PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality kyosukenoir,Thefishy == Game 1 (608186644) == [03:45:53] PDBot has started watching. [03:45:53] kyosukenoir joined the game. [03:45:53] Thefishy joined the game. [League] Bant Yisan by thefishy (14787) vs Life Burns by kyosukenoir (14795) [03:45:57] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [03:45:59] [CHAT] kyosukenoir: gl hf [03:46:01] kyosukenoir chooses to not play first. [03:46:05] Thefishy keeps this hand. [03:46:08] kyosukenoir mulligans to 6 cards. [03:46:11] kyosukenoir keeps this hand. [03:46:13] kyosukenoir puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [03:46:13] Turn 1: Thefishy [03:46:16] Thefishy skips their draw step. [03:46:17] Thefishy plays [Opulent Palace]. [03:46:21] Turn 1: kyosukenoir [03:46:23] kyosukenoir plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [03:46:25] Turn 2: Thefishy [03:46:50] Thefishy plays [Meandering River]. [03:46:57] Turn 2: kyosukenoir [03:47:01] kyosukenoir plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [03:47:03] Turn 3: Thefishy [03:47:18] Thefishy plays [Evolving Wilds]. [03:47:24] Thefishy casts [Kiora's Follower]. [03:47:28] Thefishy activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [03:47:38] Turn 3: kyosukenoir [03:47:41] kyosukenoir plays [Plains]. [03:47:46] kyosukenoir casts [Tainted Remedy]. [03:47:48] Turn 4: Thefishy [03:47:52] Thefishy plays [Island]. [03:47:55] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Island] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:47:59] Thefishy casts [Prophet of Kruphix]. [03:48:06] Turn 4: kyosukenoir [03:48:10] kyosukenoir plays [Grand Coliseum]. [03:48:14] kyosukenoir casts [Banishing Light]. [03:48:23] kyosukenoir puts triggered ability from [Banishing Light] onto the stack targeting [Prophet of Kruphix] (When Banishing Light enters the battlefield, exile target nonland permanent an opponent controls u...). [03:48:41] Thefishy casts [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard]. [03:48:42] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Yisan, the Wanderer Bard[sU] has a Advantageous bug. If all of Yisan, the Wanderer Bard's verse counters are removed in response to its ability, you are able to search your library for any creature, regardless of CMC. [03:49:09] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:49:16] Thefishy casts [Kiora's Follower]. [03:49:29] Turn 5: Thefishy [03:49:39] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Kiora's Follower]. [03:49:51] Turn 5: kyosukenoir [03:49:55] kyosukenoir plays [Swamp]. [03:50:04] kyosukenoir casts [Alms Beast]. [03:50:16] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:50:22] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [03:50:40] Turn 6: Thefishy [03:50:55] Thefishy casts [Kiora's Follower]. [03:51:12] Turn 6: kyosukenoir [03:51:25] Thefishy is being attacked by [Alms Beast]. [03:51:40] kyosukenoir casts [Congregate] targeting Thefishy. [03:51:53] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:52:00] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Island] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:52:06] Thefishy casts [Negate] targeting [Congregate]. [03:52:20] kyosukenoir plays [Swamp]. [03:52:31] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [03:52:37] Turn 7: Thefishy [03:52:43] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:52:46] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:52:50] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:52:57] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [03:53:05] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Village Bell-Ringer] onto the stack (When Village Bell-Ringer enters the battlefield, untap all creatures you control.). [03:53:30] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [03:53:37] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:53:46] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [03:53:58] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Duskwatch Recruiter], [Kiora's Follower], and [Kiora's Follower]. [03:54:05] Turn 7: kyosukenoir [03:54:05] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Duskwatch Recruiter] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Duskwatch Recruiter.). [03:54:20] kyosukenoir plays [Plains]. [03:54:41] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [03:54:49] Thefishy casts [Rogue Refiner]. [03:54:51] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Rogue Refiner] onto the stack (When Rogue Refiner enters the battlefield, draw a card and you get {EE}.). [03:54:54] Thefishy draws a card with [Rogue Refiner]'s ability. [03:54:54] Thefishy gains 2 energy from [Rogue Refiner]'s ability. [03:54:56] Turn 8: Thefishy [03:55:00] Thefishy plays [Grand Coliseum]. [03:55:11] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Alms Beast] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [03:55:13] Thefishy returns [Alms Beast] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [03:55:16] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Tradewind Rider] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:55:22] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:55:27] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:55:35] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Village Bell-Ringer] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [03:55:41] Thefishy returns [Village Bell-Ringer] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [03:55:44] Thefishy casts [Village Bell-Ringer]. [03:55:55] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Village Bell-Ringer] onto the stack (When Village Bell-Ringer enters the battlefield, untap all creatures you control.). [03:56:19] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Tainted Remedy] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [03:56:21] Thefishy returns [Tainted Remedy] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [03:56:25] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Tradewind Rider] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:56:29] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:56:38] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:56:45] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Village Bell-Ringer] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [03:56:46] Thefishy returns [Village Bell-Ringer] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [03:56:49] Thefishy casts [Village Bell-Ringer]. [03:56:52] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Village Bell-Ringer] onto the stack (When Village Bell-Ringer enters the battlefield, untap all creatures you control.). [03:57:00] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Sandsteppe Citadel] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [03:57:25] kyosukenoir casts [Utter End] targeting [Village Bell-Ringer]. [03:57:29] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Tradewind Rider] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:57:40] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Village Bell-Ringer] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [03:57:43] Thefishy returns [Village Bell-Ringer] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [03:57:47] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:57:53] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:57:59] kyosukenoir's [Utter End] is countered because it has no legal targets. [03:58:01] Thefishy returns [Sandsteppe Citadel] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [03:58:03] Thefishy casts [Village Bell-Ringer]. [03:58:03] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Village Bell-Ringer] onto the stack (When Village Bell-Ringer enters the battlefield, untap all creatures you control.). [03:58:11] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Sandsteppe Citadel] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [03:58:11] Thefishy returns [Sandsteppe Citadel] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [03:58:14] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Tradewind Rider] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:58:19] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Grand Coliseum] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [03:58:20] Thefishy returns [Grand Coliseum] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [03:58:24] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Opulent Palace] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:58:27] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Opulent Palace] ( Untap another target permanent.). [03:58:46] Thefishy activates an ability of [Soul of Theros] ( Creatures you control get +2/+2 and gain first strike and lifelink until end of turn.). [03:58:53] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Krallenhorde Howler] and [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard]. [03:58:59] Turn 8: kyosukenoir [03:59:00] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Krallenhorde Howler] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if a player cast two or more spells last turn, transform Krallenh...). [03:59:05] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Plains] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [03:59:11] kyosukenoir has conceded from the game. Winner: Thefishy Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (608188940) == [04:00:02] PDBot has started watching. [04:00:03] Thefishy mulligans to 6 cards. [04:00:05] kyosukenoir keeps this hand. [04:00:14] Thefishy keeps this hand. [04:00:17] Thefishy puts 1 card on top of their library. [04:00:17] Turn 1: Thefishy [04:00:19] Thefishy skips their draw step. [04:00:20] Thefishy plays [Forest]. [04:00:25] Turn 1: kyosukenoir [04:00:31] kyosukenoir plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [04:00:33] Turn 2: Thefishy [04:00:35] Thefishy plays [Grand Coliseum]. [04:00:41] Turn 2: kyosukenoir [04:00:43] kyosukenoir plays [Plains]. [04:00:47] kyosukenoir casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Thefishy. [04:01:09] Thefishy discards [Negate]. [04:01:09] Thefishy reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Rogue Refiner], [Kiora's Follower], [Naturalize], and [Prophet of Kruphix]. [04:01:13] Turn 3: Thefishy [04:01:17] Thefishy casts [Kiora's Follower]. [04:01:23] Turn 3: kyosukenoir [04:01:33] kyosukenoir plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [04:01:37] kyosukenoir casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Thefishy. [04:02:03] Thefishy discards [Naturalize]. [04:02:03] Thefishy reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Negate], [Rogue Refiner], and [Prophet of Kruphix]. [04:02:10] Turn 4: Thefishy [04:02:16] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:02:20] Thefishy casts [Rogue Refiner]. [04:02:21] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Rogue Refiner] onto the stack (When Rogue Refiner enters the battlefield, draw a card and you get {EE}.). [04:02:25] Thefishy draws a card with [Rogue Refiner]'s ability. [04:02:25] Thefishy gains 2 energy from [Rogue Refiner]'s ability. [04:02:26] Thefishy plays [Forest]. [04:02:35] Turn 4: kyosukenoir [04:02:46] kyosukenoir plays [Grand Coliseum]. [04:02:51] kyosukenoir casts [Tainted Remedy]. [04:02:54] Turn 5: Thefishy [04:03:02] Thefishy casts [Arbor Elf]. [04:03:11] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Rogue Refiner] and [Kiora's Follower]. [04:03:23] Turn 5: kyosukenoir [04:03:54] kyosukenoir casts [Heroes' Reunion] targeting Thefishy. [04:04:31] kyosukenoir plays [Plains]. [04:04:49] Turn 6: Thefishy [04:04:56] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Grand Coliseum] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:04:59] Thefishy activates an ability of [Arbor Elf] targeting [Forest] ( Untap target Forest.). [04:05:03] Thefishy casts [Prophet of Kruphix]. [04:05:14] kyosukenoir casts [Stasis Snare]. [04:05:22] kyosukenoir puts triggered ability from [Stasis Snare] onto the stack targeting [Prophet of Kruphix] (When Stasis Snare enters the battlefield, exile target creature an opponent controls until Stasis ...). [04:05:31] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Rogue Refiner]. [04:05:37] Turn 6: kyosukenoir [04:05:40] kyosukenoir plays [Grand Coliseum]. [04:05:48] kyosukenoir casts [Rest for the Weary] targeting Thefishy. [04:06:14] kyosukenoir casts [Rest for the Weary] targeting Thefishy. Winner: kyosukenoir Game 2 Completed. [04:06:18] Thefishy draws their next card. [04:06:19] kyosukenoir has left the game. [04:06:19] Thefishy draws their next card. [04:06:19] Thefishy draws their next card. == Game 3 (608190062) == [04:06:41] PDBot has started watching. [04:06:45] Thefishy keeps this hand. [04:06:48] kyosukenoir mulligans to 6 cards. [04:06:53] kyosukenoir keeps this hand. [04:07:00] kyosukenoir puts 1 card on top of their library. [04:07:00] Turn 1: Thefishy [04:07:03] Thefishy skips their draw step. [04:07:04] Thefishy plays [Grand Coliseum]. [04:07:07] Turn 1: kyosukenoir [04:07:10] kyosukenoir plays [Grand Coliseum]. [04:07:11] Turn 2: Thefishy [04:07:15] Thefishy casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim]. [04:07:20] Turn 2: kyosukenoir [04:07:22] kyosukenoir plays [Grand Coliseum]. [04:07:24] Turn 3: Thefishy [04:07:27] Thefishy plays [Evolving Wilds]. [04:07:38] Thefishy casts [Duskwatch Recruiter]. [04:07:41] Thefishy activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [04:07:49] Turn 3: kyosukenoir [04:07:53] kyosukenoir plays [Swamp]. [04:07:56] kyosukenoir casts [Tainted Remedy]. [04:08:00] Turn 4: Thefishy [04:08:07] Thefishy casts [Caustic Caterpillar]. [04:08:16] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Duskwatch Recruiter]. [04:08:26] Turn 4: kyosukenoir [04:08:35] kyosukenoir plays [Plains]. [04:08:59] kyosukenoir casts [Utter End] targeting [Caustic Caterpillar]. [04:09:03] Thefishy casts [Negate] targeting [Utter End]. [04:09:09] Turn 5: Thefishy [04:09:12] Thefishy plays [Evolving Wilds]. [04:09:14] Thefishy activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [04:09:24] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Caustic Caterpillar] and [Duskwatch Recruiter]. [04:09:40] Turn 5: kyosukenoir [04:09:40] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Duskwatch Recruiter] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Duskwatch Recruiter.). [04:09:51] kyosukenoir casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Thefishy. [04:10:12] Thefishy discards [Negate]. [04:10:12] Thefishy reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Elder of Laurels], [Altered Ego], and [Prophet of Kruphix]. [04:10:37] Thefishy activates an ability of [Caustic Caterpillar] targeting [Tainted Remedy] ( Destroy target artifact or enchantment.). [04:10:50] Turn 6: Thefishy [04:10:56] Thefishy casts [Prophet of Kruphix]. [04:11:03] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Krallenhorde Howler]. [04:11:27] Turn 6: kyosukenoir [04:11:36] kyosukenoir plays [Swamp]. [04:11:41] kyosukenoir casts [Rest for the Weary] targeting kyosukenoir. [04:12:40] Thefishy casts [Arbor Elf]. [04:12:42] Turn 7: Thefishy [04:12:52] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Arbor Elf], [Prophet of Kruphix], [Krallenhorde Howler], and [Avacyn's Pilgrim]. [04:13:04] Thefishy casts [Elder of Laurels]. [04:13:06] Turn 7: kyosukenoir [04:13:41] kyosukenoir casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Thefishy. [04:13:50] Thefishy activates an ability of [Arbor Elf] targeting [Forest] ( Untap target Forest.). [04:14:04] Thefishy casts [Tradewind Rider]. [04:14:42] Thefishy discards [Altered Ego]. [04:14:42] Thefishy reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing no cards. [04:14:46] Turn 8: Thefishy [04:15:15] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Elder of Laurels] and [Krallenhorde Howler]. [04:15:35] kyosukenoir casts [Heroes' Reunion] targeting kyosukenoir. [04:15:47] Thefishy activates an ability of [Elder of Laurels] targeting [Krallenhorde Howler] ( Target creature gets +X/+X until end of turn, where X is the number of creatures you control.). [04:16:00] Thefishy activates an ability of [Arbor Elf] targeting [Forest] ( Untap target Forest.). [04:16:04] Thefishy casts [Arbor Elf]. [04:16:09] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Grand Coliseum] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:16:10] Thefishy returns [Grand Coliseum] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:16:15] Turn 8: kyosukenoir [04:16:20] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Grand Coliseum] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:16:22] Thefishy returns [Grand Coliseum] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:16:27] kyosukenoir plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [04:16:30] kyosukenoir casts [Rest for the Weary] targeting kyosukenoir. [04:16:39] Turn 9: Thefishy [04:16:48] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Sandsteppe Citadel] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:16:53] Thefishy returns [Sandsteppe Citadel] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:17:04] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Elder of Laurels], [Prophet of Kruphix], and [Krallenhorde Howler]. [04:17:09] Thefishy activates an ability of [Elder of Laurels] targeting [Krallenhorde Howler] ( Target creature gets +X/+X until end of turn, where X is the number of creatures you control.). [04:17:16] Turn 9: kyosukenoir [04:17:23] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Plains] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:17:25] Thefishy returns [Plains] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:17:28] kyosukenoir plays [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [04:17:41] Turn 10: Thefishy [04:17:44] Thefishy plays [Forest]. [04:17:53] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Sandsteppe Citadel] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:17:56] Thefishy returns [Sandsteppe Citadel] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:18:02] Turn 10: kyosukenoir [04:18:06] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Swamp] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:18:09] Thefishy returns [Swamp] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:18:15] Thefishy casts [Kiora's Follower]. [04:18:21] kyosukenoir discards [Sandsteppe Citadel]. [04:18:22] Turn 11: Thefishy [04:18:25] Thefishy plays [Meandering River]. [04:18:31] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Swamp] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:18:39] Thefishy returns [Swamp] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:18:45] kyosukenoir is being attacked by [Kiora's Follower], [Arbor Elf], [Arbor Elf], [Krallenhorde Howler], and [Avacyn's Pilgrim]. [04:18:52] [CHAT] kyosukenoir: gg Winner: Thefishy Game 3 Completed. Match Winner: Thefishy: 2–1