PennyDreadful
PDS Top4 vs DustyJustice
BuggedCardObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality,Tourney
DustyJustice,EWDias

== Game 1 (598610818) ==
PDBot has started watching.
EWDias joined the game.
[Gatherling] Event=Penny Dreadful Sundays 7.11
[Gatherling] Round=5
[CHAT] DustyJustice: Hello, gl/hf!
DustyJustice chooses to play first.
DustyJustice keeps this hand.
EWDias mulligans to 6 cards.
[CHAT] EWDias: gl hf
EWDias keeps this hand.
EWDias put a card on top of EWDias's library.
Turn 1: DustyJustice
DustyJustice skips their draw step.
DustyJustice plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
Turn 1: EWDias
EWDias plays [Nomad Outpost].
Turn 2: DustyJustice
DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
DustyJustice casts [Hermit Druid].
Turn 2: EWDias
EWDias plays [Plains].
EWDias casts [Anointer Priest].
Turn 3: DustyJustice
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
DustyJustice reveals [Auramancer].
DustyJustice reveals [Doomwake Giant].
DustyJustice reveals [Dead Weight].
DustyJustice reveals [Brain Maggot].
DustyJustice reveals [Nekrataal].
DustyJustice reveals [Strength from the Fallen].
DustyJustice reveals [Tranquil Garden].
DustyJustice reveals [Hopeful Eidolon].
DustyJustice reveals [Hermit Druid].
DustyJustice reveals [Nighthowler].
DustyJustice reveals [Swamp].
DustyJustice plays [Evolving Wilds].
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
Turn 3: EWDias
EWDias plays [Mountain].
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Anointer Priest].
Turn 4: DustyJustice
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
DustyJustice reveals [Evolving Wilds].
DustyJustice reveals [Dead Weight].
DustyJustice reveals [Benefaction of Rhonas].
DustyJustice reveals [Strength from the Fallen].
DustyJustice reveals [Mesmeric Fiend].
DustyJustice reveals [Swamp].
Caesar1994 has started watching.
DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
DustyJustice casts [Herald of Torment].
EWDias casts [Midnight Haunting].
EWDias's [Midnight Haunting] creates two Spirit tokens.
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
Caesar1994 has stopped watching.
Turn 4: EWDias
EWDias plays [Plains].
EWDias casts [Anointer Priest].
EWDias casts [Stoke the Flames] targeting [Herald of Torment].
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Spirit] token and [Spirit] token.
Turn 5: DustyJustice
DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
DustyJustice casts [Doomwake Giant].
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Doomwake Giant] onto the stack (Whenever Doomwake Giant or another enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, creature...).
EWDias is being attacked by [Hermit Druid].
Turn 5: EWDias
EWDias casts [Intangible Virtue].
Turn 6: DustyJustice
DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
DustyJustice reveals [Brain Maggot].
DustyJustice reveals [Brain Maggot].
DustyJustice reveals [Foul Orchard].
DustyJustice reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
DustyJustice reveals [Hermit Druid].
DustyJustice reveals [Tranquil Garden].
DustyJustice reveals [Hermit Druid].
DustyJustice reveals [Nighthowler].
DustyJustice reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
DustyJustice reveals [Foul Orchard].
DustyJustice reveals [Hopeful Eidolon].
DustyJustice reveals [Svogthos, the Restless Tomb].
DustyJustice reveals [Tranquil Garden].
DustyJustice reveals [Evolving Wilds].
DustyJustice reveals [Nighthowler].
DustyJustice reveals [Swamp].
DustyJustice casts [Herald of Torment] for its bestow cost targeting [Doomwake Giant].
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Doomwake Giant] onto the stack (Whenever Doomwake Giant or another enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, creature...).
EWDias is being attacked by [Doomwake Giant].
EWDias casts [Stoke the Flames] targeting [Hermit Druid].
Turn 6: EWDias
EWDias plays [Evolving Wilds].
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Anointer Priest] and [Anointer Priest].
Turn 7: DustyJustice
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Herald of Torment] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life.).
DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
DustyJustice casts [Benefaction of Rhonas].
DustyJustice reveals 5 cards with [Benefaction of Rhonas]: [Seal of Primordium], [Swamp], [Dead Weight], [Dead Weight], and [Plains].
DustyJustice casts [Seal of Primordium].
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Doomwake Giant] onto the stack (Whenever Doomwake Giant or another enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, creature...).
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Seal of Primordium] targeting [Intangible Virtue] ( Destroy target artifact or enchantment.).
EWDias is being attacked by [Doomwake Giant].
EWDias casts [Midnight Haunting].
EWDias's [Midnight Haunting] creates two Spirit tokens.
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
EWDias activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
DustyJustice casts [Baleful Eidolon].
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Doomwake Giant] onto the stack (Whenever Doomwake Giant or another enchantment enters the battlefield under your control, creature...).
Turn 7: EWDias
EWDias casts [Collective Effort] targeting [Doomwake Giant] (Destroy target creature with power 4 or greater), [Herald of Torment] (Destroy target enchantment), and EWDias.
Turn 8: DustyJustice
DustyJustice casts [Herald of Torment] for its bestow cost targeting [Baleful Eidolon].
DustyJustice casts [Baleful Eidolon].
EWDias is being attacked by [Baleful Eidolon].
Turn 8: EWDias
EWDias casts [Dragon Fodder].
EWDias's [Dragon Fodder] creates two Goblin tokens.
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Anointer Priest] and [Anointer Priest].
[Baleful Eidolon] blocks [Anointer Priest].
Turn 9: DustyJustice
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Herald of Torment] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life.).
DustyJustice casts [Nekrataal].
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Nekrataal] onto the stack targeting [Anointer Priest] (When Nekrataal enters the battlefield, destroy target nonartifact, nonblack creature. That creatur...).
EWDias is being attacked by [Baleful Eidolon].
Turn 9: EWDias
EWDias exiles [Anointer Priest] with [Anointer Priest]'s ability.
EWDias activates an ability of [Anointer Priest] (Embalm {3W}).
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
EWDias plays [Mountain].
Turn 10: DustyJustice
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Herald of Torment] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life.).
DustyJustice plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
EWDias is being attacked by [Baleful Eidolon].
Turn 10: EWDias
EWDias exiles [Anointer Priest] with [Anointer Priest]'s ability.
EWDias activates an ability of [Anointer Priest] (Embalm {3W}).
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Anointer Priest] onto the stack (Whenever a creature token enters the battlefield under your control, you gain 1 life.).
EWDias plays [Plains].
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Anointer Priest].
Turn 11: DustyJustice
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Herald of Torment] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life.).
EWDias is being attacked by [Baleful Eidolon].
Turn 11: EWDias
EWDias casts [Butcher of the Horde].
EWDias activates an ability of [Butcher of the Horde] ( Butcher of the Horde gains your choice of vigilance, lifelink, or haste until end of turn.).
EWDias chooses Haste for [Butcher of the Horde].
mandrakata has started watching.
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Butcher of the Horde] and [Anointer Priest].
EWDias activates an ability of [Butcher of the Horde] ( Butcher of the Horde gains your choice of vigilance, lifelink, or haste until end of turn.).
EWDias chooses Lifelink for [Butcher of the Horde].
Turn 12: DustyJustice
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Herald of Torment] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life.).
DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
DustyJustice casts [Benefaction of Rhonas].
DustyJustice reveals 3 cards with [Benefaction of Rhonas]: [Evolving Wilds], [Auramancer], and [Foul Orchard].
DustyJustice casts [Auramancer].
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Auramancer] onto the stack targeting [Strength from the Fallen] (When Auramancer enters the battlefield, you may return target enchantment card from your graveyard...).
DustyJustice returns [Strength from the Fallen] to its owner's hand with [Auramancer]'s ability.
DustyJustice casts [Strength from the Fallen].
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Strength from the Fallen] onto the stack targeting [Baleful Eidolon] (Whenever Strength from the Fallen or another enchantment enters the battlefield under your control...).
EWDias is being attacked by [Baleful Eidolon].
Winner: DustyJustice
Game 1 Completed.
EWDias has left the game.
mandrakata has stopped watching.

== Game 2 (598613050) ==
PDBot has started watching.
EWDias chooses to play first.
EWDias keeps this hand.
DustyJustice keeps this hand.
Turn 1: EWDias
EWDias skips their draw step.
EWDias plays [Nomad Outpost].
Turn 1: DustyJustice
DustyJustice plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
Turn 2: EWDias
EWDias plays [Mountain].
EWDias casts [Intangible Virtue].
Turn 2: DustyJustice
DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
DustyJustice casts [Brain Maggot].
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Brain Maggot] onto the stack targeting EWDias (When Brain Maggot enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals his or her hand and you choose a...).
EWDias reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [Plains], [Midnight Haunting], [Intangible Virtue], [Crackling Doom], and [Butcher of the Horde].
Turn 3: EWDias
EWDias plays [Plains].
Turn 3: DustyJustice
DustyJustice plays [Forest].
DustyJustice casts [Herald of Torment].
EWDias casts [Crackling Doom].
DustyJustice sacrifices [Brain Maggot].
Turn 4: EWDias
EWDias plays [Mountain].
EWDias casts [Butcher of the Horde].
Turn 4: DustyJustice
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Herald of Torment] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life.).
DustyJustice plays [Evolving Wilds].
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
DustyJustice casts [Benefaction of Rhonas].
DustyJustice reveals 5 cards with [Benefaction of Rhonas]: [Tranquil Garden], [Tranquil Garden], [Foul Orchard], [Baleful Eidolon], and [Baleful Eidolon].
Turn 5: EWDias
EWDias plays [Evolving Wilds].
EWDias casts [Butcher of the Horde].
EWDias activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Butcher of the Horde].
Turn 5: DustyJustice
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Herald of Torment] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, you lose 1 life.).
DustyJustice plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
DustyJustice casts [Hopeful Eidolon] for its bestow cost targeting [Herald of Torment].
Turn 6: EWDias
EWDias casts [Midnight Haunting].
EWDias's [Midnight Haunting] creates two Spirit tokens.
EWDias casts [Stoke the Flames] targeting [Herald of Torment].
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Butcher of the Horde] and [Butcher of the Horde].
Turn 6: DustyJustice
DustyJustice has conceded from the game.
Winner: EWDias
Game 2 Completed.

== Game 3 (598613996) ==
PDBot has started watching.
EWDias joined the game.
DustyJustice chooses to play first.
DustyJustice keeps this hand.
EWDias mulligans to 6 cards.
EWDias keeps this hand.
EWDias put a card on top of EWDias's library.
Turn 1: DustyJustice
DustyJustice skips their draw step.
DustyJustice plays [Sandsteppe Citadel].
Turn 1: EWDias
EWDias plays [Evolving Wilds].
EWDias activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
Turn 2: DustyJustice
DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
DustyJustice casts [Hermit Druid].
Turn 2: EWDias
EWDias plays [Nomad Outpost].
EWDias casts [Sentinel Totem].
EWDias puts triggered ability from [Sentinel Totem] onto the stack (When Sentinel Totem enters the battlefield, scry 1.).
EWDias put a card on top of EWDias's library.
Turn 3: DustyJustice
DustyJustice plays [Evolving Wilds].
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
DustyJustice reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
DustyJustice reveals [Swamp].
Turn 3: EWDias
EWDias plays [Plains].
EWDias casts [Hordeling Outburst].
EWDias's [Hordeling Outburst] creates three Goblin tokens.
Turn 4: DustyJustice
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
DustyJustice reveals [Evolving Wilds].
DustyJustice reveals [Svogthos, the Restless Tomb].
DustyJustice reveals [Forest].
DustyJustice plays [Evolving Wilds].
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
DustyJustice casts [Brain Maggot].
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Brain Maggot] onto the stack targeting EWDias (When Brain Maggot enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals his or her hand and you choose a...).
EWDias reveals their hand to [Brain Maggot]'s ability, containing [Butcher of the Horde], [Swamp], [Collective Effort], and [Nomad Outpost].
Turn 4: EWDias
EWDias casts [Collective Effort] targeting [Brain Maggot] (Destroy target enchantment), and EWDias.
EWDias plays [Nomad Outpost].
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Goblin] token and [Goblin] token.
Turn 5: DustyJustice
DustyJustice plays [Plains].
DustyJustice casts [Auramancer].
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Auramancer] onto the stack targeting [Brain Maggot] (When Auramancer enters the battlefield, you may return target enchantment card from your graveyard...).
DustyJustice exiles [Sentinel Totem] with [Sentinel Totem]'s ability.
EWDias activates an ability of [Sentinel Totem] ( Exile all cards from all graveyards.).
DustyJustice's Triggered ability from Auramancer is countered because it has no legal targets.
Turn 5: EWDias
EWDias plays [Nomad Outpost].
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Goblin] token, [Goblin] token, and [Goblin] token.
[Auramancer] blocks [Goblin] token.
EWDias casts [Butcher of the Horde].
Turn 6: DustyJustice
DustyJustice casts [Benefaction of Rhonas].
DustyJustice reveals 5 cards with [Benefaction of Rhonas]: [Benefaction of Rhonas], [Seal of Primordium], [Evolving Wilds], [Baleful Eidolon], and [Dead Weight].
DustyJustice plays [Swamp].
DustyJustice casts [Dead Weight] targeting [Butcher of the Horde].
DustyJustice casts [Baleful Eidolon].
Turn 6: EWDias
EWDias plays [Nomad Outpost].
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Butcher of the Horde], [Goblin] token, and [Goblin] token.
[Baleful Eidolon] blocks [Goblin] token.
Turn 7: DustyJustice
DustyJustice casts [Mesmeric Fiend].
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack targeting EWDias (When Mesmeric Fiend enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals his or her hand and you choose...).
EWDias reveals their hand to [Mesmeric Fiend]'s ability, containing [Mountain] and [Swamp].
DustyJustice plays [Forest].
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
DustyJustice reveals [Nighthowler].
DustyJustice reveals [Tranquil Garden].
DustyJustice reveals [Baleful Eidolon].
DustyJustice reveals [Dead Weight].
DustyJustice reveals [Swamp].
DustyJustice casts [Benefaction of Rhonas].
DustyJustice reveals 5 cards with [Benefaction of Rhonas]: [Nighthowler], [Hopeful Eidolon], [Swamp], [Brain Maggot], and [Tranquil Garden].
DustyJustice casts [Hopeful Eidolon].
Turn 7: EWDias
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Butcher of the Horde] and [Goblin] token.
[Mesmeric Fiend] blocks [Goblin] token.
DustyJustice puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Fiend] onto the stack (When Mesmeric Fiend leaves the battlefield, return the exiled card to its owner's hand.).
EWDias plays [Mountain].
Turn 8: DustyJustice
DustyJustice plays [Foul Orchard].
DustyJustice casts [Nighthowler] for its bestow cost targeting [Hopeful Eidolon].
EWDias is being attacked by [Hopeful Eidolon].
DustyJustice casts [Seal of Primordium].
DustyJustice casts [Hopeful Eidolon].
Turn 8: EWDias
DustyJustice is being attacked by [Butcher of the Horde] and [Goblin] token.
EWDias casts [Hordeling Outburst].
EWDias's [Hordeling Outburst] creates three Goblin tokens.
Smashing Centaur has started watching.
EWDias plays [Mountain].
Turn 9: DustyJustice
DustyJustice activates an ability of [Hermit Druid] ( Reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a basic land card. Put that card into ...).
DustyJustice reveals [Foul Orchard].
DustyJustice reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
DustyJustice reveals [Hermit Druid].
DustyJustice reveals [Hermit Druid].
DustyJustice reveals [Hermit Druid].
DustyJustice reveals [Auramancer].
DustyJustice reveals [Doomwake Giant].
DustyJustice reveals [Strength from the Fallen].
DustyJustice reveals [Brain Maggot].
DustyJustice reveals [Foul Orchard].
DustyJustice reveals [Spider Spawning].
DustyJustice reveals [Doomwake Giant].
DustyJustice reveals [Herald of Torment].
DustyJustice reveals [Doomwake Giant].
DustyJustice reveals [Benefaction of Rhonas].
DustyJustice reveals [Herald of Torment].
DustyJustice reveals [Seal of Primordium].
DustyJustice reveals [Sandsteppe Citadel].
DustyJustice reveals [Nighthowler].
DustyJustice reveals [Tranquil Garden].
DustyJustice reveals [Swamp].
DustyJustice casts [Herald of Torment] for its bestow cost targeting [Hopeful Eidolon].
EWDias has conceded from the game.
Winner: DustyJustice
Game 3 Completed.
Match Winner: DustyJustice: 2–1
EWDias draws their next card.