PennyDreadful PD League BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality Thefishy,ApplePsyder == Game 1 (607684556) == [04:15:16] PDBot has started watching. [04:15:16] ApplePsyder joined the game. [04:15:17] Thefishy joined the game. [League] Butcher Control by applepsyder (14638) vs Bant Yisan by thefishy (14639) [04:15:20] ApplePsyder chooses to play first. [04:15:20] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Good luck in your League match! [04:15:20] [CHAT] PDBot: [sD] Due to a Magic Online bug, PDBot is unable to tell which player is which. Please report this league match manually. [04:15:23] [CHAT] ApplePsyder: Glhf [04:15:26] [CHAT] Thefishy: u2 [04:15:27] ApplePsyder keeps this hand. [04:15:29] Thefishy keeps this hand. [04:15:29] Turn 1: ApplePsyder [04:15:30] ApplePsyder skips their draw step. [04:15:32] ApplePsyder plays [Bloodfell Caves]. [04:15:33] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Bloodfell Caves] onto the stack (When Bloodfell Caves enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.). [04:15:34] Turn 1: Thefishy [04:15:38] Thefishy plays [Grand Coliseum]. [04:15:43] Turn 2: ApplePsyder [04:15:46] ApplePsyder plays [Mountain]. [04:15:50] ApplePsyder casts [Epochrasite]. [04:15:53] Turn 2: Thefishy [04:15:58] Thefishy plays [Forest]. [04:16:00] Thefishy casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim]. [04:16:03] Turn 3: ApplePsyder [04:16:19] Thefishy is being attacked by [Epochrasite]. [04:16:32] ApplePsyder plays [Orzhov Guildgate]. [04:16:34] Turn 3: Thefishy [04:16:38] Thefishy plays [Island]. [04:16:41] Thefishy casts [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard]. [04:16:42] [CHAT] PDBot: [sU]Yisan, the Wanderer Bard[sU] has a Advantageous bug. If all of Yisan, the Wanderer Bard's verse counters are removed in response to its ability, you are able to search your library for any creature, regardless of CMC. [04:16:51] Turn 4: ApplePsyder [04:16:55] ApplePsyder plays [Plains]. [04:17:04] ApplePsyder casts [Butcher of the Horde]. [04:17:10] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Butcher of the Horde] ( Butcher of the Horde gains your choice of vigilance, lifelink, or haste until end of turn.). [04:17:10] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (When Epochrasite dies, exile it with three time counters on it and it gains suspend.). [04:17:16] ApplePsyder chooses Haste for [Butcher of the Horde]. [04:17:23] Thefishy is being attacked by [Butcher of the Horde]. [04:17:31] Turn 4: Thefishy [04:17:34] Thefishy plays [Island]. [04:17:39] Thefishy casts [Prophet of Kruphix]. [04:17:45] ApplePsyder is being attacked by [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard]. [04:17:51] Turn 5: ApplePsyder [04:17:51] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [04:18:03] ApplePsyder casts [Mardu Charm] (Create two 1/1 white Warrior creature tokens. They gain first strike until end of turn.). [04:18:08] ApplePsyder's [Mardu Charm] creates two Warrior tokens. [04:18:12] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Butcher of the Horde] ( Butcher of the Horde gains your choice of vigilance, lifelink, or haste until end of turn.). [04:18:16] ApplePsyder chooses Vigilance for [Butcher of the Horde]. [04:18:19] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Butcher of the Horde] ( Butcher of the Horde gains your choice of vigilance, lifelink, or haste until end of turn.). [04:18:23] ApplePsyder chooses Lifelink for [Butcher of the Horde]. [04:18:29] Thefishy is being attacked by [Butcher of the Horde]. [04:18:47] Thefishy casts [Tradewind Rider]. [04:18:53] Turn 5: Thefishy [04:19:06] Thefishy casts [Kiora's Follower]. [04:19:13] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [04:19:26] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Orzhov Guildgate] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:19:29] Thefishy returns [Orzhov Guildgate] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:19:34] Turn 6: ApplePsyder [04:19:35] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [04:19:41] ApplePsyder plays [Swamp]. [04:20:05] ApplePsyder casts [Underworld Connections] targeting [Mountain]. [04:20:24] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Butcher of the Horde] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:20:26] Thefishy returns [Butcher of the Horde] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:20:39] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [04:20:44] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Mountain] ( Draw a card.). [04:20:46] ApplePsyder draws a card with [Mountain]'s ability. [04:20:55] Thefishy casts [Duskwatch Recruiter]. [04:21:00] Turn 6: Thefishy [04:21:06] Thefishy plays [Island]. [04:21:12] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:21:21] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:21:29] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Mountain] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:21:33] Thefishy returns [Mountain] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:21:37] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [04:21:41] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Village Bell-Ringer] onto the stack (When Village Bell-Ringer enters the battlefield, untap all creatures you control.). [04:21:56] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Bloodfell Caves] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:21:58] Thefishy returns [Bloodfell Caves] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:22:04] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Tradewind Rider] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:22:26] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Village Bell-Ringer] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:22:28] Thefishy returns [Village Bell-Ringer] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:22:33] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Avacyn's Pilgrim] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:22:38] Thefishy casts [Village Bell-Ringer]. [04:22:39] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Village Bell-Ringer] onto the stack (When Village Bell-Ringer enters the battlefield, untap all creatures you control.). [04:22:58] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Plains] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:23:00] Thefishy returns [Plains] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:23:02] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Tradewind Rider] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:23:10] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Village Bell-Ringer] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:23:11] Thefishy returns [Village Bell-Ringer] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:23:14] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Avacyn's Pilgrim] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:23:17] Thefishy casts [Village Bell-Ringer]. [04:23:19] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Village Bell-Ringer] onto the stack (When Village Bell-Ringer enters the battlefield, untap all creatures you control.). [04:23:27] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Swamp] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:23:31] Thefishy returns [Swamp] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:23:34] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Tradewind Rider] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:23:38] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Avacyn's Pilgrim] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:23:47] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Village Bell-Ringer] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:23:56] Thefishy returns [Village Bell-Ringer] to its owner's hand with [Tradewind Rider]'s ability. [04:23:58] Thefishy casts [Village Bell-Ringer]. [04:23:58] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Village Bell-Ringer] onto the stack (When Village Bell-Ringer enters the battlefield, untap all creatures you control.). [04:24:15] ApplePsyder is being attacked by [Duskwatch Recruiter], [Kiora's Follower], [Avacyn's Pilgrim], [Kiora's Follower], [Tradewind Rider], [Prophet of Kruphix], and [Avacyn's Pilgrim]. [04:24:22] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [04:24:27] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Nylea's Disciple] onto the stack (When Nylea's Disciple enters the battlefield, you gain life equal to your devotion to green.). [04:24:32] Turn 7: ApplePsyder [04:24:33] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [04:24:39] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (When the last time counter is removed from the suspended card, cast it without paying i...). [04:24:44] ApplePsyder casts [Epochrasite]. [04:24:55] [CHAT] ApplePsyder: you got this epochrasite [04:25:07] Thefishy activates an ability of [Tradewind Rider] targeting [Epochrasite] ( Return target permanent to its owner's hand.). [04:25:08] [CHAT] ApplePsyder: nooooo [04:25:14] ApplePsyder has conceded from the game. Winner: ApplePsyder Game 1 Completed. == Game 2 (607686656) == [04:25:51] PDBot has started watching. [04:25:56] ApplePsyder keeps this hand. [04:25:57] Thefishy keeps this hand. [04:25:57] Turn 1: ApplePsyder [04:25:59] ApplePsyder skips their draw step. [04:26:01] ApplePsyder plays [Orzhov Guildgate]. [04:26:05] Turn 1: Thefishy [04:26:08] Thefishy plays [Forest]. [04:26:15] Thefishy casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim]. [04:26:25] Turn 2: ApplePsyder [04:26:31] ApplePsyder plays [Swamp]. [04:26:36] ApplePsyder casts [Lay Bare the Heart] targeting Thefishy. [04:26:39] Thefishy discards [Arbor Elf]. [04:26:39] Thefishy reveals their hand to [Lay Bare the Heart], containing [Forest], [Grand Coliseum], [Evolving Wilds], [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard], and [Evolving Wilds]. [04:26:43] Turn 2: Thefishy [04:26:46] Thefishy plays [Forest]. [04:26:48] Thefishy casts [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard]. [04:27:10] Turn 3: ApplePsyder [04:27:43] ApplePsyder plays [Orzhov Guildgate]. [04:27:45] ApplePsyder casts [Epochrasite]. [04:27:46] Turn 3: Thefishy [04:27:51] Thefishy plays [Evolving Wilds]. [04:27:58] Turn 4: ApplePsyder [04:28:02] ApplePsyder plays [Swamp]. [04:28:08] Thefishy is being attacked by [Epochrasite]. [04:28:11] [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] blocks [Epochrasite]. [04:28:14] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (When Epochrasite dies, exile it with three time counters on it and it gains suspend.). [04:28:22] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [04:28:27] Thefishy activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [04:28:31] Turn 4: Thefishy [04:28:37] Thefishy plays [Grand Coliseum]. [04:28:39] Thefishy casts [Kiora's Follower]. [04:28:52] Turn 5: ApplePsyder [04:28:52] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [04:28:58] ApplePsyder plays [Swamp]. [04:29:00] ApplePsyder casts [Epochrasite]. [04:29:08] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [04:29:12] Turn 5: Thefishy [04:29:16] Thefishy plays [Evolving Wilds]. [04:29:25] Thefishy activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...). [04:29:34] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Avacyn's Pilgrim] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:29:39] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Avacyn's Pilgrim] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:29:49] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [04:29:54] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Village Bell-Ringer] onto the stack (When Village Bell-Ringer enters the battlefield, untap all creatures you control.). [04:30:04] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Forest] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:30:09] Thefishy activates an ability of [Kiora's Follower] targeting [Island] ( Untap another target permanent.). [04:30:17] Thefishy casts [Prophet of Kruphix]. [04:30:33] Turn 6: ApplePsyder [04:30:34] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [04:30:40] ApplePsyder plays [Plains]. [04:30:45] ApplePsyder casts [Magister of Worth]. [04:31:14] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Magister of Worth] onto the stack (When Magister of Worth enters the battlefield, starting with you, each player votes for grace or c...). [04:31:20] Thefishy activates an ability of [Yisan, the Wanderer Bard] ( Search your library for a creature card with converted mana cost equal to the number of verse cou...). [04:31:51] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Magister of Worth] onto the stack (When Magister of Worth enters the battlefield, starting with you, each player votes for grace or c...). [04:32:09] Thefishy votes for Condemnation [04:32:13] ApplePsyder votes for Condemnation [04:32:14] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (When Epochrasite dies, exile it with three time counters on it and it gains suspend.). [04:32:21] ApplePsyder votes for Condemnation [04:32:23] Thefishy votes for Condemnation [04:32:27] Turn 6: Thefishy [04:32:32] Thefishy casts [Duskwatch Recruiter]. [04:32:36] Turn 7: ApplePsyder [04:32:36] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [04:32:37] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [04:32:41] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (When the last time counter is removed from the suspended card, cast it without paying i...). [04:32:45] ApplePsyder casts [Epochrasite]. [04:32:55] Thefishy is being attacked by [Epochrasite]. [04:33:09] ApplePsyder casts [Epochrasite]. [04:33:13] Thefishy activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...). [04:33:17] Thefishy puts [Rhox War Monk] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability. [04:33:19] Turn 7: Thefishy [04:33:22] Thefishy plays [Island]. [04:33:27] Thefishy casts [Soul of Theros]. [04:33:40] Turn 8: ApplePsyder [04:33:40] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [04:33:46] ApplePsyder plays [Grand Coliseum]. [04:34:15] Turn 8: Thefishy [04:34:15] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Duskwatch Recruiter] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Duskwatch Recruiter.). [04:34:34] ApplePsyder is being attacked by [Soul of Theros]. [04:34:48] Thefishy casts [Avacyn's Pilgrim]. [04:34:55] Thefishy casts [Rhox War Monk]. [04:35:11] Turn 9: ApplePsyder [04:35:11] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [04:35:11] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Krallenhorde Howler] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if a player cast two or more spells last turn, transform Krallenh...). [04:35:18] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (When the last time counter is removed from the suspended card, cast it without paying i...). [04:35:23] ApplePsyder casts [Epochrasite]. [04:35:35] ApplePsyder plays [Plains]. [04:36:07] Turn 9: Thefishy [04:36:11] Thefishy plays [Island]. [04:36:17] ApplePsyder is being attacked by [Soul of Theros]. [04:36:28] [Epochrasite] blocks [Soul of Theros]. [04:36:33] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (When Epochrasite dies, exile it with three time counters on it and it gains suspend.). [04:36:44] Thefishy activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...). [04:36:49] Thefishy puts [Nylea's Disciple] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability. [04:36:57] Thefishy activates an ability of [Duskwatch Recruiter] ( Look at the top three cards of your library. You may reveal a creature card from among them and p...). [04:37:08] Thefishy puts [Rogue Refiner] into their hand with with [Duskwatch Recruiter]'s ability. [04:37:16] Turn 10: ApplePsyder [04:37:16] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (Suspend (At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter.)). [04:37:16] Thefishy puts triggered ability from [Duskwatch Recruiter] onto the stack (At the beginning of each upkeep, if no spells were cast last turn, transform Duskwatch Recruiter.). [04:37:50] ApplePsyder casts [Butcher of the Horde]. [04:38:13] ApplePsyder activates an ability of [Butcher of the Horde] ( Butcher of the Horde gains your choice of vigilance, lifelink, or haste until end of turn.). [04:38:13] ApplePsyder puts triggered ability from [Epochrasite] onto the stack (When Epochrasite dies, exile it with three time counters on it and it gains suspend.). [04:38:20] ApplePsyder chooses Haste for [Butcher of the Horde]. [04:38:28] Thefishy is being attacked by [Butcher of the Horde]. [04:38:37] Turn 10: Thefishy [04:38:40] Thefishy plays [Island]. [04:39:00] ApplePsyder is being attacked by [Rhox War Monk], [Soul of Theros], and [Krallenhorde Howler]. [04:39:11] [Epochrasite] blocks [Krallenhorde Howler]. [04:39:17] Thefishy activates an ability of [Soul of Theros] ( Creatures you control get +2/+2 and gain first strike and lifelink until end of turn.). Winner: Thefishy Game 2 Completed. [04:39:28] ApplePsyder has left the game.