PennyDreadful
PDT R4 vs Nanaiper
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
nanaiper,JarJarThinks

== Game 1 (612062290) ==
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Thursdays 8.04
[Gatherling] Round=4
[11:22:08] PDBot has started watching.
[11:22:15] [CHAT] nanaiper: gl
[11:22:15] JarJarThinks chooses to play first.
[11:22:17] [CHAT] JarJarThinks: gl
[11:22:22] JarJarThinks keeps this hand.
[11:22:24] nanaiper keeps this hand.
[11:22:24] Turn 1: JarJarThinks
[11:22:25] JarJarThinks skips their draw step.
[11:22:26] JarJarThinks plays [Mountain].
[11:22:29] Turn 1: nanaiper
[11:22:32] nanaiper plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:22:33] nanaiper activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:22:39] Turn 2: JarJarThinks
[11:22:41] JarJarThinks plays [Plains].
[11:22:46] JarJarThinks discards [Plains].
[11:22:46] JarJarThinks casts [Tormenting Voice].
[11:22:49] JarJarThinks draws two cards with [Tormenting Voice].
[11:22:51] Turn 2: nanaiper
[11:22:53] nanaiper plays [Grand Coliseum].
[11:22:58] Turn 3: JarJarThinks
[11:23:14] JarJarThinks plays [Plains].
[11:23:16] JarJarThinks casts [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[11:23:17] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Valduk, Keeper of the Flame[sU] has a Disadvantageous bug.
Valduk, Keeper of the Flame does not create an Elemental token if it dies while its ability is on the stack.

[11:23:18] JarJarThinks puts triggered ability from [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame] onto the stack (At the beginning of combat on your turn, for each Aura and Equipment attached to Valduk, Keeper of...).
[11:23:19] Turn 3: nanaiper
[11:23:22] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[11:23:26] nanaiper casts [Flaying Tendrils].
[11:23:31] Turn 4: JarJarThinks
[11:23:44] JarJarThinks plays [Plains].
[11:23:47] JarJarThinks casts [Champion of the Flame].
[11:23:51] JarJarThinks casts [Spirit Loop] targeting [Champion of the Flame].
[11:24:08] Turn 4: nanaiper
[11:24:12] nanaiper plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:24:14] nanaiper activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:24:28] Turn 5: JarJarThinks
[11:24:35] JarJarThinks plays [Boros Guildgate].
[11:24:42] JarJarThinks casts [Madcap Skills] targeting [Champion of the Flame].
[11:24:51] nanaiper is being attacked by [Champion of the Flame].
[11:24:54] nanaiper casts [Tribute to Hunger] targeting JarJarThinks.
[11:24:58] JarJarThinks sacrifices [Champion of the Flame].
[11:24:59] JarJarThinks puts triggered ability from [Spirit Loop] onto the stack (When Spirit Loop is put into a graveyard from the battlefield, return Spirit Loop to its owner's h...).
[11:25:04] Turn 5: nanaiper
[11:25:07] nanaiper plays [Calciform Pools].
[11:25:11] Turn 6: JarJarThinks
[11:25:17] JarJarThinks casts [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[11:25:25] JarJarThinks casts [Cartouche of Zeal] targeting [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[11:25:35] nanaiper casts [Utter End] targeting [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[11:25:38] JarJarThinks's [Cartouche of Zeal] is countered because it has no legal targets.
[11:25:44] Turn 6: nanaiper
[11:25:46] nanaiper plays [Island].
[11:25:52] Turn 7: JarJarThinks
[11:25:54] JarJarThinks plays [Plains].
[11:25:59] nanaiper activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[11:26:01] Turn 7: nanaiper
[11:26:07] Turn 8: JarJarThinks
[11:26:14] nanaiper discards [Decree of Justice].
[11:26:14] nanaiper cycles [Decree of Justice].
[11:26:15] nanaiper puts triggered ability from [Decree of Justice] onto the stack ( When you cycle Decree of Justice, you may pay {X}. If you do, create X 1/1 white Soldier creature...).
[11:26:19] nanaiper's [Decree of Justice] creates three Soldier tokens.
[11:26:22] Turn 8: nanaiper
[11:26:29] JarJarThinks is being attacked by [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, and [Soldier] token.
[11:26:32] Turn 9: JarJarThinks
[11:26:36] JarJarThinks casts [Champion of the Flame].
[11:26:52] JarJarThinks casts [Retether].
[11:27:14] JarJarThinks puts triggered ability from [Cartouche of Zeal] onto the stack targeting [Soldier] token (When Cartouche of Zeal enters the battlefield, target creature can't block this turn.).
[11:27:23] nanaiper casts [Tribute to Hunger] targeting JarJarThinks.
[11:27:29] JarJarThinks sacrifices [Champion of the Flame].
[11:27:36] nanaiper activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[11:27:43] Turn 9: nanaiper
[11:27:50] JarJarThinks is being attacked by [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, and [Soldier] token.
[11:27:56] Turn 10: JarJarThinks
[11:28:05] nanaiper activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[11:28:09] Turn 10: nanaiper
[11:28:12] nanaiper plays [Azorius Guildgate].
[11:28:17] JarJarThinks is being attacked by [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, and [Soldier] token.
[11:28:23] Turn 11: JarJarThinks
[11:28:30] nanaiper activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[11:28:32] Turn 11: nanaiper
[11:28:37] JarJarThinks is being attacked by [Soldier] token, [Soldier] token, and [Soldier] token.
[11:28:42] Turn 12: JarJarThinks
[11:28:46] JarJarThinks casts [Graceblade Artisan].
[11:28:52] nanaiper casts [Dissolve] targeting [Graceblade Artisan].
[11:28:55] JarJarThinks has conceded from the game.
Winner: nanaiper
Game 1 Completed.

== Game 2 (612063818) ==
[11:29:56] PDBot has started watching.
[11:30:01] JarJarThinks chooses to play first.
[11:30:05] JarJarThinks keeps this hand.
[11:30:06] nanaiper keeps this hand.
[11:30:06] Turn 1: JarJarThinks
[11:30:08] JarJarThinks skips their draw step.
[11:30:09] JarJarThinks plays [Plains].
[11:30:11] Turn 1: nanaiper
[11:30:14] nanaiper plays [Azorius Guildgate].
[11:30:17] Turn 2: JarJarThinks
[11:30:20] JarJarThinks plays [Mountain].
[11:30:22] JarJarThinks casts [Havoc].
[11:30:26] Turn 2: nanaiper
[11:30:30] nanaiper plays [Calciform Pools].
[11:30:35] Turn 3: JarJarThinks
[11:30:37] JarJarThinks plays [Mountain].
[11:30:38] JarJarThinks casts [Champion of the Flame].
[11:30:47] nanaiper activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[11:30:49] Turn 3: nanaiper
[11:30:52] nanaiper plays [Swamp].
[11:30:57] Turn 4: JarJarThinks
[11:31:00] JarJarThinks plays [Mountain].
[11:31:03] JarJarThinks casts [Cartouche of Zeal] targeting [Champion of the Flame].
[11:31:04] JarJarThinks puts triggered ability from [Cartouche of Zeal] onto the stack targeting [Champion of the Flame] (When Cartouche of Zeal enters the battlefield, target creature can't block this turn.).
[11:31:15] nanaiper is being attacked by [Champion of the Flame].
[11:31:21] nanaiper casts [Tribute to Hunger] targeting JarJarThinks.
[11:31:24] JarJarThinks sacrifices [Champion of the Flame].
[11:31:26] JarJarThinks casts [Auramancer].
[11:31:28] JarJarThinks puts triggered ability from [Auramancer] onto the stack targeting [Cartouche of Zeal] (When Auramancer enters the battlefield, you may return target enchantment card from your graveyard...).
[11:31:32] JarJarThinks returns [Cartouche of Zeal] to its owner's hand with [Auramancer]'s ability.
[11:31:35] Turn 4: nanaiper
[11:31:37] nanaiper plays [Azorius Guildgate].
[11:31:43] Turn 5: JarJarThinks
[11:31:48] JarJarThinks casts [Open the Armory].
[11:31:54] JarJarThinks reveals [Madcap Skills].
[11:31:56] JarJarThinks plays [Mountain].
[11:31:58] JarJarThinks casts [Madcap Skills] targeting [Auramancer].
[11:32:06] nanaiper is being attacked by [Auramancer].
[11:32:19] nanaiper casts [Azorius Charm] targeting [Auramancer] (Put target attacking or blocking creature on top of its owner's library.).
[11:32:19] JarJarThinks puts triggered ability from [Havoc] onto the stack (Whenever an opponent casts a white spell, they lose 2 life.).
[11:32:28] Turn 5: nanaiper
[11:32:30] nanaiper plays [Grand Coliseum].
[11:32:36] Turn 6: JarJarThinks
[11:32:39] JarJarThinks casts [Auramancer].
[11:32:46] nanaiper casts [Power Sink] targeting [Auramancer]. (X is 3).
[11:32:51] Turn 6: nanaiper
[11:32:57] Turn 7: JarJarThinks
[11:33:03] JarJarThinks discards [Cartouche of Zeal].
[11:33:03] JarJarThinks casts [Tormenting Voice].
[11:33:05] JarJarThinks draws two cards with [Tormenting Voice].
[11:33:11] JarJarThinks casts [Graceblade Artisan].
[11:33:21] nanaiper casts [Jace's Ingenuity].
[11:33:22] nanaiper draws three cards with [Jace's Ingenuity].
[11:33:23] Turn 7: nanaiper
[11:33:26] nanaiper plays [Crumbling Necropolis].
[11:33:32] Turn 8: JarJarThinks
[11:33:35] JarJarThinks casts [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[11:33:41] JarJarThinks casts [Cartouche of Zeal] targeting [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[11:33:46] nanaiper casts [Moment of Craving] targeting [Valduk, Keeper of the Flame].
[11:33:50] JarJarThinks's [Cartouche of Zeal] is countered because it has no legal targets.
[11:33:53] nanaiper is being attacked by [Graceblade Artisan].
[11:34:01] nanaiper activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[11:34:03] Turn 8: nanaiper
[11:34:05] nanaiper plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:34:07] nanaiper activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:34:15] Turn 9: JarJarThinks
[11:34:19] JarJarThinks casts [Champion of the Flame].
[11:34:25] JarJarThinks casts [Graceblade Artisan].
[11:34:30] nanaiper is being attacked by [Graceblade Artisan].
[11:34:35] Turn 9: nanaiper
[11:34:44] nanaiper casts [Akroma's Vengeance].
[11:34:44] JarJarThinks puts triggered ability from [Havoc] onto the stack (Whenever an opponent casts a white spell, they lose 2 life.).
[11:34:46] Turn 10: JarJarThinks
[11:34:50] JarJarThinks plays [Plains].
[11:34:51] Turn 10: nanaiper
[11:34:56] nanaiper casts [Greater Realm of Preservation].
[11:34:59] Turn 11: JarJarThinks
[11:35:02] JarJarThinks plays [Plains].
[11:35:08] nanaiper activates an ability of [Calciform Pools] ( Put a storage counter on Calciform Pools.).
[11:35:08] Turn 11: nanaiper
[11:35:11] nanaiper plays [Evolving Wilds].
[11:35:13] nanaiper activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
[11:35:19] Turn 12: JarJarThinks
[11:35:30] nanaiper casts [Whispers of the Muse] with buyback.
[11:35:32] JarJarThinks has conceded from the game.
Winner: nanaiper
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: nanaiper: 2–0