PennyDreadful
PDM R4 vs.DustyJustice
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
nanaiper,DustyJustice

== Game 1 (613084846) ==
[10:55:11] PDBot has started watching.
[10:55:11] nanaiper joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Mondays 8.05
[Gatherling] Round=4
[10:55:18] [CHAT] DustyJustice: Hi! GL/hf
[10:55:18] [CHAT] nanaiper: gl
[10:55:20] nanaiper chooses to play first.
[10:55:24] nanaiper keeps this hand.
[10:55:27] DustyJustice keeps this hand.
[10:55:27] Turn 1: nanaiper
[10:55:28] nanaiper skips their draw step.
[10:55:29] nanaiper plays [Azorius Guildgate].
[10:55:31] Turn 1: DustyJustice
[10:55:35] DustyJustice plays [Opulent Palace].
[10:55:37] Turn 2: nanaiper
[10:55:39] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[10:55:42] nanaiper casts [Gerrard's Verdict] targeting DustyJustice.
[10:55:52] DustyJustice discards [Catacomb Sifter].
[10:55:52] DustyJustice discards [Deathcap Cultivator].
[10:55:52] Turn 2: DustyJustice
[10:55:57] DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
[10:56:06] DustyJustice casts [Deathcap Cultivator].
[10:56:13] Turn 3: nanaiper
[10:56:15] nanaiper plays [Spawning Pool].
[10:56:17] nanaiper casts [Gerrard's Verdict] targeting DustyJustice.
[10:56:23] DustyJustice discards [Prophet of Kruphix].
[10:56:23] DustyJustice discards [Rattleclaw Mystic].
[10:56:23] Turn 3: DustyJustice
[10:56:32] nanaiper is being attacked by [Deathcap Cultivator].
[10:56:37] DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
[10:56:39] DustyJustice casts [Catacomb Sifter].
[10:56:41] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (When Catacomb Sifter enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. ...).
[10:56:42] DustyJustice's [Catacomb Sifter] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[10:56:45] Turn 4: nanaiper
[10:56:51] nanaiper casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting DustyJustice.
[10:56:53] DustyJustice discards [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[10:56:53] DustyJustice reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing no cards.
[10:56:55] Turn 4: DustyJustice
[10:57:00] DustyJustice plays [Opulent Palace].
[10:57:04] nanaiper is being attacked by [Eldrazi Scion] token, [Catacomb Sifter], and [Deathcap Cultivator].
[10:57:08] Turn 5: nanaiper
[10:57:23] nanaiper casts [Murderous Cut] targeting [Catacomb Sifter].
[10:57:26] Turn 5: DustyJustice
[10:57:30] DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
[10:57:34] nanaiper is being attacked by [Eldrazi Scion] token and [Deathcap Cultivator].
[10:57:35] Turn 6: nanaiper
[10:57:43] nanaiper casts [Banishing Light].
[10:57:45] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Banishing Light] onto the stack targeting [Deathcap Cultivator] (When Banishing Light enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent an opponent controls u...).
[10:57:47] Turn 6: DustyJustice
[10:57:54] nanaiper is being attacked by [Eldrazi Scion] token.
[10:58:00] DustyJustice casts [Catacomb Sifter].
[10:58:00] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (When Catacomb Sifter enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. ...).
[10:58:01] DustyJustice's [Catacomb Sifter] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[10:58:01] Turn 7: nanaiper
[10:58:06] nanaiper plays [Crumbling Necropolis].
[10:58:17] Turn 7: DustyJustice
[10:58:26] nanaiper is being attacked by [Eldrazi Scion] token, [Catacomb Sifter], and [Eldrazi Scion] token.
[10:58:33] nanaiper activates an ability of [Spawning Pool] ( Spawning Pool becomes a 1/1 black Skeleton creature with '{B}: Regenerate this creature' until en...).
[10:58:40] [Spawning Pool] blocks [Eldrazi Scion] token.
[10:58:57] nanaiper activates an ability of [Spawning Pool] ( Regenerate this creature.).
[10:59:00] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (Whenever another creature you control dies, scry 1.).
[10:59:06] DustyJustice puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[10:59:13] DustyJustice casts [Wretched Gryff], emerging from [Catacomb Sifter].
[10:59:13] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Wretched Gryff] onto the stack (When you cast this spell, draw a card.).
[10:59:17] DustyJustice draws a card with [Wretched Gryff]'s ability.
[10:59:25] DustyJustice casts [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[10:59:30] Turn 8: nanaiper
[10:59:36] nanaiper casts [Barter in Blood].
[10:59:41] DustyJustice sacrifices [Eldrazi Scion] token.
[10:59:41] DustyJustice sacrifices [Wretched Gryff].
[10:59:44] Turn 8: DustyJustice
[10:59:52] nanaiper is being attacked by [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[10:59:59] DustyJustice activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...).
[11:00:04] DustyJustice puts [Rogue Refiner] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability.
[11:00:06] DustyJustice put a card on the bottom of the library.
[11:00:08] DustyJustice put a card on the bottom of the library.
[11:00:09] Turn 9: nanaiper
[11:00:09] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Duskwatch Recruiter] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Duskwatch Recruiter.).
[11:00:17] nanaiper casts [Wretched Banquet] targeting [Krallenhorde Howler].
[11:00:24] nanaiper casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Swamp].
[11:00:27] Turn 9: DustyJustice
[11:00:44] DustyJustice plays [Forest].
[11:00:47] DustyJustice casts [Rogue Refiner].
[11:00:48] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Rogue Refiner] onto the stack (When Rogue Refiner enters the battlefield, draw a card and you get {EE}.).
[11:00:50] DustyJustice draws a card with [Rogue Refiner]'s ability.
[11:00:50] DustyJustice gains 2 energy from [Rogue Refiner]'s ability.
[11:01:08] DustyJustice casts [Wretched Gryff], emerging from [Rogue Refiner].
[11:01:08] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Wretched Gryff] onto the stack (When you cast this spell, draw a card.).
[11:01:10] DustyJustice draws a card with [Wretched Gryff]'s ability.
[11:01:13] Turn 10: nanaiper
[11:01:19] nanaiper casts [Consuming Vapors] targeting DustyJustice.
[11:01:21] DustyJustice sacrifices [Wretched Gryff].
[11:01:21] Turn 10: DustyJustice
[11:01:25] DustyJustice plays [Grand Coliseum].
[11:01:27] Turn 11: nanaiper
[11:01:27] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Consuming Vapors] onto the stack (Rebound (If you cast this spell from your hand, exile it as it resolves. At the beginning of you...).
[11:01:31] nanaiper casts [Consuming Vapors] targeting DustyJustice.
[11:01:34] nanaiper plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:01:36] nanaiper activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:01:44] nanaiper casts [Haunted Plate Mail].
[11:01:46] Turn 11: DustyJustice
[11:01:54] DustyJustice casts [Wretched Gryff].
[11:01:54] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Wretched Gryff] onto the stack (When you cast this spell, draw a card.).
[11:01:57] DustyJustice draws a card with [Wretched Gryff]'s ability.
[11:01:59] DustyJustice plays [Opulent Palace].
[11:02:01] Turn 12: nanaiper
[11:02:08] nanaiper casts [Demonic Rising].
[11:02:10] nanaiper activates an ability of [Haunted Plate Mail] ( Until end of turn, Haunted Plate Mail becomes a 4/4 Spirit artifact creature that's no longer an ...).
[11:02:13] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Haunted Plate Mail].
[11:02:17] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Demonic Rising] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you control exactly one creature, create a 5/5 black Demon c...).
[11:02:17] nanaiper's [Demonic Rising] creates a Demon token.
[11:02:17] Turn 12: DustyJustice
[11:02:24] DustyJustice casts [Masked Admirers].
[11:02:27] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Masked Admirers] onto the stack (When Masked Admirers enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
[11:02:28] DustyJustice draws a card with [Masked Admirers]'s ability.
[11:02:32] DustyJustice plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:02:34] DustyJustice activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:02:39] DustyJustice casts [Deathcap Cultivator].
[11:02:41] Turn 13: nanaiper
[11:02:48] nanaiper casts [Homicidal Seclusion].
[11:02:51] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Demon] token.
[11:02:56] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Demonic Rising] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you control exactly one creature, create a 5/5 black Demon c...).
[11:02:56] nanaiper's [Demonic Rising] creates a Demon token.
[11:02:58] Turn 13: DustyJustice
[11:03:06] DustyJustice has conceded from the game.
Winner: nanaiper
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (613086924) ==
[11:04:21] PDBot has started watching.
[11:04:25] DustyJustice chooses to play first.
[11:04:28] DustyJustice keeps this hand.
[11:04:29] nanaiper mulligans to 6 cards.
[11:04:33] nanaiper keeps this hand.
[11:04:36] nanaiper puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[11:04:36] Turn 1: DustyJustice
[11:04:38] DustyJustice skips their draw step.
[11:04:39] DustyJustice plays [Opulent Palace].
[11:04:41] Turn 1: nanaiper
[11:04:43] nanaiper plays [Grand Coliseum].
[11:04:45] Turn 2: DustyJustice
[11:05:02] DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
[11:05:05] DustyJustice casts [Deathcap Cultivator].
[11:05:06] Turn 2: nanaiper
[11:05:08] nanaiper plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:05:10] nanaiper activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:05:14] Turn 3: DustyJustice
[11:05:23] DustyJustice casts [Catacomb Sifter].
[11:05:23] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (When Catacomb Sifter enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. ...).
[11:05:25] DustyJustice's [Catacomb Sifter] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[11:05:27] DustyJustice plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:05:29] DustyJustice activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:05:33] Turn 3: nanaiper
[11:05:38] nanaiper casts [Gerrard's Verdict] targeting DustyJustice.
[11:05:42] DustyJustice discards [Conclave Naturalists].
[11:05:42] DustyJustice discards [Deathcap Cultivator].
[11:05:43] Turn 4: DustyJustice
[11:05:54] nanaiper is being attacked by [Eldrazi Scion] token and [Catacomb Sifter].
[11:06:03] DustyJustice casts [Distended Mindbender], emerging from [Catacomb Sifter].
[11:06:03] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Distended Mindbender] onto the stack targeting nanaiper (When you cast this spell, target opponent reveals their hand. You choose from it a nonland card wi...).
[11:06:03] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Distended Mindbender[sU] has a Disadvantageous bug.
When only some cards from an opponent's hand are revealed, they do not appear in the revealed zone

[11:06:47] nanaiper discards [Haunted Plate Mail].
[11:06:47] nanaiper discards [Banishing Light].
[11:06:47] nanaiper discards [Haunted Plate Mail] and [Banishing Light] to [Distended Mindbender]'s ability.
[11:06:49] Turn 4: nanaiper
[11:06:52] nanaiper plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:06:54] nanaiper activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:06:59] Turn 5: DustyJustice
[11:07:06] DustyJustice plays [Forest].
[11:07:12] nanaiper is being attacked by [Distended Mindbender], [Eldrazi Scion] token, and [Deathcap Cultivator].
[11:07:17] DustyJustice casts [Desecration Demon].
[11:07:22] Turn 5: nanaiper
[11:07:26] nanaiper has conceded from the game.
Winner: DustyJustice
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (613087798) ==
[11:07:42] PDBot has started watching.
[11:07:42] nanaiper chooses to play first.
[11:07:47] nanaiper keeps this hand.
[11:07:49] DustyJustice keeps this hand.
[11:07:49] Turn 1: nanaiper
[11:07:50] nanaiper skips their draw step.
[11:07:51] nanaiper plays [Orzhov Guildgate].
[11:07:52] Turn 1: DustyJustice
[11:07:55] DustyJustice plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:07:59] DustyJustice activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:08:08] Turn 2: nanaiper
[11:08:10] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[11:08:14] nanaiper casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting DustyJustice.
[11:08:35] DustyJustice discards [Catacomb Sifter].
[11:08:35] DustyJustice reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Forest], [Duskwatch Recruiter], [Swamp], [Wretched Gryff], [Entomber Exarch], and [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[11:08:41] Turn 2: DustyJustice
[11:08:47] DustyJustice plays [Forest].
[11:08:49] DustyJustice casts [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[11:08:50] Turn 3: nanaiper
[11:08:54] nanaiper plays [Crumbling Necropolis].
[11:08:58] nanaiper casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[11:09:00] Turn 3: DustyJustice
[11:09:02] DustyJustice plays [Opulent Palace].
[11:09:05] DustyJustice casts [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[11:09:06] Turn 4: nanaiper
[11:09:11] nanaiper plays [Spawning Pool].
[11:09:15] nanaiper casts [Banishing Light].
[11:09:15] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Banishing Light] onto the stack targeting [Duskwatch Recruiter] (When Banishing Light enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent an opponent controls u...).
[11:09:18] Turn 4: DustyJustice
[11:09:21] DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
[11:09:25] DustyJustice casts [Entomber Exarch].
[11:09:33] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Entomber Exarch] onto the stack targeting nanaiper (Target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a noncreature card from it. That player discards th...).
[11:09:40] nanaiper discards [Barter in Blood].
[11:09:40] nanaiper reveals their hand to [Entomber Exarch]'s ability, containing [Grand Coliseum] and [Plains].
[11:09:46] Turn 5: nanaiper
[11:09:48] nanaiper plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:09:50] nanaiper activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:09:55] Turn 5: DustyJustice
[11:10:02] DustyJustice casts [Rogue Refiner].
[11:10:03] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Rogue Refiner] onto the stack (When Rogue Refiner enters the battlefield, draw a card and you get {EE}.).
[11:10:06] DustyJustice draws a card with [Rogue Refiner]'s ability.
[11:10:06] DustyJustice gains 2 energy from [Rogue Refiner]'s ability.
[11:10:08] DustyJustice plays [Grand Coliseum].
[11:10:14] Turn 6: nanaiper
[11:10:18] nanaiper plays [Grand Coliseum].
[11:10:23] nanaiper casts [Demonic Rising].
[11:10:24] Turn 6: DustyJustice
[11:10:31] DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
[11:10:36] nanaiper is being attacked by [Rogue Refiner] and [Entomber Exarch].
[11:10:50] DustyJustice casts [Catacomb Sifter].
[11:10:50] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (When Catacomb Sifter enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. ...).
[11:10:53] DustyJustice's [Catacomb Sifter] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[11:10:54] j_meka has started watching.
[11:11:00] DustyJustice casts [Wretched Gryff], emerging from [Rogue Refiner].
[11:11:05] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Wretched Gryff] onto the stack (When you cast this spell, draw a card.).
[11:11:05] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (Whenever another creature you control dies, scry 1.).
[11:11:10] DustyJustice puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[11:11:12] DustyJustice draws a card with [Wretched Gryff]'s ability.
[11:11:14] Turn 7: nanaiper
[11:11:18] nanaiper plays [Plains].
[11:11:23] nanaiper activates an ability of [Spawning Pool] ( Spawning Pool becomes a 1/1 black Skeleton creature with '{B}: Regenerate this creature' until en...).
[11:11:28] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Demonic Rising] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you control exactly one creature, create a 5/5 black Demon c...).
[11:11:29] nanaiper's [Demonic Rising] creates a Demon token.
[11:11:31] Turn 7: DustyJustice
[11:11:34] DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
[11:11:41] DustyJustice casts [Rattleclaw Mystic].
[11:11:47] Turn 8: nanaiper
[11:11:55] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Demon] token.
[11:12:02] nanaiper casts [Banishing Light].
[11:12:06] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Banishing Light] onto the stack targeting [Catacomb Sifter] (When Banishing Light enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent an opponent controls u...).
[11:12:09] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Demonic Rising] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, if you control exactly one creature, create a 5/5 black Demon c...).
[11:12:11] nanaiper's [Demonic Rising] creates a Demon token.
[11:12:12] Turn 8: DustyJustice
[11:12:18] DustyJustice plays [Forest].
[11:12:34] DustyJustice casts [Distended Mindbender].
[11:12:34] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Distended Mindbender] onto the stack targeting nanaiper (When you cast this spell, target opponent reveals their hand. You choose from it a nonland card wi...).
[11:12:48] nanaiper casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Entomber Exarch].
[11:12:59] Turn 9: nanaiper
[11:13:06] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Demon] token and [Demon] token.
[11:13:10] Turn 9: DustyJustice
[11:13:25] nanaiper is being attacked by [Distended Mindbender], [Rattleclaw Mystic], and [Eldrazi Scion] token.
[11:13:29] nanaiper activates an ability of [Spawning Pool] ( Spawning Pool becomes a 1/1 black Skeleton creature with '{B}: Regenerate this creature' until en...).
[11:13:32] [Spawning Pool] blocks [Distended Mindbender].
[11:13:37] nanaiper activates an ability of [Spawning Pool] ( Regenerate this creature.).
[11:13:45] DustyJustice casts [Desecration Demon].
[11:13:53] nanaiper casts [Terror] targeting [Wretched Gryff].
[11:13:55] Turn 10: nanaiper
[11:13:58] DustyJustice has conceded from the game.
Winner: nanaiper
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: nanaiper: 2–1
[11:14:09] nanaiper has left the game.