PennyDreadful
pd testing dust elememtal bug
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
ribbonsofnight,wHo959

== Game 1 (608795954) ==
[13:40:38] PDBot has started watching.
[13:40:38] ribbonsofnight joined the game.
[13:40:38] wHo959 joined the game.
[League] Host doesn't have active run
[13:40:45] wHo959 chooses to play first.
[13:40:52] wHo959 mulligans to 6 cards.
[13:40:58] ribbonsofnight keeps this hand.
[13:41:04] wHo959 keeps this hand.
[13:41:10] wHo959 puts 1 card on top of their library.
[13:41:10] Turn 1: wHo959
[13:41:10] wHo959 skips their draw step.
[13:41:11] wHo959 plays [Swamp].
[13:41:48] Turn 1: ribbonsofnight
[13:41:50] ribbonsofnight plays [Plains].
[13:41:52] ribbonsofnight casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[13:41:58] Turn 2: wHo959
[13:42:00] wHo959 plays [Swamp].
[13:42:02] wHo959 casts [Dusk Legion Zealot].
[13:42:02] wHo959 puts triggered ability from [Dusk Legion Zealot] onto the stack (When Dusk Legion Zealot enters the battlefield, you draw a card and you lose 1 life.).
[13:42:09] wHo959 draws a card with [Dusk Legion Zealot]'s ability.
[13:42:15] Turn 2: ribbonsofnight
[13:42:16] ribbonsofnight plays [Plains].
[13:42:23] ribbonsofnight casts [Consul's Lieutenant].
[13:42:38] Turn 3: wHo959
[13:42:45] wHo959 plays [Swamp].
[13:42:49] wHo959 casts [Black Cat].
[13:42:57] wHo959 casts [Bone Splinters] targeting [Consul's Lieutenant].
[13:42:57] wHo959 puts triggered ability from [Black Cat] onto the stack targeting ribbonsofnight (When Black Cat dies, target opponent discards a card at random.).
[13:43:01] ribbonsofnight discards [Bygone Bishop].
[13:43:15] Turn 3: ribbonsofnight
[13:43:17] ribbonsofnight plays [Plains].
[13:43:20] ribbonsofnight casts [Always Watching].
[13:43:28] wHo959 is being attacked by [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[13:43:34] Turn 4: wHo959
[13:43:41] wHo959 plays [Swamp].
[13:43:45] wHo959 casts [Bloodthrone Vampire].
[13:44:01] Turn 4: ribbonsofnight
[13:44:04] ribbonsofnight plays [Plains].
[13:44:15] wHo959 is being attacked by [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[13:44:25] [Dusk Legion Zealot] blocks [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[13:44:38] wHo959 casts [Altar's Reap].
[13:44:41] wHo959 draws two cards with [Altar's Reap].
[13:44:48] ribbonsofnight casts [Precinct Captain].
[13:44:56] Turn 5: wHo959
[13:45:04] wHo959 plays [Swamp].
[13:45:11] wHo959 casts [No Rest for the Wicked].
[13:45:41] [CHAT] ribbonsofnight: I assume you're running immortal servitude
[13:45:55] wHo959 casts [Skulltap].
[13:45:55] wHo959 draws two cards with [Skulltap].
[13:46:03] [CHAT] ribbonsofnight: because it's much better than no rest for the wicked
[13:46:12] wHo959 casts [Claim] targeting [Black Cat].
[13:46:31] [CHAT] wHo959: yep i am
[13:46:42] wHo959 activates an ability of [No Rest for the Wicked] ( Return to your hand all creature cards in your graveyard that were put there from the battlefield...).
[13:46:42] wHo959 returns [Bloodthrone Vampire] to its owner's hand with [No Rest for the Wicked]'s ability.
[13:46:48] Turn 5: ribbonsofnight
[13:46:57] wHo959 is being attacked by [Precinct Captain] and [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[13:47:04] [Black Cat] blocks [Precinct Captain].
[13:47:10] ribbonsofnight casts [Dust Elemental].
[13:47:16] ribbonsofnight puts triggered ability from [Dust Elemental] onto the stack (When Dust Elemental enters the battlefield, return three creatures you control to their owner's ha...).
[13:47:36] ribbonsofnight returns [Dust Elemental] and [Precinct Captain] to their owner's hand with [Dust Elemental]'s ability.
[13:47:53] [CHAT] ribbonsofnight: I'm trying to test dust elemental's bug
[13:47:55] ribbonsofnight plays [Plains].
[13:47:58] ribbonsofnight casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[13:48:01] Turn 6: wHo959
[13:48:13] wHo959 plays [Swamp].
[13:48:16] wHo959 casts [Bloodthrone Vampire].
[13:48:19] wHo959 casts [Bloodthrone Vampire].
[13:48:22] wHo959 casts [No Rest for the Wicked].
[13:48:28] [CHAT] ribbonsofnight: but I screen shotted at the wrong time
[13:48:53] [CHAT] wHo959: what is the bug?
[13:48:58] Turn 6: ribbonsofnight
[13:49:14] [CHAT] ribbonsofnight: it only seems to return 2 creatures if you control exactly 3 creatures
[13:49:24] ribbonsofnight casts [Dust Elemental].
[13:49:30] [CHAT] wHo959: ah
[13:49:34] ribbonsofnight puts triggered ability from [Dust Elemental] onto the stack (When Dust Elemental enters the battlefield, return three creatures you control to their owner's ha...).
[13:50:09] ribbonsofnight returns [Soldier of the Pantheon] and [Soldier of the Pantheon] to their owner's hand with [Dust Elemental]'s ability.
[13:50:17] [CHAT] wHo959: get it?
[13:50:28] [CHAT] ribbonsofnight: yep
[13:50:35] ribbonsofnight casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[13:50:45] Turn 7: wHo959
[13:51:22] Turn 7: ribbonsofnight
[13:51:25] ribbonsofnight casts [Serra Avenger].
[13:51:30] ribbonsofnight casts [Precinct Captain].
[13:51:38] ribbonsofnight casts [Soldier of the Pantheon].
[13:51:53] wHo959 is being attacked by [Dust Elemental].
[13:52:04] Turn 8: wHo959
[13:52:10] wHo959 has conceded from the game.
Winner: ribbonsofnight
Game 1 Completed.
[13:52:15] wHo959 has left the game.

== Game 2 (608798794) ==
[13:54:06] PDBot has started watching.
[13:54:07] wHo959 chooses to play first.
[13:54:25] wHo959 mulligans to 6 cards.
[13:54:29] ribbonsofnight keeps this hand.
[13:54:30] wHo959 keeps this hand.
[13:54:38] wHo959 puts 1 card on the bottom of their library.
[13:54:38] Turn 1: wHo959
[13:54:38] wHo959 skips their draw step.
[13:54:40] wHo959 plays [Swamp].
[13:54:41] wHo959 casts [Festering Mummy].
[13:54:46] Turn 1: ribbonsofnight
[13:54:48] ribbonsofnight plays [Plains].
[13:54:52] Turn 2: wHo959
[13:54:59] wHo959 plays [Swamp].
[13:55:05] ribbonsofnight is being attacked by [Festering Mummy].
[13:55:09] wHo959 casts [Black Cat].
[13:55:10] Turn 2: ribbonsofnight
[13:55:12] ribbonsofnight plays [Plains].
[13:55:14] ribbonsofnight casts [Precinct Captain].
[13:55:21] Turn 3: wHo959
[13:55:30] wHo959 plays [Bloodfell Caves].
[13:55:30] wHo959 puts triggered ability from [Bloodfell Caves] onto the stack (When Bloodfell Caves enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.).
[13:55:42] wHo959 casts [Bloodthrone Vampire].
[13:55:52] Turn 3: ribbonsofnight
[13:55:55] ribbonsofnight plays [Plains].
[13:55:57] ribbonsofnight casts [Banishing Light].
[13:56:06] ribbonsofnight puts triggered ability from [Banishing Light] onto the stack targeting [Bloodthrone Vampire] (When Banishing Light enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent an opponent controls u...).
[13:56:27] wHo959 activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[13:56:27] wHo959 puts triggered ability from [Black Cat] onto the stack targeting ribbonsofnight (When Black Cat dies, target opponent discards a card at random.).
[13:56:40] wHo959 activates an ability of [Bloodthrone Vampire] ( Bloodthrone Vampire gets +2/+2 until end of turn.).
[13:56:48] ribbonsofnight discards [Consul's Lieutenant].
[13:56:56] ribbonsofnight's Triggered ability from Banishing Light is countered because it has no legal targets.
[13:57:01] wHo959 is being attacked by [Precinct Captain].
[13:57:07] [Festering Mummy] blocks [Precinct Captain].
[13:57:09] wHo959 puts triggered ability from [Festering Mummy] onto the stack targeting [Precinct Captain] (When Festering Mummy dies, you may put a -1/-1 counter on target creature.).
[13:57:19] Turn 4: wHo959
[13:57:23] wHo959 plays [Swamp].
[13:57:30] Turn 4: ribbonsofnight
[13:57:54] ribbonsofnight plays [Plains].
[13:58:06] wHo959 is being attacked by [Precinct Captain].
[13:58:16] wHo959 casts [Terror] targeting [Precinct Captain].
[13:58:21] ribbonsofnight casts [Precinct Captain].
[13:58:24] ribbonsofnight casts [Accorder Paladin].
[13:58:27] Turn 5: wHo959
[13:58:30] wHo959 plays [Swamp].
[13:58:43] Turn 5: ribbonsofnight
[13:58:54] wHo959 is being attacked by [Accorder Paladin] and [Precinct Captain].
[13:58:54] ribbonsofnight puts triggered ability from [Accorder Paladin] onto the stack (Whenever this creature attacks, each other attacking creature gets +1/+0 until end of turn.).
[13:59:06] ribbonsofnight puts triggered ability from [Precinct Captain] onto the stack (Whenever Precinct Captain deals combat damage to a player, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature tok...).
[13:59:10] ribbonsofnight's [Precinct Captain] creates a Soldier token.
[13:59:17] ribbonsofnight casts [Hanweir Militia Captain].
[13:59:21] Turn 6: wHo959
[13:59:39] Turn 6: ribbonsofnight
[13:59:39] ribbonsofnight puts triggered ability from [Hanweir Militia Captain] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if you control four or more creatures, transform Hanweir Militia ...).
[14:00:00] wHo959 is being attacked by [Westvale Cult Leader], [Soldier] token, [Accorder Paladin], and [Precinct Captain].
[14:00:01] ribbonsofnight puts triggered ability from [Accorder Paladin] onto the stack (Whenever this creature attacks, each other attacking creature gets +1/+0 until end of turn.).
[14:00:15] ribbonsofnight puts triggered ability from [Precinct Captain] onto the stack (Whenever Precinct Captain deals combat damage to a player, create a 1/1 white Soldier creature tok...).
[14:00:16] ribbonsofnight's [Precinct Captain] creates a Soldier token.
[14:00:24] ribbonsofnight puts triggered ability from [Westvale Cult Leader] onto the stack (At the beginning of your end step, create a 1/1 white and black Human Cleric creature token.).
[14:00:27] ribbonsofnight's [Westvale Cult Leader] creates a Human Cleric token.
[14:00:29] Turn 7: wHo959
[14:00:33] wHo959 has conceded from the game.
Winner: ribbonsofnight
Game 2 Completed.
Match Winner: ribbonsofnight: 2–0
[14:00:39] wHo959 has left the game.