shadow438 draws two cards with [Abzan Charm].
[04:52:17] J000111 is being attacked by [Sylvan Ranger].
[04:52:18] Turn 4: J000111
[04:52:28] J000111 plays [Swamp].
[04:52:29] Turn 4: shadow438
[04:52:35] shadow438 casts [Sylvan Ranger].
[04:52:37] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...).
[04:52:43] shadow438 reveals [Forest].
[04:52:44] shadow438 plays [Forest].
[04:52:46] shadow438 casts [Sylvan Ranger].
[04:52:47] shadow438 puts triggered ability from [Sylvan Ranger] onto the stack (When Sylvan Ranger enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...).
[04:52:56] shadow438 reveals [Forest].
[04:53:02] J000111 is being attacked by [Sylvan Ranger].
[04:53:14] J000111 casts [Fact or Fiction].
[04:53:20] J000111 puts [Recurring Nightmare] into their hand with [Fact or Fiction].
[04:53:20] J000111 puts [Swamp], [Swamp], [Demonic Consultation], [Filigree Familiar] into their graveyard.
[04:53:23] Turn 5: J000111
[04:53:29] J000111 casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:53:35] J000111 activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Angel of Despair] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[04:53:37] J000111 puts triggered ability from [Angel of Despair] onto the stack targeting [Foul Orchard] (When Angel of Despair enters the battlefield, destroy target permanent.).
[04:53:38] Turn 5: shadow438
[04:53:48] shadow438 plays [Forest].
[04:53:49] shadow438 casts [Vessel of Nascency].
[04:53:53] shadow438 activates an ability of [Vessel of Nascency] ( Reveal the top four cards of your library. You may put an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, ...).
[04:53:54] shadow438 reveals 4 cards with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability: [Vessel of Nascency], [Foul Orchard], [Lay Bare the Heart], and [Lay Bare the Heart].
[04:54:13] shadow438 puts [Vessel of Nascency] into their hand with with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability.
[04:54:13] shadow438 puts [Lay Bare the Heart], [Lay Bare the Heart], and [Foul Orchard] into their graveyard.
[04:54:32] Turn 6: J000111
[04:54:37] shadow438 is being attacked by [Angel of Despair].
[04:54:46] J000111 puts [Heir of Falkenrath] into their graveyard with with [Sinister Concoction]'s ability.
[04:54:51] J000111 discards [Pelakka Wurm].
[04:54:51] J000111 activates an ability of [Sinister Concoction] targeting [Sylvan Ranger] ( Destroy target creature.).
[04:54:56] J000111 casts [Recurring Nightmare].
[04:54:59] J000111 activates an ability of [Recurring Nightmare] targeting [Pelakka Wurm] (Sacrifice a creature, Return Recurring Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card ...).
[04:55:00] J000111 puts triggered ability from [Pelakka Wurm] onto the stack (When Pelakka Wurm enters the battlefield, you gain 7 life.).
[04:55:01] Turn 6: shadow438
[04:55:11] shadow438 plays [Swamp].
[04:55:13] shadow438 casts [Thran Foundry].
[04:55:15] shadow438 casts [Vessel of Nascency].
[04:55:18] shadow438 activates an ability of [Vessel of Nascency] ( Reveal the top four cards of your library. You may put an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, ...).
[04:55:18] shadow438 reveals 4 cards with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability: [Spiritmonger], [Utter End], [Thran Foundry], and [Fleecemane Lion].
[04:55:34] shadow438 puts [Fleecemane Lion] into their hand with with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability.
[04:55:34] shadow438 puts [Spiritmonger], [Utter End], and [Thran Foundry] into their graveyard.
[04:55:41] Turn 7: J000111
[04:55:45] shadow438 is being attacked by [Pelakka Wurm].
[04:55:53] J000111 casts [Merfolk Looter].
[04:55:54] Turn 7: shadow438
[04:55:58] shadow438 plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
[04:56:01] shadow438 casts [Vessel of Nascency].
[04:56:05] shadow438 activates an ability of [Vessel of Nascency] ( Reveal the top four cards of your library. You may put an artifact, creature, enchantment, land, ...).
[04:56:07] shadow438 reveals 4 cards with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability: [Swamp], [Thran Foundry], [Whip of Erebos], and [Magister of Worth].
[04:56:10] shadow438 puts [Magister of Worth] into their hand with with [Vessel of Nascency]'s ability.
[04:56:10] shadow438 puts [Whip of Erebos], [Thran Foundry], and [Swamp] into their graveyard.
[04:56:20] Turn 8: J000111
[04:56:23] [CHAT] shadow438: gg
[04:56:27] [CHAT] J000111: ggs
[04:56:28] Ninjatoga has stopped watching.
[04:56:28] shadow438 has conceded from the game.
Winner: J000111
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: J000111: 2–1