PennyDreadful
PDS R3 vs. NG4
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
NG4,DustyJustice

== Game 1 (612729076) ==
[04:40:30] PDBot has started watching.
[04:40:30] NG4 joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 8.05
[Gatherling] Round=3
[04:40:40] [CHAT] DustyJustice: Hello! Gl/hf
[04:40:42] [CHAT] NG4: hey, glhf!
[04:40:45] NG4 chooses to play first.
[04:40:51] NG4 keeps this hand.
[04:40:53] DustyJustice mulligans to 6 cards.
[04:40:56] DustyJustice keeps this hand.
[04:41:00] DustyJustice puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[04:41:00] Turn 1: NG4
[04:41:02] NG4 skips their draw step.
[04:41:18] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:41:20] Turn 1: DustyJustice
[04:41:23] DustyJustice plays [Grand Coliseum].
[04:41:35] Turn 2: NG4
[04:41:37] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:41:39] NG4 casts [Consul's Lieutenant].
[04:41:41] Turn 2: DustyJustice
[04:41:43] DustyJustice plays [Forest].
[04:41:46] DustyJustice casts [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[04:41:51] Turn 3: NG4
[04:41:54] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:41:57] NG4 casts [Bygone Bishop].
[04:42:05] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Consul's Lieutenant].
[04:42:06] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Renown 1 (When this creature deals combat damage to a player, if it isn't renowned, put one +1/+...).
[04:42:07] Turn 3: DustyJustice
[04:42:11] DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
[04:42:23] DustyJustice casts [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[04:42:29] Turn 4: NG4
[04:42:33] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:42:35] NG4 casts [Odric, Lunarch Marshal].
[04:42:36] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Odric, Lunarch Marshal] onto the stack (At the beginning of each combat, creatures you control gain first strike until end of turn if a cr...).
[04:42:44] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Bygone Bishop] and [Consul's Lieutenant].
[04:42:44] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Whenever Consul's Lieutenant attacks, if it's renowned, other attacking creatures you control get ...).
[04:42:45] Turn 4: DustyJustice
[04:42:51] DustyJustice plays [Forest].
[04:43:19] DustyJustice casts [Masked Admirers].
[04:43:19] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Masked Admirers] onto the stack (When Masked Admirers enters the battlefield, draw a card.).
[04:43:21] DustyJustice draws a card with [Masked Admirers]'s ability.
[04:43:25] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Odric, Lunarch Marshal] onto the stack (At the beginning of each combat, creatures you control gain first strike until end of turn if a cr...).
[04:43:26] Turn 5: NG4
[04:43:29] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:43:37] NG4 casts [Porcelain Legionnaire].
[04:43:37] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[04:43:40] NG4's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[04:43:44] NG4 casts [Elite Inquisitor].
[04:43:44] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[04:43:44] NG4's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[04:43:46] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Odric, Lunarch Marshal] onto the stack (At the beginning of each combat, creatures you control gain first strike until end of turn if a cr...).
[04:43:52] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Odric, Lunarch Marshal], [Bygone Bishop], and [Consul's Lieutenant].
[04:43:52] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Whenever Consul's Lieutenant attacks, if it's renowned, other attacking creatures you control get ...).
[04:43:54] Turn 5: DustyJustice
[04:44:00] DustyJustice has conceded from the game.
Winner: NG4
Game 1 Completed.
[04:44:05] DustyJustice has left the game.

== Game 2 (612730234) ==
[04:45:47] PDBot has started watching.
[04:45:48] DustyJustice keeps this hand.
[04:45:51] NG4 keeps this hand.
[04:45:51] Turn 1: DustyJustice
[04:45:52] DustyJustice skips their draw step.
[04:45:54] DustyJustice plays [Grand Coliseum].
[04:46:03] Turn 1: NG4
[04:46:07] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:46:09] Turn 2: DustyJustice
[04:46:12] DustyJustice plays [Forest].
[04:46:15] DustyJustice casts [Deathcap Cultivator].
[04:46:19] Turn 2: NG4
[04:46:24] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:46:27] NG4 casts [Elite Inquisitor].
[04:46:29] Turn 3: DustyJustice
[04:46:39] DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
[04:47:03] DustyJustice casts [Rogue Refiner].
[04:47:05] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Rogue Refiner] onto the stack (When Rogue Refiner enters the battlefield, draw a card and you get {EE}.).
[04:47:05] DustyJustice draws a card with [Rogue Refiner]'s ability.
[04:47:05] DustyJustice gains 2 energy from [Rogue Refiner]'s ability.
[04:47:07] Turn 3: NG4
[04:47:12] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:47:17] NG4 casts [Bygone Bishop].
[04:47:20] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Elite Inquisitor].
[04:47:23] [Deathcap Cultivator] blocks [Elite Inquisitor].
[04:47:24] [Rogue Refiner] blocks [Elite Inquisitor].
[04:47:38] Blockers for [Elite Inquisitor] are ordered as follows: [Deathcap Cultivator], [Rogue Refiner]
[04:47:48] Turn 4: DustyJustice
[04:47:55] NG4 is being attacked by [Rogue Refiner].
[04:48:03] DustyJustice plays [Opulent Palace].
[04:48:26] DustyJustice casts [Catacomb Sifter].
[04:48:26] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (When Catacomb Sifter enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. ...).
[04:48:27] DustyJustice's [Catacomb Sifter] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[04:48:27] Turn 4: NG4
[04:48:31] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:48:38] NG4 casts [Aerial Responder].
[04:48:38] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Bygone Bishop] onto the stack (Whenever you cast a creature spell with converted mana cost 3 or less, investigate.).
[04:48:39] NG4's [Bygone Bishop] creates a Clue token.
[04:48:43] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Bygone Bishop].
[04:48:45] Turn 5: DustyJustice
[04:48:58] NG4 is being attacked by [Rogue Refiner].
[04:49:11] DustyJustice casts [Banewhip Punisher].
[04:49:13] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Banewhip Punisher] onto the stack targeting [Bygone Bishop] (When Banewhip Punisher enters the battlefield, you may put a -1/-1 counter on target creature.).
[04:49:22] DustyJustice activates an ability of [Banewhip Punisher] targeting [Bygone Bishop] ( Destroy target creature that has a -1/-1 counter on it.).
[04:49:22] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (Whenever another creature you control dies, scry 1.).
[04:49:40] DustyJustice puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[04:49:41] Turn 5: NG4
[04:49:47] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:49:52] NG4 casts [Thalia's Lancers].
[04:49:52] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Thalia's Lancers] onto the stack (When Thalia's Lancers enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a legendary card, re...).
[04:50:01] NG4 reveals [Odric, Lunarch Marshal].
[04:50:04] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Aerial Responder].
[04:50:06] Turn 6: DustyJustice
[04:50:44] DustyJustice casts [Wretched Gryff], emerging from [Rogue Refiner].
[04:50:50] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Wretched Gryff] onto the stack (When you cast this spell, draw a card.).
[04:50:50] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (Whenever another creature you control dies, scry 1.).
[04:50:54] DustyJustice puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[04:50:56] DustyJustice draws a card with [Wretched Gryff]'s ability.
[04:51:01] DustyJustice plays [Forest].
[04:51:04] DustyJustice casts [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[04:51:05] Turn 6: NG4
[04:51:20] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:51:33] NG4 casts [Aerial Responder].
[04:51:35] NG4 casts [Spear of Heliod].
[04:51:48] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Aerial Responder].
[04:51:55] [Wretched Gryff] blocks [Aerial Responder].
[04:52:01] Turn 7: DustyJustice
[04:52:15] DustyJustice casts [Conclave Naturalists].
[04:52:18] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Conclave Naturalists] onto the stack targeting [Spear of Heliod] (When Conclave Naturalists enters the battlefield, you may destroy target artifact or enchantment.).
[04:52:26] Turn 7: NG4
[04:52:34] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:52:42] NG4 casts [Odric, Lunarch Marshal].
[04:52:46] NG4 activates an ability of [Clue] token ( Draw a card.).
[04:52:46] NG4 draws a card with [Clue] token's ability.
[04:52:48] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Odric, Lunarch Marshal] onto the stack (At the beginning of each combat, creatures you control gain first strike until end of turn if a cr...).
[04:52:56] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Thalia's Lancers].
[04:52:59] Turn 8: DustyJustice
[04:53:10] DustyJustice casts [Banewhip Punisher].
[04:53:15] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Banewhip Punisher] onto the stack targeting [Odric, Lunarch Marshal] (When Banewhip Punisher enters the battlefield, you may put a -1/-1 counter on target creature.).
[04:53:29] DustyJustice activates an ability of [Banewhip Punisher] targeting [Odric, Lunarch Marshal] ( Destroy target creature that has a -1/-1 counter on it.).
[04:53:29] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (Whenever another creature you control dies, scry 1.).
[04:53:35] DustyJustice puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[04:53:38] Turn 8: NG4
[04:53:42] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:53:47] NG4 casts [Elite Inquisitor].
[04:53:52] Turn 9: DustyJustice
[04:54:02] DustyJustice casts [Arborback Stomper].
[04:54:02] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Arborback Stomper] onto the stack (When Arborback Stomper enters the battlefield, you gain 5 life.).
[04:54:05] Turn 9: NG4
[04:54:09] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:54:12] NG4 casts [Bygone Bishop].
[04:54:19] Turn 10: DustyJustice
[04:54:23] DustyJustice casts [Banewhip Punisher].
[04:54:29] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Banewhip Punisher] onto the stack targeting [Bygone Bishop] (When Banewhip Punisher enters the battlefield, you may put a -1/-1 counter on target creature.).
[04:54:37] DustyJustice activates an ability of [Banewhip Punisher] targeting [Bygone Bishop] ( Destroy target creature that has a -1/-1 counter on it.).
[04:54:37] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (Whenever another creature you control dies, scry 1.).
[04:54:43] DustyJustice puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[04:54:46] Turn 10: NG4
[04:54:49] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:54:53] Turn 11: DustyJustice
[04:54:53] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Duskwatch Recruiter] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Duskwatch Recruiter.).
[04:55:01] DustyJustice plays [Forest].
[04:55:06] DustyJustice casts [Duskwatch Recruiter].
[04:55:10] DustyJustice activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...).
[04:55:14] DustyJustice puts [Banewhip Punisher] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability.
[04:55:16] DustyJustice put a card on the bottom of the library.
[04:55:17] DustyJustice put a card on the bottom of the library.
[04:55:22] DustyJustice casts [Deathcap Cultivator].
[04:55:26] Turn 11: NG4
[04:55:26] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Krallenhorde Howler] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if a player cast two or more spells last turn, transform Krallenh...).
[04:55:35] NG4 casts [Aerial Responder].
[04:55:40] Turn 12: DustyJustice
[04:55:53] DustyJustice activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...).
[04:56:00] DustyJustice puts [Desecration Demon] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability.
[04:56:02] DustyJustice put a card on the bottom of the library.
[04:56:02] DustyJustice put a card on the bottom of the library.
[04:56:09] DustyJustice casts [Desecration Demon].
[04:56:12] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Desecration Demon] onto the stack (At the beginning of each combat, any opponent may sacrifice a creature. If a player does, tap Dese...).
[04:56:14] NG4 has conceded from the game.
Winner: DustyJustice
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (612733004) ==
[04:57:08] PDBot has started watching.
[04:57:17] NG4 chooses to play first.
[04:57:21] NG4 keeps this hand.
[04:57:27] DustyJustice mulligans to 6 cards.
[04:57:31] DustyJustice keeps this hand.
[04:57:33] DustyJustice puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[04:57:33] Turn 1: NG4
[04:57:35] NG4 skips their draw step.
[04:57:41] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:57:43] Turn 1: DustyJustice
[04:57:47] DustyJustice plays [Opulent Palace].
[04:57:49] Turn 2: NG4
[04:57:51] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:57:54] NG4 casts [Consul's Lieutenant].
[04:57:55] Turn 2: DustyJustice
[04:58:04] DustyJustice plays [Grand Coliseum].
[04:58:12] Turn 3: NG4
[04:58:16] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:58:23] NG4 casts [Precinct Captain].
[04:58:28] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Consul's Lieutenant].
[04:58:29] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Renown 1 (When this creature deals combat damage to a player, if it isn't renowned, put one +1/+...).
[04:58:29] Turn 3: DustyJustice
[04:58:32] DustyJustice plays [Island].
[04:58:45] DustyJustice casts [Catacomb Sifter].
[04:58:49] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (When Catacomb Sifter enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 colorless Eldrazi Scion creature token. ...).
[04:58:51] DustyJustice's [Catacomb Sifter] creates an Eldrazi Scion token.
[04:58:53] Turn 4: NG4
[04:58:57] NG4 plays [Plains].
[04:59:01] NG4 casts [Precinct Captain].
[04:59:06] NG4 casts [Porcelain Legionnaire].
[04:59:11] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Precinct Captain] and [Consul's Lieutenant].
[04:59:11] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Whenever Consul's Lieutenant attacks, if it's renowned, other attacking creatures you control get ...).
[04:59:14] [Eldrazi Scion] token blocks [Precinct Captain].
[04:59:17] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (Whenever another creature you control dies, scry 1.).
[04:59:22] DustyJustice puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[04:59:22] Turn 4: DustyJustice
[05:00:02] DustyJustice plays [Evolving Wilds].
[05:00:07] DustyJustice activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[05:00:18] DustyJustice casts [Banewhip Punisher].
[05:00:23] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Banewhip Punisher] onto the stack targeting [Porcelain Legionnaire] (When Banewhip Punisher enters the battlefield, you may put a -1/-1 counter on target creature.).
[05:00:28] Turn 5: NG4
[05:00:31] NG4 plays [Plains].
[05:00:37] NG4 casts [Nobilis of War].
[05:00:41] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Precinct Captain], [Precinct Captain], and [Consul's Lieutenant].
[05:00:41] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Whenever Consul's Lieutenant attacks, if it's renowned, other attacking creatures you control get ...).
[05:00:45] [Catacomb Sifter] blocks [Consul's Lieutenant].
[05:01:32] [Catacomb Sifter] blocks [Precinct Captain].
[05:01:33] [Banewhip Punisher] blocks [Precinct Captain].
[05:01:34] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Catacomb Sifter] onto the stack (Whenever another creature you control dies, scry 1.).
[05:01:38] DustyJustice puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[05:01:38] Turn 5: DustyJustice
[05:01:42] DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
[05:01:47] DustyJustice casts [Banewhip Punisher].
[05:01:57] DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Banewhip Punisher] onto the stack targeting [Nobilis of War] (When Banewhip Punisher enters the battlefield, you may put a -1/-1 counter on target creature.).
[05:02:02] Turn 6: NG4
[05:02:06] NG4 plays [Plains].
[05:02:12] DustyJustice is being attacked by [Nobilis of War], [Precinct Captain], [Precinct Captain], and [Consul's Lieutenant].
[05:02:12] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Consul's Lieutenant] onto the stack (Whenever Consul's Lieutenant attacks, if it's renowned, other attacking creatures you control get ...).
[05:02:26] [Banewhip Punisher] blocks [Precinct Captain].
[05:02:33] DustyJustice activates an ability of [Banewhip Punisher] targeting [Nobilis of War] ( Destroy target creature that has a -1/-1 counter on it.).
[05:02:36] NG4 puts triggered ability from [Precinct Captain] onto the stack (Whenever Precinct Captain deals combat damage to a player, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature tok...).
[05:02:38] NG4's [Precinct Captain] creates a Soldier token.
[05:02:41] Turn 6: DustyJustice
[05:02:48] [CHAT] DustyJustice: ggs
[05:02:51] [CHAT] NG4: ggs
[05:02:51] DustyJustice has conceded from the game.
Winner: NG4
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: NG4: 2–1