PennyDreadful PD casual BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality neelfelps,ApplePsyder == Game 1 (607706242) == [05:56:48] PDBot has started watching. [League] Host doesn't have active run [05:56:55] neelfelps chooses to play first. [05:57:02] neelfelps mulligans to 6 cards. [05:57:04] ApplePsyder keeps this hand. [05:57:05] neelfelps keeps this hand. [05:57:10] neelfelps puts 1 card on top of their library. [05:57:10] Turn 1: neelfelps [05:57:10] neelfelps skips their draw step. [05:57:12] neelfelps plays [Vivid Crag]. [05:57:19] Turn 1: ApplePsyder [05:57:22] ApplePsyder plays [Orzhov Guildgate]. [05:57:24] Turn 2: neelfelps [05:57:28] neelfelps plays [Swamp]. [05:57:32] neelfelps casts [Strategic Planning]. [05:57:38] neelfelps puts [Nagging Thoughts] and [Pirate's Pillage] into their graveyard. [05:57:48] Turn 2: ApplePsyder [05:57:52] ApplePsyder plays [Grand Coliseum]. [05:57:54] Turn 3: neelfelps [05:58:05] neelfelps plays [Crumbling Necropolis]. [05:58:13] Turn 3: ApplePsyder [05:58:16] ApplePsyder plays [Swamp]. [05:58:24] ApplePsyder casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Swamp]. [05:58:27] Turn 4: neelfelps [05:58:36] neelfelps plays [Swamp]. [05:58:45] neelfelps discards [Radiant Flames]. [05:58:45] neelfelps casts [Pirate's Pillage]. [05:58:47] neelfelps draws two cards with [Pirate's Pillage]. [05:58:47] neelfelps's [Pirate's Pillage] creates two Treasure tokens. [05:58:57] Turn 4: ApplePsyder [05:59:00] ApplePsyder plays [Mountain]. [05:59:18] ApplePsyder casts [Mardu Charm] targeting neelfelps (Target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a noncreature, nonland card from it. That player di...). [05:59:34] neelfelps discards [Frantic Search]. [05:59:34] neelfelps reveals their hand to [Mardu Charm], containing [Strategic Planning], [Mountain], [Tormenting Voice], and [Postmortem Lunge]. [05:59:40] Turn 5: neelfelps [06:00:17] neelfelps plays [Mountain]. [06:00:23] neelfelps casts [Living Lore]. [06:00:24] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Living Lore[sU] has a Advantageous bug. If Living Lore imprints a Split Card, it has twice the expected CMC. [06:00:43] Turn 5: ApplePsyder [06:00:46] ApplePsyder plays [Vivid Crag]. [06:00:53] ApplePsyder casts [Utter End] targeting [Living Lore]. [06:01:06] Turn 6: neelfelps [06:01:12] neelfelps casts [Strategic Planning]. [06:01:19] neelfelps puts [Island] and [Sphere of the Suns] into their graveyard. [06:01:27] neelfelps casts [Frantic Search]. [06:01:28] neelfelps draws two cards with [Frantic Search]. [06:01:36] neelfelps discards [Mountain]. [06:01:36] neelfelps discards [Tormenting Voice]. [06:01:48] neelfelps casts [Strategic Planning]. [06:02:00] neelfelps puts [Island] and [Living Lore] into their graveyard. [06:02:03] neelfelps plays [Island]. [06:02:06] neelfelps casts [Nagging Thoughts]. [06:02:10] neelfelps puts [Mountain] into their graveyard. [06:02:16] Turn 6: ApplePsyder [06:02:35] ApplePsyder casts [Mardu Charm] targeting neelfelps (Target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a noncreature, nonland card from it. That player di...). [06:02:40] neelfelps discards [Postmortem Lunge]. [06:02:40] neelfelps reveals their hand to [Mardu Charm], containing [Island]. [06:02:48] Turn 7: neelfelps [06:02:53] neelfelps casts [Nagging Thoughts]. [06:03:01] neelfelps puts [Mountain] into their graveyard. [06:03:05] neelfelps casts [Strategic Planning]. [06:03:16] neelfelps puts [Vivid Crag] and [Obsessive Search] into their graveyard. [06:03:20] neelfelps plays [Island]. [06:03:30] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). [06:03:30] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. [06:03:33] Turn 7: ApplePsyder [06:03:44] ApplePsyder casts [Haunted Dead]. [06:03:44] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Haunted Dead] onto the stack (When Haunted Dead enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Spirit creature token with flying.). [06:03:46] ApplePsyder's [Haunted Dead] creates a Spirit token. [06:03:49] Turn 8: neelfelps [06:04:01] neelfelps casts [Cruel Ultimatum] targeting ApplePsyder. [06:04:16] ApplePsyder sacrifices [Spirit] token. [06:04:23] ApplePsyder discards [Radiant Flames]. [06:04:23] ApplePsyder discards [Underworld Connections]. [06:04:23] ApplePsyder discards [Magister of Worth]. [06:04:28] neelfelps chooses [Living Lore]. [06:04:28] [Living Lore] is returned to neelfelps's hand from the graveyard. [06:04:28] neelfelps draws three cards with [Cruel Ultimatum]. [06:04:40] neelfelps plays [Island]. [06:04:56] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). [06:04:59] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. [06:05:03] Turn 8: ApplePsyder [06:05:23] ApplePsyder plays [Orzhov Guildgate]. [06:05:34] ApplePsyder casts [Mardu Charm] targeting neelfelps (Target opponent reveals their hand. You choose a noncreature, nonland card from it. That player di...). [06:05:46] neelfelps discards [Frantic Search]. [06:05:46] neelfelps reveals their hand to [Mardu Charm], containing [Swamp], [Living Lore], and [Crumbling Necropolis]. [06:05:54] neelfelps is being attacked by [Haunted Dead]. [06:06:05] Turn 9: neelfelps [06:06:14] neelfelps casts [Living Lore]. [06:06:26] neelfelps plays [Crumbling Necropolis]. [06:06:33] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). [06:06:33] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. [06:06:36] Turn 9: ApplePsyder [06:06:47] ApplePsyder casts [Utter End] targeting [Living Lore]. [06:06:59] ApplePsyder casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting neelfelps. [06:07:02] neelfelps discards [Radiant Flames]. [06:07:02] neelfelps reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Swamp]. [06:07:08] neelfelps is being attacked by [Haunted Dead]. [06:07:12] Turn 10: neelfelps [06:07:24] neelfelps discards [Swamp]. [06:07:24] neelfelps casts [Tormenting Voice]. [06:07:27] neelfelps draws two cards with [Tormenting Voice]. [06:07:34] neelfelps casts [Nagging Thoughts]. [06:07:40] neelfelps puts [Crumbling Necropolis] into their graveyard. [06:07:44] neelfelps casts [Sphere of the Suns]. [06:07:51] Turn 10: ApplePsyder [06:07:53] ApplePsyder plays [Plains]. [06:08:18] ApplePsyder casts [Butcher of the Horde]. [06:08:48] neelfelps is being attacked by [Haunted Dead]. [06:08:58] Turn 11: neelfelps [06:09:07] neelfelps casts [Living Lore]. [06:09:35] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). [06:09:36] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. [06:09:41] Turn 11: ApplePsyder [06:10:03] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Butcher of the Horde] ( Butcher of the Horde gains your choice of vigilance, lifelink, or haste until end of turn.). [06:10:48] ApplePsyder chooses Lifelink for [Butcher of the Horde]. [06:11:12] ApplePsyder discards [Lay Bare the Heart]. [06:11:12] ApplePsyder discards [Plains]. [06:11:12] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Haunted Dead] ( Return Haunted Dead from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.). [06:11:34] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Haunted Dead] onto the stack (When Haunted Dead enters the battlefield, create a 1/1 white Spirit creature token with flying.). [06:11:38] ApplePsyder's [Haunted Dead] creates a Spirit token. [06:11:45] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). [06:11:45] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. [06:11:56] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Butcher of the Horde] ( Butcher of the Horde gains your choice of vigilance, lifelink, or haste until end of turn.). [06:11:58] ApplePsyder chooses Vigilance for [Butcher of the Horde]. [06:12:04] neelfelps is being attacked by [Butcher of the Horde]. [06:12:20] ApplePsyder casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting neelfelps. [06:12:23] neelfelps reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Vivid Crag]. [06:12:25] Turn 12: neelfelps [06:12:36] ApplePsyder is being attacked by [Living Lore]. [06:12:42] [Spirit] token blocks [Living Lore]. [06:12:49] neelfelps puts triggered ability from [Living Lore] onto the stack (Whenever Living Lore deals combat damage, you may sacrifice it. If you do, you may cast the exiled...). [06:13:02] neelfelps discards [Vivid Crag]. [06:13:02] neelfelps casts [Pirate's Pillage]. [06:13:07] neelfelps draws two cards with [Pirate's Pillage]. [06:13:07] neelfelps's [Pirate's Pillage] creates two Treasure tokens. [06:13:12] neelfelps casts [Obsessive Search]. [06:13:14] neelfelps draws a card with [Obsessive Search]. [06:13:24] neelfelps casts [Cruel Ultimatum] targeting ApplePsyder. [06:13:26] [CHAT] ApplePsyder: do you have self mill protection? [06:13:36] ApplePsyder sacrifices [Butcher of the Horde]. [06:13:38] ApplePsyder discards [Butcher of the Horde]. [06:13:43] neelfelps chooses [Living Lore]. [06:13:43] [Living Lore] is returned to neelfelps's hand from the graveyard. [06:13:43] neelfelps draws three cards with [Cruel Ultimatum]. [06:13:49] neelfelps plays [Crumbling Necropolis]. [06:14:00] neelfelps casts [Living Lore]. [06:14:15] Turn 12: ApplePsyder [06:14:18] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Swamp] ( Draw a card.). [06:14:21] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Swamp]'s ability. [06:14:37] ApplePsyder has conceded from the game. Winner: neelfelps Game 1 Completed. [06:14:42] ApplePsyder has left the game. == Game 2 (607710502) == [06:15:53] PDBot has started watching. [06:15:58] ApplePsyder chooses to play first. [06:16:05] ApplePsyder mulligans to 6 cards. [06:16:14] neelfelps mulligans to 6 cards. [06:16:16] ApplePsyder mulligans to 5 cards. [06:16:18] neelfelps keeps this hand. [06:16:23] ApplePsyder mulligans to 4 cards. [06:16:25] ApplePsyder keeps this hand. [06:16:28] ApplePsyder puts 1 card on the bottom of their library. [06:16:30] [CHAT] ApplePsyder: ugh [06:16:32] neelfelps puts 1 card on top of their library. [06:16:32] Turn 1: ApplePsyder [06:16:32] ApplePsyder skips their draw step. [06:16:35] ApplePsyder plays [Vivid Crag]. [06:16:42] [CHAT] neelfelps: that's brutal [06:16:45] Turn 1: neelfelps [06:16:47] neelfelps plays [Island]. [06:16:54] Turn 2: ApplePsyder [06:16:57] ApplePsyder plays [Plains]. [06:17:02] ApplePsyder casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting neelfelps. [06:17:16] neelfelps discards [Frantic Search]. [06:17:17] neelfelps reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Mountain], [Nagging Thoughts], [Tormenting Voice], [Nagging Thoughts], and [Cruel Ultimatum]. [06:17:21] Turn 2: neelfelps [06:17:23] neelfelps plays [Mountain]. [06:17:26] neelfelps casts [Nagging Thoughts]. [06:17:35] neelfelps puts [Cruel Ultimatum] into their graveyard. [06:17:41] Turn 3: ApplePsyder [06:17:43] ApplePsyder plays [Orzhov Guildgate]. [06:17:57] Turn 3: neelfelps [06:18:18] neelfelps discards [Cruel Ultimatum]. [06:18:18] neelfelps casts [Tormenting Voice]. [06:18:20] neelfelps draws two cards with [Tormenting Voice]. [06:18:23] neelfelps plays [Crumbling Necropolis]. [06:18:33] Turn 4: ApplePsyder [06:18:36] ApplePsyder plays [Grand Coliseum]. [06:18:46] ApplePsyder casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Plains]. [06:18:55] Turn 4: neelfelps [06:19:16] neelfelps plays [Mountain]. [06:19:21] neelfelps discards [Nagging Thoughts]. [06:19:21] neelfelps casts [Tormenting Voice]. [06:19:21] neelfelps puts triggered ability from [Nagging Thoughts] onto the stack (Madness {{1U}}). [06:19:30] neelfelps casts [Nagging Thoughts]. [06:19:33] neelfelps puts [Mountain] into their graveyard. [06:19:37] neelfelps draws two cards with [Tormenting Voice]. [06:19:45] Turn 5: ApplePsyder [06:19:48] ApplePsyder plays [Grand Coliseum]. [06:19:51] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [06:19:52] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [06:20:09] ApplePsyder casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Grand Coliseum]. [06:20:15] Turn 5: neelfelps [06:20:25] neelfelps casts [Living Lore]. [06:20:34] neelfelps plays [Vivid Crag]. [06:20:40] Turn 6: ApplePsyder [06:20:45] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [06:20:45] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [06:20:54] ApplePsyder casts [Crackling Doom]. [06:20:59] neelfelps sacrifices [Living Lore]. [06:21:05] Turn 6: neelfelps [06:21:20] neelfelps casts [Postmortem Lunge] targeting [Living Lore]. (X is 4). [06:21:39] ApplePsyder is being attacked by [Living Lore]. [06:21:45] neelfelps puts triggered ability from [Living Lore] onto the stack (Whenever Living Lore deals combat damage, you may sacrifice it. If you do, you may cast the exiled...). [06:21:52] neelfelps casts [Cruel Ultimatum] targeting ApplePsyder. [06:22:02] ApplePsyder discards [Underworld Connections]. [06:22:02] ApplePsyder discards [Magister of Worth]. [06:22:05] neelfelps chooses [Living Lore]. [06:22:06] [Living Lore] is returned to neelfelps's hand from the graveyard. [06:22:06] neelfelps draws three cards with [Cruel Ultimatum]. [06:22:08] neelfelps plays [Vivid Crag]. [06:22:12] neelfelps puts triggered ability from [Postmortem Lunge] onto the stack (Exile Living Lore at the beginning of the next end step.). [06:22:24] neelfelps discards [Sphere of the Suns]. [06:22:24] Turn 7: ApplePsyder [06:22:29] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Grand Coliseum] ( Draw a card.). [06:22:29] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Grand Coliseum]'s ability. [06:22:36] ApplePsyder plays [Swamp]. [06:22:43] ApplePsyder casts [Butcher of the Horde]. [06:22:48] Turn 7: neelfelps [06:23:18] neelfelps casts [Living Lore]. [06:23:33] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). [06:23:37] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Plains]'s ability. [06:23:42] Turn 8: ApplePsyder [06:24:00] ApplePsyder casts [Utter End] targeting [Living Lore]. [06:24:06] neelfelps casts [Negate] targeting [Utter End]. [06:24:16] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Grand Coliseum] ( Draw a card.). [06:24:19] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Grand Coliseum]'s ability. [06:24:21] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Plains] ( Draw a card.). Winner: neelfelps Game 2 Completed. Match Winner: neelfelps: 2–0 [06:24:29] ApplePsyder draws their next card. [06:24:30] ApplePsyder draws their next card. [06:24:31] neelfelps has left the game.