PennyDreadfulCommander
penny dreadful only 
BuggedCardObserver,LeagueObserver,PennyDreadfulLegality
EternalParadox38,Franco,walloficecream,jbro1985

== Game 1 (596887832) ==
PDBot has started watching.
EternalParadox38 joined the game.
Franco chooses to play first.
Franco chooses [Horde of Notions] as their commander.
walloficecream chooses [Wydwen, the Biting Gale] as their commander.
EternalParadox38 chooses [Lavinia of the Tenth] as their commander.
jbro1985 chooses [Horde of Notions] as their commander.
Franco mulligans to 7 cards.
walloficecream mulligans to 7 cards.
EternalParadox38 mulligans to 7 cards.
jbro1985 mulligans to 7 cards.
Franco keeps this hand.
Pixywing has started watching.
walloficecream keeps this hand.
EternalParadox38 mulligans to 6 cards.
jbro1985 keeps this hand.
EternalParadox38 keeps this hand.
EternalParadox38 put a card on the bottom of the library.
Turn 1: Franco
Franco plays [Gruul Guildgate].
Turn 1: walloficecream
walloficecream plays [Island].
Turn 1: EternalParadox38
[CHAT] walloficecream: wait who's my partner
EternalParadox38 plays [Island].
[CHAT] jbro1985: wall and eternal
[CHAT] walloficecream: yay
[CHAT] walloficecream: icecream4ever
Turn 1: jbro1985
jbro1985 plays [Swamp].
Turn 2: Franco
Franco plays [Forest].
Franco casts [Seal of Primordium].
Turn 2: walloficecream
walloficecream plays [Nephalia Drownyard].
walloficecream casts [Neurok Stealthsuit].
Turn 2: EternalParadox38
PennyDreadfulCommander
penny dreadful only 
BuggedCardObserver, LeagueObserver, PennyDreadfulLegality
jbro1985,Franco,EternalParadox38,walloficecream

PDBot has started watching.
walloficecream casts [Grafted Exoskeleton].
jbro1985 is being attacked by [Vedalken Aethermage].
Turn 4: EternalParadox38
Turn 4: jbro1985
jbro1985 plays [Plains].
jbro1985 casts [Vampiric Sliver].
Turn 5: Franco
Franco casts [Boon Satyr].
Turn 5: walloficecream
walloficecream plays [Island].
EternalParadox38 casts [Stonecloaker].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Stonecloaker] onto the stack (When Stonecloaker enters the battlefield, return a creature you control to its owner's hand.).
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Stonecloaker] onto the stack targeting [Sliversmith] (When Stonecloaker enters the battlefield, exile target card from a graveyard.).
EternalParadox38 returns [Stonecloaker] to its owner's hand with [Stonecloaker]'s ability.
Turn 5: EternalParadox38
EternalParadox38 casts [Storm Fleet Spy].
Turn 5: jbro1985
jbro1985 casts [Cultivator's Caravan].
Moxnix has started watching.
EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Vampiric Sliver].
Turn 6: Franco
Franco casts [One with Nature] targeting [Boon Satyr].
walloficecream casts [Mizzium Meddler].
walloficecream puts triggered ability from [Mizzium Meddler] onto the stack targeting [One with Nature] (When Mizzium Meddler enters the battlefield, you may change a target of target spell or ability to...).
Franco casts [Mask of Memory].
Franco activates an ability of [Mask of Memory] targeting [Boon Satyr] (Equip {1}).
walloficecream casts [Enervate] targeting [Boon Satyr].
Turn 6: walloficecream
walloficecream puts triggered ability from [Enervate] onto the stack (Draw a card at the beginning of the next turn's upkeep.).
walloficecream draws a card with [Enervate]'s ability.
walloficecream plays [Island].
Franco is being attacked by [Vedalken Aethermage].
Turn 6: EternalParadox38
Franco is being attacked by [Storm Fleet Spy].
EternalParadox38 casts [Displace] targeting [Storm Fleet Spy].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Storm Fleet Spy] onto the stack (When Storm Fleet Spy enters the battlefield, if you attacked with a creature this turn, draw a car...).
EternalParadox38 draws a card with [Storm Fleet Spy]'s ability.
EternalParadox38 discards [Emeria Shepherd].
Turn 6: jbro1985
jbro1985 casts [Manalith].
jbro1985 casts [Belligerent Sliver].
EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Vampiric Sliver].
Turn 7: Franco
EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Boon Satyr].
walloficecream casts [Jace's Ingenuity].
walloficecream draws three cards with [Jace's Ingenuity].
[Storm Fleet Spy] blocks [Boon Satyr].
Turn 7: walloficecream
walloficecream plays [Island].
Pixywing has stopped watching.
walloficecream casts [Runechanter's Pike].
walloficecream activates an ability of [Runechanter's Pike] targeting [Vedalken Aethermage] (Equip {2}).
walloficecream activates an ability of [Neurok Stealthsuit] targeting [Vedalken Aethermage] (Equip {1}).
walloficecream activates an ability of [Grafted Exoskeleton] targeting [Mizzium Meddler] (Equip {2}).
jbro1985 is being attacked by [Vedalken Aethermage].
Turn 7: EternalParadox38
EternalParadox38 plays [Plains].
EternalParadox38 casts [Tower Geist].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Tower Geist] onto the stack (When Tower Geist enters the battlefield, look at the top two cards of your library. Put one of the...).
EternalParadox38 puts [Isolation Zone] into their graveyard..
Turn 7: jbro1985
jbro1985 plays [Bad River].
jbro1985 casts [Constricting Sliver].
jbro1985 puts triggered ability from [Constricting Sliver] onto the stack targeting [Mizzium Meddler] (When this creature enters the battlefield, you may exile target creature an opponent controls unti...).
walloficecream puts triggered ability from [Grafted Exoskeleton] onto the stack (Whenever Grafted Exoskeleton becomes unattached from a permanent, sacrifice that permanent.).
EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Belligerent Sliver] and [Vampiric Sliver].
Turn 8: Franco
Franco casts [Izzet Cluestone].
Franco casts [Embodiment of Spring].
Franco activates an ability of [Mask of Memory] targeting [Embodiment of Spring] (Equip {1}).
Turn 8: walloficecream
walloficecream plays [Swamp].
Turn 8: EternalParadox38
EternalParadox38 plays [Plains].
EternalParadox38 casts [Magnifying Glass].
Franco is being attacked by [Tower Geist].
EternalParadox38 casts [Stonecloaker].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Stonecloaker] onto the stack (When Stonecloaker enters the battlefield, return a creature you control to its owner's hand.).
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Stonecloaker] onto the stack targeting [Boon Satyr] (When Stonecloaker enters the battlefield, exile target card from a graveyard.).
EternalParadox38 returns [Tower Geist] to its owner's hand with [Stonecloaker]'s ability.
Turn 8: jbro1985
jbro1985 activates an ability of [Bad River] ( Search your library for an Island or Swamp card and put it onto the battlefield. Then shuffle you...).
walloficecream casts [Time Stop].
Turn 9: Franco
Franco activates an ability of [Embodiment of Spring] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
Franco casts [Temur Ascendancy].
Turn 9: walloficecream
walloficecream plays [Island].
Franco is being attacked by [Vedalken Aethermage].
Turn 9: EternalParadox38
EternalParadox38 casts [Tower Geist].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Tower Geist] onto the stack (When Tower Geist enters the battlefield, look at the top two cards of your library. Put one of the...).
EternalParadox38 puts [Disdainful Stroke] into their graveyard..
EternalParadox38 plays [Island].
EternalParadox38 casts [Dream Thief].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Dream Thief] onto the stack (When Dream Thief enters the battlefield, draw a card if you've cast another blue spell this turn.).
EternalParadox38 draws a card with [Dream Thief]'s ability.
Turn 9: jbro1985
jbro1985 plays [Island].
jbro1985 casts [Simic Signet].
[CHAT] PDBot: [sR]Simic Signet[sR] is not legal in Penny Dreadful.
jbro1985 casts [Mesmeric Sliver].
walloficecream casts [Rend Flesh] targeting [Constricting Sliver].
walloficecream puts triggered ability from [Mizzium Meddler] onto the stack targeting [Mesmeric Sliver] (When Mizzium Meddler enters the battlefield, you may change a target of target spell or ability to...).
jbro1985 puts triggered ability from [Mesmeric Sliver] onto the stack (When this permanent enters the battlefield, you may fateseal 1).
jbro1985 chooses walloficecream.
jbro1985 put a card on the bottom of the library.
Turn 10: Franco
Franco plays [Island].
Franco casts [Seedguide Ash].
Franco puts triggered ability from [Temur Ascendancy] onto the stack (Whenever a creature with power 4 or greater enters the battlefield under your control, you may dra...).
Franco draws a card with [Temur Ascendancy]'s ability.
Franco activates an ability of [Mask of Memory] targeting [Seedguide Ash] (Equip {1}).
EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Seedguide Ash].
[Stonecloaker] blocks [Seedguide Ash].
[Dream Thief] blocks [Seedguide Ash].
Blockers for [Seedguide Ash] are ordered as follows: [Stonecloaker], [Dream Thief]
Franco puts triggered ability from [Seedguide Ash] onto the stack (When Seedguide Ash dies, you may search your library for up to three Forest cards and put them ont...).
Turn 10: walloficecream
walloficecream plays [Swamp].
walloficecream casts [Slaughter] with buyback targeting [Belligerent Sliver].
walloficecream activates an ability of [Grafted Exoskeleton] targeting [Mizzium Meddler] (Equip {2}).
walloficecream activates an ability of [Neurok Stealthsuit] targeting [Mizzium Meddler] (Equip {1}).
jbro1985 is being attacked by [Vedalken Aethermage].
Franco is being attacked by [Mizzium Meddler].
Franco activates an ability of [Seal of Primordium] targeting [Grafted Exoskeleton] ( Destroy target artifact or enchantment.).
walloficecream puts triggered ability from [Grafted Exoskeleton] onto the stack (Whenever Grafted Exoskeleton becomes unattached from a permanent, sacrifice that permanent.).
Turn 10: EternalParadox38
EternalParadox38 plays [Evolving Wilds].
EternalParadox38 casts [Lavinia of the Tenth].
walloficecream activates an ability of [Neurok Stealthsuit] targeting [Vedalken Aethermage] ( Attach Neurok Stealthsuit to target creature you control.).
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Lavinia of the Tenth] onto the stack (When Lavinia of the Tenth enters the battlefield, detain each nonland permanent your opponents con...).
jbro1985 is being attacked by [Tower Geist].
Turn 10: jbro1985
jbro1985 casts [Horde of Notions].
walloficecream is being attacked by [Horde of Notions].
walloficecream has been dealt 5 total damage by jbro1985's commander, [Horde of Notions].
Turn 11: Franco
Franco casts [Pelakka Wurm].
Franco puts triggered ability from [Temur Ascendancy] onto the stack (Whenever a creature with power 4 or greater enters the battlefield under your control, you may dra...).
Franco puts triggered ability from [Pelakka Wurm] onto the stack (When Pelakka Wurm enters the battlefield, you gain 7 life.).
Franco draws a card with [Temur Ascendancy]'s ability.
walloficecream is being attacked by [Pelakka Wurm].
Turn 11: walloficecream
walloficecream plays [Thawing Glaciers].
walloficecream casts [Slaughter] targeting [Pelakka Wurm].
Franco puts triggered ability from [Pelakka Wurm] onto the stack (When Pelakka Wurm dies, draw a card.).
Franco draws a card with [Pelakka Wurm]'s ability.
EternalParadox38 activates an ability of [Evolving Wilds] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put it onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffle your ...).
EternalParadox38 casts [Long Road Home] targeting [Lavinia of the Tenth].
Turn 11: EternalParadox38
EternalParadox38 casts [Martial Law].
EternalParadox38 casts [Azorius Arrester].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Azorius Arrester] onto the stack targeting [Horde of Notions] (When Azorius Arrester enters the battlefield, detain target creature an opponent controls.).
Franco activates an ability of [Gruul Cluestone] ( Draw a card.).
Franco draws a card with [Gruul Cluestone]'s ability.
jbro1985 is being attacked by [Tower Geist].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Long Road Home] onto the stack (At the beginning of the next end step, return Lavinia of the Tenth to the battlefield under its ow...).
jbro1985 casts [Gravepurge] targeting [Constricting Sliver], and [Belligerent Sliver].
jbro1985 put a card on top of jbro1985's library.
jbro1985 put a card on top of jbro1985's library.
jbro1985 draws a card with [Gravepurge].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Lavinia of the Tenth] onto the stack (When Lavinia of the Tenth enters the battlefield, detain each nonland permanent your opponents con...).
Turn 11: jbro1985
jbro1985 casts [Belligerent Sliver].
jbro1985 puts triggered ability from [Belligerent Sliver] onto the stack (When this permanent enters the battlefield, you may fateseal 1).
jbro1985 chooses walloficecream.
jbro1985 put a card on the bottom of the library.
EternalParadox38 has lost connection to the game.
Turn 12: Franco
EternalParadox38 joined the game.
Franco casts [Magus of the Library].
Franco plays [Forest].
Franco activates an ability of [Magus of the Library] ( Draw a card.).
Franco draws a card with [Magus of the Library]'s ability.
Franco casts [Padeem, Consul of Innovation].
Franco casts [Nulltread Gargantuan].
Franco puts triggered ability from [Temur Ascendancy] onto the stack (Whenever a creature with power 4 or greater enters the battlefield under your control, you may dra...).
Franco puts triggered ability from [Nulltread Gargantuan] onto the stack (When Nulltread Gargantuan enters the battlefield, put a creature you control on top of its owner's...).
Franco draws a card with [Temur Ascendancy]'s ability.
walloficecream is being attacked by [Nulltread Gargantuan] and [Padeem, Consul of Innovation].
Turn 12: walloficecream
walloficecream activates an ability of [Thawing Glaciers] ( Search your library for a basic land card, put that card onto the battlefield tapped, then shuffl...).
walloficecream plays [Swamp].
walloficecream casts [Wydwen, the Biting Gale].
walloficecream puts triggered ability from [Thawing Glaciers] onto the stack (Return Thawing Glaciers to its owner's hand at the beginning of the next cleanup step.).
Turn 12: EternalParadox38
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Martial Law] onto the stack targeting [Nulltread Gargantuan] (At the beginning of your upkeep, detain target creature an opponent controls.).
EternalParadox38 casts [Pilgrim's Eye].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Pilgrim's Eye] onto the stack (When Pilgrim's Eye enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reve...).
EternalParadox38 reveals [Plains].
EternalParadox38 plays [Plains].
EternalParadox38 casts [Twilight Shepherd].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Twilight Shepherd] onto the stack (When Twilight Shepherd enters the battlefield, return to your hand all cards in your graveyard tha...).
Turn 12: jbro1985
jbro1985 casts [Constricting Sliver].
jbro1985 puts triggered ability from [Constricting Sliver] onto the stack targeting [Twilight Shepherd] (When this creature enters the battlefield, you may exile target creature an opponent controls unti...).
jbro1985 puts triggered ability from [Constricting Sliver] onto the stack (When this permanent enters the battlefield, you may fateseal 1).
jbro1985 chooses EternalParadox38.
jbro1985 put a card on the bottom of the library.
Turn 13: Franco
Franco puts triggered ability from [Padeem, Consul of Innovation] onto the stack (At the beginning of your upkeep, if you control the artifact with the highest converted mana cost ...).
Franco draws a card with [Padeem, Consul of Innovation]'s ability.
Franco casts [Rampant Growth].
walloficecream activates an ability of [Nephalia Drownyard] targeting Franco ( Target player puts the top three cards of his or her library into his or her graveyard.).
Franco casts [Kessig Cagebreakers].
walloficecream has conceded from the game.
walloficecream is now a watcher.
Franco casts [Magus of the Library].
Franco plays [Frontier Bivouac].
Franco activates an ability of [Mask of Memory] targeting [Kessig Cagebreakers] (Equip {1}).
EternalParadox38 is being attacked by [Kessig Cagebreakers].
Franco puts triggered ability from [Kessig Cagebreakers] onto the stack (Whenever Kessig Cagebreakers attacks, create a 2/2 green Wolf creature token that's tapped and att...).
Franco's [Kessig Cagebreakers] creates four Wolf tokens.
Franco puts [Wolf] token onto the battlefield attacking EternalParadox38
Franco puts [Wolf] token onto the battlefield attacking EternalParadox38
Franco puts [Wolf] token onto the battlefield attacking EternalParadox38
Franco puts [Wolf] token onto the battlefield attacking EternalParadox38
[Lavinia of the Tenth] blocks [Kessig Cagebreakers].
[Azorius Arrester] blocks [Wolf] token.
[Pilgrim's Eye] blocks [Wolf] token.
Turn 13: EternalParadox38
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Martial Law] onto the stack targeting [Nulltread Gargantuan] (At the beginning of your upkeep, detain target creature an opponent controls.).
EternalParadox38 plays [Plains].
EternalParadox38 casts [End Hostilities].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Twilight Shepherd] onto the stack (When Twilight Shepherd enters the battlefield, return to your hand all cards in your graveyard tha...).
EternalParadox38 casts [Saltblast] targeting [Temur Ascendancy].
Turn 13: jbro1985
jbro1985 casts [Pulmonic Sliver].
jbro1985 casts [Bone Splinters] targeting [Twilight Shepherd].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Twilight Shepherd] onto the stack (Persist (When this creature dies, if it had no -1/-1 counters on it, return it to the battlefiel...).
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Twilight Shepherd] onto the stack (When Twilight Shepherd enters the battlefield, return to your hand all cards in your graveyard tha...).
Turn 14: Franco
Franco discards [Krosan Tusker].
Franco cycles [Krosan Tusker].
Franco puts triggered ability from [Krosan Tusker] onto the stack ( When you cycle Krosan Tusker, you may search your library for a basic land card, reveal that card...).
Franco reveals [Forest].
Franco plays [Forest].
Franco casts [Temur Banner].
Franco casts [Hibernation's End].
Franco casts [Vessel of Endless Rest].
Franco puts triggered ability from [Vessel of Endless Rest] onto the stack targeting [Emeria Shepherd] (When Vessel of Endless Rest enters the battlefield, put target card from a graveyard on the bottom...).
Turn 14: EternalParadox38
No legal targets to choose for [Martial Law]'s triggered ability.
EternalParadox38 casts [Tower Geist].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Tower Geist] onto the stack (When Tower Geist enters the battlefield, look at the top two cards of your library. Put one of the...).
EternalParadox38 puts [Plains] into their graveyard..
EternalParadox38 casts [Nephalia Smuggler].
EternalParadox38 casts [Geist-Honored Monk].
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Geist-Honored Monk] onto the stack (When Geist-Honored Monk enters the battlefield, create two 1/1 white Spirit creature tokens with f...).
EternalParadox38's [Geist-Honored Monk] creates two Spirit tokens.
jbro1985 is being attacked by [Twilight Shepherd].
Turn 14: jbro1985
jbro1985 casts [Grim Flowering].
jbro1985 draws four cards with [Grim Flowering].
jbro1985 plays [Fertile Thicket].
jbro1985 puts triggered ability from [Fertile Thicket] onto the stack (When Fertile Thicket enters the battlefield, you may look at the top five cards of your library. I...).
jbro1985 put a card on top of their library.
Turn 15: Franco
Franco puts triggered ability from [Hibernation's End] onto the stack (Cumulative upkeep).
Franco puts triggered ability from [Hibernation's End] onto the stack (Whenever you pay Hibernation's End's cumulative upkeep, you may search your library for a creature...).
Franco plays [Forest].
Franco activates an ability of [Izzet Cluestone] ( Draw a card.).
Franco draws a card with [Izzet Cluestone]'s ability.
Franco discards [Lonely Sandbar].
Franco cycles [Lonely Sandbar].
Franco casts [Sisay's Ring].
Franco casts [Shefet Monitor].
Franco activates an ability of [Mask of Memory] targeting [Shefet Monitor] (Equip {1}).
Turn 15: EternalParadox38
EternalParadox38 puts triggered ability from [Martial Law] onto the stack targeting [Shefet Monitor] (At the beginning of your upkeep, detain target creature an opponent controls.).
jbro1985 is being attacked by [Spirit] token, [Spirit] token, [Geist-Honored Monk], [Tower Geist], and [Twilight Shepherd].
Turn 15: jbro1985
jbro1985 plays [Island].
jbro1985 casts [Bonesplitter Sliver].
jbro1985 casts [Pulmonic Sliver].
EternalParadox38 casts [Draining Whelk].
jbro1985 has conceded from the game.
jbro1985 is now a watcher.
Franco has conceded from the game.
Winner: EternalParadox38
Game 1 Completed.
Franco has left the game.
walloficecream has stopped watching.
jbro1985 has stopped watching.